[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference yukon::christian

Title:The CHRISTIAN Notesfile
Moderator:YUKON::GLENNEON
Created:Wed Dec 11 1996
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:81
Total number of notes:2400

81.0. "Watts in your steeple?" by NETCAD::ROLKE (The FDDI Genome Project) Fri May 30 1997 15:37

There is currently an opportunity for many churches to make some money:
communications companies are looking for steeples in which to place
PCS antennas.

Churches with high steeples usually 1) are right downtown, 2) are the 
highest building around 3) are built on the highest point of land 
and 4) have nothing much else going on in the steeple.  A PCS antenna
or cell phone antenna will go right up there and do the job yet remain
hidden.  Typical rental fees go from $3,000 per month, say, in 
Wellesley or Weston, where coverage goes to I-90, I-95 and 30,000 
residents, to a minimum of $800 per month in some backwater like where
I live.  The comm company will go out of its way to help you fix up
your facility for earthquake, fire, lightning, electric, dry rot, and 
security.  What A Deal!

However...

I have some questions about the entire operation.  The most basic is,

     Is this a proper use for my church's steeple?

If I go ahead and recommend that my church set up a commercial enterprise
like this 

  1. Am I falling into the trap of the "money changers in the temple"
     or am I "using my talents and not burying them"?

  2. Am I hastening the day when churches will all lose their tax exempt
     status?  First I rent my gym to the Cub Scouts, next I rent my hall
     to a for-profit Antiques Fair, third I rent my downstairs to a
     year-round for-profit Day Care provider and finally I sublet the
     steeple to three or four companies like MCI and AT&T.  I'm not a
     church, I'm a telecoms provider.  My loss of tax status is no big
     deal since I just charge my tenants more and I'm rich anyway; but 
     across the state some poor church with no connections is pushed to
     extinction.

  3. The church steeple was originally built as a symbolic pointer.
     The church bell chime is a present to the community and the gigantic
     clock has become part of town life.  Am I contributing to the
     community when I provide THE BEST location for a PCS transmitter/
     receiver?  Or am I violating the trust bestowed by previous
     generations?

  4. Does a deal like this deflate the motivation for pledging?  Hey,
     the church is making all this money for nothing why should I give?

I personally am leaning toward accepting the deal.

I think that this technology will be gone in a decade or so when satellites
do all the work.  By waiting until then any opportunity to earn some money
will be lost.  My church building, 1850, has some serious structural
problems not the least of which is the failure of the old wood behind the
aluminum siding.  Replacement costs just for the new siding alone are
estimated today at $300K.  We could pour all the money from a single antenna
rental into our facility and not significantly pay for a single major
expense.

Saying no to this would be like saying no to manna.

What do you think?

Regards,
Chuck
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
81.1Church Government in ActionJULIET::MORALES_NASweet Spirit's Gentle BreezeFri May 30 1997 15:384
    I think this is a financial decision to be accepted by the deacons and
    then perhaps voted on by the people of the church.
    
    
81.2DECXPS::HENDERSONGive the world a smile each dayFri May 30 1997 15:418

 I would vote against it, were I given the opportunity.  To me it is an 
 alliance with the world that I don't think the church needs.  



Jim
81.3ALFSS1::BENSONAEternal WeltanschauungFri May 30 1997 17:2831
    
    This is an interesting question.  I haven't been confronted with such
    an opportunity since we're in a community center so I haven't thought
    about it at all.
    
    There's one thing that is certain, on the face of it there is nothing
    too different in getting money from a tower on top of the building and 
    getting money from bake sales, car washes, rummage sales, and so on, in 
    my opinion.  Are bake sales and the like appropriate or inappropriate 
    ways to raise money for the church?
    
    Aren't we all here and most of those other Christians we know
    dependent upon "worldly" occupations from which our tithes and
    offerings come into the church?  Didn't God create the system of work
    and wages and giving?
    
    Though churches come to love their buildings, are the buildings the
    church?
    
    I probably would vote in favor. Of course there would be constraining
    factors.  I would know who the company is and what they stand for.  I
    wouldn't allow a broadcasting tower on my building to consciously
    broadcast the Fox Network or the Playboy channel and worse.  And I
    would not plan a long program based on income from such a deal.  I
    would probably ask that the money go into an account which is not part
    of the general fund so that I could change my mind whenever I wanted,
    within contractual agreements of course.
    
    That's my opinion at the moment.
    
    jeff
81.4PHXSS1::HEISERMaranatha!Fri May 30 1997 17:4812
    Our church owns the shopping center where we are located.  U.S. West
    came to us last summer wanting to put up a 60ft. cellular tower on our
    property so that they could fill a transmission void in our area. 
    After a couple rejections from our church administrator, they offered
    to pay us several hundred dollars a month and mount 3 12ft crosses all
    around it.  We accepted it!  The money we make pays for running the 
    electronic stadium-sized messaging center we posted next to I-17.  Nice
    witnessing tool for rush-hour/stop&go traffic.
    
    If done right, such things can be used for God's glory.
    
    Mike
81.5BBQ::WOODWARDC...but words can break my heartSun Jun 01 1997 19:4733
    Yahbut...
    
    anyone consider the radiation emanating from these beasts? Ok, there is
    no (at this time) proven correlation between Mobile-Phone Base-Station
    tower radiation and any physiological effects on humans. But that is
    mainly due to the fact that no one has _done_ these studies. There
    appears to be a correlation between microwave radiation and/or TV/FM
    radiation and increases in some forms of cancer (including leukemia).
    But this is currently from studies done in the UK and Australia.
    
    There are presently studies under way regarding physiological effects
    of Mobile-Phone handsets, and there appears to be _something_ happening
    in the skulls of people using these devices - so what are the effects
    of a hulking great Mobile-Telephone antennae in the Bell-fry of a
    church building? 
    
    The good news is that most people will only be afected for an hour or
    so a week, except maybe the office staff and volunteers who are there
    40 hours or more - and the people nearby.
    
    I suggest some examination of the risks involved - including potential
    compensation claims in years to come. Asbestos was mined, because it
    was a safe product; fibre-glass appears to be falling into the same
    category; X-rays were considered safe until further studies were done -
    now Radiographers are sheilded, and patients are given the minimum
    possible dose; passive smoking is being seen as a cause of various
    cancers; as is (in spite of the tobacco companies) smoking.
    
    Don't take the telco's word for it, investigate for your selves.
    
    hth,
    
    H
81.6DECWET::WANGMon Jun 02 1997 18:1423
There are two instances happened in our church in a very short but critical
time frame a month ago.  It is a long story but I will make it very short.  

One instance is that we are about to get the permit to build our
church(building) on the land we own(for about 10 years) and we are about to
make a decision on whether we should go ahead to build it given all the money
contrains.  Our pastor suddenly got a phone call from a buddhist
organization that they would offer a price that basically whatever we ask for. 
They say that our land is on an excellent "fone-tsui" location and they want
it.

The other instance is a Sister from a Christian broadcasting ministry came to
our church to share and asking for help.  Her ministry just got an offer from
a broadcasting company that asking if they can produce Christian programs
for a valuable time slot, six days a week.  If not, a buddhist organization will
be very interested in the same time slot and is willing to pay MUCH more.

God has provided the best resources for us.  If we lose it, the enemy will take
over and do much damages than the small benifit we trade it for.  I do not know
if this will apply to the situation in .0 and .4 but we will definitely not
give up the land and the broadcasting time slot.

Wally