| T.R | Title | User | Personal
Name | Date | Lines |
|---|
| 18.1 | comments on issue 9 from David C. P. LaFrance-Linden | SMURF::LOWELL | | Thu Dec 05 1996 14:59 | 57 |
| 18.2 | more comments on issue 9 from David C. P. LaFrance-Linden | SMURF::LOWELL | | Fri Dec 06 1996 12:16 | 6 |
| 18.3 | Added PS11 | SMURF::LOWELL | | Fri Dec 06 1996 13:00 | 10 |
| 18.4 | Assigned | SMURF::LOWELL | | Fri Dec 06 1996 14:47 | 1 |
| 18.5 | OF/STWG 12/02/96 | SMURF::LOWELL | | Tue Dec 17 1996 12:11 | 128 |
| 18.6 | OF/STWG 12/16 | SMURF::LOWELL | | Tue Dec 17 1996 12:17 | 107 |
| 18.7 | | NETRIX::"[email protected]" | Michelle Neisser | Tue Dec 31 1996 13:12 | 6 |
| 18.8 | Compare with old Optimization section proposal | GEMGRP::BRENDER | Ron Brender | Thu Jan 09 1997 10:36 | 378 |
| 18.9 | meeting followup (or: a dangerous brainstorm!) | NETRIX::"[email protected]" | Michelle | Tue Jan 14 1997 17:35 | 81 |
| 18.10 | Interesting idea... Specific example might help | TLE::LUCIA | http://asaab.zko.dec.com/~lucia/biography.html | Tue Jan 14 1997 18:06 | 28 |
| 18.11 | reply to .10 | NETRIX::"[email protected]" | Michelle | Wed Jan 15 1997 08:34 | 16 |
| 18.12 | | ADA9X::BRETT | | Wed Jan 15 1997 09:24 | 7 |
| 18.13 | | AOSG::LOWELL | | Wed Jan 15 1997 10:30 | 27 |
| 18.14 | | TLE::LUCIA | http://asaab.zko.dec.com/~lucia/biography.html | Wed Jan 15 1997 15:49 | 3 |
| 18.15 | | ADA9X::BRETT | | Thu Jan 16 1997 08:09 | 9 |
| 18.16 | Good beginning, some comments and suggestions | FLYBA::BRENDER | Ron Brender | Thu Jan 16 1997 16:03 | 99 |
| 18.17 | Update | NETRIX::"[email protected]" | Michelle | Fri Jan 17 1997 15:21 | 50 |
| 18.18 | Update for online approval | AOSG::LOWELL | | Wed Feb 12 1997 15:14 | 9 |
| The next update of the comment section proposal is ready for review.
I'm considering this the online approval period. Starting now and
running through 2/21/97.
Michelle's taken out all of the tool version references and there
are some changes to the tag descriptor flags.
http://www.zk3.dec.com/~mn/ofst/cmscn.html
|
| 18.19 | Some comment re February draft | GEMGRP::BRENDER | Ron Brender | Thu Feb 13 1997 17:17 | 28 |
| A few comments/suggestions -- mostly regarding the API:
1) Overall looks very good
2) My recollection is that we agreed to rename CM_NULL to the more suggestive
CM_END.
3) Re st_cm_add #1: Seems like there should be an additional parameter,
st_cmhdr_t *cmhdr, which receives the handle for the newly created
subsection.
4) Re st_cm_add #2: Should make clear that a new section is added even if
there is already a section with the same tag.
5) Re st_cm_print #1: Doesn't this routine need a parameter to specify the
output unit/channel/inode where the output is to be written.
6) Re st_cm_print #2, st_cm_append, st_cm_replace, st_cm_delete: These all
seem unclear as to what should happen if there is more than one
subsection with the same tag. Perhaps it would be better to replace the
unsigned int tag parameter with a st_cmhdr_t *cmhdr parameter. Then
any iteration for dealing with multiples can be left in the hands of
the caller.
Assuming the API is not an official part of the ECO, I'll vote YES. But if
the API is included, then I'll wait to see how 2) thru 6) above are resolved.
Ron
|
| 18.20 | | SMURF::LOWELL | | Fri Feb 14 1997 10:35 | 15 |
| Ron,
Thanks for the comments on the API's. I'm sure Michelle will
address each point. In the meantime, I thought I should verify
that the API's *are not* included in the ECO. The same goes for
the new mcs tool. The new tags and tag-descriptors are the main
points of interest in this proposal.
Also, I think your vote should still be contingent on point 2
"CM_END" since that's unrelated to the API's. We'll make that
correction right away.
-Randy
|
| 18.21 | approved | AOSG::LOWELL | | Fri Feb 21 1997 09:51 | 6 |
| The .comment extension proposal has been approved.
OF/STWG ECO-ID = 11
More extensibility proposals are pending so the note
will remain as an open issue.
|
| 18.7 | moved | SMURF::LOWELL | | Wed Apr 16 1997 12:05 | 6 |
| For bookkeeping purposes, subtopics of this issue have been
split out to separate basenotes.
69.0 .comment section extensions and 'mcs' utility
70.0 object file/symbol table versioning
|