[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference terri::cars_uk

Title:Cars in the UK
Notice:Please read new conference charter 1.70
Moderator:COMICS::SHELLEYELD
Created:Sun Mar 06 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2584
Total number of notes:63384

1393.0. "Car Alarms FOR Or AGAINST" by SUBURB::LAWSONM1 () Tue Mar 19 1991 12:55

    CAR ALARMS THE CASE FOR OR AGAINST !!
    
    Can people please put their own paticular feelings for or against car
    alarms and if they are against them suggest an alternative.
    
    I for my part am against the idea, as for the last week or so we have
    had these alarms go of at unearthly hours. The other day was the record
    one at the bottom of my street went on for at least 2 hours, eventually
    the police broke into it and we all left a timely message. I have heard of
    a case in London where a woman was so P***ED of that she got a nail and
    in a savoury manner told the owner not to leave his alarm on again.
    
    My recomendation for a replacement would be some kind of personal
    bleeper that advises you of a break in, something like a bleeper, that
    way you get woken and we get some sleep.
    
    Your thoughts please  
    
    
                            
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1393.1Undecided.SHIPS::SAXBY_MSmoke me a kipper...Tue Mar 19 1991 13:0311
    
    The bleeper idea sounds good.
    
    Personally having had my alarmless car broken into I do wonder if
    they'd think twice about raiding my new alarmed car. I doubt it, but
    I have considered the alternative of putting my new car in the same
    place and then lying in wait with a baseball bat...
    
    They MIGHT wake up when the alarm goes off... 
    
    Mark
1393.2VOGON::ATWALDon't dream it, be itTue Mar 19 1991 13:1918
I really doubt the usefulness of car alarms - they just seem to serve to 
irritate people...
You must have heard them going off in car-parks etc. - did you give the car a 
second look to see if the person stood next to it was breaking in or whether he
was the owner having accidentally set it off? People just ignore their wailing 
sirens (except when they go off at 2am). I suppose if I could recognise the 
sound of the one on my car I might just rush out of the house on hearing it go 
off - by that time the person breaking in would have fled; but I bet the 
damage to the car would have been done by then.

Perhaps the choice of 'for or against' depends on what you keep in the car:
an alarm may save valuables that are regularly kept in the car (eg on bussiness).
However if the alarm's used to prevent people from stealing the car you may be 
much better of with a good steering column or handbrake-gearlever lock (having 
a removable stereo could be handy too)


...art
1393.3ForWOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsTue Mar 19 1991 13:4813
    I'm for car alarms. 
    
    I've only had a false alarm once in 6 or 7 years.  When I picked up my
    latest new car, the alarm wasn't fitted, it was fitted 4 days later
    along with a new window and radio.  The 4 days that I had no alarm cost
    the insurance comapany dearly (and my time).
    
    Having said the above, my main reason for wanting an alarm is to stop
    joyriders taking the car.  Most joyriders can't get around the ignition
    disable circuit on alarms.  The last thing I want is a wrecked car.  A
    professional is going to take the car, alarm or no alarm.
    
    I believe most car thefts are not by professionals.
1393.4Remote beeper might be bestUNTADI::LEWISHave Bike, will Ski...Tue Mar 19 1991 14:0511
    I am interested in Alarms at the moment, as somebody knocked my bike
    over last night.
    I saw something demonstrated on Top Gear last year which shouted at
    anyone who came near the car. Anyone know who makes it ?
    That, with a remote beeper would be the answer for me - I want to know
    *before* any damage is done.
    PS in 2 years, the alarm went off twice in the Snail, once in the
    middle of the night because the battery went flat, and once in the
    Ferney car park because a fly got in the sunroof.
    
    Am�d�n
1393.53 times in 2 weeks - with an alarm!RUTILE::BISHOPTue Mar 19 1991 14:2431
    I'm for car alarms, and agree that it's the odd d******d who breaks in
    to nick the stereo etc...
    
    I had my car broken into 4 times... 1st time they nicked the stereo, i
    had a courtesy light alarm, so they broke the window and jumped in. I
    just lost a �500 stereo and a quarter-light (who designed these damn
    things!!! ;-)). 
    
    Then i had a sensor alarm installed , and all i ended up with was a 
    broken quarter-light (again!) - twice - , and a busted hatch. It cost
    less than �500.. only wish i'd hade the sensor before. These 3 times
    were withing a 2 week span! (yea i was pretty gutted!). It gets to the
    point where you wonder if it's worth having a nice car!
    
    Why do most car alarms go off for `no' reason? Because the owner has
    the sensitivity too high. There is a hell of a lot of difference
    between a fly and a piece of glass! No offense Rob, i also have had 
    mine too high... various things have set it off... a leaf falling in 
    the sunroof, someone walking past... a car going past... etc
    
    A pro (as stated earlier) will have the car with or without an alarm,
    so it's not these kind of people you must look out for. Generally a
    typical thief will see an alarm, and go for an easier unalarmed car.
    
    You can bet your bottom dollar that for every car alarm, there is an
    way to get around it, but lets hope it's not generally known...
    
