[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference azur::mcc

Title:DECmcc user notes file. Does not replace IPMT.
Notice:Use IPMT for problems. Newsletter location in note 6187
Moderator:TAEC::BEROUD
Created:Mon Aug 21 1989
Last Modified:Wed Jun 04 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:6497
Total number of notes:27359

927.0. "MCC questions/wishlist." by KETJE::PACCO () Wed Apr 17 1991 13:27

    This is a "wishlist" for general DECmcc functionality.  Can somebody
    comment on it !
    
    1). Often customers ask how the ICONIC map can be printed.  A
    print-screen function to postscript format is reqested!  Today the
    print screen menu in the DECwindows session manager gives only a
    possible print of WHAT IS DISPLAYED on the screen, nota full window!
    
    2). When "DURATION" time specifications are set  in the ICONIC map
    (OPERATION TIME -- SCOPE OF INTEREST TIME) you cannot execute any more 
    simple SHOW and SET etc... commands.  Isn't it possible to "IGNORE"
    these time specifications if it is not "applicable" to the command ? 
    This would be very handy.
    
    3). Once you have used TIME specifications and you want to reset(zero) these,
    for all specifications you have to, e.g.select each entry in the
    scheduled time list, and remove the entry, select the repeat interval and 
    click the time down until "0" is reached.  Only the "CLEAR UNTIL" box
    allows to clear the "UNTIL TIME" data immediately with a single mouse
    click.  I would very much appreciate a single CLEAR box to clear ALL
    time related data in the time related windows with a single mouse
    click.
    
    4). Is it possible to introduce "programmable keys" in the ICONIC MAP
    PM to have a fast access to a certain domain or entity.  Te key
    definition file must be modifyable, manageable by the user.
    
    5). How will the ISO functional domains as
    "CONFIGURATION","PERFORMANCE","ACCOUNTING",etc... be implemented. 
    Specially, how will a user be tied to one or more of these functional
    domains.
    
    6). How is it foreseen to put protections on the VERB level. e.g. will
    it be possible and how to allow "SHOW" commands to a group of peaople,
    and "SET" commands to a more restrictive group of people?  This goes
    beyond the question 5.  It must be possible for a group of users to
    "SEE" the configuration of a network, but is must be possible to
    prevent them to modifying data.
    
    7). Another feature which is requested, is to have an AUDIT TRAIL of ALL
    commands given by an operator.  This could be in the native DECmcc
    (NCL) syntax.  With this it is possible to trace back what has been
    done on the network.
    
    Dominique.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
927.1Why can ICONS be shifted so easily ?KETJE::PACCOWed Apr 24 1991 15:1714
    Another comment.
    
    I always wonder why it is possible to move icons on the map, even if
    you have NOT selected the EDIT option.
    
    I am always annoyed when I think I select an icon, but also see that
    the icon is following my mouse.  This requires to reposition the icon on
    its original location or to work with an altered map.
    
    I would like to suggest prevent any modifications on the MAP as long as
    there is no "TOOLBOX" active.
    
    regards,
    Dominique.
927.2agree with .1JETSAM::WOODCOCKWed Apr 24 1991 19:037
>    I would like to suggest prevent any modifications on the MAP as long as
>   there is no "TOOLBOX" active.
    
You have at least one (and probably many others) more vote for this behaviour.

regards,
brad...
927.3TOOK::F_MESSINGERWed Apr 24 1991 19:2513
    
    re -.1,-.2
    
    Input noted and recorded!!  This is turning out to be a popular
    request.  Another possibility would be to have a padlock mounted
    somewhere on the map window.  Clicking the lock would cause the
    lock to look "unlocked" and would make the map window sensitive
    to moves and deletes and such.  Clicking the "unlocked" lock
    would cause it to look "locked" and also make the map insensitive
    to drags and deletes.  But the map would always remain sensitive
    to selections and navigations.
    
    Fred
927.4A few general questions still open.KETJE::PACCOFri Apr 26 1991 07:239
    Re: 927.0
    
    	Can anybody comment on the different points of that note ?  These
    questions, coming from several users, were bundled here together there.
    
    I would like to be able to give a correct answer to these.
    
    	Regards,
    	Dominique.
927.5AnswersBSYBEE::EGOLFJohn C. Egolf LKG2-2/T02 x226-7874Fri Apr 26 1991 09:1284
	Before I  begin  to  answer  these questions, let me state that
	most or all  are  great  ideas  or needs.  The basic problem is
	that there is SO  much to do and so little time to do it.  What
	seems like a trivial thing to do may not be.  What seems like a
	MUST  HAVE  to one customer is  just  that,  only  one  or  two
	customers have asked for it.  We  are  trying  to  get the MUST
	have items done to have a functional product.   The fine tuning
	that is needed will come as we have time.


    This is a "wishlist" for general DECmcc functionality.  Can somebody
    comment on it !
    
    1). Often customers ask how the ICONIC map can be printed.  A
    print-screen function to postscript format is reqested!  Today the
    print screen menu in the DECwindows session manager gives only a
    possible print of WHAT IS DISPLAYED on the screen, nota full window!

	You're  right.   We traded off this because we  had  the  print
	screen  workaround, even though it is only a window's worth  of
	data.  Not sure when this will be done the way  you  want.  Not
	planned for next release.

