[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference terri::cars_uk

Title:Cars in the UK
Notice:Please read new conference charter 1.70
Moderator:COMICS::SHELLEYELD
Created:Sun Mar 06 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2584
Total number of notes:63384

2228.0. "Brakes sometimes don't work" by BONNET::HARDY () Tue Feb 22 1994 14:30

    Chaps,
    
    I have an '87 Renault Espace GTS (2 litre carb).
    
    About 2 months ago the following was done by a local garage: 
    - new front discs and pads 
    - new rear cylinders and shoes 
    - flush and refil fluid 
    1 month ago I had to send it back for a re-bleed as it didn't seem too
    good. 
    
    Now I have the following problem: 
    - normally brakes bite at top of pedal with little effort 
    - sometimes, but I think only under conditions below the pedal goes
      almost to floor and the car stops slowly:
    *	When car is cruising at low speed, under no throttle, eg when
    	slowing down at a junction	
    *	At this time the rear brakes have sometimes locked up
    
    The brakes are bled OK, but there is no bleed valve on the pressure
    limiter.
    All of the hose to the vacuum unit look/feel ok
    There is no change of engine speed when applying brake on stationary
    car.
    
    So,,,,, what's wrong?
    
    Peter
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2228.1Hope you're not behind me!!YUPPY::TILLINGSTue Feb 22 1994 17:116
    Peter,
    
    It sounds like a problem with the servo unit, or the master cylinder
    seals. Either way your a brave man to drive it !!
    
    Simon.
2228.2Experience says it's the Master CylinderCHEFS::MCGINTYJTue Feb 22 1994 17:226
    I had a similar problem with Peugeot 505.  The problem was intermittent
    and was cured only after the master cylinder was replaced.
    
    Be careful.
    
    John
2228.3some moreLEDS::ROBERTSONTue Feb 22 1994 19:5510
    I agree with the servo unit.  However, the bleeding of the rear
    brakes needs to be done with the proportioning valve open.
    
    Just pry something between the body and the mechanism on the valve
    to make sure it is open for a proper bleed.   
    
    I'd say check the master cylinder first.
    
    Dale
    
2228.4step 2?BONNET::HARDYWed Feb 23 1994 08:3910
    Chaps, 
    
    thanks so far,
    
    Apart from signs of leaks, what should I look for/how can I check, the
    master cylinder?
    
    As for bravery, the brakes still work, it's just a little strange!
    
    Peter
2228.5GVA05::STIFFPaul Stiff EPSCC, DTN:821-4167Wed Feb 23 1994 12:244
    When you press the pedal is there a "blank spot" with no resisance
    whatsoever ?  This indicates master cylinder wear.
    
    Paul
2228.6Do the right thingMUGGER::SHARPBob SharpWed Feb 23 1994 12:257
Brakes are a safety-critical system.

Do the right thing.  Take the car to a professional, 
or at least someone you can sue.

	Bob
2228.7Probably not the servo. AYOV11::JDRAKE_100% Fact Free NoteWed Feb 23 1994 12:3615
	The symptoms seem to suggest a fault either in the master cylinder,
    or the front brake pipes, or calipers. The fact that the pedal is
    nearly going to the floor, seems to discount the servo being at fault.
    If the system on the Espace is similar to others it will be with split
    hydraulics, front and rear. The rear brakes sometimes locking when the 
    fronts are ineffective suggests that the rears are working OK, but the
    fronts are sometimes not. Likely causes are, master cylinder fault, brake 
    pipes leaking, flexible brake pipes leaking, a caliper fault, or air in the
    front brakes. Is the fluid level in the resovier dropping? If it is
    not, then suspect a fault in the master cylinder.
    
    	Having the back brakes lock before the front is dangerous as the
    car can easily spin. Having dodgy brakes at all is not a good idea.        
    
