[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

939.0. "ADABAS->Rdb migration help reqd" by ZPOVC::MICHAELLEE () Wed Jun 19 1991 16:18

    Hi:
    
    I need some info regarding migration of ADABAS DB to RDB on a customer
    VAXcluster running VMS 5.1-1. Appr if someone out there can share
    his/her experience.
    
    
    Rdgs, Mike 
================================================================================
Note 20.1                    Migrate ADABAS to RDB??                      1 of 1
ZPOVC::MICHAELLEE                                    14 lines  19-JUN-1991 04:14
                            -< Need serious help! >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    Hello:
    
    Can someone from CMS please help me in this?
    
    The customer will be evaluating Rdb. They are currently running Natural
    with Adabas as well as Powerhouse with RMS files. I would appr it if
    someone who has experience in database migration to share it. How
    should the works order be drawn up? What would be the
    measurables/deliverables for the migration efforts. Any existing tools
    available? 
    
    Thanks in advance,
    Mike


X-posted in TYFYS::DATABASE_CONVERSION
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
939.1Use Natural/RdbNOT003::DENTIIan Dent @NOT, Nottingham, UKFri Jun 21 1991 18:0827
    Software AG have announced a version of Natural to run against Rdb
    and/or RMS.
    
    This is based on Natural V2 which is a very different beast to Natural
    V1.
    
    According to Software AG's marketing, the transfer from Adabas to
    Rdb should be very easy with the same Natural code running against
    each database. 
    
    The transfer of the data may be harder in that Adabas is not
    relational. It supports repeating fields and repeating groups which
    must be converted to Rdb structures in some way.
    
    Natural itself could be used as the conversion tool as a program
    can read from one database manager (adabas) and write to another
    (Rdb).
    
    Conversion generally consists of 2 phases: 1 is to get the programs
    working correctly against the new database: 2 is to get them performing
    as well as they used to.
    
    It is likely that the same Natural programs written to run against
    Adabas will run slower against Rdb if no changes are made. Changes
    needed must be quantified somehow.
    
    Ian
939.2What sort of migration program is required?ZPOVC::MICHAELLEESat Jun 22 1991 05:0311
    re:.-1
    
    Thanks for the reply.
    
    Could the program that reads from adabas and writes to Rdb be written
    in Natural script or 3 GL language?
    
    I supposed the Rdb database needs normalisation before using the above-
    mentioned program.
    
    Mike
939.33GL or NaturalNOT003::DENTIIan Dent @NOT, Nottingham, UKMon Jun 24 1991 16:1021
    Conversion program could be written in Natural V2 (read from Adabas
    database and write to Rdb) or any Vax 3GL. Using the 3GL "direct
    calls" need to be written to access the Adabas database. These calls
    consist of setting up a lot of buffers and then calling Adabas.
    
    A 3GL program could be written containing embedded SQL (for Rdb)
    and direct calls (for Adabas).
    
    Software AG also sell a product called Adasql which allows for SQL
    statements to be embedded in Cobol, Fortran or PL/I programs and
    run through a pre-compiler. This is unlikely to be of interest to
    you as it requires Natural and Predict as pre-requisities. If Natural
    must be purchased it may as well be used.
                                             
    
    Rdb database does not have to be normalised. It could be any design
    you like. Obviously, for ease of conversion of data from Adabas
    to Rdb, it should be the same design as Adabas wherever possible.
    
    Ian
939.4TYFYS::DATA_CONVERSION gone ??COPCLU::BRUNSGAARDWho said I&#039;m paranoid ??!?Wed Jul 17 1991 11:467
    In .0 there is a notes file mentioned. Where did it go (or maybe the
    note was not completly correct).
    
    I get FILE NOT FOUND if I try to open it
    
    Thans in advance
    Lars
939.5Name correctionSHALOT::DUNCANJoe - CIS/EIC/DCC Groupworks TeamThu Jul 18 1991 18:363
    That should be TYFYS::DATABASE_CONVERSION

    Joe Duncan @ OPA
939.6Still doesn't workCOPCLU::BRUNSGAARDWho said I&#039;m paranoid ??!?Fri Jul 19 1991 10:235
    But Joe, that is what was written in .0 wasn't it ??
    Well anyway I still get FILE NOT FOUND.
    
    Still confused
    Lars
939.7I guess this counts as my mistake for FY92! ;-)SHALOT::DUNCANJoe - CIS/EIC/DCC Groupworks TeamFri Jul 19 1991 22:184
    Sorry about that, we left of the last letter.  The name of the
    conference is TYFYS::DATABASE_CONVERSIONS <- notice the use of plural!

    Joe Duncan @ OPA