T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
416.1 | a few to start | WMOIS::REINKE_B | big problems = big opportunities | Fri Feb 28 1992 17:02 | 25 |
| Well there are a lot of pagan symbols that have reflections in
Christianity.
Simplest would be a lot of the customs around Christmas time
including the time of the Christmas celebration.
The birth of Christ was set in the winter to provide an alternate
holiday to a traditional mid winter pagan holiday (saturnalia I
think).
Much of the traditional decorations - ever greens, holly, mistle toe,
the yule log, etc are taken from German pagan customs.
Other practices/symbols/themes found both in Christianity and
earlier pagan beliefs are the dying god who is resurected, the
blood sacrifice, baptism, confession of sins and personal intervention
by the god/goddess into human lives including a human woman bearing
the child of the god.
Perhaps the similarities are because the indwelling of Christ is
something that happened out side of time, so that even before
his incarnation there were echos of the miracle that could be
sensed by those who were spiritually atuned.
Bonnie
|
416.2 | | SA1794::SEABURYM | Zen: It's Not What You Think | Fri Feb 28 1992 17:12 | 7 |
|
Doesn't Easter come form Ishtar, a pagan fertility goddess ?
The traditional Easter symbols are eggs and rabbits which
are fertility symbols.
Mike
|
416.3 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Fri Feb 28 1992 17:20 | 12 |
|
Easter, for Christians represent the resurrection of Jesus, but prior
to this it a Pagan ritual celebrating the vernal equinox, or beginning
of Spring, the resurrection of life.
I begin to wonder about the term "Pagan" however. In a sense, the
Pagan celebrated very real events, but Christians do not. Jesus wasn't
born on Dec 25th, and why does the Resurrection date change as it does?
gotta go...
Playtoe
|
416.4 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Peace: the Final Frontier | Fri Feb 28 1992 20:39 | 12 |
| St. Valentine, a Roman priest, together with St. Marius and his family,
assisted the martyrs who suffered during the reign of Emperor Claudius II
in the 3rd century. Being apprehended, he was sent to the Prefect of
Rome, who commanded that he be beaten with clubs and afterward beheaded.
He suffered martyrdom about the year 270.
The custom of sending valentines on this day is the revival of an
ancient pagan practice, which consisted in boys drawing the names of
girls in honor of their goddess, Februata Juno, on February 15. To
abolish this practice names of saints were substituted on billets drawn
upon this day.
|
416.5 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Peace: the Final Frontier | Fri Feb 28 1992 21:03 | 7 |
| Interesting to note that the term "pagan" originally meant "someone
from the country." It was typically used by ancient urban dwellers who
maintained something of a snobbish attitude toward their country cousins.
Pagan was roughly comparable to such modern terms as "bumpkin" or "hick."
Peace,
Richard
|
416.6 | | CVG::THOMPSON | DCU Board of Directors Candidate | Sun Mar 01 1992 19:40 | 7 |
| > and why does the Resurrection date change as it does?
Because it's based on the lunar calendar which is not quite in sync
with the one you and I are more used to. Plus there is a little playing
around so that Easter comes on a Sunday every year.
Alfred
|
416.7 | Surprised no one else has responded to this | COLLIS::JACKSON | The Word became flesh | Mon Mar 02 1992 11:40 | 10 |
| Re: .3
>Easter... [was] a Pagan ritual celebrating the vernal eqeuinox, or
>beiginning of Spring, the resurrection of life.
Easter came directly from the Jewish celebration of Passover (as the
Scriptures make abundantly clear) and Christ's death and resurrection
on the third day after the Last Supper.
Collis
|
416.9 | | DEMING::VALENZA | Sorry, Tennessee. | Mon Mar 02 1992 13:04 | 7 |
| I could be mistaken on this, but I *thought* I heard or read somewhere
that the etymology of the word "Easter" derives from the name of the
dawn goddess. It might be interesting to check on this; it also might
be interesting to know if it is related to the word "east" (since it is
the direction where the sun rises.)
