T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
391.1 | Issue #100 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:40 | 726 |
391.2 | Issue #101 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:42 | 577 |
391.3 | Issue #102 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:44 | 698 |
391.4 | Issue #103 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:45 | 575 |
391.5 | Issue #104 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:46 | 547 |
391.6 | Issue #105 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:47 | 570 |
391.7 | Issue #106 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 13 1992 18:49 | 629 |
391.8 | Issue #107 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Feb 20 1992 13:04 | 654 |
391.9 | Issue #108 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Feb 25 1992 16:10 | 598 |
391.10 | Issue #109 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 03 1992 09:16 | 532 |
391.11 | Issue #110 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 10 1992 10:32 | 613 |
391.12 | Issue #111 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 17 1992 09:44 | 639 |
391.13 | Issue #112 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 24 1992 07:49 | 569 |
391.14 | Issue #113 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Mar 30 1992 08:50 | 553 |
391.15 | Issue #114 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Apr 02 1992 08:44 | 543 |
391.16 | Issue #115 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 07 1992 10:51 | 590 |
391.17 | Issue #116 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Apr 08 1992 09:40 | 450 |
391.18 | Issue #117 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Apr 08 1992 09:41 | 541 |
391.19 | Issue #118 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Apr 08 1992 09:42 | 523 |
391.20 | Issue #119 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 14 1992 08:36 | 532 |
391.21 | Issue #120 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 21 1992 09:17 | 533 |
391.22 | Issue #121 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 28 1992 08:16 | 608 |
391.23 | Issue #122 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Sun May 10 1992 23:58 | 561 |
391.24 | Issue #123 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue May 12 1992 09:02 | 602 |
391.25 | Issue #124 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue May 19 1992 10:31 | 614 |
391.26 | Issue #125 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Fri May 29 1992 07:30 | 580 |
391.27 | Issue #126 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 02 1992 09:35 | 571 |
391.28 | Issue #127 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 09 1992 08:32 | 669 |
391.29 | Issue #128 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 16 1992 10:26 | 599 |
391.30 | Issue #129 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Fri Jun 19 1992 10:32 | 603 |
391.31 | Issue #130 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 23 1992 08:46 | 611 |
391.32 | Issue #131 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Jun 25 1992 10:30 | 673 |
391.33 | Issue #132 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Jul 08 1992 12:51 | 616 |
391.34 | Issue #133 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jul 14 1992 22:24 | 682 |
391.35 | Issue #134 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Sun Jul 26 1992 15:50 | 581 |
391.36 | Issue #135 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Aug 03 1992 01:36 | 601 |
391.37 | Issue #136 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Aug 03 1992 01:57 | 543 |
391.38 | Issue #137 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 11 1992 10:29 | 614 |
391.39 | Issue #138 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Aug 19 1992 18:05 | 567 |
391.40 | Issue #139 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 25 1992 10:46 | 554 |
391.41 | Issue #140 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Sep 01 1992 09:45 | 561 |
391.42 | Issue #141 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Sep 09 1992 22:40 | 594 |
391.43 | Issue #142 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Sep 15 1992 08:59 | 598 |
391.44 | Issue #143 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Sep 23 1992 08:41 | 627 |
391.45 | Issue #144 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Sep 29 1992 14:47 | 577 |
391.46 | Issue #145 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 06 1992 09:02 | 620 |
391.47 | Issue #146 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 13 1992 18:12 | 613 |
391.48 | Issue #147 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 20 1992 11:04 | 533 |
391.49 | Issue #148 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Thu Oct 22 1992 10:25 | 581 |
391.50 | Issue #149 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 27 1992 07:23 | 564 |
391.51 | Issue #150 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 03 1992 08:36 | 615 |
391.52 | Issue #151 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 10 1992 09:32 | 680 |
391.53 | Issue #152 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 17 1992 20:46 | 594 |
391.54 | Issue #153 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Nov 23 1992 16:05 | 594 |
391.55 | Issue #154 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Dec 01 1992 09:30 | 568 |
391.56 | Issue #155 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Dec 08 1992 07:17 | 632 |
391.57 | Issue #156 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Dec 16 1992 06:59 | 628 |
391.58 | Issue #157 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jan 05 1993 15:52 | 674 |
391.59 | Issue #158 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Jan 13 1993 09:57 | 616 |
391.60 | Issue #159 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jan 19 1993 09:36 | 612 |
391.61 | Issue #160 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jan 26 1993 07:04 | 609 |
391.62 | Issue #161 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Feb 02 1993 08:27 | 624 |
391.63 | Issue #162 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Feb 09 1993 11:41 | 597 |
391.64 | Issue #163 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Feb 15 1993 09:39 | 475 |
391.65 | Issue #164 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Feb 16 1993 11:57 | 603 |
391.66 | Issue #165 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Feb 23 1993 11:50 | 620 |
391.67 | Issue #166 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 02 1993 06:53 | 604 |
391.68 | Issue #167 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 09 1993 09:02 | 605 |
391.69 | Issue #168 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 16 1993 09:10 | 598 |
391.70 | Issue #169 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Mar 23 1993 10:00 | 632 |
391.71 | Issue #170 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Mar 31 1993 08:26 | 646 |
391.72 | Issue #171 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 06 1993 08:36 | 595 |
391.73 | Issue #172 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 13 1993 13:14 | 585 |
391.74 | Issue #173 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 20 1993 08:43 | 621 |
391.75 | Issue #174 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Apr 27 1993 13:00 | 585 |
391.76 | Issue #175 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed May 05 1993 22:24 | 615 |
391.77 | Issue #176 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue May 11 1993 07:48 | 624 |
391.78 | Issue #177 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue May 18 1993 14:35 | 576 |
391.79 | Issue #178 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 01 1993 08:25 | 604 |
391.80 | Issue #179 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 08 1993 14:39 | 624 |
391.81 | Issue #180 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 15 1993 08:36 | 558 |
391.82 | Issue #181 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 22 1993 23:06 | 591 |
391.83 | Issue #182 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jun 29 1993 08:08 | 575 |
391.84 | Issue #183 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Jul 07 1993 08:26 | 568 |
391.85 | Issue #184 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jul 13 1993 08:37 | 562 |
391.86 | Issue #185 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jul 20 1993 10:57 | 604 |
391.87 | Issue #186 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Jul 27 1993 08:10 | 627 |
391.88 | Issue #187 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Sun Aug 01 1993 20:48 | 605 |
391.89 | Issue #188 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 10 1993 00:48 | 596 |
391.90 | Issue #189 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 17 1993 07:42 | 580 |
391.91 | Issue #190 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 24 1993 07:53 | 591 |
391.92 | Issue #191 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Aug 31 1993 08:37 | 555 |
391.93 | Issue #192 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Sep 08 1993 09:20 | 610 |
391.94 | Issue #193 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Sun Sep 19 1993 19:34 | 618 |
391.95 | Issue #194 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Wed Sep 22 1993 10:13 | 570 |
391.96 | Issue #195 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Sep 28 1993 05:47 | 614 |
391.97 | Issue #196 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 05 1993 05:39 | 642 |
391.98 | Issue #197 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 12 1993 08:17 | 617 |
391.99 | Issue #198 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 19 1993 07:32 | 590 |
391.100 | Issue #199 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Oct 26 1993 06:14 | 575 |
391.102 | Issue #200 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 02 1993 04:25 | 586 |
391.103 | Issue #201 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 09 1993 05:00 | 597 |
391.104 | Issue #202 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Mon Nov 15 1993 09:13 | 582 |
391.105 | Issue #203 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 23 1993 04:57 | 581 |
391.106 | Issue #204 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Nov 30 1993 08:30 | 613 |
391.107 | Issue #205 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Dec 07 1993 04:57 | 605 |
391.108 | Issue #206 | HANNAH::ALFRED | I'd rather be flying N4381Q | Tue Dec 14 1993 04:55 | 600 |
391.109 | Issue #207 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jan 04 1994 16:50 | 638 |
391.110 | Issue #208 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jan 11 1994 06:15 | 583 |
391.111 | Issue #209 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jan 18 1994 10:02 | 655 |
391.112 | Issue #210 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jan 25 1994 09:52 | 621 |
391.113 | Issue #211 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Feb 01 1994 08:48 | 627 |
391.114 | Issue #212 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Feb 08 1994 04:00 | 566 |
391.116 | Issue #214 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Feb 22 1994 08:39 | 672 |
391.115 | Issue #213 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Feb 22 1994 14:23 | 617 |
391.117 | Issue #215 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Mar 01 1994 06:01 | 645 |
391.118 | Issue #216 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Mar 08 1994 06:03 | 629 |
391.119 | Issue #217 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Mar 15 1994 06:03 | 646 |
391.120 | Issue #218 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Mar 22 1994 07:00 | 591 |
391.121 | Issue #219 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Mar 29 1994 07:00 | 574 |
391.122 | Issue #220 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Sun Apr 10 1994 01:51 | 603 |
391.123 | Issue #221 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Apr 12 1994 08:21 | 639 |
391.124 | Issue #222 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Apr 19 1994 07:02 | 578 |
391.125 | Issue #223 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Apr 26 1994 07:01 | 696 |
391.126 | Issue #224 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue May 03 1994 07:00 | 662 |
391.127 | Issue #225 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue May 10 1994 04:00 | 619 |
391.128 | Issue #226 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue May 17 1994 07:00 | 614 |
391.129 | Issue #227 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue May 24 1994 23:10 | 593 |
391.130 | Issue #228 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue May 31 1994 02:00 | 638 |
391.131 | Issue #229 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jun 07 1994 01:59 | 617 |
391.132 | Issue #230 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jun 14 1994 07:01 | 553 |
391.133 | Issue #231 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jun 21 1994 04:01 | 619 |
391.134 | Issue #232 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm Eng. | Tue Jun 28 1994 05:01 | 608 |
391.135 | Issue #233 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Wed Jul 06 1994 13:15 | 608 |
391.136 | Issue #234 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jul 12 1994 08:01 | 621 |
391.137 | Issue #235 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jul 19 1994 19:03 | 592 |
391.138 | Issue #236 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Wed Jul 27 1994 12:10 | 621 |
391.139 | Issue #237 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Aug 02 1994 07:01 | 579 |
391.140 | Issue #238 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Aug 09 1994 07:43 | 616 |
391.141 | Issue #239 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Aug 16 1994 07:01 | 622 |
391.142 | Issue #240 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Aug 23 1994 07:01 | 607 |
391.143 | Issue #241 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Aug 30 1994 05:00 | 613 |
391.144 | Issue #242 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Sep 06 1994 08:00 | 630 |
391.145 | Issue #243 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Sep 13 1994 07:00 | 634 |
391.146 | Issue #244 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Mon Sep 19 1994 22:59 | 601 |
391.147 | Issue #245 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Sep 27 1994 07:00 | 604 |
391.148 | Issue #246 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Oct 04 1994 08:01 | 585 |
391.149 | Issue #247 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Oct 11 1994 07:01 | 656 |
391.150 | Issue #248 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Oct 18 1994 05:01 | 601 |
391.151 | Issue #249 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Oct 25 1994 04:01 | 634 |
391.152 | Issue #250 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Sun Oct 30 1994 16:27 | 604 |
391.153 | Issue #251 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Nov 08 1994 06:51 | 612 |
391.154 | Issue #252 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Nov 15 1994 15:09 | 599 |
391.155 | Issue #253 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Nov 22 1994 03:59 | 650 |
391.156 | Issue #254 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Nov 29 1994 03:01 | 585 |
391.157 | Issue #255 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Dec 06 1994 06:01 | 611 |
391.158 | Issue #256 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Dec 13 1994 04:01 | 619 |
391.159 | Issue #257 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jan 03 1995 03:01 | 608 |
391.160 | Issue #258 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jan 10 1995 06:00 | 599 |
391.161 | Issue #259 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jan 17 1995 07:52 | 627 |
391.162 | Issue #260 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jan 24 1995 01:01 | 630 |
391.163 | Issue #261 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Jan 31 1995 08:15 | 647 |
391.164 | Issue #262 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Feb 07 1995 02:01 | 656 |
391.165 | Issue #263 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Feb 14 1995 03:02 | 601 |
391.166 | Issue #264 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Feb 21 1995 04:03 | 619 |
391.167 | Issue #266 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Wed Mar 08 1995 06:45 | 603 |
391.168 | Issue #267 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Mar 14 1995 03:03 | 627 |
391.169 | Issue #268 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Mar 21 1995 00:02 | 616 |
391.170 | Issue #269 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Mar 28 1995 01:16 | 590 |
391.171 | Issue #270 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Sun Apr 02 1995 20:19 | 642 |
391.172 | Issue #271 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Apr 04 1995 04:01 | 601 |
391.173 | Issue #272 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Apr 11 1995 02:01 | 568 |
391.174 | Issue #273 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Apr 18 1995 05:01 | 591 |
391.175 | Issue #274 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue Apr 25 1995 02:01 | 609 |
391.176 | Issue #275 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue May 02 1995 05:01 | 609 |
391.177 | Issue #276 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, DECterm | Tue May 09 1995 04:00 | 601 |
391.178 | Issue #277 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue May 16 1995 09:59 | 585 |
391.179 | Issue #278 | RAYNAL::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue May 23 1995 04:02 | 591 |
391.180 | Issue #279 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue May 30 1995 17:11 | 641 |
391.181 | Issue #280 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jun 06 1995 03:01 | 621 |
391.182 | Issue #281 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jun 13 1995 02:58 | 663 |
391.183 | Issue #282 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jun 20 1995 02:00 | 589 |
391.184 | Issue #283 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jun 27 1995 02:00 | 594 |
391.185 | Issue #284 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jul 04 1995 03:59 | 602 |
391.186 | Issue #285 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jul 11 1995 03:00 | 600 |
391.187 | Issue #286 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jul 18 1995 03:59 | 608 |
391.188 | Issue #287 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jul 25 1995 05:59 | 587 |
391.189 | Issue #288 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Aug 01 1995 05:00 | 595 |
391.190 | Issue #289 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Aug 08 1995 04:59 | 583 |
391.191 | Issue #290 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Aug 15 1995 05:57 | 600 |
391.192 | Issue #291 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Aug 22 1995 02:59 | 637 |
391.193 | Issue #292 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Aug 29 1995 03:56 | 595 |
391.194 | Issue #293 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Sep 05 1995 02:57 | 630 |
391.195 | Issue #294 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Sep 12 1995 05:58 | 634 |
391.196 | Issue #295 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Sep 19 1995 02:57 | 607 |
391.197 | Issue #296 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Sep 26 1995 04:56 | 621 |
391.198 | Issue #297 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Oct 03 1995 04:52 | 603 |
391.199 | Issue #298 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Oct 10 1995 04:58 | 607 |
391.200 | Issue #300 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Oct 24 1995 03:58 | 999 |
391.201 | Issue #301 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Oct 31 1995 04:00 | 606 |
391.202 | Issue #302 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Nov 07 1995 07:58 | 617 |
391.203 | Issue #303 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Wed Nov 15 1995 17:42 | 605 |
391.204 | Issue #304 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Nov 21 1995 04:00 | 609 |
391.205 | Issue #305 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Nov 28 1995 09:37 | 610 |
391.206 | Issue #307 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Dec 12 1995 04:00 | 641 |
391.207 | Issue #308 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Dec 19 1995 03:59 | 605 |
391.208 | Issue #309 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jan 09 1996 04:56 | 596 |
391.209 | Issue #310 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jan 16 1996 04:00 | 628 |
391.210 | Issue #311 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jan 23 1996 03:00 | 595 |
391.211 | Issue #312 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Jan 30 1996 04:02 | 599 |
391.212 | Issue #313 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Feb 06 1996 02:59 | 593 |
391.213 | Issue #314 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Feb 13 1996 17:43 | 642 |
391.214 | Issue #315 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Feb 20 1996 03:57 | 597 |
391.215 | Issue #316 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Feb 27 1996 02:57 | 585 |
391.216 | Issue #317 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Mar 05 1996 03:00 | 609 |
391.217 | Issue #318 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Mar 12 1996 03:58 | 599 |
391.218 | Issue #319 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Mar 19 1996 12:57 | 600 |
391.219 | Issue #320 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Mar 26 1996 04:59 | 589 |
391.220 | Issue #321 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Mon Apr 01 1996 09:11 | 595 |
391.221 | Issue #322 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (DECterm/VTstar) | Tue Apr 02 1996 04:00 | 609 |
391.222 | Issue #323 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (Multia Engineering) | Tue Apr 09 1996 05:15 | 594 |
391.223 | Issue #324 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe (Multia Engineering) | Tue Apr 16 1996 05:59 | 586 |
391.224 | Issue #325 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Apr 23 1996 08:57 | 625 |
391.225 | Issue #326 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Apr 30 1996 03:58 | 613 |
391.226 | Issue #327 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue May 07 1996 05:59 | 599 |
391.227 | Issue #328 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue May 14 1996 04:58 | 602 |
391.228 | Issue #329 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue May 21 1996 04:59 | 598 |
391.229 | Issue #330 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue May 28 1996 04:58 | 604 |
391.230 | Issue #331 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jun 04 1996 13:00 | 589 |
391.231 | Issue #332 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jun 11 1996 04:58 | 578 |
391.232 | Issue #333 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jun 18 1996 08:57 | 608 |
391.233 | Issue #334 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jun 25 1996 04:56 | 560 |
391.234 | Issue #335 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jul 09 1996 05:00 | 587 |
391.235 | Issue #336 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Wed Jul 17 1996 03:45 | 598 |
391.236 | Issue #337 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jul 23 1996 05:00 | 588 |
391.237 | Issue #338 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Jul 30 1996 05:00 | 552 |
391.238 | Issue #339 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Aug 06 1996 06:00 | 566 |
391.239 | Issue #340 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Wed Aug 14 1996 14:43 | 589 |
391.240 | Issue #341 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Aug 20 1996 00:59 | 591 |
391.241 | Issue #342 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Aug 27 1996 03:01 | 560 |
391.242 | Issue #343 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Sep 03 1996 07:01 | 562 |
391.243 | Issue #344 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Sep 10 1996 04:01 | 598 |
391.244 | Issue #345 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Sep 17 1996 05:01 | 595 |
391.245 | Issue #346 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Sep 24 1996 03:00 | 609 |
391.246 | Issue #347 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Oct 01 1996 03:59 | 584 |
391.247 | Issue #348 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Oct 08 1996 04:01 | 566 |
391.248 | Issue #349 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Oct 15 1996 05:01 | 595 |
391.249 | Issue #350 | HANNAH::ALFRED | Alfred von Campe, Multia Engineering | Tue Oct 22 1996 04:59 | 595 |
391.250 | Issue #351 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Nov 12 1996 09:57 | 615 |
391.251 | Issue #352 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Nov 12 1996 09:58 | 641 |
391.252 | Issue #353 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Nov 12 1996 10:01 | 609 |
391.253 | Issue #354 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Nov 19 1996 07:43 | 610 |
391.254 | Issue #355 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Nov 26 1996 08:00 | 587 |
391.255 | Issue #356 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Dec 03 1996 09:37 | 613 |
391.256 | Issue #357 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Dec 10 1996 08:36 | 597 |
391.257 | Issue #358 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Fri Dec 13 1996 07:23 | 611 |
391.258 | Issue #359 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Dec 17 1996 08:20 | 608 |
391.259 | Issue #360 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Jan 07 1997 08:47 | 603 |
391.260 | Issue #361 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Jan 14 1997 07:46 | 627 |
391.261 | Issue #362 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Jan 21 1997 11:56 | 603 |
391.262 | Issue #363 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Jan 28 1997 09:01 | 588 |
|
TidBITS#363/27-Jan-97
=====================
Apple's market share is down, but what exactly does that mean? In
this issue, we explore the seemingly random statistics about sales
of operating systems. Also this week, Geoff Duncan examines pros,
cons, and changes in Apple's brand-new Mac OS 7.6, we look back to
Macworld with some reader responses, and we note new versions of
NetPresenz and UserLand Frontier, plus a significant beta release
of Eudora.
Topics:
MailBITS/27-Jan-97
Mac OS Hardware Market Flat?
Responses to a Macworld Newbie
Apple Ships Mac OS 7.6
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-363.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#363_27-Jan-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of hard drives, tape drives, and neat SCSI accessories.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#363! <-------- NEW!
New Performa 6400/180, 16 MB RAM, includes 256K L2 cache: $1249
More info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/27-Jan-97
------------------
**Eudora Light/Pro Updated** -- Qualcomm has released version
3.0.2b7 of Eudora Light and Pro. We seldom write about beta
releases of software, thanks to the hyperactive release habits of
Internet software, but this beta fixes some potentially annoying
problems, such as an extra line when typing and most notably,
nickname file corruption, caused in at least one case by dragging
nicknames into a closed nickname file. The downloads are 1.5 MB
(for Eudora Pro) and 2 MB (for Eudora Light), and you can only
install the Eudora Pro beta if you already have Eudora Pro 3.0 or
3.0.1 installed. [ACE]
<http://www.eudora.com/mac302b.html>
**NetPresenz 4.1 Released and Discussed** -- Peter Lewis of
Stairways Software has released version 4.1 of NetPresenz , a
popular Web, FTP, and Gopher server. The main area of improvement
centers on increased stability under heavy load conditions, but
the Web server now includes enhanced CGI support, CGI
authentication, and server-side includes for creating dynamic Web
pages. You still can't beat NetPresenz's price at $10, and 4.1 is
a free upgrade for users who registered after 01-Jan-96. Users who
registered prior to that date can upgrade for $5.
<http://www.stairways.com/netpresenz/>
Stairways also announced two new mailing lists for discussing
NetPresenz and Anarchie. To subscribe, send email to either
<[email protected]> or <anarchie-
[email protected]>. Since the lists use same kind of on/off
addresses we established for managing subscriptions to TidBITS, no
commands are necessary. You can also sign up via a Web form for
these and other lists that Stairways runs. [ACE]
<http://www.stairways.com/mailinglists/>
**Not the Final Frontier** -- Frontier, from UserLand Software,
has been updated to version 4.2. A powerful, fast Mac scripting
environment, Frontier 4.2 features significantly refined Web site
management tools (including NewsPage for constantly-updating
pages), improved macro processing, live HTML editing in Frontier's
built-in outliner, support for making MCF site maps (see
TidBITS-355_), a useful suite of Finder scripts for webmasters
and authors (delivered via Leonard Rosenthol's OSA Menu), and
tight integration with WebSTAR 2.0. Frontier is still free; the
curious can get a good sense of it by studying the online
documentation. [MN]
<http://www.scripting.com/frontier/>
Mac OS Hardware Market Flat?
----------------------------
by Matt Deatherage <[email protected]>
A variety of market research firms recently released current
statistics and future predictions for the computer industry, and
the warhorse Mac OS gets mixed-to-negative marks for the future -
depending on who you ask and what you ask.
While most U.S. computer makers are expected to post fairly
healthy profits for the fourth calendar quarter of 1996, all
analysts agree that PC sales, especially in the U.S. and Europe,
are lower than expected. IBM and Hewlett Packard are expected to
do fine, being large, global, diversified companies, and Compaq is
recovering nicely from last year's bad inventory management and
weak first half. Apple, on the other hand, posted a $120 million
loss for the same quarter, but says the shortfall is almost
entirely due to lack of PowerBooks to sell and lack of U.S. buyers
for Performas.
Regarding this news, an Oppenheimer & Co. analyst told The Wall
Street Journal that Apple's operating system is "out of gas" and
that people are picking Windows over the Macintosh because there
are more Windows titles available - and further, Apple will begin
to lose ground in the education market (with no data or reasons to
back that assertion).
International Data Corporation (IDC) released early estimates for
1996 operating system shipments. The company pointed out that
Windows 95 fell short of projected units, and that "many corporate
users delayed migrating to the newer operating systems," meaning
Windows 95 and Windows NT. Not that the gains weren't spectacular
- Windows 95 was responsible for 63 percent of all worldwide OS
units in 1996, but that was still 9.3 percent less than projected.
Windows NT grew 303 percent, which was still 32 percent short of
expectations. IDC's "market observations" said "Apple clones have
yet to translate into increased market share," and "Apple must
introduce a fully multitasking operating system which is highly
compatible with its current Mac OS and recapture its technology
leadership in order to improve its position. Apple's recent
announcement of the acquisition of NeXT Software and its plans to
incorporate NeXT technology in future operating systems does not
fully address this need."
<http://www.idcresearch.com/HNR/pcopso.htm>
Given all this negativity in IDC's report, how bad were Mac OS
sales actually? Down from 6.8 percent to 6.6 percent of all units
shipped. Compare this to OS/2, which lost nearly half its market
share in the same period.
**Mac OS Market Share** -- Part of the problem is conflicting
definitions. Most of the doom-and-gloom reports in the media about
falling market share refer specifically to Apple Computer. Since
1995, that doesn't tell the story of the Mac OS market, because
companies other than Apple now sell Mac OS computers. But since
that's a recent development, there's a real tendency to think that
Macintosh market share and Mac OS market share are the same thing.
They aren't.
Market share, for the uninitiated, is the percentage of all new
sales in a given category that belong to one particular company.
To be technically correct, market share must be measured in a
given time period, but it's usually referred to in the present
tense as an estimate of what a company's sales are compared to its
competitors right now. IDC's report said that 6.6 percent of all
personal computer operating system sales in 1996 were Mac OS
purchases, down from 6.8 percent in 1995. It's interesting to note
that this figure does not include upgrades, only new licenses to
new computer owners - so it's a way of measuring the market share
of the hardware capable of running Mac OS.
Two-tenths of a percent decline isn't very much - by IDC's
numbers, we're talking about a drop of about 150,000 units on
yearly volume of five million. In 1995, IDC says there were 4.5
million Mac OS licenses sold, so how can five million be a
decline? The operating system market is growing, that's how! Mac
OS sales grew too, but not as fast as the other market segments
did. To stay at 6.6 percent of sales, Mac OS shipments should have
reached 5.15 million. They didn't, hence the drop in market share
concurrent with a growth in overall sales.
As long as IDC's statistical certainty is greater than 0.2 percent
(and it probably is, although it's not a given), Mac OS sales were
statistically flat in 1996. Yet press reports, and Apple Computer
itself, continually refer to declining sales, not flat or slower-
growth sales.
**Send In the Clones** -- Mac OS clone makers account for some of
the gains, and most likely for some of the lost sales Apple
experienced. A NEWS.COM story looked at the big four clone makers
- Daystar Digital, Motorola, Power Computing, and UMAX - to find
out what makes each of them tick. As part of the report, NEWS.COM
says that IDC's competitor, Dataquest, estimates that Mac OS
clones comprised 8.5 percent of U.S. Macintosh market share during
the third quarter of 1996.
<http://www.news.com/SpecialFeatures/0,5,6931,00.html>
Dataquest's number isn't valid for the entire year, obviously, but
it makes things more interesting. If Apple's U.S. market share in
the fourth quarter was about 7.3 percent, as has been estimated by
one source, then adding other Mac OS sales to the mix raises
overall Mac OS market share to 7.9 percent. That's still far short
of the 13.2 percent Apple had a year earlier, but few people can
be blamed, in the current press climate, for being skittish about
buying a Mac. The total market share is probably higher than 7.9
percent - I cheated and applied third-quarter clone numbers to
fourth-quarter Apple numbers. Clone numbers were likely to be
higher in the last quarter due to the arrival of machines from
Motorola (and APS), which do not seem to have cannibalized other
Mac OS purchases.
Motorola is known to have shipped at least 40,000 StarMax clones
in its first eight weeks of production, and a Motorola marketing
executive told NEWS.COM that the company "suspects" a quarter of
the buyers are first-time Mac OS purchasers. Motorola is staying
out of the retail market so far because they initially got a late
start, but now they don't have the facilities to handle the volume
of sales they expect a retail unit would generate.
UMAX, on the other hand, shipped 100,000 units in the last six
months of 1996 - numbers for Power Computing aren't available but
could, according to a previous Tim Bajarin estimate, top 500,000
units in 1996. DayStar Digital's numbers are smaller, in the
3,000-unit area, because they make high-end systems with fat
profit margins - the four-processor 200 MHz 604e box is for a
specialized market, especially at $10,000 apiece.
[Note: Apple just released some additional information on clone
sales, giving Power Computing credit for more than 100,000 sales
during its first year. -Adam]
<http://www.devworld.apple.com/devnews/devnews012797.html>
Both UMAX and Motorola believe they can achieve 10 percent of the
Mac OS market by the year 2000. This is good news for Apple if and
only if they achieve this by expanding the Mac OS market. UMAX in
particular is committed to this - with a parent company located in
Taiwan, UMAX believes that Asian markets are right for Mac OS
technology, and they're in on the ground floor. The company told
NEWS.COM they expect to increase Mac OS sales in Taiwan by 300
percent, and by even more in areas like Southeast Asia and parts
of China. That's exactly what Apple needs to hear, and if all
clone makers pull off similar market expansions, it will have been
worth weathering the early years of cloning when clone sales are
eating away at Apple's own market share.
**What Does It Mean?** What no market research firm has yet
released are continuing studies where Mac OS market share is
tracked, on a hardware level, separately from Macintosh (Apple
Computer's) market share. When OS sales are used as a benchmark,
IDC's numbers show nearly no change in market share from 1995 to
1996, despite the absolute beating Apple took in the press and in
consumer confidence, month after month. That's a reasonably worthy
achievement. IDC phrases it as "Mac OS clones have yet to increase
market share," but given that everyone believed Mac OS market
share was falling, it's not bad at all.
It's also a good idea to remember that the non-Mac OS market is
not unified. According to the eighth Computer Industry Almanac,
there are about 25 million Macintosh machines out there as of Q3
1996 (Apple says 26 million), about 180 million DOS users, 130
million Windows 3.x users and 53 million users of Windows 95/NT.
Each of these operating systems has a slightly different
programmer interface - code written for Windows 3.x will run in a
kind of emulation under Windows NT, but the reverse isn't true. If
Apple's plans (depending on who you ask) to release Rhapsody for
non-PowerPC hardware pan out, developers could find themselves
with an easy way to write a Mac OS program and have it available
on all these newer Windows machines as well. That would
undoubtedly bring more developers to the Mac OS platform, and more
software for Mac OS means more sales, according to IDC's theories.
Clearly Apple has to get their act in gear - without a good Mac OS
to license, clone sales will eventually fall by the wayside no
matter how aggressive the offerings are. Individual Mac OS clone
makers are too small to show on the market research radar scope,
so stories tend to focus on Apple - whose losses for the fourth
quarter resulted from a combination of tepid marketing, less shelf
space, overall lower-than-expected PC sales, and a crisis in
consumer confidence. Yet the clone makers are here, and are doing
well (Power Computing turned a profit in its first full quarter),
and it shows in the sales numbers, although you sometimes must dig
a little to find the not-bad news.
[This article is reprinted and updated with permission from MDJ, a
daily Macintosh publication covering news, products, and events in
the Macintosh world. If you can't get enough insightful Mac news,
sign up for a trial subscription to MDJ. For TidBITS readers who
want to subscribe, there's a special limited-time rate of $11.95
per month (20 percent off). For more information, visit the MDJ
Web site.]
<http://www.gcsf.com/tidbits.html>
Responses to a Macworld Newbie
------------------------------
by Jeff Carlson <[email protected]>
Tuesday was a good email day. After running "Impressions of a
Macworld Newbie" article in TidBITS-362_ (my first TidBITS
article), I received a steady stream of comments and words of
welcome from readers around the world.
In particular, several people commented on my advice that new
attendees refrain from picking up every freebie in sight, and
others reacted to my mention of Steve Jobs's "Reality Distortion
Field."
**Suzanne Courteau** <[email protected]> writes:
First, I left my press bag at my office. In my jacket pocket I
carried pens and business cards. When I ran across a truly fab
product, it was easy enough to write a note on a business card
asking the product manager or PR manager to send it to me at my
office. I got all my information delivered to me and suffered
absolutely no back or feet problems.
**Adam L. Pollock** <[email protected]> takes a decidedly cumbersome
approach:
As far as picking up every pen, CD, disk, etc., this was certainly
my goal. I was also hunting for t-shirts - at the end of the show
I ran around asking for freebies and trades and amassed about
twelve!
**Jack C. Kobzeff** <[email protected]> observes:
I felt that Jobs's Reality Distortion Field was only running at
half strength this time. I saw him in the early Mac days and as
NeXT was getting started, and back then he could sell snow to
Eskimos. He was incredible during the NeXT presentations, getting
suit-and-tie executives excited about a box with no applications
and no floppy disk. This time, I'm not sure if he's just older,
too rich, or doesn't quite have his heart into the Apple deal, but
he didn't have quite the same level of RDF. It was there; just
weaker.
Apple Ships Mac OS 7.6
----------------------
by Geoff Duncan <[email protected]>
Today, Apple shipped Mac OS 7.6, an all-encompassing system
software release that includes a few new features, a significant
set of changes under the hood, and a collection of Apple
technologies that were previously available for free. Mac OS 7.6
is not free and is not available for downloading. At over 120 MB
for the CD-ROM version, that's probably good.
<http://www.macos.apple.com/macos/releases.html>
Mac OS 7.6 provides a much-needed baseline for system software.
Prior to 7.6, installing the latest version of the Mac OS could be
an arduous task, involving two or three system software
installations, plus installations for technologies like OpenDoc
and Open Transport. Mac OS 7.6 eliminates many of these steps and
helps minimize confusion over various flavors of System 7.5.
Furthermore, Apple actually did what it promised: shipped an
update to the Mac OS in January of 1997.
On the down side, enthusiasm for Mac OS 7.6 has been
underwhelming, largely due to the lack of new gee-whiz features
Apple has been promising for years. Mac OS 7.6 does not include a
multi-threaded, PowerPC-native Finder, a fast, full-text search
engine, active assistance, the fabled Appearance Manager (which
provides highly-customizable desktop themes), or integrated Java
support. All these features are now candidates for Tempo, the next
update, which Apple has scheduled for July of 1997.
**Installing Mac OS 7.6** -- One of Mac OS 7.6's new features is
Install Mac OS, an umbrella installer for both the core operating
system and add-ons like OpenDoc, Cyberdog, and QuickDraw GX.
Install Mac OS has been heralded as a new installer, but it's
really a shell program that controls installers for individual
components. Thankfully, Install Mac OS notifies users to update
their hard disk drivers when installing software (a common problem
Apple previously covered in ReadMe files, which people usually
only examine after they've had trouble), and runs Disk First Aid
before attempting to install any system software. Install Mac OS
also enables users to create a brand new System Folder or to
update an existing system, a previously hidden function.
However, Install Mac OS can also be confusing. When you've told it
what you want to install, it proceeds to launch old-style
installers for components, which again ask what you want to do.
So, if you choose to install Mac OS 7.6, OpenDoc, and QuickDraw
3D, you're first presented with the Mac OS 7.6 installer, then the
OpenDoc installer, and finally the QuickDraw 3D installer. By the
time you reach the second installer, you may have forgotten how
you got there or what's coming next.
Apple has changed individual installer applications too, most
notably the Mac OS 7.6 custom install, which now groups components
in functional categories (such as Mobility, Multimedia, and
Assistance) in addition to categories like Control Panels and
Extensions. Unfortunately, this means that individual items (such
as PC Exchange) appear in more than one section, and selecting an
item in one category doesn't select it the others, creating
confusion as to whether something will be installed.
**What's Included** -- In addition to the core system software,
Mac OS 7.6 ships with QuickTime 2.5, OpenDoc 1.1.2, Cyberdog
1.2.1, QuickDraw 3D 1.0.6, QuickDraw GX 1.1.5, MacLink Plus 8.1
(from DataViz), Open Transport 1.1.1, Open Transport/PPP 1.0,
Remote Access Client 2.1, and version 1.2 of the Apple Internet
Connection Kit.
You may note Mac OS 7.6 isn't shipping with QuickDraw 3D 1.5 and
Open Transport 1.1.2. Why not? The simple answer is scheduling:
coordinating over 100 MB of material from (literally) dozens of
different product groups within Apple is no simple thing. Apple
probably set absolute deadlines for product units in order to make
Mac OS 7.6 ship on time. This is in keeping with Apple's
incremental update policy, where individual technologies - like
Cyberdog, Open Transport, and QuickTime - will be upgraded
separately between major releases of the Mac OS for users who need
the latest versions as soon as possible.
However, this situation can create hassles for users who try to
keep up with Apple technologies. If you've already installed Open
Transport 1.1.2, the Mac OS 7.6 installer will complain
(repeatedly) that you're replacing a newer version of Open
Transport. If you want to use Open Transport 1.1.2, you must
reinstall it after installing Mac OS 7.6. Classic networking isn't
supported under Mac OS 7.6, so you must use Open Transport. Though
these problems primarily affect users knowledgeable enough to
understand the situation - power users, programmers, and Mac
loyalists - it isn't making Apple many friends.
**What's New** -- Aside from the new installer, Mac OS 7.6
includes Extensions Manager 4.0, a significant improvement over
earlier versions. In addition to enabling users to manage system
extensions and extension sets, Extensions Manager 4.0 also
features an updated interface (with sorting capabilities) plus the
ability to view extensions as a flat set, by folder, or by
package. The latter is particularly useful, since it enables users
to identify and turn on or off all related parts of a complex set,
like Now Utilities or OpenDoc. Software vendors may need to update
their system extensions to identify what package they belong to,
but a surprising number of system components already have this
information. Extensions Manager 4.0 doesn't track down extension
conflicts like Casady & Greene's Conflict Catcher, but it can
export a detailed text file listing your extension configuration.
Mac OS 7.6 also includes a few new convenience items, such as
Desktop Printing 2.0.2, which lets you move desktop printers off
the desktop into folders. You can also switch between desktop
printers using a new control strip module and within the Print
dialog box (although I'm not sure if the latter requires
LaserWriter 8.4). Also, tucked away in the Speech Control Panel is
a feature called Talking Alerts, which enables text-to-speech
software to read the text of onscreen alerts after a user-defined
period of time - a potentially handy feature for the visually
impaired or for people who need to have their Macs shout to them
from across the room. Unfortunately, Talking Alerts only functions
on modal alert messages.
Also, the classic FKEY (PictWhap) that enabled you to take
snapshots of your Macintosh screen has been updated. Command-
Shift-4 no longer sends a screen capture to a printer: now, the
key combination lets you select a portion of your screen to be
saved as a file; further, if Caps Lock is down, the cursor changes
to a bull's-eye and you can take a screen shot of just about any
window you can click. Pressing Command-Shift-3 still causes your
Mac to take a picture of your entire screen, but (with either key
combination) pressing Control puts the picture into the clipboard
instead of in a file on the top level of your startup drive. These
features don't compete with screen shot utilities like Nobu Toge's
venerable shareware Flash-It, but they'll be a boon to tech
writers everywhere.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/gst/grf/flash-it-302.hqx>
There are also a number of low-level changes in Mac OS 7.6.
PowerPC and 68040 Macs can now support volume sizes up to two
terabytes, many earlier updates and system extensions have been
rolled into the system file, Apple events can now carry more than
64K of data, and improvements throughout the system significantly
enhance stability. Two memory management changes are noteworthy:
first, 24-bit machines (the Mac II, IIx, SE/30, and IIcx) that
previously used Connectix's MODE32 aren't supported under Mac OS
7.6. Similarly, machines with a 68000 or 68020 processor are no
longer supported, including the Plus, SE, Classic, Portable, LC,
and PowerBook 100. Also, PowerPC-based Macs can only run the
Modern Memory Manager under Mac OS 7.6: support for the old 68K
Memory Manager is no longer available.
Users will also notice that references to Macintosh are being
changed to Mac OS, and the familiar About this Macintosh item in
the Finder now reads About this Computer. Similarly, the much-
loved Welcome to Macintosh display that appears when a machine
first starts up has been suppressed in favor of a more modern (and
more generic) Mac OS logo.
**What's Missing** -- Mac OS 7.6 does not include Mac OS Runtime
for Java (MRJ), something Apple promised when it announced its
biannual update plan. Apple just completed MRJ 1.0 for PowerPC; a
version for 68K-based machines is promised shortly.
<http://www.applejava.apple.com/>
Mac OS 7.6 no longer supports PowerTalk, Apple's pioneering but
now-defunct email and workgroup software. If you need PowerTalk's
capabilities, you have little choice but to stick to your current
system software. Programmers and power users should also note that
Mac OS 7.6 requires MacsBug 6.5.4, which is not yet publicly
available.
The most significant missing element of Mac OS 7.6 is support for
CFM-68K. The CFM-68K extension is required on 68K Macs in order to
run a smattering of current applications including: OpenDoc,
Cyberdog, LaserWriter 8.4, Apple Media Tool, AOL 3.0, and Internet
Explorer 3.0. Apple recently discovered a serious bug in CFM-68K,
and recommends that owners of 68K Macs disable it (see
TidBITS-356_.). Mac OS 7.6 removes even the option of running
CFM-68K for risk takers who want to run CFM-68K-dependent
software. Fortunately, there are workarounds for developers to
test CFM-68K under Mac OS 7.6, and a patch may be available soon
(two potential fixes are currently being tested by Apple).
**Availability** -- You can purchase Mac OS 7.6 directly from
Claris, and it should be available in traditional channels
(including mail-order and online vendors) shortly. From Claris,
Mac OS 7.6 costs $99 on CD-ROM, and $129 on floppy disks. If you
can prove you purchased a version of System 7.5 (either on its own
or with a computer), you can upgrade for $69, or $99 on floppy. If
you recently bought a Mac that didn't ship with 7.6, you may
qualify for a $24 upgrade through Apple's Mac OS Up-To-Date
program (details at the URL below). None of these prices includes
shipping, handling, and tax: a typical $69 CD-ROM upgrade from
Claris will total more than $80.
<http://www.macos.apple.com/macos/releases/fulfillment.html>
At this time, we have no information about the availability of
localized versions of Mac OS 7.6.
**Should You Buy Mac OS 7.6?** Mac OS 7.6 would be more appealing
at a lower price - Apple would do well to re-examine discounted
upgrade pricing (or possibly subscription-based pricing aimed at
non-corporate users). If you own a Power Macintosh and like to
keep up with cutting-edge applications, Mac OS 7.6 could be
beneficial. If you're happy with your current setup or own a 68K
Mac, Mac OS 7.6 is much less compelling, and you may wish to wait
for Tempo to ship in July. If you manage a lab or set of Macs,
however, System 7.6's all-encompassing installer should prove to
be a real time-saver.
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.263 | Issue #364 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Feb 04 1997 07:53 | 620 |
|
TidBITS#364/03-Feb-97
=====================
Is text dead? Not at all! In this issue, we look at Palimpsest, a
tool for managing large volumes of text; CopyPaste, a multiple
clipboard utility; and Natural Order, an extension that (finally!)
sorts text and file names like a person would. Also in this issue,
readers respond to the new crop of HTML editors, Speed Doubler
gets an important update for Mac OS 7.6, Be stops making the
BeBox, and Apple announces major internal changes, price cuts, and
a Rhapsody kernel.
Topics:
MailBITS/03-Feb-97
HTMLbits: Following up on Free Placement
The Natural Order of Things
CopyPaste: A Scoffer No More
Palimpsest 1.1 - Is There a Document in the House?
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-364.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#364_03-Feb-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of hard drives, tape drives, and neat SCSI accessories.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#364! <--------- NEW!
Factory refurbished 8500/120, 48MB/2GB/4xCD, keyboard: $1779
More info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/03-Feb-97
------------------
**Apple Price Cuts** -- Last week, Apple announced it had lowered
dealer prices as much as 27 percent on a wide range of
Macintoshes. The largest cuts appear in the mid-to-high end of
Apple's desktop Power Macintosh line, with prices reduced as much
as $1,000 on Power Mac 8500 and 9500 models; also, the high end of
the Performa 6400-series has been discounted 15 to 18 percent, and
Apple's Workgroup Server 7250 and 8550 series are discounted 7 to
13 percent. Apple is no doubt attempting to boost sales volume
after an unspectacular holiday season and clear inventory in
anticipation of new models to be announced later this month. [GD]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970131.pr.rel.price.html>
**Apple Layoffs and Reorganization** -- It's been just over a year
since Apple's last reorganization and major round of layoffs, but
Apple is expected to announce another sweeping set of changes
intended to further focus its business model and cut operating
costs by 25 percent. According to reports, Apple plans to organize
around three major markets (publishing, education, and the
Internet), sell off some key assets (including Pippin and possibly
the Newton division), and lay off 2,000 to 3,000 employees this
year. In January, Apple said it would announce restructuring plans
aimed at cutting some $400 million in costs. After losing about
$900 million during the last year, analysts generally agree Apple
must reduce its operating costs to hope to return to
profitability. Bandai says it will continue to upgrade the Pippin
platform and introduce it to new retail markets in 1997. [GD]
**Mach Speed** -- In a letter to developers last week, Apple's
Chief Technology Officer Ellen Hancock announced that Apple has
decided to use the Mach kernel as the foundation for Rhapsody,
although no other details were given, including which version of
Mach Apple plans to use. OpenStep is targeted at the Mach 3
kernel, whereas NeXTstep uses a variant of Mach 2.5. Presumably,
Apple chose Mach in order to bring Rhapsody to market more
quickly.
<http://devworld.apple.com/>
The Mach kernel was originally developed at Carnegie Mellon
University, and is currently used by many environments, including
IBM's AIX, Apple's MkLinux project, and Tenon Systems' MachTen
Unix environment for the Mac. Though most operating systems using
Mach have been based on Unix, that doesn't necessarily mean
Rhapsody will have Unix at its heart. [GD]
<http://www.mklinux.apple.com/>
<http://www.tenon.com/>
**Speed Bump for Speed Doubler Users** -- Connectix has identified
potentially serious problems with using Speed Doubler and Apple's
Find File under the new Mac OS 7.6. Problems range from innocuous
ones like Find File not displaying information to scary ones like
disk catalog errors. Last Friday, Connectix released the Speed
Doubler 2.0.1 Updater, which corrects the problem for 2.0 users.
Speed Doubler 1.x users should be able to update to version 1.3.2
in the very near future; Connectix may have posted the 1.3.2
Updater by the time you read this text. These releases are both
U.S. versions; Connectix plans to release localized versions soon.
Connectix -- 800/839-3632 -- 415/571-5100 -- 415/571-5195 (fax) --
<[email protected]> [TJE]
<http://www.connectix.com/connect/upda.spee.html>
**No More Be Hardware** -- Industry darling Be, Inc. announced
last week it will stop making its own hardware line - the BeBox -
and focus purely on developing the BeOS for PowerPC-based
Macintosh computers. Be points out (rightly) that it's difficult
for a 50-person company to design hardware and an operating
system, and the lion's share of their target user and developer
markets are already using Power Mac hardware. Be promises to
support current BeBoxes for at least the next three years. [GD]
<http://www.be.com/developers/hardwareplans.html>
**Updated QuickMail Pro** -- CE Software recently announced the
release of QuickMail Pro 1.0.1, which fixes several bugs and
improves a few features in the company's POP3 email client. An
updater for Macintosh users is available at the company's Web
site, and CE expects to release an updater for Windows later in
February. [MHA]
<http://www.cesoft.com/quickmail/qmpupdate.html>
**Rev Now Has Online Ordering** -- The folks at 6prime wrote to
say that they were inundated with orders for Rev after my review
of their excellent revision control program in TidBITS-362_. To
better handle the volume, they've scrambled to put an order form
online at the URL below. The price remains $49.95. Shipping and
handling (and a bonus mug) is $4 for U.S. and Canadian addresses,
but if you don't need a disk or mug or are outside of the U.S. or
Canada, you can save the $4 and go for email delivery. [ACE]
<http://www.6prime.com/rev/revorder.html>
HTMLbits: Following up on Free Placement
----------------------------------------
by Tonya Engst <[email protected]>
In TidBITS-362_, I wrote about how several upcoming HTML editors
use tables or Java to offer free placement of objects. Several
readers responded with comments about problems with the Web pages
those editors are likely to produce, and with thoughts about where
this trend may take us.
**Bill Seitz **<[email protected]> noted:
Lots of pages on the Web look stupid to me because I set my
default font to Palatino 12 instead of the tiny and ugly Times 12.
Cascading Style Sheets offer some additional placement control
without resorting to tables, but still target their features to
publishers attempting exact control over the user's view. I
sometimes think these people should just make a giant JPEG for
each page and stop the pretense.
**Brad Kemper **<[email protected]> chimed in as well:
I think free placement is a disturbing trend, not because of the
code it produces (I would like not to be concerned with code at
all), but because fixed-width pages do not account for the
specific needs of people who read text onscreen. Since the first
Macs, text has automatically wrapped to fit the size of the
window. Now, thanks to programs that create Web pages with items
placed to exact pixel coordinates, we lose this capability.
Perhaps it is because we are using a page paradigm instead of
thinking of Web pages as windows or screens of information. We've
taken a huge step backwards. We should take a hint from people who
design interfaces for computer programs: good design for monitors
is different from that for print.
**Sajid Martin **<[email protected]> worried about speed,
commenting:
I think an important disadvantage could be that using tables to
configure the entire page results in much longer page rendering
times, and slows down scrolling in a browser. But, I think the
trend to make coding - including scripting - unnecessary may be
good in the long run for the end user.
The Natural Order of Things
---------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
Here's a silly question. Are the digits between one and nine
represented by a single character, or by a string of characters?
In other words, when you type the number one in a filename, do you
always prefix it with a zero? In all likelihood, a number of
people are nodding their heads and thinking, "But of course I do
that, otherwise files with numbers in the names don't sort right."
We fought with this problem with TidBITS in our early years,
because although I was clever enough to prefix my single digits
with a zero to pad them into double-digit numbers, I never
imagined that TidBITS would be around long enough to hit
TidBITS-100_, necessitating a mass renaming of the first 99 issues
to include an additional leading zero to pad everything into
triple-digit numbers. And even today, we can't imagine that we'll
be doing TidBITS long enough to need to go to quadruple-digit
numbers (although stranger things have happened).
In case you're still wondering what I'm blathering about, here's
an example. Assume you keep your own collection of TidBITS around,
but for some reason, you rename them with more natural names. You
might have the following problem with the first 12 issues when
viewing them in the Finder.
> TidBITS-1.html
> TidBITS-10.html
> TidBITS-11.html
> TidBITS-12.html
> TidBITS-2.html
> TidBITS-3.html
> TidBITS-4.html
> TidBITS-5.html
> TidBITS-6.html
> TidBITS-7.html
> TidBITS-8.html
> TidBITS-9.html
The trouble should be obvious - why do issues 10, 11, and 12 sort
before issue 2? It's because the Macintosh System is messed up,
that's why. Basically, way back when, someone at Apple decided to
implement sorting the same way that Unix, DOS, and everything else
does, by comparing one character at a time, instead of taking into
account the fact that numbers don't sort in alphabetical order the
way words do.
For years, the universal solution has been to prefix single-digit
numbers with a zero, so they sort before double-digit numbers. As
the number of digits increase, so must the number of padding
zeroes. Computers should fit the way humans work and think.
Instead, when it comes to sorting, humans must fit the way
computers work.
No longer. Stuart Cheshire <[email protected]>, author of
the popular network tank game Bolo, has released a tiny freeware
extension called Natural Order that overrides how the System sorts
numeric parts of strings. I won't repeat the example list above,
but once you install Natural Order (drop it in your Extensions
folder and reboot), issues 10, 11, and 12 would sort properly to
the bottom of the list.
Programs that benefit from Natural Order immediately include the
Finder (for "View by Name" windows), Standard File Dialogs (in any
application), and the Chooser (for sorting lists of zones,
servers, and so on). However, Natural Order works by overriding
the System's built-in string comparison routines and only benefits
programs that call those routines. A number of programs implement
their own sorting mechanisms, so those programs don't benefit from
Natural Order. A few recent programs (including Anarchie 2.0 and
Fetch 3.0.2 and later) include Natural Order's sorting routines
internally so they sort sensibly even without Natural Order
installed.
Stuart wants to hear about any programs that do not benefit from
Natural Order's sorting routines, so he can try to convince the
programmers of the benefit of making their programs call the
System's built-in string comparison routines (and thus take
advantage of Natural Order).
So, if you're bothered by the way the Mac sorts numeric strings,
give Natural Order a try. You probably won't even notice it until
you see a folder containing numbered files.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/gui/natural-order-11.hqx>
<http://rescomp.stanford.edu/~cheshire/NaturalOrder.html>
CopyPaste: A Scoffer No More
----------------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
Today I found myself in one of those situations where I had to
carry several separate pieces of information from one application
to another. I was building (in Symantec Visual Page) a Web page
composed of quotes extracted from Web pages (in Netscape
Navigator). For each quote, I needed the title and author
(displayed at the top of the page), the extract (somewhere in the
middle), and the URL (from Navigator's Location field). Now, how
many times do you think I had to switch between applications to
create each page? Wrong! For each Web page, I only had to copy the
information from Navigator and switch to Visual Page _once_ -
carrying with me the three pieces of information in _three_
separate clipboards.
In the middle of this operation I suddenly became conscious of how
wonderful it was to be able to do this, and had to stop and dash
off this praise of the extension which gives me not just three but
ten clipboards - CopyPaste 3.2.2.
Originally, I scoffed at CopyPaste, feeling about it as I once did
about drag & drop (crusty, old-timer, Gabby Hayes voice): "Why,
for years I've been cutting and pasting one thing at a time, and
it's always been good enough for me!" Besides, early versions of
CopyPaste crashed certain applications on which I rely. But
CopyPaste's compatibility has improved tremendously; and now that
I use it, I use it constantly and automatically.
The basic functionality of CopyPaste is simple to describe. You
have ten system-wide clipboards, numbered zero through nine. To
copy the current selection into clipboard 7, instead of pressing
Command-C, you press Command-C-7 - without releasing the Command
key until after you've typed the 7. The same interface applies to
both cutting and pasting, with Command-X and Command-V. Or, you
can use the Edit menu, which CopyPaste provides with hierarchical
menus leading to the ten clipboards, even showing a little snippet
of what's currently on each one.
CopyPaste provides some nice extras too. You can archive the
clipboards as files (one at a time or all at once), and you can
have clipboards automatically archived at shutdown and restored at
startup. You can copy the current selection to an append file, an
option that - for instance - works well for compiling a download
list while reading the Info-Mac Digest. And there's a windoid that
shows you the full contents of each clipboard and lets you swap
clips with one another.
Other functions do not interest me as much. There's an
application-switching shortcut I never use because it interferes
with HyperCard, and something called Tag and Drop that I don't
even understand. Plus, there are a host of clipboard-massaging
functions that basically reinvent the Clipboard Magician wheel.
Luckily, you can turn off unwanted features in a Preferences
dialog, but personally I find this "don't know when to stop" style
of programming annoying and ill-advised. What's needed is a
component approach so code for undesired functions never even
loads.
<http://www.umich.edu/~archive/mac/system.extensions/da/
clipboardmagician0.76.sit.hqx>
There are also problems caused by the fact that CopyPaste is an
undeniable hack. These troubles change from revision to revision:
partly they involve compatibility, but the main difficulty at
present is that you lose access to an application's own internal
scrap mechanism: every time you copy, even if you just press
Command-C, you copy via CopyPaste. This can be problematic for
some applications, which may switch to the Finder and back (losing
time while windows and palettes are taken down, and more time -
and perhaps information - while the contents of the clipboard are
converted away from an application's internal format). I would
much prefer Command-C just performed the application's original
default copy.
Nevertheless, the spirit of CopyPaste is commendable, and - once
you've experienced its utility - you can't fathom why it hasn't
been built into the System for years. I'd sacrifice all the touted
functional improvements of Mac OS 7.6 if only it included ten
clipboards. Meanwhile, at a shareware fee of $20, CopyPaste is a
bargain-priced way to give your machine a new soul.
<http://members.aol.com/copypaste1/index.html>
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/gui/copy-paste-322.hqx>
Palimpsest 1.1 - Is There a Document in the House?
--------------------------------------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
Readers of TidBITS know of my unabashed obsession with the storage
and retrieval of information, especially the free-form textual
information an academic must track and manipulate in order to
write lectures, books, and articles. So when a new piece of
software, Palimpsest, turned out to be created especially for
people like me, it didn't take Nostradamus to predict I'd be
intrigued. And when Palimpsest turned out to combine word-
processing elements with features of cool tools like HyperCard,
Storyspace (see TidBITS-095_), Conc, and FreeText - and written,
to top it all off, using Prograph (see TidBITS-312_) - I was
downright interested.
<http://www.umich.edu/~archive/mac/misc/linguistics/conc1.71.cpt.hqx>
<http://www.umich.edu/~archive/mac/hypercard/organization/
freetext1.03.cpt.hqx>
Palimpsest comes from Western Civilisation, an Australian company.
It started as a private way of managing thousands of pages of
legal documents; now it's released to the world for managing,
investigating, and relating electronic documents generally. (A
palimpsest is a manuscript that has been rubbed out and written
over, and no, I didn't have to look it up; I used to be a
classicist, remember?) You can learn more about Palimpsest at
their Web site, or download a demo from Info-Mac.
<http://www.westciv.com.au/>
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/text/>
**The Basic Milieu** -- You use Palimpsest to read, create,
navigate, and investigate Palimpsest documents. If your documents
aren't initially Palimpsest documents, you can create a Palimpsest
document and either paste (or drag & drop) material into it, or
import material as styled text from SimpleText.
Using Palimpsest looks and feels rather like using HyperCard. You
probably will have several windows that look like HyperCard
stacks, each consisting of one card dominated by a scrolling field
of styled, editable text. Each "stack" is actually called a
Section, and Sections are bound together behind the scenes into a
Document. Each Section can itself be subdivided by Headings.
Here's how Documents, Sections, and Headings are related:
A Heading is merely a piece of text to which you have applied the
Make Heading command. Using a floating windoid called the Heading
Browser (which displays the Headings in whatever Section is
frontmost) you can give each Heading a level, so that they appear
in a hierarchical, outline-like relationship to one another. (This
hierarchy is purely conceptual; it has no visible analogue within
the text of the Section itself.) Double-clicking a heading in the
Heading Browser jumps you to that place in the Section.
Similarly, a Table of Contents window lists the Sections of the
Document in a meaningful order, like chapters in a book. You can
change the order by dragging the Section listings, and each
Section listing can expand to show the Headings it contains.
Again, you can double-click a Section or Heading listing in the
Table of Contents to go there.
You can also navigate from Section to Section conveniently with a
pop-up menu in the lower left corner of each Section window, which
lists all Sections of the Document.
**Section Types and Document Types** -- Sections come in Types,
which are like HyperCard backgrounds: for instance, if a typical
Section of a particular Document is of the "Chapter" type, then
the physical layout of each Chapter Section is identical,
differing only in the contents of its fields. Documents come in
Types too, each consisting of the Section types it can contain. At
any time, you can alter a Document by adding a new Section of any
type which that type of Document can contain.
There are also automatic Section types: the Table of Contents is
itself a Section type, but you can't create a new one; every
document automatically contains exactly one Table of Contents, as
well as one Title Page and one Cover. You can, however, modify
these Sections - for instance, you can paste a picture on the
Cover.
A Document Type and the Section Types that constitute it form a
template instantly affecting all Documents of that type. You can
modify an existing Document type, or create a new Document type.
To do so, you draw the layout of its Section types, possibly by
modifying existing Section types to make the process faster. You
can change the size of a Section's window (its "card" size); you
can add or resize Section fields (like "card fields", their
contents are unique to each Section) or Document fields (like
"background fields", their contents are shared among all Sections
in which they appear). You can also give a field a name, a style
(e.g. scrolling or not), an initial text, initial text-style
attributes, and so on. All this can be done intuitively, as in
HyperCard or FileMaker.
