[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::seal

Title:SEAL
Moderator:GALVIA::SMITH
Created:Mon Mar 21 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1989
Total number of notes:8209

1752.0. "endless mail loop not detected problem" by CSC32::SHEAFFER () Fri Jan 31 1997 16:23

    Howdy
    
    I've got a customer w/ afwu 2.1 w/ smtpxd 1.27.1.1 who experienced a
    problem with an endless mail loop between the firewall and the internal
    mailhub.   The internal mailhub is a VMS/Multinet system running 
    Innosoft's PMDF smtp code.  He has selected the "remove node name from
    mail headers" option in the firewall's mail configuration.  
    
    He has users outside of the firewall who send mail and have it relayed
    to the firewall.  If they send mail to an address like "user@aol" it
    gets to the firewall, ruleset S7 will convert the address to
    "[email protected]" and deliver the message to the internal mail hub. 
    The internal mail hub is not configured to recognize "*.domain" as local
    mail and relays the message back to the firewall.  SMTPXD strips the 
    "Received:" line from the internal mail hub and the message is sent back 
    to the internal mailhub, looping endlessly and bringing a vax 7620 to its 
    knees.
    
    The workaround was to change the smtpxd.strip_headers option in
    smtpxd.conf to FALSE and leave sendmail.cf configured to rewrite from
    addresses as "user@domain".  Apparently PMDF has to know each host to
    consider local within a domain and could not be set up with a wildcard rule 
    as in sendmail to consider *.domain as local.
    
    Is it possible to get a version of SMTPXD that only strips headers from
    outbound mail or as suggested in note 1637.4 replaces the hostnames w/
    dummy entries leaving the Recevied headers? 
    
    Thanks in advance
    
    Danny Sheaffer
    [email protected]
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1752.1Correct the mail address ...QUICHE::PITTAlph a ha is better than no VAX!Wed Feb 05 1997 08:188
    user@aol is NOT a correct Internet mail address.  All such addresses
    have at least one dot in them!!!  As a result, the firewall correctly
    says that the sender forgot to put the domain name on, adds it, and
    then delivers the mail inside ...
    
    The correct mail address should be [email protected], I think ...
    
    T