-- Mike
|
416.8 | | WMOIS::REINKE_B | big problems = big opportunities | Mon Mar 02 1992 14:19 | 13 |
| Collis
It is quiet true, that Easter - as the celebration of the resurection
of Jesus, comes from the Passover, since Jesus and his disciples
celebrated the Passover just before He was crucified. However, it
is also undeniably true that elements of the vernal equinox
celebrations, of preChristian faiths, have been incorporated into
our Easter customs and celebrations... such as decorating the churches
with flowers and the symbolism of eggs and rabbits and their tie
to fertility. Further the image of the god that dies to be reborn
in the spring, is one far older than Christianity.
Bonnie
|
416.10 | lots of good comes from the east | CVG::THOMPSON | DCU Board of Directors Candidate | Mon Mar 02 1992 14:32 | 4 |
| East is also the direction those in the western hemisphire look
towards where Jesus died and was re-born.
Alfred
|
416.11 | and Lent means Spring, too | ESDNI6::ANDREWS | knit one, purl one | Mon Mar 02 1992 15:58 | 12 |
|
The origin of the English word "Easter" is uncertain. In the 8th
century the Venerable Bede proposed that it was derived from the
the name of the Anglo-Saxon goddess of spring, Eostre. This view
has long been popular, but another explanation has been offered.
In the early church, Easter week was called "hebdomada alba"
(white week) because of the white garments worn by those baptized
at Easter. The plural of white was later misunderstood as the plural
of dawn and so translated into Old High German as "eostarum" from
which the English word Easter was derived.
from the Encyclopedia Americana
|
416.12 | Always on Sunday | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Peace: the Final Frontier | Mon Mar 02 1992 17:09 | 9 |
| As I recall, Easter is calculated something like this:
The first Sunday after the first full moon after the Spring Equinox.
And this is why Easter might fall in March some years and in late April
other years.
Peace,
Richard
|
416.13 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Tue Mar 03 1992 17:04 | 7 |
| Re: 12
And how does that correspond with Jesus?
Is it not a Pagan ritual?
Playtoe
|
416.14 | | AKOCOA::FLANAGAN | waiting for the snow | Wed Mar 04 1992 12:37 | 5 |
| Christianity has assumed some wonderful traditions from Pagan rituals.
It is too bad that some Christians equate Pagan with evil.
Pat
|
416.15 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Wed Mar 04 1992 13:24 | 29 |
| Re: 14
Some equate "Communism" with evil too, but surely not by virtue of that
alone is an individual or nation to be considered evil.
But as innocently as you make it sound regarding Pagan rituals in
Christianity, many people have died, especially by the hands of
Christians in Europe, for being thought of as a Pagan, which my
dictionary says is synonymous as "heathen"....actually I resent the way
you've so nonchalantly overlooked it (don't take it personally),
because it was for the fact that Indians and Africans and various
underclasses of Europe observed such "pagan" rituals that the Roman
Catholic church authorized and condoned the subjugation, oppression,
and missionization of them...and now we come to find out that the "Pot
who called the kettle black" observes, beneath the cloak of terms and
pomp, many of those SAME Pagan rituals, and you say now it isn't evil?
Then if it's not the Roman Catholic church along with European
governments have greatly sinned in the past, "Thou shalt not bear false
witness against they neighbor"...and sorry, please forgive us, do you
honestly think God finds that enough to resolve these matters?
I'm a little upset, miffed, at how conveniently you've seen fit to
include Pagan rituals in Christianity. It's not that they are evil,
but the question is "Are they Christian?" If not, then they become an
evil within the domain of Christianity. Weeds aren't evil of
themselves, but they become evil in a wheat field when they begin to
choke out the wheat.
Playtoe
|
416.16 | | WMOIS::REINKE_B | big problems = big opportunities | Wed Mar 04 1992 13:28 | 18 |
| Playtoe,
I don't think that any of us have actively included 'pagan' rituals
with Christianity, but rather we have pointed out that many Christian
symbols and practices are similar or parallel symbols and practices
found in preChistian and nonChristian religions.