**Slicing the Cake** -- What I've described thus far is a
convenient method of dividing, formatting, and navigating a
document, but it isn't all that different from what you might do
with a word processor. The interesting part comes when you start
to slice through the Document's divisions, to examine and navigate
your Document in new ways.
For example, you might do a Search on a particular word or set of
words you're interested in. The results appear as a new window
showing every matching occurrence, one per line, each with some
context around it - in effect, a customized concordance to a
Document. If you double-click a line of context, you jump to that
spot in the actual Document.
You might also create a hypertext link between two places in a
Document. Such links are documented in a Cross-Reference Details
window, showing you all links emanating from the selected text,
and letting you specify a comment, an author, and a label for each
link. So, you're not only linking to another location but
annotating and categorizing the link as well. Later, having
selected some linked passage, you can either follow the link or
open the Details window. Thus, hypertext links aren't just
navigational shortcuts; they're also discussions of your reasoning
in associating various passages.
Palimpsest also has Annotations, which are like the comments
attached to hypertext links but without linking to any other
passage. Opening a passage's Annotation window is like reading a
hidden footnote about it.
You can also get three sorts of "live" summaries of hypertext
links (by "live" I mean you click a link to jump there):
* A floating windoid called the Cross Reference Browser lists all
passages in the current section from which hypertext links
emanate. (Similarly, there is an Annotation Browser.)
* You can obtain a list of all passages at the far end of links
which emanate from the current Section or Document; this is called
a Web View.
* You can obtain a list of all links you have traversed or
examined since Palimpsest was started up; this is called Paths.
**The Big, Big Picture** -- So far, I've talked as if you work
with only one Palimpsest Document at a time. But Palimpsest is
intended to manage and relate multiple Documents. Hypertext links
can run between Documents, and searches are performed over
multiple Documents. What's more, there are two further entity
types to help you.
First, there's the Paper. A Paper is a single window with one
large scrolling text field in it, nothing more. It's meant in part
as a place to take notes while you work. A Paper can also have
Headings, hypertext links, and Annotations. The hypertext linking
lets the Paper serve also as a repository for references to
various passages in Documents, and certain special features assist
with this. For instance, you can paste a passage copied from a
Document into a Paper and have the pasted material be a hypertext
link back to the Document passage, all in a single move. And the
results of Searches, as well as Web Views and Paths, can be saved
into a Paper as hypertext links, letting you quickly assemble live
references to related material.
Second, there's the Study. A Study is a clickable list of
Documents (and Papers) with a possible brief comment on each one.
(There is also something called the Archive - there's only one -
which lists all Studies.) Studies allow you to impose upon a large
collection of Documents as many different categorizations as
desired. Again, you can translate Search results, Web Views, and
Paths into Studies to save time, and comments can help explain why
you've brought these Documents together in this configuration.
So, for example, if I were writing an article on Aeschylus'
Agamemnon, and I had all the scholarship on the subject over the
past 40 years turned into Palimpsest Documents, then I might keep
track of the scholarship in Studies - one Study listing all
articles dealing with the Anger of Artemis, another listing all
articles dealing with the Hymn to Zeus, and so on. Meanwhile, I
could write my own article as a Paper, using hypertext links to
help manage references and using the link comments to remind
myself of the relationships amongst the various referenced
passages.
**Teething Pains** -- In any software's early days there are bound
to be shortcomings, and I felt there was plenty of room for small
improvements in the version I saw. Some behaviors were slow.
Windows didn't remember their sizes and positions. Windoids
couldn't be resized, and were too small to be useful. Hypertext
link labels couldn't be edited. It was difficult to know where the
end of a hypertextually linked passage was, so you could easily
extend it accidentally. Wider import/export capabilities (using
XTND, perhaps) were needed.
However, these quibbles are minor - and temporary. Western
Civilisation is a responsive company, and fully expects to
incorporate fixes and user suggestions. A faster PowerPC-native
version has just been released, and most of the points I raise
above are slated for fixing.
Granted, Palimpsest probably doesn't do any one of its various
functions as well as a program dedicated to that function alone:
it doesn't process words as well as a real word processor, or
manage hypertext with the ease of Eastgate's Storyspace, or build
its concordances with the flexibility of Conc. The important
thing, however, is that it recognizes the need to juggle, analyze,
relate, read, and write about large numbers of electronic text
documents. Once you've seen the Search (concordance) and hypertext
tools in action, it becomes obvious how badly needed they've
always been. For $50 you get a fully working copy and free updates
for a year - a very decent price. If you think Palimpsest might
have a place in your electronic world, you owe it to yourself to
download and try the free demo.
Western Civilisation Pty. Ltd. -- +61 2 9130 1731 (Australia)
<[email protected]>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.264 | Issue #365 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Feb 11 1997 07:02 | 617 |
|
TidBITS#365/10-Feb-97
=====================
Is OpenDoc an Apple technology following in the footsteps of
PowerTalk? Component computing seems to be taking off, and Adam
looks at some real-world OpenDoc products, plus Charles Wheeler
profiles a family known for its "spokesblob." We also review Bare
Bones Software's powerful, multi-purpose text editor BBEdit 4.0.2,
note Heidi Roizen's departure from Apple, reassure Newton users,
and note a Get Rich Quick scheme for serious hackers and crackers.
Topics:
MailBITS/10-Feb-97
OpenDoc Open for Business
More About Rapid-I
BBEdit 4.0.2: Speaks Softly but Carries a Big Stick
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-365.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#365_10-Feb-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of hard drives, tape drives, and neat SCSI accessories.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#365! <--------- NEW!
Factory refurbished Performa 6320 16MB/1.2GB/15" monitor: $1179
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/10-Feb-97
------------------
**Newton News** -- In the wake of Apple's latest reorganization
and cost-cutting measures, several news sources reported that
Apple might ditch its Newton division. Understandably, reactions
among MessagePad users have ranged from confusion to outrage. On
Friday, Sandy Benett, vice president of Apple's Newton Systems
Group, released a letter to developers and users reassuring them
that the group "remains intact" amid the reorganization, and that
support for the current MessagePad 2000 and eMate 300 is
proceeding alongside development of future products. [JLC]
<http://www.newton.apple.com/newton/message_Feb.7.97.html>
**Roizen Leaves Apple** -- Heidi Roizen, Apple's vice president of
Developer Relations, has announced she'll be leaving Apple on
19-Feb-97 to commit more time to her family. During the last year,
Heidi implemented wide-ranging changes in Apple's developer
support and vastly improved communications between Apple and
software developers. Her contributions will be missed in the
developer community, and we hope Apple is able to make good on her
example. [GD]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970210.pr.rel.roizen.html>
**Eudora 3.0.2** -- Qualcomm has released final versions of both
Eudora Light and Eudora Pro 3.0.2. According to Qualcomm, these
versions fix problems with nickname file corruption, along with
problems with attachments, URL handling, and Eudora's editor. You
must own Eudora Pro in order to use the Eudora Pro updater (1.6
MB); Eudora Light remains a free product and a 2 MB download. [GD]
<ftp://ftp.eudora.com/eudora/mac/pro302/eudp302updater.sea.hqx>
<ftp://ftp.eudora.com/eudora/mac/light302/eudlight302.sea.hqx>
**Get Rich Quick?** Inspired by last year's $10,000 Macintosh Web
server security challenge (see TidBITS-317_), Sweden's Joakim
Jardenberg is conducting a Macintosh Web server "Crack a Mac"
challenge. From 10-Feb-97 through 10-Apr-97, Joakim is offering a
cash prize to anyone who can alter the contents of the home page
on a standard Macintosh Web server set up for the contest running
WebSTAR 2.0. The prize this time is 10,000 Swedish crowns (about
$1,350 U.S.), but it's worth noting that no one claimed the prize
from last year's challenge. Perhaps the U.S. Central Intelligence
Agency, whose Web pages were recently cracked, should think about
hosting them on Macintosh servers. [GD]
<http://www.infinit.se/hacke/crack.html>
OpenDoc Open for Business
-------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
In the past, TidBITS has discussed OpenDoc and the promise of
component software, but I think this year's recent Macworld Expo
in San Francisco marked the turning point for OpenDoc as a useful
technology. The Component 100 set of booths showcased numerous
OpenDoc parts, now known as Live Objects, and many developers
banded together to sell differently configured bundles of Live
Objects. Prices were universally cheap, and - interestingly - most
of the developers were previously unknown small companies. Those
last two facts speak to the fulfillment of the OpenDoc promise; it
remains to be seen if companies relying on OpenDoc can become an
industry force.
I admit that I haven't yet used many of the available Live
Objects. The reason is simple - I always have a tremendous amount
of work to do, and it's almost impossible to justify trying a new
way of working unless I have a reason to abandon my previous
systems. I suspect this sort of personal inertia will be the
primary hurdle the OpenDoc development community must overcome.
The solution to this problem, I think, is to offer Live Objects
that provide features hitherto unknown. Just as users gladly
switch to new programs when there's a clear advantage, so they
will switch to OpenDoc when they see clear advantages to OpenDoc
solutions.
To give you an idea what you can do today with OpenDoc, I
collected information from many of the Live Object vendors at
Macworld Expo. I'm sure this isn't a complete list of available
Live Objects, but it highlights some interesting products you can
buy today. A more complete list is available at Apple's OpenDoc
site, and other OpenDoc sites of interest include CI Labs and
Component 100.
<http://opendoc.apple.com/users/odproducts.html>
<http://www.cilabs.org/>
<http://www.c100.org/>
I don't list prices for any of the Live Objects below because you
can generally buy them in a dizzying array of bundles, one of
which will probably fit your needs. Most of the bundles I saw
ranged from about $25 to $100. A number of the bundles are listed
on the Hutchings Software Web site, and it's worth checking out
individual sites for other offers.
<http://www.hutchings-software.com/bundles/>
**WAV** -- One of the most talked-about Live Objects was WAV from
Digital Harbor. At its heart, WAV is a word processor, but thanks
to the flexibility of OpenDoc, it integrates well with the
Internet via Cyberdog. WAV provides basic word processing tools
along with some interesting features like the ability to click and
start typing anywhere on a page. For additional high-end features,
you plug in other Live Objects. WAV provides component folders for
third-party Live Objects, accessible via tabs at the top of a WAV
window. You can also create tabs for Project Folders, which hold
URLs, Live Objects, text, and graphics for use with a specific
project.
<http://www.dharbor.com/>
**Nisus Writer 5.0** -- The powerful Nisus Writer 5.0 word
processor was one of the first well-known applications to support
OpenDoc. It's only a container for Live Objects (not a Live Object
that can itself be embedded elsewhere), but if you already use
Nisus Writer 4.x, upgrading might be a good way to start
experimenting with OpenDoc.
<http://www.nisus-soft.com/nisus_writer.html>
**C-Table, C-Graph, & C-TextBox** -- One of the most favored tools
in a word processor is the table tool, but many table tools are,
shall we say, lousy. Corda's C-Table Live Object has received good
word of mouth for its feature set and integration with other Live
Objects, including C-Graph, another Corda Live Object that makes
graphics from data taken from C-Table or other sources. Corda also
makes C-TextBox, which enables you to make text boxes in any
OpenDoc container, complete with stylized text, auto-sizing, drop
shadows, and numerous border and fill options.
<http://www.corda.com/odentry.html>
**Canopy Outliner** -- If you need an outliner, there's now a Live
Object for you. Canopy Outliner from Eclipse can embed other Live
Objects within the outline, and it can be embedded in other Live
Objects. It can organize any type of data in outline form, has
unlimited levels of undo, can auto-number items, and link to
interactive content.
<http://www.outliner.com/>
**Lexi** -- Of course, where would any word processor be without a
spelling checker? Even better, wouldn't it be nice to have a
single spelling checker available in all applications? A variety
of utilities have done this over the years, and now it's available
for any Live Object that supports Word Services extensions, such
as the forthcoming Cyberdog 2.0, WAV, Canopy Outliner, and others.
You can also use SoftLinc's Lexi in stand-alone mode, where it can
check the spelling of any text document or any piece of text
imported through drag & drop or copy and paste. Lexi includes a
212,000 word dictionary, an 185,000-synonym thesaurus, a user
dictionary, a translation dictionary, and a conjugator.
<http://www.softlinc.com/>
**Dock'Em** -- MetaMind's Dock'Em provides the basic functionality
and interface of page layout and presentation tools but works
primarily with other Live Objects. You can embed other Live
Objects in Dock'Em documents, and you can even embed Dock'Em
documents in other Dock'Em documents. MetaMind describes Dock'Em
as a document construction kit, and with the wide variety of
options offered by other Live Objects, that seems like a fair
description.
<http://pomo.nbn.com/people/minds/>
**Adrenaline Numbers and Charts** -- So far, I've mainly mentioned
word processing technology, Internet technology, and page layout
and presentation technology. But, there's also spreadsheet
technology, provided by the Adrenaline Numbers Live Object. It's a
Microsoft Excel 5.0-compatible spreadsheet, and is backed up by
Adrenaline Charts, a charting tool that can take information from
Adrenaline Numbers. Both provide, to judge from their feature
lists, all the basic features that spreadsheet users would need,
especially in conjunction with other Live Objects.
<http://www.adrenaline.ca/>
**PartBank, Internet Search Service, & WinMenu** -- Kantara
Development has created a Live Object called PartFinder that works
with the company's PartBank Web site. PartFinder enables Live
Objects to locate other data-compatible Live Objects. For
instance, a spreadsheet Live Object could locate and download
charting components automatically. Kantara Development has also
written Kantara Internet Search Service, which enables Cyberdog
users to search within a number of Web search engines and Web
catalogs, along with PartBank itself. Also available is Kantara
WinMenu, which provides a Windows menu for each OpenDoc document.
<http://www.opendoc.partbank.com/>
**Rapid-I Button** -- Last among the Live Objects I saw at
Macworld Expo, but certainly not least, is Hutchings Software's
Rapid-I Button, which enables you to put a wide variety of buttons
in your OpenDoc documents. For a better sense of Rapid-I Button
and Hutchings Software, read on for Charles Wheeler's interview
with Rapid-I Button's programmer, Brad Hutchings.
More About Rapid-I
------------------
by Charles Wheeler <[email protected]>
Tucked in the middle of the Component 100 booth at Macworld Expo
was a family-owned business that best exemplifies why OpenDoc is
important to anyone struggling with bloated software. Hutchings
Software consists of Brad Hutchings, programmer and doctorate
student at UC Irvine; sister Jennifer, graphics specialist and
webmaster; Mom, chief financial officer; and Dad, whose specific
job title and duties were not given. This Lake Forest, California,
family hand-colored their promotional refrigerator magnets and
lapel buttons, and Jennifer hand-sewed a few dolls of Rappie, the
company logo/mascot, a blue "spokesblob."
Other than their refreshingly low-key marketing approach, why
should you care about the Hutchings family? Because their first
commercial product, Rapid-I Button, is the definitive button tool
for OpenDoc. This is a fully developed, full-featured component,
on par with other commercial offerings from OpenDoc suppliers like
Adrenaline, SoftLinc, Corda, or Digital Harbor (whose WAV word
processor I'm currently using). Rapid-I Buttons can be used to
control Cyberdog, open files, run scripts, play sounds, and more.
<http://www.hutchings-software.com/>
Although he had been a Macintosh programmer since 1988, Brad first
caught the OpenDoc bug after watching a Cyberdog video in 1995. He
contacted OpenDoc Evangelist Jim Black, who sent him information
and tools. His first effort, a signaling flag part, was included
in the OpenDoc Developer Release 4 CD-ROM. Rapid-I Buttons was
first introduced at the World Wide Developers Conference in 1996.
Apparently competing button parts are in the works, but, other
than Apple's simple button component, none have shipped yet. "When
they pop up, I squash them," joked Brad, when asked about the
competition. "But I'm not just a button pusher. I want to be known
for OpenDoc tools that are the best of class." Toward this end,
Hutchings Software plans to release Rapid-I Surfboard, a Web part,
at the end of February.
So how did Macworld treat the Hutchings family? "The response has
been great," said Mom, "Consumers, especially educators, have been
very excited."
OpenDoc has once again opened the door for the rest of us. Just
when you think it takes a room full of venture capitalists, a
campus full of programmers, and a marketing department the size of
a small army to launch a new product, along comes Hutchings
Software to prove that insanely great things still come in small
packages.
[Charles D. Wheeler is a FileMaker Pro for Macintosh consultant,
Macworld Expo party crasher, and occasional TidBITS contributor.]
BBEdit 4.0.2: Speaks Softly but Carries a Big Stick
---------------------------------------------------
by Sean Peisert <[email protected]>
Over the past several years, Bare Bones Software's BBEdit has
matured from an essentials-only programmer's text editor to a
terrific, mature product. BBEdit 4.02 stands out as a highly
useful tool, especially for programmers and HTML enthusiasts, as
well as for those creating long documents that don't require many
page layout features.
<http://www.barebones.com/>
**Speaks Softly** -- With its 1 MB RAM allocation and 1.7 MB disk
footprint, BBEdit doesn't require nearly the system resources of a
modern word processor. According to Bare Bones, BBEdit runs on a
Mac Plus or better and requires System 7.0 or later, though Bare
Bones recommends System 7.5 or newer. The disk footprint may
expand, however, if you install freely from the BBEdit CD-ROM - my
complete installation of templates, extensions, dictionaries, and
more consumes about 8 MB of space.
BBEdit lists for $119, with a cross-grade coming in at $79 and
upgrades from a previous commercial version setting you back $39.
One of BBEdit's hallmarks is packing a ton of great features in an
easily-navigated interface. For instance, an optional info bar
tops each document window and shows useful data about the
document: the last saved date, if the file has been modified since
its last save, and the file's disk location. Additionally, pop-up
menus on the status bar lead to often-used functions. Keyboard
navigation works well, since there are Command-key shortcuts for
most options. One quirk I appreciate is when a document window is
created or opened: BBEdit sets a temporary keyboard shortcut
(Command-1 through Command-0) that activates the window.
Soft-wrapping, a feature that was key to transforming BBEdit from
a programmer's editor into a general purpose text editor, has been
supported since version 3.1. Text wraps automatically at the end
of a user-specified distance, much as it does in any standard
Macintosh word processor, without modifying the string of
characters. Most people take this feature for granted until they
experience a program that doesn't wrap text. In such a program,
the text of a long paragraph extends past the right edge of the
document window instead of wrapping down to the next line.
BBEdit also supports many Apple technologies and Internet trends.
For instance, BBEdit's Balloon Help explains just about every item
in the program, and the BBEdit Guide simplifies looking up terms
and can help users through complicated tasks. BBEdit isn't
recordable, but can be scripted using any OSA scripting language,
including AppleScript and Userland Frontier's UserTalk. Savvy
scripters can add custom functions to BBEdit by storing
frequently-used scripts as commands in BBEdit's Scripts menu.
Although BBEdit features a vast array of user-configurable
preferences, it's not the most flexible text editor available. I'd
give that award to emacs or Alpha (a shareware text editor by Pete
Keleher). In contrast to Alpha's ability to bind just about any
key combination to any function, the only key-customization BBEdit
users can do is assign Command-key shortcuts to items in the
Extensions menu.
<ftp://ftp.cs.cornell.edu/pub/parmet/>
<http://www.cs.umd.edu/~keleher/alpha.html>
However, BBEdit takes typical text editor features a step further.
For instance, the Find command supports GREP, which enables
searching based on complex patterns and regular expressions
instead of just words or phrases. The BBEdit manual and online
help do an excellent job documenting the complex syntax involved,
making it easy to use a search string like "[A-Za-z]+" to search
for occurrences of single words enclosed in quotes. In addition,
BBEdit includes some common GREP patterns used by programmers, and
users can store their own frequently-used GREP expressions.
**Extending the Feature Set** -- BBEdit comes with extensions, but
they are not extensions like Open Transport and RAM Doubler that
load when your Mac starts up. Instead, they work more like macros
or wizards. For instance, the Convert to ASCII extension
automatically converts text containing 8-bit characters into 7-bit
text, intelligently changing special characters like smart quotes,
bullets, and copyright symbols to 7-bit equivalents that can be
sent via email or viewed as text under a different operating
system. There's also an extension called Cut Lines Containing,
which, when activated, prompts for a search string. The extension
then searches the document for lines containing the string, cuts
them out, and adds them to the clipboard. Additionally, BBEdit
ships with a set of well-designed HTML extensions, which I discuss
in a bit.
Further, BBEdit comes with a full set of instructions, examples,
and source code which allow C and C++ programmers to create their
own extensions. A number of these extensions are available from
the Info-Mac archives as well as Bare Bones Software's FTP site.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/text/bbe/>
<ftp://ftp.barebones.com/pub/third-party-extensions/>
**Carries a Big Stick** -- BBEdit 4.0 finally implements syntax
coloring for most commonly used programming languages and even
some obscure ones. Syntax coloring means, for instance, that in
source code files, comments, language keywords, and string
constants are all colored to make them stand out better from the
rest of the code. Syntax coloring also works with HTML and makes
BBEdit all the more attractive as a Web authoring tool.
BBEdit has another neat feature called Groups, which enables you
to assign a set of files - say, all of the files for a Web site -
to a group. Once you've grouped files, it's easy to open them all
at once, or to run the Find command on the entire group. This
feature is a favorite among webmasters who use BBEdit to make
global changes: rather than open and change an element (say, a
renamed file or broken link) in each file on a Web site, it's easy
to perform a search-and-replace for all files in a group.
BBEdit's well-designed spelling checker checks words against a
primary U.S. English dictionary and a user dictionary. You can add
any of a number of optional dictionaries to that set, and included
dictionaries span subjects ranging from Biblical and British
English to Legal Secretary and Science. The checker ignores HTML
tags, making it possible to check an HTML document without
tripping over the tags.
I'm a fan of the Compare feature. In addition to comparing the
contents of two files so you can figure out how they differ
(similar to the diff command in Unix), BBEdit also compares entire
folders and Symantec C++ and CodeWarrior project files, and the
program displays Compare results in a special Browser window that
helps you cycle through the list of differences.
**The Internet Club** -- BBEdit uses Internet Config to populate
its Internet menu with your preferred Internet client programs,
which you can switch to by choosing them from the menu. You can
also open (or "resolve") a URL simply by selecting it in BBEdit
and choosing Resolve URL from the menu.
Perhaps the coolest feature of BBEdit for people uploading to
remote file servers (such as people doing HTML markup and CGI
programming) is BBEdit's built-in FTP client. This feature allows
you to maintain your Web site without leaving BBEdit. The Open
from FTP Server command transparently downloads the file to your
hard disk, and - when you save your changes - BBEdit transparently
uploads the file to the server.
**Sticking up for Developers** -- When used as an editor for
programming, BBEdit can interface with Integrated Development
Environments (IDEs) such as Metrowerks CodeWarrior and Symantec
C++. The interface goes two ways. On one hand, a user can access
BBEdit from CodeWarrior; on the other hand, a user can access IDE
features from BBEdit.
Thanks to external editor support in CodeWarrior versions CW10 or
later, CodeWarrior users can type source code into BBEdit and make
that code part of a CodeWarrior project. Then, files opened from a
CodeWarrior project appear in BBEdit.
BBEdit uses a Compiler menu to interface to an IDE/compiler,
providing quick access to commands like Compile, Set Breakpoint,
Add, and Run. One of the extra niceties provided is the Command-
Tab keyboard shortcut for switching between C or C++
implementation source files and their corresponding header
(declaration) files.
Finally, BBEdit's features good integration with the Mac scripting
environment UserLand Frontier, which is included on the BBEdit
CD-ROM. BBEdit supports Frontier's menu sharing protocol, so when
Frontier is running, a customizable Scripts menu appears in
BBEdit's menubar. (Initially, this menu features Web site
management and HTML authoring functions.) BBEdit can also serve as
an HTML editor for Frontier, enhancing Frontier's Web site
management capabilities.
<http://www.scripting.com/frontier/>
Programmers have long had great editors, however. Unix users have
had emacs; Macintosh users have had the CodeWarrior IDE, the
Symantec IDE, as well as Alpha. The explosion of the Web, however,
has brought about a huge demand for HTML editors.
**Branching into HTML** -- Many HTML extensions have been written
for BBEdit, and they all endeavor to eliminate tedious
memorization and typing, or the brain-straining visualization
necessary to code for things like tables and forms. Lindsay
Davies's HTML Tools, version 2.1.1, ships with BBEdit and includes
extensions for much of HTML 3.2, including tables and forms. In
addition to being accessible like other BBEdit extensions (from
the menu bar and Command-keys) the HTML Tools can be activated
from a floating tool palette. For instance, to format text with a
<STRONG> tag, you highlight the text and choose Strong Emphasis
from a menu that pops out of the Style button on the palette. The
HTML Tools also automate more complex tasks such as creating
tables. When it comes to a table, BBEdit prompts for what sort of
element to add, such as a row or a cell, and gives you an
opportunity to set attributes for the element.
In addition to tools for inserting HTML tags, BBEdit also provides
administrative functions. A particularly necessary feature, Check
HTML, verifies the syntax of HTML documents and displays its
results in a split window with errors on top and the HTML below.
As you scroll the list of errors, BBEdit highlights the
appropriate text in the lower pane. I won't argue with Check
HTML's utility, but I've found it a bit strict, especially
considering the changing nature of the HTML standard. A good
improvement for the future would be ability to customize the
errors Check HTML identifies.
BBEdit has a custom HTML macro feature that allows you to enter
your own HTML functions in a relatively simple pattern-matching
format. It takes time to get the hang of the syntax, but by
looking at some examples, it is not difficult to pick up
rudimentary technique. For instance, the following expression
selects a word and frames it with the font size tags:
!SW<FONTSIZE +2>\s</FONTSIZE +2>. Thus, it converts "thistext"
to <FONTSIZE +2>thistext</FONTSIZE +2>.
**Room For Improvement?** BBEdit strikes me as nearly a perfect
text editor, and I base that statement on having used many text
editors in the past, including vi, emacs, Alpha, Plaintext, BBEdit
Lite, Tex-Edit Plus, the CodeWarrior IDE, and the Symantec C++
IDE. My uses have ranged from programming C++, Perl, or Java, to
writing articles, marking up text in HTML, or simply viewing text
downloaded from the Internet.
A feature I would like to see associated with BBEdit is a Revision
or Version Control System (RCS/VCS). A Revision Control System
enables you to better manage document versions, and would extend
the functionality already in the Compare command. Consider the
following situation: you create a document, be it HTML, a text
file, or C++ source code. A few days later, you edit it and make
significant changes. A few more days later, you realize you
deleted something from the first version that you wanted after
all. A Revision Control System helps you save and track all these
existing versions by archiving the previous versions and allowing
you to compare the current document to previous versions. Although
there are a few third-party revision control system products
available (such as Rev, reviewed in TidBITS-362_), even the free
GNU XEmacs for Unix has an excellent RCS feature built in.
BBEdit has few noticeable bugs. The main one I've encountered is a
minor conflict between BBEdit 4.0.x and Apple's LaserWriter 8.4.1
driver, where the last character of a BBEdit document will not
print. Bare Bones anticipates fixing this problem in BBEdit 4.0.3,
which should be available shortly. Also, BBEdit's FTP tool doesn't
correctly handle MacBinary file transfers - extraneous information
can appear when a file is opened, and file information is lost
when a file is saved. This problem should be corrected in BBEdit
4.0.3, and an interim fix is available from Bare Bones.
**Bottom Line** -- Anyone who works frequently with HTML files,
source code, or plain text documents can benefit from BBEdit. You
can give BBEdit a trial run by downloading the demo from Bare
Bones Software's Web site.
Bare Bones also produces a freeware version of BBEdit, called
BBEdit Lite. BBEdit Lite contains all of the editing niceties of
BBEdit, but lacks many of the tools, including integration with
compilers, OSA support, the HTML floating palette, Internet Config
support, a spelling checker, and FTP features.
**DealBITS** -- Cyberian Outpost is offering BBEdit to TidBITS
readers for $94.95 ($5 off) through this URL:
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/bbedit.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.265 | Issue #366 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Feb 18 1997 08:34 | 603 |
|
TidBITS#366/17-Feb-97
=====================
The Mac OS is perhaps the easiest operating system to use, but
even beginners sense there's more under the hood than first
appears. A book by David Pogue and Joseph Schorr explores the
Mac's inner machinery. Also, Geoff Duncan reports on Apple's newly
announced Macintoshes, Matt Neuburg reviews Canvas 5.0.1, and Jeff
Carlson explores the Internet from his favorite cafe, thanks to
the Ricochet Wireless Modem.
Topics:
MailBITS/17-Feb-97
Apple Introduces New Macs
Macworld Mac Secrets, Fourth Edition
Tied Down No More: The Ricochet Wireless Modem
The Microsoftization of Deneba: Canvas 5.0.1
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-366.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#366_17-Feb-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of hard drives, tape drives, and neat SCSI accessories.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#366! <--------- NEW!
Factory refurbished Performa 6200/75MHz 8MB/1GB/4xCD: $689
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/17-Feb-97
------------------
**QuickTake 200** -- Apple announced the QuickTake 200, which
briefly catches Apple up with the digital photography industry.
The QuickTake 200 features a 1.8-inch LCD display that serves as a
viewfinder and a means of viewing photos, along with NTSC video
output and the ability to function as a video conferencing camera.
Pictures are captured to removable storage cards, with the bundled
2 MB card holding about 20 high-quality images. The camera comes
with Adobe PhotoDeluxe and PageMill, and should be available in
early March for about $600. [GD]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970217.pr.rel.quicktake200.html>
Apple Introduces New Macs
-------------------------
by Geoff Duncan <[email protected]>
Today at Macworld Expo Tokyo, Apple announced a new set of Macs,
some of which give existing machines a speed bump and minor
redesigns, one of which targets the Mac clone market, and one of
which will make some PowerBook users green with envy.
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970217.pr.rel.products.html>
**Power Macs** -- At the high end come the Power Macintosh
9600/233 and 9600/200MP, which are enhancements to Apple's 9500
series with faster versions of the 604e. The new 9600s have 12x
CD-ROMs, 4 GB hard disks, 32 MB RAM, 512K of Level 2 cache, six
PCI slots, 10Base-T Ethernet, and high performance IMS Twin Turbo
128 M4A video cards. Similarly, the new Power Mac 8600/200 is a
revved-up version of the 8500, with a 12x CD-ROM, 32 MB RAM, the
8500's video input/output capabilities, and a built-in Iomega Zip
drive. The 9600/233 should be available in May for $4,250; the
9600/200MP and 8600/200 will be available in March for about
$4,750 and $3,250, respectively.
Closer to earth is the Power Mac 7300, at prices from $2,300 to
$2,800. The 7300 replaces the 7200 and 7600 as a middle-of-the-
road system, and features a 604e processor running at 180 or 200
MHz, 16 or 32 MB of RAM, a 12x CD-ROM drive, 2 GB hard disk, 256K
of Level 2 cache, three PCI slots, and 10Base-T Ethernet. The 7300
also adds a security feature to the accessible internal design of
the 7000-series: it seems those internal components may have been
too accessible. Apparently, a thermal problem with some CPU cards
has delayed shipment of the 7300s, although Apple has reportedly
told dealers units will be available in early March.
<http://www.macweek.com/mw_1107/nw_delay.html>
If the 9600s, 8600s, and 7300s are variations on a theme, then the
low-cost Power Mac 4400 is a new tune from Apple. Designed to
compete directly with Mac clones, the 4400 includes a 200 MHz 603e
processor, 16 MB of EDO RAM, 8x CD-ROM, 2 IDE GB hard drive, two
PCI slots, 256K of Level 2 cache and 10Base-T Ethernet (via a card
in the Comm II slot). The 4400 is the first Apple machine based on
the Tanzania motherboard used by clone vendors, and (also like
clones) utilizes less-expensive parts from the PC world, including
a mostly non-Apple case and non-switching power supply. Unlike
other models, the 4400 has almost no bundled software, but with a
price around $1,700 and performance in line with similarly-
configured Mac clones, the 4400 could sell well.
The Power Macs 9600 and 8600 have new swing-out case designs that
provide easier access to internal components, and the 9600, 8600,
and 7300 all use replaceable CPU daughter cards, making it
possible to upgrade the CPU without replacing the entire machine.
These machines ship with System 7.5.5, except the Power Mac 4400,
which ships with System 7.5.3. Apple says all these machines will
run Mac OS 7.6.1, which should be available in April. All these
new systems come with both a keyboard and a mouse.
**PowerBook 3400c** -- Apple also introduced the fast, high-end
PowerBook 3400c. The feature array for the 3400c includes a 603e
processor at speeds from 180 to 240 MHz, 16 MB of RAM, 256K Level
2 cache, IDE hard drives from 1.3 to 3 GB, optional 6x and 12x
CD-ROM drives, built-in 33.6 Kbps fax modem and 10Base-T Ethernet,
and a stunning 12.1-inch active matrix screen. The PowerBook 3400c
also has a hot-swappable drive bay (for a floppy drive, CD-ROM, or
other devices), space for two Type II or one Type III PC Card, an
infrared port, and a four-speaker sound system. The 3400c is
reportedly very snappy, aided by its high clock speeds, 32-bit PCI
bus, and responsive video. However, at 7.5 pounds and prices
ranging from $4,500 to a whopping $6,500, the PowerBook 3400c is
not for everyone. The 180 and 200 MHz versions of the 3400c should
be available this week, with the 240 MHz versions appearing in
April.
**The Response** -- Are Macintosh clone vendors going to let Apple
steal the thunder with new machines? Not likely: you can expect
vendors to reduce prices in response to Apple's new models, as
well as introduce new models of their own. Also, as Apple's new
machines enter the channel, watch for discounts on now-
discontinued 7600, 8500, and 9500 models.
Macworld Mac Secrets, Fourth Edition
------------------------------------
by John Nemerovski <[email protected]>
With any new Macintosh book, I evaluate its worth on how quickly I
can locate valuable information that I can use immediately.
Macworld Mac Secrets, Fourth Edition, by David Pogue and Joseph
Schorr, rewarded me with these morsels:
* I was helping a friend do diagnostic work on her Quadra 605 and
PowerBook 140. I learned that the Quadra 605 is identical to the
LC 475 and the Performa 475, including the 68LC040 chip, which
gave me a useful frame of reference; and that the PowerBook 140
runs at 16 MHz on a 68030 chip, which helps explain the speed
discrepancy from her Quadra.
* In the chapter on ClarisWorks word processing secrets, I learned
several new features about the "wonderfulness of ClarisWorks
Click-and-Drop" and that "amazing Font menu." The Option key
triggers all sorts of tricks in ClarisWorks' humble list of fonts!
The word "secrets" is appropriate to about one third of the
information in the book. The other two thirds consist of useful
general knowledge about all aspects of the Macintosh, plus helpful
tips and tricks to boost your Mac productivity and enjoyment.
**Lots of Book for the Buck** -- Mac Secrets consists of three
components: the massive book (1,208 pages), a respectably packed
CD-ROM disk (550 MB), and a Web site for updates to the book and
the bundled software. This edition is quite current, demonstrated
by a reference to Mac OS 7.6's new installer, and, ironically, to
rumors of Apple's potential liaison with Be, Inc.
<http://www.idgbooks.com/idgbooksonline/macsecrets/>
The authors describe the fourth edition by stating that
"everything's different, nothing's changed." The format and feel
are consistent with earlier editions, but the look is cleaner and
easier to read. On the CD, the custom folder icons from previous
editions have been replaced by "plain, boring, ordinary" folders,
so they open rapidly.
Pogue and Schorr offer a diversified presentation, including
conventional text and occasional entertaining back-and-forth
dialogues, plus sidebars of secrets, true facts, case histories,
and "Answer Man" solutions. The book is peppered with bulleted
bonuses, such as Speed Tips, Exclusives, On the CD, Strange but
True, and Worth Learning. For example, one tip worth exploring is
"The Golden Troubleshooting Rule: A Clean Install," which explains
the benefits of installing all generations of Mac system software
from scratch, instead of on top of an existing System.
Chapter 4 is an outstanding, mini-encyclopedia on control panels
and extensions, including "The Ultimate Extension-Linking Guide."
Troubleshooting your Mac is covered in an excellent 30-page
chapter. An extensive glossary and index help readers locate and
understand terms, concepts, and the secrets themselves.
**More Than Just a Book** -- Is this a book or a software package?
Pogue and Schorr understand that "despite the countless hours your
cheerful authors have spent researching and writing this book, you
may well consider the software supplied with this book to be the
main course." They're not kidding: a total of 110 different
shareware, freeware, and commercial programs and demos fill up the
CD-ROM, and the book uses 58 pages explains the software in
detail.
A few fully functional titles include: CanOpener, Claris Emailer,
DiskFit Direct, TechTool, TypeIt4Me, Remember?, Cyberdog, OpenDoc,
and QuickTime. The CD is a veritable software library kept up to
date via the book's Web site. (Discount coupons for upgrades and
full versions of many commercial applications are also provided.)
On the CD, the software is conveniently listed by chapter,
category, author, and a few more groupings, aliased to the
Complete Software List. The entire text of the book is on the CD,
in searchable Adobe Acrobat format.
Macworld Mac Secrets is extensive, but no doubt there are Mac
secrets that didn't make it into the manuscript. The co-authors
are conducting a 1997 contest for the 50 best undocumented Mac
secrets, with one $500 top cash prize and 50 free books awarded
(with credit to the winners).
<http://www.idgbooks.com/idgbooksonline/macsecrets/secretscontest.html>
Macworld Mac Secrets is a good value for the money that will
receive plenty of use either as an addition to your library or as
a gift. I give this book my highest recommendation, especially for
intermediate-level Macintosh users.
Macworld Mac Secrets, 4th Edition, David Pogue and Joseph
Schorr, ISBN 0-7645-4006-8. $44.95 U.S., $62.99 Canadian.
IDG Books Worldwide, Inc. -- 800/762-2974 -- 800-667-1115
(Canada) -- <[email protected]> (international)
Tied Down No More: The Ricochet Wireless Modem
----------------------------------------------
by Jeff Carlson <[email protected]>
I'm a big fan of "cafe computing." I don't mean going to a
cybercafe, where the coffee-stained hardware is already there and
waiting, or a trendy coffee mega-chain where an open laptop
advertises pseudo-geek chic. I'm talking about sitting in my
favorite coffee house with my PowerBook and doing a little
writing. Since I spend most of my days in front of a computer
screen, it's nice to change the walls and atmosphere around it.
So, when I heard about Metricom's Ricochet Wireless Modem, I was
excited. Liberated from telephone jacks and cords, I could spend
all day at the coffee house, sending and receiving email,
searching the Web, even dialing the server at work via Apple
Remote Access. Had I stumbled upon Utopia? Well, almost.
<http://www.ricochet.net/>
**Get Unwired** -- The Ricochet modem is a small, black,
rectangular device weighing 13 ounces, with a cord that plugs into
the Mac's serial port. The cord is only about six inches long, so
you don't have to worry about dangling wire. If you use the
Ricochet on a desktop machine, I suggest buying the optional
10-foot cable. You can mount the unit on your PowerBook cover with
the included velcro pads, but since I'm the type who gets nervous
about bumper stickers on my car, I left the velcro in the package.
The kit also comes with an AC adapter; two disks with the Ricochet
software, MacPPP, and Netscape Navigator 2.0; plus a manual.
For a $29.95 monthly fee (the Basic Service option), you get
unlimited Internet access via Metricom's Ricochet servers and a
POP email account. Renting the modem costs $12.50 per month on top
of that, or you can buy the unit for either $299 (with a 12 month
service agreement) or $599 (if you want the modem, but not the
Internet access, to communicate wireless on a Ricochet-enabled
Intranet or LAN, or even in the same room with others with
Ricochets). You can also opt for a rent-to-own agreement at $25
per month. I chose the basic modem rental, since the Ricochet is
bound to get smaller and lighter over time. Additional fees give
you additional services: the Preferred option includes Telephone
Modem Access (TMA), allowing you to dial into services accessible
only via telephone number (such as other ISPs and bulletin board
services). The Elite option includes a cc:Mail account and
software (substituted for POP email), TMA, dial-in capability to
retrieve mail outside the Ricochet coverage area, and outbound fax
capability (at the unusually high cost of 50 cents per page).
<http://www.ricochet.net/order/pricing/metro.html>
The biggest limitation of the Ricochet service is its current
coverage area, which is limited to Seattle, most of the San
Francisco Bay area, and Washington D.C., although I gather that
Metricom is frantically trying to expand coverage to meet demand.
<http://www.ricochet.net/coverage/index.html>
Expanding coverage, however, isn't necessarily simple, requiring a
good deal of infrastructure and the cooperation of a given city's
government. If you live in one of the cities currently covered,
you may notice many street lamps have acquired boxy appendages.
Those "microcell radios" grab signals from Ricochet modems and
pass them along to other microcells within the license-free (902-
928 MHz) portion of the radio frequency spectrum using a technique
called frequency hopping. The radio packets are eventually routed
to a Wired Access Point (WAP), which transmits them to Ricochet's
servers via a T1 connection. Microcells are spaced roughly one-
quarter to one-half mile apart in a checkerboard pattern, mounted
on street lamps and utility poles. Installing these units requires
city approval, which in most cases is no problem. However, a large
chunk of San Francisco, for example, is currently "blacked out"
due to pending approval.
**Using the Ricochet** -- Installing the software was surprisingly
easy. Although I backed up my TCP/IP settings first, the Ricochet
installer made my preparations seem like overkill: the TCP/IP
information was stored as a new TCP/IP configuration and made
active. After a restart, I was ready to go.
The Ricochet's power switch is on the side of the unit, requiring
you to rotate the antenna out of the way to power up the modem - a
nice touch that largely avoids accidentally turning it on and
draining the battery. The switch has three settings: off,
on/silent, and on/audible. If you're used to the R2-D2-on-acid
electronic screech of most modems, the polite chirp of the
Ricochet will be a welcome change. After activation, a red light
case flashes to indicate the Ricochet is searching for the signal
from a nearby microcell; when the light flashes green, you're
ready to dial up using PPP; when you're connected, the light
flashes yellow.
Once connected, the Internet experience is similar to wire-based
connections. Metricom broadly (and wisely) claims that the
Ricochet will operate between 14.4 Kbps and 28.8 Kbps - not
lightning-fast, but good compared to cellular phone/modem
connections. People who need Internet access while away from the
office would benefit by using the Ricochet, regardless of the
speed. I found the speed hovering closer to the low range,
depending on my location. The manual recommends operating the unit
outside or near a window, and away from objects that could cause
interference, such as stereo speakers.
The Ricochet's battery lasted between four and six hours, as
promised, which was fine. I unexpectedly ran out of juice on only
a couple of occasions before discovering a tip on Metricom's Web
site: you can put the modem to sleep by running a terminal program
such as Zterm and typing "ATS327=3". You can set the time of
inactivity before sleep by typing "ATS326=x" (x being the number
of minutes; the default is 10).
**Wild, Wireless Ways** -- After using the Ricochet for a few
hours, I had completely adjusted to the notion of wireless
computing. Suddenly, the idea of messing around with phone
companies and wired access seemed outdated and antiquated.
Certainly, wireless Internet access is the way access ought to be,
although I'm sure it will years before we look back and laugh at
our reliance on land-line connections. In the meantime, users who
require mobile Internet access will find the Ricochet an
invaluable addition to the growing arsenal of portable-computing
products.
Ironically, although I enjoyed using the Ricochet, I'm compelled
to mentioned that it no longer travels with me. One of the main
reasons I got it was to serve as a second phone line both at work
and at home, with the added bonus of using it in the coffee house.
But because the speed was consistently slow in my home (and since
the people in my office are installing an ISDN line) I opted for
the slightly cheaper route and put a second phone line into my
apartment. Frankly, $42.50 per month was a bit of a luxury, so I
took the Richochet back. However, I'm still an advocate of cafe
computing, and I won't think twice about getting one in the
future. For now I'll be content to envy the other people with
Ricochets in my favorite coffee house.
The Microsoftization of Deneba: Canvas 5.0.1
--------------------------------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
Although I'm no artist, I do need to make diagrams and pictures
occasionally, and the early surprise and pleasure of MacPaint and
MacDraw helped define the Macintosh for me. For years I was a fan
of SuperPaint (TidBITS-112_), which essentially combined the two;
but it "progressed" to become sluggish, and when I used it to
diagram my New Zealand garden, it was clumsy, it wouldn't print,
and screen updating was slow. That's when I switched to Deneba's
Canvas 3.5.
**Put Me in the Picture** -- Canvas, which first appeared in 1987,
had developed a kind of cult following. It could both draw and
paint, and it went beyond SuperPaint in its precision, multi-
layered documents, and the many cool tricks it could do thanks to
its component architecture, which allowed integration of new
tools, such as binding text to a path, or adding dimension
measurements. It was quick and rugged. Most remarkably, it handled
a huge variety of graphics formats.
When Deneba announced that Canvas would be so radically improved
as to be designated 5.0, we adherents were smug. We'd backed the
right horse this time! Our anticipation, though, was prolonged.
Canvas 5.0 was advertised month after month; the upgrade was
previewed at Macworld Expo in August, 1995, and again in January,
1996; but no product. Finally, it "shipped" at the Expo in August,
1996 - meaning that in late September and early October, users
began actually receiving copies.
A collective howl of anti-climactic despair arose on the nets.
Users complained of crashes, erratic behavior, of slow screen
updating, of unaccountably large file sizes, of inability to
print, of inability to export to PICT or to import from Canvas
3.5. My own first 5.0 project, a house diagram, was a dismal
failure - the dimension measurements showed as nonsense, and
rotated text wouldn't print on my StyleWriter (I went back to 3.5
and did the job easily). Deneba's customer support server was
swamped; an email provoked an automated response after a few days,
a human response after weeks or never. Evidently, for all our
patience, 5.0 was still not the real release.
In November, a 5.0.1 updater appeared. In January, a new
installation CD shipped. My printing problems went away when I
adopted Apple's Color StyleWriter 1500 driver (no thanks to any
advice from Deneba). The dust was finally settling.
**Graphic Analysis** -- As promised, Canvas 5.0.1 goes well beyond
its predecessor, integrating into one program capabilities that
could save users from having to purchase single-purpose
applications in a number of areas.
* It's a draw program. You get the usual vector-based shapes and
Bezier paths, plus many specialized shapes, enhanced by pen
widths, arrows and calligraphic shapes, plus colors, gradients,
hatchings, and textures, all heavily customizable and savable in
library form for later use. Bezier paths can also now be combined
and blended in powerful new ways.
* It's a diagram program. As in 3.5, "smart lines" link their
objects even when the latter are moved, and dimension tools and
"smart mouse" features help with exact measurements.
* It's a 3-D program. The extrusion tool now makes parallel or
circular rotatable objects with customizable lighting.
* It's a page layout program. A new type of document, the
publication, can have columns, linked text boxes, headers and
footers. You can have cascading paragraph and character styles,
automatic hyphenation, even widow and orphan control.
* It's a paint program. The paint tools include many new ways of
laying on color, plus complex transfer modes and tools for
smudging, sharpening, blurring, saturating and so on.
* It's an image-processing program. You can use channels, masks,
and filters to manipulate images in complex ways.
* It's a presentation program. You can use successions of images
to make a slide show (not much changed from 3.5).
**Dull as Paint** -- Unfortunately, Deneba has created a decidedly
unpleasant user experience. The program feels at every step like a
cross-platform port: the help file reminds one of Microsoft Help;
the dialogs have an un-Mac-like look and feel; a status bar mars
the bottom of the screen; 3.5's extensive scriptability is
completely gone; and there are occasional meaningless error
messages. Installation is a nightmare, with dozens of undocumented
files dumped into the System folder. The manual, while
impressively slimmed down from 3.5's 900-page brick, is a tedious,
repetitive reference, burdened with double sets of illustrations
and instructions for both Windows and Mac.
A number of problems come down to speed, or the lack of it. On my
computer using Canvas 5.0.1 is painfully slow. Okay, so I've got
an LC 475. But that's a 68040 processor, though without an FPU. It
runs 3.5 quickly, and comments on the net suggest that even Power
Mac owners find 5.0.1 sluggish.
The screen is astoundingly slow to refresh - and it chooses to
refresh a lot, at the most unaccountable times: after you've
peeked at a palette; after just about any individual operation on
a single object; even after scrolling in a floating window that
doesn't cover any of the drawing. If you switch in from another
application, the screen sometimes partially redraws, then the
floating palettes redraw (also a tedious operation), and then the
screen starts redrawing (slowly!) all over again. Besides which,
the screen often unaccountably vanishes in the middle of an
operation, or redraws incorrectly, so you have to force a refresh
- and wait through it.
Various operations seem to send my computer into a frozen limbo:
no status-bar message, no watch cursor, no change in my menubar
clock, no response to clicks, no ability to switch away, nothing.
Thus I have frequently believed the program to have crashed and
restarted the computer; but it appears that most of the time there
was in fact some calculation going on. An indication of this would
have been nice.
**Bad Brushwork** -- Basic tools have not been much improved; on
the whole, they are inconvenient and clumsy to use, both
physically and mentally.
For example, selection tools are poor; it can be difficult and
tedious to select the particular vector items you want, because
all you can do is click or draw rectangles.
With the Bezier path tools, it is difficult to see what's going on
as you draw or select, even with your face right up against the
screen. Drawing a new path is unnecessarily difficult: after you
draw the first point and tangent, the tangent vanishes, leaving
just a point that's difficult to see and which gives you no sense
of what will happen as you draw the second point and tangent. (As
you draw subsequent points, the previous point and its tangent
_are_ both shown, so why not as you draw the second point?) There
are no keyboard shortcuts for selecting points or tangent handles;
you have to find them by eye (not easy) and click right on them
(ditto). There have been some improvements in these tools - a new
pop-up menu is a welcome relief from the numerous modifier-click
path editing combinations one used to have to memorize - but they
don't make up for these basic shortcomings.
When you use a paint tool, you can't see what you're doing either,
because it appears as the same little icon regardless of the size
and shape of the actual brush you're using; in effect, you're
trying to paint with an invisible brush, so you just have to guess
at the effect of clicking the mouse at any particular point. This
is a major step backwards from 3.5.
It is hard to learn what the current settings are for any
particular object. For instance, after you select an object,
clicking on the line tool doesn't show you the object's line width
(you must tear off the palette and scroll through it, hunting for
the selected item); nor does the object's pen or fill color become
selected in the inks palette. The distinction between a particular
object's settings and the default settings remains confusing as
well.
**Drawing Conclusions** -- Canvas 5.0 was shamefully full of bugs
and errors; a glance at Deneba's own lists of changes and fixes in
5.0.1 shows just how full (and such lists are usually deliberately
incomplete).
<http://www.deneba.com/dazroot/softlibs/canvas5/resolved.html>
<http://www.deneba.com/dazroot/softlibs/canvas5/changes.html>
Canvas 5.0.1 runs far more reliably, but still in a sluggish,
useless, unhelpful way. The slowness of screen redraw, in
particular, is unforgivable; I have enough spare RAM that the
program could cache the whole screen as a bitmap (though even
paging out to disk and back would be vastly faster than what's
happening now), and in any case I don't see why all 50 objects on
the screen have to redraw just because I change the color of one
of them. Both screen redraw and the interface with the basic
vector and paint tools need to be rethought from the ground up, if
this version of Canvas is to be useful.
Meanwhile, Deneba has not dropped Canvas 3.5 from its list of
current products. That's wise.
<http://www.deneba.com/dazroot/prodinfo/canvas5/cv5main.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.266 | Issue #367 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Feb 25 1997 09:20 | 608 |
|
TidBITS#367/24-Feb-97
=====================
Ever wondered what motivates sales people at large consumer
electronics stores? Money! Read about Ian Gregson's experiences
over the last holiday shopping season. Also in this issue, info on
beta releases of Emailer 2.0 and Apple's CFM-68K Runtime Enabler,
Mark Anbinder looks at the WebTV, and Stuart Cheshire examines in
detail how latency brings your super-fast new modem to its knees.
Topics:
MailBITS/24-Feb-97
Selling Performas at the Front Lines
An Internet for the TV Generation
Bandwidth and Latency: It's the Latency, Stupid (Part 1)
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-367.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#367_24-Feb-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of hard drives, tape drives, and neat SCSI accessories.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#367! <--------- NEW!
8500/120 16MB/2GB/4xCD Adobe Premiere/After Effects: $1799
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/24-Feb-97
------------------
**CFM-68K Beta** -- Last December, Apple recommended that owners
of 68K Macs disable the CFM-68K Runtime Enabler because it could
cause serious crashes and data loss with some applications (see
TidBITS-356_), and Mac OS 7.6 did not support CFM-68K. Now, Apple
has released CFM-68K Runtime Enabler 4.0b1 for 68K-based Macs.
Although Apple stresses that the beta is unsupported (so use it at
your own risk!), early tests indicate that 68K applications
requiring CFM can now run, with the exception of Cyberdog 1.2.x or
2.0. Apple plans to ship the new version of CFM-68K in Mac OS
7.6.1, an interim release due as early as next month. [GD]
<http://www.macos.apple.com/macos/cfm/cfmbeta.html>
**BBEdit 4.0.3** -- Bare Bones Software has updated BBEdit, the
commercial version of its popular text editor. (See TidBITS-365_.)
The new BBEdit 4.0.3 has improved FTP and HTML support, better
integration with CodeWarrior, and faster launch times, as well as
better performance on PowerPC 603 and 604 processors. The updater
is about 2.5 MB. [GD]
<http://www.barebones.com/updates.html>
**Emailer 2.0 Beta** -- Claris has announced a public beta of
Emailer 2.0, which now stores all its messages in a single file
(eliminating serious performance and storage problems with earlier
versions) and features enhanced filtering capabilities. Although
the Emailer 2.0 beta includes many improvements, my quick tests
show it's only stable enough for adventurous users. The download
is about 5 MB. [GD]
<http://www3.claris.com/emailer_beta/>
Selling Performas at the Front Lines
------------------------------------
by Ian Gregson <[email protected]>
Do you ever wonder why, when you walk into a large consumer
electronics store that sells Macs, the sales staff are not always
very helpful (or sometimes even friendly)? My experiences during
the last holiday shopping season gave me insight into why some
Macintosh buyers get the cold shoulder from sales staff.
I've used a Mac since 1989, and - just before Christmas - I
subcontracted with Apple on one of their in-store promotions,
called Apple Demo Days. After two days of training, I went to work
at the busiest Future Shop store in Canada's greater Vancouver,
B.C. region - which roughly translated into a pre-Christmas
shopping hell.
**Spiff and Span** -- I found that sales staff get kickbacks
(called "spiffs") from the computer companies for extra sales.
Acer, Compaq, IBM, and Apple all give incentives. Guess who gave
the best incentive at the stores I visited? Acer. Guess who sold
the most? Acer. Guess who gave the least incentive? Apple. Guess
which company sold the least? You get the idea.
Not only do incentives vary from one brand to another, but also
from one model to the next. For example, the incentives on the
Performa 6400/200 or 180 were considerably higher than on the new
6360.
The incentive scheme is probably the strongest motivator for sales
staff, and it translates into the sales staff spending more time
with a potential Acer Aspire buyer than a Macintosh buyer. It also
translates into sales staff pushing the Acer brand instead of the
Mac. "Ease of use" or "plug and play" have no meaning when the
sales staff receives incentives of up to 500 percent more.
In my time at Future Shop, the Acer Aspire sold at roughly a rate
of ten to one compared to the Macintosh. It was painful to watch.
Neophyte computer users had no idea what they were getting
themselves into. Most of them wanted a cheap machine that got them
on the Internet. The Aspire does that - eventually.
I spoke with many of these first-time computer buyers. My first
question was, "Have you ever considered a Macintosh?" Ninety
percent of the answers were "no" (and these were the polite
responses). I often received comments such as, "Is this a joke?",
"Does it do Windows?", and "My friends all have Windows 95 - why
should I buy a Mac?" After I bypassed their apparent dread of
anything Macintosh, people were always impressed with my demo.
Just putting a disk or CD in the drive and having it appear on the
desktop amazed people. The ease of use blew people away. Having
cable TV play through the Mac made people's jaws drop to the
floor. Some seriously considered the Mac as an alternative (for
about five minutes), and then bought an Acer anyway.
On a positive note, 90 percent of the Mac users were pleased to
see me. I had great conversations with long time Mac fans about
how great the Mac is and how lousy Apple is at marketing the Mac.
(The remaining 10 percent were Performa 6400 users who had bought
their machines when they first went on sale; Apple dropped the
price by about $700 Canandian two months after their
introduction).
It was obvious that new computer users were coming into the store
with preconceived notions about which computer to buy. They were
not coming to make a decision, they were coming to buy the
computer they had already chosen. Combined with the staff's
motivation to offer the Acer to anyone with the slightest doubt
about what to buy, this made for comparatively low Mac sales.
**What Should Apple Do?** Apple needs a more aggressive
advertising strategy in order to outsell the Acer Aspires of this
world. Though 30-minute infomercials are great, a creative,
intelligent 30-second ad can be more effective. Every medium must
be equally considered.
Although Apple incentives to sales staff have improved (all staff
at one Future Shop store, for example, received PowerBook 190s for
having the highest Macintosh sales over a given period), nothing
convinces commission-paid staff to sell more product than cold,
hard cash. I know this because I had several members of the sales
staff asking me to buy their PowerBooks from them.
If the Mac sales at large electronics stores are so disappointing,
why are Macs still offered in that channel? Because that's where
budget-conscious, first-time, don't-know-better computer users buy
their first machines. Future Shop stores are on the front line in
the battle for new consumer buying power.
There are still far more people without home-based computers than
with them. Apple must convert first-time computer buyers before
they even enter a store. Combine this with motivating the sales
staff to introduce Apple products to first-time buyers and Apple
sales figures could soar.
An Internet for the TV Generation
---------------------------------
by Mark H. Anbinder <[email protected]>
The Web has grabbed the attention of many people who hunger for
information and entertainment, and groups as varied as the
National Hockey League and the Oregon Shakespeare Festival have
put huge efforts into making their Web sites attractive and
informative. But, though TidBITS readers by definition already
have some form of Internet access, many families lack the
relatively modern computer, modem, and Internet service account
needed to get online.
<http://www.nhl.com/>
<http://www.mind.net/osf/>
New consumer electronics products from Philips Magnavox and Sony,
both licensing the WebTV name, make Web and email service
available to anyone whose home has a television set and a phone
line (just about everyone, although the set and phone jack must be
in close physical proximity). The sleek, black gizmos cost about
$300 (plus another $100 if you want the "optional" keyboard - you
do) and service is about $20 per month, less than most folks pay
for cable TV.
<http://www.sel.sony.com/SEL/webtv/index.html>
<http://www.magnavox.com/hottechnology/webtv/webtv.html>
<http://www.webtv.net/>
One big advantage of WebTV is that everything's ready. There are
no software programs to shuffle, no special utilities to download
if you want to listen to sound or view video, and no out of memory
errors or general protection faults. The unit has a built-in,
high-speed modem (33.6 Kbps v.34bis), so all you need to do is
hook up the cables from the WebTV to your telephone jack, an
electrical outlet, and your TV.
<http://www.webtv.net/corp/HTML/home.specs.html>
The WebTV concept is that home users want entertainment and
information to come to them. The basic WebTV model, with just a
handheld remote control and no keyboard, meets that goal. You can
browse to your heart's content, using arrow buttons on the remote
to move around a Web page, and the Go button to follow a link or
choose an option. This feels odd to someone accustomed to a mouse,
but isn't too foreign; it reminds me of programming a VCR.
