[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference hydra::amiga_v1

Title:AMIGA NOTES
Notice:Join us in the *NEW* conference - HYDRA::AMIGA_V2
Moderator:HYDRA::MOORE
Created:Sat Apr 26 1986
Last Modified:Wed Feb 05 1992
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:5378
Total number of notes:38326

4516.0. "Replacement suggestions wanted" by CX3PST::WSC160::D_WHITE (I'm patient if it doens't take very long) Thu Feb 14 1991 12:27

    
    
    Due to a recent burglary, I find that I need to replace my system.
    Here's what I had:
    
    A1080 monitor (came with my original A1000)
    A2000 (not sure what rev the motherboard was, but I had a 1Mb Agnus
    	   and 1.3 ROMs and second internal floppy)
    A2300 internal genlock
    A2058 memory expansion, 2Mb populated
    Microbotics HardFrame SCSI controller with 40Mb Quantum drive
    A2088 Bridgeboard
    ATD memory expansion, 128Kb populated to bring PC side up to 640Kb
    Miniscribe 8450 40Mb ST506 drive for the PC side
    Mouse Master Mouse/Joystick port controller
    Supra 2400 baud external modem
    Panasonic KX-P1124 printer
    
    The burglars also took my TV and VCR and a portable tape player.  The
    S.O.B.'s even stole a 12-pack of pop from the refrigerator!  Needless
    to say, this whole experience has been distressful.
    
    Anyway, I am looking for some thoughts about replacements.  I checked
    with my local dealer and he estimates that it will cost $4200 to
    replace everything above with new merchandise (didn't realize I had so
    much tied up in this system!).  However, I am thinking that I may want
    to make some changes, and now seems like the perfect time to do that.
    
    Since I got my first system in May of 1986 (has it been that long?),
    I have discovered that the 3 things that enhance an Amiga's performance
    the most are:  (1) a second floppy drive, (2) more memory, and (3) a
    hard drive.  However, with a hard drive, there is not as much need for
    a second floppy drive.
    
    Questions:
    
    1.  What do you think about the 3000 as opposed to the 2000?  It is
        going to be another couple of months or so before V2.0 ROMs are
        available for the 2000, and the upgrade is going to be more
        expensive than the upgrade from V1.2 to V1.3 from what I have
        heard.  The 3000 has a smaller footprint and power supply, and
        not as many expansion slots.  An argument can be made that the
        3000 does not need as big a power supply or as many expansion
        slots because many of the things that I had in my 2000 are
        built-in to the 3000, such as a hard drive controller and video
        enhancement.  Other than V2.0 ROMs, is there anything else about
        a 3000 which cannot be duplicated with a comparable expansion
        board on a 2000?
    2.  I never had any difficulty with my A1080 monitor.  For stereo
        capability, I connected an old receiver and a couple of speakers.
        For enhanced video, though, I was thinking about getting a
        multisync monitor.  With a 2000, I would have to get some kind
        of video enhancement board in order to take advantage of the
        features, though.  This means that the video slot is occupied
        and unavailable for a genlock.  This is not too much of a hardship,
        as I never really used the genlock.  I would appreciate thoughts
        on:  A) monitors in general, multisync in particular, and B)
        internal and external genlocks for use on a 2000 or 3000.
    3.  MS-DOS capability is important to me because of all of the
        software I have which runs on IBM systems.  I have considered
        replacing the 2088 with either an AT bridgeboard (A2286?), or
        perhaps simply getting a small clone.  The hard drive controller
        that I had for the PC side before took up 2 slots because of the
        size of the drive.  This wasn't too bad on the 2000, because I
        was able to slide in the memory expansion for the PC into a half
        card slot immediately adjacent to the PC drive card.  With an AT
        brigeboard, though, I understand that there is already 1Mb on
        board or otherwise available to the PC side, thus getting around
        the problem of PC software not running due to lack of memory.
        I have also heard or expansion daughtercards which replace the
        68000 with a combination 680x0/Intel 80x86.  Does anyone have
        suggestions or information about:  A) putting a bridgeboard and
        PC hard drive inside a 3000, B) IBM compatibility as implemented
        through the processor daughtercard, or C) moving my MS-DOS stuff
        to a separate system?  (Space is not too much of a consideration.)
    4.  If I were to go with a 2000, I plan to get a different hard drive
        controller.  The Microbotics HardFrame functioned flawlessly once
        I replaces the ST217N with a Quantum.  However, it seems rather
        silly to take up an additional expansion slot with memory when
        there are so many controllers available with memory expansion
        capabilities integrated on them.  Does anyone have information
        or experience with SUPRA or GVP (or any body else's) hard drive/
        memory expansion controllers?
    5.  I can get a Scholar from work to use for dialing in, but I miss
        my old SUPRA.  The models available now have all kinds of error
        correction and data compression capabilities which, quite frankly,
        make them superior (in my opinion) to a Scholar.  What kinds of
        modems are you folks using?  Internal or external?  What do you
        like or dislike about them?
    6.  I don't generally do anything fancy as far as printing goes, so
        the Panasonic KX-P1124 was more than adequate for my needs.  I
        will probably replace it with another one exactly like it. 
        However, since I am replacing everything and looking for
        suggestions I would like to hear any thoughts anyone might have
        regarding printers.  
    