I proposed one reason why this might be so... that the incarnation of
Christ was an event so profound in human history that echos were
picked up by spiritually sensitive people both before the event in
time and in locations far from the physical place where the incarnation
occured.
I don't think that it is a coincidence that the image of resurection
of the god who sacrifices for the sins of the people is found in
so many faiths.
Bonnie
|
416.17 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Wed Mar 04 1992 13:35 | 15 |
| Re: 15
Let me add...You know what the two most crowded church days of the year
are? Right, Christmas and Easter, two christianized pagan
celebrations. It's more upsetting when you also realize how the
majority of people only do "things Christian" at these times of the
year.
"They have eyes but cannot see, they have ears but cannot hear, they
have noses but cannot smell, they have feet but cannot walk, they have
hands but do not handle the things of God." (somewhere in the OT)
What should be done about Pagan rituals in Christianity?
Playtoe
|
416.19 | | WMOIS::REINKE_B | big problems = big opportunities | Wed Mar 04 1992 14:28 | 15 |
| Pagan symbols and practices are in Christianity because they
are part of a spiritual reality that transcends time and space.
The indwelling of God in human flesh in the incarnation of Christ
was a transcendant event that stands outside of time and space.
It is nothing to be surprised at that other spiritual beings
encountered this reality and expressed it in their own terms
with images such as the resurected child of god that was sacrificed
for others.
This is not a fairy tale, but an expression of transcendant spiritual
reality.
and Playtoe, there is no need, as I have said to you before, to
be personally insulting to me when you disagree with me. Further
if you comment on my notes then I will reply to your comments.
|
416.20 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Wed Mar 04 1992 15:51 | 46 |
|
The matter of Pagan symbols in European Christianity is primarily due
to the fact that prior to the advent of Christianity in Europe the
people had long been involved in other forms of religious activities,
and some were harder to rid the people of than others. Especially, in
the cases of the "seasonal change" celebrations, where the people had
real events to base them upon.
It dawned upon me only recently, that the "Dark Ages" of Europe,
happened in part due to the effort of European ruling powers attempting
to suppress the long held beliefs and rituals the people held,
endeavoring to bring some sense of unity and order to European people
under the authority of European images and conceptions of life...the
first attempts at gaining the "power to define", which had for ages
been done by Egyptians.
Specifically, the December 25th and Spring Equinox rituals were part of
the Osirian belief system. Europeans could accept the celebrations of
Egypt but not the cerebrations, as they rejected the early (Egyptian
educated) Greek philosophers as "introducing STRANGE GODS"...not
"strange" in the sense that "we never knew them", but "strange" as
coming from a "foreign" land, namely Egypt...and not "introducing" as
if for the first time, but in the sense that these gods were offensive
to the European ruling powers and they didn't want the masses to learn
the knowledge of these gods they celebrated for so long.
It's difficult to analyse European beginnings of "nationhood", as a
great deal of confusion and war, as well as widespread secularism,
existed in the common classes...in order to put an end to it, and
instead of "Noah's Flood", books were burned the people suppressed, the
"Dark Ages" ensued and the lights went out and the curtain was drawn on
the European theater of social (dis)order.
However, Roman Catholicism served a good purpose for the bringing of
Christianity to the "Gentiles", even as Jews served a vital purpose to
that same end...but those were stages or phases the people had to go
through to get to the "other side"....let us not get "hung up in a
tree" as they say, by refusing to outgrow that which was meant only for
time, whose time has ended.
Of course, this perception is somewhat radical, but it is viable and
quite credible as a way of looking at the situation of early European
development from a religious historical perspective.