WebTV displays Web pages on your television screen. Even if your
TV is much bigger than most computer screens, it can't display as
much information: TVs don't have as much resolution as even a 640
by 480 monitor, though the WebTV's S-Video port provides a
slightly better picture for TVs that support S-Video. Many Web
pages look quite different on a WebTV than they do in Netscape
Navigator or Microsoft Internet Explorer. For instance, thanks to
the interlaced nature of TV screens, horizontal rules flicker on a
WebTV if they are only one pixel high. Generally speaking, text
may wrap differently and graphics may appear elsewhere than the
designer intended. Web pages designed for unusually large monitors
(a bad idea in my opinion) will be difficult to deal with.
**Real Updates** -- The latest WebTV version supports RealAudio,
which enables Web users listen to concerts, newscasts, and other
sounds in real time. The bandwidth of a modem connection provides
high enough fidelity that voice (such as a newscast) sounds fine
and music (such as a concert broadcast) is passable. Early WebTV
buyers will find that their unit can update itself to include this
feature and others; when the WebTV developers complete new
abilities, each unit offers to retrieve the needed software and
update itself. Updates takes several minutes by modem, so the
WebTV asks if you'd like to take the time before it does so.
**Email for Everyone** -- WebTV can do email, too, and can keep
track of up to five private mailboxes. This kind of email is
probably best suited to writing to the kids at college, or having
Becky and Timmy drop Grandma a line. The WebTV can't fit enough
text on a TV screen to show much of an email message at once, and
the (Helvetica-like) proportional font makes formatted email
useless, but sending and receiving short messages should work
fine.
This brings us to the issue of typing. Most Internet users will
need to type from time to time, even if they never use email. To
tell your WebTV to visit "www.cnn.com" or "www.tidbits.com" you
must type the address. WebTV lets you use the remote control to
hunt-and-peck on an onscreen keyboard reminiscent of the Newton's;
this is easy to master (you can even switch between the standard
QWERTY typewriter layout and an alphabetical arrangement) but
painfully slow.
The keyboard uses the same infrared remote control technology as
the WebTV remote, so you can sit on the couch and type with the
keyboard on your lap. It's a compact keyboard, and might take some
getting used to, but it's much better for typing than the remote
control.
**Mark Likes It!** I was surprised that the WebTV's browser grew
on me; I've enjoyed the couch-potato approach to Web surfing and
appreciate the ability to pop up a Web page whose URL appears in a
TV program or commercial. In other words, even long-time Internet
users can be heavy WebTV users. Naturally, WebTV's target market
is the family that doesn't have a computer, but I can see real
value to adding a WebTV even for a connected family. While you're
at it, buy one for Grandma, too.
Bandwidth and Latency: It's the Latency, Stupid (Part 1)
--------------------------------------------------------
by Stuart Cheshire <[email protected]>
Years ago David Cheriton at Stanford University taught me
something that seemed obvious at the time - if you have a network
link with low bandwidth then it's easy to put several in parallel
to make a combined link with higher bandwidth, but if you have a
network link with bad latency then no amount of money can turn any
number of parallel links into a combined link with good latency.
Many years have passed, and these facts seem lost on the most
companies making networking hardware and software for the home. I
think the time has come to explain it.
**Speed & Capacity** -- Even smart people have trouble grasping
the implications of latency on throughput. Part of the problem is
the misleading use of the word "faster." Would you say a Boeing
747 is three times faster than a Boeing 737? Of course not. They
both cruise at around 500 miles per hour. The difference is that
the 747 carries 500 passengers where as the 737 only carries 150.
The Boeing 747 is three times _bigger_ than the Boeing 737, not
faster.
If you were in a hurry to get to London, you'd take the Concorde,
which cruises around 1,350 miles per hour. It seats only 100
passengers though, so it's the smallest of the three. Size and
speed are not the same thing.
On the other hand, if you had to transport 1,500 people and you
only had one airplane to do it, the 747 could do it in three trips
while the 737 would take ten. So, you might say the Boeing 747 can
transport large numbers of people three times faster than a Boeing
737, but you would never say that a Boeing 747 _is_ three times
faster than a Boeing 737.
That's one problem with communications devices today.
Manufacturers say _speed_ when they mean _capacity_. The other
problem is that as far as end-users are concerned, the main thing
they want to do is transfer large files more quickly. It may seem
to make sense that a high-capacity, slow link would be the best
thing for the job. What end users don't see is that in order to
manage that file transfer, their computers are sending dozens of
little control messages back and forth. Computer communication
differs from television or radio broadcasting in the interactivity
of the communication, and interactivity depends on back-and-forth
messages.
The phrase "high-capacity, slow link" above probably looks odd to
you. It looks odd even to me. We've been used to wrong thinking
for so long that correct thinking looks odd now. How can a high-
capacity link be a slow link? High-capacity means fast, right?
It's odd how that's not true in other areas. If someone talks
about a high-capacity oil tanker, do you immediately assume it's a
fast ship? If someone talks about a large-capacity truck, do you
immediately assume it's faster than a small sports car?
We must start making this distinction again in communications.
When someone tells us that a modem has a speed of 28.8 Kbps we
have to remember that 28.8 Kbps is its capacity, not its speed.
Speed is a measure of distance divided by time, and "bits" is not
a measure of distance.
But there's more to perceived throughput than issues of speed and
capacity, namely latency. Many people know that when you buy a
hard disk you should check its seek time. The maximum transfer
rate is something you might also be concerned with, but seek time
is more important. Why does no one think to ask about a modem's
seek time? Latency is the same thing as seek time: the minimum
time between asking for a piece of data and getting it, just like
the seek time of a disk, and it's just as important.
**Monkey On Your Back** -- Once you have bad latency you're stuck
with it. If you want to transfer a large file over your modem it
might take several minutes. The less data you send, the less time
it takes, but there's a limit. No matter how small the amount of
data, for any particular network device there's always a minimum
time that you can never beat. That's called the latency of the
device. For a typical Ethernet connection the latency is usually
about 0.3 ms (milliseconds, or thousandths of a second). For a
typical modem link, ping and traceroute tests show the latency is
typically about 100 ms, about 300 times worse than Ethernet.
If you wanted to send ten characters (at eight bits per character)
over your 33 Kbps modem link you might think it would take:
80 bits / 33000 bits per second = 2.4 ms
Unfortunately, it doesn't. It takes 102.4 ms because of the 100 ms
latency introduced by the modems at each end of the link.
If you want to send a large amount of data, say 100K, then that
takes 25 seconds, and the 100 ms latency isn't very noticeable,
but for smaller amounts of data, say 100 bytes, the latency
overwhelms the transmission time.
Why would you care about this? Why do small pieces of data matter?
For most end-users it's the time it takes to transfer big files
that annoys them, not small files, so they don't even think about
latency when buying products. In fact, if you look at the boxes
modems come in, they proudly proclaim "28.8 Kbps" and "33.6 Kbps",
but they don't mention latency at all.
What most people don't realize is that computers must exchange
hundreds of little control messages in the process of transferring
big files, so the performance of small data packets _directly_
affects the performance of everything else on the network.
Now, imagine you live in a world where the only network connection
you can get to your house is a modem running over a telephone
line. Your modem has a latency of 100 ms, but you're doing
something that needs lower latency. Maybe you're trying to do
audio over the network. 100 ms may not sound like much, but it's
enough to cause a noticeable delay and echo in voice
communications, which makes conversation difficult. Maybe you're
playing an interactive game over the network. The game only sends
tiny amounts of data, but that 100 ms delay makes the
interactivity of the game decidedly sluggish.
What can you do about this? Absolutely _nothing_. You could
compress the data, but that won't help: the data was already
small, and that 100 ms latency is still there. You could install
80 phone lines in parallel and simultaneously send a single bit
over each phone line, but that 100 ms latency is still there.
In other words, once you have a device with bad latency there's
nothing you can do except replace the device with one that has
good latency.
**Modem Latency** -- Current consumer devices have appallingly bad
latency. A typical Ethernet card has a latency less than 1 ms. The
Internet backbone as a whole also has very good latency. Here's a
real example:
* The distance from Stanford in California to MIT in Boston is
4320 km
* The speed of light in vacuum is 300 * 10^6 m/s
* The speed of light in fibre is 60 percent of the speed of light
in vacuum
* The speed of light in fibre is 300 * 10^6 m/s * 0.6 =
180 * 10^6 m/s
* The one-way delay to MIT is 4320 km / 180 * 10^6 m/s = 24 ms
* The round-trip time to MIT and back is 48 ms
* The current ping time from Stanford to MIT over today's Internet
is about 85 ms:
* 84.5 ms / 48 ms = 1.76
* The hardware of the Internet can currently achieve speed
of light + 76 percent
So the Internet is doing pretty well. It may get better with time,
but we know it can never beat the speed of light. In other words,
that 85 ms round-trip time to MIT might reduce a bit, but it's
never going to beat 48 ms. The speed can improve a bit, but it
isn't going to double. We're already within a factor of two of the
theoretical optimum. I think that's pretty good - not many
technologies can make that claim.
Compare this with a modem. Suppose you're 18 km from your Internet
service provider. At the speed of light in fibre (or the speed of
electricity in copper, which is about the same) the latency should
be:
18000 / (180 * 10^6 m/s) = 0.1 ms
Although modems vary, the latency over your modem is anywhere from
75 ms to about 130 ms. Modems are currently operating at a level
that's more than 1,000 times worse than the speed of light. And,
of course, latency cuts both ways. If a one-way trip using a
typical modem has a latency of about 130 ms, then the round-trip
delay is about 260 ms.
Of course no modem link will ever have a latency of 0.1 ms. I'm
not expecting that. The important issue is the total end-to-end
transmission delay for a packet - the time from the moment the
transmitting software sends the packet to the moment the last bit
of the packet is delivered to the software at the receiving end.
The total end-to-end transmission delay is made up of fixed
latency (including the speed-of-light propagation delay), plus the
transmission time. For a 36 byte packet the transmission time is
10 ms (the time it takes to send 288 bits at a rate of 28.8 Kbps).
When the actual transmission time is only 10 ms, working to make
the latency 0.1 ms would be silly. All that's needed is that the
latency should be relatively small compared to the transmission
time. About 5 ms would be a sensible latency target for a modem
that has a transmission rate of 28.8 Kbps.
**Understanding Transmission Delay** -- At each hop, overall
transmission time has two components: per-byte transmission time
and fixed overhead. Per-byte transmission time is easy to
calculate, since it depends only on the raw transmission rate. The
fixed overhead comes from sources like software overhead, hardware
overhead, and speed of light delay.
For modems, the distance is typically short, so speed of light
delay should be negligible. However, the data rate is low, so it
takes a long time to send each byte. The per-byte transmission
time should account for most of the time taken to send the packet.
To send 100 bytes over a 28.8 Kbps modem should take:
100 bytes * 8 bits per byte / 28800 bits per second = 28 ms
That means the round-trip should be twice that, or 56 ms. In
reality it's often more like 260 ms. What's going on? Two other
factors contribute to the overall time.
First, modems are often connected via serial ports. Many modem
users assume that if they connect their 28.8 Kbps modem to their
serial port at 38.4 Kbps they won't limit their performance,
because 38.4 is greater than 28.8. It's true that the serial port
won't limit throughput, but it will add delay, and delay, once
added, never goes away. So, sending 100 bytes down the serial port
to the modem should take:
100 bytes * 10 bits per byte / 38400 bps = 26 ms
Second, modems try to group data into blocks. The modem will wait
for about 50 ms to see if more data is coming that it could add to
the block, before it starts to send the data it already has. Let's
see what the total time is now:
26 ms (100 bytes down serial port to modem)
50 ms (modem's fixed waiting time)
28 ms (transmission time over telephone line at 28.8 Kbps)
26 ms (100 bytes up serial port at receiving end)
Thus, the total time is 130 ms each way, or 260 ms for the round-
trip. To make things worse, imagine that the 100 bytes in question
are used by an interactive game being played by two players. If
both players are connected to their respective Internet service
providers by modem, then the total player-to-player round-trip
delay is 520 ms, which is hopeless for any tightly-coupled
interactivity, and this is reflected in the state of today's
networked computer games. Can we do anything to improve this?
**Improving Latency** -- One thing to notice is that the 38.4 Kbps
serial connection between the computer and the modem, which many
people don't think of as being the bottleneck, turns out to be
responsible for 52 ms of the delay. In fact, it's the single
biggest contributor - almost twice as much as the actual
communication over the telephone line. What can we do about this?
If you can connect the modems at both ends at 115.2 Kbps instead
of 38.4 Kbps, the serial port delay can be reduced to 9 ms at each
end. Better still, if you can use an internal modem on a card
instead of one connected through a serial port, the delay can be
eliminated entirely, leaving a round-trip delay of only 156 ms.
Having eliminated the serial port delay, the next biggest
contributor to delay is the fixed 50 ms overhead built into the
modem itself. Why is there a fixed 50 ms overhead? The reason is
that modern modems offer lots of "features" - namely, compression
and automatic error correction. To get effective compression and
error correction, modems must work on blocks of data, which means
characters are corralled in a buffer until the modem has received
a block big enough to work on efficiently. While the characters
accumulate in the modem's buffer, they're not being sent over the
phone line. Imagine you're sending a small amount of data, 100
bytes. That's not enough for the modem to work on effectively, so
it would like a bigger block. After you have sent the 100 bytes to
the modem, it waits to see if more characters arrive. After some
time - about 50 ms - it decides no more characters are coming, so
it compresses and ships what it has. That 50 ms the modem spends
hoping for more data is unrecoverable, wasted time.
Modems were originally designed with remote terminal access in
mind. They were meant to take characters - typed by a user on one
end and transmitted by a mainframe on the other - and group them
into little blocks to send. The only indication that a user had
finished typing (or that the mainframe had finished responding)
was a pause in the data stream. No one told the modem when no more
characters would be coming for a while, so it had to guess.
This is no longer the case. Most people use modems to connect to
the Internet, not old mainframes, and Internet traffic is made up
of discrete packets, not a continuous stream of characters.
There's a simple fix for this problem. We could make modems aware
that they are sending Internet packets. When a modem sees the PPP
(Point to Point Protocol) End-Of-Packet character (0x7E), it could
realize that the packet is complete and immediately begin
compressing and sending the block of data it has, without pausing
for 50 ms. This simple fix would eliminate the 50 ms fixed
overhead, and should allow us to achieve a 56 ms round-trip delay
over a modem PPP connection - almost five times better than what
typical modems achieve today.
[Tune in next week as Stuart explains how bandwidth and latency
interact, and how software can try to cope with the latency
problem.]
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.267 | Issue #368 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Mar 04 1997 11:07 | 618 |
|
TidBITS#368/03-Mar-97
=====================
Are you a hotshot at using Macs to build full-text search engines
for the Web? Enter the first-ever TidBITS Macintosh Search Tool
Shootout! Also this week, we bring you part two of Stuart
Cheshire's article on latency and bandwidth, plus information on
new versions of Internet Explorer and Quicken. Also, our field
correspondents report on highlights from Macworld Tokyo, and we
call for additional TidBITS translators.
Topics:
MailBITS/03-Mar-97
TidBITS Macintosh Search Tool Shootout
Macworld Tokyo: Of Cameras and Macs
Bandwidth and Latency: It's the Latency, Stupid (Part 2)
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-368.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#368_03-Mar-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]> <-------- NEW!
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#368! <--------- NEW!
NEW Power Mac 7200/120 - 32 MB RAM, 1.2 GB HD, 8xCD: $1295
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/03-Mar-97
------------------
**Translators Needed** -- For the last year or so, teams of
dedicated volunteer translators have created award-winning
translations of TidBITS in Chinese, Dutch, French, German,
Japanese, and Spanish. These teams could use additional volunteers
to spread the load. Each team works a bit differently, but all
could use more volunteers to translate an article every week or
so. If you're interested in helping support the Macintosh in your
country or language, please contact the appropriate coordinator
below. [ACE]
Chinese -- Peter <[email protected]>
Dutch -- Sander Lam <[email protected]>
French -- Chantal David <[email protected]>
German -- Walter J. Ferstl <[email protected]>
Japanese -- Shuichi Odaka <[email protected]>
Spanish -- Javier Pedreira <[email protected]>
**Microsoft Internet Explorer 3.0a** -- Although I use a variety
of browsers to view and test Web sites, I'm using Microsoft's
Internet Explorer with increasing regularity. With the release of
version 3.0a (PowerPC-only, alas) last week, Microsoft has
resolved problems with deleting cache files, repeatedly reloading
some Web pages, Challenge Response Protocol (used when accessing
secured pages), and loading Java under MacTCP. Minimum and full
install versions are available, ranging in size from 2.1 MB to
nearly 8 MB. [JLC]
<http://www.microsoft.com/msdownload/ieplatform/iemac.htm>
**Steve Becker** <[email protected]> writes:
Intuit has released an R6 update for Quicken 7 and Quicken 7
Deluxe. The update fixes several bugs (see TidBITS-353_ and
TidBITS-359_), and the non-standard ROI (Return On Investment)
calculation in the Portfolio window has been replaced by the
preferred ROI calculation used in the Investment Performance
report. In addition, Q7 users may wish to know that Connectix's
Speed Doubler can significantly speed the opening of Register
windows, and indexing error warnings can sometimes be avoided by
increasing Quicken's memory allocation (an additional 1 MB worked
for me).
<http://www.intuit.com/quicken/technical-support/quicken/releases/
qfm7-releases/>
**Get Even Richer** -- If you were intrigued by the Crack A Mac
challenge underway in Sweden to break into a Macintosh Web server
(see TidBITS-365_) but felt pot wasn't sweet enough, you might be
interested to know that several Mac resellers have donated
additional funds to raise the jackpot to over $10,000 U.S. Of
course, you still have to alter the target server's home page to
claim the money. The contest runs through 10-Apr-97. [GD]
<http://hacke.infinit.se/indexeng.html>
TidBITS Macintosh Search Tool Shootout
--------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
For some time, we've been lamenting the fact that TidBITS doesn't
have a good, full-text, search engine. Years ago, Ephraim Vishniac
set up an excellent WAIS source for TidBITS, but that was when
Thinking Machines ran the public WAIS server on their Connection
Machine. That service eventually went away, and several attempts
were made to replace it. The current search engine is run by
Sensei Consulting in Australia, and although it's welcome, we
often hear of troubles accessing it. In addition, searches return
entire issues, rather than articles, so you must also search
within the returned issue.
A variety of searching tools that run on Macs have appeared over
the years, but we've never had the proper combination of time,
hardware, and experience to put them through their paces. So,
we've come up with a different method for evaluating these pieces
of software - we're going to have a search tool shootout!
We have a number of goals in mind. First, we want to pull out the
best search tools for the Macintosh among the numerous contenders.
Second, we want to let the creators of these programs strut their
stuff. Third, we want to provide a way for people to search
TidBITS easily.
**Who Can Participate?** Anyone can participate, although we
expect that those who have written search tools will be the most
interested, since this will give them a chance to show off in a
real-world test that will be useful to thousands of people. If,
however, you're a consultant and specialize in setting up
Macintosh-based search tools, you're welcome to compete.
**What's the Test?** Once everyone who has expressed interest in
participating has contacted our Managing Editor Jeff Carlson at
<[email protected]>, we'll provide access to all back issues of
TidBITS, in HTML format. No pansying around here - the competition
will use the contents of over 360 issues of TidBITS, about 11 MB
of text covering the last seven years. Once everyone has the
issues, they can set up their search engines. We don't have
anywhere near enough Macs to host this, so contestants will have
to provide their own hardware and Internet connection. Technical
questions regarding our format or other issues can be directed to
me at <[email protected]>.
**Specification** -- No contest would be complete without rules.
All entries:
* Must offer full-text search capabilities of all TidBITS issues.
* Must be made with and run on a single Macintosh running the Mac
OS.
* Must be accessible via the Web.
* Must automatically integrate new issues every week.
* Must return results at an article level (articles all start with
<H2> tags).
* Must display results using HTML source from TidBITS issues,
including hot links.
In addition, these bonus items could be included and will improve
an entry's chance of winning:
* Sorting results by date or relevance
* Low cost
* Short setup time
* Other additional features, such as suggesting alternative sites
to search if a search comes up empty
**The Time Frame** -- We don't expect contestants to drop
everything and start working on this full time - in fact, we'd
prefer to hear things in the best entries like "Yeah, I whipped
this off while I was waiting for my pizza to arrive." The
Macintosh is about ease-of-use, and we hope that it won't be
difficult to set up these systems. Here are the dates to watch:
* 17-Mar-97: Deadline for entering the contest.
* 21-Apr-97: Deadline for completing entries. Judging starts.
* 12-May-97: Winner announced.
**How Will We Judge?** Implementation details are up to the people
participating in the shootout, but we have guidelines that
contestants should keep in mind. All of the specifications should
be met, although we won't disqualify entries for not meeting all
of them (other than the Mac and Web requirements, which aren't
negotiable).
* Compliance with the specifications
* Speed of searching, independent of connection speed
* Attractive and usable interface for the search page
* Attractive and readable results pages
* Cost and setup time
* Additional features
**The Prizes** -- Obviously, a contest requires prizes, and we'll
reward the winning entry (or entries) with the main thing we have
- exposure to an estimated 150,000 Macintosh users. We plan to
write about the shootout, looking at each entry and concentrating
on the best of the crop. Then, assuming everything works out,
we'll implement the best solution on our servers for everyone to
use, giving that entry full credit and significant exposure. Other
contestants can continue to host their searchable archives of
TidBITS as a real-world demonstration of what their software can
do, and we'll link to those who keep the archive up-to-date with
new issues.
Macworld Tokyo: Of Cameras and Macs
-----------------------------------
by Chuck and Linda Shotton <[email protected]>
The Tokyo version of Macworld Expo always comes off brighter,
perkier, and quite different from the Macworld shows held in
Boston and San Francisco. Booths are generally larger, have more
staff, and the "booth babe" is a staple of nearly every venue. If
one thing stands out, it's the diversity of products. In addition
to items seen at the U.S. shows, Macworld Tokyo features an entire
hemisphere's worth of products, ideas, and technologies. Our
mission was to ferret out products that aren't generally available
in the U.S. or aren't widely known by the Mac community in the
States.
**Digital Cameras** -- Our first quest sent us on the rounds of
the digital camera vendors. The roll-out of Apple's new QuickTake
200 camera begs comparison to some new products offered by
Japanese companies. We tried to limit ourselves to notable cameras
in the $250 to $1,500 range.
Fujifilm was demonstrating its new Fujix DS-300 camera. Although
one of the more expensive offerings (educated guesses put it
around $1,400), it packs a lot of capability into a package the
size of a normal SLR 35 mm camera. In addition to RS-232 and NTSC
interfaces, this camera boasts a PC Card slot and a SCSI
interface. But the big surprise is a whopping 1280 by 1000 high-
resolution mode. You can save 8 photos at this resolution in JPEG
or TIFF format, 30 in "fine" resolution, 62 in the normal 640 by
480 mode, and 121 photos in "basic" mode, with reduced resolution.
This camera takes normal 35 mm lenses, and the CCD will emulate
film speeds from ISO 100 to ISO 400.
<http://www.fujifilm.co.jp/noah/>
At the other end of the price spectrum was Panasonic's Cool Shot
(KXL-600A-N). This pistol-grip camera is about the size of a 3" by
5" index card, less than an inch thick, and fits comfortably in
your palm. It avoids the battery-sucking color LCD viewfinders of
its competitors, opting for the simple point-and-shoot viewfinder
lens found one-button film cameras. The Cool Shot accepts standard
Type 2 PC Cards and stores either 24 640 by 480 images or 96 320
by 240 images on a 2 MB card. The major attraction of this camera
is its small size and the one-hand operation allowed by its unique
form factor. It has an optional external LCD viewer, a docking
station for use with a desktop computer, and software for Macs and
PCs. Prices range from $400 to $800.
<http://www.panasonic.co.jp/cbdo/p3/>
New lines of cameras from Ricoh and Sharp also caught our
attention. Sharp's new camera was a PC Card with a built-in
digital camera. Designed to work with the Zaurus color PDA, the
card could be popped from a portable power supply into a laptop
where the images could be accessed immediately. Ricoh's DC-2
camera series has the unique ability to capture not only still
images, but full-motion video and/or audio soundtracks and
annotations. The basic stills-only model (DC-2E) starts around
$650, with the 2L and 2V models including video and audio
capabilities for about $800 and $950 respectively.
<http://www.ricoh.co.jp/dc/index.html>
**Pioneering Macs** -- Though Apple's new hardware announcements
were a big hit, Pioneer was showing a couple of new Macs that
would be welcome on my desktop. The Pioneer clones packed serious
horsepower in a mini tower package with features that are
unavailable in the U.S. right now. The most exciting feature was
CHRP (PPCP) compliance, with the MPC-GX2 model running the CHRP
version of System 7.6. Powered by a 200 MHz 604e with 32 MB of
memory and 512K of L2 cache, the box seemed very responsive. In
addition to the usual Macintosh ports, this box sports four PCI
slots, one ISA slot, two IDE channels, a 2 GB SCSI hard disk, and
the usual set of mouse, serial, and parallel ports found on an
Intel PC. Best of all, a DVD-ROM drive tops the tower. The demo
was playing a full-screen version of the latest James Bond movie,
Goldeneye, while running System 7 applications in the foreground.
Most impressive. Retail prices weren't available but prices seemed
to start around $3,500.
<http://www.pioneer.co.jp/comp/>
**Read My Mind** -- Other notable hardware included revised
versions of the AtMark Pippin boxes and the IBVA brainwave
hardware, which had the coolest demo of all, with direct
brainwave-to-MIDI output allowing the user to "think" new music.
The new software has an open plug-in architecture that allows you
to hook the brainwave hardware and software to nearly any Mac
application through the addition of scripts and so on. The
possibilities seem novel and exciting, though the cost in Japan
was around $1,000 for the wireless headset, base station, and
associated software.
<http://www.opendoor.com/Pagoda/IBVA.html>
**Englishbonics** -- On the software front, one of the more useful
products was an English language tutor called English Now! from
Transparent Language, Inc. This product combines, written, spoken,
and visual elements into a system that provides a comprehensive
language learning environment. Features include the ability to see
English text as each word is highlighted and spoken in a variety
of synthesized voices, record your own voice and compare it to
sonographs of correctly spoken words, and numerous lessons and
games involving translating Japanese text to English and vice
versa, spoken text into written words, etc. I was very impressed
with the completeness of the package. English Now! costs
approximately $100 on CD-ROM for both Mac and Windows.
<http://www.three-a.co.jp/>
**Overall** -- There was more to see than we were able to get to
during our two days at the show. Apple's new hardware was nice,
but incremental in its innovation. I give a big thumbs up to the
Pioneer clones (and Pioneer's side-by-side demo of a 25-inch, flat
panel LCD display - a mere two inches thick!) as the cool hardware
for the show, followed closely by the IBVA package. Cool software
definitely goes to English Now! Though I'm no expert in computer-
aided language instruction, it seemed to me that you could succeed
in learning English if you worked through its lessons.
Bandwidth and Latency: It's the Latency, Stupid (Part 2)
--------------------------------------------------------
by Stuart Cheshire <[email protected]>
[Last week in TidBITS-367_, Stuart examined issues of latency and
delay in typical modem-based Internet communications. This week,
Stuart offers general observations on how bandwidth can be used
more efficiently and how it effects the overall latency of a
connection.]
Last week, I asked readers to imagine a world where the only
network connection you can get to your house is a modem running
over a telephone line at 33 Kbps. Now, imagine that this is not
enough bandwidth for your needs. You have a problem.
**Making Bandwidth is Easy** -- Technically, the solution is
simple. You can install two telephone lines and use them in
parallel, giving you a total of 66 Kbps. If you need more capacity
you can install ten telephone lines, for a total of 330 Kbps.
Sure, it's expensive, having ten modems in a pile is inconvenient,
and you may have to write networking software to share the data
evenly between the ten lines. But if it was sufficiently
important, it could be done. People with ISDN lines already do
this using a process called BONDING (which is short for "Bandwidth
ON Demand INteroperability Group"), which enables them to use two
64 Kbps ISDN channels in parallel for a combined throughput of 128
Kbps.
Getting additional bandwidth is possible, even if it's not always
economical. However, equally important is that making limited
bandwidth go further is easy.
**Compression** -- Compression is an easy way to increase
bandwidth. You can apply general purpose compression (such as
StuffIt) to the data. Even better, you can apply data-specific
compression (such as JPEG for still images and MPEG for video),
which can provide much higher compression ratios.
These compression techniques trade off use of CPU power for lower
bandwidth requirements. However, there's no equivalent way to
trade off use of extra CPU power to make up for poor latency.
All modern modems utilize internal compression algorithms.
Unfortunately, having your modem do compression is nowhere near as
good as having your computer do it. Your computer has a powerful,
expensive, fast CPU, whereas your modem has a feeble, cheap, slow
processor. In addition, as we noted last week, a modem must hold
on to data until it has a block big enough to compress
effectively. This requirement adds latency, and once added,
latency can't be eliminated. Also, since the modem doesn't know
what kind of data you're sending, it can't use superior data-
specific compression algorithms. In fact, since most images and
sounds on Web pages are already compressed, a modem's attempts to
compress the data a second time adds more latency without any
benefit.
This is not to say that having a modem do compression never helps.
When the host software at the endpoints of the connection is not
smart and doesn't compress data appropriately, then the modem's
own compression can compensate somewhat and improve throughput.
The bottom line is that modem compression only helps dumb
software, and it hurts smart software by adding extra delay.
**Send Less Data** -- Another way to cope with limited bandwidth
is to write programs that take care not to waste bandwidth. For
example, to reduce packet size, wherever possible Bolo (my
interactive network tank game) uses bytes instead of 16-bit or
32-bit words.
<http://rescomp.stanford.edu/~cheshire/Bolo.html>
For many kinds of interactive software like games, it's not
important to carry a lot of data. What's important is that when
the little bits of data are delivered, they are delivered quickly.
Bolo was originally developed running over serial ports at 4800
bps and could support eight players that way. Over 28.8 Kbps
modems it can barely support two players with acceptable response
time. Why? A direct-connect serial port at 4800 bps has a latency
of 2 ms. A 28.8 Kbps baud modem has a latency of 100 ms, 50 times
worse than the 4800 bps serial connection.
Software can cope with limited bandwidth by sending less data. If
a program doesn't have enough bandwidth to send high-resolution
pictures, it could use a lower resolution. If a program doesn't
have enough bandwidth to send colour images, it could send black-
and-white images, or images with dramatically reduced colour
detail (which is what NTSC television does). If there isn't enough
bandwidth to send 30 frames per second, the software could send 15
fps, 5 fps, or fewer.
These trade-offs aren't pleasant, but they are possible. You can
pay for more bandwidth or send less data to stay within your
limited available bandwidth. However, if the latency is not good
enough to meet your needs you don't have the same option. Running
multiple circuits in parallel won't improve latency, and sending
less data won't help either.
**Caching** -- One of the most effective techniques for improving
computer and network performance is caching. If you visit a Web
site, your browser can copy the text and images to your hard disk.
If you visit the site again, the browser verifies that the stored
copies are up-to-date, and - if so - the browser just displays the
local copies.
Checking the date and time a file was last modified is a tiny
request to send across the network - so small that modem
throughput makes no difference. Latency is all that matters.
Recently, some companies have begun providing CD-ROMs of entire
Web sites to speed Web browsing. When browsing these Web sites,
all the Web browser does is check the modification date of each
file it accesses to verify that CD-ROM copy is up-to-date. It must
download from the Web only files that have changed since the
CD-ROM was made. Since most large files on a Web site are images,
and since images on a Web site change far less frequently than the
HTML text files, in most cases little data has to transfer.
Once again, because the Web browser is primarily doing small,
modification date queries to the Web server, latency determines
performance and throughput is virtually irrelevant.
**Latency Workarounds** -- ISDN has a latency of about 10 ms. Its
throughput may be twice that of a modem, but its latency is ten
times better, and that's the key reason why browsing the Web over
an ISDN link feels faster than over a modem.
One reason standard modems have such poor latency is that they
don't know what you're doing with your computer, or why. An
external modem is usually connected through a serial port, and all
it sees is an unstructured stream of bytes coming down the serial
port.
Ironically, the much-maligned Apple GeoPort Telecom Adapter may
solve this problem. The Apple GeoPort Telecom Adapter connects
your computer to a telephone line, but it's not a modem. Instead,
all modem functions are performed by software running on the Mac.
The main reason for the criticism is that this extra software
takes up memory and slows down the Mac, but in theory it _could_
offer an advantage no external modem could match. When you use the
GeoPort Telecom Adapter, the modem software is running on the same
CPU as your TCP/IP software and your Web browser, so it could know
exactly what you are doing. When your Web browser sends a TCP
packet, the GeoPort modem software doesn't have to mimic the
behaviour of current modems. It could take that packet, encode it,
and send it over the telephone line immediately, with almost zero
latency.
Sending 36 bytes of data, a typical game-sized packet, over an
Apple GeoPort Telecom Adapter running at 28.8 Kbps could take as
little as 10 ms, making it as fast as ISDN, and ten times faster
than the best modem you can buy today. For less than the price of
a typical modem, the GeoPort Telecom Adapter could give you Web
browsing performance close to that of ISDN. Even better, people
who already own Apple GeoPort Telecom Adapters would need only a
software upgrade.
**Bandwidth Still Matters** -- Having said all this, you should
not conclude that I believe bandwidth is unimportant. It is very
important, but not in the way most people think. Bandwidth is
valuable for its own sake, but also for its effect on overall
latency - the important issue is the total end-to-end transmission
delay for a data packet.
Remember the example in the first part of this article comparing
the capacity of a Boeing 747 to a 737? Here's a real world example
of the same issue. Many people believe that a private 64 Kbps ISDN
connection is as good (or even better) as a 1/160 share of a 10
Mbps Ethernet connection. Telephone companies argue that ISDN is
as good as new technologies like cable modems because though cable
modems have much higher bandwidth, that bandwidth is shared
between lots of users so the average works out the same. This
reasoning is flawed, as the following example will show.
Say we have a game where the data representing the game's overall
state amounts to 40K. We have a game server, and in this simple
example, the server transmits the entire game state to a player
once every ten seconds. That's 40K every 10 seconds, an average of
4K per second or 32 Kbps. That's only half the capacity of a 64
Kbps ISDN line, and 160 users doing this on an Ethernet network
will utilize only half the capacity of the Ethernet. So far so
good: both links are running at 50 percent capacity, so the
performance should be the same, right?
Wrong. On the Ethernet, when the server sends the 40K to a player,
the player can receive that data as little as 32 ms later (40K /
10 Mbps). If the game server is not the only machine sending
packets on the Ethernet, then there could be contention for the
shared medium, but even in that case the average delay before the
player receives the data is only 64 ms. On the ISDN line, when the
server sends the 40K to a player, the player receives that data
five seconds later (40K / 64 Kbps). In both cases the users have
the same average bandwidth, but the actual performance is
different. In the Ethernet case, the player receives the data
almost instantly because of the connection's high capacity. But in
the ISDN case, the connection's lower capacity means the
information is already 5 seconds old when the player receives it.
The problem is that sending a 40K chunk every ten seconds and
sending data at a uniform rate of 4K per second are not the same
thing. If they were, ISDN, ATM, and other telephone company
schemes would be good ideas. Telephone companies assume all
communications are like the flow of fluid in a pipe. You just tell
them the rate of flow you need, and they tell you how big the pipe
has to be. Voice calls work like the flow of fluid in a pipe, but
computer data does not. Computer data comes in lumps. A common
mistake is to think that sending 60K of data once per minute is
exactly the same as sending 1K per second. It's not. A 1K per
second connection may be sufficient _capacity_ to carry the amount
of data you're sending, but that doesn't mean it will deliver the
entire 60K in a timely fashion. It won't. By the time the lump
finishes arriving, it will be one minute old.
The conclusion here is obvious: the capacity of a connection has a
profound affect on its performance. If you're given the choice
between a low bandwidth private connection, or a small share of a
larger bandwidth connection, take the small share. Again, this is
painfully obvious outside the computer world. If a government said
it would build either a large shared freeway, or a million, tiny,
separate footpaths, one reserved for each citizen, which would you
vote for?
**What Can You Do?** I've received numerous messages from people
who want to know what they can do to spread the word about these
latency and bandwidth problems. I've found that calling modem
vendors directly is futile, so I recommend that you circulate
these two articles to friends who might find them interesting, and
most important, send letters to editors of major magazines asking
them to include latency times via ping and traceroute when testing
modems for review. Perhaps if we can raise awareness about the
horrible latency problems that all modems suffer, modem
manufacturers will start putting effort into decreasing latency
instead of just increasing throughput.
[Portions of this article come from Stuart Cheshire's white paper
entitled "Latency and the Quest for Interactivity," commissioned
by Volpe Welty Asset Management, L.L.C.]
<http://rescomp.stanford.edu/~cheshire/papers/LatencyQuest.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.268 | Issue #369 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Mar 11 1997 09:28 | 597 |
|
TidBITS#369/10-Mar-97
=====================
How long will you wait for Mac OS 8? Only a few months, as Apple
re-christens Tempo. Also this week, we bring you news on a final
release of CFM-68K, increases in Mac OS market share, and a sweet
deal from Apple for some Performa owners. Plus, we take a look at
feedback from readers on retail Macintosh sales, and Matt Neuburg
offers an in-depth look at the multimedia authoring program
SuperCard 3.0.
Topics:
MailBITS/10-Mar-97
Eight is Enough (and More Apple News)
Front Lines Follow-up
Surprised by SuperCard
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-369.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#369_10-Mar-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* EarthLink Network -- 800/395-8425 -- <[email protected]>
Direct Internet access for Mac users. New Personal Start Page,
no setup fee for TidBITS readers! <http://www.earthlink.net/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#367! <--------- NEW!
US Robotics Sportster 56K (x2 Technology) Fax Modem: $199
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/10-Mar-97
------------------
**CFM-68K 4.0 ** -- Apple has released version 4.0 of the CFM-68K
Runtime Enabler, which corrects "all known problems" with previous
versions of the component (see TidBITS-356_). CFM-68K allows
applications that require the Code Fragment Manager (like
LaserWriter 8.4, Cyberdog, AOL 3.0, and Microsoft Internet
Explorer 3.0) to run on 68K machines. Now that a final version of
CFM-68K is available, releases of CFM applications for 68K
machines should appear shortly. [JLC]
<ftp://ftp.info.apple.com/Apple_Support_Area/Apple_SW_Updates/US/
Macintosh/System/CFM-68K/>
**Info-Mac Shutting Down for Two Weeks** -- Beginning 12-Mar-97,
the Info-Mac software archive and mailing list will be down for
two weeks to allow the all-volunteer Info-Mac moderators to shift
their operations from the venerable sumex-aim.stanford.edu to a
new machine. No new uploads or digest messages will be accepted
during this time, although Info-Mac mirrors worldwide will of
course still be available. We'll put an announcement in TidBITS
when Info-Mac is up and running at its new home at MIT. [GD]
**Fetch 3.0.2 Released** -- As companies have begun to use the
Internet to deliver software directly to users, file sizes seem to
have grown exponentially. And frequently, as you download these
huge files, your modem connection will break, requiring you to
download the whole thing again. Fetch 3.0.2 circumvents this
problem by incorporating a Resume Download feature that attempts
to pick up where the first connection left off, assuming the
specific FTP server you're using supports it. Other improvements
in this release include greater stability with Open Transport, and
incorporation of Stuart Cheshire's Natural Order sorting algorithm
(see TidBITS-364_). [JLC]
<http://www.dartmouth.edu/pages/softdev/fetch.html>
**Internal Ethernet for PowerBook 1400** -- Dayna Communications,
Inc. recently announced plans to ship an internal Ethernet adapter
for the PowerBook 1400 series this spring. The 10Base-T adapter
will install under the laptop's keyboard rather than in one of the
computer's two PC Card slots. Dayna and other manufacturers
already offer PowerBook-compatible PC Cards with 10Base-T or
10Base-2 (thin) Ethernet ports, and combination cards with
Ethernet ports and data/fax modem features. [MHA]
<http://www.dayna.com/dayna/pressreleases/pb1400.html>
**WebTV Alertbox** -- After Mark Anbinder's article about the
WebTV in TidBITS-367_, Keith Instone <[email protected]> wrote
to suggest that we check out an article about the WebTV. Written
by Jakob Nielsen (a SunSoft Distinguished Engineer) for his
Alertbox column, the article looks in detail at the usability
factors of the WebTV, and it's definitely worth reading if you're
considering one. I also encourage you to take a look at Jakob's
other Alertbox columns - I was especially intrigued by his 01-Mar-
97 column about the need for speed on the Web, which comes to the
conclusion that speed (meaning minimal graphics and multimedia
effects) must be the overriding design criterion for Web pages,
something we've long said here at TidBITS. [ACE]
<http://www.useit.com/alertbox/9702a.html>
**TidBITS Search Tool Shootout Reminder** -- In TidBITS-368_, we
announced details of our contest to find the best Macintosh-based
Web search tools to be used on the 11 MB of TidBITS back issues.
The winning solution (whether it's a specific product or creative
implementation of several tools) will receive the main thing we
have to give - exposure in TidBITS. The deadline for entering is
fast approaching - 17-Mar-97 - so contact Managing Editor Jeff
Carlson at <[email protected]> to participate. [JLC]
Eight is Enough (and More Apple News)
-------------------------------------
by TidBITS Staff <[email protected]>
In an unexpected move, Apple announced last week that Tempo, the
next incremental release of the Mac OS due this July, will ship
under the moniker Mac OS 8 instead of Mac OS 7.7. Apple claims
Tempo is a significant technological and user experience upgrade,
and includes features like a PowerPC-native, multi-threaded
Finder, significant interface changes, and the spring-loaded
folders originally intended for Copland (the now-scrapped
operating system formerly known as Mac OS 8).
It's widely rumored this re-christening has less to do with making
operating system releases clear to customers than with Mac OS
licensing fees. Clone vendors currently have licenses only for
System 7, and may have to obtain new licenses for Mac OS 8.
Although this may create new opportunities for the application-
poor BeOS, the timing should come as no surprise: most clone
vendors knew Apple planned to ship a Mac OS 8 in 1997 when they
originally signed up. However, Apple could be looking to increase
its flagging revenues at the expense of Mac OS licensees, which
could hurt the Mac clone business, a dangerous move in today's
market. [GD]
<http://macos.apple.com/macos/releases/macos8/naming.html>
<http://www.be.com/aboutbe/benewsletter/Issue63.html#Gassee>
**Mac OS Clone Sales** -- Dataquest recently released updated
personal computer market share numbers that showed Apple's
licensing of the Mac OS provided noticeable increase in the
overall Mac OS market share for 1996. Apple Computer's share of
the personal computer market was 6.7 percent in 1996, good for
fifth place, but adding the Mac OS clones into the mix raises the
numbers to 7.8 percent, or fourth place. In addition, Computer
Intelligence just released numbers showing that the Mac OS market
share in the U.S. dealer channel grew from 8 percent in Nov-96 to
11 percent in Jan-97, again, due primarily to Mac OS clone sales.
Interesting stuff, especially in light of Matt Deatherage's
comments in TidBITS-363_. [ACE]
<http://www.ci.zd.com/news/macos.html>
**Apple Drops QuickDraw GX Printing** -- Due to limited user
acceptance and developer support, Apple has announced it will not
include the printing features of its QuickDraw GX technology in
the upcoming Mac OS 8. Other aspects of QuickDraw GX, including
typographic and object-based graphics, will be rolled into the OS
release. [JLC]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970303.pr.rel.print.html>
**FTC Holds Apple Accountable** -- If you bought a Performa or LC
550 or a Performa 560 after 01-Apr-94, you may be able to purchase
a PowerPC upgrade for $599, including upgraded software and extra
RAM - and if you already upgraded your machine to PowerPC, you
might be able to get $776 back from Apple! The Federal Trade
Commission has held Apple accountable for "false and misleading"
advertising regarding PowerPC upgrades for these specific
machines. Although Apple admitted no guilt, Apple will be
contacting customers directly about rebates. If this settlement
affects you, feel free to contact Apple directly with your
machine's serial number or a proof of purchase. Apple Computer,
Inc. -- 408/996-1010 [GD]
**More Developer Relations** -- Apple recently named David
Krathwohl to replace the popular Heidi Roizen (see TidBITS-365_)
as the vice president of Apple Developer Relations. Although we
haven't heard a much from developers about the move, David has the
background for the job, having managed Developer Relations in
Europe for three years, after which Heidi named him director of
International Developer Relations. [ACE]
Front Lines Follow-up
---------------------
by Tonya Engst <[email protected]>
Back in TidBITS-367_, Ian Gregson reported on his experiences
while working at Future Shop during the last holiday shopping
season, and suggested that Apple could improve sales by better
convincing consumers that they want Macs and by better rewarding
salespeople who sell Macs. Several readers wrote in to support and
augment these views.
**Peter Miller** <[email protected]> gave an Australian
perspective, commenting that customer service is also important:
Down here in Sydney we have a number of Mac outlets, including
Apple Centres, approved resellers, and the ubiquitous
MacWarehouse. They are uniformly below what could be considered a
reasonable level of service for any consumer item. The situation
is so bad that recently my office manager told a MacWarehouse
administrator that we would gladly pay extra for reasonable
service...
Apple is being remiss in (at least) two ways: firstly they should
be looking after the Mac evangelists and should have stuck with
them despite the vast price differences between platforms.
Secondly, they need intelligent sales representatives that
actively promote and support the product. Neither of these things
seem to happen here.
**Francis Drake** <[email protected]> wrote in from the
southeastern U.S. to share concerns over Mac upkeep:
I live in the Tampa Bay metropolitan area. Lately, when I visit
the local superstores (such as Computer City or CompUSA) and
pass by the "Mac ghettos" they're invariably smaller than they
used to be or don't exist at all, the demo machines don't work,
and sales staff is nonexistent.
**Jeri Croucher **<[email protected]> from Alaska, shared
concerns with the supply of new Macs and repair parts:
I am a salesperson at a computer store in Fairbanks, Alaska. I
sell many more Macs than I do PCs because I believe that the
first-time computer user will probably do much better on a Mac.
However, lately selling Macs has been difficult. When the new
PowerBooks were released, I took orders for eight. All of these
orders were cancelled within a few months by customers who needed
a portable computer _now_. The store just received its first
PowerBook 1400 two weeks ago. These machines were ordered the day
Apple released them. Who can blame me if next time I suggest a
customer buy something I know I can get? Also, when a machine
needs a repair, often there is a long wait for the part. I have
had customers with Macs less than two months old wait up to six
months for a repair part. I think everyone should own a Mac but I
am disturbed at the way the company is handling business.
Advertising will do nothing until Apple can live up to its end of
the bargain with support and supply.
**Shawn King** <[email protected]>, wrote to both TidBITS and to Guy
Kawasaki's EvangeList with comments and suggestions for Apple:
I have been the Apple Demo Days Supervisor here in Western Canada
for the past two promotions. I can tell you from personal
experience Apple does a lousy job of communicating to the non-
computer using consumer. I had dozens of customers a day,
customers that are the perfect market for Performas (Mom, Dad, 2.2
kids, etc.) who knew Macs are easy to use but who didn't want to
buy a computer that was "out-of-date" or "from a company going out
of business." Rather than showing customers features that blow
them away like the TV Tuner Card, QTVR, ease of Internet setup,
and Megaphone, we spent an inordinate amount of time explaining
Apple. The lack of fight in Apple is perceived by the consumer
that Apple has given up and is just "clearing stock."
**Chilly Climate** -- Given the overall climate in the computer
industry, frankly, Apple gets enough bad press [most of which
comes in the form of "news" reports and opinion columns, rather
than users' honest comments. -Jeff]. However, TidBITS didn't
receive any feedback giving opposing examples to problems cited in
Ian's article.
I'd love for someone in a leadership role at Apple to outline a
plan for addressing these problems and periodically share the
progress in implementing the plan. Take America Online: they have
a big problem - it's difficult to connect to their service since
they instituted flat-rate pricing. What are they doing? Running
prime-time TV ads about how they are solving the problem. The ad I
saw last night even mentioned how many new phone lines they've
added recently. Little would please me more than - six months from
now - writing a glowing article describing how Apple is
implementing a crisp and polished sales strategy for the next
holiday shopping season.
Surprised by SuperCard
----------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
As a long-time user of Apple's HyperCard, I had never given
SuperCard a glance. HyperCard, when it was free, had been my
reason for first buying a Macintosh; with it, I've written
language-lab courseware and distributed stacks on the net, and I
still reach for it to contrive spontaneous solutions when
information storage or task automation beckons. It's easy: you
draw buttons for clicking, and fields to hold text, arrange them
on "cards" (sets of window contents), and endow it all with
functionality through HyperTalk, an English-like, powerful, mildly
object-oriented, dynamic scripting language. Presto, you've put up
a Mac-like interface to a homemade program.
My HyperCard loyalty verges on fanaticism; a once-again free
HyperCard figures heavily in my secret, mad strategy to save the
Mac. Nevertheless after HyperCard's explosive development between
1987 and 1991, it languished and nearly died at version 2.1. True,
in early 1994, version 2.2 appeared, a major upgrade that greatly
heartened users, including me. But progress since then, although
we're now at version 2.3.5, has been all but insignificant.
HyperCard 3, Apple's planned port to QuickTime, seems an
intriguing but as-yet distant dream.
SuperCard, meanwhile, I knew of only by hearsay, as a "HyperCard
wannabe." Then I saw SuperCard demonstrated at Macworld Expo in
January and wondered: what if, after all, this was HyperCard done
right?
SuperCard was created by Silicon Beach Software, eventually
acquired by Aldus. Allegiant Technologies, Inc., then broke away
from Aldus to take over SuperCard's development. That was at the
end of 1993; thus, exactly while HyperCard has seemed most
moribund, SuperCard has most vigorously evolved. SuperCard 3.0, a
major upgrade, was unveiled just this past December. [A 3.0.1
updater that improves performance is available via the Allegiant
Web site. -Adam]
<http://www.allegiant.com/>
**Objects All Sublime** -- SuperCard rethinks and extends the
HyperCard battery of objects. The top of HyperCard's hierarchy is
the stack; changing windows means changing stacks, unless you use
an XCMD to put up an "external" window. SuperCard starts with the
"project"; one project can open another, but it can also contain
multiple windows, and each window, though in effect a HyperCard
stack, can be of any standard type, including dialogs and floating
palettes.
Menus are similarly well integrated. A project can contain
multiple menu sets, each containing menus which contain menu
items. Both menus and menu items are full-fledged objects, both
containing scripts and receiving messages.
Like a HyperCard stack, a SuperCard window has backgrounds and
cards, and these can contain buttons and fields. But they can also
contain graphics; these too contain scripts and receive mouse-
event messages, just like a button. A graphic can be a bitmapped
rectangular region, or it can be vector-based, thus taking up
little memory and adopting any standard shape (rectangle, oval,
arc, roundrect, polygon, or freehand). Since buttons themselves
can be polygons, too, it's no wonder that "Anything can be a
button" was once a SuperCard motto.
The SuperTalk language is mostly a superset of HyperTalk,
extending it in clever and desirable ways. Some telling examples:
there's a "case" control structure; besides the string offset
function, there's the lineOffset that tells you in what line of
one string another is found; the "describe" function makes lists
of similar features, such as all the buttons of this background;
the textHeightSum tells you the pixel height of all text in a
field as currently wrapped; you can set not just the itemDelimiter
but the wordDelimiter and the lineDelimiter as well. The message-
passing hierarchy beats HyperCard's too, especially when
HyperCard's "start using" feature is generalized to allow
insertion of scripts from any object at either the bottom or the
top of the hierarchy.
In just one respect, I feel, SuperCard's structure falls short.
Imagine a stack (project) of to-do items: every card contains a
field describing the item, plus a checkbox to show if the item is
completed. Since these elements are common to all cards, they
should be background items; but SuperCard background buttons
cannot have different highlighting on each card (checkbox checking
is considered highlighting). The same problem vitiates one of
SuperCard's most brilliant innovations: user properties. You can
define and manipulate custom properties for any object, thus
associating information directly with the object to which it
pertains; yet a background object cannot have different values for
its user properties on different cards. To me, that undermines the
value of background objects.
**The Multimedia Is the Message** -- In line with its image as a
multimedia tool comparable to Macromedia Director, SuperCard
integrates many features to dazzle and entertain the end-user. Of
these, the most welcome to HyperCarders is surely color, which is
fully built in. Vector graphics, fields, and buttons can have
colored and patterned frame and fill. In fields, a character style
can involve color. Buttons can have color icons (but not,
curiously, colored text). Vector graphics can contain colored
text, or a picture image (importable from various popular
formats). Overlapping colors can interact in complex ways via many
transparency, blending, and addition effects. Custom color tables
and import of 16-bit and 24-bit bitmaps allow top-quality images.
Powerful movie commands let you manipulate QuickTime to your
heart's content, and if that isn't enough you can play PICS
animations and PICT "filmstrips" - plus, objects can be made to
move along paths, and change their pictures or icons. Sounds can
be played either from resources or from AIFF/AIFC files, and you
can access text-to-speech through the Speech Manager. Since these
effects are available asynchronously, your project can easily
become a riot of activity and sound.
**Edit for Your Life **-- The SuperCard environment is not fully
dynamic; you are either running a project as an end-user, or you
are editing it to add, remove, and alter objects, with system
messages suppressed. The two states do overlap somewhat: in run
mode you can still edit scripts, and in edit mode you can still
send messages via the message box. Nevertheless, the dichotomy
seems unfamiliar and awkward to a HyperCard user (and the
transition between the two modes is rather tedious on my 68K
machine).
Editing uses the new Project Editor, a set of windows, floating
palettes, and menus which themselves are a SuperCard project, an
astonishing demonstration of SuperCard's power (and a commendable
example of the toolmakers relying on their own tool, a practice
which invariably improves the tool). The Project Editor supersedes
SuperCard's earlier editing environment, called SuperEdit - which
is still included (because not all its functions could be emulated
by the Project Editor), even though it has not been upgraded for
SuperCard's new entities.
The result is a hybrid. Only SuperEdit can edit cursors, icons,
color tables, and bitmaps in close-up ("fatbits"); only SuperEdit
lets you shape polygon buttons via auto-tracing, or replace a
card's background without affecting its card layer. But it ignores
color icons, and can't import PICT resources into graphics. In
general, you're expected to work in Project Editor and quit out to
SuperEdit only when necessary. It's disconcerting.
The good news is that many of the Project Editor tools are just
what HyperCarders are starved for. The Property Inspector palette
lists and lets you select every object of the current card or
background, then shows and lets you set the selected object's
name, position, size, and major properties. The Project Browser
lets you list, select, create, and delete windows, cards,
backgrounds, and menus - plus it includes a resource copier. There
are palettes for object color and object text. Object editing
includes the ability to align, scale, and rotate objects, lock
them to prevent accidents, and even group them into new compound
objects. A fine Search feature lets you look for text in names,
scripts, or contents, and restrict your search to various object
subsets, obtaining a clickable list of objects and scripts.
Best of all is the message box - why on earth didn't HyperCard do
it this way? The SuperCard message box has two parts, one for your
command, the other for SuperCard's response (whereas HyperCard's
response overwrites your command). The response area can be
enlarged and scrolled so you can see a whole multi-line response,
and your commands are saved into a history pane for later
repetition. But why didn't Allegiant go all the way and let the
command area be multi-lined too, so that you could type and run a
utility script from it? Instead, you have to create a handler in
some object's script and then call it, as in HyperCard.
Script editing takes place in a modal dialog box that covers the
screen and can't be resized (unless you're in SuperEdit). I find
this unpleasant and astonishingly primitive; while editing a
script, one needs to investigate objects and consult other
scripts.
**What's Up, Docs?** The manuals are not at all bad, considering
the size of the subject. There are quite a number of misprints,
including occasional howlers where a crucial sentence asserts
exactly the opposite of the truth. There's also a certain amount
of repetition; the manuals are a bit out of synch with what's
actually shipped, and some of the coolest new features are
omitted. But much effort has evidently gone into making the
manuals both compendious and instructive, and it has paid off.
**Letting Go** -- SuperCard projects can be released in three
forms. The project itself can be given to someone who has
SuperCard or the free SuperCard Player. Or, the project may be
built into a stand-alone application. Or, the project (provided it
has but one window, and subject to many other restrictions) may be
played over the Internet through a Web browser using the free
Roadster Web browser plug-in.
I tried to convert a project into a stand-alone and found the
process harrowing. My main difficulty turned out to be SuperCard's
handling of color icons from its SharedFile library. These need to
be transferred into the project, but if you set up the Standalone
Maker utility to do this automatically it changes the icons' ID
numbers and the project can no longer see them. So you have to
find all color icons manually and move them into the project, then
change every button that uses them to see its newly renumbered
icon. This took a couple of hours, and the interface was buggy and
crude. At the end of the process the Standalone Maker quit with an
unexplained error and I never got my stand-alone. I did learn that
a stand-alone aimed at 68K machines adds nearly 1 MB to the size
of the project, much more than the 540K claimed by the manuals.
I didn't have the wherewithal to test the Roadster distribution
method properly for this review. It's intriguing, though, and the
manual outlines numerous techniques for loading data so the
project will start running on the user's machine before all the
resources and data have downloaded (and even how to behave if
particular data or media is not yet available). Acceptance is the
real problem - whether people will download a 1 MB browser plug-in
just to view your project, especially with so many other plug-ins,
plus Java, clamoring for attention.
SuperCard won't replace HyperCard in my personal software arsenal,
because to me they aren't in the same category. To throw together
a solution for personal use, HyperCard will always get the nod:
it's faster, smaller, and far more convenient. And even though
Allegiant touts HyperCard compatibility, few of my existing
HyperCard stacks could be effectively ported to SuperCard, because
they each rely on HyperCard features that SuperCard lacks: its
ability to print reports and fields; its full scriptability (and
its capacity to run OSA scripts internally); its use of fields for
list-selection (SuperCard has list-selection fields but you can't
style individual chunks of text in them); its far better sorting;
its Boolean card-marking; and (as already mentioned) its use of
non-shared background button highlighting. I believe that these
shortcomings could mostly be worked around or made up for by XCMDs
(not all of them free), but it's interesting that the focus of my
HyperCard stacks is so exactly SuperCard's missing features.
Nonetheless, to build and distribute stand-alone applications that
don't need any of these features (since presumably my issues with
Standalone Maker can be ironed out), SuperCard ought to be ideal.
Its rational design shows up HyperCard for the quirky, misshapenly
grown plant that it is. Its extended HyperCard-like metaphor is a
powerful, easy, and flexible way to make an interactive
application, and its integrated color and other multimedia effects
ensure high presentation value. I do think the price tag (at about
$330) is somewhat high, though the academic version comes in at a
more reasonable $129, with site license options. If you know a
current SuperCard user, that user may have received a mailing
enabling them to share with you Allegiant's recent $149.95
"SuperCard for a Friend" offer. Still, SuperCard 3.0 is a major
upgrade of a product that deserves to attract serious attention;
perhaps it will get it despite the price.
**DealBITS** -- Cyberian Outpost is offering SuperCard to TidBITS
readers for $317.95 ($10 off Cyberian Outpost's regular price)
through this URL:
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/super-card.html>
Allegiant Technologies, Inc. -- 800/255-8258 -- 619/587-0500
619/587-1314 (fax) -- <[email protected]>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.269 | Issue #370 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Mar 18 1997 09:34 | 590 |
|
TidBITS#370/17-Mar-97
=====================
Last week brought us "black Friday" as Apple announced employee
layoffs and another restructuring; this week, Adam looks at what
Apple's keeping, setting aside, and putting into maintenance mode.