    I regularly keep up with this conference and have read other notes
    covering most of the topics discussed above, although some of them
    are rather old and outdated.  Pointers to these other notes are
    welcome, but I am really looking for new opinions and ideas.  This
    conference has been invaluable to me in the past, answering questions
    and reviewing new software and hardware products.  Sorry this is so
    long, but I was hoping that I could prevail upon the DEC Amiga user
    community once again for help.  Any suggestions, recommendations,
    price quotes, or technical clarifications would be most appreciated
    either here in the conference or through MAIL.  Thanks.
    
    Dave
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
4516.1Oh goodie - another chance to ...MADRE::MWMThu Feb 14 1991 15:0826
First, I disagree about two floppies not being usefull with an HD. First, it
makes copying floppies much easier. Second, if you've got a good backup
program (e.g. ExpressCopy), it'll put up a requester to change one floppy
while writing to the second, thus running the slowest part of the backup
process asynch.

Anyway:

1) The one thing you can't get on a 2000 is a 32 bit path to CHIP ram.
For some things, this is important (I'm beta testing one that A3000
owners will _love_), for others, it doesn't matter.

2) If you're not serious about video work and have a 3000, you should go
ahead and buy at least a VGA monitor. The cost difference isn't that
large, and the solid display is well worth it. If you later decide to do
video work, you can still get NTSC video off the RGB port.

3) Last time I checked, CBM had not released a bridgeboard for the 3000.
The stated reason was that the '030 cache and the bridgeboard memory
interface didn't work well together. If space isn't a problem, I'd go
to a second system. After all, it's cheaper; Fry's is advertising 386
systems for under $400.

	<mike


4516.2Can't BRIDGE a 3000?SDOGUS::WILLIAMSTOPGUNThu Feb 14 1991 15:522
    My A3000 and 286 bridgeboard work fine.
    TOPGUN
4516.3FlixerFixer + GenlockTLE::RMEYERSRandy MeyersThu Feb 14 1991 17:1729
Re: .0

>        For enhanced video, though, I was thinking about getting a
>        multisync monitor.  With a 2000, I would have to get some kind
>        of video enhancement board in order to take advantage of the
>        features, though.  This means that the video slot is occupied
>        and unavailable for a genlock.  This is not too much of a hardship,
>        as I never really used the genlock.

One change coming for the 2000 is that it is going to get the Enhanced
Chip Set version of the display chip.  With will enable the 2000 to
output a 400 line non-interlaced display in a new video mode.  The
drawbacks are the new mode has a severe limit on number of colors
that are displayed, the size of the palette that you can choose colors
from, and the amount of chip-memory related cycle stealing.  To use
this new mode, you need a multisync monitor (or a VCG monitor if you
don't care about using any of the old Amiga modes).

A Microway FlickerFixer doesn't preclude using an internal genlock anymore.
You need in addition to the FlickerFixer a daughter board that allows
the FlickerFixer to work with a genlock (internal or external).  Then
so you can use it with an internal genlock, you need the DEB card
from Microway that, in effect, converts a normal expansion slot into
a second video slot that the FlickerFixer can use.

I suspect that the new Commodore de-interlace board doesn't need any
special daughter board so that it can co-exist with a genlock.  However,
I don't know if it can plug into a DEB board so that you can free up
the real video slot.
4516.4One more hat in the ring...TLE::TLET8::ASHFORTHThe Lord is my lightFri Feb 15 1991 08:0512
FWIW, I have no doubts, myself: in your situation I would get a 3000UX. But, it
depends on what you want out of it. For me, the opportunity to have not only an
Amiga, but a standard "System V" Unix box at home would be a major plus, not to
mention the advantage of a true 32-bit architecture. As a 1000 owner who took
the upgrade to the 2000 (HD), I also think the opportunity to get back on the
bandwagon at the "latest and greatest" level shouldn't be passed up. Of course,
there's the matter of "total bucks" as an aatribute of a system, too- anyway,
good luck on your cogitations and contemplations.


