[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference lgp30::christian-perspective

Title:Discussions from a Christian Perspective
Notice:Prostitutes and tax collectors welcome!
Moderator:CSC32::J_CHRISTIE
Created:Mon Sep 17 1990
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1362
Total number of notes:61362

181.0. "Multi-Cultural versus Ethnic Churches" by NYTP07::LAM (Q ��Ktl��) Tue Mar 12 1991 12:22

Living in a metropolitan area like New York, you have a wide variety of ethnic
groups.  Many churches in New York find it a challenge to evangelize to such
a wide variety of people, others tend to focus only on particular ethnic groups.
For example, Chinese will tend only to witness to Chinese or Koreans will only
focus on Koreans.  When I visited Atlanta, I noticed that most African-Americans
will only go to black churches.
 
 	Personally though I feel it really shouldn't matter since the
Gospel is for all people regardless of their ethnic makeup.  Considering once
a person becomes a Christian he/she is a fellow brother/sister in Christ. 
I would prefer to see all people worship together.  I notice that Roman Catholic
churches, at least here in New York, are one up on Protestant churches in this
area whereas many ethnic churches tend be made up of one particular ethnic 
group.

	Those who favor ethnic churches tend to argue that people would be
more receptive to the Gospel if they heard it in their own language or from
someone of their own kind.  But I would argue that missionaries have
successfully transmitted the Gospel to people who are completely different
from themselves ethnically and racially.  Some others, especially minorities, 
find that when they attend a church that is dominated by Caucasian whites, they
have problems blending in because they feel they arent fully accepted, they feel
like a fringe element rather than real members of the church.  So they go to
ethnic churches.

I'm curious to know what others in this conference think of this issue?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
181.1CSC32::J_CHRISTIEAccessory to truthTue Mar 12 1991 22:0316
    Re: .0
    
    I can go either way on this one.
    
    Language can be a factor.  Customs and expectations can be a factor.
    "High church" versus "informality" in worship may be a factor.  Existing
    friendships and family ties may be factors.  And, let's face it,
    appearances and prestige may be factors.
    
    I am currently considering membership in a local church where there
    exists richness of ethnicity.  Nevertheless, I am in the minority.
    Not only am I the only one there who is in a wheelchair, I'll be the
    only heterosexual I know there who is a member. 8+}
    
    Peace,
    Richard
181.2society has a special place for the "not normal"XANADU::FLEISCHERwithout vision the people perish (381-0899 ZKO3-2/T63)Wed Mar 13 1991 00:1314
re Note 181.1 by CSC32::J_CHRISTIE:

>     Nevertheless, I am in the minority.
>     Not only am I the only one there who is in a wheelchair, I'll be the
>     only heterosexual I know there who is a member. 8+}
  
        It sounds as if you are part of that same larger minority
        that the rest of the congregation also belongs to -- the "not
        normals."

        I suspect that any "not normal" can identify, to some extent,
        with any other "not normal."

        Bob
181.3but I know better.CSC32::LECOMPTEThe lost are always IN_SEASONWed Mar 13 1991 01:223
    
    	Bob,
    		If I didn't know better I would say that was a slam.
181.4my ethnic group is Christian2B::THOMPSONWhich side did you say was up?Wed Mar 13 1991 10:4344
    The church I attended in Brooklyn (NYC) was almost all white when
    we first moved to that area. Gradually the population changed. By
    the time I moved up here to New Hampshire the church was mostly
    non white. A lot of blacks. Some from the south, some from the
    islands. The church hosted a service for Haitians. They had their
    own pastor and language. It was sort of a church with in a church.
    There were also a large number of people of other ethnic groups. 
    People from the Indian sub continent, Asians of various groups.
    And on and on.

    Honestly I never noticed. One day my father, the pastor of that church
    during the whole 20 years I attended there, pointed out how the
    membership had changed. It was a shock as I'd not really noticed the
    colors and accents were different. The change was too natural. Of
    course what I had noticed was that many of the surrounding churches
    had fewer people then they used to while we had more. I did then and
    still do think that was largely because we continued to preach the
    same Gospel while the others depended on "social things" to attract
    people. While our church was always involved in the community we never
    lost focus on the true purpose of the Church. The spiritual feeding of
    the body of Christ.

    I guess the point is that ethnic churches serve a purpose when a group
    comes to an area where they haven't been before all at the same time.
    But if a neighborhood develops gradually and naturally churches can
    and perhaps should reflect the diversity of the neighborhood and the
    local body of Christ. My own father was raised in an ethnic church
    (services were in Norwegian) in Brooklyn and it served his parents
    well. And he still enjoys attending serviced in Norwegian but the
    churches he's pastored have all been polyglot and reflected a wide
    range of ethnic groups.

    Interesting side note. When my father left that Brooklyn church the
    conference picked his replacement based largely on race. Ie a black
    pastor for a black church. The ones most bothered by this were black.
    And for cultural reasons. Those bothered by this were raised in the
    West Indies in black churches with white pastors. These were Anglican
    churches where it was considered prestigious to "import" your pastor
    from England which pretty much meant you got a "white'. "Importing"
    a pastor from the country of the church's origin is pretty common
    in all sorts of ethnic churches even if that's the only tie people
    really have with that country BTW.

    			Alfred