[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

542.0. "Yes - Fragile" by QUARK::LIONEL (Reality is frequently inaccurate) Sun Nov 23 1986 14:46

    I picked up "Fragile" by Yes yesterday at Record Town in Manchester,
    NH - $15.99.  They had at least one more.  I'm disappointed with
    the sound - I admit it's been a while since I listened to the LP,
    but so much of the disc sounded distorted, though other parts were
    quite clear.  Maybe I'm asking too much?  Overall it was pretty
    good, especially for a Yes freak like me.
    				Steve
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
542.1And Another YesASIA::MCLEMANOut of the Myopic Void...Mon Nov 24 1986 08:175
    I picked up "CLOSE TO THE EDGE" at Rockit Records on D.W. Hiway
    south and Saturday. Nice Stuff!
    
    Jeff
    
542.2CEDSWS::NEWKERKWed Dec 03 1986 23:109
I second the vote for "CLOSE TO THE EDGE".  Good job.  Of course
I have a certain sentiental 'fix' for the album.  It was the only 
cassette that my two friends and I all liked on our trip through
Europe on the trains.  We must have played it a couple of hundred 
times.  Great music for a train ride through the Alps....

Oscar

542.3Yes, Yes, YesNISYSE::GREENIDGEThu Dec 04 1986 12:1211
    Fragile on cd is a good choice, yet I have also noticed distortion
    on some areas of the music.  However, when I compare the cd to the
    album, I notice the same distortion.  The source must be in the
    original tapes, not in the cd conversion process.  I love Yes and
    most of their albums, but I have yet to see "Close To The Edge"
    on cd.  Hoorah for all who buy it.  I only have "The Yes Album"
    and "Fragile."  Now if "Tales..." were released, that would be very
    interesting.
    
    			-Superclam
    
542.4QUARK::LIONELReality is frequently inaccurateThu Dec 04 1986 14:033
    I picked up "Close to the Edge" at Lechmere in Nashua the other
    day.  Beautiful!
    				Steve
542.5RDGENG::LESLIEAndy, CSSE ME, VOTS, OSAK, MRX.400Mon May 11 1987 22:421
    Fragile is to me, the best of all Yes albums. Beautiful!
542.6Thppt to Atlantic!'RDGENG::LESLIEAndy `{o}^{o}' Leslie, OSI CSSEMon Sep 07 1987 17:404
    I bought Fragile last week, but swapped it back. The Vinyl album
    has so much better sound I wonder where they kept the YES masters!
    With YESSONGS so awful and FRAGILE dulkl and lifeless, I've written
    to the label saying I intend to buy no more YES CD's.
542.7REGENT::SCHMIEDERWed Sep 09 1987 13:3520
This is a shame, because I was originally intending on buying "Close to the 
Edge", since my vinyl is in horrible shape and that's the only Yes album I 
like anyway (I still like "Roundabout" and "Yours Is No Disgrace", though).

I have had bad luck, in general, with the Warner family discs.  With the 
exceptions of the ones that have been remixed (which is not stated).  The 
CSN(Y) discs were clearly remixed.  Peter Gabriel was not.  Some of the 
imports have been OK.  After buying Yazoo and being disappointed, another 
noter mentions to me that the U.K. versions had extra songs anyway.  I'm 
borrowing them soon to compare quality as well, to figure out what the story 
is.  I figure Warner's such a big company, they have the hardest time of 
keeping quality intact and maintaining consistency to the way they go about 
their CD releases.

"Close to the Edge" could stand a remix, as could "Fragile" and the others.  I 
had the import vinyl of "Fragile" and thought it sounded dull and lifeless, so 
maybe the problem IS in the master tape!


				Mark
542.8COMICS::HUDSONthat's what I thinkSat Sep 12 1987 05:133
    Don't write off 'Close to the Edge'; I have the cd and I think that
    it sounds very good indeed.  If they don't release 'Tales' and 'Going
    for the One' I'd be very upset.
542.9REGENT::SCHMIEDERMon Sep 14 1987 13:0110
RE: .8

I'll try it when it goes on sale.  This is one album that DEFINITELY needs CD 
technology to be appreciated, due to all the dynamics and quiet passages.  It 
kind of spoils the atmosphere to hear grinding sounds during the bird 
tweetings at the beginning and end, even though I'm not normally bothered by 
vinyl surface noise.


				Mark