[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

404.0. "Distributed Ingres and Ultrix (TCPIP or OSI ?)" by LARVAE::TARZEY (Bob Tarzey, UK GRAC) Fri Aug 18 1989 16:45

    I'm told that distributed Ingres works o.k. over DECnet.
    
    Does any one know how distributed Ingres works in the Ultrix
    environment ? Does it use TCPIP or OSI ? or can it use both ?
    
    Thanks in advance for any help
    
    Bob Tarzey
                                          
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
404.1re:404PARVAX::FITZGIBBONSWed Aug 30 1989 23:3410
    Ingres will not be supported under Ultrix until version 6 is fully
    available in November (according to local RTI sources in NJ). The
    RISC platform will be supported in roughly the same timeframe.
    
    It will support TCP/IP via DECnet/Ultrix, Fusion, Wollongong.
    If you have a PC Unix desktop environment, the Ingres/PClink (not 
    yet available under version 6) will allow to extract data from 
    the VAX to the PC while utilizing TCP/IP.
        
    		                             Mayo Edghill
404.2Ingres on Ultrix supported since last yearSMURF::FRIEDMANJoshua FriedmanFri Sep 01 1989 02:5919
Ingres 5.0 has been shipping and has been fully supported since at least 
December of '88, since we have a version (5.0/04a) that's that old (I know
we had a version before that as well, but I wasn't around then). This 
version supports the NET and STAR functionalities using TCP/IP or DECnet.

The newest release on Ultrix is 5.0/06a VAX or 5.0/06 MIPS (RISC), and has
been shipping since roughly mid June of this year.  The RISC platform does
not yet support DECnet, though the VAX Ultrix version does (and the VMS 
platform does not yet support DEC's VMS TCP/IP, just Wollongong or DECnet).

Ingres 6.2 will be the first release 6 version of the product released
on Ultrix, and RTI will begin its field test in October of this year
(on Ultrix 3.0 / 3.1).

I don't know why the "RTI sources in NJ" said they won't be supporting
Ultrix until version 6; version 5 has been fully supported for Ultrix as
I've described above.
					--Josh Friedman
					  Ultrix Engineering
404.3THIS IS WHY YOU BUY FROM THE VENDOR!COOKIE::BERENSONVAX Rdb/VMS VeteranSat Sep 02 1989 21:2120
And people complain when various DEC products don't ship compatible versions!

Over a year after V6 announcement, INGRES still isn't shipping it on all
platforms and not all of their related products work with V6!

The story is the same with ORACLE.  Over a year after announcement they
still aren't shipping their latest version on all platforms, and they
still aren't shipping the full functionality they announced!

This is the kind of stuff we should really use against them (on VMS at
least).  What good is ORACLE's portability message when the versions on
different platforms are so out of synch that you can't use any new
features (if you want the applications to be portable) for years after
announcement!

As for RTI, we need to work this problem so that products DEC is relying
on, like Ultrix INGRES and INGRES-TOOLS-FOR-RDB are amongst the first
things they release rather than the last ports!  Otherwise, our
relationships with them will leave us at a disadvantage versus
competitors (and RTI itself on other platforms).
404.4A litlle Competitive ProblemQUILL::BOOTHWhat am I?...An Oracle?Sun Sep 03 1989 04:1610
    The RTI agreement for Sun ports first was in existence before the
    RTI-Digital agreement. That will make it hard to change.
    
    The versioning synchronization problem is used competitively agsinst
    these vendors. But it's kind of a catch-22. Oracle's versions are very
    late. But Oracle PC applications are portable to the VAX. Not so with
    RTI (with whom we have a marketing agreement), whose PC version is out
    of sync with the VAX version. 
    
    ---- Michael Booth