[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference iosg::all-in-1_v30

Title:*OLD* ALL-IN-1 (tm) Support Conference
Notice:Closed - See Note 4331.l to move to IOSG::ALL-IN-1
Moderator:IOSG::PYE
Created:Thu Jan 30 1992
Last Modified:Tue Jan 23 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:4343
Total number of notes:18308

1788.0. "Local Language Quality " by UTRTSC::SCHOLLAERT (AJAX beats Feyenoord again and again) Mon Nov 16 1992 13:54

    Hello,
    
    I am concerned about the quality of the local language
    variant(s) of our favorite product.
    
    Customer installs IOS 3.0 Dutch on a clean system and finds
    five (translation related) bugs in two days....
    
    I expect that a number of problems will occur in other languages too.
    
    1) Fresh Installation reports "error CM022, refer to documentation"
    2) Author field on form WP is always empty
    3) Modification of datasets by typing the entry form name does not work.
       Prompt is in English. Choices in Dutch. Half of the Dutch
       choices fail. 
    4) ALL-IN-1 accounts IVP, A1$SCRIPT contain "NO MAIL" for 
       maildes. Not valid in Dutch. Modification to "GEEN POST"
       does not work. Next time you perform an Edit, "NO MAIL"
       is back again. Same problem with the rest of the values.
       After an upgrade, the problem  will occur for all users with
       a maildes other than "ALL-IN-1".
    5) ALL-IN-1 accounts IVP, A1$SCRIPT contain    
       "Start hour: 08:00A" and "End hour:   05:00P". "A" and "P" are
       not valid on non-english versions like Dutch.
    
    All problems seem easy to fix, and cost us lot of fun (sorry, work). 
    I will post them overhere.
    
    Worried,
    
    Jan
       
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1788.1Have you reported them formallY?AIMTEC::WICKS_ALiverpool 4 Norwich 1Mon Nov 16 1992 16:4820
    Jan,
    
    the first question that springs to mind is are you really sure
    that they are translation bugs? the second is have you contacted
    Frankfurt?
    
    The CM one i've seen on U.S English systems and Simon produced an
    excellent document that contained this and the other 869 CM error
    messages (it's in STARS)
    
    The WP one doesn't appear on ny multi-ling system but I only have
    French as a second-lang.
    
    The last 3 I can't reproduce since I only have systems with U.S English
    as a primary English and they don't appear when you have one of them
    there Euro languages installed secondary.
    
    Regards,
    
    Andrew.D.Wicks
1788.2Working...UTRTSC::SCHOLLAERTAJAX beats Feyenoord again and againMon Nov 16 1992 20:3552
	Andrew,

>    the first question that springs to mind is are you really sure
>    that they are translation bugs? 

      Yes, at least for the first 4.

>			the second is have you contacted
>    Frankfurt?

      Not yet. I expect more calls from this customer...

>    1) Fresh Installation reports "error CM022, refer to documentation"

      Element A1LINK.COM has "DUTCHN" as .language in CM$SDC$DUTCH.DAT.
      Should be "DUTCH".
      After the merge, Simon compares the number of records with .language eq
      SHARE or DUTCH in CM$SDC.DAT with the total number
      of records in CM$SDC$DUTCH.DAT. result in error CM022.
      I  afraid Simons list only applies for "normal" failures.

>    2) Author field on form WP is always empty

      /GET=AUTHOR,OA$CURDOC_AUTHOR missing on form WP

>    3) Modification of datasets by typing the entry form name does not work.
>       Prompt is in English. Choices in Dutch. Half of the Dutch
>       choices fail. 

      Screen text not translated. Mismatches between 
      contents of OA$_ENTRYMENU_TABLE and OA$_MO_ENT_mumble .

>    4) ALL-IN-1 accounts IVP, A1$SCRIPT contain "NO MAIL" for 
>       maildes. Not valid in Dutch. Modification to "GEEN POST"
>       does not work. Next time you perform an Edit, "NO MAIL"

      Looks like a problem in /LANG=xx$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
      on MAIDES .
      Fails for SM MUA E as well as US SWC .
      I did a quick $ search *.a1$msg lang_mail . Not
      all symbols are translated.
    
