[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

1029.0. "Harvest Pink Floyd CDs" by DSSDEV::MOR () Mon Dec 28 1987 15:45

    I'm interested in buying the Harvest Versions of Pink Floyd
    Wish You Were Here & Dark Side of the Moon.  Apparently,
    CD stores are either having trouble ordering them or are
    charging mucho dinero for them.  Can anyone tell me where
    or how I can buy them at a reasonable price.  I understand
    that they cost more than regular CDs because they're imports
    and am willing to pay the extra cash.  Optionally, is anyone out
    there, by some remote chance, willing to sell their versions.
    Once again, I'm willing to pay a reasonable price.
  
    For the person in a previous note that said they are worth $150,
    I hope you are joking.  If you were, you're a pretty funny guy.
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1029.1LESLIE::LESLIEAndy, CSSE DECnet/OSI Program, WG5.Mon Dec 28 1987 18:134
    
    My DSoTM is marked with the Harvest logo. It cost �9.99.
    
    What difference is represented by the logo?
1029.2For People With Four EarsAQUA::ROSTDecember boys got it badMon Dec 28 1987 18:309
    
    The US issue is on Capitol.  Supposedly the UK Harvest issue has
    better sound.  Why they have separate masters for CDs in different
    countries I'll never understand.....
    
    Now if they would only issue the old German SQ mix on CD...8^) 
    8^)  8^)  8^)  8^)  8^)
    
    
1029.3UNIVAX::SCHREIBERNoting never goes awayMon Dec 28 1987 18:328
    Just to add to the confusion (?), there appear to be at least 2
    pressings of the Harvest CD.  I picked mine up quite a while ago,
    and it is black on top with silver lettering.  I recently saw a
    newer version, and it is a silver platter with black lettering.
    
    Maybe the older, black one is worth $150 (hope, hope)?
    
    -- Benn
1029.4How about other P.F. CDs?HPSRAD::BLITZOld man, sign ze papers old man!Tue Dec 29 1987 08:069
    Have other  Pink  Floyd  CDs  from Harvest increased in value as well. I
    have  "The  Wall" from Harvest, and there is a big difference between it
    and the US (Columbia?) version that a friend of mine has.

    BTW: In  an  earlier  note, there was a controversy over whether EMI and
    Harvest  were the same. My DSotM has both Harvest and EMI printed on the
    label.

    marty
1029.5exDECWET::HELSELTue Dec 29 1987 10:5710
    re -.1
    
    Mine has Harvest and EMI printed on mine also, but it looks like
    the EMI stuff is just copyright stuff.  Is yours silver with black
    writing?
    
    Give it up Benn, the silver CD's with black writing are ECO CD's.
    Clearly sound better and are worth more :-)
    
    Brett. 
1029.6Japanese Import "DARK SIDE OF THE MOON"OTFSV2::DONELYTue Dec 29 1987 22:128

  While I was out shopping for a CD player just over a year ago
a Salesman told me of his months of hunting for the ultimate
"Dark Side of The Moon" CD..
  Apparently there is a Japanese Import which is supposed to
be Far superior to that of the U.S. or U.K. Import versions..
Costly though; It was about 50% more than the usual Domestic cost...
1029.7Talk about the Dark Side ? ;*)VLS8::SHOREMANTimes a thief when yer undecidedWed Dec 30 1987 07:5111
    
         This seems to be a good spot to add this.  I don't know if
    this has happened to anyone else....But, for Christmas I received
    Floyd's  "Dark Side of the Moon"...Capitol release....I put it in
    the disc player..Sat back....and.......I got Joan Jett and the 
    Blackhearts.  Not EVEN trying to do PF. ;-*).....I moved up a couple
    of tracks.....Same thing.....JJatBH's.......Has this happend to
    anyone ???
    
