[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference vmszoo::rc

Title:Welcome To The Radio Control Conference
Notice:dir's in 11, who's who in 4, sales in 6, auctions 19
Moderator:VMSSG::FRIEDRICHS
Created:Tue Jan 13 1987
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1706
Total number of notes:27193

1678.0. "Fox 45/50 engine problems - help!" by WRKSYS::HOLT () Wed Aug 16 1995 13:32

    
    My father (not a Digital employee) is having a lot of problems with his
    Fox 45 and 50 engines.  These are ring and ball-bearing engine types.
    He asked me to put in this note to see if anybody has any advice (I
    thinks he's on the verge of throwing them in the trash).
    
    He says the 50 runs for about two minutes in the air, then it dies.
    
    The 45, he says, surges after getting into the air; then, it dies.
    
    He says he IS using Duke's recommended fuel.  He's sent each one back
    to the factory, TWICE, and supposedly nothing is wrong with the
    engines, but the above problems keep recurring.
    
    Any suggestions?  (If you have other questions that would help with
    "diagnosis," let me know... we really didn't get into plane types that 
    he has, or anything.)  He's in a flying club in Maine, but his fellow
    pilots can't offer any ideas, I guess.
    
    Thanks!  Betsy Holt
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1678.1Some things to be aware of.ANGLIN::SPOHRWed Aug 16 1995 15:2317
    The 50 may be leaning out once it warms up and gets in the air.  Tell
    him to try setting the high end a couple of clicks richer.  
    
    The 45 sounds like it may have a fuel draw problem.  
    
    On both engines, he should make sure that the prssure tap from the
    muffler is clear and not obstructed.  Also, the position of the fuel
    tank is critical on some engines.  Ideally, the centerline of the fuel
    tank should be in line with the carb on the engine.  More than 3/4" or
    so and some engines won't run consistently.
    
    Also, have him try another brand of fuel.  Borrow a tank from a couple
    different flying buddies.  One with more nitro and one with less.  He
    should also try changing glow plugs.  Try a different brand with and
    w/o the idle bar.
    
     
1678.2Some thoughtsSNAX::SMITHI FEEL THE NEEDThu Aug 17 1995 08:4050
    Not sure what you mean by "surges" after it get's into the air, but if
    you mean leans out and dies, the high end needle is probably too lean.
    Have him set the needle on the ground and hold the nose up. If the
    engine speeds up and dies, it's too lean. Set the high end needle
    richer. An engine will always run faster in the air after it (unloads)
    and will run a little leaner. If he's tweeking the needle on the ground
    for maximum rpm, again the engine is probably leaning out once
    airborne.
    
    Check and make sure the fuel tank clunk is not stuck forward in the
    tank. Typical symptom of a forward clunk is that the engine runs fine
    on the ground, but once you take off and start climbing out, the engine
    quits.
    
    Running for a couple of minutes and then dying is another indication of
    a fuel tank problem or too lean a mixture setting. If the engine slowly
    looses power and then dies, it's leaning out in the air, and
    overheating. If it maintaines good power but quites after a couple of
    minutes, again check the fuel tank. Make sure the clunk line reaches
    the back of the tank but moves freely up, down, and sideways. The clunk
    should always rest on the bottom of the tank regardless of attitude. In
    other words, if you flip the plane inverted, the clunk should be able
    to drop to the "top" of the tank which is now the bottom.
    
    Check for a leak in the clunk line which is another indication of an
    engine that runs for maybe half a tank and then dies. With a full tank,
    the leak is covered with fuel and therefore has no effect. However as
    the tank empties, the hole becomes exposed and starts sucking air
    instead of fuel.
    
    As Chris mentioned, tank hight and location is another consideration.
    It would help to know what type of planes these engines are being run
    in.
    
