T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1328.1 | | DELNI::OTA | | Tue Mar 25 1997 14:04 | 14 |
| Jeb
To be honest, I think you need to consult your personal physician for
an answer. This is just a notesfile of people who like to trade
information about weigth lifting and assorted sports activities. I
beleive I speak for all of us, in that if you have been told your too
high risk for a stress test, then you really need to talk to your own
doctor to get the answers to your questions. I know I would not want
to say something, have you try it then keel over from a hear attack 8^)
Talk to your doctor, its the best place for this information.
Brian
|
1328.2 | Had to ask | PCBUOA::BAYJ | Jim, Portables | Tue Mar 25 1997 14:52 | 49 |
| Actually, I already have. He gave me a "clean bill of health", as it
were. However, he would not recommend a weight loss program, even when
urged. There was no concern about my level of health. Just a
reluctance to "get involved" and take a personal interest. I really
don't understand why, other than my general lack of faith in the
medical community, and my belief that fear of liability outweighs any
possibility of doing the "right thing". He gave me the full smear,
including an EKG, though he did not give me a stress test.
The problem is, although everything and everyone says "see your
doctor", just try it some time. They won't do or tell you anything
when it comes to exercise, unless you've already had a heart attack,
that is! There are specialty "sports medicine" physicians these days,
but as something I read recently said, they are primarily to help
atheletes and would-be atheletes recover from over-doing. There are
bizarre fat farms you can go to, where they have paddles charged and
ready in case you keel over. But NO ONE will give you a sensible
program, monitor you, and send you off on your own. I think they all
consider it too risky.
As for the risk assessment forms, they are based 99% on generic
information, like "do you have relatives with heart conditions". They
don't say anything about you personally, they just come up with a
statistic that flags off the tester if your uncle smoked five packs a
day and keeled over at 45.
Bottom line, I can't seem to find resources anywhere that will assist.
I'm beginning to understand how lepers or aids patients feel. "What?
He's overweight and sedentary?!?! Run away!!!!!" :-(
I have feelers out in a few places I've seen on the net. In the
meantime I'm working out at a level that that would be easy for an
octogenarian, and despite my very low levels, I'm seeing weight loss
(albeit slow) and improvement (higher speed and distance at the same
low heart rate).
Its wierd, because my wife says she used to be concerned about me
hopping on the NordicTrack, huffing and puffing and getting all red
faced. Now she's concerned I'm not going fast enough!
In fact, all over the net they recommend 60-85%, which is actually
pretty darn high. I'm actually below that, so I'm not worried. I was
just hoping that someone might have come across some additional
information on this along the way and could point me to it.
Thanks anyway!
jeb
|
1328.3 | | DELNI::OTA | | Tue Mar 25 1997 15:35 | 10 |
| Jeb
You need a new doctor. Mine is always ready to help answer my
questions. When I had high chlorestoral many years ago, he put me on a
diet of excercise and nutrition and I have been going since. Doctors
are like any service, you just keep going until you find one you like
and responds to your needs. I would not keep going to a doctor that
does not give you the medical advise you seek.
Brian
|
1328.4 | How's that for action? | PCBUOA::BAYJ | Jim, Portables | Tue Mar 25 1997 17:12 | 5 |
| Well, I just called and switched. I'll see Friday if I get any better
results.
jeb
|
1328.5 | | HOTLNE::BURT | rude people rule | Wed Mar 26 1997 08:09 | 14 |
| i agree, new doc and seeing as how you did just switch- make sure to ask the
right questions and press for answers if he doesn't give you what you want. if
you belong to an hmo, see if they have a nutritionist on staff.
there's also jenny craig, weightwatchers etc which all becoming certified and
are being made to have actual doctors on staff or at least referencable to
give you the info you need.
any doc that says you don't need to lose weight and (if) you are carrying around
a spare tire, etc- that doc is a quack.
i hope you new one is more responsive to yuor needs.
reg.
|
1328.6 | another program option | JARETH::PAINTER | | Wed Apr 02 1997 15:27 | 39 |
|
A few weeks ago, I was in a weekend seminar with John Douillard, a
former Olympic Triathlete, turned Ayurvedic doctor, and now has a
Life-Spa clinic out in Boulder, Colorado.
He has written a book entitled, "Body, Mind, and Sport", which talks
about many of these kinds of topics, especially how to legitimately
access the zone. (This is unrelated to the Zone book that was
published not that long ago.)
Probably the best tip I learned at the seminar is that we should all be
breathing in and out through our nose, especially when we exercise. As
a group, we did an exercise of walking up and down a very long
driveway/hill, all the while breathing in and out slowly through our
noses. I was in great shape, just having come back from a week of
skiing in Switzerland, so I was having no problem at all. He came to
me toward the end, told me to sprint up the last bit of driveway, and
finally I hit the point where I wanted to take a mouth breath in. I
slowed down, kept with nose breathing, and went through it. Amazing.
