T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1071.1 | | MPGS::MASSICOTTE | | Mon Jul 12 1993 13:12 | 12 |
|
You can do a HELI-COIL installation yourself.
As for the carbs, how long do you intend on keeping this engine?
It's got "knots" on it and it's not a new puppy.
I'd run about a pint of fuel with a little drygas or denatured
alcohol through it, if it were mine. Then try a normal mix,
and if she didn't perform as it did before this happening, then
I'd go for the repairs.
Fred
|
1071.2 | | MONTOR::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Mon Jul 12 1993 13:45 | 24 |
| re: <<< Note 1071.1 by MPGS::MASSICOTTE >>>
> You can do a HELI-COIL installation yourself.
Can you describe it a bit more ? Is the objective to redo the
threads to the same size as the original ? If not, what would
you do about plug size ?
> As for the carbs, how long do you intend on keeping this engine?
> It's got "knots" on it and it's not a new puppy.
Seeing how I've only had it for about 18 months, it normally
runs perfectly, and is very dependable, I'd like to get many
more knots on it ;-) Is the procedure he's recommending
necessary (ie, carb rebuilds and all that) ?
My feeling was to do what you describe, try a little drygas
in the first tankful, and take it from there. I know I've had
water in my car gas before, and that's all it took to get around
the problem. The guy at the marine place told me "don't use drygas
in there", but I have reason to be a little suspicious of his advice.
Thanks
Ken
|
1071.3 | Get a second opinion! | SALEM::NORCROSS_W | | Mon Jul 12 1993 14:11 | 30 |
| Personally, I think the guy saw you coming and is going to take you for
a ride as far as he can. You should be able to take the jets out
yourself and hit them with a carb cleaner which will both clean them
and dry them. I bet the drygas would work anyways. Use the good stuff
(methanol??) not the cheap $.33 per bottle stuff. Using it only once
or twice shouldn't cause harm to the rubber seals, etc. As far as the
helicoil repair. Some people use them, some won't. I don't have any
particular opinion because I never tried one. I did strip a spark plug
on a Honda motorcycle once (aluminum head, same as outboard?). I
tipped the motorcycle upside down (drained the oil first, something you
don't have to do) and used a thread repair tap made for spark plugs and
a vacuum cleaner with a small hose attached that I could stick into the
hole after each turn. I would take a quarter turn in at a time and
then backed it out some so the shavings would work there way out.
After a couple of times of doing this, I would carefully remove the tap
and clean it off with a spray brake (or carb) cleaner and then vacuum
the hole out. A little light oil on the tap after cleaning it off
helps. I was able to rethread the hole without having to resort to a
helicoil (which, by the way, probably requires that you go to the same
trouble of preventing shavings from entering into the combustion
chamber as if you were just rethreading).
Personally, I would give Rick Wilson in Milford, NH a call. He was our
resident outboard (especially older OMC) expert until he got TFSO'd a
couple of weeks ago. I'm sure he would gladly discuss your problems
over the phone and he would charge you alot less (and only do what
really needed to be done). Webster to Milford is probably a 2 hour
ride over good roads if towing a boat. Rick's number is 603-673-3840.
Wayne
|
1071.4 | good news! | GNPIKE::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Mon Jul 12 1993 14:27 | 32 |
| re: <<< Note 1071.3 by SALEM::NORCROSS_W >>>
> -< Get a second opinion! >-
> Personally, I think the guy saw you coming and is going to take you for
> a ride as far as he can.
Thanks for your note. This is the feeling I get too! The guy
is talking about a lot of work for having water in the fuel line.
The motor had been running great before this incident, and he's
talking about rebuilding the carbs, new float needles, etc. Seems
like if the alcohol in fuel these days was gonna be a problem it
would have surfaced by now.
> You should be able to take the jets out
> yourself and hit them with a carb cleaner which will both clean them
> and dry them.
I'll try the drygas first (after dealing with the plug), the good
stuff. One question: what are the jets and what would I look for
to clean em ? Do I need to open anything up to get at them ?
After all the work on the Thompson (new transom, etc etc etc),
I was heartbroken for this stuff to happen, especially the hole :-/
I thought I had seen the last of the epoxy + fiberglass for a while!
