T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
202.1 | Response to 190.7 | LJOHUB::NSMITH | rises up with eagle wings | Wed Apr 03 1991 14:54 | 44 |
|
RE: 190.7, Mike,
I really enjoyed your note! It's helpful to me to try to "translate" the
"faith-language" of others into my own. Perhaps it's the inability to do
this that sometimes gets us into trouble.
> Perhaps what Christians perceive as promptings of the Holy Sprit and
> what Buddhists call thinking with the big mind are merely different
> perceptions of the same thing.
And here, you're doing it, too! :)
Incidentally, it's also helpful to find out what non-Christians don't believe
that Christians supposedly do believe. I can often agree with their
non-belief! There is a story about a conversation with an atheist. When
the atheist explained why he didn't believe in God, the Christian said that
*he* didn't believe in *that* God, either!
> We all get caught up in words and abstract concepts and miss what is
> important which is putting what we believe into practice. There are times
> when I feel that I do not understand much about Christianity when I read
> about it in books are read arguments in notes conferences.
I know what you mean. Yet those studies and discussions help many of us
who are Christians to understand and refine the meaning of our
faith-experiences better. I, for one, need language and a systematic
organization of that language to help me understand what I believe. (Well, I
*am* in technical writing! :-) ) It's unfortunate -- tragic, in fact --
when the *_efforts_to_formulate_meaning_* result in stumbling blocks either to
others' faith or to communication with others *about* their faith.
And it's also tragic when I become so satisfied with a meaning that I
codify it and close down my mind and heart to new understandings.
> Then on the
> way home from work I'll see someone coming out of The Open Pantry with
> bags of groceries and their children in tow and think that I understand
> all that I'll ever need to know about it.
Amen!
Toward sharing the understandings we have in common,
Nancy
|
202.2 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Sun Apr 07 1991 01:51 | 14 |
|
After reading 190 I felt that many nonchristians are not
seeing christians as they really are. I'm Southern Baptist, ok ok
I hear the groans :^), and a pastor friend of mine once told me that
churches were "for sinners only" and that perfect people need not
apply. Its kind of a flippent statement and yet there is a *LOT* of
truth in it. Too many times I hear people put Christians down for
being too "holy" and thinking that they are better than anyone else.
Nothing is further from the truth....in most cases....the *ONLY*
difference between a non-christian and a "born again" Christian is the
word "grace".
Dave
|
202.3 | | WILLEE::FRETTS | To the bright side of the road... | Mon Apr 08 1991 10:34 | 14 |
| RE: .2 Dave
>Too many times I hear people put Christians down for
>being too "holy" and thinking that they are better than anyone else.
>Nothing is further from the truth....in most cases....the *ONLY*
>difference between a non-christian and a "born again" Christian is the
>word "grace".
Hmmm....personally Dave I can't agree with this. I do not call myself
a Christian, but I do have a personal relationship with Christ. From
my perspective and experience, God's grace is given freely to all life,
all the time. What do you base your above statement about 'grace' on?
Carole
|
202.4 | | SA1794::SEABURYM | Zen: It's Not What You Think | Mon Apr 08 1991 13:39 | 11 |
| Re.2
Dave:
I'll be the first to admit that I may not see Christians
"as they really are", but I would like to think that I am managing
to avoid putting Christians and Christianity down.
Perhaps you could get in on the discussion and help a non-
Christian like myself gain a better understanding of what Christians
are really like from your perspective.
Mike
|
202.5 | Both sides of the coin are there | ISVBOO::JACKSON | Collis Jackson | Mon Apr 08 1991 15:02 | 16 |
| Mike,
I think a religion can be both very emotional and very logical at the
same time. It is quite true that there is much emotion in Christians,
particularly in some branches of Christian worship. But I think that
this in no way negates the tremendous amount (and I mean tremendous
amount) of logically study that goes on in the lives of many Christians
including those who attend formal theological training.
