[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

725.0. "Classical CD Recommendations" by TIPPLE::MIANO (John M. Miano - KYO) Fri Apr 17 1987 11:36

    For those who are not cultured enough to appreciate the nth 
    definitive CD recording of the "1812 Overture" or "Bolero" I make
    the following recommendations:

    Scriabin Symphony Number 1 - Philadelphia Orchestra
                                 Muti
                                 Westminster Choir
                                 ANGEL                                    
    
    Scriabin Symphony Number 2 - Scottish National Orchestra
                                 Jarvi
                                 CHANDOS
                                      
    
    Stenhammer Symphony Number 2 -
               Excelsior Overture - Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra
                                    Jarvi
                                    BIS
    
    The performances and recording quality of these three CDs are
    excellent.  The works are not in the basic repertoire ( Maybe they
    should be ), but if you are interested in late romantic music you won't
    be disapointed.
       
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
725.1I agreeSTKHLM::LITBYP-O Litby, TSSC Stockholm/SwedenSat Apr 18 1987 10:3812
	 I'll have  to  agree with the previous - the ``1812'' ouverture may
	 be spectacular sound-wise, but it's pretty boring music.

	 I have the Scriabin 2nd Symphony on Chandos as well. This is a very
	 interesting  label - lots of good stuff. I'll take this opportunity
	 to  recommend  their  recording of Dvor�k's 7th Symphony, also with
	 the Scottish National Orchestra under Neeme J�rvi (Chan 8501).

	 The BIS recordings if Stenhammar's symphonies are all good. 

	 --- POL
725.2COMET2::STEWARTLong Live Dead ComposersSat Apr 18 1987 22:5236
    I've come to realize that in most cases the biggest bang for the
    buck where CDs are concerned is in the classical genre.  This
    being the case the majority of my purchases will classical in
    nature an I will read this topic with much interest.
    
    Three recordings that I would reccomend would be:
    
    	- Strinvinsky: Symphony of Psalms
    	- Poulenc:     Gloria for Soprano Solo, Chorus & Orchestra
    
    		Robert Shaw, Atlanta Symphony & Chorus
    		Telarc CD-80105  DDD
    
    	Nice performance.  I'm really quite happy to see Choral
    	Music showing up on CD.
    
    	- John Williams, Academy of St Martins-In-The_Fields
    		Guitar Transcriptions of Bach, Handel &
    			 Marcello Concertos.   
    
    		CBS Masterworks MK 39560   DDD
    
    	Excelant transcriptions and performance. 
    
    	- Parkening Plays Bach
    
    		Angel CDC 7 47191 2   Add
    
    	50 minutes of solo Parkening.  The last 6 sellections of the
    	16 are by Handel, Visee, Weiss, Couperin and Scarlatti.  Even
    	though the original session was recorded using analog equipment
    	any hiss is at a minimum or eliminated in the digital mastering.
    	Superb performance.  I reccomend this one, especially, to anyone
    	that likes the sound of the guitar.

    =ken
725.3In search of ExcelsiorLYMPH::DICKSONNetwork Design toolsTue Apr 21 1987 13:023
Yeah, but where can you GET the Excelsior overture?  The Coop didn't have 
it, although they had the other (newer) Stenhammer CD.  (Which sounded to 
me a whole lot like the Saint-Saens organ symphony minus the organ.)
725.4Excelsior LocationTIPPLE::MIANOJohn M. Miano - KYOWed Apr 22 1987 12:2321
    RE: .3
    
    The Excelsior Overture is on the same disk as the 2nd Symphony.
    
    If you want to find it and/or anything else the best place to go
    is The downtown (NY) Tower Records.  They have literaly everything.
    There are no bins labeled "Classical Q-Z".  There is a separate
    section for each composer.  If a disk contains works by several
    composers, copies are placed in the sections for each composer on the
    disk.
    
    The Lincoln Center Tower Records is also good but the classical
    section is not nearly as large.  Another good place is J&R across
    from City Hall.  Their prices are usually better than Tower's.
                          
    By the way, does anybody know how much record stores pay for CDs?
    I saw in Keynote magazine that the list price for the Scriabin/Jarvi
    disk in .0 has a list price of 13.99.  The price in my local (Short
    Hills NJ) record store is 19.99.  The regular price for most CDs
    is 17.99, but usually at least one brand is on sale for 13.99.
    
725.5LYMPH::DICKSONNetwork Design toolsWed Apr 22 1987 17:293
The wholesale price is somewhere around 50% of the retail price.  The
difference goes to pay for store rental, insurance, salaries, taxes,
advertising, etc. 
725.6More SuggestionsTIPPLE::MIANOJohn M. Miano - KYOThu Apr 23 1987 09:5627
    Two more ideas:
    
    Hanson Symphony #2 St. Louis, Slatkin, Angel
       This work was played in the move ALIEN.
    
    Rachmaninov Symphony #2, Ashkenazy, London
       Beware, there are two versions of this symphony out by Andre Previn 
       ( Angel and TELARC ) and both are terrible.  I have not heard
       recordings by Maazel (DG) and Rattle (Angel).
    
    More on Previn - 
    
    I think that Previn has many embarassingly bad records out.  I have
    his "Rhapsody in Blue, Concerto in F, American in Paris" on Angel.  In this
    Disc a third of "Rhapsody in Blue" is cut out and there are times when 
    the orchestra fails to make entrances during the piano parts.  I'm
    not sure if the recording was editing incorrectly or if Andre can't
    tell the difference.
    
    I have also heard his Gershwin "Cuban Overture-Second Rhapsody" disc and
    it is even worse.  The orchestra is rarely playing in tune and it
    is often playing the wrong notes.
                                     
    So if you see a recording by Andre Previn, I recommend that you
    don't buy it.
    
    
725.7PDVAX::P_DAVISaka SARAH::P_DAVISThu Apr 23 1987 11:378
    Re/ .4,.5:
    
    I've seen wholesale distributor catalogs which list CDs for around
    $10.99, so I don't think the typical mark-up is that big, at least
    not for smaller dealers.  Places like Lechmere may get huge quantity
    discounts or something.
    
    -pd
725.8More Russian MusicTIPPLE::MIANOJohn M. Miano - KYOMon May 11 1987 14:0112
    The performance of
        
    Tchaikovsky Symphony #2 "Little Russian" and
    Rimsky-Korsakov Symphony #2 "Antar"      with
    
    Maazel, Pittsburg Symphony, Telarc
    
    is excelent.  Of course you may have to be a fancier of Russian music
    to appreciate it.  Ovation gave it a good review.
    
    As with all Telarc disks, the recording is near perfect.