[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference hips::uk_audioo

Title:You get surface noise in real life too
Notice:Let's be conformist
Moderator:GOVT02::BARKER
Created:Thu Jul 28 1988
Last Modified:Mon Jun 02 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:550
Total number of notes:3847

229.0. "Re-tip a Troika ?" by HAND::LARSEN (Rob Larsen @BST) Thu Nov 15 1990 17:10

    Hi UK Audio Reader's ,
    
    Question:
    
    My Linn Trokia is getting a bit old these days...
    
    I can trade it in for a new one or,
    
    how about getting it re-tiped �la Van Der Hul.
    
    Your comments please.
    
    Thanks,
    
    Rob.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
229.1Linn won't do itCHEST::WATSONBack to monoFri Nov 16 1990 08:239
    Linn have just (yesterday) changed the rules for traiding in your old
    Troika (You know get �320-00 back - See 222.1).
    
    As for retipping it - Linn won't do it (All traided in MC cartidges are
    scrapped) and I'm not sure of the sound quality you'd get. I did here a
    very convincing argument against a re-tip - but for the life of me I
    can't remember it ... sorry.
    
    	Rik
229.2 ? Cantilever damage ??COMICS::FLANDERSDThe doctor is in ...Fri Nov 16 1990 09:229
    
    I heard somewhere that the reason for not retipping (from Ortophon I
    think) was that they couldn't be sure about invisible damage to the
    cantilever (stress etc.).
    
    I suppose they might also get cartridges for retipping which have been
    retipped before (etc. etc. ...).
    
    Dave
229.3get potted...BAHTAT::SALLITTDave @RKG, 831-3117Fri Nov 16 1990 13:3711
    Another argument against retipping is that it isn't always just the tip
    that wears. The cantilever suspension can harden - depends on age and
    environment - and in modern centrally heated rooms this can accelerate
    and cause a cartridge to sound "worn" well before the tip itself wears out.
    Increasing room humidity with plants can extend the life a little if this 
    is likely!
    
    I didn't think Linn scrapped used Troikas, as the body comprised around
    50% of the cost anyway, but I could be mistaken.
    
    Dave
229.4Roxan do itCHEST::WATSONBack to monoFri Nov 16 1990 14:5310
    If I'd bothered to engage my brain before making my comments I would
    have added the following.
    
    	1. It was ASAKs that Linn were scrapping - these had horrible
    plastic covers ...
    
    	2. The Roxan MC cartridge (Sharaz (? sp)) IS retippable - by Roxan
    no less.
    
    So there is more to this than meets the eye (or ear).
229.5...and the coilsSCARP::BRIGHTI'm back!Mon Nov 19 1990 08:545
I was under the impression that when an MC cartridge wears out, it's
the coils that expire as well as the tip.

Steve.
229.6Thanks guys!HAND::LARSENRob Larsen @BSTFri Nov 23 1990 13:0510
    Thanks Guys, 
    	
    Ive decided to get a new Troika. What has been said in the previous
    notes is along the same feelings Ive had. 
    
    	Rob.
    
    	PS. A friend of mine is going to get his Troika retipped, I'll
        report on the results.