In fact, it is not the emotionalism that draws me to Jesus (which is
there, by the way), but rather it is the logic and truthfulness of
what the Scriptures teach. I know I am not alone in this. The proof
is there. The body of Jesus is gone. He is risen! (Speaking a logical
fact with emotional emphasis. :-) )
Collis
|
202.6 | the "one-liner" version... | TFH::KIRK | a simple song | Mon Apr 08 1991 15:21 | 9 |
| or, as Nancy's wonderful personal name stated,
Passionate Commitment to Reasoned Faith.
(I always liked that line, Nancy!)
Peace,
Jim (hey Collis, we agree! .-)
|
202.7 | | JURAN::SILVA | A word to ya MUTHA! | Mon Apr 08 1991 15:22 | 14 |
|
Dave, I find a lot of truth in what you wrote. I also don't see it as
any sort of put down. All you said was the only difference between a
non-christian and a born again christian is the word grace. How could anyone
conceive this to be a put down? It's true that some people will always feel as
though they are better than anyone else, it just doesn't pertain to Born again
christians. I think every denomination is capable of doing this as we are all
human. It is strange though that you hear about this happening more with the
born again christian than any other denomination though. What humans can do to
a group is amazing, huh?
Glen
|
202.8 | | SA1794::SEABURYM | Zen: It's Not What You Think | Mon Apr 08 1991 16:01 | 24 |
|
Collis:
Yup, no doubt about you can't have a one sided coin.
And I'll agree with you that much serious, logical and very
scholarly thought and research takes place within the Christian
religion and in the lives of individual Christians.
However, I still think that faith and the emotion attendant
with it are very much at the core of Christian belief. You may
disagree with this, but I don't think there is any amount of
study, research or scholarship that will prove the existence
of God or that Christ is indeed risen. Religion need not be and
seldom is an affair of logic and reason. It is not mathematics
or programming. Zen is certainly not logical as the term is
generally understood.
Collis, never has a person told me I could be saved
by reason and logic, nor have I been told to seek God with all
my scholarship and I'd be mighty surprised if they did.
Yes, there is and probably be a balance between the
two. No negation was intended, simply my view of a single
aspect of many that comprise Christianity.
Mike
|
202.9 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Mon Apr 08 1991 21:27 | 30 |
| RE: .3 Carole,
Your statement about having a relationship with
Christ and not calling yourself a Christian puzzles me. But since I am
not you, I have to take that statement at face value. I based my
statement on the passage in Ephesians Ch. 2 vs 8 & 9:
" 8. For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of
yourselves: it is a gift of God: 9. Not of works, lest any man should
boast. "
The above passage say's a lot to me. It tells me that God
has a plan for me but it is for God to save by his grace, I can't
"earn" it....I must only accept it. I don't deserve it but it is given
freely.
RE: .4 Mike,
I'm not sure how to answer you Mike, except to say that we
are all human and being thus, we are subject to the same anger's,
love's, hatred's, ect,ect. Christians are not perfect, only that that
lives within is. Some Christians will tell you that they are "made
perfect" thru Christ and they are right, the problem enter's into the
picture when they believe that they are "living" perfect. They never
can....thus the reason God sent his Son. When we condem others, we
come under condemnation ourselves.
Dave
|
202.10 | | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Uncomplacent Peace | Mon Apr 08 1991 21:54 | 22 |
| I'm feeling a little uneasy about this string.
190.0 is marked SRO (Supportive Responses Only). This was done
deliberately to impede the impulse to defend one's own Christian faith
and doctrine, and also, to prevent disparaging remarks about non-Christian
religions. Listening (active listening) occurs, I believe, only when one is
not busy erecting barricades.
SO FAR in this string, I judge there has been a healthy and
worthwhile exchange. Good.
Having said that, I would like to interject that, personally, I
perceive Christianity to be a religion primarily, but far from exclusively,
of the heart. It is filled with sentimentality and feeling. There is nothing
wrong with that. Really!
At the same time, I don't believe followers of Christ are required
at any time to disengage their brains for any reason. Christianity is certainly
not without its great analytical thinkers.
Peace,
Richard
|
202.11 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Mon Apr 08 1991 22:00 | 8 |
| RE: .10 Richard
I will say to you, and thru you to *ALL* in this
file that *NONE* of my statements were meant to hurt or anger. If that
has been the result, then I say, sincerely, I am sorry.