We also bring you news on Java and Shockwave security problems and
a PowerPC update to QuicKeys, plus a detailed review of Digital
Chisel, an easy-to-use multimedia authoring and Web publishing
tool aimed at kids.
Topics:
MailBITS/17-Mar-97
Apple Computer '97: What's In, What's Out
Digital Chisel: An Elegant Eye-Opener
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-370.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#370_17-Mar-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#370! <--------- NEW!
Performa 6320 - 24 MB RAM, 28.8 modem, and 15" monitor: $1199
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/17-Mar-97
------------------
**Java and Shockwave Security** -- Although mainstream media has
been saturated recently with news of security issues in the
Windows version of Microsoft Internet Explorer, a different
security problem in Sun's Java received comparatively little
attention. Basically, it's possible for a Java applet to disable
security safeguards and grant itself full access to the local
machine. It's important to note the problem is very difficult to
exploit, but theoretically affects anyone licensing Java
technology from Sun. Microsoft has released a 500K update to its
Java implementations for the Mac version of Internet Explorer;
Netscape 3.0 doesn't use Sun's Java, and isn't impacted.
<http://www.microsoft.com/ie/security/java.htm>
<http://www.javasoft.com/sfaq/index.html>
Another, more easily exploited security problem involves
Macromedia's Shockwave Director plug-in in conjunction with Web
browsers (particularly Netscape Navigator). Essentially, it's
possible to author a Shockwave Director movie that can
clandestinely read email or files on a user's machine, along with
documents residing on other Internet servers, even behind a
corporate firewall. The relative simplicity of this particular
oversight highlights the possibility other simple loopholes in a
variety of products. A pre-release of Streaming Shockwave 6
reportedly does not exhibit these problems, but otherwise the only
way to make sure you're not vulnerable is to de-install Shockwave.
[GD]
<http://www.webcomics.com/shockwave/>
<http://www.macromedia.com/shockwave/download/plugin.cgi>
**Quicker QuicKeys** -- CE Software has (finally) released a
PowerPC native version of QuicKeys, their powerful tool for
assigning keyboard shortcuts and automating tasks (see
TidBITS-347_). Also included with this update are pre-made
toolbars for popular applications such as Photoshop, PageMaker,
and Netscape Navigator, in addition to a Finder toolbar. QuicKeys
3.5 owners can download a 1.8 MB update from CE Software. [JLC]
<http://www.cesoft.com/quickeys/qkppc.html>
**Fetch 3.0.3** -- Last week, we noted the release of Fetch 3.0.2,
which added a Resume Download feature and enhanced Open Transport
support. Shortly thereafter, Fetch 3.0.3 emerged, which fixes a
View File bug that dropped the first character of the file being
viewed. [JLC]
<http://www.dartmouth.edu/pages/softdev/fetch.html>
Apple Computer '97: What's In, What's Out
-----------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
By now you've all heard about Apple's cold turkey diet regime for
cutting costs in an effort to return to profitability in 1997.
Let's take a quick look at what was cut, what's on life support,
and what survived. If you want to see the official word, check out
these press releases, then come back for some analysis.
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970314.pr.rel.restructure.html>
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q2/
970314.pr.rel.faq.html>
**2,700 Employees** -- Apple announced plans to lay off 2,700
full-time employees out of a total of about 11,000. Also being
terminated are 1,400 of 2,400 contractors and temporary employees.
Many of those employees worked on technologies that are being cut,
although Apple's Advanced Technology Group (ATG) was reportedly
hard hit. About 55 percent of the layoffs are in the U.S., with
the rest coming from international groups. Interestingly, in
response to a question during the analysts' conference call on
Friday, Apple executives said none of the layoffs were hitting
Apple Japan.
There's nothing good about laying off employees, other than the
cold-blooded bottom line numbers, but I suspect these Apple
employees will have relatively little trouble finding new jobs. I
hear Microsoft's popular MS Bay Macintosh development group (the
folks responsible for Internet Explorer for the Mac) are hiring
like crazy.
**ATG** -- Speaking of ATG, a good deal of Apple's basic research
has been eliminated, which could prove problematic a few years
down the road. Apple executives said that 90 percent of future R&D
would be devoted to education, publishing, and human interface
design. They claimed that they were aiming to make the ATG budget
five percent of sales, down from about six percent last year. That
doesn't sound bad, but when you think about how sales have
dropped, the cuts equal about a third of the ATG budget. The Apple
executives noted that Compaq and other major PC vendors typically
spend only one to two percent of sales on R&D.
**Performa** -- In my opinion, the smartest cut Apple made was of
the Performa brand name (although existing Performas will remain
in the channel until sold out, when they'll be replaced by Power
Macs). I've never liked the Performa branding; when it first
appeared, I commented back in TidBITS-142_: "The name, which
appeared soon after Compaq's Prolinea line, doesn't impress me,
and I worry about the recycling of technology into a new product
line... It shows that the Performa line is primarily a marketing
move." I thought then that users would be confused by the name,
since it wasn't inherently clear that a Performa even was a
Macintosh, and the rapid proliferation of model numbers made it
impossible for even those of us who watch the Mac closely to track
each model. On Friday, Apple finally admitted that confusing
consumers who want Macs is a bad thing.
**Videoconferencing** -- Apple has dropped its videoconferencing
products and technologies in favor of solutions from other
companies. Overall, this strikes me as a good move -
videoconferencing hasn't been a killer application because of the
bandwidth needed, and other companies have more experience and
more interest in the field. Apple can't do everything, and
videoconferencing must be completely cross-platform to succeed in
a commercial way. Let someone else do it.
**AIX and the Network Servers** -- Apple's recently-introduced,
high-end Network Servers run AIX, a version of Unix from IBM.
Although the Network Servers have been well-received by the high-
end publishing crowd, Apple has decided to pull AIX from future
servers, which will instead run either the Mac OS or Rhapsody, the
code name for the first version of the Mac OS based on NeXT
technologies. Apple will support existing customers, and I suspect
those machines will continue to work just fine. This doesn't feel
like a bad decision either - Apple can't waste effort supporting
too many operating systems.
**Biannual System Updates** -- A while back, Apple promised major
retail Mac OS updates every six months, with minor bug fixes every
three months or so. It was a bold announcement, and I hope whoever
made it enjoyed the taste of the words. After Tempo, now called
Mac OS 8, which will debut in July, biannual System updates are a
thing of the past. Apple executives admitted that the programmers
simply couldn't get software out the door that fast. The schedule
now calls for the "premier" release of Rhapsody to appear at the
end of 1997, and Apple will try for a yearly release schedule of
major updates, with minor bug fixes coming every six months. I
think this is all just posturing. Scheduling in the computer
industry is known to be fantasy: there's nothing wrong with Apple
announcing schedules and trying to stick to them, but anyone who
believes that Apple (or anyone else) can do so consistently is
dreaming.
**Maintenance Mode** -- The items mentioned above are now history.
However, a number of other technologies have been placed in
"maintenance mode." It's still not quite clear what that means,
although I suspect that bug fixes will be made and updates to
support new hardware may happen, but there won't be much more.
Apple's press release claims: "Most of the elements of Mac OS
today are maintained in this sense today - yet customers and
developers use them daily. Apple continues to improve the
reliability and performance of the overall system including
technologies that have not seen major updates in years.
Furthermore, these technologies will reside in Rhapsody as part of
the Mac OS layer (the 'Blue Box') that will run today's software
for years to come on a faster, more reliable foundation." Keep
that in mind when I talk about the following items.
**Open Transport** -- On the face of it, I think putting Open
Transport in maintenance mode and switching to a Unix-derived
Berkeley Standard Distribution (BSD) networking scheme on top of
the Mach kernel is an idiotic move. Apple went through serious
pain to transition AppleTalk and the aging MacTCP to Open
Transport, and after an initial bad version (forced by the release
of the Power Mac 9500) Open Transport has proved a solid, flexible
performer that meets the many and varied needs of Macintosh users.
Questions surrounding this move abound for Rhapsody. For instance,
how will Apple support AppleTalk in a BSD-based networking
implementation? What about plug & play networking? What about
security (you don't see many $10,000 security challenges being
hosted on Unix BSD-based systems)? And what about features already
demonstrated for the now-cancelled Open Transport 1.5, including
IPv6 and multi-homing? I'll be writing more about this issue soon,
because if interface is the heart of the Mac, networking is the
soul.
**OpenDoc** -- Apple seems to believe that OpenDoc and Java fill
similar roles in the world of component software technologies.
Although I'm not sufficiently technical to verify that (any
programmers want to write an article about it?), the feeling was
that it was wasteful to put effort into OpenDoc when so many
developers consider Java to be the feline's sleepwear, and
OpenStep already offers a powerful model for component software
development. OpenDoc will continue to be supported in the Blue
Box, but I can't see any reason why independent developers should
continue OpenDoc development. Overall, I think it's a shame, given
that OpenDoc was just starting to turn the corner, as noted back
in TidBITS-365_. Apple put a lot of effort into developing OpenDoc
and evangelizing developers; if I were one of those developers,
I'd be utterly disillusioned right now.
**Cyberdog** -- Speaking of disillusionment, I imagine Joe Kissell
and David McKee, authors of a cool book called Cyberdog: Live
Objects on the Internet, must be feeling pretty low. Cyberdog was
OpenDoc's killer application (if that term can apply to a
document-centric technology), and Apple has put it in the same
maintenance mode as OpenDoc. Cyberdog 2.0, which is currently in
beta, and OpenDoc will ship with Mac OS 8 in July, so they'll
still be available for people to use, but it's hard to recommend
that people use Cyberdog in favor of competing technologies that
have a future. I imagine the version of Netscape Navigator once
promised for Cyberdog can be forgotten too.
**Game Sprockets** -- Game Sprockets was a set of libraries and
tools designed to make it easy to program games for the Macintosh.
Like OpenDoc and Cyberdog, it will continue to live on in its
existing form in the Blue Box. Ironically, that will mean that
games written using Game Sprockets will only run in the Blue Box,
just as there are PC games today that only run in DOS, not
Windows. Although I don't have any opinion about Game Sprockets in
particular, I think the game market is an important one for a
computer that's aimed at the individual consumer, and Apple had
better do something to ensure that game developers want to
continue developing for the Mac.
**Mac OS Development Tools** -- Apple has created numerous tools
for programming the Mac OS over the years, and although those
tools will remain available, Apple is concentrating instead on
development tools for Rhapsody. Although a tremendous amount of
code for current Macintosh applications was written using Apple
tools like MPW and MacApp, programmers were already aware they'd
have to use new tools to develop for Rhapsody, and many already
rely on tools from independent developers such as Metrowerks and
Symantec.
**Alive and Well** -- All this doom and gloom shouldn't give you
the impression that Apple is closing up shop to become, as one
joke press release suggested, a non-profit corporation. Apple
still makes a lot of money (they're estimating about $8 billion
for 1997), and Amelio and company have given some products and
technologies a respite, presumably for the cash flow they bring
in.
**Newton** -- I'm sure a collective sigh of relief went up from
Newton owners and developers when Apple announced that the Newton
division would emerge unscathed. The Newton MessagePad 2000 and
eMate 300 are now shipping and have been well received, so they
survive... for now. Apple's press release notes: "Apple is
exploring a wide range of options for future Newton business. We
have no specifics regarding those discussions at this time." To my
mind, this means one of three things, and I have to admit that I
don't much care which so long as the Newton technology survives
and moves forward. Take your pick of:
* Apple continues to work on the Newton internally.
* Apple spins the Newton division off into its own company.
* Apple sells the Newton division to some other company.
**Claris** -- I don't believe that Claris was ever in much
jeopardy, and the wholly owned subsidiary will continue earning
money for Apple. Claris reported record revenues of $67 million
for the first quarter of fiscal year 1997, and revenues of $236.2
million in 1996. Demand for Claris's products has remained strong
on both the Mac and Windows, with FileMaker Pro 3.0 for Windows
becoming the second best-selling database in the PC desktop
database market. The Mac version has long been the best-selling
Macintosh database.
**Mac OS Licences** -- Rumors have been flying that Apple hopes to
increase revenues by charging the Mac OS licensees more for the
right to make Mac clones. As explained during Friday's conference
call, nothing has changed in this situation. The fees will change
at some point soon, but that's because currently Mac OS licensees
also license Apple's hardware designs, the so-called "Tanzania"
motherboard. Once it's possible to make CHRP (Common Hardware
Reference Platform) machines, clone makers won't have to license
the Tanzania motherboard, and Apple has always planned at that
point to adjust the license fees to account for the new situation.
**Loyal Customers?** I'd like to close by noting that in the
analysts' conference Apple's executives went on a bit about how
the company's greatest asset is its loyal customers. In the past
that's certainly been true, and it may still be true now that the
company has lost so much money, laid off so many employees, and
discontinued so many technologies. However, from talking to
numerous users and developers, it seems to me that although
loyalty to the Macintosh and all it embodies may remain, loyalty
to Apple as a company is hitting an all-time low. There's a big
difference, and I'm not sure it's one that Apple's management
realizes. One of the executives commented that Apple would reward
loyal customers by continuing to build great products. I would
question if that's likely in the near future or, more important,
it it's sufficient to reward the years of loyalty so many people
have shown in the face of continual derision and obstacles.
Digital Chisel: An Elegant Eye-Opener
-------------------------------------
by Tonya Engst <[email protected]>
Digital Chisel HTML 2.1.3, affectionately known as "the Chisel,"
comes from Pierian Springs Software, and it's used by teachers and
students to devise snazzy multimedia presentations, tutorials, and
even tests. Digital Chisel HTML recently added "HTML" to its name,
and - intrigued by the HTML aspects - I decided to review the new
version. I thought it would be eye-opening to try a totally
different approach to creating Web sites than that offered by
page-oriented software like PageMill or tag-focused software like
BBEdit.
I found Digital Chisel to be a fun, elegant product whose
presentations can run under the freely distributable Digital
Chisel Player or be converted to Web sites. Digital Chisel
projects resemble HyperCard stacks, with screens linked together
by buttons. Developers needn't worry about code at all, and the
Digital Chisel Player takes care of behind-the-scenes operations
like recording test scores.
<http://www.pierian.com/>
Kids and teachers are making Chisel projects of all sorts: the
life cycle of salmon, mock commercials about missions to Mars, and
digital portfolios. In addition, students are making quizzes for
other students to take, and teachers are producing serious tests.
**Objects of Desire** -- When working in Digital Chisel, you work
on one screen at a time, though it's easy to switch screens.
Screens contain text, graphics, animations, and sounds, which - as
far as Digital Chisel is concerned - are "objects." You can drag
objects anywhere you like, even overlapping other objects. Any
object can be animated, either along a path or as part of a
simple, flipbook-style movie. Objects can be created within
Digital Chisel, imported from disk, or accessed from Chisel
libraries, which provide a quick way to browse groups of objects.
Digital Chisel comes with 25 or so sounds, including the likes of
Aooga and Dinosaur Growl. The package also includes a few
QuickTime movies, a number of general clip-art images, and a
library of 70-odd useful and attractive button images.
I started my first screen by drawing out a text object and typing
inside it. Text can be formatted with a fairly normal array of
styles, fonts, sizes, and colors. In some kids' programs, I've
seen special formats like big bubbles and sparkles, but the Chisel
has no such novel formats. Text can also be turned into hot links
leading to pop-up notes. For instance, a hot link might define a
new vocabulary word.
After figuring out text, I moved on to graphics. Graphics can be
drawn as vector-based images (where images consist of shapes that
can be re-sized or re-colored) or painted as collections of pixels
located in a user-defined paint object. I especially liked the
ability to insert some pre-drawn objects like arrows and stars.
One frustration was the color palette. The palette has plenty of
colors, arranged in a 16 by 16 square. I had a hard time
remembering exactly which colors I had used previously, and the
Chisel has no eyedropper, custom palette, or other tool that might
have refreshed my memory.
Not wanting to stop at simple text and graphics, I moved on to
adding sounds. Digital Chisel can import sounds, but I used the
simple recording interface to record my own. (Several teachers
told me that their kids especially like this feature; apparently
they like to play back their voices.) I made some sounds that
played when users clicked buttons and others that played
automatically when a screen first opened. Similarly, it's possible
to create or insert QuickTime movies. You make a QuickTime movie
one frame at a time, and you'd better get it right, because
there's no way to go back and edit the frames. In addition,
there's no way to add sound to a movie.
**Moving Target** -- Once you've set up a few objects, you can
call it quits, or you can figure that the fun is just beginning.
Double-click any object and a palette comes up that enables you to
set which events happen when the mouse moves over the object, when
the mouse button is pressed over the object, or when the button is
released over the object. Objects can change color, animate along
a path, play sounds, speak words, cause a portion of a CD or video
disk to play, and more. Just one event can happen, or up to 24
events can happen. For instance, in my project (which was about
how Adam and his father cut down a dead tree in our back yard [a
technically tricky and heroic procedure involving chainsaws that
resulted in minor damage to only two feet of our deck's railing,
rather than the total obliteration of the deck from the 100-foot
tall dead hemlock. -Adam]), I made a person move to look at the
dead tree, and then say, "oh no!" In effect, every object is
potentially a button.
Buttons can also link to other screens, and you could easily
design and implement your own navigation bar, or use buttons to
jump users around in the project. (Those who don't want to build
their own navigational devices, however, can use the default
navigation toolbar). If you'll be exporting to HTML, you can also
link buttons to URLs.
**Change of Screen** -- In addition to customizing what happens
when an object is moused, you can set things to happen as a new
screen opens. Any screen can open with a transition effect, such
as a zoom or a "venetian blind" open. In addition sounds and
movies can play when a screen opens.
**Quizzes** -- Any screen can be part of an online quiz, and
Digital Chisel comes with optional templates to speed the quiz
creation process. In the case of tests having fixed answers (like
multiple choice or true/false), the screen can be told which
answer is correct, and during testing respond based on whether a
student chooses the correct answer. Students taking quizzes can
indicate who they are, and any Chisel project can record quiz
results in a simple database.
**Stepping onto the Web** -- Digital Chisel has taken the big step
of adding HTML export features. The export works on an entire
project at once, or you can export individual pages. The HTML
export turns each screen into a Web page and converts the
navigation bar into appropriate buttons. Hot text links connect to
anchors further down on the page. To place objects correctly,
Digital Chisel utilizes tables and specifies cell widths by the
pixel. To maintain some semblance of how the font looked in
Digital Chisel, it employs the <FONT> tag with size and color
attributes. Pages with test questions do not convert to HTML.
Although I normally disapprove of pixel-specific layouts (see
TidBITS-362_), to my surprise, I found myself not minding Chisel
using a pixel-specific technique. Chisel authors are inherently
designing for the screen and can set the assumed screen size.
Digital Chisel calls its parts "screens," not "pages," and
displays them in a landscape orientation (since most screens are
wider than they are high). That assumption means Digital Chisel is
coming at the Web from a completely different mindset than the
shock-blink-and-frame crowd, and it's great that Chisel
presentations can be placed on the Web instead of living out their
lives in the relative obscurity of the Digital Chisel Player.
I was not satisfied with the HTML export because objects tended to
end up misaligned, and working with the table tags in the
resulting HTML documents proved frustrating. I also thought that
hot text links should open a new page or window instead of linking
to the bottom of the page. And, as an HTML-savvy adult, I wanted
more control over decisions like using the <FONT> tag. However, in
this version of Digital Chisel, I think it's important to consider
the HTML export a possibly handy add-on, not a raison d'etre.
Unlike many sub-par HTML editing tools whose marketers say that
the tool may lack features but works wonderfully for kids and
novice adults, this product is _intended_ for kids. What features
belong in an HTML product for kids remain to be seen, and I
suspect that Pierian Springs is working hard on this issue, since
their upcoming 3.0 version will offer more Web-related features.
**Review Roundup** -- I have little first-hand appreciation for
what a twelve-year-old might find lacking in the program, but
features I missed were style sheets for text and a grid for lining
up screen elements. (It's possible to set a temporary grid on the
background - each screen can have a background, and backgrounds
can be shared, much like master pages in PageMaker). I've spent a
lot of time working with the likes of Claris Home Page and
Symantec Visual Page, so I missed the freedom of importing objects
via drag & drop from the Finder. Additionally, there's no way to
see an overview of a project. A palette lists project screens, and
you can use drag & drop to reorder the screens, but I'd like to
see a thumbnail view of the project, complete with the ability to
drag & drop objects onto screens in the thumbnail view.
Those complaints aside, the Chisel strikes me as a top-notch
program. Teachers I spoke with backed up that impression, with
comments like "student friendly," and "it takes you as far as your
imagination will take you." The interface is easy to learn and
appealing to look at, and I highly recommend it to anyone under
the age of 16 who wants to have a blast making presentations. The
arrangement of the menus, the palettes, the commands, the entire
way that the program fits together has an easy, elegant feeling
found rarely in software, and makes me like the program far more
than I would if the interface were compromised to add more
features.
I had an excellent experience with Pierian Spring technical
support - the support person not only gave lots of suggestions for
solving my problem, he also helped me avoid future problems. All
the teachers I spoke with praised the support staff without being
asked.
To run Digital Chisel, Pierian Springs says that ideally you'd
have a 68040- or PowerPC-based Macintosh, with 5 MB available
application RAM and a monitor that can display 256 colors.
Minimally, the company recommends a 25 MHz 68030-based Mac, 3 MB
available RAM, any version of System 7, and at least a 12-inch,
256-color monitor. You also need at least 5 MB free hard disk
space. Pierian Springs is working on Digital Chisel 3.0 (it's
about to go into beta), and a Windows version is also in the
works.
Digital Chisel costs $109 for a single user, school packs cost
$149, and there are also various site license deals. Additionally,
through 30-Apr-97, Strata and Pierian Spring are offering a joint
bundle that includes Vision 3D 4.0, Media Paint 1.2, two copies of
VideoShop 3.0, Digital Chisel 2.1.3, a Vision 3D tutorial, and a
t-shirt. This bundle costs $379; $239 educational.
<http://www.netschool.com/oasis/news/hotdeal.html>
Pierian Springs Software -- 800/472-8578 -- 503/222-2044
503-222-0771 (fax) -- <[email protected]>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.270 | Issue #371 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Mar 25 1997 08:07 | 571 |
|
TidBITS#371/24-Mar-97
=====================
Apple's PowerBooks not only redefined the laptop computer
industry, but also embodied a nebulous combination of style,
innovation, and prestige - elements Apple has been trying regain.
In this issue, we take real-world looks at the newest contenders:
the PowerBook 1400 and 3400, the latter currently holding the
title as fastest laptop in the world. Also, Adam raises some
interesting questions about Apple's decision to drop Open
Transport in Rhapsody.
Topics:
MailBITS/24-Mar-97
Rhapsody and Networks: Some Questions
PowerBook 1400/133: Poise and Punch
PowerBook 3400: The Ultimate Laptop?
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-371.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#371_24-Mar-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#371! <--------- NEW!
Apple PowerPC 604 132 MHz daughter card - only $129
More info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/24-Mar-97
------------------
**CDA Goes to Washington** -- The U.S. Supreme Court has begun
hearings on the Communications Decency Act. I won't pretend to
analyze the results of the initial oral arguments, but I found
reading the complete transcript to be fascinating. If you're
interested in how the Supreme Court justices queried the attorneys
for both sides, check it out at the URL below. If you haven't
followed the issue over the last two years, the Communications
Decency Act (passed as part of the Telecommunications Act of 1996)
attempts to limit "patently offensive" material on the Internet as
defined by local community standards (see TidBITS-315_). [ACE]
<http://www.aclu.org/issues/cyber/trial/sctran.html>
**About Those R&D Numbers** -- Several readers wrote into comment
about the numbers Apple was bandying around in relation to the
research and development budgets. The Apple executives said that
other PC vendors devote only 1 to 2 percent of sales to R&D. That
may be true, but it doesn't take into account the fact that other
vendors pay licensing fees to Microsoft, in part to account for
Microsoft's R&D on Windows 95. In addition, I said that Apple was
aiming to cut the ATG (Advanced Technology Group) budget to 5
percent of sales; I should have said that Apple plans to cut the
total R&D budget to 5 percent of sales, since ATG is only a part
of Apple's overall research efforts. [ACE]
**Macromedia Fixes Shockwave Director** -- On 19-Mar-97,
Macromedia issued a fix for the security holes in Shockwave
Director we reported on last week (see TidBITS-370_). No other
details were available, but note that you must download the
complete Shockwave Essentials package to get the fixed version of
Shockwave Director. The download is 1.1 MB. [ACE]
<http://www.webcomics.com/shockwave/>
<http://www.macromedia.com/shockwave/download/>
Rhapsody and Networks: Some Questions
-------------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
As many of you know from reading my article in TidBITS-370_, Apple
has announced that Open Transport will enter "maintenance mode"
and eventually be replaced in Rhapsody by Unix BSD (Berkeley
Standard Distribution) networking code. Open Transport will
continue to exist within the "Blue Box," which is the
compatibility layer for current Mac OS applications running within
Rhapsody.
Response to this announcement from the Internet development
community has ranged from confusion to frustration and back to
confusion again.
For instance, Amanda Walker, who developed parts of TCP/Connect
and InterPPP II for InterCon Systems (now owned by Ascend
Communications) said, "I think that not porting Open Transport
(which is essentially Mentat Portable Streams - one of the fastest
and most flexible Unix networking stacks) to OpenStep (which uses
a good, but slower and less flexible 4.3 BSD-based networking
stack) is stupid and shortsighted. I will be amused if the classic
Mac OS ends up being a better server platform than Rhapsody."
<http://www.mentat.com/>
**Some Questions** -- Other developers voiced similar concerns,
but the common theme among them were the numerous questions that
came up. Replacing Open Transport with BSD networking (I'll refer
to it merely as BSD from now on) is not a trivial decision, and it
affects the Mac both at a low level and at a user administration
level. Avoiding the truly technical issues, here are a few
questions about the future of networking on the Mac whose answers
will affect many of us. These questions may not have answers yet;
any Mac user who relies heavily on Open Transport should be
concerned about the fact that Apple didn't have answers ready when
they made the announcement.
Do note that I'm not interested in hearing speculation about the
answers - the only people who can answer these questions are the
Apple engineers working on the Rhapsody networking transition.
* Open Transport deals well with multiple TCP/IP configurations,
making it easy for Macintosh users to switch between multiple ISPs
and even multiple methods of connecting to the Internet (modem,
network, etc.) without rebooting. BSD was designed for Unix
workstations that never move and don't have to change their
networking configurations multiple times per day. How will BSD
deal with, as a friend noted, "the diversity of messed-up network
configurations" that Open Transport handles with ease?
* Open Transport may not have a perfectly simple interface, but
it's pretty easy. Will BSD networking be as easy for a novice user
to set up and reconfigure if necessary? Will Rhapsody have to ship
with your own personal Unix guru?
* Numerous Macintosh developers have invested a great deal of
time, energy, and code in developing for Open Transport. Does it
make sense to "trade" those developers, all of whom are interested
in developing for the Macintosh, for a new set of Unix and Windows
developers (BSD comes from Unix, and WinSock in Windows is based
on BSD), few of whom have any interest in developing for the Mac?
As Amanda Walker says, "If I'd wanted to develop for a niche Unix
machine, I'd have been a NeXT developer."
* Open Transport supports (of course) AppleTalk. BSD has no built-
in support for AppleTalk. How will Apple add support for AppleTalk
to BSD? Wouldn't it be ironic if Apple had to buy an AppleTalk
stack for Rhapsody from an outside source?
* What happens with plug & play networking under BSD? Will you
still be able to plug in an Ethernet card and have it work without
fuss? For instance, on a PC, if you so much as move an Ethernet
card from one PCI slot to another, you have to reinstall the
drivers, something that would be laughable on a Macintosh. Also,
what about LocalTalk support? Vast numbers of Macs rely on simple
LocalTalk networks for sharing files and printing.
* IPv6, which encompasses the next generation Internet addressing
scheme (since the Internet is running low on IP numbers), has been
demonstrated under Open Transport. IPv6 is a big deal for higher
education institutions working on Internet II, the very-high-speed
Internet connection between these institutions. What's the story
with IPv6 under BSD?
<http://playground.sun.com/pub/ipng/html/ipng-PS.txt>
<http://www.mentat.com/ipv6.html>
* How will Open Transport in the Blue Box and BSD in the Yellow
Box (which is the layer where native Rhapsody applications run)
share networking resources such as modems or Ethernet cards? For
instance, if you make a PPP connection using FreePPP in the Blue
Box, can you use an Internet application that only runs in the
Yellow Box over the same connection?
* In Apple's testing on a 10 Mbps Ethernet network, Open Transport
could sustain throughput of 9.6 Mbps. In contrast BSD could only
sustain 7 Mbps (and the venerable MacTCP could only do 2.3 Mbps).
That may not sound like a huge difference, but what about a 100
Mbps Ethernet network? Open Transport has been shown to sustain 40
Mbps on those networks - how well will BSD do? Wouldn't it be
ironic if existing applications running on Open Transport in the
Blue Box significantly outperform future applications running on
BSD in the Yellow Box? (This isn't an Internet issue since
throughputs on the Internet are so slow in comparison with
Ethernet networks that even users with T1 Internet connections
would be unlikely to notice the difference.)
* Open Transport supports filters such as SurfWatch, one of the
programs that prevents users from seeing "objectionable" sites.
Without getting into the issue of defining "objectionable," what
does BSD offer in terms of filters?
PowerBook 1400/133: Poise and Punch
-----------------------------------
by Mark H. Anbinder <[email protected]>
When Apple introduced its first family of laptop computers, the
PowerBook 100, 140, and 170, the machines were hailed as capable
and feature-rich, and were attractive and usable to boot. With
additions to the 100-series PowerBook family, and then the advent
of the Duo and 500-series PowerBooks, Apple managed to maintain
its reputation. But in recent years the offerings have been
limited, and it wasn't until the release of the PowerBook 1400
that Apple had another winner on its hands.
<http://product.info.apple.com/productinfo/datasheets/pt/pb1400.html>
**Overview** -- As the second generation of PowerPC-based Apple
laptops, the PowerBook 1400 family sports a stunningly large
display, clean design, and the first built-in CD-ROM drive in a
PowerBook. When it was introduced last year, the 603e-based 1400,
running at 117 MHz, was considered a shade slow compared to other
current Macintosh desktop computers and PC laptops. Apple's
February release of a 133 MHz model provides a perfect bridge for
those who would like a solid performer but don't need (or can't
afford) the wicked-fast PowerBook 3400 (see Marc Bizer's review of
the PowerBook 3400 next in this issue).
**Look & Feel** -- Though Apple's first PowerBooks weren't that
visually exciting, they lived in an era when computers weren't
trying to be works of art. The 500-series machines were sleek,
making it clear that aesthetic design had been considered in their
production, so the PowerBook 5300 family was especially
disappointing in its tendency toward visual doldrums. I was
delighted to see a visually appealing laptop the first time I
encountered a 1400 in a local dealer showroom, and in the month
that I've owned one, I've continued to be happy with its looks.
Accessible layout is at least as important as aesthetics, and
Apple has succeeded again in producing a machine that's easy to
approach. The display offers easy-to-reach brightness and contrast
controls (they're on the right side, but are as reachable with the
left hand as with the right), and though the catches that open the
PowerBook and release the battery and CD-ROM or floppy drive
seemed "backwards" at first (requiring a press in the opposite
direction from my old PowerBook 100), I adapted quickly. The
battery and drives can be removed with the same hand that releases
the catch, important if you're holding the PowerBook with the
other hand or, for whatever reason, have only one hand available.
Apple's new PowerBook keyboard is a wonderful improvement over
past models. The twelve function keys (F1 through F12) are small
but usable, and so far I've found nothing that insists upon the
higher-numbered keys being available. (I've remapped Microsoft
Word's word count feature, which uses F15, to F12. Yes, I can live
without a double-underline keystroke.) Unlike some laptop
keyboards, this one doesn't slow down my fairly fast typing pace,
and so far I've accidentally hit the wrong key on only a few
occasions; certainly no more than on my desktop keyboard. My only
wish is that there were a right-hand Command key, so I could, with
a single hand, hit the Command-Shift-9 SignatureQuote FKEY I've
used for years. I suspect I can either get used to doing it two-
handed or select another FKEY number for use with Rick Holzgrafe's
invaluable shareware tool. (I now do virtually all my email from
the PowerBook, and I'm _not_ giving up SignatureQuote.)
<http://www.opendoor.com/Rick/SQ.html>
The trackpad has a clickable button, but I find myself hardly ever
using it, relying instead on the trackpad's tap, double-tap, and
drag capabilities Apple has added to the trackpad since earlier
incarnations. These features are adjustable, so you can turn them
off if you prefer to click using a physical button, or if you
prefer to be able to tap but not drag on the trackpad.
**Accessibility** -- The twin bays in the front of the PowerBook
1400, below its now-familiar wrist rest, hold the battery on one
side and the swappable CD-ROM and floppy drives on the other side.
I expected to have to complain that the floppy drive and CD-ROM
drive couldn't be swapped at any time without a restart - but it's
not so! These two drives are "hot-swappable," so they can be
inserted or exchanged at any time whether the computer is on, off,
or asleep. (If a CD or floppy happens to be mounted when you
remove the drive it's in, the computer will ask you to put the
drive back and dismount the item before trying again.)
I wouldn't be surprised to see other modules for the PowerBook
1400 in the near future, such as a DAT drive, or a DVD drive, or
just about any other storage device. A much-delayed Zip drive is
scheduled for release by VST Technologies in "second quarter
1997."
<http://www.vsttech.com/>
Meanwhile, the twin Type II PC Card slots (formerly called PCMCIA
slots) on the left side of the computer serve my
telecommunications needs, working fine with Global Village's
PowerPort Platinum Pro or with Dayna's CommuniCard Plus, each of
which offers both 33.6 Kbps modem and 10Base-T Ethernet
capability. These slots can be used for hard disk storage, too,
and the modem or Ethernet tasks can be relegated to the computer's
internal expansion slot.
The expansion slot, located in the back of the computer under the
speaker grille, is unbelievably easy to access and use. I needed
to read the instructions that came with my video card before I
could determine that sliding the speaker grille to the left would
release it, but the rest of the installation process was self-
explanatory. A small Phillips-head screwdriver is needed, which
renders my specialized T-8 and T-10 screwdriver tips obsolete.
(They were necessary to get into earlier PowerBook models, and a
modicum of luck was needed to get out of them.)
I was surprised that video output and Ethernet are both optional,
but I can understand Apple's desire to avoid crowding the
PowerBook with features that not every user will use. If both
could be added internally without the use of a PC Card, I'd do it,
but I'll settle for having internal video and PC Card Ethernet.
My only accessibility complaint is that the PowerBook 1400 takes a
tad too long to wake up to suit my tastes, between 20 seconds and
a minute, averaging around 30 seconds. This is much faster than
starting up from scratch but ought to be nearly instantaneous. A
modern computer often needs to do much more upon waking up than
the earliest PowerBooks, but it ought to be able to perform those
tasks more quickly, or perhaps simultaneously rather than
sequentially.
**Battery** -- Apple's 500-series PowerBooks cleverly allowed the
use of two batteries at once; one battery could be replaced by an
optional PC Card cage. Although you can store a spare battery in
the bay designed for the CD-ROM and floppy drives, that battery
can't be active, surprisingly enough. Two batteries in tandem last
longer than two batteries used one after the other, so it would be
useful for Apple to build battery contacts into this bay. The
single nickel metal hydride battery is rated for two to four
hours, but seems to last up to an hour and a half in standard use,
with occasional CD or floppy access, and the color display's
backlighting at a comfortable level. Of course, conserving power
through actions such as turning down the display brightness will
make the battery last longer, perhaps even over two hours.
**Sound & Display** -- Shorter battery life may not be such a bad
trade-off, considering the bright, attractive, 11.3-inch, active-
matrix color display on the 1400c. Its 800 by 600 display (the
resolution can't be changed) is slightly smaller than the same
display on a 16-inch color monitor, but not enough smaller to make
it at all uncomfortable, and the image is sharp across the entire
display without any visible split lines.
The optional video output card, which comes with the same adapter
cable required for Apple's earlier video-capable PowerBooks,
supports a variety of monitors and up to thousands of colors
(16-bit color).
Sound is not a key feature of the PowerBook 1400, though its
capabilities are adequate. The machine includes a mono microphone,
built into the display, and a small mono speaker which doesn't do
justice to audio CDs. However, the audio jack on the back of the
computer supports stereo headphones, battery-powered external
speakers, or speaker-equipped monitors.
**The Verdict** -- Apple's PowerBook 1400 isn't a raw powerhouse
like its big brother the 3400, but neither does it carry the
3400's price tag. With a range of speeds from 117 to 133 MHz, a
range of storage, video, and expansion options, and good standard
features, the PowerBook 1400 is a good choice for those who need a
Mac laptop for a reasonable price (roughly $2,500 to $4,000,
depending on configuration). For more information about the 1400,
see Geoff Duncan's overview article in TidBITS-350_.
**DealBITS** -- With the purchase of a PowerBook 1400 or 3400,
Cyberian Outpost is offering TidBITS readers free copies of
Aladdin's Spring Cleaning 1.0 and FWB Software's HSM Toolkit 1.0.
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/power-books.html>
PowerBook 3400: The Ultimate Laptop?
------------------------------------
by Marc Bizer <[email protected]>
I was overjoyed to have been selected as a seed site to test a new
PowerBook, the much-anticipated machine code-named Hooper, which
Apple shipped on 17-Feb-97 as the PowerBook 3400. I had no idea
how Hooper had been named - did it mean the laptop would jump
through hoops which no other portable computers had jumped before?
All I knew for sure was that I was eager to try Apple's fastest
portable ever.
<http://product.info.apple.com/productinfo/datasheets/pt/pb3400.html>
**General Impressions** -- Taking the unit out of the box and
opening its lid, I was amazed at how large its 12.1-inch screen
seemed in comparison to the 9.5-inch display on my PowerBook 540c.
My initial physical impressions were positive: its active-matrix
screen is bright and sharp, displaying 16-bit color at a
resolution of 800 by 600, and its keyboard feels just right.
Although the 3400 resembles a large 5300, the unit feels much
sturdier; it is a pleasure to touch and behold. The placement of
the microphone and sound-out jacks on the left side of the
computer is convenient; I can't say as much about the ADB port at
the back on the left side, since it could be inconvenient for
right-handed users who attach devices like mice or numeric
keypads. I found the 3400 to be a speedy performer, approximately
in the range of a Power Macintosh 8500/150 except for video.
Software installs speedily from the built-in 6x CD-ROM. Reviewers
complain that the PowerBook 3400 weighs over seven pounds, but it
felt lighter in my carrying case than my PowerBook 540c, perhaps
because its power adapter is lighter than the 540c's.
One disappointment was the wakeup time. Since the 170, I've found
PowerBooks to have an annoyingly long wakeup time, and the 3400 is
no exception. Ideally, wakeup should be almost instantaneous. I
know that Apple's engineers are making efforts in this area.
**Configurations** -- The PowerBook 3400 comes in four
configurations, three of which are shipping. First of all, there
are two units with a PowerPC 603e processor running at 180 MHz.
One is a $4,500 stripped-down version which comes with neither the
ingenious PCI-based Ethernet/modem card nor the 6x CD-ROM drive
which fits in the 3400's expansion bay. Both feature a 1.3 GB IDE
hard disk. The second 180 MHz configuration costs approximately
$5,000 and includes the CD-ROM and the Ethernet/modem card.
For approximately $5,500, Apple offers a 3400 with a 200 MHz 603e,
the same 6x CD-ROM and Ethernet/modem card, and a 2 GB hard disk
(which is somewhat faster than the 1.3 GB hard disk in the 180 MHz
configurations. Finally, in April, Apple plans to ship an ultimate
high-end notebook, a 240 MHz 3400 with a 12x CD-ROM drive and a 3
GB hard disk for approximately $6,500. In other words, these
machines are not cheap.
All configurations come with 16 MB of RAM soldered to the
motherboard, which leaves the one non-stackable memory slot free.
A memory card holding up to 128 MB can be installed, which brings
the maximum capacity of the 3400 to 144 MB of RAM, more than
double the capacity of the PowerBook 1400.
Given that the built-in Ethernet/modem PCI card (absent in the
low-end 180 MHz model), takes up the single PCI slot, those who
wish to install third-party PCI boards will have to remove the
modem. One wonders how many third-party boards will be developed
for the 3400's miniature PCI slot; even though it uses PCI, it's a
non-standard size.
**Hardware Characteristics** -- The PowerBook 3400 uses the basic
architecture of the 7500/8500/9500 desktop PCI Power Macs: it has
a 64-bit data bus between processor and memory (and a 40 MHz bus
speed); 256K of high-speed L2 cache; DMA (Direct Memory Access)
for I/O; its single serial port is a GeoPort; and a first in
PowerBooks, it uses high-speed EDO (Extended Data Output) RAM more
common to the Intel platform. A Chips & Technologies video chip,
typical on high-end PC notebooks, offers limited QuickDraw
acceleration (rectangle copy and fill). The lower PC card slot
accepts "zoom" video cards, giving them direct access to the
3400's video hardware and thus permitting full-motion full-screen
video.
The sound quality from the four built-in speakers is mediocre:
when playing music, it sounds tinny, with no bass whatsoever. It
is fine for multimedia presentations, however, and headphones
completely alleviate this shortcoming.
**Design** -- Though its internal architecture is much more
advanced than that of the relatively old 5300/1400 architecture,
the physical design of the 3400 lags behind that of the 1400 in
some significant ways: for example, in the 1400, Apple has done
away with Torx screws and gives complete and easy accessibility to
memory, expansion cards, and the hard disk.
**Usage** -- I used the PowerBook 3400 at least seven hours per
day for two months with no problems whatsoever and few crashes.
This is a testament to the robustness of the hardware and the
stability of System 7.6. Battery life (using lithium-ion
batteries) is adequate but not stellar at about two hours even
under relatively severe conditions (i.e. no RAM disk, PowerBook
control panel set to "maximum conservation" with backlight dimming
set to turn off completely, Ethernet connection, but no CD usage).
The Ethernet/33.6 kbps modem card automatically switches between
the modem and Ethernet functions depending upon whether a standard
telephone or Ethernet cable is plugged into it; the 3400 ships
with a dongle allowing both modem and Ethernet connections at the
same time. I learned from Cary Lu's Macworld review of the 3400
that this is Apple's first PowerBook to include a fan (not
mentioned in Apple's technical documentation). This surprised me;
although the palm rest area to the left of the trackpad could get
fairly warm, which I actually appreciated in chilly Parisian
libraries (did Apple borrow this idea from Saab cars?), I'm fairly
certain that the fan never came on during two months of operation.
<http://www.macworld.com/pages/april.97/Feature.3382.html>
<ftp://ftp.apple.com/devworld/Technical_Documentation/Developer_Notes/
Macintosh_CPUs_-_PPC_Portable/Macintosh_PowerBook_3400.sit.hqx>
**More Features** -- The 3400's modem, based on the Rockwell 288
chip, offers good reliability (twice I inadvertently picked up the
phone handset while I was connected to the Internet, without
dropping the line) and good performance. The modem does not have
flash ROM, so it will not be upgradable to upcoming 56K
technologies. It can be used either with AppleFax or FaxSTF
software (bundled).
I understand that the 3400 is the first PowerBook with active
termination on the external SCSI bus, and this relieves it of some
of the "sensitivity" which some users may have experienced while
using previous PowerBooks with improperly terminated SCSI devices.
I had no trouble connecting an Iomega Jaz and an external Apple CD
600e CD-ROM drive to the 3400.
The 3400 does video mirroring, a feature where the PowerBook
display also shows on an external monitor or, more likely, on a
big screen via an overhead projector. The 3400 can drive an
external monitor at 1024 by 768 pixels, however, it can only do so
with 256 colors, which may be unacceptably low for people who need
such a high-end laptop. The 3400 needs more VRAM, at least 2 MB,
which is becoming standard on high-end PC laptops. Unfortunately,
the 3400 cannot drive two monitors in non-mirror mode - a feature
many PowerBook 3400 owners will surely miss.
**The Right Idea** -- Although it lacks a few features, most
notably in the video support, the 3400 is the consummate PowerBook
with an emphasis on the word "power." It is by far the most
comfortable and usable laptop I have tried. The bad news is that
I'll have to sell my car to buy one.
**DealBITS** -- With the purchase of a PowerBook 1400 or 3400,
Cyberian Outpost is offering TidBITS readers free copies of
Aladdin's Spring Cleaning 1.0 and FWB Software's HSM Toolkit 1.0.
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/power-books.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.271 | Issue #373 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 01 1997 15:52 | 692 |
|
TidBITS#373/01-Apr-97
=====================
EXCLUSIVE! Hot on the heels of Oracle CEO Larry Ellison's public
speculation of a hostile takeover of Apple, Steve Jobs announces
the merger of Apple and Pixar, Jobs's successful animation
company. In this special issue, we also unveil a host of
behind-the-six-colored-curtain information, including sale
of the Newton and PowerBook divisions, new technologies for
Rhapsody, a TidBITS global reorganization, rumors of Cyberdog
abuses, and more.
Topics:
MailBITS/01-Apr-97
Apple Goes Hollywood
Waxing Rhapsodic: New Technologies from Apple
The TidBITS Channel
Internet Merchandising Takes Off
The PowerBook Secret
TidBITS Web Surfing Party Game
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-373.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#373_01-Apr-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* The Intergalactic Kelvinball Federation -- <[email protected]>
"If you're confused, you're just starting to get the hang of it."
"Life's not fair, and neither's Kelvinball." -- "Kelvinball in
the dark. It takes a whole new dimension away from the game."
"Foul! Excessive jubilation." -- "Curses! Foiled again!"
* ZZEdit -- 888/ZZZ-EDIT -- <[email protected]>
The professional text and HTML editor that puts your competition
to sleep. Order now for free spinning guitar plug-in! <-------- NEW!
* WeebleWeb -- 888/375-7693 -- <http://www.weebleweb.com/tidbits/>
Stability is in the eye of the beholder. Our motto: "Your site
might wobble, but it won't go down."
* Extranet Starter Kit -- Fully buzzword-compliant!
Ever wondered what an extranet is? This soon-to-be best-selling
book won't tell you, but it's got a great title for only $24.99!
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/01-Apr-97
------------------
**New PowerBooks** -- Just after the release of the PowerBook
3400, dubbed "the world's fastest portable" by Apple, comes the
PowerBook 1000, codenamed Falcon. Announced on 01-Apr-97 and
bearing the affectionate slogan "the fastest hunk of junk in the
galaxy," the PowerBook 1000 is based on the diminutive PowerBook
100 design and features a 320 MHz low-power PowerPC 620 CPU, 80 MB
of RAM, a 2 GB hard disk, a hot-swappable removable storage bay
that supports a CD-ROM drive, Zip drive, or floppy drive, and ten
hours of battery life on trilithium resin battery technology.
Unique to the PowerBook 1000 is generalized wireless communication
technology that enables the machine to act as a pager or cellular
telephone, or to connect to the Internet via a wireless modem at
speeds up to 53 Kbps. Prices are expected to start at $1,500.
[ECA]
<http://product.info.apple.com/productinfo/datasheets/pt/pb1000.html>
**Double the Trouble** -- Connectix recently announced the latest
in its Doubler suite, a new browser plug-in called JAVADoubler
(formerly known by its code name, DoubleShot). Slated for release
on 01-Apr-97, the plug-in downloads all Java applets twice. Using
special parallel download technology described by engineers as
"caffeinated to the max," the double download takes no longer than
a normal, single download. Why download two copies? Well,
JAVADoubler doesn't stop percolating its magic once the copies are
downloaded. Using memory buffering technology borrowed from RAM
Doubler, JAVADoubler monitors the first download's activities, and
when the applet crashes or hits an offending instruction,
JAVADoubler moves operations over to the second downloaded copy.
While that copy continues to run, JAVADoubler quickly downloads
another copy. We applaud Connectix for its continuing efforts to
help users catch up to the ever-rushing train of technological
change. [EJT]
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.connectix.com/>
**Cyberdog Abused?** Rumors are circulating on the net that the
real reason for the demise of Apple's OpenDoc technology was due
to allegations made by an organization calling itself the Animal
Internet Rights Foundation (AIRF) about Apple's mishandling of
Cyberdog. A spokesperson was quoted as saying, "We received
reports that Cyberdog was repeatedly hacked, delayed, and not
given proper resources." AIRF investigators are also reportedly
looking into the conduct of programmers Peter Lewis (in regard to
his domestication of the Anarchie kangaroo), and Jim Matthews (for
not paying enough attention to the Fetch dog). The University of
Minnesota could not be reached for comment regarding its treatment
of the gopher in the almost-defunct TurboGopher. Some have
suggested that the decline of the Gopher technology was related to
cutbacks in the University of Minnesota's gopher food budget.
[ECA]
**Mac Attack** -- In a swift and decisive move, Symantec
Corporation announced that it would purchase game developer Id
Software for an undisclosed sum. Id, creator of popular "blast-
and-run" games such as Doom and Quake, immediately issued a press
release disclosing that negotiations had been "relatively
bloodless (ha ha)." Symantec's first offering from its new
Chainsaw/Cutting Edge department will be a revised version of
Norton Utilities for Macintosh entitled NUM-Cruncher, in which
users will be able to run through virtual 3D "corridors" of their
hard disks in real-time, blasting bad sectors and setting fire to
corrupted B-tree branches. [CLJ]
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.symantec.com/>
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.idsoftware.com/>
**TidBITS Announces Reorganization** -- Following in the footsteps
of such industry leaders as Apple Computer, TidBITS today
announced plans to lay off thousands of employees. "It's a bit
like selling a stock short," explained TidBITS publisher Adam
Engst. "First we lay off the employees, take advantage of a
massive tax write-off, and then we can use the money to hire
them." TidBITS also announced a shareholders meeting to be held
this time next year; bring a dessert to share. [ECA]
**Smoking Newtons, Batman!** After a flurry of industry
speculation about the fate of its underappreciated handheld
technology, Apple has sold its Newton line to the highest bidder,
the RJR Nabisco Holdings Corp. (RN), parent company of the
independently traded Nabisco, Inc. (NA) and creator of cigarette
lines Camel, Winston, and Salem. As a result of the sale,
Nabisco's well-known Fig Newton line will gain a new member - the
Cig Newton.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.nabisco.com/Townhall/
FunFacts/NEWTONS.html>
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.triadonline.com/rjrt/>
Cig Newtons will feature a special compartment for storing
cigarettes. An RJR representative commented that "too many
potential smokers use PDAs but don't want the inconvenience of
carrying around a PDA and a cigarette pack. By giving customers
cigarettes and a PDA in one handy package, we think we can
convince adults to try smoking and turn a huge profit." The
representative had no comment when asked if the new Newtons would
ship with a program that automatically recorded cigarette usage
and charted the increasing risk of health problems. Additionally,
no comment was offered when asked if the company would offer a
similar Cig Newton aimed at children, based on the eMate design
and sporting a Joe Camel face. Rumor has it that RJR is currently
negotiating a technology alliance that would enable it to add a
"flick-top" Bic lighter technology to future models. [EJT]
**Kinko's, The New Way to Verb** -- If you don't possession at
home the software or hardware you requirement to completion a job,
automobile down to your nearest Kinko's, where you'll discovery a
row of Macs cargoed with a good selection of fonts and software,
plus some great printers. Everything is all arrangemented so that
at the end a time slip is printered enumerationing your charges.
I've employmented this service on a number of occasions and I
consideration it fun and easy; if you entrance at an odd time
(such the middle of the night) you can just chair down and
commencement working without competitioning for a computer. [NAM]
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.kinkos.com/>
Apple Goes Hollywood
--------------------
by Grubuen Ttam <[email protected]>
In a move that surprised all but the cagiest industry analysts, it
was announced this week that Apple Computer, Inc., had been
acquired by Pixar Animation Studios. Apple promptly laid off its
entire development staff, plus David Krathwohl and the whole
Developer Relations department, hiring in their place on permanent
retainer a number of film stars including Jim Carrey, Jeff
Goldblum, Roy Scheider, and others who have been seen using Apple
computers in movies over the years. According to former CEO (now
Vice President of Rhetorical Affairs) Gil Amelio, Apple will
henceforth confine its activities to star-studded, high-tech
animated multimedia presentations at conventions and stockholder
meetings.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.pixar.com/>
"This was the real reason we bought NeXT [Software, Inc.], but we
couldn't announce it until the details were finalized," Amelio
said. "We needed to leverage the animation expertise of Pixar, and
this was the only way Steve [Steven P. Jobs, CEO of both NeXT and
Pixar] was going to let us at it. We save NeXT, he saves Apple: it
was a simple quid pro quo."
"It was a completely logical move, which I'd been contemplating
ever since I joined the board of directors [in 1994]," Amelio went
on. "I looked at Apple's work over the last five years or so and
saw immediately that Apple was really in the business of giving
demos about technology that they never had and never intended to
release. People were shelling out big bucks to watch this stuff at
Macworld Expo and the World Wide Developers Conference. For a
while early on it had looked like folks might catch on to the fact
that all the so-called demos were just animations, but we started
interspersing occasional screen shots of MacsBug and the critics
went wild."
"Meanwhile, the actual development effort had become a complete
financial sinkhole," Amelio continued. "I realized quickly that we
could save a lot of time and expenditure by cutting development
out altogether. Computers and entertainment have been linked from
the start; Apple has been marketing computer-based fiction for
years and now we're going into it full time."
Ellen Hancock, executive vice president of research and
development, will remain with Apple to help plan the scenarios of
future animations, in which Apple, in an ongoing soap opera, will
portray a Silicon Valley corporation desperately coming up with
ever-whackier technologies in an effort to stay afloat. Hancock
will be assisted by Walter S. Mossberg, formerly of the Wall
Street Journal, who will serve as chief editor and head writer.
Apple's move was enthusiastically received by the press, who, in a
frenzy of interviewing one another as usual after the press
conference, looked forward to ripping Apple's new fictional
company to shreds. Steve Jobs, now CEO of Apple as well as Pixar
and NeXT, was unavailable for comment.
Waxing Rhapsodic: New Technologies from Apple
---------------------------------------------
by Nacnud Ffoeg <[email protected]>
In an effort to reassure the Macintosh developer community in the
wake of recent layoffs and restructuring, Apple Computer has been
privately demonstrating a host of cutting-edge new technologies
slated to appear in its forthcoming NeXT-based operating system,
codenamed Rhapsody. Though none of these new features have been
finalized, TidBITS was fortunate enough to attend one of Apple's
sneak previews for programmers and developers, and the
demonstrations were truly spectacular instances of Apple
showmanship.
**Also Known As...** System 7 first introduced Macintosh users to
aliases, tiny files that point back to an original item, like a
program, document, folder, or disk. Rhapsody will take aliases to
the next level by integrating them with both the Appearance
Manager (scheduled to appear in Mac OS 8) and Macintosh Easy Open,
enabling Rhapsody users to work in a predominantly Windows or Unix
environment without being detected. "We've heard about sites,
particularly in corporate America, where Mac users are being
forced to give up their Macs and switch to another platform," said
an Apple representative. "Rhapsody's new Alias Manager lets these
Apple customers continue to use their Macintoshes in those
environments under an assumed identity." The new Alias Manager,
codenamed AKA, can give a Macintosh the appearance of a Windows
95, Windows NT, or Sun OS operating system, complete with
functional interface elements, all tied to customized hot keys
that let Macintosh users switch between interfaces when their
supervisors have left the room. Although the new Alias Manager
cannot fully emulate other operating systems, it's smart enough to
know when its out of its league, and simulates a disk problem,
network error, program crash, or other commonplace event for the
simulated operating system if it gets too close to its limits. "At
no point does it give away that you're using a Mac." When asked
how many users are expected to rely on the new Alias Manager, an
Apple spokesperson declined to give specific figures, but
predicted large numbers, especially after a planned alliance with
the Federal Witness Protection Program, noting Apple was already
planning an advertising campaign for the year 2000, entitled
"We're everywhere."
**How Does That Make You Feel?** Recognizing that modern operating
systems are becoming increasingly sophisticated and difficult to
deal with, Apple also demonstrated an early version of the Empathy
Manager, codenamed Troi, which lets the Macintosh running Rhapsody
use a PlainTalk microphone and a video camera (like a Connectix
QuickCam) to sense and respond to a user's moods and emotions. If
the user is in a good mood, the Empathy Manager will change the
screen's appearance to happy colors, change the system beep to
joyous tones, and even make the Internet work faster. If you're in
a bad mood, the Empathy Manager will try to be supportive,
offering to open windows, edit email, let the user win a few games
of solitaire, or even suggest a well-deserved nap. Like many of
Rhapsody's technologies, the Empathy Manager is Internet-ready;
using a protocol called ThinkTalk, Macs with the Telepathy Manager
can pool mood information about their users, enabling them to more
effectively formulate work strategies, delay email that might
upset their user, or even request prescription medication via a
secure Web server.
**Internet for the Rest Of Us** -- Although Apple recently
discontinued its Performa brand of computers, Rhapsody is
scheduled to include technologies specifically intended for low-
end, non-technical Macintosh users. First among these is
GeekWatch, an Internet utility designed to filter out confusing
and overly technical information on the Internet. "The Web offers
a vast amount of information, but a lot of that information isn't
relevant to many non-technical professions, like hairdressers,
rock musicians, and marketing executives," said an Apple
representative. GeekWatch monitors information as it comes into
your computer from the Internet and compares it to a user profile
built up gradually from the contents of Internet sites visited by
a particular user. If the content of a site is deemed too
technical, that data is blocked by GeekWatch. As an example,
someone who was mainly interested in gardening information who
accidently loaded a Web page on Java programming, a GeekWatch
dialog appears with a smiley-face icon and the phrase "This site
blocked by GeekWatch!" (Version 1.1 will include translations for
technical terms; in the previous example, an Apple Guide window
would appear beneath the smiley-face icon, explaining that Java is
"essentially another term for coffee, which programmers need to
survive." At this point, the Empathy Manager could kick in and
suggest that the user go brew a cup.) The Apple representative
commented, "We think this will make the Internet less intimidating
for real people, and have a beneficial side effect of letting real
geeks talk to each other without confusing anyone."
**The Blame Game** -- Finally, the most fundamental - and perhaps
most controversial - new functionality scheduled to appear in
Rhapsody is the Conspiracy Manager, a comprehensive set of low-
level object classes designed to handle errors and crashes for all
programs and services. The Conspiracy Manager allows programmers
to have extensive control over the appearance, timing, and impacts
of their errors. With the preemptive multitasking capabilities
provided by Rhapsody's Mach kernel, errors and crashes can appear
to be caused by any program or software component running under
Rhapsody. Thus, a programmer could release a program that blamed
all its crashes on the ever-popular whipping boy Microsoft Word,
Java, the dreaded "extension conflict," or even a particular
Internet site. Acknowledging that the best way to hide a
conspiracy is to admit to it up front, Apple representatives
declined to comment on how the Conspiracy Manager might make
Macintosh use less intuitive for users, although they did note
that Apple had to conform to industry standards for software
problems, and the Conspiracy Manager was vital to the job security
of technical support workers around the world. Apple
representatives also refused to comment on whether Apple was
considering licensing the Conspiracy Manager to other companies.
"Um...," the Apple rep nodded. "Could be."