                  Jeremy
2228.8Its unanimous(ish)BONNET::HARDYWed Feb 23 1994 13:4421
    Chaps,

    It's booked into a garage for tomorrow morning. This is a different one
    to he who did the initial work as I'm not overconfident in the first
    one's ability. I was also rather niffed at being charged for the
    re-bleed two weeks after the initial work "as they didn't know if I'd
    abused the car in the meantime".

    I selected tomorrow's garage because in agreement with the replies in
    here he said "sounds like the master cylinder".
     
    I'll post the result in here, probably next week.

    thanks again

    peter
    
    PS, I'd thought about a front/rear cylinder split but didn't
    understand the way the pressure limiter fitted into that arrangement.
    Guess I'll have to read the manual tonight!

2228.9front/rear versus diagonal splitRDGE44::ALEUC1Barry Gates, 7830-1155Wed Feb 23 1994 14:369
    I always thought that "European" versions of cars had a diagonal brake
    split (my terminology is a bit lacking here!). So if one half of the
    brake system fails you will still be able to brake using a front wheel
    on one side of the car and a rear wheel on the other side. I believe
    that models for the Japanese market have a front/rear split.
    
    Have I misunderstood?
    
    Barry.
2228.10LEMAN::CHEVAUXPatrick Chevaux @GEO, DTN 821-4150Wed Feb 23 1994 15:1712
    .9�    I always thought that "European" versions of cars had a diagonal brake
    .9�    split (my terminology is a bit lacking here!). So if one half of the
    
    I think only a few cars have this feature (Audi ?). Most have the
    traditional front/rear arrangement.
    
    As far as the rear brakes pressure limiting device is concerned this is
    a valve in the circuit that prevents (normally) wheel locking with cars
    that have most weight on the front axle. Decent cars (like the Porsche
    911) have the right weight balance and don't need that sort of kludge.
    They also have MUCH better braking power since both axles participate
    in the braking effort. 
2228.11A worn wheel bearing?ALBURT::LEWISThu Feb 24 1994 09:1511
    Could it possibly be that one of your front wheel bearings is worn thus
    causing the brake pads to be pushed out from the brake disk? This would
    have the effect of requiring the brake peddle to pressed a couple of
    time to bring the pads back in to contact with the disk but the rear
    brake would still operate as normal due to the split braking system.
    
    
    Just an idea,
    
    
    Neil
2228.12WARNUT::ALLENIt works better if you screw it in..Thu Feb 24 1994 15:4211
    Best guess is master cylinder as others have said. The last note does
    remind me of something I used to take part in. Economy runs. You take a
    screwdriver to the pads and lever them off the disc as far as they will
    go and then NEVER touch the brakes until your 1 gallon runs out. If you
    forget to press the stop pedal a couple of times before you go out on
    the open road the results are "interesting". A warped disc or worn
    bearing etc could produce the same effect as the screwdriver, i.e.
    knock the pads away from the disc. You wouldn't see any drop in brake
    fluid unless the pads were pushed far enough back to force the fluid
    out of the top of the pot which you can very soon spot because of the
    rapid corrosion in that area!
2228.13there's always a catchBONNET::HARDYFri Feb 25 1994 11:2713
    Chaps,
    
    A new master cylinder is on order.
    
    Unfortunately I'm in the UK at the moment but it's a left hand drive
    car. Hence most pedal related items are mirror imaged. A new one will
    take a day or two to arrive.
    
    When Joe Spanner did the pads, etc he left the fluid reservoir
    completely full. I can't work out how this could cause the failure, but
    I can't help wondering if it contributed.
    
    Peter
2228.14WARNUT::ALLENIt works better if you screw it in..Fri Feb 25 1994 13:034
    Are you sure he did? Reason I ask is that my previous reply about the
    pads being moved off the disks would cause the fluid to rise
    substantially in the resevoir. You'd be surprised by how much.
    
2228.15tuppence worthKERNEL::BARTHURFri Feb 25 1994 15:0512
    
    My money is on one of your brakes  binding intermittently, because
    the re-lining was not done properly, this causes the brake fluid to
    boil near the offending wheel. Next time you hit the pedal, it goes to
    the floor. You see no obvious leaks and the level in the master
    cylinder never alters.
    
