T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
93.1 | playing devil's advocate... | LASHAM::PHILPOTT_I | Col. Philpott is back in action... | Wed Jun 07 1989 10:00 | 16 |
|
I nearly put this in AUDIO, but having seen the same note twice
I now can't resist.
Not meaning to pick on anybody, but,...
Car audio is getting better I admit. My question though is why bother?
if you only listened with the car engine switched off, and the car
parked off road somewhere a long way from traffic then I could see
the point, but last time I measured the sound level in my car (a
while back) I got 69dB of *noise*. To achieve say a 50dB signal
to noise ratio (very minimal requirement in my opinion) I'd have
to play the stereo at 119dB which is close to the pain threshold
and over the point at which hearing damage is inevitable...
/. Ian .\
|
93.2 | I think I agree....I think | BAHTAT::SALLITT | Dave - @RKG & ICI, 0642432193 | Wed Jun 07 1989 11:36 | 19 |
| re .1....
Ah, but what was the spectral content of your 69db of noise? Chances
are that there were several gaps through which a reasonable illusion
of quality music reproduction could get through. Also, so long as
the music was 3db above the noise level, it would be perceived as
twice as loud, dynamic range notwithstanding - I don't recall the
figures, but I'm sure cassette can't achieve 50db *range*, and
certainly most FM stations don't, even though it may be achievable.
CD can, of course, but then your argument begs the question of whether
there's any point in in-car CD or not - probably not, unless you
drive a Roller or a Jag. And many modest but good in-car systems
are as good as the exotica on the move, given quality source material.
Like Ian I can't see the point, but if others do, fine. But it ain't
really hifi, is it?
Dave
|
93.3 | | LARVAE::JEFFERY | A simple prop to occupy my mind | Wed Jun 07 1989 19:24 | 6 |
| Well, I enjoy listening to music in the car, so it must be worth
it!
Cheers.
Mark.
|
93.4 | The MUSIC is what matters | SEDOAS::KORMAN | | Thu Jun 08 1989 10:57 | 11 |
| And remember that you brain does some pretty astounding maths
(convolution etc) to enable it to select the sounds that it wants
to hear....the road/engine noise can be ignored by the brain to
a large extent... try listening to a decent ICE system on the motorway
at high volume, then turn it off!
No, it's not Hi-Fi by any standards... but it's ENJOYING THE MUSIC
THAT COUNTS.
Dave
|
93.5 | <background>+<signal>=<a lot> | MALLET::NEALE | Security - eat note after reading! | Thu Jun 08 1989 15:39 | 23 |
| re .1
I remember an article in Wireless World some years back which raised
essentially the same points. The author calculated the sum of the
various background noise sources, added on what to him seemed a
reasonable signal-above-noise threshold, and then outlined his design
for an amplifier capable of delivering the required output. I seem to
recall such points as heatsinks constructed from old cast-iron central
heating radiators, and power supply connections using starter-motor
cables from scrapped cars. He also mentioned that due to audio feedback
effects, the turntable itself had to be installed in a shed at the end
of the garden, which lead to problems with hearing the first few bars
of any record. On one occasion he dropped the pickup arm on to the
record, and the subsequent transients required him to replaster the
ceilings of three rooms!
He concluded, however, by saying that for as-yet unexplained reasons,
he had later been able to purchase both adjoining properties at very
advantageous prices, and this had helped to subsidise the cost of the
equipment.
Oh yes, the author's name was George Izzard de Veering (say it slowly)
and while I forget the year, the cover date was certainly April.
|
93.6 | I think it sounds all right. | URIAH::PETTEFAR | | Tue Jul 11 1989 10:33 | 19 |
| I drive an XJ6 and have installed a Pioneer 9080 with a Pioneer
amplifier for the rear speakers. The speakers are AR, although
I don't know the model as the shop installed them with the original
Jaguar grills back on for aesthetic reasons.
The sound is excellent but I detest the digital volume control which
is so difficult to operate or even find if you want to drop the
volume in a hurry. Why couldn't they have fitted a big 'proper'
volume control knob.
The unit is a bit flashy as well, with far too many lights and things,
typically Japanese. It is a pity that English firms don't make
decent car audio that doesn't look flash (like my Cyrus II amp and
Quad tuner etc.)
Anybody any comments?
Nick.
|
93.7 | | JUNO::WOOD | Scalpel, scissors, replace head ....... | Fri Feb 01 1991 13:29 | 20 |
|
My friend has bought a Pioneer I.C.E. unit, and wants to fit an amplifier to
it, the only problem is, he was told that he needed one with a High Powered
Interface, which is not standard (obvously) and that Pioneer were still working
on their one.
Does anyone know which makes produce such a unit, whether this just means
pre-amp and that he will be able to get away with just using a higher power amp,
or indeed if anyone has such an amp ??
Thanks
Alan
~~~~~~
Mail : Juno::wood or Janus::wood
DTN : (7)830 4662 (DP2)
P.S. I will be cross posting this in CARS_UK.
|