T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1521.1 | | SQUID::GOODWIN | | Sat Oct 14 1989 01:16 | 26 |
|
I'm not sure I can answer all your questions, but I've done some
re-loading and re-wiring of my speaker cabs before, so I can provide
some info. I'll start with the simpler 2x12 configuration. In
a series circuit the impedance is additive, therefore 2 eight ohm
speakers wired in series would yield a 16 ohm load. The formula
for calculating the impedance in a parallel connection is:
1 1 1
- = - + -
X Y Z
where X is the total impedance and Y and Z represent the impedance
of the individual speakers. That would give a total of 4 ohms for
two eight ohm speakers wired in parallel.
Most 4 x n cabs I've seen are wired in series/parallel combination,
which yields a total impedance equal to the impedance of one speaker
(provided all 4 speakers have the same impedance rating.)
Four 8 ohm speakers wired in series would give a total impedance of 32
ohms, and a parallel connection would give a total of 2 ohms.
I hope this has been some help.
/Steve
|
1521.2 | ex | VLNVAX::ALECLAIRE | | Sat Oct 14 1989 20:52 | 3 |
| My cabs have 2 16's in parallel for 8 total ohms;
this is then in series with an 8 ohm yeilding 16 total, for a 3x12.
|
1521.3 | .1 said it all | MILKWY::JACQUES | | Mon Oct 16 1989 09:44 | 15 |
| .1 is exactly right.
It's true that speakers do not act like resistors, but all you are
trying to calculate is *nominal* impedance. Resistors have the same
resistance regardless what signal you put through them. Speakers
impedance varies with frequency, however, for the purpose of matching
speakers to amps, nominal impedance is all you need to know.
Wire it up series/parallel for an 8 ohm load and you should be
all set.
Good luck. BTW, what are you strapping this beast to ?
Mark
|
1521.4 | Thanks! | CSC32::G_HOUSE | Spam Monkey Shin Dance | Mon Oct 16 1989 11:54 | 48 |
| Thanks to you all, that REALLY helps.
>It's true that speakers do not act like resistors, but all you are
>trying to calculate is *nominal* impedance.
THANK you!!! That was the piece of the previous discussion I was
missing. That had me really confused. Your explanation really
clarifies it for me.
So, just to make sure I'm clear on this... From my original question,
this would be the correct diagram for series/parallel (which using 8ohm
speakers would be an 8ohm wiring)?
|------|-(-)
(+)--|-----||
| | ||
----||-|- ---||---
| /--\ | | /--\ |
| | || || ||
| \--/ | | \--/ |
| | | |
|---||--| |--||--|
/--\ /--\
| | | |
\--/ \--/
If I wire this in this way, can I use a common ground through all the
speakers?
I've been thinking and what I'd eventually like to do is wire the
cabinet in stereo, like GK does, where if you plug into only one input
jack, you get all the speakers wired like a normal mono cabinet, but if
you plug into both jacks you get a separate stereo wiring. Given what
you've told me so far, if I can use a common ground, I think I can do
this by putting in a jack with a switch in it to disconnect the
positive wire of one of the series 2x12 sets from the other. Does this
sound feasible, or am I way off base?
> Good luck. BTW, what are you strapping this beast to ?
For now, a Hiwatt 100wt, but sometime in the "near" (near being a
relative term, if ya know what I mean) future, it'll probably be hooked
up to a stereo rack setup. I have most of the pieces for this now, I
just need the power amp. Unfortunately, the holiday season is about
upon us and excess money is starting to get scarce.
Tanks,
Greg
|
1521.5 | another cut at the same thing . . | SQUID::GOODWIN | | Mon Oct 16 1989 12:56 | 20 |
| I may be confused, but your diagram in .4 looks like a full
parallel wiring to me. I'll attempt a diagram of a series/parallel
set-up and see if I can cloud the issue even more!!! ;-)
(+) -----------|----------------|
(+) (+)
SP1 SP2
(-) (-)
| |
(+) (+)
SP3 SP4
(-) (-)
(-) -----------|----------------|
Make sure and get it right, I hate smoked transformers!!
