Conference smurf::buildhelp

408.0. "Sterling BL7 vs. ODE" by SMURF::FILTER (Automatic Posting Software - mail to flume::puck) Wed Nov 03 1993 09:06

Date Of Receipt: 	 3-NOV-1993 09:03:43.17
From: 	ABYSS::werme "Eric Werme USG"
To: 	abyss::odehelp
CC: 	abyss::werme
Subj: 	Sterling BL7 vs. ODE

I don't know what got into me, but I decided to install Sterling on one of
my RZ25s.  I kept my 1.3 release on another RZ25.  While getting my ODE
envinronment back in shape, I noticed that the Sterling /etc/services
file has this:

kerberos		750/udp		kdc
kerberos_master		751/tcp
passwd_server		752/udp
krb_prop		753/tcp

The kerberos_master and passwd_server entries apparently were from 1.3,
the kerberos and krb_prop entries are new.

My old /etc/services file has:

supfilesrv      871/tcp sup
kerberos        750/tcp kdc
kerberos        750/udp kdc
krb_prop        752/tcp
kerberos_master 754/tcp
kerberos_master 754/udp

The kerberos and kerberos_master entries I installed after I read the
Silver supplement to ode.  (They may have been modified when I ran the
ODE 2.0 setup script.

Note that the port number for kerberos_master and krb_prop do not match!

The ode startup script has this:

    tmp=""
    tmp=`grep "^supfilesrv" /etc/services`
    if [ "X$tmp" = "X" ]
    then
	echo "ERROR: supfilesrv entry missing from /etc/services" > /dev/console
    fi
    tmp=""
    tmp=`grep "^kerberos.*${default_kerberos_svc}" /etc/services`
    if [ "X$tmp" = "X" ]
    then
        echo "ERROR: kerberos entry missing from /etc/services" > /dev/console
    fi
    tmp=`grep "^krb_prop.*${default_kprop_svc}/tcp" /etc/services`
    if [ "X$tmp" = "X" ]
    then
        echo "ERROR: kprop entry missing from /etc/services" > /dev/console
    fi
    tmp=""
    tmp=`grep "^kerberos_master.*${default_kerb_master}" /etc/services`
    if [ "X$tmp" = "X" ]
    then
        echo "ERROR: kerberos_master entry missing from /etc/services" > /dev/console
    fi

So, when I start my Sterling system, I see:

ODE-II Starting Tue Nov  2 16:35:38 EST 1993
ERROR: kprop entry missing from /etc/services
ERROR: kerberos_master entry missing from /etc/services
ODE-II Started Tue Nov  2 16:35:39 EST 1993

I have not tried ODE yet.  I am going to setup my system with the old
port numbers, but I am curious as to why the mismatch exists.  I think
a bug report should be filed against either Sterling or ODE.  Which one should
I pick, or has this been reported already?

	-Ric Werme

P.S.  inittab says:

s3:3:wait:/sbin/rc3 < /dev/console > /dev/console 2>&1

which implies to me that the ose startup script doesn't need to direct its
output to /dev/console.