Dave
|
202.12 | Double good | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Uncomplacent Peace | Mon Apr 08 1991 22:19 | 13 |
| Re: .11
Dave,
Permit me to reiterate....
> SO FAR in this string, I perceive there has been a healthy and
>worthwhile exchange. Good.
8-}
Peace,
Richard
|
202.13 | | WILLEE::FRETTS | when love comes to town... | Tue Apr 09 1991 14:45 | 19 |
| RE: .9 Dave
Thanks for your reply Dave.
Your quote from Ephesians and your further explanation of your
experience haven't really helped to answer my question from .3.
I was curious about your stating that, basically, non-Christians
do not receive God's grace. Ephesian's does not say this.
Regarding my relationship with Christ, I have a very different view
of this relationship than Christians do. I feel that the Christ
Consciousness dwells within all of us, but in many of us is still
'asleep'. It doesn't matter whether one is a Christian or not.
Purely MHO!
Carole
|
202.14 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Tue Apr 09 1991 17:33 | 20 |
| RE: .13 Carole,
Let me preface this with these are *MY* beliefs. I
am only trying to explain to you what they are. :) ok?
In Romans 10:9 I read the following: "That if thou
shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine
heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved".
* This passage coupled with the Ephesians passage tells me
that, indeed, it is a gift but it must be accepted. Now, thru these
conditions and having met each requirement, I feel that I am saved.
Your question seems to be asking me if I think you are. I do not know!
Your salvation is between you and God and I'll not set myself up as a
judge. You, between these two passages, have heard what I believe you
have to do in order to be saved. Thats NOT a judgement, only what *I*
believe.
Dave
|
202.15 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Tue Apr 09 1991 18:27 | 17 |
| RE.13 Carole,
In my .14 I don't think I "fully" answered you
questions.
>Regarding my relationship with Christ, I have a very different view
>of this relationship than Christians do. I feel that the Christ
>consciousness dwells within all of us, but in many of us is still
>'alseep'. It doesn't matter whether one is Christian or not.
Very interesting thought, Carole, and there are *MANY* who
agree with you. There is even some evidence to support it. To tell
you the truth...I am not sure of it. I do know that when I saw God in my
acceptence of him, that I did recognize that he was God.
Dave
|
202.16 | | JURAN::VALENZA | Voulez-vous noter avec moi? | Wed Apr 10 1991 11:01 | 8 |
| Carole,
Your comment about the Christ consciousness residing in everyone is
very similar to the Quaker belief in the Inner Light residing in
everyone. Although I am not a Christian, most Quakers are--so I don't
think that your views are inconsistent with Christianity.
-- Mike
|
202.17 | | SA1794::SEABURYM | Zen: It's Not What You Think | Wed Apr 10 1991 11:27 | 11 |
|
Carole and Mike:
The belief of Christ Consciousness and the Inner Light are
also very much the same as the Buddhist teaching that all
beings possess the Buddha nature.
Mike
|
202.18 | Into the mystic | CSC32::J_CHRISTIE | Uncomplacent Peace | Wed Apr 10 1991 19:07 | 7 |
| Re: .17
The last few are rapidly approaching the thread of mystical
experience which appears almost universally, though not in great measure,
among religious people, and occasionally even among unreligious people.
Richard
|
202.19 | | WILLEE::FRETTS | when love comes to town... | Thu Apr 11 1991 10:30 | 12 |
|
RE: .14 and .15
Dave, I appreciate your responses and accept your perspective on
this subject. What I get from your responses is that you connect
being saved and receiving grace. I don't embrace the concept of
'being saved', however I have received grace and feel that it is
available for everyone....we can open our hearts and consciously
receive it. Sometimes people receive grace and don't even know
that's what it was!
Carole
|
202.20 | | DPDMAI::DAWSON | Could be....But I doubt it! | Thu Apr 11 1991 18:26 | 11 |
| Carole,
Your .19 is very interesting....My wife went thru the
same thing. She *always* felt God working in her life and felt that
she was "saved". During a Church service, she felt this overwhelming
compulsion to "walk" the isle and confess her belief in front of
the whole service and after doing so, her mental anguish ended...it had
been bothering her for several months.
Dave
|