I'll let someone else cover the mono/stereo switchable wiring
as I am not certain how that would be accomplished.
Steve
|
1521.6 | use the circuit in .5 | MILKWY::JACQUES | | Mon Oct 16 1989 14:21 | 15 |
| Your diagram in .4 is definately a full parallel circuit. Impedance
would be:
1/x = 1/8 + 1/8 + 1/8 + 1/8 = 4/8
x = 8/4 = 2 ohms. Very few power amps can handle a 2 ohm load.
.5 has the right circuit diagram for series/parallel. Use this circuit
for a mono system of 8 ohms impedance.
Perhaps someone can figure out the GK trick, or you could find a friend
with a cab, and peek inside to see the trick they use. I would imagine
they use something like a nomalled jack, as found on a patchbay.
|
1521.7 | Good thing I asked, huh? | CSC32::G_HOUSE | Spam Monkey Shin Dance | Mon Oct 16 1989 17:23 | 7 |
| Ah, I get it now! (Your diagram is much easier to read too...)
Thanks Steve!
I know someone that has a GK stereo cab, I'll see if they'll let me
take it apart to check the wiring. ;-)
Greg
|
1521.8 | Switchable Modes, Stereo Jacks | AQUA::ROST | Chickens don't take the day off | Tue Oct 17 1989 10:22 | 21 |
|
A common feature in some cabs (particularly Ampeg) is to use 16 ohm
speakers, switchable between series/parallel for 16 ohm operation or
full parallel for 4 ohm operation. The purpose of this is that when
using *two* cabs in parallel, put each one in series/parallel (16 ohmms
each) to get 8 ohms total, still drivable by most amps (as opposed to
two 4 ohm cabs in parallel, total of 2 ohms, not drivable by most
amps).
For stereo wiring, have two jacks to the cab, one a regular 2 conductor
jack, the other a "switched" jack. Use the regular jack for mono, both
jacks for stereo. I can't draw the wiring easily on this terminal, but
basically the two jacks are shorted (giving a parallel connection) if
only the regular jack is used, but plugging into the second jack breaks
the connection (similar to how headphone jacks turn your speakers off
on stereos).
Using a series/parallel wiring with 8 ohm speakers, you would get an 8
ohm mono load or two 16 ohm loads for stereo. Using 16 ohm speakers in
full parallel, you would get 4 ohms for mono, two 8 ohm loads for
stereo.
|
1521.9 | DUH...I still don't get it. | MSBCS::KALINOWSKI | | Thu Apr 04 1991 13:23 | 14 |
| Yo EE dudes.........
OK, so I have a 4x12 loaded with 16 ohm speakers wired to 4 ohms. What
would I do (Keeping in mind I don't know squat about creating loads and
shorting and stuff....basicly I need a picture or step by step
directions) to make this 4x12 an 8 ohm stereo 4 ohm mono cab. If
someone has the time I'd appreciate the explaination, diagram or even
call me and say "now connect from + on #1 to +..bla bla bal"
Thanks EE dudes. (Mom was righht I should have stayed in Electrical
engineering)
Brian
DTN :293-5146 (For those who'd rather call and describe it over the phone)
|
1521.10 | It's as easy as Ohms law.. | BTOVT::BRONSON | This AXE was made for choppin'! | Thu Apr 04 1991 13:40 | 25 |
|
It's easy......
4 ohm mono is the equivalent of all 4 speakers in
parallel..
-> + --> + --> + -- +
[ [ [ [ equals 4 ohms 16/4=4
-> - --> - --> - -- -
Stereo 8 ohms Left -> + --> +
[ [ 8 ohms 16/2=8
-> - --> -
Right -> + --> +
[ [ 8 ohms 16/2=8
-> - --> -
Hope this helps...