Playtoe
Playtoe
|
416.21 | To help meditate | CHGV04::ORZECH | Alvin Orzechowski @ACI | Thu Mar 05 1992 14:15 | 18 |
| I was talking with some people the other day and the subject of
religious practices regarding food (what to eat, what not to eat) came
up. It was pointed out that many of these traditions were started for
rather non-religious purposes which have since become obsolete because
of new insights or modern circumstances. Someone then questioned the
value of continuing a practice when the non-religious import had
become extinct, and the thought occurred to me that any practice done
for the sake of a higher purpose (religious if you will) is just an
expression of self-discipline that helps the practitioner focus on the
higher vision. It seems to me that this would hold true for any
practice/activity, even if it started out as an adaptation of a pagan
one. If believers use them to bring their beliefs to mind, then who
cares, except for academic reasons, why/how any such traditions got
started?
Think "Peace",
Alvin
|
416.22 | y | TFH::KIRK | a simple song | Thu Mar 05 1992 14:54 | 38 |
| Hi Playtoe,
You ask if Pagan rituals that have been adopted by Christianity "are
Christian", and what should be done about Pagan rituals in Christianity.
My perspective is that the rituals in and of themselves are nothing. What
they invoke in the person practicing them is what I find important.
What should be done about Pagan rituals in Christianity? I'd say, celebrate
them as Christians!
Note that this does not open up a free-for-all. I think there *are* some
practices which are not compatable with Christianity (child sacrifice comes to
mind...) This also means that there may be some practices that some people, in
their personal Christian relationship could not--in true faith--practice,
while for others they pose no problem.
I've seen quite a range of attitude to the use of ritual and symbology.
I've been to simple, unadorned churches with white walls and not much else, as
well as churches with stained glass representations of Jesus, Mary, and
assorted Saints and Martyrs, where the smell of incense hung heavy in the air
(very practical, that, too, back when disease was often spread by the local
water source and common people couldn't take baths... .-) For some, "'tis a
gift to be simple", while for others, the rich tapestry of tradition and
ritual helps anchor them in their faith.
In my church there are some etched glass panels of several stylized symbols,
one of which is a Phoenix, a bird that is consumed by fire and risen again
from its ashes; a symbol of Resurrection. No, it is not a Christian symbol
for everyone, not everyone needs accept it as such, but for those who do, it
is a an excellent pointer to the gift Jesus offered us all.
We bring what we have to God, offer it freely, and receive it back
transformed.
Peace,
Jim
|
416.23 | The mystery of transitions.... | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Thu Mar 05 1992 16:04 | 12 |
| re 21
That sounds nice and all, but what does God think about such things
entering into the Christian faith, Jeremiah, Chapter 10 (?) has
something to say about the "christmas tree", God says it is a form of
idolatry.
If there is no religious impart why isn't it ok to leave it out and
still perform the ritual...why must it be made a part of the Christian
practice? Or, why was it made so? I know why!
Playtoe
|
416.24 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Thu Mar 05 1992 16:13 | 15 |
| Hi Jim:
Is it up to us to decide what is Christian practice and what is not? I
say it is not up to us. The only two rituals that I can clearly say
are Christian rituals CHRISTIANS DON'T EVEN PERFORM :-), namely
"Keeping the Sabbath", and "Passover", Jesus instructed us to observe
them...he never said celebrate my birth and ressurrection, he said
believe in it. It wouldn't be so bad if we were doing everything Jesus
had asked us to do and then on top of that went further to celebrate
the beginning of Spring/Easter and the Winter Solstice/Christmas, but
when we perform the Pagan celebration, and neglect to perform those
things asked of us it is a problem...don't you think so? Put yourself
in God's shoes for minute, OK so there EXTREMELY LARGE, but...
Playtoe
|
416.25 | Remember the ... | USCTR1::RTRUEBLOOD | Rollyn Trueblood DTN 297-6553 | Thu Mar 05 1992 18:46 | 13 |
| Hi Playtoe,
Without tossing a `gotcha', some who try to follow the teachings
of Christ do take His admonishments seriously and also support the
Traditions of Abraham and Isaac.
But then again, one might be labeled a fundamentalist for so observing
or observing worshipping on a different day than Christ's Sabbath
might have more to do with Constantine's preferences than Christ's.