>    5) ALL-IN-1 accounts IVP, A1$SCRIPT contain    
>       "Start hour: 08:00A" and "End hour:   05:00P". "A" and "P" are
>       not valid on non-english versions like Dutch.

      Have to check the intallation procedure.
    
    Regards, 
    
    Jan
1788.3MAIDES /RECOG and /LANGUAGE conflicting ?UTRTSC::SCHOLLAERTAJAX beats Feyenoord again and againTue Nov 17 1992 06:3252
    re.2
    
>>    4) ALL-IN-1 accounts IVP, A1$SCRIPT contain "NO MAIL" for 
>>       maildes. Not valid in Dutch. Modification to "GEEN POST"
>>       does not work. Next time you perform an Edit, "NO MAIL"
>
>      Looks like a problem in /LANG=xx$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
>      on MAIDES .
>      Fails for SM MUA E as well as US SWC .
>      I did a quick $ search *.a1$msg lang_mail . Not
>      all symbols are translated.

    Hmm, I have been jumping to conclusions on this one.

    Difference between 2.4 and 3.0 is that om SM forms, which
    are not translated, the fields are displayed with the English 
    values. So that must be the reason that SM$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
    contains the English values twice and SA$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
    (used in translated Administrator Forms) is translated. 

    The problem is that OA$MAIDES, which is used for recognition
    and validation on field MAIDES always checks for the Dutch translation
    of MAIDES.

    How is this supposed to work ?
    
    Regards, 
    
    Jan

SM$PROFILE :

;;MAIDES;;

/HARD=OA$_SM_HRD_MAIL_DEST/RECOG="OA$MAIDES"
/VALID=<XOP ~~VALID_MAIDES~~
/LANGUAGE=SM$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
                                                   
result of /recog :

1  ALLIN1
2  ALL-IN-1
3  GEEN POST
4  PRINTER
5  AFDRUK
6  HARD-COPY
7  VMSMAIL
8  VAXMAIL

<get SM$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPER MAIL/NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-CO

1788.8This is what I received from the I18N Product ManagerIOSG::PYEGraham - ALL-IN-1 Sorcerer&#039;s ApprenticeFri Nov 20 1992 11:2760
        		International Systems Engineering (ISE)
        
        		    ALL-IN-1 Problem Reporting
        
        
        ESCALATION FLOW AND PROBLEM REPORTING
        
        The ISE/Localisation Centres are connected through ECSO to the 
        European Support Centres. This means that the official way of 
        escalating problems should go through the Customer Service 
        Centres. When using ECSO the Site "FLC" (Frankfurt Localization 
        Centre) should at least be informed and if necessary support 
        should be requested.
        
        The FLC will track for the upcoming problems and deliver either 
        solutions or give statements. The FLC expects that the 
        qualification of a problem, that was done by a Customer Support 
        Centre, identifies the problem as a localisation or 
        internationalisation problem. Software problems regarding the 
        Base Component reported to Frankfurt will be passed over to IOSG 
        and vice versa, L10N problems reported to IOSG will be passed 
        over to Frankfurt. In both cases the first site that was involved 
        will give a statement to the issuer of the problem, that the 
        problem has been passed over.
        
        
        PATCH KITS FOR LLV's
        
        The FLC works closely to IOSG Support and will either deliver a 
        patch for an LLV or ensure that a patch delivered by IOSG Support 
        contains the fix. Fixes will be integrated where possible in the 
        next version of ALL-IN-1. 
        
        
        COMMUNICATION
        
        Usually the Customer Support Centres will be informed directly 
        from the FLC about the availibilty of a patch or a fix.
        
        The FLC is planning to install a notes conference. This 
        conference will not only give the same level of information to 
        other persons inside Digital who don't have access to "TIMA" 
        and/or "STARS", but it will also be used to discuss localisation 
        (L10N) and internationalisation (I18N) issues. Announcement will 
        be soon.
        
        
        IF NON OF THE ABOVE WORK...
        
        
        Peter Hanspach
        ISE ALL-IN-1 Product Management
        
        Mail Address:
        PAULUS::HANSPACH
        Peter Hanspach @FRO
        
        Phone:
        DTN: 861-3576
        EXT: 49 6103 383576
1788.10One question leftUTRTSC::SCHOLLAERTAJAX beats Feyenoord again and againMon Nov 23 1992 14:1320
    Thanks for all the replies.
    
