[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference moira::parenting_v3

Title:Parenting
Notice:READ 1.27 BEFORE WRITING
Moderator:CSC32::DUBOIS
Created:Wed May 30 1990
Last Modified:Tue May 27 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1364
Total number of notes:23848

1242.0. "Parental reactions to choking in young children" by MR4DEC::DONCHIN () Mon Dec 09 1991 12:08

    My husband and I took the kids to a family-type holiday party yesterday
    with a few other families. At one point, almost everyone was gathered
    around the dining room table eating snack food, when a two-year-old
    child began choking on a meat stick (they look like two- to three-inch
    hot dogs and they can be made of chicken, beef, etc.) The mother was
    standing next to the child, asking him if he was O.K., and sort of
    tapping him on the upper back. Well, after about 30 seconds, it was
    apparent to me that the child was in serious trouble, so I practically
    threw my son at my husband, ran around the table, picked the child up
    under the left shoulder, leaned him over, and gave him three whaps in
    the middle of his back with the heel of my hand (hard). Thank goodness
    the meat came out and he recovered, but the mother acted as though
    nothing had happened to the child. And earlier, the hostess had told me
    that her daughter (a little over one) recently choked on and then
    swallowed a barrette, and she acted very cool about that too.
    
    Maybe it was the group I was with, but as a parent of two--one of which
    is nearly four and past the "everything in the mouth" stage--I can't
    understand how these parents can be so casual about choking. When my
    daughter was an infant/toddler, I was always concerned about her choking on
    some food or object. As my son will reach that stage in the
    not-too-distant-future, I'm already worrying about that with him too.
    In the situation I described above, I wasn't expecting the mother to
    get hysterical. But her reaction was just *too* casual.
    
    I asked my husband after-the-fact if he thought the child was in
    trouble or if I reacted too quickly. He felt that the adults at the
    table knew the child was in trouble but were too paralyzed to react. He
    also couldn't understand why the parents never thanked me for helping
    their son, but I really don't care about that. What I don't understand
    is the casual reactions to these situations.
    
    Any opinions?
    
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1242.1A job well done!MCIS5::TRIPPMon Dec 09 1991 12:1917
    Not being there in the situation, I would hardly be the one to pass
    judgement on the parent.  Yes fear can/will literally paralize you!
    
    All I can say is Thank God you had the sense and courage to react to
    the situation.  If you read my note 199, the parents didn't react and
    the result was tragic.
    
    Check with local protocols, however, I recall that backblows may have
    been eliminated, and chest thrust (Himlich manever) is the only thing
    being done now (American Red Cross procedures), at least in Adults if
    not in infants and children.
    
    I will check as well with our EMS director and post a correction if
    needed.
    
    God bless you for reacting, and averting a tradgedy!
    Lyn
1242.2Some people!GEMINI::NICKERSONMon Dec 09 1991 12:2412
    As a parent of three VERY active boys I have ALWAYS been paranoid about
    choking.  My husband always jokes about how small I cut up my two years
    olds meat.  When we have "choky" kind of food I don't think I
    completely relax until the meal is over.  The older kids tease me about
    it now but they also are very quick to tell their little brother to put
    his arms up over his head if they think he's choking!
    
    I'm amazed at the reaction of the parents at the party you went to. 
    They should be thankful you were there or they may not be having a very
    happy holiday season!
    
    Linda
1242.3IRONIC::BRINDISIMon Dec 09 1991 12:5117
    We were at a restaurant once and my daughter started choking on oyster
    crackers.  At that time I hadn't taken any CPR/First Aid courses, so I
    panicked.  My husband started banging her on the back (she was about 16
    months) and eventually it came out.  I did notice though that not one
    person in the rest. even got out of their seats to help.  I mean it was
    obvious that we were hysterical.  I am in no way judging these people,
    I was just so surprised and at that point realized that it was up to me
    to take the course (which I did).
    
    BTW, was the child coughing or making any noise.  Because if they are
    making noise (coughing) then they aren't really choking.  Maybe the
    mother knew this and in this case the best thing to do is let the
    person/child cough it out.
    
