[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference hydra::dejavu

Title:Psychic Phenomena
Notice:Please read note 1.0-1.* before writing
Moderator:JARETH::PAINTER
Created:Wed Jan 22 1986
Last Modified:Tue May 27 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2143
Total number of notes:41773

216.0. "In the Genes?" by --UnknownUser-- () Fri Oct 03 1986 16:57

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
216.1Maybe, and maybe not.PBSVAX::COOPERTopher CooperFri Oct 03 1986 17:1322
    There are lots of stories, like yours, which seem to indicate that
    they can be inherited, but only in the broad sense of the word.
    
    For subtle things like this its very hard to figure out whether
    the ability is actually "in the genes".  There are similar problems
    with figuring out whether things like musical ability is inherited.
    
    The problem is telling the difference between things your mother
    taught you (perhaps unconsciously) and what she passed on genetically.
    
    The only way that they can really tell, short of finding the gene
    chemically, is by comparing identical twins to fraternal twins.
    If the identical twins show the same ability more often than the
    fraternal twins, then you've probably got something genetic going
    on.
    
    The best that can be said, is that paranormal abilities seem to
    have a tendency to run in families, for whatever reasons, but lots
    of people with such abilities are not knowingly related to anyone
    else who has them.
    
    				Topher
216.2ProbablyINK::KALLISMon Oct 06 1986 11:426
    In a way, I agree with Topher.  I _suspect_ there's a genetic tie-in,
    but this sometimes devolves into the argument -- "What's more
    important, heredity or environment?"
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
    
216.3Trading placesHUDSON::STANLEYI'll Take a MelodyMon Oct 06 1986 12:345
    re: .2
    
    I'll bet you a dollar that heredity is more important.  :-)
    
    		Dave
216.4two more cents?NATASH::BUTCHARTMon Oct 27 1986 16:108
    Without the genes, any talent cannot be manifested.  _But_ if no
    opportunity arises that causes the person to have to/start to exercise
    the talent, it will be as if (s)he had not inherited it.
    
    I think this is true for any talent that one may have inherited,
    not just psychic ones.
    
    Marcia
216.5Your InheritanceFDCV16::RUHEMon Dec 22 1986 11:0512
    Morphogenetic patterning can also be a factor, whereby once something
    has been learned, descendents learn it more quickly.  An example
    is skateboarding: it is easier to learn to ride a bike than it is
    to learn how to use a skateboard.  The proposed reason is that more
    people have learned to ride a bike, so our brains have developed
    the ability to learn bike riding.  The ability to ride a bike is
    not inherited, but the ability to learn might be.
    
    Controversial, but interesting.
    
    -Ginny