    You could save a lot of money by simply waiting until the problem
    appears, stop the car and feel which drum/disc is twice as hot as the
    others!
    
    Bill
2228.16The plot thickens (unlike the fluid)BONNET::HARDYFri Feb 25 1994 16:2910
    Nice one Bill,
    
    Wouldn't I get pulling to one side? I know when it boiled, the air
    would take pressure of both sides, but just beforethat the "hot" pad
    would loose efficiency?
    
    Hmmm
    
    peter 
    
2228.17only maybeKERNEL::BARTHURFri Feb 25 1994 16:487
    Peter,
    It would be noticeable, i suppose if it was jammed quite tightly on one
    of the fronts, but i had this problem on a rear brake and it was
    impossible to detect from normal driving. I've found that even a small
    amount of sticking can produce this problem.
    
    Hope you fix it quick
2228.18Fiver on boilingCMOTEC::JASPERStuck on the Flypaper of LifeMon Feb 28 1994 15:3322
    
    
    .15 beat me to it. You had the front disks & pads replaced. This means
    that both the front cylinders are suddenly operating in an area
    previously unused for some time. There could be rust or debris in this 
    area of the slave cylinder(s).
    
    I would expect the reservoir to have overflowed when both disks & pads
    were replaced.
    
    Some garages pinch the flexible hoses to stop fluid loss during brake 
    servicing, so its also possible that internal damage to the bore of the 
    flexible pipe could send fragments of rubber into the front wheel slave 
    cylinders, part-siezing 1 or both.
    
    For my money, I'd repair or replace both cylinders. This fault seems very
    dangerous. My guess is its fluid-boiling. The condition of the wheel
    bearings will also have an effect on this. Worn bearings may clear the
    fault temporarily as the calipers are forced apart.
    
    Tony.
    
2228.19Answer coming.... tomorrowBONNET::HARDYTue Mar 01 1994 12:2114
    Chaps,
    
    The LH drive master cylinder arrived yesterday so it's going on at this
    very moment.
    
    We'll find out if it's the master cylinder or the slaves/fluid boiling
    in the next couple of days. More correctly, my wife will as she's the
    test pilot!
    
    I would have thought that rust/debris in the slaves would have caused
    loss of fluid, more than boiling. I'm not loosing fluid.
    
    Peter 
    
2228.20BAHTAT::EATON_NPersonal Name Removed to Save CostsTue Mar 01 1994 12:478
    
    Wise man, I'd get my wife to check out brake trouble too! Hope she's
    well insured!  8^)
    
    Kidding, really, just kidding!  8^)
    
    Nigel
    
2228.21will it or wont it?KERNEL::BARTHURThu Mar 03 1994 12:438
    
    Peter,
    do you trust the garage? If they fit the new one and find that it
    hasn't cured the problem, they might fix the proper cause, not tell you
    and charge for the new MC.
    
    cynically yours :>)
    
2228.22And the answer is!BONNET::HARDYMon Mar 07 1994 10:0113
    Chaps,
    
    Well I got it back with the new master cylinder.
    
    All looks (and feels) OK, including a reasonable length drive to check
    out the boiling fluid scenario.
    
    Wife now test driving it ;-}
    
    Thanks for all the input.
    
    Peter.
    
2228.23Battery white deposit and spongy brakes!VARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 17 1994 12:0950
Our car is going into the garage on Thursday to have a few tweaks done to 
it under guarentee (it's just over 9 months old). So checking over the car 
this weekend I found that around the battery and in its "tray" below there 
is a fair amount of white deposit. I assume it's come from the battery 
where it has "leaked" and then dried. I'm concerned that this is a bit 
excessive (not to mention what damage the corrosive liquid could do before 
it dried)! 
    