The TidBITS Channel
-------------------
by Tsgne .C Mada <[email protected]>
We at TidBITS have long been proponents of the theory that we
should provide TidBITS in as many ways as possible for our
readers. Unlike other publications, which limit themselves to the
Web, we've long supported email, FTP, and Usenet news. That's why,
when Intermind announced its Intermind Communicator product last
year, we started publishing TidBITS that way as well, even though
the Macintosh version of the product hadn't yet shipped.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.intermind.com/prod_demo/
version_need.html>
We've also been trying to separate our organization from the
TidBITS newsletter slightly - you might have noticed our copyright
notice for "TidBITS Electronic Publishing." All of these moves
have come in preparation for our latest announcement, the TidBITS
Channel!
**Shove Technology** -- The TidBITS Channel will take advantage of
the very latest in Internet technology - so-called "shove"
technology, which was designed specifically for information with
an attitude. We feel that shove technology is the logical
extension of the initial "pull" technology of the Web, where users
had to go get everything manually, and the "push" technology used
by companies such as Intermind, PointCast, Marimba, and BackWeb.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.intermind.com/>
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.pointcast.com/>
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.marimba.com/>
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.backweb.com/>
So, thanks to our use of shove technology, when you turn on your
computer in the morning, an avatar (we're in negotiations with
Chicago Bulls "bad boy" Dennis Rodman) will appear on screen and
begin a dialog with you. "Hey bud, move back from the screen - yer
crowding me," it will say. If you don't do as it asks (or at
random times even if you do), it will invite you to step outside,
saying, 'You wanna piece of me? Huh? Whatsa matter, sucker, you
scared?" Once you've been sufficiently cowed, the avatar will get
down to business. "Read this, dork!"
We have high hopes for the future of shove technology - some
joystick manufacturers have already signed up to provide physical
feedback devices that will be able to simulate those initial
shoves before a fight starts for real. Future enhancements to
these devices will be able to simulate the feeling of being thrown
against a wall and having a chair broken over your head.
But enough about the nuts and bolts behind the TidBITS Channel,
let's look at our new content. We've been watching a lot of
syndicated television recently, and have "borrowed" a few ideas
from our favorite shows.
**Martha Stewart Macintosh Makeover** -- Everyone loves and envies
uber-homemaker Martha Stewart, and we convinced her to broaden her
horizons past projects that help you filter your compost and teach
you how to make delicious desserts and centerpieces from the parts
that haven't yet fully decayed. On this show, Martha will
demonstrate how to use a soldering iron to stencil those cute
little geese onto the side of your Macintosh so it matches your
curtains, how to French-braid your cables to avoid that ugly cable
nest behind the computer, and other fun projects that anyone can
do, given a week or two of concentrated effort with Martha
standing over your shoulder with a whip.
**BitWatch** -- This new show will star ex-Apple employees who
don't have anything better to do while working off their five-
month severance packages. Each week will focus on a different,
recently eliminated Apple technology and the team that had been
working on it. Of course, everyone on the cast will wear only
small bits of clothing, and the show will be set on Silicon Beach.
**Tonya: CodeWarrior Princess** -- TidBITS Senior Editor Tonya
Engst has always wanted to branch out into fantasy, and she gets
her chance in this new show. Dressed up in a skimpy leather and
metal outfit with a very large sword, Tonya roams Silicon Valley
with her wise-cracking sidekick Ebbe (Even Better Bus Error),
protecting innocent memory and battling evil big-endian overlords,
CISC wizards, foul daemons, and other 3D-rendered terrors.
Preliminary ratings and usability studies indicate a spin-off
series (Colonel Mach: Justice Server) might get the go-ahead for
next season.
**TidBITS Swimsuit Channel** -- Not to be left behind in the
annual fuss over the Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue, we've
decided to do our own swimsuit issue, complete with swimsuit
pictures of some of your editors in exotic locales. Of course,
being as sensitive as we are to the bandwidth problems on the Web,
we've come up with a clever way to present these images for your
viewing pleasure. Check them out on our Web site! (Warning! These
images have not been rated by the RSAC Ratings Service.)
<http://www.tidbits.com/photos/swimsuit.html>
Internet Merchandising Takes Off
--------------------------------
by Tsgne .C Mada <[email protected]>
We've all watched fads turn into trends and crumble under the
withering heat of reality. Most of these fadlets (trendlets?)
suffer because they don't work, or perhaps no one's willing to
ante up even a small amount of money for the resulting products.
An argument could be made that Web browsers fall into this
category.
However, recent announcements from the leaders in the 1997
Internet Press Release Championships, Netscape Communications and
Microsoft Corporation, hold promise for some truly successful new
products.
As everyone knows, making money on the Internet is generally a
losing proposition. Most of the money made so far has been in
advertising, and if you look closely, you'll realize that the same
companies are both accepting ads and buying them on other sites.
In other words, money is staying in the system. Researchers at
Cornell University's Johnson School of Management believe they've
uncovered a relationship that implies that all money on the
Internet will be conserved and recycled, much as water from the
oceans evaporates, moves around in the atmosphere, returns to
earth in the form of precipitation, and washes back down to the
oceans.
Unwilling to accept this theory, the Internet economics engineers
at Netscape Communications (well known for engineering Netscape's
1996 IPO (initial public offering) that showed that money really
does grow on trees hydroponically raised in the dark sewers of New
York City under Wall Street) have come up with a new money-making
idea that's sure to succeed.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.netscape.com/>
Netscape's mascot, before the company became too stuffy to have a
mascot, was the lovable Mozilla, a Godzilla-like creature born in
the minds of the early Netscape programmers from watching too many
bad science-fiction movies while writing NCSA Mosaic, Netscape
Navigator's predecessor. In an effort to capitalize on the
Netscape name, Netscape plans a line of Mozilla action figures,
including a plastic Mozilla that can melt AOL floppy disks with
the addition of common household items such as matches and an
aerosol can. Another Mozilla will be a large plush stuffed animal
that can repeat several phrases, including "See you on
alt.dinosaur.barney.die.die.die!" and "Bill Gates is a weenie."
In response, industry juggernaut Microsoft announced that it has
had a line of action figures in the works for some time, the first
of which will of course be the Bill Gates action figure, available
for free download on the Internet to anyone who can figure out how
to download an action figure. A Steve Ballmer action figure that
froths at the mouth while talking about the Macintosh is planned
for the fifth quarter of this year.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.microsoft.com/>
Microsoft also announced the IAFS, or the Internet Action Figure
Standard, and said that it would be turning the standard over to
the IETF to show that it wasn't really interested in controlling
the world. A spokesman for the IETF sounded confused when asked
about the IETF's plans for the IAFS. "The what?" he asked.
The nascent IAFS has already come under fire from Internet
security experts after a class of third graders at Benedict Arnold
Elementary School near Burlington, Vermont, uncovered a security
hole in the Bill Gates Action Figure using a networked pool of
eMate 300s. Unfortunately, because TidBITS is a family publication
(and was already cited once under the Communications Decency Act
in 1996 - see TidBITS-321_), we can't provide additional details
about the security hole. Microsoft promises a fix but has not yet
given a date when it will be available.
Other computer industry companies refused to comment on their
action figure strategies, although rumor has it that Apple plans
to release a Steve Jobs action figure (based on the G.I. Joe
action figure with the karate chop arm) once engineers can figure
out how to miniaturize a PowerBook sufficiently to please Jobs,
who reportedly said that any Steve Jobs action figure must include
a fully functional, no-compromises PowerBook.
The PowerBook Secret
--------------------
by Tsgne Aynot <[email protected]>
Although much of Apple was acquired by Pixar Animations Studio
(see the related article earlier in this issue), some hardware
divisions were sold off. In a move that surprised many industry
analysts, the PowerBook division was exchanged for a $1 million
gem-encrusted brassiere (reportedly now worn by Ellen Hancock in
Apple/Pixar soaps) and will now be under the control of the well-
known lingerie chain, Victoria's Secret.
Said Kelly Kahn, VP of Technology Acquisitions, "Modern women
don't just want to look great, they want to function effectively
in a chaotic, information-rich world. PowerBooks are the
management tool of choice, and we look forward to improving the
line to better meet fashion needs. Take the stylish eMate 300: we
plan to move the PowerBook line in that direction, with more
colorful, fun looking cases, slimmer profiles, and vastly improved
customer support."
In time for Boston Macworld this year, Victoria's Secret plans to
ship a series of HotSurfer PowerBooks. These machines will be
based on the Duo line, but Victoria's Secret has eschewed the use
of numbers to describe machines. Ms. Kahn commented, "We could
have named them with numbers, but we felt that HotSurfer much more
aptly describes the new line." An important innovation in the
HotSurfers will be a second drive bay designed either to hold a
hot-swappable storage device or a special purse. The new
PowerBooks will have strong enough shells that for many events a
protective carrying case won't be necessary. By stowing a wallet
and other essentials in the purse, HotSurfer owners can attend
such events looking "streamlined and elegant," not "burdened with
accessories."
In addition, to help users avoid the awkward look and feel of
operating a computer attached to a snake's nest of cables, the
company is aggressively partnering with technology companies that
support wireless communications.
Victoria's Secret also plans a new line of PowerBook cases. Cassie
Connolly, Director of Accessory Fashions explained, "Most of
today's PowerBook cases operate on a functional level only. Our
customers want cases that express personality or inject a humorous
note. Cases will range from elegant satin or velvet items to
whimsical options, decorated with lace, silk flowers, and faux
fruit." Straw cases will be sold only in warmer climates; look for
quilting and polar fleece in colder areas. The buzz on the street
suggests that a matching line of hats may be in the making.
Perhaps the most exciting part of the buyout, though, is that
every Victoria's Secret store is adding a special PowerBook sales
area right up front. Many big malls have a Victoria's Secret
store, and with the displays slated to combine eye-popping models
holding slick looking PowerBooks, not only should business should
be brisk, but consumers should see the Macintosh portable market
in a more favorable light. Executives at Power Computing are
already working with Victoria's Secret on sublicensing and cross-
marketing deals.
<http://smeg.com/backwards/b2.cgi?url=www.powercc.com/>
Will Victoria's Secret introduce unisex- or male-oriented
PowerBook models? Ms. Kahn noted, "We don't want guys to feel
excluded - sure, our cases will appeal more to women, at least in
the short term. However, we think we can make PowerBooks that
appeal to both sexes. We don't look at our upcoming PowerBooks so
much as for one sex or another, but for people who have fashion
sense or want to look glamorous while computing."
TidBITS Web Surfing Party Game
------------------------------
by Noslrac Yerffej <[email protected]>
With the recent rise of "Geek culture," the long-held
misperception that computer users are solitary, electronic slaves
is slowly receding like a ten percent drop shadow. Geeks have
asserted for years that they can party as hard as any
testosterone-filled football player. To prove it, we present the
TidBITS Web Surfing Party Game (TBWSPG, pronounced "Fred").
Fred is best experienced in a group setting (say, a rack of office
cubicles at lunchtime), but you can also play at home alone or
networked, of course. To play, choose your favorite drink, connect
to your ISP, and start surfing the Web. Remember to be
responsible, and hand over the mouse when you've drunk too much.
**Drink once if:**
* your modem has to redial when connecting to your ISP (if more
than five times, stop drinking and cancel that darn AOL account
already!).
* you see a "Best Viewed With..." tag (twice if it's animated)
* you get any error message (bad URL, etc.)
* you see an under construction sign
* you view a page with a Web counter (twice if it's a broken
graphic)
* you view a blink tag (not necessary to drink for every blink)
* you come across a Java applet (twice if it doesn't load)
* you see the phrase "cool links"
* a background sound loads (you also must dance with drink in
hand)
* your browser crashes
* you have to resize the browser window
* a graphic doesn't load
**Drink twice if:**
* you hit a JavaScript error
* you arrive at a password-protected site (if you can guess the
password in three tries, collect a dollar from everyone in the
room and chug drink)
* you find a home page purportedly belonging to someone's pet.
* "cool" is spelled "kewl"
* you have to download a plug-in and restart your browser
* the graphics are broken on a Web designer's home pages
**Special:**
* If you hit a Shockwave project, you have to wait to drink until
it's downloaded. (This is a good chance to walk to the store for
more drinks, render 3D images, or write a new operating system.)
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.272 | Issue #372 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 01 1997 16:26 | 586 |
|
TidBITS#372/31-Mar-97
=====================
Speculating about Apple, while not yet named as an official
Olympic sport, is certainly popular enough to be considered for
the Exhibition category. In this issue, Adam examines much of the
Apple speculating that's going on and offers his own views about
Apple's directions. We also cover Apple's presence at the recent
Internet World, and look in detail at Snapz Pro, a snappy new tool
for creating screenshots.
Topics:
MailBITS/31-Mar-97
Apple's Decisions
iWorld and Welcome to It
Say Cheese! Snapz Pro
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-372.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#372_31-Mar-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#372!
Apple PowerPC 604 132 MHz daughter card - only $129
More info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/31-Mar-97
------------------
**Express Yourself to Microsoft** -- Microsoft's new Macintosh
Office development team (about 100 developers dedicated to working
on the Macintosh version of Microsoft Office 97) has posted a set
of survey questions on the Web, the answers to which they hope
will help them make Office more Mac-like. The mainstays of Office,
Excel and Word, are among the most important Macintosh
applications - without them, the Mac would have little to no
chance of being sold in quantities to large businesses. Thus, it's
in all of our interests to encourage Microsoft to create more
Mac-like applications, much as the MS Bay team is doing with the
Mac version of Internet Explorer. [ACE]
<http://www.hinfo.com/ask97/mac/m1.htm>
**New from Cupertino** -- Last week, Apple formally rolled out the
powerful Newton MessagePad 2000 and the sleek Twentieth
Anniversary Macintosh, while also announcing availability of
OpenDoc 1.2. Regarded by some as the first truly functional
Newton-based device, the MessagePad 2000 is powered by a 160 MHz
StrongARM processor, features reportedly excellent handwriting
recognition, and operates vertically or horizontally. The
Twentieth Anniversary Mac, on the other hand, seems like a device
for prominent display in a gallery, and with its $7,500 price tag,
buyers might choose to consider it modern art. On the software
side, the new version of OpenDoc (4.3 MB download) fixes bugs
dealing with international systems, increases stability in low-
memory conditions, and supports Apple Guide 2.1, although some
OpenDoc applications (like Nisus Writer 5.0) reportedly do not
work correctly with OpenDoc 1.2. [JLC]
<http://www.twentiethanniversary.apple.com/>
<http://product.info.apple.com/productinfo/datasheets/pi/mp2000.html>
<http://www.opendoc.apple.com/users/getod.html>
**Internet Explorer 3.0.1b1** -- Microsoft has released a beta of
Internet Explorer 3.0.1; this release supports JavaScript, both
68K and PowerPC Macs, plus a new Download Manager, the ability to
accept or decline HTTP cookies, and a search feature tied directly
to Yahoo. Downloads vary from 2.6 MB to a stunning 9.5 MB for the
full install. [GD]
<http://www.microsoft.com/ie/mac/default.htm>
Apple's Decisions
-----------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
We've spent a lot of time and energy in recent TidBITS issues
looking at the moves Gil Amelio and Apple management made to bring
the company back to profitability. There's no question that some
moves were more popular than others, but I think the time has come
to delve into what might be going on, or at least what a
significant number of people feel might be going on.
**What Else Could Gil Have Done?** Apple has taken flak for
decisions to lay off employees, terminate some technologies, and
place other projects in maintenance mode. I'm certainly guilty of
harassing Apple about decisions I feel were mistakes, but let's
face it: Gil had to do something. Apple lost a lot of money in
1996, and clearly that trend would continue in 1997 unless drastic
action was taken. The recent announcements were that drastic
action.
With no reason to assume sales would exceed all expectations, the
only way Apple could regain profitability was to cut costs.
Reportedly, a single engineer costs Apple about $150,000 per year
in salary, benefits, support structure, office space, and so on.
Not all of the 2,700 employees laid off were engineers, of course,
and the 1,400 contractors and temps were undoubtedly cheaper, but
even if you assume a savings of $100,000 per person, that's $410
million.
More important, unlike previous Apple layoffs, this one was
combined with elimination of projects. That's depressing but
realistic, since it means Apple isn't expecting to continue with
business as usual, just with fewer people. You can't lay off 4,100
workers and expect to do everything you did while they were there.
That said, I would have liked to see Apple address its financial
problems in other ways as well. First, where were the voluntary
pay cuts and eliminations of bonuses for the executive staff? It
seems hypocritical for executives to eliminate 4,100 employees not
take pay cuts themselves. The buck stops at Gil Amelio, and I
think it's only fair to have fewer bucks stop at his paycheck.
Second, were the Apple technologies cut of so little value that
they couldn't be sold to raise money, such as with
videoconferencing? Alternately, couldn't Apple have created
technology incubators with these projects? Form a new company
around each one, give the source code to the former Apple
employees, provide some administrative support resources, and
retain 40 percent ownership. If they succeed, Apple makes money
and Mac users benefit; if they fail, Apple loses nothing more than
what was already being thrown away.
**The NeXT Takeover** -- One theme among the mail I've received
about Apple's recent changes is the perception that former NeXT
employees are now making Apple's decisions. One person even
commented that it felt like NeXT had bought Apple, not the other
way around. To some extent, these perceptions are accurate - after
all, Avie Tevanian and Jon Rubinstein, two ex-NeXT folks, are in
charge of the operating system and hardware divisions.
In the past, Apple has been accused of a "Not Invented Here"
syndrome (NIH), where the only technologies perceived to be
worthwhile were those developed within Apple. Now, some feel the
NIH syndrome has been reversed, with internal Apple technologies
being viewed as inferior and over-engineered. The NeXT acquisition
is the best example of this - there's some question if, had Apple
really buckled down, bringing Copland to fruition would have cost
$400 million and taken until 1998. Buying NeXT was a bold move,
but it was neither cheap nor immediate relief from Apple's
technology troubles.
The fact that concerns me most is that many of the comments about
NeXT engineers making the important decisions come from Apple
employees, Apple insiders (often former employees), and long-time
Macintosh developers. Psychologically, I'm sure there's resentment
about being bailed out by the acquisition of NeXT, a company whose
technological achievements may be significant but didn't result in
a profitable business. Similarly, from the NeXT point of view,
becoming part of Apple gives former NeXT employees a chance to
show off to a true mass market - so an interest in pushing their
technology over Apple technology shouldn't be surprising.
In essence, the acquisition of NeXT is having a significant impact
on Apple's culture. That's not necessarily bad, but it can make
for an occasionally acrimonious transition. The question is
whether the attitudes and beliefs that made the Macintosh special
can survive in the new atmosphere.
**Mac OS 95/Mac OS NT** -- As I was talking with friends about the
Rhapsody networking issues, I realized that the issue of the Mac
OS and Rhapsody coexisting is worth additional thought. Consider
the following:
* At best, Rhapsody will be available for users in early 1998. So,
developing for the Mac OS isn't a bad move for several years yet.
The existing market isn't going away, and Mac OS machines will
outnumber Rhapsody-capable machines for a long time.
* Although it will reportedly be easy to program for Rhapsody (and
some Unix applications can be ported without much trouble),
Rhapsody's Yellow Box will have relatively few applications for
some time. There's a distinct risk of Rhapsody being marginalized
unless Mac OS applications running in the Blue Box or on Mac OS
machines carry it along.
* Rhapsody will have preemptive multitasking and protected memory
for Yellow Box applications, which means that they could perform
better and more reliably. In addition, things like the file system
should have better performance, making the Yellow Box the obvious
target for server applications and other situations where
stability and performance are paramount. But, with the vast
majority of the Mac market and the most applications, Mac OS
machines will probably be the main clients for Rhapsody servers.
Now, doesn't the differentiation between the Mac OS and Rhapsody
sound like the difference between Windows 95 and Windows NT? They
look the same, and most applications work under both, but Windows
NT has fewer native applications and is more trouble to set up and
maintain. But, Windows 95 doesn't share NT's stability and
performance. The main difference is that Windows 95 and Windows NT
share the same programmer interfaces (APIs), so properly written
applications run on both Windows 95 and NT. In contrast,
Rhapsody's Yellow Box applications won't run on non-Rhapsody Macs,
and existing Mac OS applications won't be able to take advantage
of the preemptive multitasking and protected memory of the Yellow
Box.
Comparisons to other Microsoft operating system switches may also
be relevant. Even today, some PC games basically don't run in
Windows, and users run them from DOS (which isn't possible with an
NT-only machine). Similarly, some current Windows programs are
still 16-bit and don't support such niceties as long filenames. In
other words, switching from one operating system to another is
seldom a clean process, and even Microsoft hasn't escaped its DOS
and Windows 3.x legacy. In contrast, Apple has handled its
operating system upgrades and even the move from the 680x0 to the
PowerPC chip with aplomb. Will Apple maintain that level of
consistency and excellent user experience in the future, with the
move to Rhapsody?
**For Sale or Breakup?** Some of my more business-oriented friends
have commented that Apple's recent moves might be gussying up the
company for acquisition. Drop unprofitable products, eliminate
technologies that haven't taken the world by storm, lay off 4,100
employees, and suddenly Apple becomes a more attractive
acquisition target. We know Apple has had acquisition discussions
with companies such as Sun Microsystems in the past; is it far-
fetched to think Apple might consider such a move again? Rumors
have already surfaced of a group of investors (led by Oracle CEO
Larry Ellison) buying Apple.
Here's another, less-depressing thought: one of Apple's long-term
problems is that it has always tried to do everything: hardware,
operating systems, new technologies, application software, server
software, and so on. Trying to do everything often causes
conflicts, both internally and with third-party developers. Might
it make sense to break Apple into three different companies, each
of which could focus on its own goals more seriously?
One company would focus on operating systems and low-level
technologies. As an independent company, it could focus on
technologies that would advance the industry and earn licensing
fees (can you say QuickTime?). That would probably mean more
emphasis on cross-platform technologies and operating systems, and
on shipping products in a reasonable time frame. It might also
mean alliances with technology development projects in higher
education, often the bellwether for the computer industry.
I see another company devoted to hardware, and since Apple has
always made some of the best computer hardware, that company could
make decisions that would let it be as successful as possible. If
that meant making Intel-based hardware, so be it. Claris has made
a lot of money selling Windows software, and the money is just as
green on other platforms (in the U.S. anyway, where we have dull-
looking money).
The third company would devote itself to application and utility
software. Apple already has such a company in Claris, although I
think Claris would do well to take over a number of additional
products currently controlled by Apple. Even the Finder, which is
just another application, could move to Claris, which could make
different versions for different markets or platforms. I'd love to
see the Finder instead of the standard Windows 95 interface.
Of course, this is mostly a thought exercise: I'm not in charge of
anything at Apple, and I doubt Apple would do something so
drastic. The question is, in such a situation, would there be an
Apple Computer? If the answer is no, would that matter if the
Macintosh survived and continued to thrive? When I commented in
TidBITS-370_ that customer loyalty to Apple was at an all-time low
while users remained loyal to the Macintosh, email comments
flooded in, agreeing 100 percent. It's an interesting phenomenon,
and one that Apple and the Mac clone vendors would do well take
into account.
Perhaps, in the end, Macintosh is an experience, not a machine.
iWorld and Welcome to It
------------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
Myriad are the ways in which technological and economic experts
propose to assist you with the Internet, as I discovered at the
Spring Internet World convention held the week of 10-Mar-97 in Los
Angeles. They want to give you access, give you faster access,
restrict your employees' access, give the outside world access to
you, restrict outside access. They want to push, help you push,
sell to you, help you sell, help you gather information, advertise
for you, advertise to you. They want to teach you about it, teach
you to program it, teach you to use it effectively, sell you books
and magazines about it, and teach you to make money from it in
dozens of ways from ISP to entrepreneur. They want to host
conventions about it, and sell you CDs about the conventions.
Everyone from cataloguers to meteorologists has a site for you to
visit, and you in turn are supposed to brighten your site with
powerful software, professional design, dynamic response, and
high-bandwidth innovations.
<http://events.iworld.com/spring97/iw/>
It was fun in that exhausting way that these conventions are; and
I learned a thing or two. The convention struck me as indicative
of how the Internet largely remains little more than a tentative
state of mind. There can't be many true experts on Web site design
or how to make money on the net, because the former (aside from
being a moving target) has existed only briefly, and the latter is
a complete mystery [except, perhaps, to X-rated sites, which
according to recent media reports are an extremely successful
example of Internet commerce -Adam]. So, the idea that such people
exist and can pontificate to us - and that we will pay them to do
so - is the product of a kind of self-hypnosis.
Indeed, the entire event seemed a smoke-and-mirrors affair;
especially compared to Macintosh conventions. Attendance the first
day was meagre: aisles that, at a Macworld Expo, would have been
shoulder-to-shoulder one minute after opening time, were nearly
empty. At talks, sound systems were muddy, projection facilities
were unreliable. Email stations were rows of PCs poorly configured
and so tightly crammed together that you couldn't move the mouse.
Nearly every demonstrator bemoaned the abysmal Internet access
(another IBM triumph - remember the Atlanta Olympics?). In
contrast to a Macworld Expo's feverish emporia, few booths had
anything physically for sale: most were selling a dream, a hope, a
future business relationship.
As a Macintosh partisan, I instantly found myself a minority in an
alien world. Here, Apple was but a minor player, and everything
had an unfamiliar slant, starting with all the demos on PCs -
including General Magic's Magic Cap under Windows - and extending
to the unaccustomed non-Apple philosophy that predominated.
Watching someone from Microsoft smugly demonstrate how Internet
Explorer and the operating system will be so tightly integrated
that the webmaster will determine what applications the user can
see from the desktop, I barely refrained from saying that if my
computer ever did that to me I would hurl it out the window.
Apple CEO Gil Amelio's keynote speech was the first good
performance I've seen from him - intelligent, coherent, even
dynamic, recalling the legend of the dying swan's terminal song.
His choice of four pieces of software historically representative
of the Mac's unique importance - PageMaker, HyperCard, Director,
and Frontier - seemed to me one of Apple's more perceptive self-
assessments. I may not have agreed with everything he said (Apple
is betting the farm on gaining 15 percent of the Web server market
share? how?) but I did feel for once like defending his right to
say it. And the demos, especially of Frontier and of QuickTime
3.0, were stunning.
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/speeches/1997/q2/970312.amelio.iworld1.html>
I also attended a talk on Apple and Java, where the speaker was
somewhat hamstrung both by the approach of Black Friday (then only
four days away - see TidBITS-370_) with its attendant unknowns and
by Apple's general Java uncertainty. The present situation is
reflected by Mac OS Runtime for Java, but the future is expressed
as a vague diagram in which Java looms as a mysterious third
beside the Blue Box (System 7 and its heirs) and the Yellow Box
(OpenStep). I admit to bemusement as to the wisdom of this, since
if Java becomes a full citizen the Mac OS may lose its
distinctiveness and hence its appeal. I did come away feeling
friendlier to Java than previously, at least.
Amidst all the glitter, I found two sites that particularly
impressed me with their promise. SemioMap makes a Java applet and
a search tool which coordinate to provide an MCF-like
visualization of related topics on the Web (or any other data
collection). StockSmart is a living advertisement for Java and for
Oracle Corporation; even if you don't care about stocks, this is a
fine and generous presentation of live, searchable data.
<http://www.semio.com/>
<http://www.stocksmart.com/>
Say Cheese! Snapz Pro
---------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
I just finished another book, and the books I write require
screenshots. Previously, I relied on a shareware screenshot
utility called Flash-It. Written by Nobu Toge and last updated in
1993, Flash-It 3.0.2 continues to function today, surprising for a
utility that works at such a low-level.
That is, Flash-It continues to work well with one notable (if not
surprising) exception: Microsoft applications. If I were a
conspiracy buff, I'd say Nobu Toge did that on purpose, but that's
unlikely since most of the Microsoft programs it has trouble with
didn't exist in 1993. Some problems were minor, such as bits of
color showing in screenshots taken when the monitor was set to 256
grays.
Internet Explorer 3.0, though, was the final straw for poor Flash-
It due to problems in Standard File dialogs, so I went looking for
another screenshot utility. I didn't go far, because Ambrosia
Software posted their $20 shareware Snapz Pro 1.0.1 to Info-Mac
that very day, and I've used it happily since. There are many
other screenshot programs out there, but Snapz Pro met my
immediate needs, so I didn't look further. Perhaps some day I'll
compare them all, but for now I'm sticking with Snapz Pro.
<http://www.ambrosiasw.com/Products/SnapzPro.html>
**Loading the Film** -- Snapz Pro installs a single control panel,
but you only use it for basic setup. Clicking the Settings button
brings up a small dialog where you choose the Snapz Key that
invokes Snapz Pro (it defaults to Command-Shift-3). A checkbox
toggles sound effects. Snapz Pro only saves screenshots in PICT
format (which may seem slightly limiting - more on that later),
but you can choose which program will open those PICTs when you
double-click them in the Finder. Finally, a pair of radio buttons
let you select whether invoking Snapz Pro should open the Snapz
palette (the program's primary interface) or take the screenshot
with the last-used capture tool.
**Click the Shutter** -- When the time comes to take a screenshot,
you arrange the screen however you want, and, if necessary, drop a
menu. Then you press the Snapz Key, which brings up the Snapz
palette.
The palette contains four large buttons for the different capture
tools: Screen, Window, Menu, and Selection. Below the four capture
tool buttons are three pop-up menus. One lets you choose where you
want to send your screenshot: to a file in the Screen Snapz folder
that Snapz Pro installs in your Apple menu, to the clipboard, to
the printer, or to a file within a folder in your Screen Snapz
folder. Another pop-up menu lets you set the scaling of your image
from 10 to 400 percent in a variety of useful percentages. The
final pop-up menu enables you to change the colors in your
screenshot using different palettes, including Black/White, System
palette, Greyscale palette (probably the standard for books),
Thousands, and Windows palette.
Checkboxes let you decide if the cursor should show in the
screenshot and if you want to name each screenshot individually.
If you choose not to name each screenshot, Snapz Pro names them
using the name of the active program, several spaces, an
incremented digit, and a ".pict" filename extension.
Once the Snapz palette has appeared, you modify the settings in
the pop-up menus and the checkboxes (Snapz Pro remembers your
settings from the previous usage), then you click one of the four
capture tool buttons. (There are also copious keyboard shortcuts.)
The cursor changes to indicate which tool you've selected, after
which you click on the screen, window, or menu you want to
capture. Obviously, the Selection capture tool requires you to
drag out a rectangular selection instead of just clicking, and the
Menu capture tool is unavailable unless you had a menu dropped
when you invoked Snapz Pro. Helpfully, Snapz Pro enables you to
select which sub-menu you capture of a set of visible hierarchical
menus, and by default captures all visible sub-menus down from the
one you click.
As you click on a screen, menu, or window, or let up on the mouse
button after making a selection, Snapz Pro makes a clicking
shutter noise and inverts the area you've captured, providing
visual feedback about your target area. If you're saving to a file
and you've selected the checkbox to choose the file name, a small
dialog appears where you can enter the name (it's not a Standard
File dialog, and the file will be stored in the pre-specified
folder). If you enter the name of an existing screenshot, Snapz
Pro asks you to confirm that you want to replace it.
The well-written Snapz Pro documentation outlines various options
you can apply to each of the capture tools. For instance, pressing
Option causes the Snapz palette to reappear so you can take more
screenshots immediately. The Command key modifies the Screen
capture tool to capture all attached monitors, and also modifies
the Window capture tool to capture only the window content. When
using the Selection capture tool, Shift constrains the selection's
shape to a square, and Command tries to select the smallest area
in the selection that is not of a certain "bluescreen" color.
**Developing the Image** -- For my purposes, Snapz Pro's ability
to change the palette to greyscale was helpful, but not
sufficient. The publisher, Osborne/McGraw-Hill, wanted screenshots
in TIFF format, and Snapz Pro only takes PICTs. Luckily, the free
clip2gif from Yves Piguet works wonderfully for converting files
with a single drag & drop action.
<http://iawww.epfl.ch/Staff/Yves.Piguet/clip2gif-home/>
Clip2gif proved useful later on as well. My publisher wanted me to
print all the screenshots and label them with the appropriate
figure numbers. This was a pain, but it's hard to argue with
production departments - you don't want them to mess up your
screenshots. I turned on the Desktop Printer capabilities in
System 7.5.5, selected the screenshots for a chapter, and dropped
them on the desktop printer icon, which resulted in the files
printing in the order that they appeared in the Finder window
(View by Name in this case).
The only problem was that if I used the SimpleText PICT files,
SimpleText printed multiple pages for the larger screenshots.
Since the paper copies were merely representative of the
screenshots, I saw no reason to waste paper printing edges that
flowed onto a second page. If, however, I dropped the clip2gif
TIFF files on the desktop printer, clip2gif displayed the Print
dialog for each file, allowing me to specify that I wanted to
print only the first page of each one.
**Image Problems** -- Although Snapz Pro met my immediate needs,
it isn't perfect. The feature I would have most liked to see is an
option to set the pattern for automatically naming and numbering
screenshots. The basic capability is obviously there - what's
lacking is an interface to let the user specify a more useful
pattern to the names and numbers, like "Figure 23-12."
Also annoying was the requirement that the screenshots end up in
the Screen Snapz folder in my Apple Menu Items folder. I partition
my hard disk in very specific ways, and I don't like being forced
to save files in one place, much less in my System Folder.
Whenever I finished taking screenshots for a chapter, I had to
copy them to the proper location for them on my hard disk. The
destination folder should be configurable.
Finally, I could see adding the capability to send screenshots to
more than one place at a time - I would have tried printing a
screenshot at the same time I saved it to a file, especially if
Snapz Pro could scale it to fit on a single page and automatically
print the filename as a footer on the page. Perhaps that's
excessive, but authors would appreciate the flexibility.
**Choosing the Camera** -- I used Snapz Pro for about a month and
took over 80 screenshots with it, so I felt comfortable paying the
$20 shareware fee via Ambrosia's Web site (Snapz Pro reminds you
about paying after 15 days of use by telling you how long you've
had it and how many screenshots you've taken, which I rather miss
now that I've paid, since I'm generally curious about how many
screenshots I've taken). I never experienced crashing problems,
and it's a fat binary, so its performance was always snappy on my
Power Mac 8500.
If you're not happy with the built-in screenshot capability in the
Mac OS, (press Command-Shift-3 to try it; in Mac OS 7.6, you can
also press Command-Shift-4 to make a selection or capture a
window), Snapz Pro is worth a look. It's a solid utility, and a
great example of a program that works well as shareware.
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.273 | Issue #374 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 08 1997 10:55 | 594 |
|
TidBITS#374/07-Apr-97
=====================
This week opened with a bang as Microsoft announced plans to
purchase the Internet start-up WebTV, Connectix announced its
Pentium-emulating Virtual PC, and Apple delivered the free Mac OS
7.6.1 Update, which eliminates most Type 11 errors by decree.
Also, Tonya reviews Akimbo's Globetrotter Web site creation tool,
and we welcome StarNine as a new TidBITS sponsor.
Topics:
MailBITS/07-Apr-97
Apple Releases Mac OS 7.6.1
Globetrotter: Brilliant Yet Bewildering
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-374.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#374_07-Apr-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#374! <--------- NEW!
Performa 6200 8MB/1GB/CD 15" monitor, refurbished: $979
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]> <--- NEW!
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
Download your free demos now: <http://www.starnine.com/>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/07-Apr-97
------------------
**StarNine Technologies Sponsoring TidBITS** -- We're extremely
pleased to welcome our latest sponsor, StarNine Technologies. As
many of you know, StarNine makes the popular Macintosh Web and
mailing list servers, WebSTAR and ListSTAR, along with some mail
gateways and Quarterdeck Mail (nee Microsoft Mail). The other
products notwithstanding, WebSTAR and then ListSTAR really put
StarNine on the map for us.
WebSTAR began as the shareware MacHTTP, created by Chuck Shotton.
When Chuck announced that StarNine had acquired MacHTTP and would
be renaming it WebSTAR, we were concerned. Not all shareware makes
the transition to the commercial world, but Chuck and StarNine did
well, making WebSTAR the leading Mac Web server and continuing to
push the feature and performance envelopes.
As important as WebSTAR is (and TidBITS uses it for our Web
server), ListSTAR saved our bacon in August of 1996, when Rice
University shut down the aging IBM mainframe that had been hosting
the TidBITS mailing list. We moved the entire list to a Power Mac
7100 running ListSTAR, and it (along with a custom FileMaker
database) has run smoothly since. Considering that there are over
46,000 people on the TidBITS list, ListSTAR demonstrates the fact
that Macintosh is a serious Internet server machine.
In September of 1995, the now-beleaguered Quarterdeck Corporation
acquired StarNine, which initially looked like a synergistic move.
Little development came of it, but StarNine has remained a wholly-
owned subsidiary and thrives on its own. We're happy to see
StarNine supporting the Internet community via their sponsorship
of TidBITS and other Macintosh resources like the Info-Mac Digest.
[ACE]
**Microsoft Buying WebTV** -- On 06-Apr-97, Microsoft announced a
surprising $425 million dollar stock and cash deal to buy WebTV
Networks, Inc., makers of the WebTV set-top box that enables users
to surf the Web via their television (see TidBITS-367_). Already a
content provider with efforts like MSN and MSNBC, WebTV also gives
Microsoft a strong foothold in an emerging online consumer
electronics market and - perhaps more importantly - may let
Microsoft control key patents relating to set-top box design and
software technology. [GD]
<http://www.sjmercury.com/business/webtv.htm>
**PC in a Mac** -- No, it's not a late April Fools joke, though it
does point the way to another method for keeping a Mac on your
desk and running PC software when necessary. Connectix, makers of
RAM Doubler, has announced Virtual PC, Macintosh software that
emulates a Pentium-based PC. Because Virtual PC aims to emulate a
processor, not an operating system, it reportedly will enable Mac
users to run off-the-shelf versions of DOS, Windows 3.1, 95, and
NT, plus NeXT OpenStep and OS/2, with support for key PC options
including SoundBlaster Pro, Ethernet, printing, and modems.
Virtual PC should ship in June and run on any Power Mac with
System 7.5. Although there are emulation alternatives like
Insignia's SoftWindows or plugging in a hardware card, I expect
that Virtual PC will inject new blood into the emulation market.
Connectix -- 800/950-5880 -- 415/571-5100 -- 415-571-5195 (fax)
<[email protected]> [TJE]
<http://www.connectix.com/connect/CVPC.PR.html>
**Microsoft says thanks** to the TidBITS and Evangelist readers
who took part in the "Mac-likeness" survey mentioned in
TidBITS-372_. Despite problems with their server, Microsoft
collected more than ten times the data it was looking for in
a week and a half, and says it received a strong message about
what Macintosh users expect from software. Nice job, folks -
we'll see if we can convince Microsoft to pass along the survey
results. If you didn't get a chance to take the survey, Microsoft
has a general feedback area where users can comment on any of
their products. [GD]
<http://www.microsoft.com/regwiz/wiz6.asp>
Apple Releases Mac OS 7.6.1
---------------------------
by Geoff Duncan <[email protected]>
Today, Apple released Mac OS 7.6.1 in three forms: four disk
images for owners of Mac OS 7.6, five disk images for owners of
PowerBook 3400s, and a full Mac OS CD-ROM. The disk images
versions are freely available for downloading from Apple's
Internet sites; getting physical copies is more complicated, but
CD-ROM (for owners of the latest Macs) or floppy disk versions can
be obtained through Apple's Mac OS Up-To-Date program (800/335-
9258). For further information, see the files that accompany the
online version of the update or URLs below.
<http://support.info.apple.com/ftp/7.6.1.html>
<http://www.macos.apple.com/macos/releases/fulfillment.html>
Online, the Mac OS 7.6.1 Update is available as a net install or
as disk images totalling about 6.5 MB. The 7.6.1 disk images use
Apple's new NDIF format, so you must use the newly-revised
DiskCopy 6.1.2 (itself a 1.1 MB download) to use the disk image
(utilities like ShrinkWrap don't yet support Apple's new format).
You don't need DiskCopy to use the net install version.
<ftp://ftp.info.apple.com//Apple_Support_Area/Apple_SW_Updates/US/
Macintosh/Utilities/Disk_Copy_6.1.2.sea.hqx>
Currently, Mac OS 7.6.1 Update is only available for U.S. English
system software. Apple says localized versions of the update
should be available within 90 days.
**So What Is It?** Mac OS 7.6.1 is mostly an incremental OS update
to support new Apple hardware, like the PowerBook 3400 and the
Power Mac 4400, 5500, 6500, 7300, 8600 and 9600 models. It's not
intended to offer new features or add items released since Mac OS
7.6, like Open Transport 1.1.2 or Macintosh Runtime for Java.
However, it also contains a handful of subtle fixes that can be
useful for owners of Mac OS 7.6. (For a detailed overview of Mac
OS 7.6, see TidBITS-363_). Remember: unless you buy the full
CD-ROM version of 7.6.1, you must already own Mac OS 7.6 to
upgrade to Mac OS 7.6.1.
**About Those Type 11 Errors...** The big talk about Mac OS 7.6.1
is the elimination of nearly all Type 11 crashes on PowerPC-based
Macintoshes, which at first glance seems like a spectacular thing.
Unfortunately, this has been widely misinterpreted in discussion
forums and some press reports as a giant leap in the stability of
Mac OS 7.6.1 over previous releases.
Here's the real story: before Mac OS 7.6.1, most crashes in Power-
PC native code were mapped to the error number 11, which stands
for a generic fatal error. Frequently, the Macintosh had another
error code that accurately described the problem, but because the
crash happened in PowerPC code the Mac couldn't do anything more
precise, and users saw the number 11. The big change in Mac OS
7.6.1 is that errors in PowerPC code now map to the _correct_
error numbers. This doesn't mean the crashes have gone away, but
rather that the system software can now report them accurately.
So what? If the crash is still going to happen, what does it
matter if a different error number is reported? The difference is
in how the Mac can handle those errors. Without a low-level
debugger like MacsBug installed, a Type 11 error forces the
immediate restart of your computer: there's no opportunity to save
work in other programs. Under Mac OS 7.6.1, most of these errors
will simply cause the offending application to quit (resulting in
a familiar "application has unexpectedly quit" dialog) rather than
a complete restart of the machine. You _should_ still restart your
Mac after such an error (there's no telling what the crashed
application left in memory), but now you'll be able to save work
in other applications, eject disks, or make a quick backup copy of
an important file before you restart. Yes, it's still a crash, but
in many cases it'll be a nicer crash.
**What Else Is There?** Mac OS 7.6.1 also includes CFM-68K 4.0
(see TidBITS-369_), which lets 68K Macs run software (like
Cyberdog, Microsoft Internet Explorer 3.0.1, AOL 3.0, and
LaserWriter 8.4) that requires the Code Fragment Manager. Support
for CFM-68K was explicitly removed from Mac OS 7.6 due to
potential serious problems, giving 68K owners little incentive to
upgrade. Including CFM-68K 4.0 in Mac OS 7.6.1 lets Apple have a
single version of the System software that offers comparable
features for all 32-bit clean Macs (from the Mac IIci onwards).
Mac OS 7.6.1 also includes Apple CD-ROM 5.3.3 (which supports
high-speed IDE CD-ROM drives), Apple System Profiler 1.1.4, Apple
Video Player 1.6 (now scriptable!), and improved software for
PowerBook PC Cards.
Mac OS 7.6.1 also includes a library called ObjectSupportLib 1.2,
which is important if you do any Macintosh scripting, or need to
run scripts on your Mac. In recent months there has been a
cacophony of versions, reversions, and regressions of
ObjectSupportLib, which would be funny if all the shenanigans
hadn't caused so much confusion. Complete, gory details are
available in an Apple Tech Note, but the bottom line is that you
should use ObjectSupportLib 1.2, which is also available with many
third-party products like Eudora and Internet Explorer.
<http://www.devworld.apple.com/dev/technotes/tn/tn1095.html>
**Miscellaneous Changes** -- Mac OS 7.6.1 includes a few other
changes and bug fixes, including updates (and a larger memory
allocation) in the Process Manager, improved IDE driver support,
serial communications improvements in some Performa models, a fix
in the DR (68K) emulator from 7.5.5 that was accidently left out
of Mac OS 7.6, and anyone who still has to use old 400K MFS floppy
disks will find that they're read-only under Mac OS 7.6.1. Apple
has made a complete list of updated components, changes, and known
problems in Mac OS 7.6.1 available in a Tech Note, including
workarounds for problems with LaserWriter 8.3.4 (use version 8.4)
and using Virtual Memory with DayStar 040 Upgrade cards.
<http://www.devworld.apple.com/dev/technotes/tn/tn1096.html>
If you have a PowerBook 3400 and want to use both Mac OS 7.6.1 and
Open Transport 1.1.2, install Open Transport 1.1.2 over System
7.6, _then_ install the 3400s version of the 7.6.1 update, or
you'll wind up with the wrong versions of some network resources.
**Should You Install 7.6.1?** If you own Mac OS 7.6 or one of the
new machines Mac OS 7.6.1 is explicitly designed to support, then
getting Mac OS 7.6.1 is probably a good idea. If you use or
support a range of Macintoshes (including older 68K machines along
with newer models) and need to have one comprehensive system
release that will work well on all those machines, then the 7.6.1
Update is worth some thought if you've already upgraded to Mac OS
7.6. Otherwise, if you're looking for new features, bells, and
whistles, it's probably best to wait for Mac OS 8 (Tempo), due to
ship in July.
Globetrotter: Brilliant Yet Bewildering
---------------------------------------
by Tonya Engst <[email protected]>
Globetrotter Web Publisher 1.1.1, created by Akimbo Systems
(publishers of the FullWrite word processor), blends word
processing and HTML editing features to make a brilliant but
bewildering Web authoring tool.
<http://www.akimbo.com/>
**Excuses, Excuses** -- Ideally, TidBITS would have published this
review in late 1996, soon after Globetrotter 1.0 shipped.
Unfortunately, I was slowed by my Macintosh's strange crashing
problems with Modern Memory Manager turned off (more on that
later), Globetrotter's documentation, and my false expectation
that Globetrotter shipped as it was billed in pre-release versions
- as software intended for people who want to print documents and
publish them as Web sites.
Instead, over time, I learned that Globetrotter is aimed at those
who want to make Web pages using word processing tools.
Globetrotter also works reasonably well for producing printed
documents, but that's primarily a side-effect of the fact that
Globetrotter has much in common with FullWrite.
**Don't Worry, Be Happy** -- Open a new Globetrotter document, and
you'll see a rich set of menus. Some have a good set of keyboard
shortcuts, but others - particularly menus for tables and forms -
lack shortcuts.
You'll also notice buttons for switching between Browser View and
Page View. In Browser View, you cannot make changes, but you can
see how your document might appear on the Web. In Page View, you
can edit documents, and additional buttons (such as two-page view)
appear and modify Page View. I spent most of my time in Page View
because my Mac crashed four of the first five times I tried to
switch into Browser view.
To make a Web page in Globetrotter, just start typing. You can
also paste in text or import files via XTND. You can apply formats
like bold, small caps, or strikeout, change fonts and sizes, and
even change text color. Globetrotter refers to formats using word
processing terminology, with nary an <EM> or <STRONG> to be seen.
There are few ways to control (or - in some cases - predict) how
Globetrotter will convert formats to HTML. If you have no interest
in HTML, you won't care, since the resulting Web pages tend to
look fine. You can customize the occasional format; for instance,
you can turn off <FONT FACE> so font choices don't end up in the
HTML.
Globetrotter feels like a word processor. Sometimes this is good,
but other times it's weird, because Globetrotter operates on a
printed page metaphor, not a screen metaphor. When you insert a
page break after a few inches of text, you see a big blank area
representing the rest of a sheet of paper. The blank area only
shows in Globetrotter, not on the Web, and there's no way to set a
custom page size that equates to a screen.
The bulk of Globetrotter's Web publishing features are accessible
through a regrettably modal, multi-tabbed Web Setup dialog box
where you configure most Web-related details: whether recent
changes should be color-coded or take on a "NEW!" graphic, the
appearance of the default horizontal rule, settings for a
navigation bar, and so on.
**Slip Between the Style Sheets** -- Globetrotter beats the
PageMill-and-friends crowd with its ability to connect styles to
how text appears on the Web. For example, to structure a site
quickly, you could style main topics with a paragraph style called
"Contents." Your site would consist of one Globetrotter file, but
each topic would automatically appear at the top of a new Web
page, tagged as an <H1> heading.
Contents-styled topics could appear in a navigation bar on each
page (a text-based bar or one based on Globetrotter's limited
button set). Main topics could also appear in a bulleted list on a
separate page or at the bottom of the first page. But, there's no
way to customize this list, and no way to create list sub-heads.
In Globetrotter, you can't see the list or the navigation bars,
but they do appear when you preview or export to HTML. (Akimbo
prefers the term "publish" instead of "export.") Styles strike me
as the most important part of Globetrotter, and I can't understand
why Akimbo demoted them to the bottom of a long menu, with no
keyboard shortcuts. It would also be handy for Globetrotter to
come with styles pre-set to match HTML tags. Styles like
"Heading1" or "IndentedQuote" would easily map to HTML tags
without confusing users, and they might push authors towards
creating well-structured documents where tags indicate text's
function in a document, not just its appearance.
**Links** -- Linking options are weak in Globetrotter. Linked text
appears with a dotted underline, but you cannot wave the mouse
over linked text to see the URL; instead, you must double-click
the text to open a dialog containing the URL. Other problems
include no single-step method for removing link information and no
way to access frequently or recently used URLs.
Although savvy Globetrotter users can handle intra-site links
through styles, Globetrotter can also convert URLs in the text to
links, or you can make links by hand. If you create a link by
hand, you can choose a picture or button to represent the start of
the link. The text that acts as the start of the link
automatically appears in the button.
Globetrotter has no link verification feature, but it can store
URLs in its glossary. To use a stored URL, you type its name in
angle brackets, like this: "<<URLname>>". On export, Globetrotter
automatically swaps in the correct URL. If the URL changes, you
simply change the glossary entry and export again.
**Graphics** -- Globetrotter has numerous graphics-related
features and offers some uncommon ones. For instance, text
formatted with fonts like Zapf Dingbats or Symbol converts to a
graphic when you export to HTML. Additionally, horizontal rules
can be individually customized or take on characteristics from the
Web Setup dialog box, where you can even substitute a graphic for
the standard horizontal rule.
Globetrotter accepts PICT, PNTG, JPEG, and GIF files. Graphics can
be linked from a document or incorporated into the document file.
The program has transparency and interlacing features, and it can
add <ALT> tags to images. There's no way to resize graphics by
dragging their edges, though you can type numbers to change the
height or width, or resize by percentage. Globetrotter can align a
graphic with respect to text in a paragraph, but these alignments
don't display in Page View, and popular options for wrapping text
left or right of a graphic are not available.
Although the half-baked alignment feature is a disappointment,
image maps work well, with full support for client- and server-
side options. The image map editor does a good job with the usual
suite of features (sans a zoom), plus the capability to set <ALT>
tags for any image map section and optionally have them show up in
a text-based navigation bar below the image.
Globetrotter sidebars can contain either graphics or text
callouts, and they float on a page, with text wrapping around
them. When published to the Web, the contents of a Globetrotter
sidebar can convert to a graphic, a good way to create jazzy
looking headlines. Sidebars can also be ignored, or published as
separate, linked-to pages. Linked-to pages are titled with the
contents of their first paragraph, and there's no way to customize
that. Sidebars are another example of where word processing
concepts feel funny, because you'd never guess to employ a sidebar
to accomplish these tasks. Instead, you might look in vain for a
Text to Graphic or Link to Page command.
**Forms** -- Choose Insert Form Here and Globetrotter pops up a
dialog box asking how the form will communicate with your Web
server. You can enter a URL to any CGI, or set up extensive
options for how results might be mailed to you or stored in a
tab-delimited text file. Options include the subject of the email
file and an acknowledgment page that people receive after filling
out the form. Globetrotter creates Perl scripts for these options
(Perl 4 or 5, or MacPerl), and such scripts should work on a wide
variety of servers, though people using Macintosh Web servers must
set up an AppleScript for the email feature.
Form elements are inserted from a menu and as you insert most
elements, a detailed configuration dialog box opens. For each
element, you can indicate whether its value should appear on the
optional acknowledgment page. Regrettably, there is no toolbar or
keyboard shortcuts for inserting form elements; Globetrotter comes
with a Form Toolbar folder (in the Extras folder) that contains
clipping files of form elements, but it's not much faster to drag
elements in than it is to choose them from the menu.
**General Web Publishing Features** -- In addition to features
I've already mentioned, Globetrotter has a Get Info dialog box
that estimates download times for each page. There are options for
including Java applets and embedding plug-in-type objects, and
it's even possible to create annoying running type in the bottom
of a browser window. In another feature list checkmark,
Globetrotter has a Post command for uploading to a remote server.
**Tables** -- HTML table support is present, and it's possible to
set up many table options, like vertical alignments, colors, and
cell padding. Formatting is easy, though the modal Table Format
dialog box has no Apply button, so experimenting with different
table formats takes a lot of mousing. Some cell formats, most
notably vertical alignment, must be set by double-clicking a tab
marker in the ruler above the table. You can select cells
horizontally and then apply a format (such as bold), but you
cannot select vertically in order to format an entire column in
one step. Globetrotter exports tables nicely to HTML, and even
inserts extra characters to accommodate browsers that don't
understand table tags.
I ran into a bothersome problem where table cells wouldn't select
or deselect properly. Akimbo eventually identified the problem as
a bug with using black as the selection color.
**Writing Tools** -- Globetrotter packs a pile of helpful writing
tools. The spelling checker ignores URLs and email addresses and
can be controlled almost completely from the keyboard. It has a
Valid in Doc command for indicating that words are correct only in
the context of a particular document. The thesaurus strikes me as
useful and friendly. The glossary combines an "auto-correct"
feature with the more traditional ability to store frequently used
bits of text, and the bits can be lengthy (according to Akimbo,
they can exceed the often-bothersome 32K limit inherent to many
such features).
The reasonably capable Find dialog box can find and replace based
on formatting information, and it supports a limited set of wild
cards, an important, though undocumented feature: few people will
guess at Option-X to represent any word and Shift-Option-? to
represent a character.
In short, compared to most HTML editors, Globetrotter offers more
mature writing tools. It can sort numerically or alphabetically,
offers clipboard-related commands like Copy Append and Paste Swap,
and has variables for inserting updating elements like change date
(complete with what look like features for running a print merge,
though the documentation is silent on this topic).
However, Globetrotter lacks two important word processing
features. The first is a multiple undo, which I increasingly
consider a necessity. Second, Globetrotter's outliner occupies a
prominent position in the interface but is only good for creating
the Web equivalent of basic lists, not for outlining an entire
document. The outliner would shine if outline levels could be
linked to Globetrotter's styles, which can be easily linked to
HTML tags.
**Weak Documentation** -- Anyone who doesn't already know Akimbo's
FullWrite will have a tough time learning Globetrotter, and even
FullWrite aficionados will have trouble divining some of
Globetrotter's unique features. Learning the ins and outs of
Globetrotter has felt like a frustrating dialog with a teacher who
gives bad grades but rarely explains the topic at hand.
The interface does not lend itself to exploration; there is no
toolbar and thus no tool tips, and nothing like Balloon Help or
helpful dialog box comments. The heart of the Web-based
documentation, called the Answer Guide, has about ten pages: Using
Tables, Creating Forms, Formatting, and so on, and each page has a
long list of questions and answers. There's no detailed table of
contents and no index. I've read the documentation completely, and
some of it multiple times. Even so, on many occasions, I only
found out how to do something by inferring from a reference in the
documentation, through the printed FullWrite manual, or by asking
Akimbo directly.
**Memory Madness** -- Try to use Globetrotter on a Power Mac
running any version of the Mac OS before 7.5.5, and it won't
launch with Modern Memory Manager turned on, a trait perhaps
unique to Globetrotter amongst all currently shipping Macintosh
programs. Akimbo does this to avoid crashing, and points the
finger at Apple as the cause of the problems. I found it
tremendously annoying until I upgraded to Mac OS 7.6, because my
Mac crashed frequently without Modern Memory Manager turned on,
and basic troubleshooting failed to solve the problem.
**Too Many Features, Too Little Documentation** -- Globetrotter
has a perplexing mix of word processing and Web site tools, almost
as though Akimbo included a ton of features from FullWrite and
then didn't have the mettle to look at the octopus it had created
and sever some of the nonsensical arms. This impression comes in
large part from the interface, which highlights trivial options
like two-page view and outlining at the expense of important Web
options like styles and the features accessible only through the
modal Web Setup dialog.
I have no quarrel with creating Web pages in a word processing
environment, but I find it annoying to have irrelevant aspects of
word processing thrust on me. If Globetrotter is for Web
publishing, its documents don't look like it. Document windows
should look more like a screen and less like a sheet of paper.
Documents should be editable in a view that shows their
approximate Web appearance, not a print preview. Sites should
optionally display in a graphical or hierarchical overview so it's
easy to understand the relationships between pages.
If you use FullWrite and have little interest in learning HTML
basics, Globetrotter may be a good choice for you. I think most
people will find Globetrotter much better in its next release,
when - hopefully - Akimbo will give the interface a makeover and
supply more complete and better-organized documentation.
<http://www.akimbo.com/globetrotter/download.html>
According to Akimbo, to run Globetrotter, you need at least a
68020-based Mac running System 7.0, but they recommend a 68040- or
PowerPC-based machine running System 7.5 or higher. You also need
4 MB available application RAM and between 1 and 5 MB of disk
space. Akimbo sells Globetrotter for $99 via a Web download. A 1.9
MB demo is available from the Globetrotter Web site.
Akimbo Systems -- 800/375-6515 -- 617/776-5500 -- <[email protected]>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.274 | Issue #375 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 15 1997 08:59 | 580 |
|
TidBITS#375/14-Apr-97
=====================
Are Macintosh software sales rising or falling? An important
question, and one that guest writer Matt Deatherage examines in
detail. Also this week, both Claris and Qualcomm update their
email clients, FreePPP 2.5v3 appears, Info-Mac continues working
on its move, the Crack A Mac challenge ends, and Adam marks the
seventh anniversary of TidBITS.
Topics:
MailBITS/14-Apr-97
TidBITS 7.0
Despite the Gloom, Mac Software Sales Up in 1995
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-375.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#375_14-Apr-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers!