    
    Joyce B.
    
1242.4Another guessNEWPRT::WAHL_ROMon Dec 09 1991 13:1010
    
    I wasn't there so I really hesitate to make judgements. I'm the mother
    of a GAGGER and the wife of an ALARMIST - so we have lots of episodes
    at our house!
    
    I FORCE myself to remain calm when my 18 month old starts gagging. If
    a stranger grabbed her in a restaurant - my reaction might seem
    nonchalant - until I scrape daddy off the ceiling.
    
    Rochelle   
1242.5GRANMA::MWANNEMACHERpeace on earth-goodwill to allTue Dec 10 1991 09:168
    I always try and remain calm, there are enough others around panicking
    so as it is good to have a cool head.  I also do not act unless the
    child is not passing any air.  I believe the protocol for choking is
    first the three blows to the back and if that does not dislodge the
    article, then you go to the heimlich maneuver.
    
    
    Mike
1242.6Some info..CLT::KOBAL::CJOHNSONEat, drink and see Jerry!Tue Dec 10 1991 10:4817
    
    This information is provided by the American Red Cross on choking.
    
    CONSCIOUS, CHOKING
    
    Can they speak, gasp, cough, wheeze, etc?
    
    YES - Leave alone.  Watch carefully.  No back blows.
    
    NO - ADULT or CHILD: 6 - 10 abdominal thrusts 
         INFANT: 4 back blows and 4 chest thrusts
    
    Note: for infants - shrill sound with no cry means they need help
                        with breathing.
    
    
    -Chris
1242.7FSDEV::MGILBERTGHWB-Anywhere But America Tour 92Tue Dec 10 1991 13:426
    
    The lack of thanks says to me that these parents were probably deeply
    disturbed under their apparent cool. Sometimes adults react outwardly
    in what is often an "expected" manner while they are falling apart
    inside.
    
1242.8Any more info on Red Cross guidelines?MR4DEC::DONCHINTue Dec 10 1991 14:2124
    re: .6
    
    Chris-
    
    I'm very surprised that the Red Cross no longer advocates trying to
    perform back blows before attempting abdominal thrusts in adults. I
    wonder why adults and children would be treated any differently, given
    that everyone has the same anatomy...just in different sizes. Do you
    have a date on the Red Cross guidelines you posted in your reply?
    
    In Sunday's situation, the child was not passing any air or sounds and
    exhibited other symptoms if choking (mouth open with tongue hanging and
    color changing from pale to red to purple...luckily the meat was
    dislodged before he could turn blue). I just reacted as I did years ago
    when I learned CPR (a LONG time ago). Guess it's time for a refresher
    course if the guidelines have changed.
    
    I agree with -1 that the mother in this situation was probably scared
    witless by this episode, which explains her casualness about the whole
    thing. I guess I became disturbed about her action, combined with the
    other mother's casualness about the barrette episode, and wondered how
    you all felt about this subject. Thanks for the input.
    
    Nancy-
1242.9That's me!!MCIS5::TRIPPTue Dec 10 1991 14:3513
    re .7, that's ME exactly!  I can't tell you how many times I reacted
    calmly, only to fall apart when I knew he was all right, or being cared
    for by someone more qualified than I!
    
    Like the incident last month when AJ fell off the playground, I very
    calmly put a napkin from the car on it, put him in the front seat, even
    remembered to buckle the seatbelt, and drove calmly to meet the
    ambulance at the barn.  Once I had handed him over to my coworkers on
    the ambulance I literally fell apart and became the hysterical mother.
    (a period of about 10 to 15 minutes total).  Maybe I'm just a little
    slower to react?
    
    Lyn
1242.10ARC CPR is being changed all the timeESKIMO::MELIATue Dec 10 1991 19:1522
    re: .8
    
    Nancy-
    
    Backblows are not done on either Adults or Children. They are only
    performed on Infants in conjunction with chest thrusts. This is 
    because it is easy to invert an infant. The head must be lower than
    the chest. Otherwise you run the risk of forcing the obstruction even
    deeper into the airway.
    
