[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

522.0. "Music starts too soon..." by SKYLAB::FISHER (Burns Fisher 381-1466, ZKO1-1/D42) Wed Nov 05 1986 13:49

    I've not seen this mentioned before, but it is a problem that I
    frequently notice with CDs:  The music often seems to start just a fraction
    of a second before the 0:00 time.  Thus if this is the first track,
    or if you seek to it, you miss the first "consanent" of the music.
    
    Do others have this problem too?
    
    Burns
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
522.1moving picturesSWIFT::HUDSONthat's what I thinkWed Nov 05 1986 14:456
    i think i've noticed this but only on one of my discs...
    moving pictures by rush; the first track 'tom sawyer' seems to
    start slightly earlier than the 0:00 second mark. 
    
    nick
    
522.2COVERT::COVERTJohn CovertWed Nov 05 1986 19:447
You may be having tracking problems.  This was the first symptom of
tracking problems on my CD-X1, that it wouldn't play the beginning of
O.M.D.'s Crush.  The amount that it missed kept getting more; it wouldn't
move forward and backward well, and then finally it would skip drastically
while playing -- but only on about 1/3rd of my CDs

/john
522.3It might be normal...LA780::GOLDSMITHWed Nov 05 1986 20:0611
This problem can be caused by a incorrectly mastered CD. I have noticed
it on a couple of the CDs I own.

Another possibility is that you are just noticing the delay between the start
of a "track" and the actual zeroing of the time display. Most players I
have used take a fraction of a second to update the time display. On "tracks"
that have a quiet period before their start, this pause is not noticed, however,
on recordings that have no quiet (such as live recordings and some albums
like "Dark Side of the moon") this pause becomes more noticeable.

								--- Neal
522.4get this...JON::MORONEYWelcome to the MachineThu Nov 06 1986 22:538
FWIW: I have one disk that has one track that starts at 3 seconds, counts DOWN
to 0 seconds, stays at 0 seconds for 2 seconds (instead of 1) and then plays
normally. The music on that track starts 1 second into 0 (the crossing from -0
to +0?) Someone must have been playing some sort of game to do that!  Seeking
to that track goes to 0 seconds, and it works normally then (0 only lasts 1
second)

-Mike with his new toy
522.5COVERT::COVERTJohn CovertFri Nov 07 1986 08:126
It is normal for tracks to be able to count down.  My player has a minus sign
to be able to indicate this; maybe the minus sign on your player is missing.
It looks like CDs must use one's complement arithmetic (or the equivalent),
providing, like Univac 1100 series machines, both a plus and minus zero.

/john
522.6Yeah, CDs seem to have +0 and -0.SKYLAB::FISHERBurns Fisher 381-1466, ZKO1-1/D42Fri Nov 07 1986 15:3917
    re .4 and .5:  I agree:  Many CD tracks start before 0.  My D-5
    counts them down with a -.  It does have a -0 and a +0, however.
    I don't know how much of this is the individual player's interpretation
    and how much is actually on the disk.
    
    Re the timer update:  Nope, it is an audio problem, not video. 
    I really do miss the first fraction of a beat on some CDs.  It is
    consistent on particular CDs.  If I go into search mode (where I
    can control the seconds rather than the track) and start playing
    at -1 or -0, then all is well.  However, if I start playing at exactly
    0, then I miss the first few milliseconds.
    
    One example is L'oiseau-Lyre 400059-2, Handel's Water Music and
    Fireworks Music by Hogwood.  It also happens on not-the-first cut
    if I skip to it rather than letting it play the negative numbers.
    
    Burns
522.7LDP::WEAVERLaboratory Data ProductsFri Nov 07 1986 19:425
    Re: .6
    
    I believe that some CD players do better in this regard than others.
    
    							-Dave
522.8Ones complement = Index register off by one bugsYOUNG::YOUNGMon Nov 10 1986 15:389
    Use of ones complement arithmetic is no excuse for showing a minus
    zero and plus zero on the same track.  That's probably caused by
    the seconds being incorrect on the disk; it should go -2, -1, either
    + or - 0, +1...  But what some do is go -2, -1, -0, +1...  It's
    this sort of indexing problem that caused the computer industry
    to go for twos compliment!
    
    				Paul