R.B.
|
1521.11 | One more question. | MSBCS::KALINOWSKI | | Thu Apr 04 1991 13:48 | 6 |
| How do you get them to switch from mono to stereo though that's the
concept that I really can't get ahold of.
brian
Oh ya..... thanks for the speedy reply.
|
1521.12 | Another cut at it... | BTOVT::BRONSON | This AXE was made for choppin'! | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:17 | 20 |
|
Still very easy....
A switch will be wired in between the 2nd and 3rd speaker
which will either connect all speakers or segregate the last 2..
______ + Left stereo in
|
+ Right ---> + ----> + --- \----> + ------> +
S/mono [ [ SW1 [ [
- ground --> - ----> - --- ----> - ------> -
/
|_______ - Left stereo ground
Sw1 would switch 3rd/4th speaker to either the 1st/2nd speaker or
to the Left input. The double pole/double throw switch wiper
is wired to the 3rd/4th speaker + and - respectively..
R.B.
|
1521.13 | Closed Circuit Jacks | IXION::ROST | I dreamed I was Roy Estrada | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:19 | 10 |
| You can buy switching jacks, like the kind they put in stereos that
shut off your speakers when you plug in headphones. These are called
"closed circuit" jacks.
For mono, you plug into a non-switching jack and get all four speakers
connected, plugging into the second (switching) jack connects each jack
to two speakers apiece. I won't bother to try to draw this out on a
VT100...
Brian
|
1521.14 | bzzz!sorry wrong answer | HAMER::KRON | ELECTRIFIED | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:21 | 5 |
| no switch required!!!!
just plug both sides into the amp and they will be parallel
anyway!
-Bill
|
1521.15 | A Switch Is Invitation To Disaster | IXION::ROST | I dreamed I was Roy Estrada | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:21 | 7 |
| Re: .12
I'd avoid a switch and use the jacks as recommended in .13, because the
day the switch gets bumped into the mono position and you short both
channels of your stereo amp together will be a sad day indeed.
Brian
|
1521.16 | Bitch, Bitch, Bitch | IXION::ROST | I dreamed I was Roy Estrada | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:23 | 8 |
| Re: .14
Geez, how fast can people type around here?
That's right, but you need two speaker cords when running mono. Using a
closed circuit jack you only need one when running mono.
Brian
|
1521.17 | | CAVLRY::BUCK | Eight days til ANACONDA! | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:55 | 4 |
| gh's new cab has 15ohm Celestions in it!
Good luck gh!
;^)
|
1521.18 | *FIFTEEN* Ohm?!??? | GOES11::G_HOUSE | Stereotype, monotype, blood type... | Thu Apr 04 1991 14:56 | 3 |
| What on earth are you taking about???
gh
|
1521.19 | | CAVLRY::BUCK | Eight days til ANACONDA! | Thu Apr 04 1991 15:37 | 1 |
| 15 ohms dude!
|
1521.20 | | GSRC::COOPER | Major MIDI Rack Puke (tm) | Thu Apr 04 1991 16:13 | 8 |
| I'd bet no such beast is on earth.
I've noticed when you measure impedance on a speaker, the voltage
from the VOM battery will make the impedance vary. A good source
of speaker info told me that a 4 ohm speaker will measure anywhere
from 2 to 7 ohms... Same with others.
jc
|
1521.21 | Thank yous all......;^) | MSBCS::KALINOWSKI | | Thu Apr 04 1991 16:19 | 6 |
| Thanks guys.........
I'll go to Radar Shack tonoght and get the stuff I need. I appreciate
the help.
Brian
|
1521.22 | | CAVLRY::BUCK | Eight days til ANACONDA! | Thu Apr 04 1991 16:27 | 4 |
| RE: Coop
If dat was da case, how come Celestion went through the trouble to
print "30wt -- 15ohms" on the back of each speaker?!?"
|
1521.23 | | 9KCSSE::LEITZ | butch leitz | Thu Apr 04 1991 16:36 | 6 |
| I was in a band in college that had 2 monitors with 15 ohm speakers.