    John
    
1029.8It happensGCANYN::MACNEALBig MacWed Dec 30 1987 08:005
    I had a similar experience last year (in fact there is probably a note
    in here on it).  I bought Tears for Fears "Songs from the Big Chair"
    and got Bryan Adams.  Probably just a production glitch caused a disk
    to be mislabled.  I exchanged the disk for the one I wanted with
    absolutely no problems. 
1029.9SARAH::P_DAVISPeter DavisWed Dec 30 1987 08:186
    There have been a number of incidents of discs being incorrectly
    labelled and packaged.  The first I heard about was when a number
    of people played what they thought was going to be Lawrence Welk,
    and got the Sex Pistols instead.
    
    
1029.10DSSDEV::CHANWed Dec 30 1987 09:178
    RE: wrong disk.
    
    I'd save the disk.  Could be a collectors item one day.  One can
    never tell what people are willing to pay for a few years down the
    line.
    
    Kenney
    
1029.11Mislabeled or packaging mixup?FROST::EDSONDWed Dec 30 1987 10:095
    re .7
    
    Was the disc itself marked as Pink Floyd or as Joan Jett?
    
    Don
1029.12VLS8::SHOREMANTimes a thief when yer undecidedWed Dec 30 1987 12:527
    
    re:-1
    
         The disc itself *was* labled as Dark Side of the Moon.....
    
    John
    
1029.13LESLIE::LESLIEAndy, CSSE DECnet/OSI Program, WG5.Wed Dec 30 1987 13:527
    I've listened to both the US and UK versions this year.
    
    No difference at all to my philistine ears... (My Harvest has black
    writing on a silver platter)... still better than my somewhat beaten
    up 4th vinyl copy of DSoTM.
    
    Andy
1029.14Is this what your looking for?NOVA::LAVASHSame as it ever was...Thu Dec 31 1987 07:335
    This note got me curious so I checked out my copy of DSoTM.  It
    is a Harvest with silver lettering and a black backround and it
    was printed in Japan.  Now is this 'one of the good ones'? 

    George
1029.15Same as it ever wasHPSRAD::BLITZOld man, sign ze papers old man!Thu Dec 31 1987 08:507
    RE: 14

    That's the  one I have as well. Black with silver writing. My "The Wall"
    is also from Japan and black with silver writing.

    Marty
1029.16nasty bubbles?MEMORY::SLATERThu Dec 31 1987 14:5510
    I would love to have Sex Pistols with Laurence Welk label :-)
    
    On Dark Side of Moon versions, I am confused. What are the difference
    in digital masters. I suppose the dynamic range could be lost due
    to  A/D conversion or some odd digital weighting could have been
    used or range or whatever. Does anybody have an answer or a pointer.
    
    Thanks,
    
    Les 
1029.17AKOV11::BOYAJIANLyra RA 18h 28m 37s D 31d 49mWed Jan 06 1988 15:3718
    The Harvest issues used to be fairly plentiful in the US before
    Capitol and CBS squared up the CD rights in the US. One can still
    find them by looking hard (I found the Harvest issue of MEDDLE
    just a few months ago, for example). They normally aren't any more
    expensive than the average UK import.
    
    re:.6
    
    I bought the Japanese (EMI label) DSotM back when I first started
    buying CD's. At the time, I only paid $22 (this was when the average
    price for new domestic CD's was $17-19). I've not done any A/B
    comparisons myself, but everything I've read about the different
    issues is that the Japanese is superior to any other. I could
    believe that *this* is the one that's going for $150.
    
    I've also heard of an MFSL issue that is supposed to be excellent.
    
    --- jerry
1029.18OTTO::COTTONLoid CottonFri Jan 08 1988 08:474
    My flatmate bought Roxy Music's Avalon, which turned out to be Phil
    Collins No Jacket Required.  He wrote into a CD magazine to see
    if this was/would be worth anything, but they said it was doubtful.
    
1029.19yet another copy......whats next????CYBORG::MORRELLMon Apr 04 1988 06:4316
    
    
       check this out......Mobile Fidelity has released
    
         Pink Floyd____Dark Side Of The Moon
    
      on a (get this) 24k Gold (plated) CD..........and the sound is
    SUPERB!!!  it makes the U.S. cd sound like an echo.....
    
          it's on HARVEST and is made in JAPAN. also comes with a neat
    case that actually lifts the cd out of the case for you.....
    
                 all for only $26.99
    
    
                                               _Charlie_