Cheers,
	Bob
4516.5FlickerFixer & A2000A DECAUX::VNATIM::HELMUTShe&#039;s always a VAX to meFri Feb 15 1991 11:3825
Re: .3

> A Microway FlickerFixer doesn't preclude using an internal genlock anymore.
> You need in addition to the FlickerFixer a daughter board that allows
> the FlickerFixer to work with a genlock (internal or external).  Then
> so you can use it with an internal genlock, you need the DEB card
> from Microway that, in effect, converts a normal expansion slot into
> a second video slot that the FlickerFixer can use.

  Is this DEB card also compatible with the old motherboard with the 
  short videoslot. The short slot prohibits using the Microway FlickerFixer
  and this card would allow using that card in my old Amy.

  If it's possible I would be interested in price and where I can get it
  from.

    ______________
    \            /
     \	Thanks  /
    |-\ Helmut /
    |__\  Hg  / 
        \____/


N.B.: Is there any possibility to get a new motherboard at a reasonable price ?
4516.6Motherboard ExchangeTLE::RMEYERSRandy MeyersFri Feb 15 1991 13:1428
Re: .5

>  Is this DEB card also compatible with the old motherboard with the 
>  short videoslot.

I don't know if it is compatible with the old "A2000" motherboards.


>Is there any possibility to get a new motherboard at a reasonable price ?

It depends on what you think is reasonable.  Commodore does have a
motherboard exchange program.  When I last asked my dealer about it
I believe the terms were that Commodore would exchange any version
of the motherboard for the latest version of the motherboard for
US $500 (or was it $300?).

I have a minor problem with by parallel port: it works fine for
output and only partially works for input.  Thus, I can not use
a DigiView at all, but I can use a Perfect Sound if I digitize
only the left sound channel but not the right.  My dealer checked
over my system and found replacing all of the chips involved had
no effect.  Commodore recommended that he replace the motherboard.
Since the Amiga was out of warranty, I elected not to go this route.

However, I plan on re-thinking this decision when Commodore starts
shipping Amiga 2000s with the enhanced chip set and 2.0 in ROM.  If
I do a motherboard exchange for that version of the motherboard, then
I'll be getting the new chips "for free."
4516.7ELWOOD::PETERSFri Feb 15 1991 13:355
	I just looked into a mother board swap. The cost was about
  $650.

		Steve Peters
4516.8If your going to replace motherboard...wait for 2.0CHAKRA::ROBERTFor more info, call: 800/555-1212Mon Feb 18 1991 17:145
	If you have an old 2000 motherboard, you would want to wait for one
with 2.0 rom and the enhanced chip set on it.  The chips alone for 2.0
should cost between $250 & $350 (Especially if you need the 1 MEG Agnus).

-----Robert
4516.9Haven't made up my mind, but getting closerCX3PST::WSC160::D_WHITEI&#039;m patient if it doens&#039;t take very longTue Feb 19 1991 15:2525
    Thank you for all of your responses.
    
    re .1  I think you misunderstood me.  I didn't say that a second floppy
    	   drive was not useful; I found plenty of uses for it and sometimes
    	   wished I had a 3rd drive.  Hard drive backups were definitely
    	   one of those times.  When I started with my 1000, I only had the
           internal drive.  Adding the second floppy made life much easier,
    	   and was a pretty reasonable alternative to spending nearly as
    	   much for a hard drive and controller as I did for the original
    	   system.  The prices of drives and controllers have come down
    	   considerably AND the technology has improved vastly over what
    	   was available 5 years ago when I got my first system.  If I
    	   absolutely HAD to, I could live with a hard drive and only one
    	   floppy drive.
    
    re .3  Thanks for the technical insight, Randy.  This is exactly the
    	   sort of thing that I was looking for.
    
    Of course, whatever I decide to do will depend on what kind of settle-
    ment I get from my insurance company.  Also, availability and price
    will play a role in my decision.  Overall, though, I find that I am
    not quite as anxious to be on the "bleeding edge of technology" as I
    was 5 years ago, so I am leaning toward getting a replacement 2000.
    
    Dave