    Keep it out of site and locked,
    
    					
    				Lewis.
1393.6Alarm, be blowed !UNTADI::LEWISHave Bike, will Ski...Tue Mar 19 1991 14:298
    I did ask this morning in the motorcycles file if anyone had a source
    of Claymore Mines for the purpose, but no replies...
    
    Anyone here ?
    
    Or a couple of Patriots ?
    
    Am�d�n
1393.7DOG ALARM?VIVIAN::C_MIDGLEYTue Mar 19 1991 14:502
    The best car alarm you can get is two attack trained rottwiellers that
    weigh 12st each that have not eaten for a week?????.
1393.8The Ultimate deterantSUBURB::LAWSONM1Tue Mar 19 1991 15:044
    Re previous. I have got a shitsoo that hasn't had his tea will it have 
    the same effect
    
    
1393.9GREAT...ishUNTADI::LEWISHave Bike, will Ski...Tue Mar 19 1991 15:5810
    re .7
    
    Brilliant !!!
    That's just what I need !!!
    
    Where can I get some ? How much ? How do I stop them walking off with
    the bike ? How do I persuade them to let me near the bike ?
    I think I better think it out again...
    
    Am�d�n
1393.11YesGRANPA::63654::NAYLORPurring again.Tue Mar 19 1991 20:5517
I've got one in the Alfa, but it came with it.  That said, I think I'd save
the $600 this one cost and put a blinking red led on the dash in future - same
effect.  The car was towed (when owned by the previous owner) and the alarm
went off when they jacked it up, so the tow-truck guy just cut the wires to the
siren!  Left the beeper inside going, that's all!  

With a rag-top, the only deterrent I have any confidence in is my Krooklok (or
at least the local equivalent thereof).  Highly visible and stops the joy-rider.
If they can get the stereo out of the dash I'd be really pleased - the tape
player needs it's azimuth adjustment doing and I can't get it out to do it!!

Ideal alarm?  One that lets the thief get inside the car then locks the doors
behind him and a tape starts screaming RAPE! at 200 watts, in stereo of course,
from hidden external speakers.  In the meantime, a high power transducer emits
105 dB screams inside the car.  Enough to hurt, but not harm permanently.

Brian
1393.12Now that's what I call an alarmRUTILE::SMITH_ANo-one puts baby in the cornerWed Mar 20 1991 08:3416
    Interesting topic...
    
    Personnally I'm indifferent about car-alarms for the reasons first
    stated. Who pays any attention when they go off ? 
    
    IMHO the only effect car alarm is an 'offensive' rather than
    'defensive' alarm. Big sign on, or in, the car to the effect "This car
    is protected with an 'offensive' alarm - touch it and die". Then anyone
    trying to pinch it gets the 105 Db, CS gas, and large spike through the
    drivers seat, treatment.
    
    I think the 12st Rottweilers are the same thing but for people that
    can't read. aren't they ?
    
    
    T.
1393.13WOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsWed Mar 20 1991 08:407
    Alarm stickers and flashing LEDs are certainly an attractive
    alternative to an alarm.  I personally would worry about what is quite
    a common technique though:
          
    potential thief walks past car 
    hits side window (most alarms activate this way)
    if no alarm sounds, return to car
1393.14TASTY::JEFFERYI shot the sherrif (and the deputy!)Wed Mar 20 1991 08:433
Shouting "FIRE!" is more effective than shouting "RAPE!" apparently.

Mark.
1393.15I'd be heart-broken if it did get stolen.SUPER7::BROWNTigers go WOOF!!Wed Mar 20 1991 08:4617
    In the Frogeye I rely on two things:
    
    1) a Krooklock as a visual deterrent to the passing joy-rider.
    2) a battery isolator switch stashed under the dash as a physical
       barrier. Without the key, the whole car is dead.
    
    It's true that rag-tops are more vulnerable, and my bonnet can easily
    be opened from the inside, allowing access to the back of the isolator
    switch for short-circuiting. However, it would take someone quite a
    while to work out how to open the bonnet, another deterrent for the
    casual tea-leaf.
    
    The big-boys, in my opinion will steal your car if they really want it,
    whatever you do to it. Truth is, I'm more worried about losing my tax
    disc!
    
    Laurie.
1393.16Vote against...VOGON::MITCHELLEBeware of the green meanieThu Mar 21 1991 15:1611
    
    A couple of weekends ago I had to wait about 15mins for Autocross to
    open after lunch. There shop is under the multistory carpark in
    Bracknell. There was a constant sound of car alarms, and kids laughing,
    I assumed they were running round rocking the cars. I didn't do
    anything about it because I assumed the Police wouldn't have been in
    the slightest bit interested. We don't have a car alarm, and I think
    they are only worth having if your car is normally kept where there is
    a specific history of stolen vehicles, and where you are in a position
    to hear it. No-one else is going to do anything about it......, and as
    a deterant you might as well have a red flashing light.
1393.17SUBURB::THOMASHThe Devon DumplingThu Mar 21 1991 16:306
>    to hear it. No-one else is going to do anything about it......, and as
>    a deterant you might as well have a red flashing light.

