T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
439.22 | Chains vs Snow tyres. | NEWOA::SAXBY | A house! My kingdom for a house! | Wed Jun 19 1991 16:35 | 13 |
|
Well, the skiing holiday is booked and we're driving! (Got to see
140mph on the Calibra's clock once. :^)).
My question is, are snow tyres better than chains? Would it be worth
buying some steel rims and snow tyres to drive in Germany/Austria or
would chains be a better compromise solution? Presumably snow tyres
don't come in 140 mph rating?
I'm off to Le Mans on Friday, so I'd like to look for chains there if
they are reasonable thing to have (as this note seems to suggest).
Mark
|
439.23 | | DCC::HAGARTY | Essen, Trinken und Shaggen... | Wed Jun 19 1991 16:53 | 17 |
| Ahhhh Gi'day...�
I've never had snow tyres in three years here in Munich. With a 200
horsies under the bonnet, there's a few times I wish I did though.
It depends where you are going, whether you'll be driving around the
high villages when you get there, and what the roads and weather is
like on the way. If it's snowing badly on the autobahn, it doesn't
matter much what you've got, you sit in a jam, especially if there is
lots of ice around.
Chains are only for low speed putting around, really. You couldn't
drive great distances in them. I tend to look at chains as a last
resort, dig me out of a snow drift, get me down the mountain type
addition. Snow tyres might make you relax a bit more.
Quite a few winter tyres are rated up to 190 kph.
|
439.24 | Recommend you hire chains | NEWOA::MACMILLAN | So many V****s, so little time | Wed Jun 19 1991 16:54 | 10 |
| I wouldn't bother with trying to get hold of snow tyres - they'll drive
you mad with the noise they make on the tarmac and the grip will be
rather "different".
You can hire chains from "the man that can" (probably others too) and
pick them up/drop them off at the port. We did this when we went to
Val Thorens - one of the highest resorts in the Alps in March; we
didn't even take the chains out of the box.
Rob
|
439.26 | This is what I call being organised well in time! | VOGON::MITCHELLE | Beware of the green meanie | Wed Jun 19 1991 18:48 | 13 |
|
Yes, snow tyres are the best - but they are noisier, and do handle
diffently. Your main consideration is whether they are worth the
investment - ie how long will you wnat to keep a car that the tyres
fit, how many trips are you going to do in that time? What will the
weather here be like next year? :-) We use our winter tyres here, but
it's more a case of "we've got them, might as well use them!"
(If you think about buying winter tyres abroad, make sure you get the
speed rating you want, many of them are only rated to about 70mph)
Elaine
|
439.27 | Is that for studs? | PLAYER::KENNEDY_C | The same old clich� | Wed Jun 19 1991 18:58 | 3 |
|
I don't know of any rated about 70 mph. Usual is 160 kph, but nowadays
you can get 210 kph winter tyres.
|
439.28 | Snow tyres get my vote | NSDC::SIMPSON | There is no escape except to go forward | Wed Jun 19 1991 19:15 | 6 |
| My snow tyres aren't noisy - do the rest of you have studded snow tyres - which
aren't allowed on motorways in Switzerland?
Snow tyres work just fine in most situations - they only time you need chains
are when you've got 6"+ of fresh snow which hasn't been removed by the
snow-ploughs yet
|
439.29 | Not so noisy | EEMELI::JMANNINEN | Untouchable | Thu Jun 20 1991 09:31 | 18 |
| Advice from Finland (land of snow and ice):
If you want silent but very good snow tyres; buy the new
Good-Years (can't remember the model code; but the newest type). I had
the with studs under my Vectra - they very much more silent than
Firestone summer tyres.
But if don't need them permanently, then it's waste of money. Snow
tyres are very expensive...
If you have good - I mean *GOOD* - summer tyres you can manage it even
in snow if you drive carefully.
Remember; when driving in winter conditions you must avoid sudden
movements with steering, gas, brakes etc...
- Jyri -
|
439.31 | | UFHIS::GVIPOND | | Thu Jun 20 1991 14:10 | 11 |
|
When I lived in Munich before, I bought some 195 tyres for my golf, used
those in summer and my old summer tyres in winter ( 175's I think )
with no problems, as long as you drive sensibly. The only time you
need chains are when its REALLY bad or when your somewhere like Pass Thurn,
but then thier on and off like the perverbial "young ladies undies" ;-)
I'd hire chains just in case, but drive carefully and you'd have no
problems with summer tyres.
|
439.32 | vorsprung durch technik? | TURB0::art | | Thu Jun 20 1991 14:18 | 10 |
| >> but then thier on and off like the perverbial "young ladies undies" ;-)
sidetracking here, but is there a difference in the drag coefficient between
young and older "ladies undies" ?
...Art
|
439.33 | Take Chains.. | RTODWT::KMORRISSEY | Pet the Hot Kitty.. | Thu Jun 20 1991 14:23 | 15 |
| You may have problems with access to certain passes if you don't have
chains - the police sometimes make a point of stopping every car &
turning back everyone who doesn't have them (even 4wd's!!).