Assuming that the battery was not over filled when we bought the car how 
much would you expect to see (white deposit wise)? I've seen a few times 
the top of the battery "damp" around the plugs (thats the plastic plugs 
for each of the seperate battery chambers) but didn't think much of it 
at the time and just gave it a quick wipe. This time I also checked the 
actual chambers and I've seen that 2 of them (one at either end) are a 
bit low of liquid (well lower than the other 4 or 6 but should still be 
okay)!

What does the panel think - Am I being too pinickety or is it that the 
battery can't cope with the load and the liquid is "boiling" and so could 
this point to something that is not right (with the battery or car) or...?


Second worry - now driving the car this weekend I noticed that at one point,
while waiting at a toll booth with my foot on the brake peddle, it quickly
"sunk" about � inch (it felt like something small releasing) and with a bit 
more pushing (as the brake peddle was now fairly spongy) I was able to touch 
the "stopper" (something hard before reaching the floor)! Checking further, 
when I got home, I switched off the engine and then pushed hard on the 
brake peddle it seemed okay (I can't remember if it was on the first push 
or after a couple of pumps [need to check again tonight]). Then I went for 
a another drive and again it seemed soft. Even pumping it didn't seem of 
make it "firm" again. Not being the regular driver of the car I'm not sure 
if this is as it has always been there. When it first happened I asked my 
wife if this had happened to her, she said yes but thought that it was due 
to the air conditioning kicking in.

About a month ago I did top up the brake fluid chamber. It didn't need 
much but I just topped it up to nearly the maximum line and at the time 
I just put down to normal wear and tear.

As my wife drives the car and especially as we have 2 little kids being 
driven around in it I want to be certain that the brakes are 100% safe...
    
So again am I being too pinickety...

Plus as the car is still under guarentee I want to get as much sorted out
before we have to start paying....
    
Dave
2228.24FORTY2::HOWELLJust get to the point...Mon Oct 17 1994 12:2217
    re. Brakes
    
    	Go out and try and emergency stop (30mph, clear road, dry, etc..)
    ?!?!
    
    	I must admit the symptom you describe (*sudden* pedal change)
    sounds worrying, since a leak will usually be gradual. All I can think
    of is maybe a caliper is sticking ? Considering you've probably got
    4-pot calipers (I don't know what car we're talking about here) the
    effect on braking may not be immediately noticeable (since the other 3
    pistons will be working fine).
    
    	I'd have it checked out (if you're not willing to have a look
    yourself, of course).
    
    	As for the battery, I wouldn't expect it to leak THAT much after
    only 9 months.
2228.25FORTY2::PALKAMon Oct 17 1994 12:5023
    The brake pedal sinkling to the floor could be a faulty master
    cylinder. The seal around the piston is leaking, allowing fluid to
    return from the high pressure side (to the brakes) to the low pressure
    side (to the reservoir). In this case there is no overall loss of fluid
    (the reservoir remains full), but the brakes might give out on a long
    stop (from high speed say). They will recover if your release the pedal
    and try again (pumping the pedal).
    
    The white deposits could be the result of overflowing, possibly due to
    overcharging (faulty regulator in the alternator). It's not likely to
    be overheating from being overloaded. When you have topped
    up the cells you should check the density of the electrolyte (after
    allowing the added water to mix and the battery to charge up again).
    You may need to add acid if the density is too low. If you think the
    battery acid has spilled then wash the area thoroughly to remove any
    remaining acid. (You can use a weak bicarbonate of soda solution to
    help neutralise any remaining acid, but rinse in plain water again -
    and try not to get anything into the battery cells !). Check the
    voltage with the engine running at 2000-3000 rpm.
    
    I dont think either of these things should happen to a new car.
    
    Andrew
2228.26FORTY2::HOWELLJust get to the point...Mon Oct 17 1994 14:051
    Or something to do with a brake servo ? Pipe came loose?
2228.27TRUCKS::BEATON_SI Just Look InnocentMon Oct 17 1994 14:236
    The battery on my 205 has been with the car since 1986.... Absolutely
    no white deposit at all.
    