    
    2). When "DURATION" time specifications are set  in the ICONIC map
    (OPERATION TIME -- SCOPE OF INTEREST TIME) you cannot execute any more 
    simple SHOW and SET etc... commands.  Isn't it possible to "IGNORE"
    these time specifications if it is not "applicable" to the command ? 
    This would be very handy.
    
	This one bothers me as well.  I almost consider this a  bug.  I
	will have the team(s) look into how this can work better.

    3). Once you have used TIME specifications and you want to reset(zero) these,
    for all specifications you have to, e.g.select each entry in the
    scheduled time list, and remove the entry, select the repeat interval and 
    click the time down until "0" is reached.  Only the "CLEAR UNTIL" box
    allows to clear the "UNTIL TIME" data immediately with a single mouse
    click.  I would very much appreciate a single CLEAR box to clear ALL
    time related data in the time related windows with a single mouse
    click.
    
	I  agree again.  I'll ask the Iconic map team to look at  this.


    4). Is it possible to introduce "programmable keys" in the ICONIC MAP
    PM to have a fast access to a certain domain or entity.  Te key
    definition file must be modifyable, manageable by the user.
    
	No.  There are  "Accelerator" keys to help with operations like
	ALT-O to open a domain  or  ALT-S  to save a map.  There are no
	plans to allow users to create  new ones or redfine the current
	ones.  I can't do it with my Windows 3 system either.

    5). How will the ISO functional domains as
    "CONFIGURATION","PERFORMANCE","ACCOUNTING",etc... be implemented. 
    Specially, how will a user be tied to one or more of these functional
    domains.
    
	Not clear if we want to do it this way.  Under investigation.

    6). How is it foreseen to put protections on the VERB level. e.g. will
    it be possible and how to allow "SHOW" commands to a group of peaople,
    and "SET" commands to a more restrictive group of people?  This goes
    beyond the question 5.  It must be possible for a group of users to
    "SEE" the configuration of a network, but is must be possible to
    prevent them to modifying data.
    
	User profiles.  We are getting many  request  for user profiles
	that identify what user can do what command  on which entities.
	No idea when this will be implemented.


    7). Another feature which is requested, is to have an AUDIT TRAIL of ALL
    commands given by an operator.  This could be in the native DECmcc
    (NCL) syntax.  With this it is possible to trace back what has been
    done on the network.
    
	When you talk FCL, it becomes easier to understand  the  issue.
	When  you  talk  Iconic  Map, the problem becomes too large  to
	think  of at this time.  Customers are asking for this  and  it
	will be strongly considered.  No idea when implemented.

    Dominique.
927.6Paris was not built in 1 day too !KETJE::PACCOFri Apr 26 1991 16:339
    Thanks for the repy John,
    
    As a last comment on wish 7.,  it is as important for the FCL as for
    the ICONIC MAP.  The purpose is to be able to track some eventual
    misuse (intentional or not) of the management system.  This must be a
    "central logging/auditing facility" in my opinion.
    
    	Regards,
    	Dominique. 
927.7re:.0BARREL::LEMMONThu May 02 1991 11:1237
    2). When "DURATION" time specifications are set  in the ICONIC map
    (OPERATION TIME -- SCOPE OF INTEREST TIME) you cannot execute any more 
    simple SHOW and SET etc... commands.  Isn't it possible to "IGNORE"
    these time specifications if it is not "applicable" to the command ? 
    This would be very handy.
    
>
> The difficulty is figuring out if it is applicable.  Currently there is
> no mechanism in DECmcc to specify which time formats a specific 
> a sepcific Verb, Entity, Attribute tuple supports.  This is also true for
> qualifiers.  You can't assume that "simple" directives will always ignore
> these time specifications.  It is up to the management module developer. 
>  
> One possible way of solving this problem is to extend the MSL to allow this 
> association.   I proposed doing this back in 1988 when I was working on the
> Enrollment chapter of the SRM but was vetoed by the architects.   If I 
> remember correctly, they said that all MMs must allow the time and qualifiers
> be passed across the interface. The MM could either ignore it or return
> an error condition saying it wasn't supported.   I wasn't able to convince
> them otherwise.  
>

    3). Once you have used TIME specifications and you want to reset(zero) these,
    for all specifications you have to, e.g.select each entry in the
    scheduled time list, and remove the entry, select the repeat interval and 
    click the time down until "0" is reached.  Only the "CLEAR UNTIL" box
    allows to clear the "UNTIL TIME" data immediately with a single mouse
    click.  I would very much appreciate a single CLEAR box to clear ALL
    time related data in the time related windows with a single mouse
    click.
    
>
> I also noticed that this is a pain. Its on our wish list but may not
> be in v1.2 due to time constraints.  (if I got a nickel every time I 
> I have to say that...:-)  
> 
>   /Jim  (Iconic Map PL)
927.8logging in FCLThe fclTOOK::CALLANDERThu May 02 1991 12:3110
 does support a loggin command (USE LOGGING ON) which will log
both the input and output of each command entered. The commands will be
as typed by the user, and the output will be presented in a commented out 
fashion so that the file produces can actually be rerun as a command procedure.
If you want this system to do this for all users you can create a system
wide initialization file, or have all users add it to their init files.

The name of the log file will default if you do not explicitly chose one.

jill