I climbed back into this conference to get Rick's #, and then
I read your reply ;-) I figure he's probably bored not working ;-)
Message left.
Thanks,
Ken
|
1071.5 | | FSOA::PRINDLE | Send Lawyers, Guns, Money, and SOFTWARE | Mon Jul 12 1993 15:07 | 21 |
| In my opinion if you plan on keeping this boat for a while then pull
the head to fix the damaged threads. It only takes one scratch in the
cylinder to cause you more headache than pulling the head to begin
with. I have a 1969 85hp Johnson and pulling the head is as simple as
taking out the bolts that hold the head on. I don't think there is
that much difference between our engines. You will need a new gasket
to put the head back on after the threads are repaired.
Be real careful with the helicoil repair kit. Follow the advise of the
previous note to the letter. It does not take much to clog up the tap
and bore yourself a nice smooth hole. This is experience on this one.
If you don't feel comfortable with this one you can take it to a
machine shop, but it will cost you. Another option that might be
cheaper is to call Whitney's in Leominster. He might have a head
floating around real cheap. If you do decide to call him wait till
next week because he is on vacation.
I agree with everyone else regarding your carbs. Try the dry-gas
route. Sounds like this guy is trying to make a buck.
Wayne
|
1071.6 | owners choice... | USCTR1::BORZUMATO | | Mon Jul 12 1993 15:49 | 23 |
|
Here's my .02 cents worth.
1. Don't use anything with alcohol.
2. if you have never done a helicoil, dont do it.
3. Seems you've already called Rick, which is my last piece
of advice.
The guy at the marine place, right on not using alcohol.
Sounds kinda wrong on rebuilding just yet, water shouldn't clog
the jets, unless the fuel was so crudded up, that he saw something
we or you have not.
Is $250 kinda high, depends what is hourly rate is.
If your concerned about doing it yourself let Rick do it,
he knows his stuff.
JIm
|
1071.7 | Gas | SALEM::GILMAN | | Mon Jul 12 1993 16:07 | 16 |
| You might have gotten water into the gas via condensation instead of
water leaking directly into the tank. If it is a metal tank,
condensation contributed to some of the water anyway. You can put
the expensive type of drygas into the tank to eliminate the water
problem in the future.
I learned the old gas lesson the hardway. I properly stored a tank
of gas/oil mix over the winter WITH drygas and fuel stabilizer. In
the Spring the engine wouldn't run well on it at all. It took mixing
in fresh fuel/oil to straighten things out. You had water in there
too, no wonder you have engine problems. But.... live and learn.
Yup... go to Rick.
Jeff
|
1071.8 | is all drygas alcohol based ? | GNPIKE::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Mon Jul 12 1993 16:49 | 38 |
| I definitely won't try the re-threading myself. Either I'll
have Rick do it, or a mechanic friend. Depends on what Rick
has to say later...
On the fuel/water problem, I'm hearing 2 opinions: a little
alcohol based stuff is OK, or use *no* alcohol.
Is the good drygas (eg, STP) *not* alcohol based ? I know that
NAPA auto parts sells drygas but it's 99.9% (or so) pure alcohol - it
worked great in my car when I got bad gas, and I thought I "bought the
good stuff", at least that's what they said at the parts store.
What kind of drygas would you recommend ?
re: <<< Note 1071.7 by SALEM::GILMAN >>>
> You might have gotten water into the gas via condensation instead of
> water leaking directly into the tank. If it is a metal tank,
The water came from a plastic tank that I basically used for
storing excess fuel - when I had a 1/3 tank or something left
in my boat tank (metal) I'd pour it into the plastic one, then
get a fresh 6 gal w/ a full can of Johnson oil. If I had a 1/2
tank after running the new gas, I'd add the 1/3 from the plastic
tank and be all set. I think I'm gonna use your method of
filling whatever gas I'd need, like 2/3 new gas, and add 2/3 can
of the oil, rather than the switch routine.
The problem was probably a combo of condensation *and* water
intake through leaks. That gas tank is gonna be disposed of now...
> live and learn.