    Reargards,
    
    Stephen
2228.28WOTVAX::HARDYPMon Oct 17 1994 14:3414
    Dave,
    
    See 2228.*
    
    Or try dir/title=brakes......don't work    ;-}
    
    Peter
    
    PS Maybe they've crossed your petrol filler with a brake pipe. This
    might explain several things!
    
    
    
    
2228.29PLAYER::BROWNLCoito ergo sumMon Oct 17 1994 14:575
    .2 says it for me. I agree with both diagnoses. In particular, the
    braking problem could be dirty fluid, but in any event, is almost
    certainly the master cylinder.
    
    Cheers, Laurie.
2228.30Now, where's the Vaseline?MOEUR5::SMITH_MMartin Smith, Evry (F). - 858 4896.Mon Oct 17 1994 15:3119
�                                                   So checking over the car 
� this weekend I found that around the battery and in its "tray" below there 
� is a fair amount of white deposit. I assume it's come from the battery 
� where it has "leaked" and then dried. I'm concerned that this is a bit 
� excessive (not to mention what damage the corrosive liquid could do before 
� it dried)! 

   Dave,

   For a 9-months old car, I wouldn't expect to see any white deposites on
   the battery terminals. As to the cause,  I'm not sure, but I thought it
   was the reason why the polarity of cars was changed (a looong time ago) 
   from +ve earth to -ve earth.

   Anyway, once the garage has detected and solved the problem,  I suggest
   that you cover the terminals with some petroleum jelly; I can guarantee
   you won't see white deposites again (famous last words!).

   Martin.
2228.31They have been added to the garages "To Do" list - thanksVARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 17 1994 15:4526
    Thanks folks - you confirmed that it should not be normal for a car
    under 1 year of age to exhibit the soft brakes and battery dandruff.
    
    RE: .3 - I had a check around the servo yesterday and a quick look
    near the wheels to make sure nothing has come loose. I'll check again
    just to make doubly certain. But in any case below the car it's dry.
    
    RE: .5
    
    Peter - I wondered about the other brake exploits (including yours) but
            as the car is still relatively new I wondered what I should
            expect. If the car had been over the one year (and therefore
            out of the warrenty period) then I would have done some more
            checking myself. At least now I know we can add it to the "to
            do" list for the garage on Thursday.
    
    RE: .7
    
    Martin - Trust you to talk about Vaseline!
    
            At the moment I don't see any battery dandruff around the
            terminals it's down the side and mainly in the battery tray.
    
    Thanks folks...
    
    Dave
2228.32Old battery technologyEICMFG::JOCONNORSomebody else did it and ran away.Mon Oct 17 1994 15:594
    I'm surprised that somebody is making cars without sealed for life
    batteries nowadays.
    
    John O'Connor
2228.33FORTY2::HOWELLJust get to the point...Mon Oct 17 1994 16:071
    What car are we talking about, out of interest?
2228.34Ford Mondeo (2L Ghia estate)VARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 17 1994 18:121
    
2228.35Ford Mondeo problems - Meant to post this months agoVARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 17 1994 18:2757
Taken from French car mag which listed problems etc. for about 200 cars

Car: Ford Mondeo

Reliability: most frequent problems

Mechanical:

    Gear Box:	2litre weakness of syncro for 2nd gear. Changing between
		1st and 2nd gear is not smooth, mostly when the engine is
		running with high revs. For the TD, jumps out of second.
		New syncro since Sept. '93. On TD 5th hard/slow to engage.
		
    Breaks:	Noisy pads in front

    Suspension:	Noisy (silent blocks) at joints at rear

    Active suspension:
		Sport suspension sometimes locked in "Sport" position. New
		electronic module in June '93. Some troubles due to bad
		positioning of wiring on rear wheel housing.