New subject- where did the halo come from, it seems to me this was
something left over from Constantine's sun-worshipping days?
Best wishes,
Rollyn
|
416.26 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Thu Mar 05 1992 20:00 | 44 |
| RE: 25
>Without tossing a `gotcha', some who try to follow the teachings
>of Christ do take His admonishments seriously and also support the
>Traditions of Abraham and Isaac.
I can relate to this...in my heart of hearts I'd like to do more in
terms of a performance of God's Word, but sometimes you're scheduled to
work on Saturday's, sometimes Saturday is only day you can get certain
things done...on the other hand we/I don't have a lot of encouragements
to do many of the things I have in my heart to do...but Easter's always
on a Sunday, and we get Christmas off, great encouragements for all to
participate...and I do myself, right!
But I look at it like this, if Lot could do it I guess I better
try...Lot was the man at the gate entering Sodom, probably knew every
dirty joke, all the prostitutes (male especially), he knew who's-who in
Sodom no doubt, and hold a conversation with the best of them, I mean
he HAD to be good at it, the GATE KEEPER to SODOM! But God, through it
all found him righteous AT/IN his HEART, as he vexed his own soul each
night about his "filthy conversation".
It's saying to me that although life may force or influence us to do
certain things, and even after we know better we still sometimes
continue to do them...but that is NO REASON to begin to JUSTIFY them or
forego prayers of forgiveness.
It's also affirming for me the separation of Body and Mind, of the
Inner Man and the Outer Man. That's what Paul is speaking of when he
says, "In the world but not of the world," and again, "We realize that
we are like foreigners in the world." That we come from some other
reality...if this was our primary reality, we'd probably be like the
animals, who never become discontent with being just what the are,
having no aspirations for other realities...we have that unction
because it IS a truth for us, that we have another place, another land
from which we come...
Sorry to get off the subject there!
I don't know the story on the origin of the halo, I think it's older
than Catholicism though, I think halos in the Rig Veda, or Hare Krishna
faith.
Playtoe
|
416.27 | halo tangent | ATSE::FLAHERTY | That's enough for me... | Thu Mar 05 1992 20:33 | 10 |
| Hi Rollyn .25,
I would suspect the halo seen around Christ as well as Mary and many of
the Saints was actually their electromagnetic energy field (called aura
in some circles). Scientists are now working on devices that can
actually measure this field. It seems plausible to me that their auras
would be more radiant than the average person's. FWIW.
Ro
|
416.28 | Tangents & Original Thought | USCTR1::RTRUEBLOOD | Rollyn Trueblood DTN 297-6553 | Fri Mar 06 1992 10:20 | 41 |
| Hi Playtoe,
Perhaps the most difficult thing about contrasting theology
from religion is in comparison of theory to action. The theory
says `Remember the Sabbath and keep it Holy'. The action is
up to us; within the `valuing-differences' vocalization currently
in vogue surely one's employer would not be upset to hear an
employee say s/he has religous conflicts working on one day or
the next, `so long as the employee does not try to take advantage
of the situation'. In my own stead I have made it quite clear
I will not work on Saturday - sundown to sundown but that any other
time is open, including Saturday evening and all day Sunday, without
thought of special consideration/compensation.
However, without wasting too much time, when I was in a position
of authority and someone claimed personal religous exemption, I
watched them. If their standards of practice did not match up to
their religous convictions, Heaven help them! God could have their
souls, but their ... belonged to me!!!
Back to tangents -
When I started this note, I asked about customs and traditions from
Pegan or competing religions, what were they, their origins, and
in effect how have they blended in to religous practice within
Christianity as you have define it today.
For example the halos, we understand the veneration of saints via
halos. But where did the symbol come from, what was its previous
use, when did it start becoming a Christian tradition and has its
transfer been consistant?
Holly at Christmas, what is its orign Duridic, Celtic, Norse? What
was its previous use or reason for being a symbol & what has it
come to mean today within your observation.