That's the moral to the story ;-)
Ken
|
1071.9 | | MPGS::MASSICOTTE | | Mon Jul 12 1993 17:41 | 13 |
|
You took the engine across from "Lics" restaurant?
If you never did any tapping before, let someone who has
do it for you. Best way is to pull the head, but I've done
a few without. I've got/had and extension on my air hose
nozzle that would go inside the cylinder and anything in
there would come flying out. The chips made are much larger
than the gap between the piston and cyl. wall.
Fred
|
1071.10 | | SALEM::NORCROSS_W | | Tue Jul 13 1993 08:37 | 13 |
| Again, standard dis-claimer in affect regarding my lack of experience
with outboards.
From what I have read, alcohol can attack the rubber, etc.,
in your carb and fuel lines when allowed to sit for a period of time.
If you are going to use all of the tank quickly and then refill with
fresh gas that doesn't have drygas in it, then I would expect few
problems if done only once. I do not know if the alcohol in your gas
will cause the oil mixed in to come out of suspension or spark knock
or any other problems unique to a two stroke motor. I have used it in
my four stroke motor with no problems. Again, Rick W. can give you an
honest, knowledgeable answer from an "outboarder's" viewpoint.
Wayne
|
1071.11 | | GNPIKE::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Tue Jul 13 1993 11:05 | 12 |
| re: <<< Note 1071.9 by MPGS::MASSICOTTE >>>
> You took the engine across from "Lics" restaurant?
I just called Hazard Marine, didn't bring it there. It's located
near a public entrance to Webster Lake, and the police station,
near the intersection of Rt's 12 and 16(?). I'm pretty sure there's
a restaurant near the place, which is on small side street.
Do you know of the place ?
Ken
|
1071.12 | some answers | GNPIKE::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Tue Jul 13 1993 11:13 | 31 |
| A small-motor mechanic friend of mine looked at the
Evinrude last night. He said he could easily re-thread
it if I remove the head. It appears that removing the
head would just involve removing a bunch of bolts; my
worry would be snapping a bolt - it's seen a lot of salt
water but it's "clean" under the cover.
If/when I remove the bolts, does the head come off easily ?
Any flying parts to watch out for ?
I also asked him about the alcohol/drygas issue. He said he'd
never use drygas (alcohol) in a 2 stroke motor. The reason
is that alcohol and oil don't mix, much like water and gas
don't mix (which I'm aware of ;-). So there's a possibility
that alcohol would be fired up in the cylinders - if enough
alcohol it would burn real hot and could fry a piston.
For 4 stroke motors, the alcohol mixes with the gas and it's
not a problem.
He said Cumberland Farms discontinued alcohol in gas because
of problems with people using it for 2 stroke motors, even
though the pumps were labeled "not for 2 stroke motors".
His explanation seemed to make a lot of sense.
As for the jets, he'd just recommend cleaning em and draining
the carbs, which is no big deal.
Still waiting to hear back from Rick, when he returns.
Ken
|
1071.13 | Simple solutions ... Cheap fix | 11SRUS::FYFE | United We Stand America - 800 283-6871 | Tue Jul 13 1993 13:02 | 25 |
|
First, get a fresh tank of fuel and hook it up. The carbs on that motor have
little screws at the bottom on the bowls. Remove these screws and drain out
the water. Pump the bulb in the fuel line until all the fuel lines have been
flushed out thru the carbs. Replace the screws. Open the fuel pump cover and
clean out the screen if necessary. Replace screen and cover.
Pop the head off. Nothing special, just remove the bolts. A machine shop can
fix the threads for less than $20.
Put the head back on (20-25 FT-lbs I think, can verify if need be).
New plugs. Drop the boat in the water and fire her up. It may take
a few minutes to get any remaining junk out.
Rebuilding the carbs is unnecessary unless lots of junk got past the two screen
filters (unlikely). Water will not adversly affect the carbs unless the
exposure was over a long period of time (many months).
DON'T USE ALCOHOL or DRYGAS! Although todays fuel systems are made to withstand
exposure to these products the original equipment manufactured in the 70's
was not.
Good luck,
Doug.
|
1071.14 | New fuel worked for me | JUPITR::NEAL | | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:14 | 9 |
| I had the same problem with exception of the stripped plug at
the beginning of the season (when did the ice go out?).