After returning, I went back to climbing the usual 12 flights of stairs
where I was working for the prior 3 months, only using nasel breathing.
I did have to slow down a few times, but rather than being winded and
exhausted and having to walk around to slow down my heart rate, I was
calm, cool, energized, and the receptionist couldn't believe I'd just
'walked the stairs'. I took along a colleague the next day, had him do
it with me, and he couldn't believe it either. One can do this during
weight training, Nordictrack, running, etc. I have also tried it on my
exercise bike, just focusing in on nasel breathing (no reading), and
suddenly, 5 miles went by without my even noticing.
John also has out a tape set called "Invincible Athlete" which is good
too. He has consulted to many of the top tennis players - Billie Jean
King, Martina Navratalova, etc., along with many top athletes as well,
and they highly recommend his program. For those of you who know about
Ayurveda, John co-managed the Lancaster, MA clinic with Deepak Chopra
for 8 years. He's one amazing person.
Cindy
|
1328.7 | | PCBUOA::BAYJ | Jim, Portables | Wed Apr 02 1997 19:10 | 51 |
| Re: nasal breathing
Thats interesting. In a sense, I sort've discovered that myself,
because, until the fatty acid flood kicks in, I can exert a lot of
control over my heart rate just by careful deep breathing.
However, after the "flood", which is happening for me anywhere from
18-24 minutes, my heart rate is completely dependent on my exertion
level. I think at that point, if I were to raise my heart rate until
I'm on the border of having to breath through my mouth, then I'd
clearly be identifying my aerobic threshold.
I'm not quite ready to do that because...
I visited my new primary care physician. I can't say I'm overly
impressed. His immediate response was that 110bpm was too slow, but at
the end of the interview (since he didn't really check me out) he
recanted and suggested I keep it low till I'm over the 30 minute mark.
Unfortunately he seemed more focused on my cholesterol, and treating it
with meds, rather than encouraging someone who is obviously prepared to
start a fitness program to go for it!
Despite the doctor's warning, duration isn't my problem. I'm convinced
I could be going an hour right now, but I'm worried that if my body
tells me I'm overdoing, its going to be in a way I really don't like.
So I've been working up gradually so my body doesn't have to issue any
stern warnings. I'm probably way below what I COULD do safely, but
better safe than sorry. (A friend suggested I take a stress test in the
doctor's office, because that way if something happened, he'd have the
paddles right there - GREAT IDEA!!!! :-(
Re: "the flood".
Covert Bailey describes the "fatty acid flood" in his new book "Smart
Exercise". I have to admit it was really a trip when I experienced
"the flood" for the first time this weekend. I was hauling along, my
pulse and speed jumping all over the place as usual, and then all of a
sudden, my pulse just dropped like a rock, from 110 to 90, and my speed
just started coming up. I brought my speed up to 4.2kph (according to
the Nordictrack) which is normally tough for me to reach without
exceeding my target HR, and my pulse was nailed on 108 (my current
target). It was really cool seeing this effect actually taking place
in me.
I think I may try the nasal breathing thing in a couple more days, just
to see how that pace jibes with my predicted heart rates. I know
compared to weight lifting this may all be pretty bizarre, but I really
appreciate having a place to toot my horn. Thanks!
jeb
|
1328.8 | | HOTLNE::BURT | rude people rule | Thu Apr 03 1997 09:23 | 23 |
| nasal breathing revisisted. a while back i brought up the notion of nasal
breathing and got all in a twither over it. i do practice nasal breathing most
all the time, and my sense of smell [which was exceptionally good to begin with]
has increased ten fold allowing me smell an ant fart nowadays.
i generally feel calmer, more enegetic, however- under times of extensive stress
i have found that i really do need to exhale forcefully through my mouth and
nose [benching, squating, leg presses, running up hill to name a few]
nasal breathing is a great relaxation technique [yoga] and is a wonderful way to
help one sleep better at nite [i think so, anyway].
it takes awhile to get used to and sometimes its not so good [i.e. wearing face
mask in fab and inhaling your own breath everyday; i _will_not_ stop eating
garlic though!] 8^)
work at it for most anything you do, however, you may find that you will
occassionally need to gulp for air when really stressing the body. remember,
we all start out not even breathing through our mouths until the doc whacks us
on the bottom [not that we were breathing our noses, either and not that our
lungs weren't full of the gift of life, too].
reg.
|
1328.9 | Re.8 | LOUISA::PAINTER | | Thu Apr 03 1997 11:28 | 31 |
|
>i generally feel calmer, more enegetic, however- under times of
>extensive stress i have found that i really do need to exhale
>forcefully through my mouth and nose
That's the key. Mouth breathing is a reaction to stress, and the body
is sent into 'fight or flight' mode. When in this mode, the body burns
short-term reserves of sugar, as opposed to longer-term reserves of
fat. Also, it's been shown that when the body goes into this state,
free radicals are released, and this is not a good thing.