Perhaps your form of Christianity has absorbed traditions or practices
from competing religions too e.g. Moslem, Tsao, Hindu, & etc. These
would be interesting to be discussed a little too.
Best wishes,
Rollyn
|
416.29 | | SWAM1::DOTHARD_ST | PLAYTOE | Fri Mar 06 1992 12:45 | 45 |
| Re: 28
Hi Rollyn:
Yes, "theory and action", "principle and practice" pose issues which
are of vital concern to all of our lives.
I think the "theory/principle" aspect has been given greater validity
since Jesus...well it started with Abraham, "he BELIEVED God, and it
was counted for righteousness."
> Perhaps your form of Christianity has absorbed traditions or practices
> from competing religions too e.g. Moslem, Tsao, Hindu, & etc. These
> would be interesting to be discussed a little too.
I don't believe in "competing" religions, because there's only ONE
God. I don't view the variety of religions as unique systems, but as
components of a grand system...and in that light, I'd agree with you
that I have absorbed principles and practices from other
religions...for instance, after I say my prayer each night, I also
chant "Words-Sounds of Power" according to Egyptian spiritual
cultivation teachings (ie AUNG-HUNG-KRING, AUNG-AUSAR-HUNG,
SHRING-KRING-VANG, and so forth, each word has a specific "POWER" of
manifestation of life, each represents a certain stage in the process
of any thing that is manifested, or will ever be manifested.)
I seek the "common threads" in "comparitive religious studies", I don't
compare to assess the "better or worse" of the two or many, I seek to
know, through comparison, how they are/can be united or in common with
one another, under ONE God.
However, the matter of "PAGAN" is itself controversial, my dictionary
says, "Any one not Jewish, Christian or Islamic; a heathen". And
although I don't view PAGAN as an inherently evil description of a
person or practice, I think calling the PAGAN a "heathen" implies it!
Which I feel betrays the self-centered attitude of the national leaders
and "protectors of the realm" (if you will).
Anyway, the labels "Pagan", "Gnostic", etc, doesn't carry a lot of
weight with me, in and of themeselves. I need to know something of
one's underlying principles and beliefs in order to make an assessment
of one's character or justifications.
Playtoe
of
|
416.30 | now back to the regularly scheduled topic... | TFH::KIRK | a simple song | Fri Mar 06 1992 14:59 | 36 |
| re: Note 416.24
Hi Playtoe,
Is it up to us to decide what is Christian practice and what is not?
I'll skirt your question slightly and say I believe God gave us free will
with which we are able to prayfully discern what our own personal faith
response practices will be...
Many Christians I know actually do perform the two things Jesus told us to,
keeping the Sabbath and Passover, but what does that mean?
I know some who keep the Sabbath on Saturday, for some of these people that
particular day is a focal point of their theology. For others, the exact day
is less important than the action of setting aside a time to be wholy devoted
to the Lord. Others still seek to have their whole lives devoted to the Lord
at all times and in all places.
Likewise, I know some who worship in a eucharistically centered church,
celebrating Jesus' last Passover feast. Others remember Jesus *wherever* they
eat or drink, be it kneeling at an altar rail, at a dinner table with family,
or in front of a vending machine at work or hanging out at a fast food joint.
An interesting thing about all this is that no one can be sure about any other
person's faith response, it is between that person and God. Yes, one might
know who is practicing the *letter* of the Law, but the Spirit of the Law is
far more subtle.
As far as wearing God's shoes, yes, I think they're a bit larger than the size
8� I wear (.-), but my personal view is that I think God would rather us be
sincerely incorrect rather than insincerely correct.
Peace,
Jim
|
416.31 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Only Nixon can go to China | Tue Jul 28 1992 17:51 | 5 |
| The Olympics are rooted in pagan tradition.
Peace,
Richard
|
416.32 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | the lower I go, the higher I become | Wed Jul 29 1992 11:14 | 8 |
| RE: .31 Richard,
I would agree that they were originally but are now
political in nature.......on second thought maybe those two words mean
the same thing! ;-) Yeah....yer right Richard!