My engine is a Merc, but I doubt your problem and fix is much
different. I removed the filter bowl and cleaned it, removed the
gas line and emptied it. Changed the gas in the tank. Hooked
everything back up and it ran fine. Total cost about $10 for new
gas and oil.
Rich
|
1071.15 | Old OMC's die hard | MSDOA::SCHMIDT | | Wed Jul 14 1993 11:06 | 35 |
| Folks,
Here's what my experience has been....
I sunk my old outboard boat 6 years ago... The 1970 Evinrude 115 was
underwater for about 2 days ( I was out of town ). The OMC repair
manual actually had a "what to do when your motor plays submarine"
section, split into sunk while running and sunk while not running. The
short version is the recommended taking out the plugs, putting rubbing
alcohol or dry gas in through the carbs and cranking the engine for
a while to dry it out. Then try to hook up good gas and try to start
it. My motor started in about an hour and ran many many hours after
that.
I live on a lake in NC, and we leave pontoon boats in the water all
year. We ( considering a group of 10-15 boat owners with various make
outboards ) have had water in gas problems before ( rain, condensation,
bad fillup). We typicallly put a container of drygas in every 5 or 6
weeks to keep the fuel systems "dry". Mix according to the product
recommendations - meaning 1/2 a bottle for a 6 gallon tank. None of us
have had any problems over the past 5-6 years, but that's not to say we
won't in the future.
Over the 8 years I owned that motor, I also ended up stripping out
2 spark plug threads. I am fairly handy and was able to heli-coil the
threads. They lasted another 2 years with no problems. I took the head
off to do the work ( it's a 1/2-1 inch thick cap on the cylinder with
between 8 and 12 bolts to remove ). The heli-coil kit was probably $10-20.
At the time I never thought to price a replacement head, but they may not
be very expensive and would be an unbolt / bolt on fix. If a shop would
fix it for $20 that would also be a fair option.
Good luck!
Chuck
|
1071.16 | use the proper sequence. | SALEM::LAYTON | | Wed Jul 14 1993 11:59 | 8 |
| Just a reminder to avoid warping the head.
Make sure you understand the sequence for tightening the head bolts,
ie; tighten bolts on opposite sides of the head alternately. Don't
tighten any single bolt all at once; go thru the sequence three or four
times, starting with just a little more than finger tight.
Carl
|
1071.17 | Thoughts | SALEM::GILMAN | | Wed Jul 14 1993 12:46 | 33 |
| We (boating notesfilers) had a long discussion about a year ago
in this file regarding using drygas in 2 strokes. Rick Wilson was in
on the discussion and, as I remember said it was ok as long as you use
ISOPROPYL ALCOHOL rather than methyl alcohol. I have used isopropyl
alcohol in my 1978 25 HP Johnson fuel/oil mix with no problems. Rick
also said to run PREMIUM fuel in your 2 stroke because the current
cheap regular gas tends to cause ping and destroy pistons.
As far as Cumberland Farms discontinuing GASAHOL because of 2 stroke
problems:
1. Isn't gasahol about 1/3 alcohol rather than the much reduced
concentration created by using drygas?
2. Does gasahol have methyl or isopropyl alcohol in it? If its
methyl alcohol that explains the problems.
Pop the cylinderhead off....... RIIIIIGHT! What will probably happen is
you will break one or more head bolts and the head WON'T pop right off,
you will have to pry it off being VERY careful not to damage the head
gasket surfaces.
Not to be negative but if you realize that the above is probably what
will happen and are prepared to deal with it you won't go into this
unprepared.
As far as using compressed air injection into the cylinder while you
rethread...... I would think turbulance would NOT blow all the
particles out as you tap.... and many of the particles would have to be
small.... small enough to get between the piston side wall and
cylinder.
Jeff
|
1071.18 | Should be runnin' by now. | MPGS::MASSICOTTE | | Wed Jul 14 1993 13:18 | 5 |
|
RE: .11, Yup, know the place well.
Nope. Don't recommend it at all.