    Shock absorber:
		Some rear shock absorber deficient - noise (rattle eg. due
		to movement) - change under guarentee

Body work/Equipment:

    Wind noise:	whistles on low angles of window screen

    Glove compartment:
		Doesn't shut properly - rattles

    Petrol flap:
		Blocked with remote control - Cable badly adjusted in
		factory and grips within tubing. Corrected in May '93

    Speedo:	Needle "vibrates"

    Indicators:	Airbag indicator - blinks. Connection on steering wheel
		better connected since Nov. '93. Sometimes the indicator of
		cooling liquid lights without reason. Due to fautly sensor.

    Air vents:	On '93 models, the lever breaks on the right hand side on
		dashboard. Problem still continues on central air vents.

    Seats:	Creaks after 15,000 kms especially on the rear. Lock of the
		back seat noisy.

    Gear lever:	"Ball" not properly fastened and twists

    Vibrations:	Central console rubbing type creak on uneven surfaced
		road. 5th door plastic cover and rear shelf noisy.

    Finish:	Door covering (velours/velvet) comes unstuck just over the
		arm rest. Central console vulnerable to marking from
		scratches etc. Rear comparment noisy on "berline" 5 door.
2228.36Get rid of that white stuff PDQ!CMOTEC::POWELLNostalgia isn't what it used to be, is it?Tue Oct 25 1994 12:427
	Dave, if you have white powdery stuff on the Battery tray, I'd wash it
off PDQ!  It is acid and will continue to eat the metal even if it looks dry and
harmless - it ain't!  As mentioned in a previous reply, use a solution of
Bicarbonate of Soda and rinse copiously with fresh water afterwards.

				Malcolm.
2228.37First part solved (we hope)VARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 31 1994 08:1529
    Sorry for the late response to some previous replies but I've been out
    for a week...
    
    The garage verified the charge from the alternator and said it was
    okay, they then said that the problem was caused by the battery cells
    being overfilled! I wasn't happy with this answer because the 2 cells
    in question had gone down below the top of the plates in the chamber! I
    therefore pushed the issue and finally they replaced the battery under
    warrenty! 
    
    I couldn't wash the area before I took it into the garage as they
    wouldn't have had anything to look at. Mind you I don't believe they
    washed the area properly so this is something that I still have to
    check before it goes into the garage for the other work that needs to
    be done next week.
    
    Concerning the brakes they said that it's okay! We're going to take the
    car to a couple of other garages in the area to get a second opinion.
    Mind you after a good � hours test drive we've finally managed to prove
    that there is something wrong with the ABS. Basically when moving away,
    after starting the engine, there is a metalic rubbing/releasing noise
    after about 5 metres. It's not a loud noise but with metal "rubbing" on
    metal something will give after a while...
    
    Before someone says take it to another garage... unfortunately this
    particular garage is the best Ford garage in the area (Cannes,
    Antibes and Nice) and as we are having the work done under warrenty...
    
    Dave
2228.38just a thoughtLEMAN::CHEVAUXPatrick Chevaux @GEO, DTN 821-4150Mon Oct 31 1994 10:375
    .37�    after starting the engine, there is a metalic rubbing/releasing noise
    .37�    after about 5 metres. It's not a loud noise but with metal "rubbing" on
    .37�    metal something will give after a while...
    
    Sounds like the parking (hand) brake ... 
2228.39certainly not the handbrakeVARDAF::CHURCHDave Church@VBE (DTN 828-6125)Mon Oct 31 1994 11:3717
    RE: .38
    
    Patrick,
    
    >> Sounds like the parking (hand) brake ...
    
    No it happens even when you don't use it. The mechanic who test drove
    the car said it's certainly an ABS problem and he has only heard of it
    once before and he is not sure what the solution was! Anyway I'm
    certainly not going to let this problem rest because I don't fancy the
    warrenty running out and us being stuck with a nice bill when it
    finally does go wrong/breaks...!
    
    Dave
    
    P.S. I'll dig out the photo negatives in the next couple of days for 
         you and then see about getting them to EHQ.