[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

1418.0. "IT'S A PUZZLEMENT" by DIRK::LUST (REALITY IS WHEN YOU CAN'T HANDLE DRUGS) Mon Dec 05 1988 11:27

On Saturday, I bought a CD at Lechmere in Nashua.  The CD was supposed to be
a compilation of overtures played by the Berlin Philharmonic under Herbert
von Karajan.  The Label on the Disk itself also said HvK etc.  When I actally
played the CD, however, it turned out to be "Dr Hook's Greatest Hits".

Now I'm perplexed:  should I return the CD and get a new (hopefully correct)
version, or should I hang on to the damn thing as a collector's item.

	DECISIONS, DECISIONS

By the way, it is an Angel/EMI disk (Capitol).  I don't recall ever seeing
von Karajan and the BPO on anything but DGG.

Any comments and or suggestions?

Dirk

P.S.  I kind of like Dr Hook too.

P.P.S.  I'm afraid that if I take it back to 'LEECHmere', they'll try to 
charge me extra since I obviously got an unexpected 'bonus'.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1418.1stranger than fictionCGVAX2::HARRISMon Dec 05 1988 13:0214
    TAKE IT BACK!!!!
    
    I work at a record store (Rockit) and this has happened a few times.
    We justa send the defective disk back to the distributor.  I remember
    1 disk that was supposed to be the Doors "LA lady" but no one knew
    who it was.  Another time, disk said it was Mark Isham, but it was
    a compilation called Rockin 50's.  The strange thing about this
    one was that they were 2 entirely DIFFERENT labels!!
    
    You should return it and get a new one, or keep it if you're into
    collecting wierd things.
    
    Ann
    
1418.2COOKIE::ROLLOWThe thing dreams are made of.Mon Dec 05 1988 13:534
	If you like the music keep it and get the other later.  There
	might be speculative value in keeping it just because people 
	will collect the weirdest things and pay lots of money for 
	them, but I wouldn't plan on it.
1418.3Beware of a bad batch!CSSE32::RHINEJack Rhine - DTN: 381-2439Mon Dec 05 1988 17:112
I had this happen to me once.  Don't get a new copy at the same place.  When
it happened to me, the store had several more but the whole batch was bad.
1418.4ASABET::MCLAUGHLINSkier au Mont FortTue Dec 06 1988 18:3117
    Many record labels, large and small alike, farm out the actual
    manufacture of CD's to companies which specialize in the pressing
    of compact discs.  Ultra labels such as Sony/CBS make their own, 
    of course.  Just as is the case with CD players and VCR's, a few 
    companies make them all, regardless of the multitude of record 
    labels.  If you closely examine your discs, with attention to the 
    clear plastic ring in the center, or the area around that
    ring, you may find the name of the company that actually pressed
    each disc.  For example, many of my discs were made by "Digital
    Audio Disc Corporation", and the company name is molded into the
    clear center ring.  Some discs do not indicate manufacturer's
    name.                   
    
    RE: .0  The pressing company must have mixed up the labels and master
            tapes of two different clients.
            
    Shawn
1418.5PDVAX::P_DAVISPeter DavisWed Dec 07 1988 07:283
    There have been many cases of this.  The first one I remember hearing
    about was a disc packaged and labelled as Lawrence Welk, but actually
    containing the Sex Pistols.  I'm surprised anyone noticed.