[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference kali::dewbr

Title:DECbrouter-90T2,-T2A,-T1
Notice:Kits, DOCs, Release notes, SPDs notes 1-10
Moderator:FOUNDR::SHEEHAN
Created:Wed Dec 23 1992
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1313
Total number of notes:4889

1310.0. "Standar IP access list" by TPOVC::MIKECHANG () Mon May 26 1997 12:08

 It's cross post in CISCO conference
 -----------------------------------
 Hardware/SW Platform : 7507
 IOS Software Version : 11.2
 Feature Set 	      : Authentication
 Problem Summary      : Deny is oneway or bi-dirction in standar IP access list
 Problem Description  :


    		    Host A(192.168.1.1)   B(192.168.1.2)     CISCO 7507
         		   |   			  |	    
   192.168.1.0 VLAN A    --+----------------------+----------FastE1/0.10
   192.168.2.0 VLAN B    ------------------------------------FastE1/0.20
   192.168.6.0 VLAN C    --------+---------------------------FastE1/0.30
               			 |
         		Host C(192.168.6.3)

The configuration is shown above,3VLAN are connected by Catalyst 5000 and trunk
to CISCO 7507. The goal of access list is to deny host B to access the host of
192.168.6.0  Per manual setting is done BUT the result is diffenent and 
unexpected,anything is wrong please point it out,your input are very appreciated

 access-list 1 deny   192.168.1.2  0.0.0.0
 access-list 1 permit 192.168.1.1  0.0.0.0  (for troubleshooting only)  
 access-list 1 permit any

 Interface FastE1/0.30
 ip access-group 1 out

 The result : 

 a) Host B ping host C,We got ICMP_TYPE(3) message (ie. Dest Unreachable) in 
    each ping ICMP packet in host B and final return "192.168.6.3 does not 
    Responde" 
 b) BUT host C ping host B,wait and untill timeout and got "192.168.1.2 does 
    not responde" message.

  The deny is bi-direction ? anything is wrong ?
  

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines