T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1824.1 | On a less serious note... | BINKLY::DEMARSE | Soak the Sun | Fri Apr 09 1993 16:03 | 3 |
| Maybe he's going to have a Quantum Leap.....:) just kidding.....
:), danielle
|
1824.2 | | HOO78C::ANDERSON | I've got a LA50! | Tue Apr 13 1993 07:28 | 7 |
| >Although I'm curious as to what a medical doctor might tell him.
It could be a form of epilepsy, temporal lobe - also known as
psychomotor epilepsy, produces symptoms which include those you
describe. Perhaps a visit to the doctor is called for.
Jamie.
|
1824.3 | Could be. | DWOVAX::STARK | Skin of a living thought | Tue Apr 13 1993 14:38 | 13 |
| re: .2,
That's true, it could possibly be a form of epilepsy.
Temporal lobe abnormalities have sometimes
been implicated in this sort of experience. Researchers
in the past have been able to sometimes trigger out of body
type experiences, and reportedly even experiences distinctly
resembling popularly reported _alien_abductions_ by electromagnetic
stimulation of the brain in this general area.
kind regards,
todd
|
1824.4 | intersting... | BRYAN::TREBILCOTT | bdatft | Wed Apr 14 1993 15:00 | 13 |
| Theey've been able to explain even alien abductions? Interesting...an
awful lot of people in the world with brain-wave activity that is
shorted out...
funny, ever since my anyeurism I've had an abnormal eeg, but nothing
ever happened to me...
it would be nice to explain it away with medicine, but that aside, what
supernatural cause could be at the bottom of it?
I'm curious what your friend's doctor tells him?
|
1824.5 | You said it was an explanation, not me. | DWOVAX::STARK | Skin of a living thought | Wed Apr 14 1993 15:39 | 53 |
| > Theey've been able to explain even alien abductions? Interesting...an
> awful lot of people in the world with brain-wave activity that is
> shorted out...
Maybe, but that's not anything like what I said. First of all,
electro-chemical activity in the brain isn't at all constant, it is always
fluctuating. It fluctuates with mood, thought patterns, external
stimuli, and so on, in ways that no gross surface measurement (like an
EEG) can yet accurately track. Your EEG abnormalities don't
necessarily have anything at all to do with the kinds of abnormalities
we were referring to.
'Brain-wave activity shorted out' implies to me some kind of massive
change, like seen in grand mal epilepsy, which is not neccessarily
the case. Small fluctuations are often confined to a small region
of the brain and may have very limited effects. The regions of
activity in the brain are distinguished chemically even more finely than
they are electrically, which is largely responsible for this
locallization of effect (ordinarily).
Secondly, just because an experience could be triggered by temporal lobe
storms or externally by electrical means doesn't tell us all that much
about the significance or the experience itself or other causal
factors. The point that Jamie made, and I agreed with, was that
it is known to potentially be symptomatic of epileptic or other
kinds of abnormalities, at least in some cases. It's not a
'medical explanation,' it's a medical *description*, there's a big
difference ! Neurologists don't in their professional capacity
don't generally investigate or care about extraterrestrial activities.
Many psychological models of alien abduction nowadays tend to avoid
focusing on whether people are actually being abducted, which can't yet
be determined for certain in most cases, take them at face value,
and focus on the effects and precursors of the experience itself.
These seem to have some significance.
There are some tentative background and personality commonalities between
people who experience certain kinds of extraordinary experience,
including alien abduction. There might turn out to be neural
commonalities as well. Who knows.
If that turns out to be true, it still doesn't completely rule out that
extraterrestrials are involved , and simply favoring people with those
commonalities for some reason. But it does tell us more about the
effect that the experience has on people.
What's a supernatural cause, anyway ?
Are extraterrestrials somehow intrinsically unnatural ?
I wonder if they'd agree with that. ;-)
kind regards,
todd
|
1824.6 | geese...I meant... | BRYAN::TREBILCOTT | bdatft | Wed Apr 14 1993 15:59 | 36 |
| todd:
If the activities fluctuate to the poin tthat no gross surface
measurement can track it accurately, how is it that doctors associate
it with epilepsy? And why don't they investigate non-scientific
reasons for it? Do they search for a medical symptom, whatever,
because they don't want to think what the other would mean?
You asked if extraterrestrials were unnatural. Well, if you think of
it in the sense that it is not somethign that occurs naturally to
humans in general, then I'd say so. A natural occurrence, at least to
me, is simply something that is normal to happen to humans, like losing
your baby teeth. Whether you are Russian, Chinese, whatever, whether
you are black, white, oriental, whatever, there are certain things that
are normal.
I think things that happen to individuals outside that "norm" are
unnatural, but not necessarily ABnormal or bad.
I think they fall under the catagory of phenomenon because they are
difficult for certain people to conceptualize or explain.
I was trying to make a point that there are an awful lot of people
(since there are so many who have claimed to be abducted) who have some
sort of common "difference" (I won't say abnormality, although most
people don't seem to have it) in their brains that may either cause
them to think they were abducted, or that would attract the aliens were
it to be real.
My jury is still out on the idea. I don't believe or disbelieve it...
I just want proof more than hypnosis of someone...
if there were medical implications that brain activity and these
incidents are related, then that would allude to disproof...
|
1824.7 | another reference | TNPUBS::PAINTER | angel pranks, swan songs | Wed Apr 14 1993 19:01 | 59 |
|
From: "The Kundalini Experience", by Lee Sannella, M.D., p.101
Nonphysiological Phenomena
Out-Of-Body Experiences
Out-of-body experiences (OBEs) involve the subjective feeling of leaving
the physical body either as a formless conscious identity or in the form
of a supraphysical counterpart ("etheric double" or "astral body," etc.).
This phenomenon has come to the attention of the medical establishment
through the large number of patients who have reported having had this
experience during anesthesia or while being otherwise unconscious.
Medicine treats out-of-body experiences as hallucinations or delusions.
Attempts have been made, however, by parapsychologists to establish the
objective nature of these experiences. There is some evidence that OBEs
can be at least partially objective. This calls in question the current
Western model of the relationship between brain and consciousness. As in
single seeing, the language used to describe OBEs is so typical that we
may think of these experiences as distinct from other states of divided
consciousness.
There are many anecdotal accounts of this experience. An interesting one
is that given by Joyce MacIver (1983). She has had numerous OBEs, all
triggered by her Sufi practice of relaxation and meditation. Of special
interest is her following observation:
"Soon, usually in a matter of five or ten minutes...I would
see the great banks of clouds sweep down and separate, roll
back and then sweep down again in different formations and
colors and separate again, always leaving the path at the
center... Simutaneously a feeling of warmth and movement
would start up from the bottom of my spinal column, rising,
growing warmer as it moved up, on up toward my shoulder
blades, accompanied by flashes of heat coming up over my
skin - until arms, legs, hands and back, and lately abdomen,
sometimes felt uncomfortably warm. The pusher, as I called
this spinal crawler, seemed to meet with some block before
it could get to my neck. No matter. Each time I did the
exercise it seemed to strike out harder and harder and
lately, toward the end of the sixth week, I noticed flashes
of light, seemingly in the room and near my body, beyond the
Private Theatre, appearing in my closed eyelids." (pp. 87-88)
As I wrote in an appendix to Joyce MacIver's book, "It is very clear to
me that her journeys into the hidden levels of reality had a positive,
healing and revelatory effect on her life...This conclusion is frequently
countered with the argument that such experiences are only possible if
you believe in them. To this argument I answer yes, such experiences are
only possible if you believe in them and may in fact be created by that
belief. This answer does not diminish the value of the experience,
instead it leaves open and unrestricted our definition of human
potential and provides unrestricted horizons for the depth and scope of
spiritual growth."
For further data on the OBE phenomenon the works by Robert Monroe, Sylvan
J. Muldoon, and Robert Crookall can be recommended.
|
1824.8 | pointer | TNPUBS::PAINTER | angel pranks, swan songs | Wed Apr 14 1993 19:04 | 6 |
|
Re.0
You might also look at topic 1561 in this conference.
Cindy
|
1824.9 | | HOO78C::ANDERSON | I've got a LA50! | Thu Apr 15 1993 05:57 | 11 |
| The question was asked what a medical doctor would make of the symptoms
described in the basenote. I checked up and they fall within the
symptoms of one form of epilepsy. I did not state that people who claim
to have been abducted by aliens had epilepsy, nor for that matter did
the symptoms described in the basenote refer to abduction by aliens.
So I do not know where that rathole came from, nor can I see any
relevance to it and the questions asked in the basenote. I would
therefore suggest that another topic be started to discuss this point.
Jamie.
|
1824.10 | My fault. | DWOVAX::STARK | Skin of a living thought | Thu Apr 15 1993 12:46 | 16 |
| re: .9,
Sorry, the rathole came from my response. I obviously added more
confusion than clarity ! The summary is that paresthesias
and other odd sensory experience may or may not also be indicative
of a medical pathology, but in any case there are very frequently
_physiological_correlates_, whether they represent illness or not,
contrary to what radical mind-body dualists
and supernaturalists would have us believe. And the correlates
are themselves sometimes very useful to know about.
The alien abduction thing was just a very loosely connected piece of
trivia I happened to remember at the time, sorry it caused confusion.
kind regards,
todd
|
1824.12 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Tue May 04 1993 14:29 | 8 |
| Marcos,
Maybe some psi got freaked out by the alien abduction thing and
inadvertently triggered a reaction in a lot of other people...
but.... have you seen any evidence in (what we laughingly call)
reality that supports the theory that this government (or any other)
has any control over anyone's mind except in their dreams and
research grant proposals? I haven't...
|
1824.14 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Tue May 04 1993 15:58 | 45 |
| VAXRIO::MARCOS
>My intent was not to draw accusations nor rathole this topic. I just wanted to
>point out that "the alien abduction thing" is not so trivial as some people
>claim and apparently is spreading to alarming proportions. As to what it really
>is is anybody's guess.
...maybe some group psychic break developing from the extreme stress
of living in modern society.
>"Evidence" is a very strong word but UFOS 181 has 202 references and a vast
>bibliography. Did you read it all?
That's not evidence though, Marcos... we've gotten those million line
conspiracy/alarmist notes coming over the net for years...
>If not here's something else. A fact.
>
>The man in question was "an Air Force veteran" from "Long Island" [home of the
>infamous project PHOENIX for mind control]. The medical examiner's autopsy of
>the victim revealed that "pieces of metal, like the prongs of a kitchen fork,
>were embedded, as if implanted, in a calloused hole in the skin behind his left
>ear". The man claimed that "someone had inserted a transmitter in his head
>and was thereafter tormenting him mentally."
Nope... that's not a 'fact'... that's just more words on a terminal
screen.
>The implant was REAL. Who put it there is the question.
Oh come on, Marcos... how do you know the implant was real or the guy
was real or any of that was real?
>We hear and hear and hear and end up trying to "arachnid" things.
Huh? What do spiders have to do with it?
> Article from "The Newsday Magazine", March 31, 1991 (from a
> Long Island newspaper).
>
> A Lone Death By The Side Of The Road - by Ed Lowe
>
Maybe Bill got into a fight with someone and got stabbed with a fork.
|
1824.15 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Tue May 04 1993 16:01 | 5 |
| Marcos,
If this government knew anything at all about mind control, do you
think they'd have used tanks and chemicals on a bunch of religious
extremists in Waco Texas?
|
1824.18 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Tue May 04 1993 17:09 | 33 |
|
VAXRIO::MARCOS
>I never said it was. I inserted a "but" in my statement. I meant that although
>that paper could not be taken as "evidence" (because evidence is a pretty
>strong statement) the paper had plenty of references and a vast bibliography.
>
>Did it read it all?????
Yep... I read it... I wasn't very impressed though.
I mean... they take a few simple cases of psi leakage and turn it into
a big black evil conspiracy thing... some people make a big deal out of
everything.
>What do you thing it's needed to say that a thing is real or a fact?
Me personally?
Well... to be honest with you... if I haven't experienced it myself
then I probably wouldn't believe it...
Come to think of it... even if I *have* experienced it myself, I
probably wouldn't believe the slant that someone else puts on it.
Actually... I don't believe nor disbelieve much of anything... one
way or another...
>Arachnic is a psychological tendency that some people have "to tie things
>together" as a spider.
Oh.. that's interesting... I do that..
|
1824.20 | | 25314::STANLEY | | Wed May 05 1993 09:23 | 1 |
| True enough... that's why i don't bother reading them anymore, I guess.
|
1824.21 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Wed May 05 1993 12:21 | 3 |
|
True enough... that's probably why I don't bother reading them much
anymore.
|
1824.22 | | VERGA::STANLEY | | Wed May 05 1993 13:28 | 1 |
| ... course... I don't disbelieve much of anything either...
|