[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

482.0. "SQL functionality, Oracle vs Rdb" by TYFYS::MUNNS () Mon Nov 06 1989 23:15

My group, the Center for Migration Services, is looking at some Oracle
to Rdb conversion tools. 

A very important area for us to investigate is SQL implementations by 
Oracle and Digital, for example, how does Oracle's SQL (plus extensions) 
map to Digital's SQL ?  

What we need is information on this mapping.  Does anyone know if a 
comparison of these 2 SQL's exist ?

Where might I find this information ?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
482.1Want Manuals ??MAIL::DUNCANGBo knows RdbTue Nov 07 1989 00:0328
    I believe your best source of information would be in the VAX SQL
    manual where we compare Rdb to DB2.  Since Oracle is closely aligned
    with DB2, this would serve as a quick starting point.  For a more
    detailed study, you need Oracle manuals.
    
    I have a SQL*Plus manual which I could send your way if you would
    copy it and send it back since I use it about every week.  Be aware
    that SQL*Plus is similar to our interactive VAX SQL except that
    SQL*plus contains a ton of proprietary extensions.  Any conversion
    effort would have to include SQL*plus command files (like DCL .COM
    files).  SQL*plus is used widely for simple ad hoc queries and quick
    and dirty dba work.
    
    For 3gl programs, I have a Pro*C user guide for loan as well.  It
    probably is not appropriate to assume that a customer's 3gl code
    would have only SQL statements.  There are bound to be those customers
    who have written their code using the HLI (high language interface).
    When using the HLI method, your 3gl program would include numerous
    calls to Oracle routines.  Think of HLI like writing a program using
    DSRI calls.... pretty wild stuff.  If you run across an ISV who
    has a lot of experience with Oracle, I would expect you to encounter
    HLI more frequently than with a customer with just a couple of years
    experience.

    Oracle 3gl programs which do use SQL statements should map nicely.
    For SQL*forms, I assume you are aware of Trifox on the west coast.
	
    -- gerry duncan
482.2Look back 16 monthsCOOKIE::BERENSONI'm the NRATue Nov 07 1989 20:263
The DECtp Buffer Special Issue from July '88 has some comparison
information between the SQLs.  Its a bit out of date, particularly with
the announcement of Rdb/VMS V3.1, but its a start.