Performa 6200 8MB/1GB/CD 15" monitor, refurbished: $979
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
Download your free demos now: <http://www.starnine.com/>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/14-Apr-97
------------------
**FreePPP 2.5v3 Patcher** -- Steve Dagley and the FreePPP Group
have released a 36K patcher program that updates the FreePPP 2.5v2
extension to 2.5v3. It fixes a nasty bug that has long been
lurking in the original MacPPP code. In situations of heavy load,
this bug could cause FreePPP to crash or hang. If you use FreePPP
2.5v2, you should update your copy. [ACE]
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/select/free-ppp-25v3-patch.hqx>
**Info-Mac Back Soon** -- Worrying about the return of Info-Mac?
Fear not, Info-Mac will return - the moderators continue to work
hard at correctly setting up all the important scripts and Unix
details. All the files have been moved over from sumex-aim, and
the new machine (a gift from AOL a few years ago), is officially
set up and working at MIT. The hope is that Info-Mac will come
online in the next week or so. Please don't submit new files to
the archive until that time; some resubmissions will be necessary
for files that arrived during the move. [ACE]
**Emailer 2.0 Available** -- Last week, Claris released Emailer
2.0, sporting a revamped interface and a handful of new landmark
features. The most important change is that Emailer now stores
messages in database form (rather than as separate files) which
greatly reduces disk space overhead in comparison to storing
messages as individual files. Emailer's Mail Actions are more
robust and offer extended filtering options, and Emailer now
supports hierarchical File Cabinet folders. If you upgrade from an
earlier version, ensure that your existing mail converts properly
by reading the installation instructions carefully. Claris has
posted a 4 MB trial version of Emailer 2.0. Claris -- 800/544-8554
[JLC]
<http://www.claris.com/products/claris/emailer/site/>
<ftp://ftp.claris.com/pub/USA-Macintosh/Trial_Software/
ClarisEmailer2.0Trial.bin>
**Eudora 3.1 Available** -- Hot on the heels of the release of
Claris Emailer 2.0, Qualcomm released version 3.1 of Eudora Light
and Eudora Pro. The main new feature in both versions is a
hierarchical Mailboxes window that provides a target for drag &
drop of messages, quick access to mailboxes, and easy manipulation
of your mailbox hierarchy. Eudora Pro 3.1 also features a toolbar
that simplifies adding styled text to messages, support for
displaying attached graphics within a message window, and
"personalities." Personalities enable a single copy of Eudora Pro
to send and receive mail on multiple Internet email accounts,
which is ideal for those of us with lots of accounts. People who
share a copy of Eudora Pro will still want to keep separate Eudora
Folders with separately configured Eudora Settings files. The
update for Eudora Pro is free, and Eudora Light remains completely
free. The Eudora Pro updater is 1.7 MB, and Eudora Light 3.1 is 2
MB. [ACE]
<http://www.eudora.com/>
**Crack Proof** -- In TidBITS-365_, we noted the two-month "Crack
A Mac" challenge being held in Sweden, offering a cash prize to
anyone able to change the contents of a Web page running on a
standard Mac OS Web server. The prize money eventually rose to
over U.S. $13,000, but no one claimed the prize by the contest
deadline of 10-Apr-97 - though not for lack of trying! The
challenge's coordinators have posted a summary of the contest
results and various break-in attempts made on the contest server,
including some clever (and amusing) social-engineering attempts to
make the contest coordinators to change the Web page themselves.
[GD]
<http://hacke.infinit.se/resumeng.html>
TidBITS 7.0
-----------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
This week marks the seventh year of TidBITS, making us serious
Internet geezers. If you're new to TidBITS (and many of you are!)
I thought I'd take a moment to note where TidBITS is on this
anniversary. Back in April of 1990, Tonya and I released the first
issue of TidBITS to the Internet in HyperCard format (a format
that survived for 99 issues before being replaced by setext).
Since then we've published on a weekly basis through several Apple
CEOs (Sculley to Spindler to Amelio), numerous business cycles for
Apple Computer, the release of more Macs than we can count, the
arrival of Macintosh clones, the continuing ascendancy of the
Internet, the hyping of Java, and the change in fortunes of
industry luminaries like WordPerfect, Aldus, Borland, Ashton-Tate,
and Lotus.
You could argue that the world has changed completely since we
began, and in many ways it has. Heck, even some of our April Fools
jokes (such as in TidBITS-052_) have come true. But, just as
everything continues to change at an increasingly fast pace,
there's also a case to be made for everything staying much the
same. Microsoft still calls many of the shots in the computer
industry. Apple still gets bad press even when it's undeserved.
The Mac OS is still the easiest operating system to learn and use.
Macworld Expos are so similar that it's almost impossible to
remember what happened at any given show.
**Some Numbers** -- Even TidBITS embodies this dichotomy (and
we've never been afraid to use the occasional word that might
require a trip to the dictionary - think of it as expanding
horizons). Our format has stayed extremely consistent since the
switch from HyperCard, and we've stuck within our informal limit
of 30K of text per issue without fail (other than a few special
issues). And yet, the number of people reading TidBITS continues
to skyrocket. Our English-language mailing list (originally run
thanks to the generosity of Rice University, and now run on a
Power Mac 7100 and StarNine's ListSTAR) served about 19,000 people
in April of 1995, 37,000 in April of 1996, and 46,000 today. In
April of 1995, TidBITS went to 65 countries; today that number has
hit 106, including a number of countries that weren't on the
Internet two years ago (or weren't even countries). Want to help
those numbers? Tell your friends they can subscribe to TidBITS,
for free of course, by sending an email message to
<[email protected]>.
We've found it difficult to estimate the number of TidBITS
readers, thanks to redistribution lists and popular areas like the
comp.sys.mac.digest newsgroup, which can't be tracked well.
Nonetheless, we've always committed to publishing in as many ways
as made sense, so we'll continue to make issues available via
email, FTP, Usenet news, and of course the Web. Check our Web site
for the latest issue and links to every past issue of TidBITS.
<http://www.tidbits.com/>
**The Top Seven** -- Leading the pack in number of English-
language subscribers in the country category are the United
States, Canada, Japan, Australia, the United Kingdom, Germany, and
Sweden. The top seven Internet providers are AOL, EarthLink,
CompuServe, Netcom, MindSpring, Northwest Nexus, and AT&T
WorldNet. The top seven non-ISP companies (many others have
internal distribution lists we can't track) are Apple, Motorola,
Hughes Aircraft, Microsoft, DuPont, McDonnell Douglas, and
Schlumberger. The top seven educational institutions are
University of Minnesota, Stanford University, University of
Michigan, Cornell University, University of Washington, University
of Texas, and Harvard University.
In my mind, our most impressive achievement is that we've
published on a regular weekly schedule the entire time. In the
early days, a weekly schedule and a shorter lead time than any
paper publication put us on the edge of speedy computer
journalism. These days, it's hard to avoid being inundated with
poorly-written, poorly-researched daily news (though there are
notable exceptions, like Matt Deatherage's MDJ and Ric Ford's
MacInTouch). We try to do more than merely report the news, and
instead try to offer some context or analysis so you can get a
better sense of what it all means. And, sometimes we ignore events
because we don't want to clutter your brains with useless
information. I believe that's what sets a publication apart from a
stream of raw data.
<http://www.gcsf.com/>
<http://www.macintouch.com/>
**Finances** -- I'm pleased that we've kept TidBITS completely
free all these years. I won't pretend that TidBITS has made us
rich, but we've never lost money (in fact, we made about $900
million more than Apple last year, if you want to talk bottom
line). Most of TidBITS's income comes from our sponsors, and it
has enabled us to contract with Geoff Duncan and Jeff Carlson, our
Technical and Managing Editors. Without their help, we'd never be
able to keep up our schedule and quality, both of which are
important to us. As much as TidBITS remains an idealistic venture,
it must also remain a viable business.
Interestingly, we started the sponsorship program back in July of
1992, before the Web had appeared and years before advertising on
the Internet was even acceptable, much less commonplace as it is
today. Although a few of our early sponsors have been acquired or
are no longer around, most current and past sponsors have proven
to be the stalwarts of the Macintosh and Internet worlds. Among
this group are (in order of appearance) Nisus Software, Dantz
Development, APS Technologies, Northwest Nexus, PowerCity Online,
Hayden Books, InfoSeek, Power Computing, America Online, EarthLink
Network, Aladdin Systems, Small Dog Electronics, and our most
recent sponsor, StarNine Technologies.
Any Macintosh or Internet company that's interested in supporting
a high-quality, free resource like TidBITS and reaching a few
hundred thousand readers each week should contact Tonya at
<[email protected]> for more details. Who knows, one of these
years Apple or Claris might even sponsor us.
**Translations** -- 1996 also marked the year in which TidBITS
translations came into their own. The Japanese translation team
has done a wonderful job since TidBITS-281_ (and has amassed their
own mailing list of over 8,600 people), and the other five
language teams (Chinese, Dutch, French, German, and Spanish)
basically all appeared in 1996. Thanks to our early status as one
of the few sources of timely information for readers in other
countries, and our efforts to not ignore international concerns,
being able to publish in six different languages has been a real
treat. As always, if you're interested in helping the volunteer
translation teams by translating an article every so often, check
our Web site for the address of the appropriate coordinator. We're
always happy to have more help with translations.
<http://www.tidbits.com/about/translations.html>
**Further Reading** -- If you're interested in TidBITS history,
you might want to browse our past anniversary issues. Check out
TidBITS-001_, TidBITS-120_, TidBITS-173_, TidBITS-222_ (the most
detailed history so far), TidBITS-273_, and TidBITS-324_. We're
proud of the fact that every single one of our issues is available
online. Two conversions were necessary for that to be true. In
1992, my sister Jennifer Engst converted the first 99 HyperCard
issues into setext, and toward the end of 1996, our Contributing
Editor Matt Neuburg converted the first 275 setext issues into
HTML to flesh out our Web presence. Everything's available on our
Web site, so feel free to browse.
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/>
In the end, I feel that TidBITS is entering its prime (after a
year of being divisible by two and three). There's no telling if
we'll make it to the next prime number in four years, but we have
no plans to stop.
Despite the Gloom, Mac Software Sales Up in 1995
------------------------------------------------
by Matt Deatherage <[email protected]>
The press loves to quote numbers, especially when predicting the
immediate demise of Apple Computer. However, the numbers the press
uses are often less precise than they would have you believe. For
instance, the Software Publishing Association (SPA) tracks
software sales on a regular basis and reported last year that
Macintosh software sales in 1995 were down roughly 14 percent.
However, the SPA releases sales figures for a given year twice - a
preliminary set about three months into the next year, and a final
set a year later. That 14 percent drop came from preliminary
figures for 1995; now that 1996 is over, the SPA has released the
final numbers for 1995, which show that Macintosh software sales
were in fact up 24 percent. Oops. Let's take a look at how the SPA
gathers this information and what it all means.
**What is the SPA?** The recently released numbers come from the
SPA's ongoing sales survey research effort. The SPA is a non-
profit membership organization that works to advance recognition
of key software industry issues with the government and business
communities. Past SPA initiatives have included extensive anti-
piracy efforts, lobbying for pro-software legislation in
Washington D.C. (including efforts against tariffs and export
controls and in favor of cryptography), and educational efforts
like the "Cybersurfari" contests that help students learn about
the Internet.
As a trade group, the SPA's members are naturally interested in
using the organization's resources to advance their business
goals. To that end, the software surveys of SPA members exist
(more or less) to convince the world that the software business is
booming and is therefore a fertile ground for investment and
career choices. Even with such a purpose, though, the SPA is not
afraid to publish results that indicate bad times - for example,
the last release in December showed an overall decline in software
sales for the third calendar quarter of 1996, but the organization
did put the best possible spin on their results, pointing out how
sales the previous year were artificially high due to the
introduction of Windows 95 and associated software.
Companies participating in SPA surveys are asked to submit sales
totals in seventeen categories, broken out by operating system.
Submissions are due six weeks or so after the end of each quarter.
The SPA then tabulates the results and distributes them to
participating companies in large, detailed spreadsheets about
three weeks later. Three to four weeks after that, the SPA
announces the results to the press, although with far less detail
than participating companies receive.
<http://www.spa.org/research/default.htm>
**Flawed Research** -- The system seems reasonable on the face of
it, but it has flaws:
* Unknown sample size: The SPA says that SPA members are
responsible for 85 percent of all North American software sales
(and the numbers in this particular survey and article, by the
way, are _only_ for U.S. and Canadian sales), but they refuse to
disclose how many of those members participate in the voluntary
sales surveys. If the responding companies represent significantly
less than 85 percent of all software sales, the survey results are
correspondingly less important.
* Restricted responses: Only SPA members can participate, and
since dues start at $750 per year and go into the hundreds of
thousands of dollars for the largest companies (depending on
software revenues), many smaller developers - the kinds that
traditionally do innovative Macintosh work - choose not to join,
and are therefore ineligible to have their sales tabulated.
* Few uniform guidelines: The SPA tabulates data exactly as
companies report it - so if those companies have little
information on where their software goes, the SPA has just as
little. Take the well-publicized case of hybrid CD-ROMs that
contain Macintosh and Windows software. The SPA makes no attempt
to figure this out, and they shouldn't have to. Instead, they rely
on data from reporting member companies. If a software company
ships 10,000 hybrid titles in a year but has no idea how many went
to Mac users and how many went to Windows users, they'll either
not report the sales or they'll estimate percentages. The SPA
doesn't provide guidelines for collecting accurate information,
and Apple executives have publicly speculated that many more
hybrid CD-ROM sales should be counted as Mac OS sales than are
reported that way. With the SPA's voluntary survey, there's no way
to tell.
**Fast But Inaccurate** -- However, the biggest problem is that
the results have, for the past several years, been shown by the
SPA itself to be highly inaccurate. Some companies don't have the
data the SPA wants by the deadline, so they don't turn it in. If
they come up with it a month or two later, they'll submit it then,
and the SPA will assimilate it into the results. Then, when the
SPA needs numbers for the same period, the revised and ostensibly
more accurate figures are used.
It makes sense to use the most accurate information available,
says the SPA. However, over the past few years, some figures
available a year after initial reporting have been vastly
different from the originally announced figures. The SPA then
commits a sin of synchronization - they compare the fast-but-
incomplete results (which I call "preliminary" numbers) to the
year-old, far-more-complete figures I call "final" results.
With few exceptions, the final results for Macintosh software
sales have been higher - often significantly higher - than
preliminary numbers. By comparing the preliminary numbers to the
final numbers, the SPA is comparing apples to oranges, and they
get percentage changes from one year to the next that can be
invalid and highly misleading.
**1995: A Good Year** -- That's what we see with the results for
software sales in 1995. Remember that the SPA releases numbers
twice - preliminary figures about three months after the end of
the year being discussed, and final numbers one year later as the
basis for comparisons against the current year. We now have final
1995 numbers because the SPA is using them as a base to see the
differences in the preliminary 1996 numbers.
Several of the SPA's seventeen categories showed little or no
difference between the preliminary results and the final results,
meaning the original reports were relatively representative - word
processors, spreadsheets, databases, integrated software and
presentation graphics were all revised by 4 percent or less.
However, other categories saw major corrections. Sales of
Macintosh utilities are now believed to be twice what the SPA
reported a year ago, with similar gains in the Drawing & Painting,
personal information management and home education categories.
Overall, the SPA now believes that Macintosh software sales were
44.2 percent higher for 1995 than originally reported.
A year ago, when the SPA released preliminary 1995 results, they
said Macintosh software sales were down 13.9 percent from 1994's
final figures, meaning Macintosh software market share fell to 14
percent from 18 percent in 1994. Now that final 1995 numbers are
available, it turns out that Macintosh software sales for the year
actually grew 24 percent in 1995.
Unfortunately, Mac OS software still slipped to 15.5 percent
market share. That's not because sales fell, but because Windows
software sales grew faster - easy to understand during the year
Windows 95 was released.
**1996: An Iffy Year** -- The recent announcement from the SPA
compares preliminary 1996 numbers to the new, final 1995 numbers.
The comparison shows what you'll read in the major press coverage
of these results - a drop of 24 percent in sales for 1996.
However, consider the following. What if we assume the under-
reporting for 1996 will be similar to the under-reporting that
took place in 1995? Perhaps, by comparing the two sets of
preliminary numbers (an "apples to apples" comparison), we might
find a better estimation of how things are really changing.
Such a comparison shows yearly growth of about 11 percent instead
of a decline of 24 percent. This is a lot easier to swallow. Other
research I've done showed that Mac OS market share actually rose
during the last part of 1996 (see TidBITS-369_), and it's hard to
believe that computer sales were up while software sales for them
were down. Historically, new computer sales have been a large
driving force behind new software sales; new software, especially
major software, is typically purchased only with new computers or
when new versions are released.
Interestingly enough, the SPA's preliminary and final numbers for
1994, a year earlier, were close to each other - within about 3
percent. If we try to average 1994 and 1995 differences to get a
sense of how far the SPA's preliminary numbers might be off, we
come up with the idea that preliminary numbers are about 21
percent below final numbers. If we go with that idea, we could
expect to see 1996 Macintosh software sales drop a bit as a 21
percent margin of error doesn't quite match the 24 percent drop
the SPA reports in its preliminary 1996 numbers. However, don't
put too much faith in this "average error" approach - the two
margins of error for 1994 and 1995 are very different, a good
indication that any speculations based on their average may not
mean (no pun intended) much.
Past experience with the SPA's numbers and an understanding of the
Mac OS market leads me to believe that the final numbers for 1996
will eventually reveal a small increase in sales, but nothing like
the large increases for Windows-based software. 1996 was a
difficult year for Macintosh software and hardware developers
alike, and though customers did eventually return to the platform
in small but significant numbers, I think that 20 percent or 30
percent gains would be unrealistic. It's more likely that the
platform saw about 8 percent growth or less during the year. The
hardware market showed similar moderate growth during 1996, and
the "apples to apples" comparison of preliminary numbers is also
in that ballpark. We won't know for sure until a year from now,
when the SPA releases final numbers for 1996.
**Why Does the SPA Do This?** I spoke extensively on this matter
last fall with SPA public relations director David Phelps, who
confirmed my description of the process with research director Jim
Sanders. Phelps vehemently insisted that the SPA was not anti-
Macintosh and was, in fact, almost an entirely Mac OS shop - it's
just that the numbers show declines, and they report them at the
time with the best information they have available.
The SPA certainly isn't trying to deceive people about the
Macintosh specifically, but the organization does show a marked
and lamentable tendency to put the value of its own numbers above
the good of the developers they're supposed to serve. The
discrepancies mentioned above also affect other SPA categories -
Windows (both 16-bit and 32-bit) and DOS - but in those cases, the
differences are of magnitude, not of sign. DOS sales in the final
figures didn't fall as much, and Windows sales in the preliminary
figures didn't rise as much as later information showed. Only the
Macintosh sales actually change direction, going from an announced
loss to a quiet gain. When the SPA's final figures are 150 percent
to 200 percent of the originally reported figures, as is often the
case here, the preliminary announcements become significantly
misleading.
This then is the SPA's problem. The group is determined to release
the numbers on schedule, which invites these inaccurate and
misleading reports. Requests that the SPA disclose how many member
companies report, disclose the full results that reporting
companies receive, and point out when revised figures make the
original announcements invalid have all been rejected. There is
only one crack in the armor - in this latest press release,
touting how all application software sales topped $10 billion for
the first time (although a year from now it will probably be
significantly higher), the SPA said that the 1996 total was "an
8.3 percent increase from a revised $9.8 billion in 1995" (let me
emphasize "revised"). Last year at this time, the SPA said 1995's
total was $7.53 billion - an error, again, of nearly 25 percent.
The group appears afraid that if they point out how inaccurate
their results are shown to be a year later, the press and public
will stop paying attention to their cries that the software
industry is healthy. But ironically, these same reports are making
the Macintosh software market less healthy. Venture capitalists
and other investors who read these results in the popular press
will never hear about the corrections, or about the difference
between "preliminary" and "final" numbers. The numbers keep going
up and the SPA keeps announcing that sales are falling - if they
were to point out the paradox in this proposition, they'd have to
admit that they don't have accurate data three months after a year
ends. They seem completely unwilling make that admission.
There's always hope that this trend will change. After MDJ
reported in January (reprinted in TidBITS-363_) that Mac OS
hardware market share was flat to improving and noting how major
research firms didn't bother to track Mac OS market share
differently from Apple Computer's market share, some research
firms started tracking Mac OS market share and the press was
surprised to discover that it was growing. I'm not claiming cause
and effect here, but the truth has a way of catching on once it
escapes. The truth is that the Mac software market, while
suffering through a bad year, has been significantly healthier
than the SPA's preliminary numbers have indicated, and there is no
reason to believe that situation has changed. Perhaps a different
group will come along with scientifically sampled surveys that
more accurately represent software sales, so the business
community can accurately judge the validity of an investment in
Mac OS technology.
[This article is reprinted and updated with permission from MDJ, a
daily Macintosh publication covering news, products, and events in
the Macintosh world. If you can't get enough insightful Mac news,
sign up for a trial subscription to MDJ. TidBITS readers who had a
free trial before 01-Apr-97 are invited to accept another one and
see how this publication has changed since its beta-test period
last year. For more information, visit the MDJ Web site.]
<http://www.gcsf.com/>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.275 | Issue #376 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 22 1997 11:05 | 576 |
|
TidBITS#376/21-Apr-97
=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D=3D
How will books and seminars change as the two fields meet online?
Adam tackles this topic with a look his most recently completed
project. In news this week, Apple posts a quarterly loss and cuts
prices on some models, GoLive Systems releases a hot-looking HTML
editor, and Jeremy Kezer updates his Control Strip Modules.
Finishing off the issue, Tonya reviews Online Army Knife, a
Macintosh spelling checker with a new attitude.
Topics:
MailBITS/21-Apr-97
DigitalThink and Electronic Courses
Onward Online Soldier: OAK, the Essential Batch Spelling=7F Checker
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-376.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#376_21-Apr-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.1, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers! <----- NEW!
Performa 6220 16MB/1GB/CD/TV/VI14" Monitor, refurbished: $954
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
Download your free demos now: <http://www.starnine.com/>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/21-Apr-97
------------------
**Apple Posts $708 Million Loss** -- As readers in the United
States agonized over their tax forms last week, the folks at Apple
found themselves staring at a $708 million quarterly loss, the
second worst showing in Apple's history. The bulk of the loss
comes from Apple's $375 million purchase of NeXT Software and a
$155 million charge to cover "restructuring activities."
Although the numbers sound intimidating, especially since the
company's deep reserve pockets are now significantly shallower,
the press hasn't jumped back on the "Apple is dead" bandwagon that
keeps rolling along Infinite Loop. This may be due to several
elements that support a gradual success of the company's
restructuring plans: operating expenses were down $32 million from
last quarter, and down $65 million from the same quarter last
year; business sales climbed 35 percent over the first quarter;
and PowerBook sales accounted for 22 percent of total revenue, up
from 10 percent. [JLC]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q3/
970416.pr.rel.q297.html>
**Apple Price Cuts** -- Last week, Apple announced $200 price cuts
on Performa 6360 and 6400-series computers, but (more
significantly) cut some prices in the PowerBook 1400 line by more
than 30 percent. A PowerBook 1400cs/117 system now starts at
$1,700 ($300 more for one with a CD-ROM), with prices extending to
$3,200 for a PowerBook 1400c/133. If you've been putting off
buying a PowerBook and the 3400s are too expensive, it might be a
good time to re-examine the PowerBook 1400. Meanwhile, rumors
continue to circulate about the PowerBook 2400, a 4.2-pound
subnotebook developed by Apple and IBM, but it still appears its
availability in the U.S. will be quite limited. [GD]
<http://biz.yahoo.com/prnews/97/04/18/aapl_x000_3.html>
**GoLive Lives On** -- Last week, GoLive Systems shipped GoLive
CyberStudio, currently at version 1.0.1. Although the $349
suggested retail price puts CyberStudio out of reach for casual
Web authors, it offers a promising WYSIWYG alternative for
professional authors, especially those who create visually rich
Web sites, frequently employ plug-ins, or would appreciate a
built-in JavaScript editor with color syntax checking.
<http://www.golive.com/>
CyberStudio retains the elegant look of its predecessor, GoLive
Pro (see TidBITS-337_), and adds many important features. The
Layout Grid tool enables users to create pixel-specific layouts.
On the HTML side of things, these layouts turn out to be complex,
fixed-size tables, but the grid is optional and sizable, so it's
easy to create pages that don't impose a particular browser window
size. Site management options that I spotted on a quick tour of
the program included viewing site structure and checking for bad
links, plus the ability to export to Apple's Meta-Content Format
(see TidBITS-355_). I'm particularly taken with the fact that
although you can type HTML in the Source view, you can also create
tags using the menus and toolbar, just as you would in Layout
view, a seemingly obvious feature that other WYSIWYG HTML editors
have failed to implement.
According to GoLive Systems, CyberStudio can simultaneously
support multiple language sets. The company has near-term plans to
ship localized international versions, including Japanese and
German. To run the software, you'll need to meet somewhat hefty
system requirements - a PowerPC-based computer running System
7.5.5 or later and at least 8 MB free RAM, with 16 MB recommended.
A thirty-day trial version is available; the download is about 4
MB. Upgrades from golive and golive pro cost $249. GoLive Systems
415/463-1580 -- 415/563-1598 -- <[email protected]> [TJE]
**Jeremy's CSM Updated** -- Jeremy Kezer has released version
1.6.4 of Jeremy's Control Strip Modules, a $10 shareware
collection of tiny, helpful tools. These tools consist of both new
and replacement control strip modules for Apple's Control Strip,
that ubiquitous utility that made its debut on PowerBooks a few
years ago and is now available for desktop computers as well.
Although many of Jeremy's modules are useful only on PowerBooks
(including a revised temperature module that better keeps track of
the computer and battery temperatures, plus a module that predicts
how much battery time remains) version 1.6.4 also offers a revised
AppleTalk module that improves handling of File Sharing, an easy
pop-up menu of Open Transport TCP/IP configurations, and an
improved speaker volume control. [MHA]
<http://members.aol.com/jbkezer/shareware.html>
DigitalThink and Electronic Courses
-----------------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
As most of you probably know, along with TidBITS, I also earn a
living writing books, the best known of which is Internet Starter
Kit for Macintosh. What's ironic for me as an Internet book author
is that the Internet I've helped to popularize has seriously
altered the market for computer books. Books are sold online,
books are advertised online, and some books are even published
online in their entirety.
One of the reactions to these changes has been for people to
rethink the purpose and marketing of books. Many computer books
are essentially tutorials - they purport to teach a set of skills,
ranging from how to achieve certain effects in Photoshop to how to
find things on the Internet. Book-based tutorials go beyond the
computer field though. What are most cookbooks or gardening books,
if not tutorials on how to perform certain tasks? And, might there
be better ways of publishing tutorials, perhaps using the
Internet?
Some companies are taking the kind of tutorial content you'd find
in a book and turning it into an interactive electronic course. Of
these, I'm most familiar with a small San Francisco startup called
DigitalThink, because they've adopted an interesting way of
differentiating their content. They don't have just anyone write a
course - they specifically look for best-selling authors who have
proven that they know the subject matter and how to explain it.
<http://www.digitalthink.com/>
I recently spent a few months creating an interactive electronic
course called "Living with the Internet" for DigitalThink.
Obviously, since the course is delivered over the Internet, it
assumes you're already connected and have a basic grasp of using a
Web browser. However, there's a lot more to using the Internet
than the essentials of a specific program, and that's the focus of
my course. I have high hopes for DigitalThink, because I think
they're on to something genuinely useful and new. If you're
interested in online learning and interactive courses, read on for
details on how it all works.
**Course Makeup** -- I said before that these courses were
interactive, and I think that's an important requirement for them
to succeed. Just putting a set of steps to follow on a Web page
has not only been done, it's pretty much uninteresting. Instead,
DigitalThink has come up with a number of systems for introducing
interactivity into a course. Students are meant to interact not
only with DigitalThink's server, but also with others enrolled in
the class and the instructors.
A DigitalThink course consists of five or six broad modules, each
of which in turn holds between six and twenty lessons. Each lesson
has a goal (DigitalThink's research showed that people liked
having goals). Lessons also contain the lesson text, which is
generally short since people don't like reading much online, and
optional sidebars for related information, exercises, discussions,
chats, and quizzes. These final elements provide the interactivity
needed to give the online course some pizzazz.
**Lesson Text** -- The most challenging part of writing the course
was keeping the amount of text I wrote to a minimum. Tali Bray, my
producer, initially recommended that I aim for about 400 words per
lesson, but when that proved unworkable with the conceptual size
of my topics, we worked on moving lesson portions into sidebars to
include the information in a less imposing setting. Tali's overall
goal was help me to distill the necessary information into its
most fundamental form, since that's what online training has to
deliver, especially in contrast to books.
DigitalThink addresses the issue of limiting online lesson text to
fundamentals in other ways as well, by having required book-based
reading for many of the courses and by encouraging interaction
between students and between the instructor and the students.
**Exercises** -- Another part of writing each lesson involved
coming up with an exercise. Some exercises are as simple as asking
students to visit a couple of Web pages, read their contents, and
think about the implications. Others are more complex (for
instance, requiring students to rate the Internet programs they
currently use so the scores can be compared with overall ratings
from other students.)
I had fun with some of the exercises - there's nothing that says a
course has to be boring. For the lesson that explains
client/server computing, there's an optional exercise that entails
going out to dinner with a friend. And then, when I discuss how
email actually works on the Internet, the exercise involves the
use of small children, assuming you have access to any.
**Quizzes** -- Courses generally need some form of testing.
Students submit answers to some of the exercises, but the main way
that DigitalThink's electronic courses test knowledge is via
quizzes. Most of them are multiple choice, although true/false
questions also pop up from time to time. Once a student submits a
quiz, DigitalThink's server shows which questions were answered
right or wrong, and explains the answers, sometimes providing
additional information in the process. Whenever you're in a
course, you can click the Scores button to see a graph of your
total quiz scores next to everyone else who has taken the class.
**Discussions and Chats** -- Exercises and quizzes force you to
interact with DigitalThink's server, and although that's a good
first step in providing a compelling interactive experience,
there's no substitute for live people. Because of that, most
lessons have a discussion, and each module has at least one live
chat scheduled. The discussions work a bit like Usenet news, with
messages posted one after another. Online chats use the iChat
plug-in.
As the author, I show up for a few hours a month in the course,
participating in the discussions and perhaps an occasional chat,
although I generally avoid online chats because they're hard on my
hands. I seeded each discussion with an initial post, and each
lesson also has questions for students to consider. Along with
everything else, I'm trying to help people think about the
Internet and the issues that surround it.
Whether in the discussion forum or the online chats,
DigitalThink's hope is that encouraging students to interact with
one another and with the instructor will not only make the course
more fun, but will also make it more instructive. Some recent
research has shown that the interactivity involved in online
instruction can make it even more successful than traditional
classroom instruction.
<http://www.csun.edu/sociology/virexp.htm>
**The Overall System** -- DigitalThink's technology for providing
these courses goes well beyond basic HTML. I don't know all the
details, but I do know that they have developed a proprietary
system that tracks all the parts of a course and all the students.
That's how it can grade quizzes instantly and update scores
immediately. Students can also click the Classmates button
whenever they're in a course to see who else is taking it. As a
nice touch, though, DigitalThink gives each student a special
DigitalThink email address that forwards to the student's real
address. That way, students can contact each other, but still
maintain a level of privacy.
The unfortunate side-effect of this mechanism is that it relies on
JavaScript for the course syllabus and discussions, and currently
Microsoft Internet Explorer 3.0 for the Mac doesn't support
JavaScript (although Explorer 3.0.1b1 just added JavaScript
support; see TidBITS-373_). Other technical requirements include
the Shockwave plug-in if you want to listen to my dulcet tones at
various points throughout the course, and the iChat plug-in that's
necessary to participate in chats.
Students' personal information is maintained in their lockers,
which contain information about their courses and any other
information they wish to give out. For instance, my Bio field
reads merely "Carbon-based." After you've enrolled in a course,
you go to your locker every time you revisit the DigitalThink site
to continue with the course.
As I understand it, DigitalThink is hoping to meet the needs of
people and companies who can afford a one- or two-day seminar but
don't have several days to devote to full-time instruction.
Courses are designed to take about 25 hours to complete, and
students can spread that out over time, working as quickly or
slowly as they want, within reason.
**Courses** -- Currently, DigitalThink offers a number of courses
in the three main categories of Internet, Computer Science, and
Multimedia. Some titles include: Object-Oriented Programming with
C++, Home Sweet Home Page, Advanced Perl for the Web (part of the
Perl for Programmers Series), Building Graphical User Interfaces
(part of the Java for Programmers Series), and Hands-On Photoshop.
<http://www.digitalthink.com/catalog/>
DigitalThink has two new sections which should be available by the
end of April, Finance and Lifestyles. As you'd expect, Finance
covers personal finance software, investments, and so on. I'm
looking forward to the Lifestyles section, which will have
subjects that aren't work-related, such as wine-tasting. That
should prove interesting, although quizzes might become
significantly more difficult if you don't spit during the tasting
exercises.
Course fees vary widely, depending on the type of course and its
length. Introductory courses are only $45, but the range goes up
to $275 for the full-length, advanced Computer Science courses.
If you like going to seminars and taking short classes, check out
the DigitalThink Web site and the course offerings, especially
Tali's free course on searching on the Internet. I enjoyed
creating the "Living with the Internet" course more than my major
book projects thanks to the way it helped me rethink the way I
explain the Internet. If that's true of the other DigitalThink
authors too, I can only assume that their courses will have
benefited as well. Who knows, these sort of electronic courses may
be the future of certain types of computer books.
Onward Online Soldier: OAK, the Essential Batch Spelling Checker
----------------------------------------------------------------
by Tonya Engst <[email protected]>
Late last year, I reviewed Casady & Greene's Spell Catcher, a
handy utility that helps with spelling and other writing tasks
(see TidBITS-353_). I was particularly taken with the fact that I
could set up its user dictionary and Interactive Checking glossary
once, and then use them in any program - words I taught the user
dictionary while in my word processor would also be understood
when I spell checked an email message. At the time, I promised to
review other, similar utilities, and the next one up is Online
Army Knife 1.21 (OAK) by JEM Software.
<http://www.casadyg.com/C&G/Products/SpellCatcher/description.html>
<http://arielpub.com/jem.html>
OAK aims to provide spell checking and other services to Internet
users, particularly in Internet-related programs like email
clients or HTML editors that lack adequate spell checking
features. Additionally, in Swiss-Army Knife-style, OAK piles on
additional features: grammar checking, playing a QuickTime movie,
opening GIF, PICT, or JPEG graphics (and optionally converting
them to a variety of formats including EPS and TIFF), opening and
converting among WAV, SND, and AIFF sounds (plus a basic sound
recording feature), encrypting text (encrypted text can be
decrypted by anyone owning OAK or the OAK decrypter), and removing
high-ASCII characters like curly quotes that can be messed up when
sent over the Internet.
I won't deny the potential uses of any of these features, but OAK
put itself on my list of must-have utilities after I experienced
its most important feature - batch spell checking (a feature Adam
suggested in part to JEM Software after he grew tired of linear-
mode spell checkers).
OAK is a control panel and an application, so after installing it,
I put an alias to the OAK application in my Startup Folder. OAK
launches as a small window containing eight buttons. Press a
button, and you'll see a short list of options relating to the
button. You can hide OAK just like any other application, so it's
easy to hide if screen real estate gets tight.
**The Basic Batch Check** -- At a basic level, OAK performs its
spell checking via the Spelling button. Press it, and you may
choose to check the contents of the clipboard or a file. (You can
also spur the spelling checker into action by selecting text in
any program and issuing a configurable keyboard shortcut.) OAK
responds by listing possible errors in the Batch Processing dialog
box. If a mistake occurs more than once, OAK only lists it once.
I've found this list to be a great convenience. To process the
list of possible errors, I first select words I want ignored, and
then I click the Ignore button (the Ignore option can be set to
work until you quit OAK). Second, I select words I want learned
and click the Learn button. Finally, I select the remaining words
and click the Correct in Context button. This button leads to a
more traditional spell checking window, which can be driven
completely from the keyboard. There's also a button for starting a
Grammar Check or checking for doubled words.
To measure speed, I batch-checked a recent TidBITS issue. It took
OAK a hair more than a second to list 24 unknown words out of 4561
total on my Power Mac 7600 (120 MHz PowerPC 604) and almost ten
seconds to complete the same task on my Duo 230 (25 MHz 68030).
According to JEM Software, OAK can check as large a file as you
have memory available.
The batch checking is great, so great that I intend to keep OAK
installed just to use it with Eudora and other instances where I
work with unformatted text. Unfortunately, OAK won't replace Spell
Catcher in my software collection. When OAK pastes text into a
document after a spelling check, styles and formatting tend to
disappear. In my testing, serious loss-of-formatting problems
arose after an OAK spell check in Word 5.1, Nisus 4.1 and 5.0,
WriteNow 3.0, and WordPerfect 3.5. However, OAK and Word 6.0 got
along well for the styles and formats I tested. JEM Software may
add Word Services support to a future OAK version, which might
help avoid this problem.
**The Interactive Zone** -- Beyond basic batch checking, OAK
offers interactive checking features galore, including a real-time
spelling checker that doesn't suffer formatting problems, so you
can use it with most programs. Turn on the Real-Time option and
OAK puts up a tiny Unknowns & Suggestions windoid that floats over
application windows. If you type a word OAK doesn't understand,
OAK (optionally) plays a sound or flashes the menubar. The sound
or flash is your cue to look in the Unknowns & Suggestions
windoid, which contains two lists. The left-hand list shows words
you've typed that OAK considers misspelled. When you click an
alleged error, OAK displays suggestions on the right. If you deal
with the error right away, you can simply tell OAK to skip,
ignore, or learn the word, or you can choose a suggested fix. You
can even click the Glossary button so the next time you make that
mistake, OAK automatically replaces it with the correction. You
can also deal with errors later - OAK stores them in a list in the
windoid. I don't like dealing with errors later because all OAK
can do is paste corrections into your document at the location of
the cursor, not over the mistake.
If you turn on the appropriate options, OAK can instantly
uppercase letters accidently left lowercased and instantly fix
accidental character transpositions (i.e. incorrectly spelling
"Apple" as "Appel").
Although the batch checker ignores email addresses and Web URLs,
the real-time checker flags pieces of them that it doesn't
understand. (I had to teach it the likes of www and com.) This
trait is particularly annoying in Web browsers. Future versions of
OAK should feature an interface for turning OAK off in
applications where it's not wanted.
There's also a glossary for storing commonly used blocks of text,
and it's easy to edit the glossary or add additional entries. For
example, I used the glossary to make it so every time I typed
"ti", OAK expanded my typing to "TidBITS." I also used it for my
standard email signoff, long company or product names, and my
snail mail address. The glossary does not come preconfigured with
entries for common typos and their corrections, but it's easy to
generate a custom set of typos quickly if you pay attention and
use the Glossary button in the Unknowns & Suggestions windoid.
Also, the folks at JEM Software have pointed out that the
transposition fixer eliminates many common typos.
**A Kajillion More Features** -- OAK has additional features that
you might expect, like one that stores keystrokes so you can
rescue data in the event of a crash, and features that you might
not expect, such as one that helps you complete crossword puzzles
and another that enables you to launch programs with a keyboard
shortcut and set up a schedule for your Mac to launch programs on
its own automatically.
There's also a grammar checker that will be mainly of use to
people having trouble with common usage rules. Most grammar
checkers offer a haystack of inappropriate suggestions, making it
hard to focus on the few needles that point to important problems.
OAK's grammar checker flags words in a document that match its
list of 25 commonly confused word pairs (pairs range from simple
ones like "your" and "you're" to the less common "stationery" and
"stationary"). When OAK flags a word, it notes a possible error
and gives information about proper usage for each word in the
pair, often with a tip for remembering the information. You can
keep your word choice or exchange it for the other word in the
pair. You can easily remove pairs from the grammar checker or add
your own.
Additionally, Online Army Knife comes with MemoEdit, a text editor
intended to replace Simple Text for basic text editing needs. On
top of SimpleText's basic functionality, it has a simple Find and
Replace command and a sleek color selector (for coloring text)
where you wave your mouse around on a multi-colored field, and
watch the RGB numbers posted beneath the field update
correspondingly.
**Spell Catcher Comparison** -- I used Spell Catcher for about
three months before switching to OAK for this review. My main
frustration with Spell Catcher was that it has no clue about URLs,
a problem that OAK's batch checker does not share. Another issue
was that Spell Catcher's Interactive Checking performance was
noticeably slow in ClarisWorks 4.04 and NisusWriter 4.1; OAK is a
snappy performer and did not experience slowdowns with those
programs. Further, I found it hard to recommend Spell Catcher for
use on machines slower than my Duo 230. OAK's Real-Time spelling
checker is a little slower to suggest replacements on the Duo, but
overall performance is fine.
Spell Catcher has been tweaked over the years to focus on the
needs of writers and match many different writing styles (and the
latest release, version 1.5.7, includes a few additional tweaks).
It curls straight quotes, eliminates double spaces, and comes with
a glossary that automatically corrects 1,000+ typos. Unlike OAK's
all-or-nothing approach, these features start turned off and you
turn them on as needed on a per-application basis. It comes with a
thesaurus, but not a grammar checker. Spell Catcher's Ghostwriter
feature helpfully organizes saved keystrokes by day and
application. Also, it comes with numerous dictionary options for
different languages and professions; OAK only supports American-
English speaking Internet users. Both programs have useful manuals
that read as though real people wrote them; OAK's is a bit more
casual and personal.
OAK is a young, enthusiastic program with new ideas. Don't try its
batch checker unless you plan to keep OAK installed, because once
you've tried it, there's no going back to the clunky, linear
method of spell checking. Another big difference between OAK and
Spell Catcher is that OAK's glossary accepts far longer entries
than Spell Catcher's somewhat grudging 255 characters. And, of
course, OAK comes with tons of other frills and utilities that add
to its overall value.
According to JEM Software OAK works with any Macintosh running
System 7.1 or later and requires 1 MB of available RAM to run its
core spelling and grammar checking features. A full installation
takes about 4.5 MB of disk space. The suggested retail price is
$128; direct orders placed before 01-Jul-97 cost $69.95. Spell
Catcher/Thunder 7 owners can crossgrade for $49.95 (and the OAK
glossary can import a Spell Catcher/Thunder 7 glossary), and
owners of several other competitors can crossgrade for $59.95. A
seven-day demo is available on JEM's Web site; the download is
sized at about 1 MB.
JEM Software -- 800/335-0935 (orders through Ariel Publishing)
<[email protected]> -- 303/422-4856 (fax)
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.276 | Issue #377 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Apr 29 1997 10:54 | 580 |
|
TidBITS#377/28-Apr-97
=====================
Is Apple getting a bad rap from journalists, or is it just a
conspiracy cooked up by Apple management? This week, Keith
Brindley offers a journalist's view on how Apple contributes to
its own bad press. Also this week, Adam shares some techniques for
enhancing the usability of Web browsers, Apple releases a fix for
disabled Level 2 caches, the Info-Mac archive comes back online,
we ask a favor of folks redistributing TidBITS issues, and we
introduce MacWorks as a new TidBITS sponsor.
Topics:
MailBITS/28-Apr-97
Sex Wax Your Browser
Apple's Bad Press Relations
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-377.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#377_28-Apr-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/> <-- NEW!
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers!
Performa 6220 16MB/1GB/CD/TV/VI14" Monitor, refurbished: $954
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]> <----- NEW!
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]> <----------------- NEW!
TidBITS Special - free shipping on Apple upgrade cards from $79
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/specials/tidbits.html>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/28-Apr-97
------------------
**MacWorks Sponsoring TidBITS** -- We'd like to welcome our new
sponsor, MacWorks. Self-billed as "Macintosh enthusiasts with a
great sense of humor," MacWorks has a store in Lenexa, Kansas, and
also sells products (primarily hardware) to Macintosh users near
and far. We've been satisfied MacWorks customers on several
occasions, and we have a good deal of experience with them because
they essentially acted as an anchor for the DealBITS mailing list,
which we ran in 1995 and 1996. We found them an all-around good
company to work with: DealBITS readers liked them, they turned in
well-written copy on time, and they paid their bills promptly.
It's a long way to Kansas for most of you, but anyone with a
browser can visit them virtually on the Web. If you do stop by
their Web site, check out "Hey, Stuff This!" a regularly updated
"MacBiased" cartoon drawn by Pete Steinfeld, a MacWorks staff
member. [TJE]
<http://www.macworks.com/>
**Apple's Level 2 Cache Fix** -- Last week, Apple released the
54xx/64xx L2 Cache Reset extension, fixing a bug that disabled the
Level 2 processor cache in machines using Apple's "Alchemy"
motherboard design. This includes Power Macintosh or Performa
6360, 5400-series, and 6400-series computers, Power Computing's
PowerBase series, and UMAX C500 and C600 models. In case you're
wondering, Level 2 cache is a bit of high-speed memory - usually
256K to 1 MB - that lives near the PowerPC processor. The CPU uses
it to cache instructions and data for quick retrieval rather than
returning to the (comparatively slow) RAM and disk systems to get
the same information over and over again.
You need this update if you use one of the above machines _and_
you're running Mac OS 7.6.1, or System 7.5.3 and the 54xx/64xx
Update 1.1 extension. The update re-enables Level 2 caches on the
systems, producing speed gains of as much as 30 percent in some
circumstances. Although this patch is a tiny disk image file
(11K), you'll need Apple's DiskCopy 6.1 (about 500K) to mount the
image and drag the extension to your System folder. [JLC]
<ftp://ftp.info.apple.com/Apple_Support_Area/Apple_SW_Updates/US/
Macintosh/System/Mac_OS_7.6.1_Update/54xx-64xx_L2_Cache_Reset.img.hqx>
<ftp://ftp.info.apple.com/Apple_Support_Area/Apple_SW_Updates/US/
Macintosh/Utilities/Disk_Copy_6.1.2.sea.hqx>
**Info-Mac Back Online** -- After a longer-than-expected hiatus,
the Info-Mac archive is up and running at its new home. Unlike the
old sumex-aim archive, the new Info-Mac location is not available
for anonymous FTP; instead, Info-Mac users need to access the
archive using one of the dozens of mirror sites around the world
(including the Info-Mac HyperArchive at MIT, AOL's Info-Mac
mirror, the selective mirror of the Info-Mac comm directory
maintained on TidBITS' FTP site, among many others).
<http://hyperarchive.lcs.mit.edu/HyperArchive.html>
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/select/>
The Info-Mac Digest has resumed mailing and posts to the
<comp.sys.mac.digest> newsgroup, and the Info-Mac moderators have
worked their way through most of the backlog of new file
submissions. If you need information about the Info-Mac archive or
mailing list, check out their Web site (most of which has been
updated to reflect Info-Mac's new home). Special thanks go to the
assiduous efforts of all-volunteer Info-Mac moderators for making
this substantial transition as painless as possible. [GD]
<http://www.pht.com/info-mac/>
**Cyberdog 2.0** -- Apple recently released version 2.0 of
Cyberdog, its OpenDoc-based set of Internet tools. This is the
version that's expected to ship with Mac OS 8 this July, and it
features improved HTML support and performance (especially with
Web pages and email handling), the ability to handle multiple
email accounts, and Cyberdog DocBuilder for making custom Internet
front-ends. Cyberdog 2.0 continues to offer OpenDoc and Finder
integration, support for Web browser plug-ins and Apple's
Macintosh Runtime for Java, plus strong (and often overlooked)
AppleTalk network support. Cyberdog 2.0 requires a 68030 processor
or better, System 7.5.3 or higher, a minimum of 8 MB of RAM, and
the recently-released OpenDoc 1.2. [GD]
<http://cyberdog.apple.com/>
<http://opendoc.apple.com/>
**Do You Re-distribute TidBITS?** Each week, a number of people
receive TidBITS issues that are redistributed via private mailing
lists or online forums, rather than via direct email
subscriptions. Many of these services exist within companies, user
groups, and other organizations where a single, central address
for receiving TidBITS issues makes a lot of sense. This sort of
thing is fine with us, but it can cause problems when mail errors
are returned to us from addresses that aren't directly subscribed
to TidBITS. In those cases, we have little choice but to ferret
out and unsubscribe the address of the entire mailing list in
order to make the mail errors stop, and that can inconvenience a
lot of people. Unfortunately, as the TidBITS list grows, that's
happening more and more often.
So, if you're _in_charge_ of a mailing list, online forum, or
other service that redistributes TidBITS each week, please contact
Geoff Duncan <[email protected]> with the following information:
* The email address of the redistribution service that's
subscribed to TidBITS
* The name and email address of the person to contact if there are
problems with the redistribution service
* The approximate number of people who use the service or receive
messages from it
This information will be held in the strictest confidence (as is
the entire TidBITS subscription list!); the idea is to let us
gracefully handle any problems that might arise without
interrupting anyone's access to TidBITS. Thanks! [GD]
Sex Wax Your Browser
--------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
Like many of you, I spend a lot of time in my Web browser each
day. In my case, I'm researching topics for TidBITS, following
URLs sent to me in email, or perhaps working on a book project.
I've been known to fill up Internet Explorer's 500-site default
history file in a few days (it's now set to 2,000). In short, I
stress Web browsers. I want them to be as fast and fluid as
possible, within the constraints of my 56 Kbps dedicated Internet
connection. Actually, I'd like them to read my mind, but that
could get kind of creepy given the nature of the main Web browser
companies. Over time, I've developed some ways of working that
make using a Web browser easier and faster - perhaps some of them
will be of use to you as well.
**Shortcuts 'R' Us** -- I'm on a mission to tell people about a
neat little shortcut in the latest versions of both Netscape
Navigator and Microsoft Internet Explorer. Most company Web sites
have the domain name www.company.com, where "company" is the name
of the company. In both of the main Web browsers, if you type just
the name of the company in either the Address/Location field or
the Open Location dialog box, the Web browser will guess at
"www.company.com" for you. (And don't forget that you don't ever
have to type in "http://" to go to a Web site.) Since I spend a
lot of time hitting sites for companies like Apple, Microsoft,
Netscape, Claris, Adobe, Symantec, and so on, I've found this to
be a tremendous time-saver over trying to edit the existing URL
showing in the Address/Location field or typing the full domain
name. For some reason, it even feels faster to me than creating a
bookmark. Netscape Navigator currently takes this feature one step
further than Internet Explorer: using Navigator, you can use just
a company name along with the remainder of a URL path, so just
typing "tidbits/tb-issues" in Navigator's Location field is
equivalent to:
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/>
**He Who Dies with the Most Buttons Wins** -- The left button on
my venerable Kensington TurboMouse 4.0 stopped working recently,
and I took the opportunity to buy a new TurboMouse 5.0, which has,
count 'em, four buttons. With the associated MouseWorks software,
you can define those buttons to do almost anything in any program.
The programs I've concentrated on so far are my Web browsers,
since I find that I tend to do the same things in almost all Web
pages. I click the Back button a lot, and I scroll up and down in
pages that don't fit on screen. So, I've defined the top two
buttons to Scroll Previous and Scroll Next, and the lower-right
button to Back (it actually types the Command-[ keystroke). I
can't tell you how much smoother browsing the Web feels when you
have single-button access to those functions. I've always liked
Kensington's input devices - if you spend a lot of time in a Web
browser, that may be enough of an excuse for you to think about
getting a multiple button mouse or trackball.
<http://www.kensington.com/>
**ShrinkWrap the Web** -- One technique I've started using
recently to improve the speed of my Web browsers (this works for
both Netscape Navigator and Microsoft Internet Explorer) relies on
Aladdin's ShrinkWrap 2.1, written by Chad Magendanz (watch for
version 3.0 soon, with some neat new features). Web browsers all
use cache folders to store Web pages you've visited and display
them again quickly if you revisit the site. Reading files from the
hard disk, though faster than bringing them in over the Internet,
isn't as fast as many of us would like. What if you could have the
Web browser store the pages on a RAM disk instead? That would be
significantly faster and would have the added advantage of keeping
all those cache files off your hard disk, where they're just
clutter. Even better, since off-loading the cache files to a RAM
disk reduces the number of writes to your hard disk, disk
corruption is less likely to occur if you crash while a cache file
is being written, for instance.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/disk/shrink-wrap-21.hqx>
I first tried using the RAM disk capabilities available from the
Memory control panel, but the standard RAM disk didn't work well.
It loses its contents if you shut down the Mac, and it can also
forget its name, which screws everything up. So, and I don't know
who first suggested trying this, I turned to ShrinkWrap, which can
mount a disk image in RAM, essentially creating a persistent RAM
disk.
Although not difficult, the process isn't inherently obvious.
Launch ShrinkWrap and open the Preferences dialog. Make sure "Keep
mounted images in RAM" and "Mount images unlocked by default" are
checked, since you want to take advantage of the speed of RAM and
the Web browser must be able to write to the image. Make sure that
the "Save disk image files as" pop-up menus are set to "ShrinkWrap
Image File" (or else ShrinkWrap won't mount them automatically).
Then, from the Image menu, choose New Image, name the disk image,
click the Other button, and enter the size you want.
If you've got enough RAM, I recommend about 5 MB. The Web browsers
won't use all that space (since they know they shouldn't fill up
the hard disk). There's not much advantage to using a larger cache
folder setting unless you frequently visit Web sites that use
Shockwave Director heavily. You want your Web browser to check
pages once per session, because otherwise you'll miss changes, so
it's unlikely that storing any more than a few megabytes of cache
files will help performance.
When you click the OK button, ShrinkWrap creates an image file (on
the desktop by default). If you double-click that image file,
ShrinkWrap mounts it as a volume. Next, you must set your Web
browser to use the ShrinkWrap volume for cache files.
In Microsoft Internet Explorer, open the Preferences dialog from
the Edit menu, and click the Advanced tab. Make sure the Cache
settings are set to a maximum of 5 MB, and click the Change button
to locate your newly created ShrinkWrap volume. You may wish to
click the Empty button to delete all the previously cached files
before changing over to the ShrinkWrap volume, just to recover
some space.
In Netscape Navigator, from the Options menu choose Network
Preferences. Click the Cache tab, set the Cache Size to 5 MB or
so, and click the Browse button to locate your new ShrinkWrap
volume. Again, you may wish to click the Clear Disk Cache Now
button before switching to recover the space that's being used.
Once you've got your Web browser set to use the ShrinkWrap volume,
you need to make sure that it will be present whenever you launch
your Web browser. Otherwise, the Web browser will reset itself to
use some other folder. (Internet Explorer is a bit messy about
this, placing the Explorer Cache folder in a variety of places.
Netscape Navigator always seems to go back to the Cache folder in
the boot volume's Netscape folder, located in the Preferences
folder.) So, move the ShrinkWrap disk image file (not the mounted
volume!) to your Startup Items folder so that ShrinkWrap mounts it
on every restart.
One slight problem that I had is that you can't put an alias to a
Web browser in your Startup Items folder because it will launch
before ShrinkWrap has finished mounting the volume. You might be
able to get around this with creative naming to force certain load
orders, depending on your specific situation, but another solution
could be to use Exta Software's $8 shareware Delayed Startup Items
utility, which waits until your Mac is idle for a few moments and
then launches items in a Delayed Startup Items folder.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/cfg/delayed-startup-items.hqx>
If you ever launch your Web browser when the ShrinkWrap volume
isn't mounted (say, if you boot without extensions and then drop
an HTML file on your Web browser to view it), be aware that the
Web browser may reset its cache folder to another volume. It's
worth checking every now and then to make sure this hasn't
happened accidentally.
Once you do this, you can enjoy the added speed of reading cached
Web pages from a RAM disk and the peace of mind of knowing that
you're keeping hundreds of unnecessary files off your hard disk.
Apple's Bad Press Relations
---------------------------
by Keith Brindley <[email protected]>
When I read Ian Gregson's piece about his experiences with
Macintosh retail sales (see TidBITS-367_), I was amazed at how
much it mirrors the situation here in the U.K. I also anticipated
Apple would begin complaining about the attitudes of retail stores
rather than changing the way Macs are sold through these outlets.
After all, Apple's usual line of defence in such matters is to
attack the attacker. I know about this stance - I'm a journalist
and I've suffered the slings and arrows of Apple's misfortune (not
personally, but as part of my profession). To mix metaphors, Apple
has long blamed the messenger for its own woes. Apple's main
stance is to blame bad press as the reason why sales are low at
Christmas, or why the quarter's loss is greater than expected
(sound familiar?).
But blaming the press is only half of the story, and there is
another half. What about us journalists; what do we feel? We're a
pretty apathetic bunch, after all (and, as you'll see, that's an
inherent part of the problem), slothful in the extreme, drunkards
in the main, quick to go with the mainstream, slow to try
something new and potentially better, only looking for a free
lunch and the pay cheque at the end of the month. At least that's
the common perception - never mind that it's largely incorrect.
In journalism, time is the most important factor, as I hope to
prove; yet, Apple doesn't seem to appreciate that fact. Even when
we try to tell Apple about the problem, do we get the message
through? Of course not. Have you ever tried sending email to
Apple's management? Did you receive a response? I didn't think so.
**A Journalist's Point of View** -- Ian Gregson's piece made me
think it might be a good idea to relate a journalist's
perspective. Although this is from a U.K. hack's position, what
I've heard from the other side of the pond seems similar. Perhaps
someone in Apple has an ear on the pulse of the Internet
(metaphors exist to be mixed - they grab the reader's attention
more than boldly split infinitives!) and perhaps something good
will become of this article. (Come to think of it, maybe the
person reading this article and checking the pulse will be Doctor
Amelio himself... Nah, it'll never happen.)
Let's begin with four facts:
* Good editorial coverage can be the most effective advertising a
product can have - it's certainly the most cost effective.
* Bad editorial coverage can rarely be countered by any amount of
advertising.
* If a product is good (well, as good as a Mac, anyway) good
editorial coverage is cheap - far cheaper than advertising.
* Time is of the essence.
To understand the fourth fact, we need a little background on the
editorial process. As a journalist, it's important that I receive
the information I need quickly. If I'm commissioned by an editor
to write a review or a feature, in most cases the editor wants it
within a couple of days. Even when a feature is planned in
advance, I generally have only a week or two for research. This is
the case throughout U.K. journalism, irrespective of media
(magazine, newspaper, broadcast) and I suspect it is the same in
the U.S. Journalists need information fast. Put another way, fact
four is that journalists can't wait beyond the deadline for the
information to come to them at Apple's convenience.
It's relatively easy for companies like Apple to make written or
verbal information available. The various electronic means (email,
HTML, PDF, even fax and telephone) can all help to ensure a
journalist gets necessary information rapidly. Over the last few
months, it has been nice to see Apple start to get its act
together in providing factual information. Apple's Web sites are
increasingly becoming a joy to use as the information and links
they hold become more and more coordinated. When I need rapid
access to information, I frequently turn to them as one of the
first sources. Apple's improving in this respect, and I find
little to criticise.
When a journalist writes about a particular product, on the other
hand, that product must be available for a first-hand evaluation.
I cannot review a product if I don't have it. Here is where Apple
lacks a coordinated and workable response to journalists.
**Some Examples** -- To back this up I'm going to quote some real,
live examples that I've had to contend with. These might be U.K.-
specific, but vibes I get from reading U.S.-based magazines make
me think the problem is endemic within Apple and all its
subsidiaries.
First, how do other companies handle journalists? Take Microsoft
in the U.K. They have a press agency (Text 100), which has a
dedicated Microsoft helpline for journalists (no messing around
with a switchboard, or holding to canned Muzak). When a journalist
requires a product for review, Text 100 arranges for the product's
immediate courier delivery - no questions. The product is an NFR
(not for resale), which becomes the journalist's personal copy.
This is a slick operation in the UK. Microsoft knows the value of
good editorial copy. Other successful companies (software and
hardware - Adobe, Macromedia, and Visioneer to name a few) have
similar PR setups. For pity's sake, even Quark has its act
together with press relations.
How does Apple U.K. handle journalists? Its U.K. press agency
takes your call, then must get the product from Apple. Most times,
Apple only allocates two or three product items for use by the PR
agency on a loan-only basis, so the product must be returned after
the review. Typically, loaned items are in popular demand by
journalists, and it may be weeks before everyone has a turn at
borrowing them.