    
    Low end needle setting is also important and works in conjunction with
    the high end needle. If, for example the low end needle is too lean,
    and you throttle back in the air, when you try and throttle up, you get
    no fuel and the engine dies. If too rich, the engine will load up and
    die. A correct low end needle setting should allow for a reliable idle
    and smooth transition to full power. You should be able to let the
    engine idle for a minute or so with the engine maintaining a constant
    rpm. When you throttle up, it should be smooth with no sputtering or
    hesitation. If, after a minute of idle the engine sputters and blows a
    fair amount of smoke when you throttle up, the low end is too rich. If
    the engine sags or outright dies, the low end is too lean. Low end
    mixture settings should be made a "little" at a time. Only turn the
    screw about an eighth of an inch at a time. ALWAYS reset the high end
    needle every time you change the low end. Like I said, they work
    together.
1678.3THANK YOU!WRKSYS::HOLTMon Aug 21 1995 12:066
    
    Thank you both, very much!  I mailed up your replies to my Dad on
    Friday, so he should be getting the stuff today/Tuesday.  I really
    appreciate it!  :^)
    
    Regards, Betsy
1678.4As was said earlier - try new fuelSPEZKO::FRASERMobius Loop; see other sideMon Aug 21 1995 14:4913
        Just as another data point on this one - I've had engine problems
        for the last couple of club sessions with what was a consistently
        strong stable engine (OS 46) up till this. Engine would peak out
        fine on the ground, plenty of power but would cut out after maybe
        4 minutes in the air. Needle cleaned, adjusted, readjusted, new
        plug, etc. - same result. 
        
        To cut a long story short, the fuel was bad. Scrounged a tankful
        from one of the guys and the engine was back to it's old self
        immediately.
        
        Andy
        
1678.5why did this help?CSLALL::ONEILLTue Aug 22 1995 14:4812
    Funny you should mention fuel. A friend of mine was haveing alot
    of trouble keeping his Thundertiger engine running on 5% notro.
    Tank postion and plug changes didn't seem to help. The only way to 
    keep it running was to run it rich, real rich. Takeoffs were
    dangerously near stall and throttle response sucked. He switched
    to 15% nitro and we were able to lean out to a nice two stroke
    sound and still have a faint smoke trail out the exaust. This is the
    .40 size engine and as a side bar, we were having the same problem
    with my brother in laws O.S .40. unfortunatly, he had to return home
    to So. Carolina before we could try the higher nitro in his ship.
    
                                                            Jim
1678.6IMHOANGLIN::SPOHRWed Aug 23 1995 13:3030
    The notro content has an effect on the engine performance due to
    several factors, the most significant being compression ratio and port
    timing.  
    
    My preference these days is Cool Power 12.5% Heli fuel in ALL of my
    engines.  It has extra oil and a dark color (better to see) and just
    enough nitro to run well, actually very well, in all of my engines.  I
    run heli's and high-end sport engines currently (OS, YS, and Webra).
    
    Typically, I have found that lower compression "SPORT" engines like 10% or
    15% fuels.  High compression "SPORT" engines seem to run best on 5%,
    maybe 10%.  It varies from engine to engine.  High-perf and ducted fans
    engines, piped engines are a whole new ball game.  
    
    These are just my own observations, so experiment with different fuels,
    plugs, props, etc... until you get the right combination.  Each has an
    effect, some small - some large.  Take the time to find out works best
    for each plane/engine combo.  It will greatly enhance your flying
    pleasure.
    
    I know my engines are setup right when I can snap the spinner backwards
    and it runs within one or two tries.  Warm or cold!  This happens about
    95% of the time when I go flying.  If not, I know I have a problem.  
    
    Strong suggestion: Change one thing at a time.  Does it get better or
    worse.  Go from there.  Changing more than one thing at a time will
    sometimes induce new problems that will further frustrate you.
    
    For what it's worth,
    
1678.7tank positionCSLALL::ONEILLWed Aug 23 1995 14:3113
    Thanks,
                One other thing has puzzled me for some time. When
    I got into this hobby, I was told, and read, the center line of
    the fuel tank should be even with the center of the carb. If it's to
    low, the engine will lean out. It was obvious with the last two
    people I was helping out that their tanks were below the center but
    moving tank helped little if any. As I said, my brother in law had to
    return home before we could try the other fuel. We did get to raise his
    tank which helped a bit but it would have been interesting to see how
    his plane responded to the higher nitro. So I guess what Im asking is,
    were do people stand on tank vs. spray bar height?
    
                                                             Jim
1678.8Fox engine fixALFSS1::HOWERon Howe - Project Manager - DTN 343-0065Tue Apr 23 1996 10:307
    I just read your note.  I love my Fox 45 and 46 engines.  The secret
    was going to the new style carburetor.  I never met anyone who could
    get the old style to hold a setting more than one day.
    I almost threw the engines in the river.  Now I love them.
    Let me know, if your Dad still has trouble.
    Ron