    The guidelines for American Red Cross 1st Aid and CPR have had some 
    major changes in the past 2 years. This is one of the reasons that
    the CPR certification only lasts 1 year. There is also a new way of
    becoming recertified without going through the entire course again.
    Provided you hold a current certification, you can study the text on
    your own then take the written exam and perform the drills using the
    manikins. This should take about half an hour to complete for the 
    basic Adult CPR. This way people will be less likely to let their cert.
    lapse.
    
    Brenda
    (ARC Adult 1st Aid/CPR instructor)
1242.11It's a TWO year cardMCIS5::TRIPPWed Dec 11 1991 12:3014
    re .10....  ummmm Brenda, check again on the every year re-cert.
    
    There is a lively discussion going on in the Fire_Rescue_EMS notes on
    this subject.  Seems cards are now renewed every TWO years.  Several of
    the NH EMT's were just issued new CPR cards with a '93 expiration.
    
    Now back to what sounds like a do it yourself CPR course, I like that
    idea, but that's the EMT in me speaking.  For the most part recert
    courses, which can be in the vicinty of 10 hours are boredom bigtime,
    to the lay person I would approach a self-paced course with a little
    hesitation.  People who don't do CPR on a regular basis, would IMO,
    need more hands on refreshing.
    
    Lyn
1242.12My card says....MCIS2::DUPUISLove is grand, divorce is 20 grandWed Dec 11 1991 13:0924
    I have a card from the Red Cross 
    
    
    front of card...
    "This certifies that 
    _(me)________________________
    has completed the ADULT CPR
    course of instruction 
    at _____Digital Equipment Corporation____
    ____August 19, 1991____
    Date course completed
    
    			(signature)-->George F. Moody
    			 Chairman, American Red Cross"
    back of card
    "NOTE:  Training in Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR)
    is valid for one year from the course completion date.
    
    Name of Chapter ___________________________________
    Chapter Respesentative ____________________________
    Instructor ________________________________________
    Holder's Signature ________________________________"
    
    Roberta
1242.13Huh?PROXY::HOPKINSVolunteer of the monthWed Dec 11 1991 13:137
    Not long ago I just completed my yearly CPR certification course.  I
    haven't looked in the Fire_Rescue_EMS notes but I was told to be
    certified you have to take it every year.  The first aid part of it is
    every two years.  But either way, there have been changes to CPR just
    about every year since I started taking it 6 years ago.
    
    Marie
1242.14I am awaiting clarificationMCIS5::TRIPPWed Dec 11 1991 13:3420
    I NOT trying to start a rathole here... I too am holding a card, about
    to expire with a one year renewal.
    
    I have sent mail to the author of the EMS note asking for
    clarification, since he resides in and works for a NH service, it may be
    different there.  If I can't get a clear answer my next move might be
    the Central Mass EMS corp., which is our clearing house for all
    in-service training. This has caused much discussion among several
    groups, we're not not alone here.
    
    re: a couple back...your card says "ADULT" CPR?  Would that not
    translate into the old "heartsaver" courses the company gives?  CM-EMS
    says that I can't take the courses given by DEC, they are not considered 
    by the Comm of Mass to be enough, my card say BLS (Basic Life Support) CPR,
    which is infant, child, adult one and two man CPR, plus obstructed airway 
    for all three categories, it involves 10+ hours classroom plus the
    written and practical test.
    
    Lyn
    (EMT Oxford MA)
1242.15embarrassed?SCAACT::COXManager, Dallas Demonstration Center, SME SupportThu Dec 12 1991 14:5915
Perhaps the parents were embarrassed????

Once we gave Kimmi Jo chips at a Mexican Restaurant and she began to choke.
Both of us knocked over our chairs to get to her.  David didn't have a clue
so he gave moral support while I turned her upside down and did back thrusts.
It came out before the first thrust.

While nobody got out of their chairs to help, I was a little embarrassed about
causing such a scene, and merely sat back in my chair like nothing had
happened!  I still shiver when I think about it, though.....

Re:  expiration rathole - my LIFESAVING card lasts 2 years, but my CPR card
lasts one year.  Both issued by Red Cross.

Kristen