Dave
|
416.33 | | MIMS::ARNETT_G | Creation<>Science:Creation=Hokum | Wed Sep 23 1992 09:43 | 10 |
| re: .31
Richard,
Most things today (whether they be political, athletic, religious)
have some basis or parallels in "pagan" traditions. While the Olympics
may, by some stretch of the imagination, be based on pagan traditions,
I do not think you could condemn them as such.
George
|
416.34 | | SOLVIT::MSMITH | So, what does it all mean? | Wed Sep 23 1992 11:10 | 8 |
| Indeed. Much of the liturgy of the Catholic Church, at least, and many
of our traditional religious holidays are rooted in paganism, or were
set up to be in competition to pagansim. The idea, I suppose, was to
make the forms of practice of the new religion be as familiar as
possible to people who were used to the pagan forms, and thereby
attract them to Christianity.
Mike
|
416.35 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Keep on loving boldly! | Wed Sep 23 1992 16:10 | 7 |
| .33 George
I'm not particularly in favor of condemning traditions rooted in
paganism. Sorry to have led you to such a conclusion if I did.
Richard
|
416.36 | I don't intend to remove mine because of it | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Rise Again! | Mon Mar 01 1993 19:11 | 4 |
| I heard recently that wedding rings were symbols rooted in pagan tradition.
Richard
|
416.37 | Fine Line to Travel | JUPITR::HILDEBRANT | I'm the NRA | Tue Mar 02 1993 08:05 | 16 |
| The pagan traditions seem to walk a fine line for me. The commandment
that "thou shall not have false gods before me" is real for me.
I have a problem when people start praying to crystals or other
false images (like the TV!). On the other hand, there are basic,
human/nature aspects to life that need a celebration. Spring time
with the re-establishment of life is a natural. Also, during the middle
of winter the human body needs to party!
Its a fine line.....I quess that the real difference is when the
worship is directed at a being *other than* God....i.e. mother nature
then the line has been crossed into false worship.
Wedding rings....nothing wrong with a pagan symbol used to amplify a
Christian meaning.
Marc H.
|
416.38 | | CSC32::KINSELLA | it's just a wheen o' blethers | Tue Mar 02 1993 12:56 | 19 |
| I mentioned in 608.11 that many pagan traditions were in fact mimicking
Christian traditions for mocking purposes. For example the occult took
on the symbol of the Star of David. Halloween actually has it's
foundation in Christianity right down to the ghoulish costumes. They
were representative of the early Christian martyrs who were tortured
with spears and other weapons and tools of torture for days before
dying. All over the world it's celebrated as a Christian holiday
except for America whos celebration just started taking on Satanic
undertone in the last 100 years or so. I've got an excellent book on
this and will try to bring it in to share more.
As for the church moving Christian holidays to give people another
alternative to pagan celebrations, could it be that the church was
trying to meet the needs of people who might otherwise be lured in by
the festivities of pagan celebrations. Sounds like the church was
meeting people where they were at. Something that seems to be highly
valued in this conference.
Jill
|
416.39 | | BUSY::DKATZ | March of the Falsettos | Tue Mar 02 1993 13:01 | 23 |
| >Note 416.38 Pagan Traditions 38 of 38
>CSC32::KINSELLA "it's just a wheen o' blethers" 19 lines 2-MAR-1993 12:56
>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> I mentioned in 608.11 that many pagan traditions were in fact mimicking
> Christian traditions for mocking purposes. For example the occult took
> on the symbol of the Star of David.
Jill, do you mean the Pentagram? If so, the five-pointed star is leap
in design from the Magen David...do you mean it was adapted from the
Shield of David?
> Halloween actually has it's
> foundation in Christianity right down to the ghoulish costumes. They
> were representative of the early Christian martyrs who were tortured
> with spears and other weapons and tools of torture for days before
> dying.
