[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

81.0. "Rdb vs. ORACLE info. req." by BARNA::MAURI () Wed Mar 02 1988 12:36

    A prospect of us is considering wether buying Rdb or ORACLE. I need
    some comparisions between the two databases in order to force the
    prospect to buy Rdb.
    
    I've read Topics 4, 14 of this Notebook and 1116 of RDB_OLD. This
    last one is good except in one point : they ommit results about
    multiuser benchmarks. Does anyone have any empirycal data on such
    kind of benchmarks ? 
    
    Any help (data or addresses where I can find data) will be appreciated.
    
    Thanks,
    
    Jordi Mauri (SWAS Barcelona - Spain)
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
81.1SomethingAUNTB::BOOTHA career of MISunderstandingWed Mar 02 1988 21:5113
    Oracle has told it's user group that its new transaction processing
    software will be (originally) 10 times as fast as its general purpose
    database. At that meeting, they quoted the new software rate at
    28 TPS (Debit/Credit). That means that the general purpose Oracle
    must perform at 2.8 TPS. Oracle rarely quotes a machine size. But
    if they are using the numbers, you can bet they were generated on
    a high-end VAX. I would add that they are now quoting the new software
    at 6 times the rate of the old. That would be 16.8 TPS.
    
    If the 2.8 TPS figure is correct, then Oracle is approximately half
    as fast on Debit/Credit as Rdb/VMS.
                  
    ---- Michael Booth
81.2TPS is becoming as meaningless as MIPS32371::BERENSONRdb/VMS - Number ONE on VAXThu Mar 03 1988 16:0812
DebitCredit performance comparisons are meaningless without a full
description of how the benchmark was run.  Are the numbers for 1 second
95% response times (the benchmark spec), 1 second 90% response times
(the Tandem way of reporting), maximum throughput independent of
response times?  Is it just Database performance or is forms processing,
etc. included?  Where is the response time measured, at the backend or
at the terminal.  On and on.

Depending on how the measurements are done, how tricky one is willing to
be, etc., the Rdb/VMS V2.3 DebitCredit numbers run from 2-9 TPS on an 8700.
Who knows what the range is for ORACLE or which numbers they are quoting
for *TPS.
81.3Another source of information...BISTRO::KIRKDiamonds on the sole of my keyboardTue Mar 08 1988 15:369
    Jordi,
    
    You may also want to take a look at the other products that Oracle
    may be selling with the database, such as SQL*Forms, and compare it to 
    Rally. Take a look at
    
    	BISTRO::RALLY_COMPETITION
    
    Richard