	Aha, but a blue-flashing light might have more impact!

	Heather
1393.18Another one goes ofSUBURB::LAWSONM1Fri Mar 22 1991 08:404
    Thanks for your reply's but has anyone had the experience of being kept
    up late with a siren going on down the street from someone's car.
    
    " Not another alarm "
1393.19KERNEL::PARRY16 bits R SXyFri Mar 22 1991 09:146
Yes, and it wasn't even in the same street.  It was 
going off between 11pm and 3am due to the wind.  I called	
the Police who could just confirm that it was a car 
alarm (great help that was).  They are not allowed to	
break in and stop it and couldn't trace the owner.  I was
very tempted to go and turn it off myself with a hammer :-)
1393.20The current law doesn't go far enoughJANUS::BARKERJeremy Barker - T&N/CBN Diag. Eng. - Reading, UKThu Mar 28 1991 01:0210
The law requires that any alarm shuts itself off after no more then 5 minutes
and the the device which does this shutting off is kept in good repair.

I believe that the law should be changed so that a Polica Officer (or any
person operating with the authority of a Police Officer) can take any
action they see fit in order to silence a car alarm that goes off without
obvious cause.  The owner of the vehicle would be liable for any damage to
the vehicle necessary to silence the alarm.

jb
1393.21PRFECT::PALKAThu Mar 28 1991 14:135
    re .20
    
    Good idea. Should apply to all alarms, not just car alarms !
    
    Andrew
1393.22Can't see any alternative to getting an alarm personally45538::CHRISWewease WogahTue Apr 30 1991 15:1723
    
    Well, after another bungled attempt to get my car/contents of, I feel
    I've got no other alternative but to get an alarm fitted.  A bit back I
    had the lock drilled out of my Volkswagen Santana (not a very flash car
    to want to nick at all, maybe that's why they went for it!), and a few
    days back I had the front quarterlight window smashed.  In both cases
    the would-be-thieves had gained complete access to the car and I reckon
    the only thing that stopped them completing the operation was that they
    were disturbed by someone.  Both attempts were literally less than
    thirty (no I didn't measure the distance!) yards from where I was
    sleeping.  I don't know how bad the inconvenience of having an alarm is
    going to be (false alarms etc.), but if it can wake me up when someone
    is trying to nick my car I don't care...if it wakes everybody else up
    in the street that's even better - OK I know that's a dodgy blanket
    statement, but you must know what I mean!  (In other words I don't want
    an argument starting up around the fact that alarms annoy other people
    more than they help!  =;*)    ).
    
    All I've got to do now is find an alarm that I can fit myself and
    doesn't cost the best part of a fortune...
    
    
    Chris.
1393.23SUBURB::SCREENERRobert Screene, UK Finance EUCWed May 01 1991 19:096
     I have a few articles on Car alarms, in some f.fwd's.
     
     Mostly high end stuff, the magazine is obviously trying to cultvate the 
     market.  But the information contained within is very useful.
     
     Let me know if you would like to read them.
1393.24VULCAN::KINGWewease WogaahThu May 02 1991 10:128
    
    Ta Robert, I'll have a look the next time I'm in DP.  I'm looking for
    summat about a hundred quid, if there are big benefits in getting
    something more expensive I may go for it.  I'm going to have to fit it
    myself, 'cos I can't afford to have it fitted!  (By some of the replies
    in the other notes on alarms I think I'm doing the right thing!)
    
    Chris.
1393.25Beware of cheap alarmsBAHTAT::BAHTAT::HILTONHow's it going royal ugly dudes?Thu May 02 1991 11:107
    Beware of cheap alarms that monitor movement, I had a friend install
    one in his car, thieves broke in at the back, nicked his jacket and the
    alarm never went off - seems it was only powerful enough to monitor
    the front!!
    
    
    Greg
1393.26Who does the alarm belong to?BAHTAT::BORKALAERIC MVSMon May 20 1991 18:3212
    On the theme of Car alarms, does anyone know the answer to this.
    
    When we have car alarms install by VSL, my understanding is that DEC
    pays for the alarm. Therefore, when the lease expires, would it be
    possible to take the alarm off my current car and put it onto my next
    one, hence saving DEC money. Or does Both the car and alarm have to go
    back to the lease company?
    
    Eric
    
    
    
1393.27Convenient and easy to use, yes - but Bad News all the sameCRATE::RUTTERRut The NutMon May 20 1991 19:1810
�    possible to take the alarm off my current car and put it onto my next
    
    I don't know about VSL, but most alarms seem to be fitted with
    plentiful use of 'scotchloks'.  These things should be banned !
    
    They are destructive in their nature and should not be removed
    once they have been used to knacker a particular piece of wire,
    unless that wire is about to be replaced.
    
    J.R.
1393.29TASTY::JEFFERYI shot the sherrif (and the deputy!)Tue May 21 1991 15:593
I know someone who did this.

VSL Seem OK about it.