My crowning example of this problem occurred when I wrote a series
of articles about various online and Internet services a year or
so ago. I intended to look at Apple's now-defunct eWorld as part
of this series, but was told by the PR agency that only two
accounts were allocated to U.K. journalists (only two for the
whole of the U.K.?), but I could have an account for a couple of
weeks if I could wait for six weeks before receiving it as I was
fourth in the queue. As I was in the fortunate (and unusual)
position of writing a multi-part series in a monthly magazine, I
figured I'd fit in eWorld somewhere down the line and agreed. If
I'd been writing a single feature (the norm for other journalists)
I simply couldn't have included eWorld. The account duly arrived
after six weeks and I put it aside until I was to write that part
of the series. Later, I tried to log on and was rejected because
I'd overrun the two weeks by a day. Like most of the world's
journalists who suffered the same lack of PR, I didn't write about
eWorld at all, so undoubtedly I unwittingly became part of
eWorld's demise.
How does Microsoft ensure journalists remain Microsoft-friendly in
the same circumstances? Every journalist who wants can have a free
and permanent connection to the Microsoft Network. Other online
services in the U.K. (AOL and CompuServe) do the same, as do most
ISPs. In a nutshell, maybe that's why Apple pulled the plug on
eWorld! Not because it wasn't a good service (I can't comment - I
never got access, remember), but because it never got decent press
coverage due to Apple's complacency.
This isn't an isolated instance in my experience. I went through
the same procedure to review the MessagePad 130, and found I could
borrow one for only a week, some four weeks on down the line.
Everyone knows (except Apple, presumably) that you must use a
Newton for at least a month for it and you to become au fait with
each other. A journalist playing with a MessagePad for a week
can't be expected to write about it with serious conviction.
To introduce a new technology like Newton, Apple should have given
MessagePads to every high-tech journalist in the world, as a loss
leader. I don't think it would be unfair to say the technology
would have been more widely adopted by now if that had happened.
As it is, the much inferior Windows CE (which any interested
journalist need only call the local Microsoft PR agency to try)
has a good chance to succeed where the Newton probably won't. It's
no good merely telling people how good your new technology is, you
must prove it.
In a nutshell, there are maybe 400 journalists in the U.K. who
influence the total computer purchasing powers of Joe Public here.
To give them all a MessagePad 2000 and a 6500/300 might seem a lot
to write off, but, for heaven's sake, we're talking of potential
sales in the millions. Nobody, and I mean nobody, buys a computer
without reading any of the multitude of magazines on the
newsstands. As few of the non-Mac-specific magazines mention Apple
at all, Joe Public will obviously think of the Mac as not worthy
of consideration. Q.E.D.
This malaise is not restricted to the Apple mother company itself.
A few months ago I was commissioned to write a roundup of email
software for Internet Today magazine. Naturally, I wanted to
include Claris Emailer, but neither the editor of the magazine nor
myself could acquire a shrink-wrapped copy in time for the
deadline (a fairly typical two weeks). I had to download a 30-day
demo off the Claris Web site to see the product. To say this was
unsatisfactory is merely being polite. [Perhaps the situation is
improving - TidBITS received a shrink-wrapped copy of Claris
Emailer 2.0 the day before it officially shipped, and two more
inexplicably arrived a week later.-Adam]
**It's Not About Freebies** -- I realise many readers will think
I'm being self-centered in my argument that myself and other
journalists should receive freebies. That's crap! Freebies are a
fact of life in journalism - you should see my attic: it's stuffed
full of products I've reviewed or featured and, apart from writing
about them and being paid for that, I receive no financial gain
from any of them. Companies who issue freebies as part of the
marketing process reap the rewards in editorial coverage. If the
products being freebied are good, then the editorial coverage will
be good. Journalism is a profession, and journalists are
professionals, but they don't have the time to chase companies
like Apple for product. If product isn't available journalists
can't see it and discover its value. Worse, they might (and do)
create negative editorial coverage for lack of product. You only
have to understand how journalism ticks to see where Apple is
going wrong.
I'm a Mac user, I love the Mac, I love just about every product
Apple produces. But I'm frustrated. I want everybody else to be a
Mac user. I'm prepared to put up with problems like those I've
given as examples because of my love.
On the other hand, journalists who don't share my love for the Mac
don't need to and frankly won't put up with these problems - hence
the bad press Apple appears to suffer constantly. In reality, much
of it is not bad press, it's merely misinformed press. The problem
is not just one of making sure journalists have the information
they need instantly. It is a problem of making sure they have
product instantly, too. Without product, there is no incentive to
look for the information in the first place, so a chicken-and-egg
situation evolves. Until Apple meets the problem head-on and
starts helping journalists instead of blaming them, bad press will
not change.
Please Gil and company, change it.
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.277 | Issue #378 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue May 06 1997 13:57 | 602 |
|
TidBITS#378/05-May-97
=====================
Perhaps it was our use of the word "wax" in a headline. Last
week's "Sex Wax Your Browser" article prompted several reader
suggestions, so this week we're baring all to share more
techniques for making Web browsing easier. We've also got a
detailed summary of why no one walked away with 100,000 Swedish
kronors in the Crack A Mac challenge, information on the rapidly
multiplying Mac OS clone market, and news of two applications that
don't mind pushing you around.
Topics:
MailBITS/05-May-97
Crowds of Clones
Even Sexier Wax for Your Browser
The Crack A Mac Story
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-378.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#378_05-May-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS#378! <--------- NEW!
Performa 6400 32MB/1.6GB/256kL2/28.8/15" monitor, refurb: $1529
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]>
TidBITS Special - free shipping on Apple upgrade cards from $79
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/specials/tidbits.html>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/05-May-97
------------------
**Feeling Pushy?** PointCast, Inc. and Marimba, Inc. this week
released new Mac versions of their much-hyped "push technology"
receivers. PointCast's Network (PowerPC only) has been pushed up
to version 1.0.1, offering six additional channels including the
Wall Street Journal, TechWeb, and the Chicago Tribune. The update
also includes a Control Strip module for controlling the Network
application from the desktop. Users of version 1.0 should receive
the update automatically the next time they connect, and don't
need to download the file (3.6 MB for an easy install, 2.6 MB for
the smaller installation). Version 1.0 of Marimba's Castanet Tuner
(also PowerPC only) allows access to Marimba channels, and is
based on Java; the 2.9 MB download includes version 1.0.2 of
Apple's Mac OS Runtime for Java, which it requires to run. [JLC]
<http://www.pointcast.com/download/dwnmac.html>
<ftp://ftp.marimba.com/pub/release/mac/tuner.hqx>
**TCP/IP CC Apology** -- My apology to Tim Kelly and Jeremy Kezer
for carelessly including a description of Tim's TCP/IP CC control
strip module when talking about the Jeremy's Control Strip Modules
package in TidBITS-376_. The "buckware" tool (it costs $1) is not
part of Jeremy's collection of control strip modules; it's one of
many neat programs available at the official Tim Kelly software
page. [MHA]
<http://www.madison-web.com/tkelly/>
Crowds of Clones
----------------
by Jeff Carlson <[email protected]>
For years, one of the main laments about the Macintosh was Apple's
failure early on to license the Macintosh and/or Mac OS to outside
vendors. Now, Mac OS clone manufacturers like Power Computing and
Motorola are prompting users to choose not only which model to
buy, but from which vendor. Here at TidBITS, we've often found it
difficult enough to keep up with Apple's products (something
exacerbated by the now-defunct Performa line), let alone sets of
Macintosh compatibles from other manufacturers both in the United
States and throughout the world. As a result we have a tendency
not to talk about clone models or clone makers with great
consistency, which doesn't do justice to the now rapidly-
developing field of Macintosh compatible hardware. With that in
mind, here's a brief rundown of some of the major and minor
players in the Mac clone market. For more information on Mac OS
clones, check out David Engstrom's The Mac and Mac Clone
Performance Comparison Page.
<http://ng.netgate.net/~engstrom/cc.html>
**Power Computing** -- Now approaching "grandfather" status in the
field, Power pioneered the Mac OS clone market and gave users
reason to believe non-Apple machines could be a viable
alternative. Power's line of computers fill both the low- and
high-end markets: a 180 MHz 603e processor-based system starts at
$1,199 (including decent RAM, hard drive, video, and expandability
options), while their top of the line PowerTower Pro models hover
between $2,700 and $3,700.
<http://www.powercc.com/>
**UMAX** -- Umax's SuperMac line, originally inherited from former
clone manufacturer Radius, also appeals to a broad range of users,
starting with the inexpensive C Series and topping off with the S
Series. UMAX has moved ahead forcefully with its product lines:
all SuperMac machines are based on an Advanced Scalable Processor
Design (ASPD), allowing for easy processor upgrades (rather than
replacing the entire motherboard); the S900 machines also come
with the ability to run as dual-processor machines.
<http://www.supermac.com/>
**DayStar Digital** -- Unlike many clone vendors who are
positioning their systems to appeal to all users, DayStar Digital
continues to concentrate on the heavy-horsepower crowd with their
multi-processor Genesis MP workstations. The low end of these "big
iron" machines offers two PowerPC 604e processors running at 200
MHz, six drive bays, six PCI slots, eight DIMM slots (allowing
over 1 GB of RAM), and more, starting at $5,000. DayStar wants to
dominate high-end graphics, video, and media production markets,
and the few people I know who've used their machines don't plan to
ever take their work back to single-processor Macs.
<http://www.daystar.com/>
**Motorola** -- It was only a matter of time before Motorola, the
manufacturer of Macintosh processors since the 68000, started
building its own boxes. The StarMax line starts with a 200 MHz
603e and the usual complement of entry-level components (16 MB
RAM, 1.2 GB hard drive, CD-ROM), and ramps up to the StarMax
5000/300 mini tower, featuring a 300 MHz 603e (not 604e, which is
available at 200MHz in the StarMax 4000/200) with 32MB of RAM,
Ethernet, internal Zip drive, and 4.3 GB hard drive. Like IBM,
Motorola may sublicense Mac-compatible systems to other
manufacturers (such as APS) without explicit permission from
Apple, and Motorola also offers a five-year limited warranty with
its machines.
<http://www.mot.com/GSS/MCG/starmax/products.html>
**APS** -- APS hard drives, cables, and accessories have been a
TidBITS standard for years, so it came as no surprise when APS
announced its M*Power line of Macintosh clones, based on CPU
designs from Motorola. Starting with the M*Power 603e180 ($1,199)
and maxing out with the M*Power 604e200 ($2,399 for the best
configuration), APS brings a wide range of configuration options
plus their excellent support and quality hardware to the Mac OS
clone arena (despite a lack of original machine names).
<http://www.apstech.com/>
**Computer Warehouse** -- The machines from this United Kingdom-
based vendor are geared toward speed and power in multimedia
authoring. Based on Motorola's Tanzania motherboard designs, all
of their lines - New York, Manhattan, and Hollywood - run from 200
MHz 604e processors and start with 64 MB of RAM, priced between
1,500 and 2,000 British pounds, excluding VAT. Computer
Warehouse's machines are being manufactured in West London and
aimed at the European market.
<http://www.computerwarehouse.co.uk/>
**Akia** -- Akia demonstrated their array of MicroBook Power
machines at Macworld Tokyo this year. The name suggests PowerBook
clones, but Akia's machines come in tower and desktop models based
on 604e and 603e processors and logic boards sublicensed from IBM,
all with a minimum of 80 MB RAM and 4 MB of video RAM. Also
interesting are the monitors that can be purchased for these
systems: all of Akia's screens are flat-panel displays. To buy
them, however, you'll have to travel to Japan.
<http://www.akia.com/mac/amac.htm>
**Vertegri Research** -- Canada-based Vertegri made news recently
by announcing a Mac OS portable not based on Apple's PowerBook
specifications (which aren't currently licensable). The
imediaEngine features a 604e processor running at either 200 MHz
or 240 MHz, built-in CD-ROM, and optional internal Zip and Jaz
drives. What it lacks, however, is a battery. Vertegri also offers
the Quicktower 200e, a 200 MHz 604e system.
<http://www.vertegri.com/>
**Vision Power** -- A newcomer to the clone market, Vision Power
plans to offer two lines of machines: the 603e-based PowerExpress
and 604e-based PowerMax, both available in desktop and tower
models and targeted at North American customers, although the
company has reportedly been selling Mac clones in Asia since late
1996. According to reports, high-end models will offer a second
processor slot for multi-processing applications (similar to
UMAX's S900 models), but few other details are available. The
company can be reached via email at <[email protected]>.
Even Sexier Wax for Your Browser
--------------------------------
by Geoff Duncan <[email protected]>
Maybe it was the steamy title, but Adam's article "Sex Wax Your
Browser" in TidBITS-377_ (which contained a few tips for
efficiently using Web browsers) generated a surprisingly large
email response from TidBITS readers. Many people wrote in with
additional thoughts or variations on Adam's suggestions - I
thought I'd share a few of those and throw in some thoughts of my
own.
**Shortcuts, Intranets, & Open Transport** -- In his article, Adam
wrote that the latest versions of Netscape Navigator and Microsoft
Internet Explorer both enable you to access a Web site with a
domain name in the form of "www.company.com" by typing just the
word "company" in the browser's Address or Location field. Thus,
entering "tidbits" in the field would take you to:
<http://www.tidbits.com/>
Although what Adam describes is typical for many dial-up and
dedicated Internet users, readers wrote in to note some
variations. Typing "tidbits" in a browser's Address/Location field
actually first tries to set up a connection with a machine called
"tidbits" within your current domain (such as
"tidbits.company.com"). If you're using a stand-alone Mac, this
isn't a problem: the Web browser fails to find that machine, then
tries "www.tidbits.com." However, if you're on a corporate or
organizational intranet, you might see different behavior. For
instance, if there really is a machine called "tidbits" within
your intranet, your browser will connect to it rather than
TidBITS' Web site. Also, if your intranet is large (or slow),
merely searching the network for a local machine can take quite a
bit of time. A few readers reported their browsers frequently time
out before they're done looking for a machine on their corporate
intranets, so they always use bookmarks (or type in longer forms
of a site's domain name) to access external Internet sites.
If you're using Open Transport, you can change how Internet
applications look for sites. At the lower right of the TCP/IP
control panel, you'll see a field labeled Search domains (or
Additional Search domains, if the control panel is in Advanced
mode - you can select User Mode from the Edit menu to change
modes). In this field, you can enter other Internet domains you'd
like your Mac to treat as if they were on your local network.
For example, I access the Internet from the domain quibble.com.
However, I've also entered tidbits.com as an additional search
domain, so I don't have to type it out to access any of TidBITS
Internet servers. I can access TidBITS' Web site by typing "king"
in the Address/Location field, since the machine www.tidbits.com
also goes by the name king.tidbits.com. This technique works so
long as none of TidBITS' machines have the same names as machines
within my quibble.com domain - if I type "www" my browser will
preferentially connect to my (currently unexciting) Web server at
www.quibble.com.
Open Transport's additional search domains can be confusing; for
instance, Internet sites you access using these additional search
domain appear as if they're on your local network, so the full URL
in the example above appears as "http://king/", which isn't what
you'd want to cut and paste into an email message to someone on a
non-local network. Additional search domains can also be slow if
you add large domains (like apple.com) or slow domains. However,
once you get used to them, many people find additional domains
helpful, and they work with any Internet application - including
Anarchie, Fetch, and Cyberdog - not just the major Web browsers.
**ramBunctious** -- The bulk of Adam's article discussed how to
set up a custom ShrinkWrap volume to hold your browsers' disk
caches in RAM for better performance. Several TidBITS readers
wrote in to recommend ramBunctious - a $12 shareware RAM disk
program from Elden Wood and Bob Clark - for the same purpose. As
an application, ramBunctious seems to do a decent job with pure
RAM disks, offering write-throughs to your hard disk to preserve
your data, and an optional folder for items that are opened
whenever you mount a RAM disk on your desktop. Although I can't
really recommend ramBunctious over the ever-versatile ShrinkWrap -
RAM disks can only be used with the ramBunctious application
running (which takes another 380K of RAM), it can't mount or
manipulate standard disk image files, it isn't scriptable, it has
a few quirks, and ShrinkWrap is still free for non-commercial use
- ramBunctious was stable in my brief testing, and a few TidBITS
readers preferred its interface to ShrinkWrap's somewhat over-
burdened preferences dialog. If you frequently need RAM disks and
never use disk image files, ramBunctious might be worth a look.
<http://www.kagi.com/authors/rambunctious/>
**Cyberdog** -- Adam's discussion of using ShrinkWrap for browser
caching only applied to Microsoft Internet Explorer and Netscape
Navigator. Greg Scarich <[email protected]> wrote in with a tip on
how to use the same technique with Cyberdog:
"Thanks for the detailed discussion of setting up the persistent
ShrinkWrap RAM cache. I took it one step further and got it
working for Cyberdog. Cyberdog doesn't let you select the location
for its cache, so I followed your instructions, then manually
created a folder named Cyberdog Cache on the ShrinkWrap disk, then
put an alias of that folder in the Cyberdog Preferences folder
[which is inside the System's Preferences folder -Geoff],
replacing the default folder of the same name."
I found Greg's technique works fine with Cyberdog 2.0, although
presumably it would work with earlier versions too.
<http://cyberdog.apple.com/>
**ShrinkWrap & AppleScript** -- Finally, many TidBITS readers
wrote to say they're taking advantage of ShrinkWrap's
scriptability and using a script to mount a ShrinkWrap image for
disk cache and then launch their favorite Web browser once the
disk is mounted. Suzanne Courteau <[email protected]>
writes:
"This has come up several times in Macworld and other
publications. In April we ran a Quick Tip ("Efficient Browser
Cache") that suggested writing an AppleScript program to mount
your ShrinkWrap RAM disk not at startup but when you're ready to
go online - though I suspect after reading TidBITS-377_, for you
that _is_ right after startup!"
<http://www.macworld.com/pages/april.97/Column.3377.html>
Suzanne's right: Adam, Tonya, and I have dedicated Internet
connections so we tend to want our disk caches ready from the
moment we start up. However, many users with dial-up access to the
Internet may not want to constantly set aside a few megabytes of
RAM as a browser cache. The AppleScript outlined in the Macworld
tip shows how to mount your ShrinkWrap image in RAM and launch
Netscape Navigator from a single, double-clickable icon in the
Finder; the same principles can be applied to UserLand Frontier,
OneClick, and other programs. I've also written a slightly more
elaborate AppleScript that isn't hard-coded to a particular
ShrinkWrap image file or Web browser; with a little ambition, it
could be modified to work with ramBunctious RAM disks.
<http://www.quibble.com/geoff/hacks/as.html>
We hope you find these tips from other TidBITS readers useful -
happy Web browsing!
The Crack A Mac Story
---------------------
by Joakim Jardenberg and Christine Pamp <[email protected]>
[Back in TidBITS-375_, we noted the success of the "Crack A Mac"
challenge held in Sweden for two months last February to April.
The contest offered prize money - eventually more than $13,000
U.S. - to anybody who could alter the contents of a Web page
served by a standard Macintosh-based Web server. Here's the story
of the contest and the server setup, plus some of the break-in
attempts and hoaxes the contest team encountered. -Geoff]
**What We Did and Why** -- To prepare for the Crack A Mac contest,
we simply unpacked a standard Power Macintosh 8500/150 from its
box. Then we installed WebSTAR 2.0 (the popular Macintosh Web
server from StarNine), upgraded to Open Transport 1.1.2, connected
the machine to the Internet, and put some Web pages on it. We
didn't do anything special with the server - it wasn't behind a
firewall, and we didn't make any other security arrangements. The
entire setup took less than 30 minutes.
We publicized the challenge and Hacke (the name of our server) via
the Web and email, and information about the contest was carried
by many diverse venues, including Ric Ford's MacInTouch, MacWEEK,
Wired, TidBITS (of course), along with several Swedish
publications, the Wall Street Journal, and the New York Times. The
contest reward was initially 10,000 Swedish kronor (about $1,350
U.S.), but during the challenge we were able to increase the
amount of prize money a couple of times, thanks to nine Swedish
Apple resellers. In the end, the contest reward was 100,000
kronor, or approximately $13,500 U.S.
Why did we do it? We wanted to prove there is an alternative to
large and expensive Unix- and Windows NT-based solutions for
secure World Wide Web services - a solution that doesn't require
hundreds of hours to set up or need a separate firewall. We were
not trying to prove a Mac OS-based solution is right for everyone,
but we are saying it is exactly the right solution for many of us.
We wanted to prove the Macintosh is an off-the-shelf system that
allows safe, secure, and reliable presence on the Internet within
30 minutes. Since no one was able to claim the prize money, I
think we proved our point.
For more detailed information on the contest, rules, and frequent
questions and answers that came up during the contest, check out
Hacke itself.
<http://hacke.infinit.se/indexeng.html>
**The Best Attempts** -- In the early stages of the challenge,
visitors were trying to exploit more or less known security issues
under Unix. We also tracked news coverage on Windows NT security
flaws by increased attempts to hack into our server using those
flaws; each time a new article appeared about a security problem
with Windows NT or NT-based server software, it was followed by a
new set of attacks on our server. Many crackers seem to believe
Windows NT and Mac OS have something in common. Needless to say,
Hacke didn't respond at all to these attacks.
Would-be crackers also spent a lot of effort on trying to guess
the password to pi_admin, an administration identity under WebSTAR
2.0 that enables webmasters to handle some core functions
remotely. There were more than 220,000 attempts to guess the
username and the password, but to the best of our knowledge, none
were successful. However, even if someone had guessed the
password, they would not have been able to change the content of
the server; it simply wasn't possible through pi_admin using the
set of WebSTAR plug-ins we had installed.
When guessing at the pi_admin password grew stale, crackers tried
to break in to the machine providing our DNS service, with the
goal of moving Hacke to another IP number, and then changing the
content of the server. [DNS, or Domain Name Service, translates
between IP numbers and the more-friendly names of Internet
machines. -Geoff] But since our DNS service (provided via
Men&Mice's QuickDNS Pro) is also running on a Mac, these attempts
were destined to fail. The success rate was not any better for
contestants that tried to get into Hacke via our mail server; it
was running under Mac OS as well, so there was no Unix sendmail
program to try to exploit.
<http://www.miceandmen.com/products/quickdnspro/>
Tired of all the Mac servers, would-be crackers tried to find
something in our network that was not Mac-based. The only thing
they found were the routers. Fortunately, the routers were
secured, but breaking into them could have been a problem, since
it could have taken part or all of our network off the Internet
entirely. The question is, would that have counted as a hack that
was eligible for the prize money? Successfully attacking a router
would have merely revealed a security hole in our ISP's
connection, and the idea of the challenge was to alter the
contents of a Web page. In the end, I suppose it would have
depended on the results of a successful router attack, but none
were successful.
The most interesting attempts occurred near the end of the
competition when people realized they needed a different solution.
The best attack was pure social-engineering.
It started when <[email protected]> received an email message
apparently sent by <[email protected]>. The message requested
Christine put new text on the front page of Hacke because "I don't
have the time to do it myself." We would probably have seen
through this ruse anyhow, but it was even more apparent because
the letter was written in English, and we normally communicate
with each other in Swedish.
The next perpetrator was a Norwegian who claimed he had broken
Hacke but he had been thrown out before he was done. He couldn't
prove that he had been there but he threatened us with lawyers if
he didn't receive the prize money. He even called us and told us
that he had 3,000 witnesses because he'd accomplished the feat on
a big screen during a conference in Norway. However, no evidence
or witnesses have materialized.
On the last day of the contest, we received email from two people
that seemed to be very polite and helpful. They told us that they
had found some information that could be very useful for us. Their
enclosures looked like documents but they were, in fact, small
AppleScripts that could have changed Hacke's front page had they
been launched on the server. They were easy to spot, but it was a
good try! The people who wrote the scripts probably realized they
would not be successful, since in the middle of the code we found
"Rats! No $13,000 for me today."
**Performance & Reliability** -- It is well known that the Mac OS
is currently sensitive to Ping of Death attacks, and that Open
Transport and WebSTAR do not have functions to handle SYN attacks.
We were largely spared the latter, and while Ping of Death
attempts did not seem to knock out the server every time, Hacke
was crashed three times by Ping of Death attacks. Since our idea
was to conduct the challenge on an easy-to-set-up server, we did
not try to defend against these attacks. Instead, we installed the
widely-used shareware programs Keep It Up and AutoBoot to restart
the server automatically if it crashed.
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/cfg/keep-it-up-131.hqx>
<ftp://mirror.aol.com/pub/info-mac/cfg/auto-boot-15.hqx>
[For background, Ping of Death attacks involve sending large data
packets (usually over 64K) that get re-assembled by the receiving
machine into a block of data larger than the original, often
causing an overflow and hence a crash. The attack is usually
carried out via ping, but in theory the technique can be applied
to any IP datagram. A SYN attack is a denial of service attack
that involves sending a flood of SYN packets (which are always
used to start a TCP transaction) that contain faked source
addresses. The receiving machine then spends a lot of its time and
resources trying to send and receive acknowledgments to and from
machines that don't exist. SYN attacks can be used to block
individual TCP ports (or entire machines) from real users. Macs
aren't the only machines susceptible to these attacks, but most
other platforms have patched vulnerabilities to the Ping of Death,
and Apple plans to do so in a future update to Open Transport.
-Geoff]
Our philosophy was that crashing a Web server only to have it
reboot a minute later was not as severe a problem as an attack
which alters the content of a Web page. For example, it is far
more serious for a firm like Telia (the Swedish telecommunications
company) if their home page is altered to read "Felia" (which, in
Swedish, could mean "something that is consistently done wrong")
than it is for their Web site to be down temporarily.
Additionally, the Macintosh server was incredibly dependable. As
noted above, it went down just three times, and in each case we
were able to trace the cause to oversized ping packets. We had
expected that. This reliability was also demonstrated by our other
Mac servers - Web, Mail, and DNS - that were exposed to attacks
and inquiries during the contest. Further, the performance of the
server was never a problem. Although Hacke was often very busy
(with over 50 simultaneous connections), it sent out a single
"busy" message. Some challengers may have had problems connecting
to the server, however, since we're located in the southern
Swedish countryside and our connection to the world is only 64
Kbps. Also, users from overseas undoubtedly experienced some
connectivity problems getting through to us at all.
**Some Statistics** -- During the competition's two months,
Hacke's English and Swedish entry pages logged more than 650,000
hits, and over 100,000 unique IP addresses were logged. The server
sent out over 8,000 MB of data. Approximately 75 percent of
Hacke's visitors came from the United States, 20 percent from
Sweden, and the remainder were spread throughout the world. Many
companies and organizations expressed interest - we logged several
visitors from IBM, Hewlett-Packard, Cray, Digital, SGI, Novell,
Boeing, AT&T, and Netscape. In addition, NASA and the U.S.
military were frequent guests.
**The Next Step** -- Hacke will not disappear. We plan to announce
future contests using more sophisticated setups, to address common
criticisms of the Macintosh as a Web server platform (including
handling several domains, remote administration, high levels of
interactivity, access to databases, and so forth). We need to
contact sponsors, define a stable and interesting concept, and
ensure all criticisms about inadequate features or capabilities
are addressed. We also need to do our real jobs: we haven't earned
a single krona for the time we spent on the Crack A Mac
competition. It should also be noted the Crack A Mac challenge was
in no way affiliated with Apple Computer. We just feel we have a
vision that should make it possible for more organizations to take
the leap toward the Internet.
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.278 | Issue #379 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Mon May 12 1997 21:38 | 631 |
|
TidBITS#379/12-May-97
=====================
Considering the purchase of a Newton? Don't miss this week's
detailed review of the Newton MessagePad 2000, written by a long-
time Newton owner who recently bought the latest model. This week,
we also examine each of the entries in our TidBITS Search Engine
Shootout, and bring you news about the upcoming PowerBook 2400c,
and Aladdin Systems purchasing Rev.
Topics:
MailBITS/12-May-97
Shootout at the Searching Corral
MessagePad 2000: New Newton Exceeds Expectations
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-379.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#379_12-May-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special TidBITS deal!
Performa 6400 32MB/1.6GB/256kL2/28.8/15" monitor, refurb: $1529
More details: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]>
TidBITS Special - free shipping on Apple upgrade cards from $79
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/specials/tidbits.html>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/12-May-97
------------------
**A PowerBook for Tiny Fingers** -- Apple and IBM officially
introduced the PowerBook 2400c last week, filling the sub-notebook
category left vacant by the discontinued Duo line. The machine
runs on a 180 MHz 603e PowerPC processor with a 256K Level 2
cache, and supports a 10.4-inch active-matrix color display.
Weighing only 4.4 pounds and smaller than notebook-sized paper,
the 2400c should be a relief for travelers burdened by shoulder-
straining loads of equipment. Some concessions Apple made in the
2400's size are a smaller keyboard (originally designed for the
Japanese market, where hunt-and-peck typing in Kanji is more
common than touch typing in English) and a lack of an internal
floppy drive. Prices should start around $3,500; units will start
shipping in Japan at the end of the month, and are expected be
available in the United States at the end of July. [JLC]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q3/
970508.pr.rel.pb2400c.html>
**Aladdin Revs Up** -- Aladdin Systems has acquired publishing
rights to 6prime's Rev, the $99.95 easy-to-use revision control
software I reviewed back in TidBITS-362_. Rev saves intermediate
versions of frequently saved documents, making it possible to
return to one of those intermediate versions in case of otherwise
irrevocable mistakes. Even though Nisus Writer provides unlimited
undos that work through saves, I still use Rev with documents I
work on frequently, and on several occasions Rev has saved me from
recreating work. I'm pleased to see Aladdin picking up Rev so it
can benefit from the additional support. [ACE]
<http://www.aladdinsys.com/rev/>
Shootout at the Searching Corral
--------------------------------
by TidBITS Staff <[email protected]>
The deadlines for our TidBITS Search Engine Shootout contest
announced in TidBITS-368_ have come and gone, and it's time to
share the results. To begin, we want to thank each and every
entrant personally. These folks put tremendous effort into
creating search engines that would serve the Macintosh community,
and for that alone they all deserve kudos. Overall, the quality of
the search engines was great, and we enjoyed reading about how the
entries were constructed.
In this week's article, we're going to spotlight each entrant and
provide comments about each search engine. Then, next week, after
we've had more time to chat with the top entrants, we'll announce
the winner (or winners, if necessary). Feel free to visit the
sites (listed below in no particular order), but don't worry if
you can't connect - because some entries are running on personal
machines, they may not be available full time. You can also refer
to TidBITS-368_ for the contest criteria.
**Scott Ribe & WebServer 4D** -- By far the snappiest entry came
from Scott Ribe, who wrote a text indexing extension that works
with MDG's $295 WebServer 4D to provide a blindingly fast, full-
text search engine for TidBITS. Although Scott had to write the
code, which took a few weeks (and it's still relatively hard-wired
to TidBITS, but he plans to generalize it for commercial release),
the setup seems simple, with the text indexing extension looking
for TidBITS issues in a specific drop folder.
<http://www.mdg.com/>
We liked this entry quite a bit, in large part thanks to its
speed. It has a relatively spartan results page, with the issue
number and the article title, but I imagine it could fairly easily
add the author, or perhaps the first line of the article to a
summary list. Results are sorted by reverse chronological order,
and Scott plans relevance ranking for a future release. The search
finds articles containing all the search terms, and although you
can search for issue dates, neither Boolean nor phrase searching
is available. Oddly, it also can't handle hyphenated words, like
"Ashton-Tate". [ACE]
<http://38.254.39.13/tidbits_archive/>
**Ethan Benatan, Frontier & Phantom** -- Ethan Benatan came up
with a creative, highly functional solution for searching TidBITS
issues: using Userland Frontier, Ethan wrote a scheduled script
that uses Fetch to download new TidBITS issues, and (when a new
issue appears) breaks it up into articles and saves the resulting
files in a local directory. Each night, Maxum's Phantom adds any
new files to its cumulative index, while continuously serving as a
CGI to handle queries from users. Frontier also uses Eudora Light
to send status reports. Phantom is about $300, while Frontier and
other components have little or no cost.
<http://www.maxum.com/Phantom/>
<http://www.scripting.com/Frontier/>
The result is a spiffy TidBITS search engine, offering word-
stemming, Boolean and phonetic searching capabilities from
Phantom, plus "convenience" features for searching just 1996 or
1997 TidBITS issues, searching only URLs or headers, detailed or
compact results formats, and relevancy-ranked search results
(expressed in percentages). To our delight, Ethan went to the
extra effort of breaking MailBITS up into separate articles so
they can be matched individually. Although the detailed search
results are marred by navigation links showing up in the three-
line previews, all in all, Ethan's effort is outstanding. [GD]
<http://anacardium.bio.pitt.edu:8080/>
**Andrew Warner & FoxPro** -- You don't hear much about the Mac
version of FoxPro since Microsoft purchased Fox back in 1992 (see
TidBITS-113_). But, it's still out there, and Andrew Warner has
shown that it can still perform. This search engine was written
entirely in FoxPro and is highly customizable. It reads TidBITS
issues from a drop folder, and provides dynamic headers and
footers. The system includes a file parsing program that reads the
HTML of each issue and parses them into separate articles. Then,
Phdbase, a text searching library add-on for FoxPro/Mac, does the
indexing.
<http://www.microsoft.com/vfoxpro/vf_xplat.htm>
Since Andrew had to run this on his personal machine, we couldn't
do much testing in the time available. Boolean and phrase
searching (via quotes) were available, and you could limit the
searches to specific fields (such as article title or,
hypothetically, date) as well. Andrew didn't spend much time on
this solution, but he said he could easily add or modify many
features, given more time. The results list included the article
title and issue date, and articles displayed relatively well, with
an occasional glitch or inappropriate search hit. [ACE]
<http://agency.arnoldcom.com/aw.search2.html>
**Ole, David, FileMaker & Frontier** -- Ole Saalmann and David
Weingart harnessed Userland Frontier not only as a CGI engine for
returning search results, but also as a parser and scheduled
retriever for new TidBITS issues. Frontier scripts grab TidBITS
issues, break them into articles, and stores them in a simple
FileMaker Pro database. When search requests come in from users,
Frontier tells FileMaker what to search for, then returns the
results in HTML.
<http://www.scripting.com/Frontier/>
<http://www.claris.com/products/claris/filemakerpro/filemakerpro.html>
Ole and David's project offers a pleasing AltaVista-like
interface, detailed and compact results pages (plus an Advanced
Search option with some Boolean and phrase-searching operations,
plus searches in articles titles, issue ranges, and date ranges).
Although the service displays some HTML oddities and doesn't offer
relevancy ranking for articles, it's speedy, offers excellent
search results pages, and has a particularly elegant scripting
setup on the Web server. [GD]
<http://www.gilbert.org/searchBITs.fcgi>
**Duane Bemister & WebSonar** -- Duane Bemister created his entry
using Virginia Systems' WebSonar Professional. Products in the
WebSonar line make it possible to search large quantities of
documents via the Web, and those documents can be in many
different formats, making it possible to place documents online
without converting them to HTML.
Although WebSonar offers many sophisticated options, it suffers
under the burden of so many possibilities that casual users may
become discouraged with the complex menu- and toolbar-driven
interface. Further, WebSonar uses a page metaphor which causes
search results to not appear to return discrete articles. WebSonar
represents a powerful tool, but we aren't convinced that casual
searchers will wish to devote the mental cycles necessary to jump
its learning curve. [TJE]
<http://www.websonar.com/websonarcom/tidbits_challenge.html>
**David, Curt & Apple e.g.** -- We received two entries that used
Apple e.g., a CGI (currently freely available and in beta) from
Apple that adds search features to Macintosh-based Web sites.
Technically speaking, Apple e.g. uses technology from Apple
formerly codenamed the V-Twin text indexing engine, but now
saddled with the rather dull appellation of Apple Information
Access Toolkit. From a backend standpoint, we like the way both
entries integrate Apple e.g. with TidBITS, and we also like the
user experience. It's easy to find articles, and the results list
gives a relevancy score for each found article. Plus, there's a
feature for checking off particularly relevant documents in a
results list, and then finding similar articles to those checked.
We were rather impressed at how well that feature works.
<http://cybertech.apple.com/apple_eg.html>
The first entry, created by David Clatfelter, gives results in
table or text format. Table format uses graphics to create a
relevancy score fill bar and gives information about each found
article. Unfortunately, the information begins with a jumble of
text from the top of the issue containing the found article. The
text format uses asterisks to indicate a relevancy score and gives
the title of the issue in which the found article resides.
<http://idoseek.ucr.edu/cgi-bin/appleeg/eg.acgi>
Curt Stevens submitted the second Apple e.g. entry. Users can
choose from full or compact format for viewing results. Full
format returns a list of found articles, each with a fill bar
indicating a relevancy score. After the score, each entry begins
with the article title, and includes the first few lines of the
article, making it easy to determine if the article is of
interest. Compact format is much like David's text format, except
it lists the article's title instead of the title of the issue
that containing the article. Overall, we are impressed with the
performance and possibilities of Apple e.g. and plan to take a
closer look. [TJE]
<http://17.255.9.121:8080/TidBITS.acgi>
**Jacque Landman Gay & LiveCard** -- When I wrote about LiveCard,
the $150 CGI from Royal Software, in TidBITS-338_ I mostly noted
its ability to put HyperCard stacks on the Web with little or no
modification. Little did I expect one of the most noted members of
the HyperCard community would use it as the basis for a TidBITS
search engine.
<http://www.quibble.com/HyperActive/LiveCard.acgi>
LiveCard acts as an intermediary between a Macintosh Web server
and Jacque's custom HyperCard stack that indexes issues, performs
searches, and report results. LiveCard presents a simple search
form for entering up to three sets of search terms. Quoted phrases
can be used, and Boolean search options are available. Search
results are displayed as a list of article titles, and clicking a
title takes users to the appropriate location in a TidBITS issue.
Although HyperCard is sometimes maligned as a CGI engine in
comparison to Frontier or compiled solutions, this LiveCard tool
searches more than 10 MB of TidBITS articles and returns search
results with surprising speed (and my server, where it's
temporarily being hosted, isn't particularly fast). Although this
search engine doesn't let users restrict searches to particular
ranges of dates or issues and only presents a bare-bones results
listing, it's a surprisingly smooth effort given the small amount
of time Jacque was able put into it, and an apt demonstration of
the kinds of Web services that can be produced with off-the-shelf
authoring software (especially since LiveCard is included in
Apple's HyperCard 2.3.5 Value Bundle). [GD]
<http://www.interedu.com/royalsoftware/descriptions/LiveCard.html>
<http://hypercard.apple.com/>
**Glen Stewart & WarpSearch** -- Glen Stewart's WarpSearch CGI
works differently from most of the other entrants. Other solutions
usually index the entire TidBITS archive, which makes for fast
searches, but requires weekly additions to the index and can use a
fair amount of disk space. In contrast, WarpSearch just searches
the entire archive each time. That might sound slow, but it still
manages to search the 10 MB of TidBITS issues at roughly 700K per
second.
WarpSearch only allows phrase searches, and no Boolean or multiple
non-contiguous word searches. The results list provides the issue
name, the size of the issue, the modified date, and the number of
matches in that issue. Unfortunately, it doesn't break articles
out of the overall issues, sometimes returns unintelligible
issues, and because it uses text from our setext files rather than
the HTML versions, the found text doesn't look as good as it
could. [ACE]
<http://stewart-3.pnet.msen.com/cgi/warpsearch/warpsearch.html>
**Nisus Software & GIA** -- Although Nisus Software's GIA (Guided
Information Access) technology isn't precisely a full-text search
engine, we decided to let them compete anyway. GIA provides
keyword-based live filtering, so as you select keywords from a
predefined list, the lists of matching TidBITS articles and
available keywords both shrink. Selecting additional keywords
decreases the number of articles and keywords until you've
narrowed the search to a manageable set of articles. The hardest
part of setting up a keyword system is selecting the keywords, and
the system seemed to work best for relatively broad searches.
Looking for a specific article was sometimes frustrating if
necessary keywords weren't present.
I continue to be impressed with the possibilities of GIA, but its
reality lags. Nisus Software has implemented GIA entirely in Java,
and although we used it with a different Java VMs (including
Internet Explorer on a PC), it was continually plagued by
interface glitches. Some can no doubt be easily fixed, but others
may be more basic to Java or current tools. In the end, although
GIA is fascinating technology, it doesn't meet the shootout
criteria, since the server doesn't currently run on a Mac, and
it's not providing a full-text search. [ACE]
<http://www.infoclick.com/gia/gia6/TidBits1.html>
**Roger McNab & NZDL** -- Roger McNab at the University of Waikato
integrated the text of TidBITS issues with the search engine of
the New Zealand Digital Library (NZDL). The NZDL enables users to
search specific collections of documents (including Project
Gutenberg, FAQ Archives, others only available in PostScript or
TeX formats), and permits ranked or Boolean queries, additional
search options, and compact results pages that identify article
titles and authors.
Although the NZDL archive is functional, useful, and offers an
attractive query interface, it also violates one of our contest's
ground rules: it doesn't run on a Macintosh. Although core
portions of the project are written in Perl and the author doesn't
anticipate problems with a Macintosh port, the simple fact is that
a Mac version doesn't yet exist. [GD]
<http://www.cs.waikato.ac.nz/~nzdl/tbc/>
**Tune In Next Week** -- There you have our contest entrants -
tune in next week for more details on our favorites and the
eventual winner or winners.
MessagePad 2000: New Newton Exceeds Expectations
------------------------------------------------
by David Gewirtz <[email protected]>
It took a long time, but I'm finally the proud owner of a slick
MessagePad 2000 (MP2K). Getting it was a challenge. The original
unit I purchased was stolen en route from NewtonSource to my
office, but after a week or so (and thanks to a harried
NewtonSource employee), a unit is in my hands. Although I've had
the machine for a short time, I can definitely say it's pretty
cool.
<http://www.newton.apple.com/product_info/devices/MP2000/MP2000.html>
<http://www.newtonsource.com/>
**MessagePad 2000 Hardware** -- Compared to my previous Newton (a
MessagePad 120), the MP2K is about three-eighths of an inch wider,
a tad taller, and about the same thickness, although most reports
claim it's thinner. Using the always-scientific "heft test," the
MP2K (with batteries) feels slightly heavier than its older
cousin. [The spec sheet claims a height of 1.1 inches, width of
4.7 inches, and depth of 8.3 inches, with an overall weight
(batteries included) of 1.4 pounds. -Tonya]
Despite the small physical size increase, the screen real estate
has grown dramatically from 320 by 240 to 480 by 320. The added
pixels fit nicely into a similar physical display space because
the new screen has a resolution of 100 dpi. It was neat seeing my
to do list (which had previously spilled over the bottom of the
screen) fit inside the available space. Comparatively speaking,
you get about as much additional screen space as you would if you
jumped from a 640 by 480 monitor to 800 by 600.
The display also now supports 16 shades of gray, which provide a
slight improvement to some interface items (like the Newton Works
scroll bar), but the various grays become somewhat difficult to
see in less-than-perfect lighting.
Though the MessagePad 130 featured a backlit display, this is my
first experience with one. As I sit at Bennigan's (a restaurant)
gobbling appetizers, I can finally clearly see my MessagePad's
screen. It's even bright enough to use in the total darkness of my
car.
Handwriting recognition is fast (especially if you turn off the
delay option), thanks to the MP2K's 161 MHz StrongARM processor.
When writing long notes in the MessagePad 120's NotePad, I often
experienced lags; this problem does not occur on the MP2K, and I'm
happily writing this article in the new Newton Works word
processor.
The MP2K looks different than its predecessors. The pen drops in
from the top and has a nifty pop-out stand. The screen cover opens
like a book from the side. With a bit of creativity (propping it
up on the keyboard case and rotating the screen), the door becomes
a stand that holds the Newton at the right angle for typing on the
optional external keyboard.
Taking honors as the first Newton with sound input capabilities,
the MP2K includes a new NotePad paper that records sound for up to
sixty seconds per sheet. Unfortunately, there's no easy way to
start recording without going to the NotePad and clicking the
record button - which means it's tough to do one-touch recording
while driving.
**Docking Port** -- A small door located at the top of the MP2K
opens to reveal a power tap and a mini-bus that's now called a
"docking port." The earlier mini-DIN serial port now comes in the
form of an easy-to-lose dongle that plugs into the docking port.
As soon as they become available, I plan to buy several dongles
for when I lose the original.
The MP2K includes an auto-docking function that activates the
connection utility when the dongle is plugged in. That's not
necessarily exciting in its own right, but I hope that some
enterprising firm builds a complete docking stand that takes
advantage of this feature.
**PC Card Slots** -- A real win is the addition of a second PC
Card slot. It's finally possible to put a modem in one slot and a
memory card in the other. This will come in handy as you make use
of EnRoute i-net (an email client) and NetHopper (a Web browser).
EnRoute has a robust set of rules to process incoming mail, but I
also want to see how Eudora Pro for the Newton stands up.
<http://www.netstrat.com/>
<http://allpen.allpen.com/nethopper3.html>
<http://www.eudora.com/newton/>
**Battery Power** -- The MP2K uses four off-the-shelf alkalines
(AA) to power its hungry processor. Though marketing hype claims
three to six weeks of life during normal use, I worry about it.
After a week, the battery indicator shows I've consumed half the
available power, leading me to believe I'll be swapping batteries
at least twice a month.
There's no support for a charging station (although the docking
connection could conceivably be useful here), so it's not possible
to drop the MP2K onto the charger when you return home at night
and know there will be juice in the morning. Apple offers a Newton
9W Power Adapter that's supposed to charge a set of nickel-hydride
batteries, but neither the battery nor the charger I ordered
showed up with the Newton. In the interim, I've installed a 4 MB
memory card, and I'm going to initiate a backup each morning.
**Button Panel** -- Instead of the silk-screened button panel, the
MP2K renders a "soft" panel on the display. At first I wasn't
impressed with the grayscale shading of the panel, but it grew on
me as I discovered some of its secrets, such as:
* When you rotate the screen, the panel rotates as well, so the
buttons and associated text face the right direction.
* You can drag & drop items from the Extras drawer onto the button
bar, and - in this way - customize the bar to contain the goodies
you want.
Since the button bar is a function of software, we can expect to
see replacements and enhancements in the future.
(Ah, the perils of mobile computing. Bennigan's is closing, so
I'll continue this review somewhere else... and here I am a few
days later having breakfast at Friendly's.)
**Newton Works** -- An important new feature, Newton Works appears
at first to be a simple word processor (like the original
MacWrite). But if you look at the New pop-up menu, you'll discover
you can create a new paper or a new spreadsheet, thanks to the
optional QuickFigure Works. There's now enough screen space for a
reasonable number of cells, so a Newton spreadsheet is finally
practical. According to the documentation, QuickFigure can read
and export to Excel.
I'm not sure why QuickFigure Works is part of the Newton Works
program. There's no provision for intermixing spreadsheet data and
word processing documents (or I haven't found any), and though the
word processor requires the Newton Keyboard (there are some
downloadable utilities to get around this), the spreadsheet
recognizes handwriting. Interestingly, the paper document object
has a subordinate object called QuickSketch that enables you to
put a drawing in a word-processed document.
**Other Installed Software** -- The traditional Newton
applications haven't changed in any discernible way. The In Box
and Out Box icons have been combined into InOut; the Connection
icon has become Dock, and (depending on which Newton bundle you
purchase) you'll also get EnRoute, NetHopper, and QuickFigure
Works.
After crashing my Newton badly on the first day (I kept popping
out the battery pack to show it around), I was concerned I'd lose
the installed software on a system reset. Fortunately, I didn't
have to reset the MP2K back to bare hardware to restore the
system. If it has been necessary to zero the system and restart
it, I could have downloaded the spreadsheet, email software, and
Web browser from a desktop computer, and Apple provided PC and
Macintosh floppies with copies of the add-on software.
**Newton Connection Utilities** -- Because I'm thrilled with my
MessagePad 2000, I hate to end this review on a sour note, but I'm
disappointed with the long-awaited Newton Connection Utilities
(NCU), which comes as a beta release with the MP2K, complete with
a "special, limited time offer" that gives users the "incredible
opportunity" to upgrade to version 1.0 sometime between now and
November.
<http://www.newton.apple.com/product_info/SW/ncu.html>
I find shipping a beta version inexcusable. Users are spending
nearly a thousand dollars on what, for many, is a luxury item, and
they shouldn't have to worry that the software for moving personal
data between a desktop computer and the Newton is unfinished and
subject to known problems.
NCU is huge. Weighing in at over 4 MB (for a data transfer
program!), NCU supports backup, synchronization, package download,
and remote keyboard functions. I tried a backup and it failed
twice. The third time NCU successfully accepted a backup session
from the Newton.
NCU provides synchronization functions for _only_ Claris Organizer
2.0 and Now Contact/Up-to-Date 3.5. I own version 3.6 of Now's
products, so it's not clear if I'll be able to do a successful
synchronization.
I considered purchasing a U.S. Robotics PalmPilot because of its
one-touch synchronization feature (and the little dock is sexy).
However, I didn't want to learn Graffiti, it didn't include an
outliner, and its the desktop computer software is single-user
only. [TidBITS will review the Pilot in the near future. -Jeff]
By contrast, the Newton has everything - except quality
synchronization. NCU could have provided it, but although there's
an auto dock feature on the MP2K, there's no corresponding
functionality in NCU, and you must launch NCU by hand. Further,
NCU has no facility for automation and no scripting support.
**Conclusions** -- The Newton MessagePad 2000 is an exceptional
piece of hardware. The fit and finish of the device is everything
we've come to expect from Apple. Even so, I am disappointed with
Apple's performance in providing supporting resources:
rechargeable batteries, docks, replacement dongles, and a better
version of Newton Connection Utilities.
Given Apple's inconsistent long-term approach to the Newton
platform, I worry about relying on the product. On the other hand,
I'm extremely happy with the device, and I'll continue to use it
constantly.
<http://www.newton.apple.com/>
**DealBITS** -- Through the URLs below, Cyberian Outpost is
offering TidBITS readers deals on the Newton MessagePad 2000. The
basic MP2K is $939.95; the enhanced model with keyboard, case, and
spreadsheet, is $1,079.95.
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/message-pad-2000.html>
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/message-pad-2000-deluxe.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.279 | Issue #380 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue May 20 1997 11:23 | 619 |
|
TidBITS#380/19-May-97
=====================
In March we promised you a Search Engine Shootout, and this week,
with gun smoke still hanging in the air, we'll show you which
entries are still standing. We also discuss Apple's new customer
support options, the newest version of Microsoft Internet
Explorer, the release of Newton Connection Utilities 1.0, and
TidBITS distribution on CompuServe.
Topics:
MailBITS/19-May-97
Apple Revamps Support Options
And Then There Was One...
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-380.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#380_19-May-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers! <----- NEW!
Used IIci 8/80, 13" Apple RGB, keyboard, Word 5 upgrade: $339
More details: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]>
TidBITS Special - free shipping on Apple upgrade cards from $79
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/specials/tidbits.html>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/19-May-97
------------------
**Internet Explorer Updated** -- Microsoft last week released
Microsoft Internet Explorer 3.0.1, which adds several welcome
features. Most notable are the capability to monitor Web sites for
changes, an AutoComplete feature that finishes typing URLs for you
if you've visited that URL before; site password management that
remembers cookies, usernames, and passwords; and a Download
Manager that finally downloads files in a download window rather
than the main browser window. Internet Explorer 3.0.1 also adds
support for Netscape's JavaScript scripting language, gives you
the choice of accepting or declining cookies, and offers an
AutoSearch that lets you search directly from the Address bar by
typing "go" or "?" and then the search keywords. Versions are
available for both PowerPC and 68K Macs, and download sizes range
from 3.3 MB to 12.3 MB. [ACE]
<http://www.microsoft.com/msdownload/ieplatform/iemac.htm>
**Reduced Distribution on CompuServe** -- If you've become
accustomed to downloading TidBITS from a CompuServe forum, the
time has come to change your habits. We'd been thinking about
dropping direct CompuServe distribution because the download
counts have fallen while direct email subscriptions to CompuServe
subscribers have been climbing steadily, plus CompuServe Navigator
is old, clunky, and difficult to automate. However, our hand was
forced a few weeks ago when our CompuServe account via ZiffNet/Mac
stopped accepting our password. We have no problem with TidBITS
appearing in CompuServe forums but don't plan to handle the
distribution any more. If anyone wants to upload the issues, as is
happening in the MACCLUB forum, feel free to do so. It's probably
easier for CompuServe members to subscribe to our Internet mailing
list (which already has over 800 CompuServe subscribers) by
sending email to <[email protected]>. [ACE]
**Newton Connection Utilities 1.0** -- In TidBITS-379_, David
Gewirtz complained that a beta version of Newton Connection
Utilities shipped with the MessagePad 2000 (and the eMate 300).
Apple just released an updater to Newton Connection Utilities 1.0,
which updates NCU 1.0b6 to version 1.0. If you've used the beta
version to synchronize between your PDA and desktop machine, Apple
recommends that you run another synchronization right before
updating NCU. The download weights in at 4.8 MB. [ACE]
<ftp://ftp.info.apple.com/Apple.Support.Area/Apple.Software.Updates/US/
Newton/For_MacOS/Other_Newton_Updates/NCU_1.0_Updater.img.hqx>
Apple Revamps Support Options
-----------------------------
by Jeff Carlson <[email protected]>
For the last several years, for those with 800-number access, if
you experienced problems with your Mac, you could call Apple
toll-free at 800/SOS-APPL. As of last week, however, Apple has
multiplied its telephone customer support options to bring it in
line with industry standards and to try to recoup the high cost of
technical support. Although the shift isn't sudden or surprising,
Apple's implementation of its new policies has been less than
clear. Here is a brief rundown of what to expect if you need to
contact Apple with a problem. [Most of this article applies to
people in the United States; our apologies to readers in other
countries who have questions along these lines. -Tonya]
**A Winding Path** -- Last February, Apple reduced free telephone
help for Performa owners from 24 hours a day, seven days per week,
to 12 hours per day, five days per week, in order to concentrate
resources on those hours when the volume of calls was highest.
Then, in March, Apple announced the basics of the current plan:
all new Apple customers who bought products after 01-Apr-96
receive 90 days of free phone support. Callers requesting help
after that period will be directed to other support options,
including Technical Support Online and the new fee-based Apple
Support Line (see below). Until 15-May-97, however, the company
wasn't strictly enforcing the 90 day limit.
<http://www.info.apple.com/>
Now, Apple is sticking to the policy set forth in March, with
three exceptions: Lifetime technical support will be available via
800/SOS-APPL in education channels; for Apple-branded products
purchased between 01-Apr-93 and 01-Apr-96; and for Performas
purchased between 01-Sep-92 and 01-Apr-96. The last two conditions
apply the original owners of Apple equipment..
Apple's new support structure now incorporates four main areas:
**AppleAssurance** -- AppleAssurance covers every Apple product
and includes a one-year, worldwide hardware warranty and 90 days
of free phone support (800/500-7078). You must provide your
Support Access Number, included with your product.
<http://support.info.apple.com/support/supportoptions/appleassurance.html>
**Apple Support Line - Level I** -- For a $69.95 annual fee,
you can sign up for the new Apple Support Line - Level I. (There
doesn't seem to be a Level II.) This support option covers one CPU
and attached peripherals in the United States for up to one year
or ten incidents (defined as "a question relating to a specific,
discrete problem that can be answered by isolating its origin to a
single cause"). Phone support is available Monday through Friday,
6 A.M. to 6 P.M., Pacific Time. Those who cough up the cash will
also receive a free Macintosh: Beyond the Basics CD-ROM. Call
toll-free 888/APL-VALU (888/275-8258) to sign up through Apple, or
contact your local reseller.
<http://support.info.apple.com/support/supportoptions/suptline/aplsupline.html>
**AppleCare** -- Apple's extended service program works the same
as the one-year hardware warranty, with prices varying depending
by product and whether you choose carry-in, on-site, or mail-in
service (the price for my PowerBook 5300cs, for example, is
approximately $240 for a year of the carry-in option).
<http://product.info.apple.com/productinfo/applecare/applecare.html>
**Support Professional** -- Geared toward support managers and
staff, Apple's Support Professional option costs $2,000 to $3,400
per year and includes access to a private Web site with an
expanded Tech Info Library, software updates, disk images of all
Apple software, and Apple manuals in PDF format. Apple also
provides bimonthly support CDs and quarterly support briefing
teleconferences.
<http://support.info.apple.com/sp/supportpro.html>
**What about AppleClub?** Although it first appeared to be an
offshoot of Apple's support options, AppleClub is more of an added
service. For a $19.95 annual fee, members receive exclusive
software and hardware discounts, Apple software updates accessible
via private servers, a free CD-ROM, and, presumably, that hey-
buddy feeling of belonging to an exclusive club.
<http://club.apple.com/>
Apple has come a long way from when the company provided its
operating system free of charge, and though I expect that
technical support was a big red line in Apple's profit and loss
statement, it's sad to bid farewell to yet another aspect of what
was once a rather idealistic company. In particular, small
businesses who own a number of Macs may find the new pricing
particularly unpalatable, and it sounds like quite the headache
for consultants who need to contact Apple regarding clients'
machines. For the money, though, I hope Apple will be able to
provide uniformly quick, competent, and friendly service.
And Then There Was One...
-------------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
First, a correction. While developing search engines for the
TidBITS Search Engine Shootout, some entrants sent more than one
URL as they changed configurations, or temporarily used different
servers as test machines. The URL we gave last week for Glen
Stewart's WarpSearch entry such a temporary location, set up only
for the duration of the Shootout. You can check out WarpSearch
reliably at the following URL:
<http://associate.com/innovative/Glen_Stewart/About_WarpSearch.html>
Last week in TidBITS-379_ we introduced you to all the entrants
and promised we'd make a decision this week. It hasn't been easy.
Of our 11 entrants, all of whom submitted excellent entries, four
stood out.
* Scott Ribe and WebServer 4D
<http://38.254.39.13/tidbits_archive/>
* Ethan Benatan, Frontier and Phantom
<http://anacardium.bio.pitt.edu:8080/>
* Ole Saalmann and David Weingart, Frontier and FileMaker Pro
<http://www.gilbert.org/searchBITs.fcgi>
* Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
<http://17.255.9.121:8080/TidBITS.acgi>
**The Criteria** -- We had hoped that one of the entries would
obviously rise to the top, but we had no such luck. So, we came up
with some refined criteria for comparing our top four entries.
These criteria are:
* Ease of use for the end user
* Searching power for the end user
* Ease of setup and maintenance for us
* Searching speed
* Setup cost
* "Hit by a bus" survivability (I'll explain this later)
* Overall accuracy of results
We are aware that Apple has not yet shipped a final Telepathy
extension, so we're sure some of the comments below can easily be
addressed by the developers. We've tried to take that flexibility
into account, but overall, we judged what we saw.
Also keep in mind that we didn't evaluate these search engines for
which is _generically_ the best. We instead chose which would be
the best solution for TidBITS. That's likely to be different from
anything you may want a search engine to do, so if you want to
build your own Mac OS-based search engine, you should investigate
these technologies more closely (and check last week's article for
others that might suit your purposes).
**Ease of Use** -- Obviously, a search engine should be as easy to
use, because otherwise people will avoid it. This criterion is
often at odds with the next one, which rates searching power,
since the more options, the more complex the interface and the
results list inevitably become. Ethan's Phantom-based entry has
more options on its main search page than the rest, lowering its
ease of use slightly. Some of us like AltaVista's interface, and
familiarity on the Web is a good thing, so Ole and David's
Frontier and FileMaker entry gets points for providing both simple
and advanced search forms. Curt's Apple e.g. entry and Scott's
WebServer 4D entry have dead simple interfaces, which is good.
All our entrants provide results at the article level (and Ethan
gets extra points for breaking out MailBITS separately), although
Curt links to the article within the full issue rather than
breaking the articles out as individual files. Curt's technique
forces people to download a full issue each time but provides
context around the article in question and makes it easy to scan
other articles in the same issue. Ole and David straddle the fence
by breaking the articles out and also pointing into the full issue
on our Web site, which is good for an independent search engine,
but less important for something we'd run ourselves.