That's interesting -- I had been under the impression that the
celebration of Samhain pre-dates Christianity by quite some time...does
anyone have any documentation on this?
Daniel
|
416.40 | | CVG::THOMPSON | Radical Centralist | Tue Mar 02 1993 13:08 | 7 |
| > Jill, do you mean the Pentagram? If so, the five-pointed star is leap
> in design from the Magen David...do you mean it was adapted from the
> Shield of David?
FWIW, I've heard the 5 pointed star called the Star Of Solomon.
Alfred
|
416.41 | ;-) | GLITTR::BROOKS | | Tue Mar 02 1993 13:19 | 3 |
|
Next we'll hear that Brigit, Great Goddess of Ireland, derives from the
Christian saint...
|
416.42 | | BUSY::DKATZ | March of the Falsettos | Tue Mar 02 1993 13:22 | 15 |
| Alfred,
Interesting...I've never heard that before. Do you remember from where
you heard that?
Just as another clarifier: I think it is a mistake to confuse Satanism
with the celebration of Samhain (AKA Halloween). I have several
friends who are witches and they are very clear that Satanism and
witchcraft are not the same thing. In order to worship Satan, you need
to believe in Satan -- the majority of witches do not include Satan in
their Cosmology. Satanism would be more accurately described as
"Anti-Christian" because Satan is opposed to God in Christian
Cosmology.
Daniel
|
416.43 | | CVG::THOMPSON | Radical Centralist | Tue Mar 02 1993 13:34 | 10 |
| > Interesting...I've never heard that before. Do you remember from where
> you heard that?
Israel. Touring the ruin of a synagogue in Capernium on the northern
shore of Kennerit. A guide was explaining the 5 pointed star carved
in relief in a wall. He could have been wrong. Tour guides stand down
there with Democrats and reporters in my list of not always credible
sources. :-)
Alfred
|
416.44 | Reference material at home. | CSC32::KINSELLA | it's just a wheen o' blethers | Tue Mar 02 1993 14:03 | 8 |
|
Oops...sorry Alfred my mistake on the star.
As I said in my note I do have a book giving lots of details and
references on Halloween included time references. It's a very
interesting book. I'll try to bring it tomorrow.
Jill
|
416.45 | Tangental Stream of Consciousness (new term for rathole!) | LEDS::LOPEZ | A River.. proceeding! | Tue Mar 02 1993 15:50 | 13 |
|
re.43
Alfred,
My wife and I have been considering going to Israel for vacation.
Any recommendations on how to get about, where to stay, etc. Would
you recommend it? What time of year is best, etc.?
thanks,
ace
|
416.46 | see topic 562 for more information | CVG::THOMPSON | Radical Centralist | Tue Mar 02 1993 15:57 | 8 |
| > Any recommendations on how to get about, where to stay, etc. Would
>you recommend it? What time of year is best, etc.?
It's been awhile. Last time I got about by bicycle and stayed at youth
hostels. You may want to try something else. :-) I would recommend the
trip though.
Alfred
|
416.47 | The Games or the Ceremonies? | MIMS::ARNETT_G | Creation<>Science:Creation=Hokum | Thu Mar 18 1993 13:59 | 12 |
| re: .4
Richard,
When you state that the "last summer Olympics (an event rooted in
pagan tradition...", do you mean to say that the games themselves are
rooted in pagan tradition or that the rather beautiful opening
ceremonies had elements of non-Christian mythology?
Yeah, I know, way off topic, but if you can move this to a more
appropriate venue, I'd appreciate it.
George
|
416.48 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Rise Again! | Thu Mar 18 1993 14:20 | 6 |
| .47 I'm referring to the games themselves.
Richard
PS Hope you don't mind me moving your note to this string.
|
416.49 | Thanks | MIMS::ARNETT_G | Creation<>Science:Creation=Hokum | Thu Mar 18 1993 15:12 | 6 |
| re: .48
Nope, no problems with it being in this string at all.
George
|