Fitting & removing the new-style chains is a doddle - so apart from the
cost there's no reason not to carry them.
The AA rental service is good & quite cheap,a few years ago I managed
to break one of their chains & I still got the deposit back....
I use Goodyear M&S Snow tyres in the winter on my Golf GTI,& very good
they are too... I still HAD to use the chains twice last year,& it was
a mild winter..
~Kev~
|
439.34 | | AEOEN2::MATTHEWS | In a negative brownie-point situation ... | Thu Jun 20 1991 15:30 | 20 |
| Mark,
For the odd weeks holiday, don't bother to buy snow tyres. Your car is
new-ish, and the tryes are new-ish, so you shouldn't have problems getting
to within a few miles of the ski station.
Buying chains is probably worth-while, but with the car you have it will
not be at all easy to fit them. I assume the clearance you have between
the tyres and the wheel-arches is SMALL. On my BMW it is quite BIG, and
the chains I have still like to bite chunks out of the arches !!!
Also, buying chains in the supermarkets in France at the moment might
be a problem. Space on the floors is limited, and only things which
are currently selling are there. And to be honest, not a lot of people
are thinking that far ahead yet ...
If you do get some, do a trial fitting BEFORE you need to use them in
anger. It's amazing just how quickly your hands go numb when you are
fiddling around in the snow under the car with a load of cold wet metal
in your hands ...
|
439.35 | Thanks all. | NEWOA::SAXBY | A house! My kingdom for a house! | Thu Jun 20 1991 15:39 | 17 |
| Mark
I wouldn't have thought that a 3 series had a lot more clearance
between wheel and arch, but I'll watch for that.
You're probably right about availability, but I'll have a look anyway.
Nothing ventured...
I reckon chains alone will be sufficient for 90% of what I might
encounter. I picked the car up the weekend that we had a lot of snow
here and it showed no special vices.
I guess if I can't buy chains in France this weekend I'm best to rent from
the AA/RAC or buy in Germany/Belgium on the way to Austria. Of course, if
it's like recent winters, I'll be looking for some slicks! :^)
Mark
|
439.36 | Vauxhall say snow chains can't be fitted to the 16V Calibra with standard fit tyres | 45235::KORMAN | tgif!! | Thu Jun 20 1991 16:39 | 6 |
|
Note that the Calibra handbook says that snow chains can't be used on
the the big tyres fitted to the 16v - probably not enough clearance or
something to do with the ultra-low profile.
If you know otherwise, I'd be interested to hear.
|
439.37 | | NEWOA::SAXBY | A house! My kingdom for a house! | Thu Jun 20 1991 16:42 | 9 |
|
Eeeek!
I hadn't looked at that yet!
What now! Maybe I'll have to buy snow tyres after all?
Mark
|
439.38 | Skiing... don't ya love keeping fit? ;-) | RUTILE::BISHOP | | Thu Jun 20 1991 17:12 | 8 |
| Mark,
If you can't buy snow chains, but the next best thing...
a snow shovel.... just incase ;-)
|
439.39 | Never raced, rallied! | PLAYER::KENNEDY_C | The same old clich� | Fri Jun 21 1991 10:20 | 2 |
|
So buy mine then ...
|
439.40 | Snow chain question | KERNEL::SHELLEYR | On the bank of brinkruptcy | Thu Oct 10 1991 10:30 | 10 |
| A friend of mine with a Fiesta RS turbo is planning on going skiing in
a few months time. He plans to drive through France. He is concerned
that some areas have signs that say you must have snow chains fitted.
The handbook for the RS says that snow chains cannot be fitted to this
model. ANy reasons why not ? Could it be the low profile tyres.
Has anyone else got a car with this restrictions.
Roy
|
439.41 | | RUTILE::BISHOP | | Thu Oct 10 1991 14:32 | 11 |
| Just for information :-
The road clearing system in France is _very_ good in winter. It's
very rare that you will see some people being stopped from proceding
due to not having snow chains fitted, and that is nearly always going
high up into the resorts.
If he is just driving through France (as the note implies) then he
should really have no worries. Unless you're going up into the resorts
then everything should be ok. Out of interest, what tyres do the RS
Fiesta's have?
|
439.42 | | BELFST::FLANAGAN | Too much alcohol is a good thing | Thu Oct 10 1991 18:13 | 3 |
| The Fiesta RS Turbo has 185x14x50 or is it 185x14x55 ?
Gary.
|
439.43 | | KERNEL::SHELLEYR | On the bank of brinkruptcy | Fri Oct 11 1991 16:21 | 6 |
| �185x14x50 or is it 185x14x55 ?
The tyres are 185 14 55.
Roy
|
439.44 | yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh | DCC::HAGARTY | Essen, Trinken und Shaggen... | Fri Oct 18 1991 16:20 | 3 |
| Ahhh Gi'day...�
Get a 4WD car.
|