Fred
|
1071.19 | Use grease on the tap | BLUEFN::GORDON | | Wed Jul 14 1993 14:21 | 5 |
| I have done helicoil's on aircraft engines we pt grease on the tap. Most if not
all of the aluminum filings stuck to the grease. If you're careful you shouldn't
have a problem
Gordon
|
1071.20 | Some motors yes, but probably not this one. | 11SRUS::FYFE | United We Stand America - 800 283-6871 | Wed Jul 14 1993 14:45 | 28 |
|
> Pop the cylinderhead off....... RIIIIIGHT! What will probably happen is
> you will break one or more head bolts and the head WON'T pop right off,
> you will have to pry it off being VERY careful not to damage the head
> gasket surfaces.
>
> Not to be negative but if you realize that the above is probably what
> will happen and are prepared to deal with it you won't go into this
> unprepared.
Head bolts are not under a lot of torque for their size for this motor. They
should spin out pretty easily. One technique to use, if you suspect corrosion
has cemented the threads, is to first try to TIGHTEN the bolts to break the
threads free. I would only do this if moderate pressure does not break the
bolt loose in the 'off/left' direction. If you should choose to tighten them
first, you should only allow the smallest amount of travel to occur.
I've work on many of these engines (and I have some spare parts if you need 'em)
and I've never had a head bolt cease, even in the salt water motors where
the water jackets are severely corroded.
After the bolts are out you can use a plastic tap hammer to break the seal
and loosen the head.
Now, the lower ends of these beasties are a different story 8-}.
Piece of cake!
|
1071.21 | update | MONTOR::FURTHR::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Thu Jul 15 1993 10:26 | 42 |
| First off, I spoke to Rick Wilson tues night - he's doing well, still
looking for a job, but sure sounded relaxed ;-) He misses Notes and
says Hello to everyone here. I also gave him an update of recent
topics, especially this one ;-)
Rick's opinion of the carburator rebuild recommendations from the
2 Evinrude marinas is that it's NOT necessary and that they are just
trying to make a buck, saying this is what gives marinas/mechanics a
bad name. He recommended draining the carbs and using isopropyl-based
drygas, not a lot, just a little (3-4 oz/tank) in the new gas mixture
to deal with any remaining water.
On the spark plug helicoil, he says it's not necessary to pull the head,
which is what Holland Marina also said. He offered to do the work, but
I opted to get it done yesterday @ Holland Marina, since it's so close
to my house and since a mechanic friend said they are good mechanics there.
Cost me $35.00 for new threads/helicoil, and Rick said they'd still be
making a buck - can't complain though. They used grease to trap any metals.
So that problem is solved (I hope).
I plan on dealing with the carb and have it running by the weekend.
I'll post the progress (or questions ;-) as soon as I know more.
Then to deal with the gash in the hull :-/
re: Chuch Schmidt
My owners manual also has a "Sunk Motor" section! I never thought of checking
that. Curious to see what they recommend.
re: Jeff
Breaking bolts was definitely one of my fears. I've done it before on
the car - what a pain! There's zero corrosion under the "hood", but
I'm glad I don't have to deal with removing the head now.
re: Fred M - Hazard Marine
Interesting... I'll deal with Rick from now on.
Thanks,
Ken
|
1071.22 | looking good! | MONTOR::GNPIKE::HANNAN | Beyond description... | Mon Jul 19 1993 11:17 | 24 |
| I got the motor started this weekend! I did as Rick and others
suggested: removed the carb covers (2), which took all of 2 mins,
and basically drained each carb with the drain screw at the bottom
of each. Very easy to do. I also drained all hoses that I could
get at to try and remove as much water as possible from the system.
It was *mostly* water in each carb!
After I did this once, the motor wouldn't fire - all plugs still had
some water droplets on them. So I basically kept cleaning the plugs
during each "start iteration", and drained the carbs again (twice total).
That's all it took. After the water was removed, the motor fired right
up and seems to be fine. Hopefully it will continue to run great when
I get it out on the water (once the hole is fixed).
I'm also running with about 3 oz of drygas in 6 gallons of gas, which
Rick recommended.
One more rec from Rick Wilson: use anti-sieze compound on the plug
with the helicoil to avoid pulling the helicoil out. Sounds like good
advice.
Thanks for all the help!
Ken
|