T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1779.1 | | WLDWST::POLLARD | | Mon Nov 12 1990 13:36 | 18 |
| My bias: I own the cheapo Minoura stand and dishing tool, but have
occasional access to a Park Pro and Campy dishing tool.
The Minoura is quite nasty but gets the job done. The dishing tool
flexes and the stand isn't quite square in every (any?) dimension. The
stand flexes too. It doesn't prevent you from building nice wheels,
but it could be better.
With the Park stand and a Campy dishing tool, I can work twice as fast
(at least) because of a lot of little things. Don't trust the "self-
centering" feature though. It's not dead reliable like a dishing tool.
Overall, though it is a joy to work with.
Which to buy? It's kind of like a choice between Snap-On tools vs a set
of K-Mart sockets. If you use it A LOT, it is probably worth it to
get the good stuff. If you like to have nice tools, get the good
stuff. For infrequent, utilitarian use, the junk functions and costs
about 1/3 as much.
|
1779.2 | anything without the jaws... | SUSHI::KMACDONALD | Drywall Poster Child for 1990 | Mon Nov 12 1990 17:07 | 13 |
| I prefer any stand without the little centering jaws typical of the
Minoura and Park models - I like just having an easily adjustable arm
that adjusts for in/out and side-to-side. As .1 indicates, the centering
jaws can be (or get) misaligned. I prefer the flip-it-over-to-check
dishing method, so I've never needed a dishing tool. The nicest stand
I've used was a homemade job, one wheel support moved side-to-side to
adj. for hub width, and it had a bent rod that stayed wherever you moved
it via spring tension. I built probably 200 wheels on it. I grieve for
its loss whenever I have to build a wheel ;-(. Currently I think I've
got a Minoura, anyway it's a copy of a Park style with the jaws 'cuz it
was all I could find at the time. It's serviceable, and I don't build
wheels that often anymore.
ken
|
1779.3 | Keep them away from my bike | NOVA::FISHER | Rdb/VMS Dinosaur | Tue Nov 13 1990 08:18 | 6 |
| "For infrequent, utilitarian use, the junk functions and costs
about 1/3 as much."
Cheap tools are the most expensive thing you'll ever own.
ed
|
1779.4 | | WLDWST::POLLARD | | Tue Nov 13 1990 11:01 | 6 |
| re: .3 I see you have the full Campy tool set. Can I borrow
the bottom bracket facing tool? :^)
But seriously, I don't think that you will damage anything by using a
minoura stand unless you wield it like a mace. Wrenches, etc are a
different matter, I agree.
|
1779.5 | Even "professional" tools can be improved | DECWET::BINGHAM | John | Tue Nov 13 1990 16:49 | 5 |
| I saw a truing stand that had come from Europe (Italy I believe but am not sure)
that had been modified to use dial guages with rollers for truing wheels. They
helped show how much a wheel was out of true quickly. The mechanic measured
the wheel gap---outside to outside of locknuts or axle---and the rim width
to locate rim center and set the gauges accordingly. He built nice wheels.
|
1779.6 | strategic trueing | SHALOT::ELLIS | John Lee Ellis - assembly required | Tue Nov 13 1990 18:11 | 9 |
|
Speaking of gauges, etc. - there are also rumors of a laser-based
truing device, with readouts down to the micron. You can apparently
get an add-on option - a spin-off from our SDI taxpayer dollars - to
upgrade the laser to a power laser, which "corrects" out-of-true
rims by itself, in a process which as a byproduct also reduces that
all-important rotating rim-mass.
-john
|
1779.7 | :-) | NOVA::FISHER | Rdb/VMS Dinosaur | Wed Nov 14 1990 05:32 | 3 |
| Yes, John, and NASA has built a robot to ride the bike for you, too.
ed
|
1779.8 | Cyborg stoker | DECWET::BINGHAM | John | Wed Nov 14 1990 12:50 | 1 |
| > .7 At last a "real engine" for a tandem stoker. . . . .
|
1779.9 | The Park Professional, the only way to go | TEMPE::HUFFAKER | | Wed Nov 21 1990 18:01 | 8 |
| I have a Park Pro. I had a Minoura prior. The Minoura was a pain at
time but worked. I treated myself to the Park just for the heck of it.
It is great. The auto center is reliable but you do have to set the
unit up correctly and check to make sure something hasn't moved (after
dropping or hitting the unit accidently my garage is crowded). Its a
joy to work with long after you forget the $140 I paid Nashbar for it.
mike
|