A final part of the ease of use criterion is the results page. The
results should be attractive, easy to scan quickly, and sorted
well. Ole and David score points from their homage to AltaVista
but display results newest first, whereas Ethan and Curt both take
advantage of relevance sorting. Ethan's results list unfortunately
includes the text from the navigation bar in the summary text, but
that's probably easily rectified. Scott's results page does
chronological sorting (relevance is slated for a later release)
and uses a simple table with the issue number and article title,
but no summary text, which makes it more difficult to determine
which article you might want. I suspect that's fixable.
Both Ethan and Curt include a field for a new search in the
results list, and Ethan puts the search terms in the field. Apple
e.g.'s option to find similar documents is more flexible than
Phantom's, since you can select multiple articles by clicking
multiple More checkboxes, whereas you can only find documents
similar to a single hit in Phantom's results list.
Although we're splitting hairs here, since all four are easy to
use, we give the ease of use award to Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
for the combination of a simple interface and a clear and
attractive results list.
Ease of Use: Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
**Searching Power** -- Sometimes you want to find information
that's not easily identified with a word or two. For that, you
need additional flexibility and power in the search engine. You
may know roughly when an article was published, or you may know
how a word starts or how it sounds but not know how to spell it
properly. Ethan's Phantom-based entry wins hands down when it
comes to searching power, which is the trade-off for losing a bit
on simplicity of interface. Phantom provides Boolean searching,
phonetic searching, word stemming, searching within certain HTML
tags, and some level of date range searching. Ole and David's
Frontier/FileMaker entry offers an advanced search that provides
Boolean searching, title searches, issue number searches, and date
range searches, which are quite useful. Curt's Apple e.g solution
and Scott's WebServer 4D entry offer little in the way of this
sort of flexibility, although you can throw parts of dates (like
the last two digits of the year) into the search string to improve
granularity.
The capability to find similar documents is useful for narrowing
searches. It's provided by both Ethan and Curt via Phantom and
Apple e.g., and both seem to do a good job at it. Overall, we
found that Apple e.g. had a better interface for finding similar
documents, but it's not enough to compete with Phantom's searching
flexibility.
Searching Power: Ethan Benatan, Frontier and Phantom
**Ease of Setup and Maintenance** -- This category is difficult to
judge, because we neither set up nor attempted to administer all
of the contest entries. However, based on what we know of the
tools involved and what we know of our existing tools, we can make
some assumptions.
Ole and David and Ethan use Frontier to suck in new TidBITS
issues, parse them into articles (and MailBITS, in Ethan's case),
and then turn them over to the database engine (FileMaker Pro and
Phantom, respectively). Ole and David also use Frontier as the CGI
to communicate between the Web server and FileMaker Pro, whereas
Phantom acts as both the indexer and the Web server. Using
Frontier offers significant flexibility, but may suffer from ease
of setup - scripting solutions seldom have well-designed graphical
interfaces. Similarly, although the flexibility is there, changes
require programming, and although both Geoff Duncan and Matt
Neuburg are capable of that, the rest of us at TidBITS aren't.
Since we're small, we try to keep overlapping skill sets so anyone
can step in for anyone else if necessary.
Scott and Curt both look in a drop folder for new issues of
TidBITS to index, which is an ideal solution for us, because it's
easy for us to modify our existing distribution automation to put
a copy of the issue in a folder. Curt's Apple e.g. entry is
probably the best here, since we believe we can point it at our
existing folder of TidBITS issues, whereas Scott's WebServer 4D
entry currently deletes the original from the drop folder after
importing it. We're sure that's an easy thing to change if
necessary.
Ease of Setup and Maintenance: Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
**Speed** -- Overall, we didn't notice that any of the entries
were particularly slow, and speed wouldn't have entered our
consciousness in a big way if it hadn't been for Scott Ribe's
WebServer 4D entry. Everyone else seemed roughly similar (and
since there are lots of variables in how fast something works on
the Web, we ignored occasional differences), but Scott's entry was
blindingly fast, so much so that I ended up using it a few times
in the last few weeks because I knew it would be the quickest to
send results back. There's not much else to say about this
criterion, but wow!
Speed: Scott Ribe and WebServer 4D
**Cost** -- Again, it's difficult to estimate the cost of setting
up one of these search engines since we already have some of the
necessary equipment and software. For those of you interested in
setting up a similar server from scratch, we'll rough out the
costs as we understand them.
* Scott's entry requires the $295 WebServer 4D from MDG, and he
said that he hopes to sell the custom text indexing extension he's
writing for this purpose for somewhere in the $100 to $200 range.
It achieves its blinding speed on a Quadra 800 with a PPC upgrade
card, which is about as slow as Power Macs get, so CPU power isn't
much of an issue, nor is disk space or speed. RAM is useful
though, and Scott recommends a system with 48 MB.
<http://www.mdg.com/>
* Ethan's entry uses Maxum's Phantom running in stand-alone mode,
so it doesn't even require an additional Web server. Phantom is
the major cost at $395, although Ethan's setup also uses the free
Frontier and the free Eudora Light (for reports). Currently,
Ethan's entry runs on a 32 MB PowerBase 180 from Power Computing.
<http://www.maxum.com/Phantom/>
<http://www.scripting.com/Frontier/>
* Ole and David's entry uses the free Frontier, Chris Hawk's free
Quid Pro Quo as the Web server, and Claris's FileMaker Pro, which
costs roughly $200. To avoid buying FileMaker Pro, Ole and David
say that you could use their Frontier suite with other databases.
Ole and David's entry was hosted on two separate machines; the
main one we pointed at turned out to use a 68040 and 20 MB of RAM,
so hardware shouldn't be an problem for their solution.
<http://www.scripting.com/Frontier/>
<http://www.socialeng.com/>
<http://www.claris.com/products/claris/filemakerpro/filemakerpro.html>
* Curt's entry uses Apple e.g., which is free, although it does
require a Web server such as StarNine's WebSTAR, which we use, or
the free Quid Pro Quo. It's running on an Apple Workgroup Server
8150/110 with 40 MB (10 MB for Apple e.g.). That's a 100 MHz
PowerPC 601 - not a particularly fast machine. The bottom line
comes down to the fact that if you have a Power Mac, you wouldn't
have to spend any money to get Apple e.g. up and running.
<http://cybertech.apple.com/apple_eg.html>
Cost: Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
**Hit by a Bus** -- As I noted before, TidBITS is a small
organization, and as with any small organization, we worry about
what TidBITS would do if something terrible (such as being hit by
a bus) were to happen to one of us. As such, we avoid situations
where any one of us is the only person who could perform an
important task - if that person were to die in a freak gardening
accident, that task would be difficult to continue. So, in
thinking about which search engines to adopt, we considered the
ramifications of the hit by a bus scenario for each one.
Curt's Apple e.g. entry would seem to be the obvious winner, but
for one wee problem: it's currently a custom job. Curt works at
Apple on Apple e.g., and he modified Apple e.g. to understand that
TidBITS issues have more than one article in them. So, unless
Curt's custom changes are rolled into the public version of Apple
e.g. and maintained (which is the plan), Curt becomes our weak
link. And, given Apple's recent troubles, Apple e.g.'s future in
general is something of a question mark.
Scott's entry suffers some of the same problems, given that the
bulk of the work is his custom text indexing extension, which is
currently hard-coded to certain aspects of TidBITS. If we were to
change something about our format, and Scott had been abducted by
space aliens, we'd be in trouble. Also, although WebServer 4D is
obviously performing well, MDG is a small company in what can be a
hard market.
Interestingly, although we marked Ethan and Ole and David's
entries down slightly for ease of setup because they're based in
large part on Frontier, they both do better in this category
because of that. Frontier may not be the sort of thing that some
of us have ever been able to wrap our heads around, but many
people know it and could help in case of emergency. Ethan also
uses Phantom, and Maxum seems like a solid company that is
unlikely to disappear or drop Phantom. Ole and David rely on
FileMaker Pro, and given that it's the most popular database on
the Macintosh, it's a good bet that it will be around forever with
plenty of people who know how to use it.
Ethan edges out Ole and David by a hair here, if only because he
seems to rely on Frontier a little bit less, which means finding
someone who could fix a problem in his code would be slightly
easier.
Hit by a Bus: Ethan Benatan, Frontier and Phantom
**Overall Accuracy** -- There's nothing worse than not being able
to find something you know exists thanks to some quirk in a search
engine. Geoff Duncan was a software tester in a previous lifetime,
and he briefly hammered on all of the entrants with deliberately
stressful and unusual searches. I'll let him report on which ones
fared well.
Fortunately, the four final entrants all provide essentially
correct and functional search results. Simple targeted tests for
known items - the word "emporia," for instance, which until now
only appeared in one TidBITS issue - worked correctly in all
engines; similarly, Boolean functions plus issue and date
restrictions appeared to function correctly where they were
offered. Stress tests for large (or huge) results lists and
simultaneous queries were also handled properly. However, some
more complex (or more naive) queries occasionally generated mixed
hits or unexpected results lists. After isolating the search
engines' behaviors, I tried to figure out how quirks might impact
real users.
Both Curt with Apple e.g. and Ethan with Phantom sort search
results by perceived relevance, which proves both a strength and a
weakness. On one hand, they both tend to let the most appropriate
articles float to the top of a results list, which is obviously
useful. However, relevancy ranking also tends to break down with
(perhaps unwittingly) vague queries. Apple e.g. casts a wide net,
routinely finding more than 100 matches for simple queries ("RAM
Doubler review"), of which the top-most matches were fine, but
subsequent matches can appear random at first glance and also have
a comparatively high relevancy. Phantom, conversely, throws away
the chaff: the same query turns up just three items, the first of
which is right on target, and the other two of which mention all
the terms but (appropriately) have single-digit relevancy. Phantom
does a similarly good job narrowing down results with other
generally phrased searches.
Neither Scott's nor Ole and David's entries offer relevancy;
instead sorting results from most to least recent. However (and
this is probably fixable), Ole and David's entry sometimes returns
duplicate hits in early TidBITS issues, with some early hits
appearing at the top of the results list, then repeated later in
correct sort order. More often than not, trying to access these
duplicated entries returns an error. Scott's entry doesn't suffer
from result duplication, but it does ignore URLs, which (judging
from TidBITS email) are frequently sought items.
So, although Apple e.g. provides more advanced features for
finding articles similar to ones in a results list, for pure
accuracy and relevancy of results, I give the nod to Phantom.
Accuracy: Ethan Benatan, Frontier and Phantom
**Quantitative Ratings** -- As a final method of differentiating
the search engines, I asked everyone at TidBITS to list these four
search engines in order of overall preference. I figured that
would help include any intangibles that might have slipped through
the criteria above. I then took the ratings and assigned points,
one point for the first choice, two for second, three for third,
and four for fourth. I next added the points for each entrant, and
ranked the entrants accordingly (like in the cross-country races I
ran in high school and college). With five people voting, the
scores could range between 5 and 20. Here's how it came out:
* 6 points: Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
* 13 points: Ethan Benatan, Frontier and Phantom
* 14 points: Ole Saalmann and David Weingart, Frontier and
FileMaker
* 17 points: Scott Ribe and WebServer 4D
Quantitative Ratings: Curt Stevens and Apple e.g.
**And in the End...** I feel terrible having to single out a
winner. All four entrants have done a fabulous job. Scott knocked
our socks off with the raw speed of his search engine - keep an
eye out for when he releases the commercial version of his text
indexing extension. Ethan showed how he could use Frontier to
enhance Phantom's already impressive capabilities. Ethan also says
he's looking for work soon - someone give this man a job! Ole and
David wanted to make sure Frontier got the exposure it deserves,
and they put together a great resource despite not knowing each
other and living on different continents. They're a tribute to the
spirit of the Internet. Curt wanted to show what Apple's free
Apple e.g. could do, and frankly, Apple can use all the impressive
technology demonstrations it can muster.
In our eyes then, they're all winners. But, we don't need to run
four separate search engines ourselves, so we plan to implement
Curt's Apple e.g. solution first because, all other things being
equal, it seems to be the easiest to merge into our existing
setup. Should we run into problems, we'll next test both Ethan's
and Ole and David's solutions. It will probably be easier to try
Ethan's solution, since it doesn't have to integrate with our
existing Web server. However, Ole and David's solution might
dovetail nicely with some other work that Geoff is doing with
keyword indexing. The final option would be Scott's WebServer 4D
solution solely because it involves acquiring, installing, and
learning several new pieces of software. There's no overall
problem in that, just the reality of how much time and bandwidth
we have to learn new things.
Thanks again to all of our entrants!
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.280 | Issue #381 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue May 27 1997 09:03 | 585 |
|
TidBITS#381/26-May-97
=====================
Looking for a new spreadsheet? Don't miss Matt's cheery review of
Spreadsheet 2000, a user-friendly program with a new take on how a
spreadsheet should work. This issue also features a close look at
Apple's recent Worldwide Developers Conference, Apple's plans for
the Newton, and details on Global Village's latest foray into
telecommunications technology.
Topics:
MailBITS/26-May-97
Global Village's 56K for PowerBooks
Yellow Box, Blue Box, Rhapsody & WWDC
A Spreadsheet for the Millennium
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-381.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#381_26-May-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers!
Used IIci 8/80, 13" Apple RGB, keyboard, Word 5 upgrade: $339
More details: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]>
TidBITS Special - free shipping on Apple upgrade cards from $79
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/specials/tidbits.html>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/26-May-97
------------------
**Apple Spins Out Newton** -- Last week, Apple announced plans to
form a subsidiary company based on the Newton group. The new
company, which doesn't yet have a name or a CEO, will focus on
"the computing and communications needs of mobile users." At the
moment, that means the company has two products, the MessagePad
2000 (see TidBITS-379_) and the eMate 300 (see TidBITS-361_),
although Apple will continue to support, sell, and market the
eMate into the education market. Future products will probably
focus on vertical markets such as health care, sales force
automation, and field service industries, and the company will
also seek to create and license new technologies aimed at meeting
the needs of mobile users. It would be ironic if Apple, in its
search for a CEO for the new company, considered ex-Apple CEO John
Sculley, who has the experience and championed the Newton during
his tenure at Apple. [ACE]
<http://product.info.apple.com/pr/press.releases/1997/q3/
970522.pr.rel.newton.html>
**TidBITS Still on ZDNet/Mac on CompuServe** -- Kevin Norris of
ZDNet/Mac tells us that they're continuing to upload TidBITS to
the ZDNet/Mac Arts & Fun Forum's (GO ZMC:ZMACARTS) Electronic Pubs
library (#11). He also notes that forum and all of ZDNet are now
part of CompuServe's Computing Professionals package (GO CPRO).
So, if you want to download TidBITS from CompuServe rather than
receive it in email (by subscribing to our mailing list at
<[email protected]>) or visiting our Web site, check out that
forum. [ACE]
<http://www.tidbits.com/>
Global Village's 56K for PowerBooks
-----------------------------------
by Mark H. Anbinder <[email protected]>
This Tuesday, Global Village Communication will announce a new
line of PC Card modems and Ethernet/modem combination cards
offering 56 Kbps telecommunications to laptop users. The new cards
support the K56flex technology developed by Rockwell and Lucent
and should reach customers in mid-June.
<http://www.globalvillage.com/>
The PC Cards will initially support PowerBook 190, 5300-, and
1400-series computers running System 7.5 or later. Global Village
plans to ship a free software update in July for PowerBook 3400-
and 2400-series laptops. Global Village is also releasing a
parallel pair of modem and Ethernet/modem combo PC Cards for
Windows 95 laptops - it's the first time the company has offered
the same products simultaneously for Macintosh and Windows. Both
cards offer fax capability via the popular GlobalFax software.
In response to questions about using K56flex technology over the
competing U.S. Robotics X2 56 Kbps technology, Global Village said
they had found broader support in the Internet Service Provider
community for K56flex dialup users, and the same was true in the
remote access server market dominated by companies like Cisco and
Shiva. The new modems have a flexible flash ROM and software
upgradable DSP technology that the company anticipates will allow
upgrades to whatever 56 Kbps technology emerges as a standard.
(Global Village Platinum 28.8 Kbps modem owners have been able to
upgrade at no charge to 33.6 Kbps using updaters.)
<http://www.globalvillage.com/support/software.html>
The 56K cards use the same external dongle (known as a Clyde) as
previous Global Village PC Card products to provide telephone and
10Base-T Ethernet connections. The Clyde also helps protect the
card from surges and higher line voltages on some digital phone
systems. The cards support the cellular adapter cables sold for
Global Village's previous PC Card products. Global Village expects
street price around $269 for the modem alone; $379 for the
modem/Ethernet combo cards.
Global Village Communication -- 800/736-4821 -- 408/523-1000
408/523-2407 (fax) -- <[email protected]>
Yellow Box, Blue Box, Rhapsody & WWDC
-------------------------------------
by Geoff Duncan <[email protected]>
Every year, Apple puts on the Worldwide Developers Conference
(WWDC), a pricey technical get-together for serious Macintosh
programmers. Unlike trade shows such as Macworld Expo, WWDC isn't
packed with hundreds of vendors; bag-carrying, button-clad
attendees; and stages awash with marketers, headset microphones,
and plenty of styling gel. Instead, WWDC is a chance for
programmers to learn about Apple's future technologies and
directions, ask questions, and let Apple know what they're
thinking. Developers are Apple's toughest audience - they're least
likely to be influenced by promises, and most likely to require
tangible proof of claims. WWDC is never easy from Apple's point of
view.
What's more, Apple hasn't had a great year. In the wake of Apple's
financial troubles and the acquisition of NeXT, speculation was
high and expectations were low for this year's WWDC. No one knew
what Apple would bring to the table, and many developers have had
their faith shaken by Apple's recent layoffs, technology freezes,
and the ascendence of NeXT executives who seem to hold the fate of
the Macintosh in their hands.
**Rhapsody & Yellow Box** -- One thing everyone at WWDC wanted to
see and hear about was Rhapsody, Apple's forthcoming operating
system based in part on technologies acquired from NeXT. Apple
delivered on that expectation, surprising many attendees with
demos of the Yellow Box, the environment derived from OpenStep
that will occupy center stage under Rhapsody. The Yellow Box was
shown on both PowerPC and Intel hardware including an Intel demo
of the shoot-em-up game Quake (writing to the Yellow Box's Display
PostScript while playing movies in the background), plus PowerPC
demos of QuickDraw 3D and a commercial application from Stone
Design ported from OpenStep in only a few days. Apple wanted to
prove one thing: they had running code, not just promises. The
Unix command line was also seen (to hisses from some attendees),
but Apple stressed it will be hidden in Rhapsody's Unified
release, available only if users want it. The Yellow Box interface
was described as a work in progress, but it already bears some
resemblance to the Mac.
Although the Yellow Box derives directly from OpenStep and
includes NeXT standbys like Display PostScript and Unicode
conversion, Apple plans to add several Macintosh technologies,
including the QuickTime Media Layer (QTML), QuickTime VR,
QuickDraw 3D, ColorSync, QuickDraw GX typography, and the V-Twin
text indexing engine (on which Apple e.g. is based). Although it's
too early to tell what this means, Apple also said all
applications built for the Yellow Box will have some
scriptability, and Yellow Box scripting would be carried as far as
possible toward AppleScript. The Yellow Box will also include
NeXT's much-touted WebObjects FrameWorks and Java.
Apple confirmed it plans to ship a version of Rhapsody for
computers based on Intel chips; however (and this was arguably the
big announcement for WWDC), Apple also announced it will ship a
version of the Yellow Box for Mac OS.
To understand this, think of the Yellow Box as an application
environment, like its predecessor OpenStep, rather than as a
component of Rhapsody's larger operating system. Yellow Boxes for
Intel and Mac OS would in theory make the Yellow Box the premiere
choice for cross-platform development, because developers could
deliver applications that run on Rhapsody (both PowerPC and
Intel), Mac OS, Windows NT, and Windows 95 - all using tools
derived from NeXT's highly regarded, object-oriented development
environment. According to Apple, an application written for the
Yellow Box can simply be recompiled for a different platform, or
even shipped as a single, large file containing executable code
for multiple platforms. (Aladdin's Leonard Rosenthol referred to
these programs as "obese binaries.") To hammer home the idea,
Apple also announced no-fee licensing of the technology that
allows the Yellow Box to run on top of Windows, so deploying
Yellow Box applications for Windows won't cost developers extra.
A version of the Yellow Box for the Mac OS is also an intriguing
carrot for some developers. In theory, this would allow users
running today's Mac OS (or future versions, such as Mac OS 8 or
Allegro) to run Yellow Box applications without switching over to
Rhapsody. Although no schedule was given and there are serious
questions about what subset of the Yellow Box can be supported
under Mac OS (threading was mentioned as a significant issue, and
symmetric multiprocessing is right out), the ability to run some
Yellow Box applications under Mac OS may help alleviate transition
fears and give Yellow Box applications a wider market.
**Rhapsody & Blue Box** -- Apple also demonstrated Rhapsody's Blue
Box running a beta of Mac OS 8, and hosted hands-on labs where
developers could run Mac OS programs under Rhapsody's Blue Box.
According to Apple, only five of about 500 programs tested in the
WWDC labs failed due to errors with the Blue Box.
The Blue Box is essentially a Yellow Box application designed to
run under Rhapsody for PowerPC. (Rhapsody for Intel will not
include the Blue Box.) The Blue Box uses a Mac ROM image to run
the Mac OS unmodified, so users can run unaltered Mac OS
applications and system enhancements with much more compatibility
than Copland would have provided. The Blue Box should inherit
benefits from Rhapsody, including enhanced virtual memory and I/O
improvements. Although Mac applications will not get separate
protected memory, crashing the Blue Box will not take down
Rhapsody. However, as an application, the Blue Box will run in its
own window, and Mac applications will not sit in the same screen
space as Yellow Box applications. Blue Box programs will be able
to communicate with the Yellow Box via Apple events and more
traditional mechanisms like the clipboard, but there will be a
firm line between the Mac OS and the Yellow Box. The Blue Box will
be able to run in a full-screen mode (and Apple reps noted this
included _all_ screens), but I have the impression using the Blue
Box will be like peering through a magnifying glass at your old
Macintosh.
**Java** -- During the WWDC keynote, new Senior VP of Software
Engineering Avie Tevanian called Java Apple's biggest opportunity.
It's not clear how many Apple developers share that opinion, but
Apple proved it can make grand statements about Java as well as
the next software company, announcing support for the Java
Foundation Classes under development by Sun, Netscape, and IBM,
and simultaneously announcing Java would have full access to
Yellow Box APIs, thereby making it possible to write Yellow Box
applications without resorting to Objective C or other programming
languages. Although Apple stressed its commitment to "100 percent
pure Java," it also stressed access to the Yellow Box would allow
developers to deploy best-of-class Java applications, which sounds
similar to what Microsoft tells developers about its competing
Application Foundation Classes for Java.
**The Rhapsody Schedule** -- Currently, the Rhapsody schedule
calls for a developer release in mid-1997 (with no Blue Box, and
probably only supporting Power Mac 8500/8600 machines), a Premiere
release for early adopters in early 1998 with some Blue Box
capability for PowerPC, and a Unified release for general users in
mid-1998 with full Blue Box capability for PowerPC. Apple plans to
ship client and server versions of Rhapsody and has stated that
the Unified release will work on today's PowerPC-based Macs and
Mac clones.
**The Spin** -- There's no doubt that Rhapsody's potential is
compelling. Developers and conference attendees I spoke with were
generally surprised with Apple's progress so far, although
opinions differed radically as to whether Apple could deliver on
its ambitious schedule. For some developers, Rhapsody is simply
too late: they needed mature cross-platform development tools over
a year ago, not a promise they'll be available a year from now. On
the other hand, some developers seemed incredibly energized by
Apple's plans, including some makers of low-level tools and
utilities for whom Rhapsody is an enormous technical challenge.
However, the gulf between NeXT and Apple cultures is still
apparent. Steve Jobs managed to insult or offend many Mac
developers in his WWDC fireside chat, and occasional comments from
former NeXT employees during WWDC sessions highlighted the
differences. This is an over-generalization, but NeXT customers
tend to deal with high-end, often corporate environments with
abundant bandwidth and CPU resources, while Mac customers are
possessive about their machines and are more likely to think about
sharing a single CD-ROM drive across a high school's LocalTalk
network. Whether a healthy medium can be achieved in either
Apple's software engineering teams or Rhapsody remains to be seen.
For more details and announcements from WWDC, check Apple's
Developer World site; WWDC Webcasts are available until 31-May-97.
John Norstad has also posted excellent notes on Rhapsody based on
what he learned at WWDC.
<http://devworld.apple.com/>
<http://charlotte.acns.nwu.edu/jln/wwdc97.html>
A Spreadsheet for the Millennium
--------------------------------
by Matt Neuburg <[email protected]>
At a time when Apple and the Macintosh seem to be whirling in
fragments around my head, the release of Spreadsheet 2000 from
Casady & Greene has given my spirits a much needed lift. It is a
powerful, flexible, interesting way to store and retrieve
information (in this case, numerical information, along with
calculations). That, as longtime TidBITS readers know, goes right
to the heart of what I want from my Mac. The light-hearted
interface shows that there is still room for originality on the
Mac. It is easy to learn: you do the tutorials, you grok the
metaphor, and from then on it's completely intuitive. It was
basically written by Steve Wilson of Emergent Behavior,
reaffirming the place of small developers. And, the fact that
Spreadsheet 2000 was written with Prograph CPX, my favorite Mac
development environment (see TidBITS-312_), is a delightful bonus.
<http://www.casadyg.com/C&G/Welcome.html>
Spreadsheet 2000, officially abbreviated S2K, is actually version
2.0 of Let's Keep It Simple Spreadsheet, officially abbreviated
Let's KISS, or LKISS, or just plain KISS.
**Go With the Dataflow** -- A spreadsheet is a place where,
typically, numbers live, some of which are the result of live
calculations using others. For instance, in recording a budget,
altering or adding a figure in a column of food-related
expenditures for the month might automatically change entries for
the month's food total, the month's grand total, and the year-to-
date grand total.
In most spreadsheet programs, this is done through hidden
formulas. You are presented with a blank grid of cells, into each
of which you can put either a number or a formula describing a
calculation based on other cells. A cell containing a formula,
though, shows only the result of the formula's calculation. That
number can then be used in still other formulas, and so on. This
means that you must learn a formula language, which is often
difficult. More important, it means that a spreadsheet is hard to
explore and easy to harm: since you cannot usually see the
formulas (and even when you can, it is hard to trace a cell's
formulaic dependencies), you may accidentally make a change that
causes a formula to give a bad result, or one that overwrites a
formula altogether.
Spreadsheet 2000 is nothing like this. Instead, you are presented
with a completely empty window. Into this window you place, by
drag & drop from palettes, any of a number of objects, and by
dragging arrange them as you like, much as in a drawing program.
These objects are principally either rectangular grids of cells,
or operators (such as "+", "*", "avg", and so on) represented as
small named rectangular panels. You then click to draw connecting
lines leading from grids to operators, and from operators to other
grids ("output" grids). You can put numbers into the cells of
grids - but not if they are output grids (output grids
automatically take on a different color). So, the results of
calculations are specially marked and automatically protected.
Also, the structure of each calculation is visible as a physical
flow of data: from an input grid or grids, through an operator, to
an output grid.
The chain of grid-operator-grid can be extended as long you like;
a grid may serve as input to more than one operator, and an
operator may require input from more than one grid. To prevent a
clutter of such chains from tangling up like spaghetti, you can
select a segment of chain and "crunch" it, replacing it by a
single custom operator. If you double-click the custom operator,
an edit window opens and displays the grids and operators you
crunched. You can work in this edit window, rearranging elements,
altering data, modifying calculations, and even crunching segments
of chain within it, too. By judicious naming and arrangement of
crunched custom operators, you can create visual calculation
structures which remain neat and easy to understand; yet the
details remain available by quickly drilling down, opening the
edit windows of custom operators to any desired level.
Spreadsheet 2000 also provides a second way to avoid clutter. This
is called a report, though I prefer to think of it as a view,
since it's really another way of looking at particular portions of
your data. The main window (called the Master) is replaced by one
containing just a designated subset of elements: typically, one
window might show two or three chief grids, with no operators or
connections at all. A document can have many different named
reports, listed in a Report menu, and at any given moment you see
either one report or the Master (which is another reason I call
them views). How you use reports is up to you. You can enter data
in a report, so when a calculation involves a lot of bits of data,
multiple reports can provide multiple entry forms. They are also
good places to summarize the grand results of a calculation.
I mentioned earlier that spreadsheet elements are added by drag &
drop from palettes. You may create your own palettes to store
elements you might need later (libraries, in other words). Such
elements might range from a complicated, crunched custom
calculation that generates histogram information to a simple,
frequently needed grid of data or an empty 12-row grid labelled
with the names of the months.
Spreadsheets can also contain special elements, such as charts
that automatically show simple but effective graphs of any grid
connected to them. There are also notes - simple text rectangles
useful for placing comments and instructions - and graphics. These
can all be arranged as desired, of course.
**True Grid** -- All data entry and display is, as already stated,
by way of grids. You can type data directly into a grid cell, and
of course you can cut and paste data between grids and another
applications (S2K does some intelligent processing of clipboard
contents); you can also export grid data as tab-delimited text
files.
A grid can be resized to any rectangular dimensions in terms of
the cells it contains: it can be a single cell, a single column, a
single row, or a full rectangle. Labels can be attached to any
grid's top, side, or both, letting you specify what each column or
row denotes; with output grids you can attach labels yourself, or
tell an operator to allow its input's labels to "flow through," so
that the operator's output grid reproduces them.
The display of numeric data can be formatted by dragging &
dropping a formatting icon onto it; various basic formatting icons
live in a toolbar at the top of the screen, or you can tear off a
formatting palette which lets you be more specific about things
like the number of decimal places to be displayed. Text formatting
works similarly, or you can choose from a Text menu. S2K enforces
formatting consistency: you can numerically format a whole grid or
selected columns, or textually format a whole grid or all top or
side labels, but not individual cells.
One of Spreadsheet 2000's cleverest features is the intelligent
behavior of its operators with respect to grids. Take, for
example, the "+" operator: what it does depends on the shape you
give its output grid. Imagine you have a 5-by-4 grid of numbers
connected into a "+" operator. If the "+" operator is then
connected to a single-cell grid, that cell will display the sum of
all 20 input cells. If it is connected to a single-row grid, that
grid is automatically resized to 5-by-1, and displays the sum of
each column of the input. If it is connected to a single-column
grid, that grid is automatically resized to 1-by-4, and displays
the sum of each row of the input.
Other operators that take multiple inputs react to the shapes of
those inputs. For instance, the "A+B" operator, which adds two
inputs, will add two single-column grids by making the output a
single column each of whose cells contains the sum of the
corresponding pair of cells. It will add a rectangle grid to a
single-column grid by making a rectangle grid, summing
corresponding pairs of cells one column at a time. It will add a
single-column grid to a single-row grid by making a rectangle
grid, each cell containing one of the possible sums of pairs. And
so on.
The extraordinary thing is that, although this sounds very
involved when I describe it, in action it is immediately obvious
and intuitive. S2K gives you a sense of doing the right thing, of
knowing what you mean (often better than you do yourself!).
**Spreadsheet Icing** -- Native operators include standard numeric
functions (arithmetic, trigonometric, exponential, rounding), and
"form" operators act as a shortcut in the composition of
elementary algebraic expressions; basic statistical functions
(such as average and standard deviation) are included too. Grid
operators let you count cells, columns, and rows; combine or
decompose grids; copy, rotate, and sort grids; and extract grid
parts by various match criteria. Logical operators let you perform
Boolean tests and even build "if-then-else" constructs. Loop
operators generate automatic fill data, and let you construct
cumulatively computed output grids (such as a running bank
balance).
These operators turn out to be sufficient for most needs; the
trick, when you want to build a new function, is getting used to
the dataflow model, which works differently from an algebraic
language. To help you, a large selection of pre-built custom
operators is included; these can be used as shortcuts, and (being
constructed from the native operators) they are also valuable
study models. They range from simple unit conversions and physical
constants to arithmetic representations of complex numbers,
polynomial roots, primeness test, Fibonacci series, pseudo-random
number generation, linear regression, and various financial
operators - enough to prove that S2K's dataflow language is pretty
powerful (especially considering its lack of recursion).
Many model solutions are also included in the form of stationery
and other files. Again, the wide range testifies to Spreadsheet
2000's power: break-even and depreciation, budget and car leasing,
triangle solution, Fourier sine wave addition, numeric integration
by Simpson's rule, a gradebook, even baseball statistics. More
user-created templates can be found on Casady & Greene's Web site.
<http://www.casadyg.com/C&G/Products/spreadsheet_2000/Solutions/
solutions.html>
The manual, unfortunately, fails to document any of this (except
for the native operators). Otherwise, though, it is quite nice: it
consists mostly of chatty tutorials and general advice, followed
by some lightly written reference material, which is all you need
because the program is easy to use once you've done the tutorials.
There is also good balloon help, plus some Apple Guides.
**The Magic Draggin'** -- If I have one overall complaint about
Spreadsheet 2000, it is that the program is strongly mouse-
oriented. I like dragging & dropping as much as the next person
(and S2K's optional sound effects add to the fun), but the program
calls for more physical dexterity than I possess and more reaching
hither and yon than I have patience for.
I've made this and several other suggestions to S2K author Steve
Wilson - such things as having crunched operators' edit windows
remember their size and position next time they're opened, and an
optional dialog to make it easier to size a grid. His receptive
attitude suggests that, with constructive suggestions from users,
S2K's future incarnations will be even better.
Having exhausted my feeble supply of negatives, I'll reiterate:
Spreadsheet 2000 is a fine program. It seems rock solid (I haven't
been able to make it choke or crash); its behavior is intuitive
and convenient. It has those direct, simple, Mac-defining
qualities that come along once in a blue moon, giving it the
potential to be a classic. It performs a powerful, basic function,
yet is easy to learn, and satisfying and fun to use. In my opinion
it is the everyday spreadsheet that every Mac owner must have.
**Hot Off the Grid** -- A splendid QuickTime movie showing S2K in
action can be found on Casady & Greene's Web site (200K), along
with demo versions of S2K for both 68K and PowerPC-based Macs (a
little over 2 MB):
<http://www.casadyg.com/C&G/Products/spreadsheet_2000/S2Kmov.html>
In our checking, the street price for Spreadsheet 2000 ranged from
$60 to $75, and there's currently a $30 rebate if you own another
spreadsheet. The LKISS upgrade is $20 (free if purchased in 1997).
<http://www.casadyg.com/C&G/Products/spreadsheet_2000/description.html>
**DealBITS** -- Through the URL below, Cyberian Outpost is
offering TidBITS readers Spreadsheet 2000 for $54.95, which is $5
off the standard price.
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/spreadsheet-2000.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|
391.281 | Issue #382 | DPE1::ARMSTRONG | | Tue Jun 03 1997 08:39 | 604 |
|
TidBITS#382/02-Jun-97
=====================
Tune in this week for a review of the popular email client program
Claris Emailer 2.0, plus Adam's thoughts on the benefits of
smaller Mac fairs in comparison to large trade shows. Also, we
note the need for ongoing vigilance against Macintosh viruses,
welcome a Portuguese TidBITS translation, give pointers to an
Apple Internet Solutions guide, and offer news on NetObjects
Fusion and upgrading some Global Village modem cards.
Topics:
MailBITS/02-Jun-97
The Little Mac Fairs
Wrestling in the Global Village
Email Reliance: Emailer 2.0
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/TidBITS-382.html>
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/1997/TidBITS#382_02-Jun-97.etx>
Copyright 1997 TidBITS Electronic Publishing. All rights reserved.
Information: <[email protected]> Comments: <[email protected]>
---------------------------------------------------------------
This issue of TidBITS sponsored in part by:
* APS Technologies -- 800/443-4199 -- <[email protected]>
Makers of M*Power Mac OS compatibles & premium storage devices.
APS price lists: <http://www.apstech.com/aps-products.html>
* Northwest Nexus -- 800/539-3505 -- <http://www.nwnexus.com/>
Professional Internet Services. <[email protected]>
* Power Computing -- 800/375-7693 -- <[email protected]>
PowerTower Pro 225 MHz - the fastest desktop system ever.
Build Your Own Box online! <http://www.powercc.com/>
* Aladdin Systems -- 408/761-6200 -- <http://www.aladdinsys.com/>
Makers of StuffIt Deluxe 4.0, the Mac compression standard, and
InstallerMaker 3.1.3, the leading installer for Mac developers.
* Small Dog Electronics -- Special deal for TidBITS Readers! <----- NEW!
NEW Message Pad 2000 with keyboard, spreadsheet and case: $1049
More Info: <http://www.smalldoggy.com/#tid> -- 802/496-7171
* StarNine Technologies -- 800/525-2580 -- <[email protected]>
Top Internet tools: WebSTAR, WebCollage, ListSTAR, and more.
WebCollage is shipping! <http://www.starnine.com/webcollage/>
* MacWorks -- 800/463-1026 -- <[email protected]> <--------------- NEW!
CLOSEOUT SPECIAL: Limited quantity of Apple 604/120, only $49
More Info: <http://www.macworks.com/>
---------------------------------------------------------------
MailBITS/02-Jun-97
------------------
**Virus Complacency** -- Though there are few Macintosh viruses
(especially in comparison to the PC world), in the last few weeks
I've received several reports of virus-infected CD-ROMs or files
(the most recent one an upload caught by alert Info-Mac archivist
Michael Bean). Although all the viruses were old and easily
handled by John Norstad's free Disinfectant 3.6, I believe many
Macintosh users have been lulled into complacency by the minimal
virus problems of late. In addition, many people have become Mac
users in the last few years, and thus missed the era when most
Macintosh viruses appeared. Most existing Macintosh viruses aren't
particularly dangerous, but it's always worth running an anti-
virus program. For more information on the different viruses, read
Disinfectant's excellent online manual by selecting Disinfectant
Help from the Apple menu. If you feel like spending money (we at
TidBITS recommend and use Disinfectant), check out commercial
virus protection software like Symantec AntiVirus for Macintosh
and Datawatch's Virex for Macintosh. [ACE]
<ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/tisk/util/disinfectant-36.hqx>
<http://www.symantec.com/sam/index.html>
<http://www.datawatch.com/virex.shtml>
**TidBITS in Portuguese!** We're especially pleased to welcome our
latest translation of TidBITS, this time into Portuguese. If you
or someone you know would prefer to read TidBITS in Portuguese,
check out the Web page below. Special thanks are due to Henrique
Penha <[email protected]>, who put together a team of six
translators and is coordinating the effort. More volunteers would
be extremely welcome, so if you're interested in helping, send
Henrique email.
As always, let me know at <[email protected]> if you want to help
with any TidBITS translation. We've had some interest in Italian
and Russian translations but have lacked either a strong
coordinator to get things rolling or enough translators to make
the amount of work manageable. [ACE]
<http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/lang/pt/>
**New Fusion Version** -- NetObjects Fusion 1.0, software for
creating Web sites, shipped in late 1996 and blazed new ground
with its site-centric emphasis, including easily changed site
styles for text, graphics, and navigation bars. Like the soon-to-
be-released Adobe SiteMill 2.0 (look for more information next
week), Fusion makes it easy to modify a site's structure, and like
the recently-released CyberStudio 1.0 from GoLive Systems (see
TidBITS-376_), NetObjects Fusion used tables behind the scenes to
enable users to place objects on Web pages freely.
Great ideas take time to refine into practical implementations,
and last week NetObjects shipped Fusion 2.0, a new version that -
by way of a casual look - has matured significantly. The new
version has many new features including a spelling checker,
support for Macintosh drag & drop, better support for frames, and
the capability to import existing sites as a whole, instead of
page-by-page. A 30-day trial version is available (as a 14.5 MB
download) from the NetObjects Web site.
<http://www.netobjects.com/downloads/softwaredownload.html>
Fusion 2.0 is still rather stout: the new version requires a
PowerPC-based Macintosh, wants 16 MB application RAM, and a full
install takes a startling 90 MB of disk space. The expected retail
price for Fusion 2.0 is $495; inside the box is a coupon for a
$100 rebate, good through 31-Jul-97. NetObjects -- 415/482-3200 --
415/562-0288 (fax) -- <[email protected]> [TJE]
**Macintosh Internet Solutions Resource** -- Starfish
Technologies, an Australian consulting firm specializing in Mac
OS, Unix, and internetworking, has prepared a useful overview to
Macintosh Internet solutions. Originally commissioned for use by
Apple resellers in Australia, Apple Australia has made the guide
available for anyone needing solid information about Macs and the
Internet. It's great to see Apple's overseas divisions
contributing to the international Macintosh community in this way.
Software developers who wish to have their Internet-related
products (commercial, shareware, or freeware) included should
contact <[email protected]>, and anyone interested in other
comprehensive collections of Macintosh Internet resources should
check out the Web sites below. [ACE]
<http://www.apple.com.au/GSAIS/>
<http://www.starfish.net.au/>
<http://host.comvista.com/Internet.tfm>
<http://www.netprolive.com/products/productDefault.html>
<http://www.cen.uiuc.edu/~wronkiew/macos_servers/>
The Little Mac Fairs
--------------------
by Adam C. Engst <[email protected]>
Recently, Tonya and I have attended and spoken at two relatively
small Macintosh fairs, BMUG's one-day MacFest in Berkeley and
LAMG's two-day MacFair in Los Angeles. Both have been around for a
number of years, and both were obviously extremely popular, given
the crowds (BMUG's MacFest hit 7,500 in attendance). Afterwards,
we found ourselves comparing them favorably to the full-bore
Macworld Expos in San Francisco and Boston.
<http://www.lamg.org/>
<http://www.bmug.org/>
**Macworld Expo Overload** -- Macworld Expos are no longer as
necessary for learning about new products, in large part because
the Internet has improved communications about those new products.
It's occasionally useful to see a demo, but I can generally learn
more in 15 minutes on my own than by watching a typical hour-long
demonstration. The conferences at Macworld Expos can be
worthwhile, but, since speakers aren't paid, the quality ranges
widely. And, let's face it, Macworld Expos are incredibly
draining. You're on your feet in a large city for 16 hours a day
for three or four days, and there's just too much stimulation.
Everyone's shouting, everyone wants you to see their products, try
their products, buy their products, and you can't even walk on the
streets without having Expo-related brochures shoved in your
hands.
Sure, going to a Macworld Expo is a thrill, but many of us have
figured out better and cheaper ways to get our thrills that don't
involve injury to the lower extremities. At computer shows I'm
more interested in meeting people, catching up with email friends,
chatting with people who read TidBITS or my books, and generally
getting out a little, something us work-at-home types don't do all
that often.
**The Small Fair Solution** -- For those purposes, smaller
regional Macintosh fairs turn out to be just the ticket. The show
floors occupy the space of a large hotel ballroom, not the dual
halls of San Francisco's Moscone Center, which are roughly the
size of Rhode Island (and don't get me started about travelling
between the vast halls at the World Trade Center and Bayside in
Boston). The regional shows have plenty of people, but not so many
that your personal space is constantly compromised. It's easy to
walk the floor at these smaller shows and spend time at each
booth, or to browse through quickly looking for someone. The
booths tend to be relatively spartan, which is refreshing after
the expensive, often spurious extravagance of Macworld Expo
booths. John O'Fallon, president of Maxum Development, concurred,
saying, "Putting everyone in a simple 10' by 10' booth without a
lot of glitz is nice. It keeps the cost down and lets everyone
focus on products instead of stage shows."
<http://www.maxum.com/>
Better yet, the booths are often staffed by people who know
something, another pleasant change from the well-groomed, yet
frequently clueless marketing denizens of Macworld Expos. That's
in part due to the preponderance of smaller companies at the
smaller fairs, but both shows had representatives from larger
companies as well, including Apple. Sheer numbers of vendors don't
compare to Macworld Expos, but even still, MacFest sported 43
vendors this year, and hopes to hit 50 next year. My impression
was that LAMG's MacFair had even more vendors on its somewhat
larger show floor.
The vendors I spoke with afterwards, including folks from Maxum
Development, APS Technologies, Sonic Systems, and Dantz
Development, seemed happy with the response they'd gotten,
although the user group audience wasn't always a perfect mesh. As
John O'Fallon noted, "User group members don't buy Internet
servers as often as business customers, not surprisingly. We'll be
watching for similar small shows with emphasis on business or the
Internet. There are several of these we have done already
(Mactivity, StrictlyBusiness) with varying degrees of success."
Another nice aspect of the small user group fairs that we attended
was that they were inexpensive, not just for vendors, but also for
attendees. Conferences can easily cost $200 to $800 these days,
and that's before travel and hotel costs. BMUG's MacFest was free
to the public, although they requested a $5 donation. LAMG's
MacFair wasn't free, but it was inexpensive in comparison with
Macworld Expos, which cost may only $25 for access to the floor
but $170 for access to the conferences, keynotes and sessions (all
of which were included at MacFair). Despite being inexpensive,
both BMUG and LAMG were extremely pleased with the financial boost
the fairs provided.
**Some Thoughts** -- I mentioned this topic while chatting at my
favorite local Macintosh dealer, Westwind Computing, and the
president immediately expressed interest in having a fair here in
Seattle. Needless to say, he wasn't up for organizing it on his
own, but volunteered on the spot to help line up vendors. With
some coordination from dBUG, the local Macintosh users group, and
the local Apple office, a small local Mac fair in Seattle isn't
inconceivable. And, if BMUG and LAMG can put on these kind of
fairs, and merely mentioning the possibility in Seattle can
produce such a reaction, I can only assume that other parts of the
country and the world could do the same. Each show would carry the
flavor of the group that organized it, so some might focus more on
desktop and high-end publishing, whereas others might be more
Internet-related.
<http://www.westwind.com/>
<http://www.dbug.org/>
These fairs need not be difficult to put on. Colleen Miller of
BMUG noted that organizing MacFest didn't require a massive staff.
"I put the entire thing on myself with the help of Sean O'Connor
and, on the day of the event, numerous volunteers. Just about
everything went smoothly. The key to running such an event is
starting early and making sure you're incredibly organized. Also,
press, marketing, and a combination of big name companies and new,
cutting edge companies are key to making sure you get attendance."
I don't want to imply that the huge Macworld Expos don't have
their place. Bringing together tens of thousands of Macintosh
users and hundreds of vendors is useful. The big shows help
vendors meet distributors outside the U.S., network with other
developers, and get in front of the press (although I think the
traditional press would appreciate the smaller fairs if complaints
from fellow journalists are any indication). However, a short,
sweet, small Mac fair can be a breath of fresh air. As Colleen
Miller said, "Accessibility, cost, and a general feeling of
camaraderie make the smaller events much better."
Wrestling in the Global Village
-------------------------------
by Glenn Fleishman <[email protected]>
I recently spent some time wrestling with software upgrades, and
discovered some hidden morsels in a couple of Global Village
downloads. Although some of these enhancements have been available
for a while, I chose to wait and bulk-update my PowerBook in one
session. If you use a PowerPort Platinum or Platinum Pro PC card,
Global Village has a firmware update that upgrades the 28.8 Kbps
modem to 33.6 Kbps. Additionally, they've released a beta version
of the PowerPort PC Card control panel that temporarily fixes a
"port busy" error when using Open Transport/PPP (see
TidBITS-354_). The following assumes you're using Open Transport
1.1 (1.1.2 is the latest version) and System 7.5.5 or later.
<http://www.globalvillage.com/support/swlocator/pplocator.html>
**PC Card Updater** -- The PowerPort PC Card update is a 1.2 MB
download containing an application that updates the PC Card's
firmware. Firmware is software that lives in some kind of
persistent memory; unlike RAM, turning off electricity doesn't
erase the contents, but (unlike ROM) applying certain charges or
triggering a pin on the chip allows new code to be installed. The
new Global Village firmware adds the protocols and routines
necessary to support 33.6 Kbps modem speeds - that is, if you have
a phone line and provider that can support it. (Now that I'm
updated, I get 31.2 Kbps consistently, which is almost 10 percent
faster than 28.8 Kbps).
If you use OT/PPP (which I highly recommend), the 33.6 Kbps update
also comes with a modem script that you must use. Copy the script
"GV 28.8/33.6 for ARA 2.1/OT-PPP" to the Modem Scripts folder in
your Extensions folder, and then use the Modem control panel to
select the new script. Otherwise, OT/PPP will not recognize the
new speed and won't initiate PPP correctly.
<http://devworld.apple.com/dev/opentransport/ppp.html>
**PC Card OT/PPP Beta** -- The beta PowerPort PC Card control
panel fixes the "port busy" problem that's been reported
frequently by folks using the PowerPort PC Card with OT/PPP.
Essentially, the problem causes the Mac OS to think another
application is using the serial port, which prevents you from
using your modem. I've had this problem for months off and on, and
the only solution I found was to turn off RAM Doubler 2 (or vary
the amount of extra RAM it was adding) and reboot. Although the
port problem has nothing to do with Connectix's software, this
worked fairly consistently for me. The new PowerPort PC Card
control panel has alleviated this problem for me entirely.
**Snooze & Lose** -- Even though I've given Global Village my
email address with multiple product registrations, I never
received email notification of either piece of software, both of
which are available free of charge. This seems like a missed
opportunity for Global Village; I was ecstatic to get a free
update that gave me 33.6 Kbps capability, and being able to access
my serial port consistently without rebooting is a godsend. In the
future, I hope Global Village will take advantage of its customer
email lists to notify us of tremendous time savers like these two
downloads. I'm pulling out less hair already.
Email Reliance: Emailer 2.0
---------------------------
by Jeff Carlson <[email protected]>
I'm surprised at how much I rely on electronic mail. What used to
be just another method of communicating has become my main link to
the outside world, my to-do list, and a searchable database of
projects. On top of that, email enables me to communicate
regularly (and inexpensively) with my mother in Sacramento,
California, my father in Redmond, Washington, and a collection of
friends around the world.
This reliance on electronic communication calls for heavy-duty
email software. After using Claris Emailer 1.1v3 for a year and
living with some of its limitations, I was eager to try Emailer
2.0. What I've discovered since is a full-featured program with
few shortcomings.
<http://www.claris.com/products/claris/emailer/>
**A Brief Overview** -- The great benefit of using Emailer when it
first came out was its capability to handle multiple email
accounts. Although one America Online account may be fine for a
beginning user, more people now access and manage email from
multiple sources. Emailer allows you to send and receive standard
Internet mail using POP and SMTP, plus email via CompuServe, AOL,
the now-defunct Claris OfficeMail, and RadioMail.
Emailer not only lets you connect to any combination of the above
at once (including multiple addresses on any service) but also
lets you schedule unattended mail checks. Impatient types can set
Emailer to check for mail every two minutes, while calmer users
can schedule bulk sends and receives in the middle of the night,
or even at designated times on certain days.
Emailer offers a range of encoding and compression options for
sending attachments to other computers using different operating
systems. Email messages can be composed offline for later
transmission, or saved as drafts until you're ready to send them.
Emailer also supports Internet Config, which stores your main
Internet settings in one location accessible by a number of
applications (like Anarchie and Microsoft Internet Explorer).
<http://www.quinn.echidna.id.au/Quinn/Config/>
**My Hard Drive is Back!** One of the biggest shortcomings of
Emailer 1.x is the way it stores messages. It saves each message
as an individual file, which can inadvertently consume a huge
chunk of disk space. The Mac file system divides a hard disk into
64,000-odd pieces, each of which can be occupied by only one file,
or one part of a larger file. On a sizable hard disk (say, 2 GB),
that means the _minimum_ amount of space allocated for any file is
32K - even if that file contains only one character! If you have
hundreds (or thousands) of small files, that lost space adds up
quickly. And if you store hundreds of messages in Emailer 1.x, you
might start to believe that a 2 GB hard disk isn't very large.
Emailer 2.0 saves all mail in a main Mail Database file, with a
Mail Index file that tracks it. After upgrading to 2.0, a friend
of mine reported that he reclaimed about 85 MB from the reduced
file overhead alone!
Storing messages in a centralized database also improves
performance, since Emailer must open and close far fewer files.
Emailer 2.0 can perform multiple simultaneous searches for words,
and although the search speed isn't as fast as I would like, I no
longer have to go make coffee while conducting search.
If you switch from 1.x to 2.0, I cannot stress too highly the
importance of making a backup of your mail files and reading the
instructions that come with the program. If you don't follow them
to the letter, you may lose data.
For me, the only problem the switch has caused involves
synchronizing my mail between the PowerBook and my desktop
machine. Where before I had to copy only the added or changed
email files, usually no more than 20K each, now I must copy one 25
MB mail database each time. Since I regularly synchronize the two
machines, I bought a relatively inexpensive 4-port network hub to
create a two-machine Ethernet network at home.
**Adjusting to the New Look** -- Because I had grown comfortable
with the interface in Emailer 1.x, the split-window approach of
version 2.0 required some adjustment on my part. Along its left
side, the main Browser window displays folders such as In Box and
Out Box, plus user-created folders; the contents of the selected
folder show on the right. On smaller screens this can feel
cramped, requiring experimentation with resizing the message
columns - Subject, From/To, Date, Priority - and the vertical bar
separating the two main sections. If you prefer to not have email
folders and messages parceled within the Browser, you can also
open folders as their own windows.
Emailer also has a floating Toolbar window containing buttons for
common commands and a floating Connection Status window. For users
who don't want to interpret icons, positioning the cursor over a
button displays a label that names the button. I'm more oriented
toward keyboard shortcuts, so I chose to reclaim precious screen
real estate by hiding the Toolbar.
Emailer's new interface has dozens of smaller adjustments that
demonstrate the engineers at Claris thought about how people use
the product. For example, managing multiple accounts is now
easier. Under Emailer 1.x, if I wanted to send a message to a
number of people from <[email protected]> instead of
<[email protected]>, I had to specify my From address manually for
each recipient. In version 2.0, a single pop-up menu allows me to
choose from which account all the recipients will receive the
mail.
**Filing a Mass of Email** -- A welcome addition to Emailer 2.0 is
its increased flexibility when working with mail folders. You can
now create sub-folders within folders, and rename them from the
Folder menu. I currently have 56 mail folders, so being able to
nest my Article Ideas folder under a main TidBITS folder helps me
stay organized and reduces visual clutter.
Each email message includes a pop-up File icon, allowing you to
file it in a mail folder quickly. A similar button appears on the
Toolbar. You can also drag & drop a message to its intended
folder, or (my favorite) press Command-Option-F to bring up a
dialog listing folders, select the one you want, and press Return.
One nice touch is if you file a message while it's still open, the
message window stays onscreen until you close it.
**Prioritizing Actions** -- The most difficult thing about email
is organizing and categorizing what lands in the In Box. Emailer's
Priorities and Actions features allows me to at least pretend that
I have some control over the bulk of mail that arrives every day.
Mail Actions act as filters for incoming mail, and are, in my
opinion, invaluable. Emailer 2.0's Actions have been beefed up
from the previous version, adding more options for examining your
mail and executing commands based on what it finds. For example,
I've set up an informal mailing list for eSCENE, an electronic
magazine I edit in my spare time. Whenever anyone sends me a
message with "yesmail" as the Subject, Emailer files their message
in an eSCENE folder I've created, then automatically sends a
confirmation to the sender. I could also choose to automatically
add email addresses to my Address Book, forward a message, print a
message, add or remove a sender from an Address Group, or run a
designated AppleScript. All without a moment's intervention from
me.
<http://www.escene.org/>
I use Actions primarily to prioritize incoming mail. Any message
can be marked as one of 19 user-defined priorities (Emailer
reserves the twentieth for alerts) that can be assigned separate
colors. When I receive a piece of email from Adam, Tonya, or
Geoff, the message appears in my In Box marked "TidBITS" and
colored purple. My other clients have separate colors, and some
items (such as press releases) get filed in designated folders for
later perusal. By prioritizing the email in my In Box, I can
respond to it faster and file the messages in folders.
One notable improvement over version 1.x's automatic filing
feature is that Emailer 2.0 tracks unread messages that have been
filed. A small envelope appears on folders that contain unread
messages, and the folder names appear in bold. From the Mail menu,
via the Go to New Mail submenu, you can jump directly to folders
with unread mail.
Recently, Fog City Software (the original developer of Emailer)
released a set of Mail Actions that attempt to block unsolicited
email ("spam") by checking incoming email against a list of
domains known for sending large amounts of unsolicited email.
Although unsolicited email is a complex topic (see TidBITS-347_
for a primer) and I can't vouch for how effective these Mail
Actions will be, they might be worth a try if you are tired of
receiving email about how to make a billion dollars without even
changing out of your pajamas.
<http://www.fogcity.com/em_utilities2.0.html>
**The King of Address Books and Other Features** -- Without a
doubt, Emailer's Address Book rates as one of its coolest
features. Not only can you store names and email addresses, but
searching is a breeze. When you begin typing in the Filter field,
the list dynamically narrows as it finds strings matching what
you've typed. In most cases, typing two or three letters narrows
the search to the name you want.
Adding names is also a graceful process. Every incoming email
message includes a plus (+) button next to the From address;
clicking it creates a new entry, with first name, last name, email
address, and account filled in. You can also drag & drop an email
address onto the Address Book window to create a new entry, or
even drop a text file containing a list of email addresses to
create a set of new entries at once.
Other improvements include enhanced AppleScript support and
integration (including a separate AppleScript menu and sample
scripts such as Speak Unread Mail), and a spelling checker that,
ironically, flagged "email" and offered no alternative. Also, a
fairly comprehensive, context-sensitive online Help system is now
standard fare.
**Reliable** -- There are still a few things that I'd like to see
changed: Emailer doesn't support redirected mail like Eudora;
pressing Command-D in an open message deletes that message unless
you're viewing an Auto File Log, which you must delete from the
Browser; and if you add an address to a Group, the address in the
Group doesn't update if the original address changes. It would be
nice to be able to select multiple messages in the Browser and
save them to a single text file. But these are minor details that
I've largely been able to route around. As someone who relies
heavily on email, I'm impressed and relieved that I can rely on
Emailer to handle it.
Emailer 2.0 requires a 68020-based Macintosh or newer, System 7.1
or higher, 9 MB disk space, and 2 to 3 MB RAM. Claris gave Emailer
an "estimated street price" of $49, and - in my checking - the
street price ranges from $45 to $50. Claris is offering a $10
rebate on upgrades from 1.x, and to owners of various other Apple
software. Claris also has a downloadable demo weighing in at about
4.1 MB.
<ftp://ftp.claris.com/pub/USA-Macintosh/Trial_Software/
ClarisEmailer2.0Trial.bin>
**DealBITS** -- Through the URL below, Cyberian Outpost is
offering TidBITS readers Claris Emailer 2.0 for $42.95, which is
$2 off their normal price.
<http://www.tidbits.com/products/emailer.html>
$$
Non-profit, non-commercial publications may reprint articles if
full credit is given. Others please contact us. We don't guarantee
accuracy of articles. Caveat lector. Publication, product, and
company names may be registered trademarks of their companies.
This file is formatted as setext. For more information send email
to <[email protected]>. A file will be returned shortly.
For information on TidBITS: how to subscribe, where to find back
issues, and other useful stuff, send email to: <[email protected]>
Send comments and editorial submissions to: <[email protected]>
Issues available at: ftp://ftp.tidbits.com/pub/tidbits/issues/
And: http://www.tidbits.com/tb-issues/
To search back issues with WAIS, use this URL via a Web browser:
http://wais.sensei.com.au/macarc/tidbits/searchtidbits.html
-------------------------------------------------------------------
|