Exercise should not be stressful. It does take time to retrain to
breathe through one's nose...it took John somewhere between 3-6 months
to get back to where he was with traditional breathing...but it can be
done.
John talked about a story with one of his children, when his child was
an infant, he was trying to breathe through his nose but it was stuffed
up and couldn't. Eventually, in response to this, he panicked and began
to cry (body was sent into a stressful 'fight or flight' mode), which
triggered breathing through his mouth. It is not a natural thing for
us to breathe through our mouths, but because we are always under so
much stress, that's what we've learned to do.
Our noses contain turbines to focus the air and drive it down into the
lower lobes of our lungs. It's also important to exhale through the
nose as well, to drive the toxins back out from the lower lobes. Mouth
breathing - even though it may seem to - does not reach the lower lobes
at all. It only goes into the upper lobes.
Cindy
|
1328.10 | | LOUISA::PAINTER | | Thu Apr 03 1997 11:39 | 15 |
|
Re.7
Yes, that does sound characteristic of reaching the Zone - where your
pulse rate remains the same, yet your performance increases.
John mentioned a marathoner who ran a marathon using nasel breathing
(he had been training with it for some time beforehand), yet couldn't
get his pulse rate up past 126. Initially the heart rate may go up
when you switch to nasel breathing, because it does take some adjusting.
It will be interesting to read your findings.
Cindy
|
1328.11 | | LUDWIG::BOUCHARD | | Fri Apr 04 1997 10:59 | 40 |
|
I know much of this has been discussed before in this conference
but here's a related topic that kind've ties in the nasal breathing
and aerobic/anerobic debate.
I read an interesting article in Climbing magazine the other day
in regards to aerobic/anaerobic training for high altitude climbers.
The article touched on the fact that more intense "aerobic" workouts
actually do less for a person that is trying to lower their body
fat than less intense workouts. It went on to say that when your
maintaining your heart rate in the 50-65% max. your body is recouping
its energy from stored fat. At this heart rate you're body is capable
of supplying the required oxygen necessary to metabolize fat stores.
(On a side note it said something to the affect that theoretically
since the majority of the population has >15% body fat, ~30-40k stored
calories, one should be able to maintain a 50-65% max. heart rate
activity for some rediculous length of time). When you're training
above the 65% max. heart rate you are incapable of supplying enough
oxygen to your body to metabolize fat, so you get your energy from
carbs/protiens which are metabolized more easily. The average person
can carb load ~2000 calories, once these are burnt, the debilitating
affects of lactid acid build up occur because you're now chowin'
protien, your muscles.
In a nutshell the flavor of the article came down to more
is not necessarily better ...
From a pure weight loss/body fat reduction point of view, less
intensity and longer aerobic workouts are more beneficial than
high intensity anaerobic.
From a climbing/endurance athelete point of view, the key is to train
your body to metabolize fat through long "aerobic" workouts but to also
mix in anerobic high intensity workouts so your body is trained to
handle heavy stress/burst of power situations when necessary.
For what its worth, thought you might be interested ...
db
|
1328.12 | Just feeling good today! | PCBUOA::BAYJ | Jim, Portables | Mon May 05 1997 14:39 | 36 |
| Hey, I'm pumping up some heavy iron, now! Thats right! I jumped right
on up to the big time. Two sets, 20 reps, and, are you ready for this?
THREE POUND DUMBELLS!
Yessir, you BB people are really going to stand in awe before *my*
mighty biceps! (Should you ever somehow get a glimpse of me!)
As mentioned in previous notes, I am taking things slow. But I've
moved up to occasional forays at higher pulse rates, so I figured that
I might be able to tolerate lifting something that weighs about a third
as much as the brief case and laptop computer I carry to work every
day!
Actually, I am really amazed at how quickly I'm starting to see the
definition return (I've lifted a little from time to time, way back).
I don't think anyone standing beside me could see it (I keep flexing
for my wife - she grins supportively and goes back to peeling
potatoes). But I can definitely see a little tiny bit of shape whereas
before it was just round flabby stuff.
Right now I'm only doing curls, and whatever they call the one that
compliments the opposing muscles; where you hold a weight over your
head and lower it behind your back. Oh, and shrugs. Not a full
program at all, but even this little bit I'm convinced is keeping my
wieght from coming down.
However, I have so much energy I can't believe it, so I'm still
tracking my heart rate, watching my progress, and trying not to get
depressed about the scale being rusted solid in one spot. Oh, and even
though its hard for even me to see, I feel my jeans getting looser and
looser. I'm living for the day I slip into the next lower size
without the help of machinery!
jeb
|