When the band broke up & we divvied equipment I got these (and other
things) but could never use them since I didn't have the right cross
overs or whatever the heck I needed to drive them. They barely made
a sound on an 8ohm output. I assumed then (and still do) that 15ohms
is real (real weird) speaker for fun (weird fun) configurations...
|
1521.24 | gimme that 15 ohm stuff, but cheap! | EZ2GET::STEWART | No, I mean Real Music. | Thu Apr 04 1991 18:20 | 15 |
|
I know you all already know this, but
Resistance does not equal impedance except at 0 Hz.
|
1521.25 | close enough for R & R | LEDS::BURATI | Infidel THIS! | Thu Apr 04 1991 18:42 | 17 |
|
It's my opinion that 15 ohms is close enough for rock and roll.
Two in parallel make 7.5 ohms and you can't tell me that that
a big deal to an 8 ohm output. I'd use 'em.
RE: .23
Butch,
A 15 ohm speaker connected to an 8 ohm output will make
lots of sound unless there's something dreadfully wrong with it.
It's not a good match but it will make plenty of sound. So maybe
that speaker is blown. Does the cone move? If so, does it make
a rubbing sound when you push down gently and evenly on the cone?
If it's hadly making any sound, the voice coil could be jammed.
--rjb
|
1521.26 | | GSRC::COOPER | Major MIDI Rack Puke (tm) | Thu Apr 04 1991 18:59 | 7 |
| Strange...
Are these Green Backs ??
And I would say that 15 ohms is close enough to 16 to run off a
marshall. :)
jc
|
1521.27 | NOT half of sum (recipricals involved) | PHOBIA::BULLARD | | Thu Apr 04 1991 20:00 | 9 |
| I seem to remember from my electronincs training (many years
ago that: (R=resistance, same for impedence)
series: R1+R2=Rt
paralell: 1/R1 + 1/R2 = 1/Rt (LOTS less than half of sum)
chuck
|
1521.28 | Phase relationships make Z's different than R's.. | BTOVT::BRONSON | One picture is worth many verbs! | Fri Apr 05 1991 07:59 | 7 |
|
If all R's are equal you can devide by the R by the number of R's..
Or use the 1/R1 + 1/R2...+ 1/Rx = 1/Rt (total)...method
R.B.
|
1521.29 | They're the same | LEDS::ORSI | Tripe my shorts | Fri Apr 05 1991 10:11 | 6 |
|
In the UK, their nominal impedance of 15 ohms is equal
to the USA 16 ohms. There is no electrical difference.
Neal
|
1521.30 | correction | HAMER::KRON | ELECTRIFIED | Fri Apr 05 1991 10:56 | 9 |
| Sorry kids but impedance=resistancecoupled with reactance which
means that your speaker which is a coil of wire surrounded by a
magnet is a inductor and will have a definite change in the
"resistance" you measure as you change the frequency of the
signal passing through it.
Anyway you would need 2 cords to run the cabinet in stereo
....why go through a whole Rube Goldberg setup to
avoid carrying an extra cord when running mono?????
-Bill
|
1521.31 | Clarification, (or confusion ?) | PHOBIA::BULLARD | | Fri Apr 05 1991 12:21 | 21 |
| re: .30
You are correct that impedence changes with frequency.
for coils it is: for capacitors it is:
I=2(pi)FL 1
_______
2(pi)FC
I=impedence
F=frequency in hertz
L=inductance in henrys
C=capacitance in farads
These properties are put to great use in crossover networks
(for example). Impedence in coil increases as frequency rises
letting the woofer get only lows. Impedence rises in capacitor
as frequency drops letting tweeter get only highs.
But a coil and capacitor do have static resistance (coils
approach 0, capacitors approach infinity). In an 8 ohm speaker
the voice coil would measure approx. 8 ohms with an ohmmeter.
Amps are designed with a certain load (speaker) in mind.
They work best (without damage or diminished sound) when amp/
speaker (load) are correct.
|