    Could someone have a look at .3 
    
    I am still confused how processing of MAIDES on SM$PROFILE 
    is supposed to work. 
    
    ;;MAIDES;;
    
    /HARD=OA$_SM_HRD_MAIL_DEST/RECOG="OA$MAIDES"
    /VALID=<XOP ~~VALID_MAIDES~~
    /LANGUAGE=SM$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION
    
    OA$MAIDES is "translated". SM$_LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION is not.
    So one of them should be modified. Which one ?
    
    Thanks,
    
    Jan
    
1788.11Change the form (IMHO)IOSG::PYEGraham - ALL-IN-1 Sorcerer&#039;s ApprenticeMon Nov 23 1992 17:0620
    A quick search for "PAPER" revealed several other symbols:
    
    	OA.A1$MSG:
    	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION <NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPER MAIL>
    
    	SA.A1$MSG
    	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION <NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPERMAIL...
    
    	SM.A1$MSG
    	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION <NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPERMAIL...
    
    Personally I would say that OALLV is right, and that you should change
    the form to match. Problem is that there doesn't seem to be a symbol to
    use. Hence this is a base bug. I think you'll need to hardcode it for
    now.
    
    Of course you'd need to test this, but it's (relatively) easy to change
    it in the form!
    
    Graham
1788.12Translating LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION solves problemUTRTSC::SCHOLLAERTAJAX beats Feyenoord again and againMon Nov 23 1992 21:3234
    Graham,
    
    RE.-1
    
    Checked the dutch messages files and forms for usage
    of LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION.
    
>    	OA.A1$MSG:
>    	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION <NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPER MAIL>
    
    Not translated. Used in SWC. Fails. 
    
>    	SA.A1$MSG
>	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION	<GEEN POST,POSTLIJST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,AFDRUK/NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPER MAIL>
    
    Translated but not used in SA$PROFILE. SA$PROFILE contains hardcoded
    /LANG .... Should have worked when used.
    
>    	SM.A1$MSG
>    	LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION <NO MAIL,MAIL-LIST,PRINTER,HARD-COPY,PAPERMAIL...
    
    Not translated. Used in SM$PROFILE. Fails.
    
    I added the translated version of LANG_MAIL_DESTINATION in SITE$SM.A1$MSG
    and SITE$SA.A1$MSG. All seems to work now. 
    
    By the way, I had a hard time to 
    find out that you have to precompile a form library when your 
    change the contents of a symbol, used in the named data (SWC in
    OAFORM in the case).
    
    Thanks for your help,
    
    Jan
1788.13Where has LLV support gone now???COPCLU::COPLE4::GLARGAARDAllan Glargaard, DS @DMOTue Nov 23 1993 10:3618
  Rumour has it that the Frankfurt Localisation Centre does no longer
  exist. I haven't seen any official statement about this, maybe one
  of you could forward me the official story.

  I have a LLV problem that I need to report, how should I do that?

  best regards,
  Allan who will certainly miss the excellent work/support from
  Germany!!

  PS The problem I need to report is about the oa$at_data_sort_table
  in OALLV.BLI. It can be used together with BIND/SORT_KEY to sort an
  index on a given field, but the table has not been adapted to local
  sorting rules. I have a modified table for Denmark if anyone wants
  it.

  PPS I'll try to ask Peter Hanspach about the LLV support also ...
  any relevant answer will be posted here also
1788.15use ECSO for problemsFROCKY::HOFMANNStefan Hofmann, IST FiWi @FRSTue Nov 23 1993 14:0734
    Allan,
    
    yes, it's true, the Frankfurt LC has been closed. Work (on ALL-IN-1) was 
    passed over to our colleagues in ISE/Tel Aviv. They will take care about
    future ALL-IN-1 localization - with translation support from ISE/Valbonne.
    
    You won't be very lucky with asking Peter Hanspach. Like me he already
    started a "new career" somewhere with Digital.
    
    If you or somebody else wants to report problems, you should continue
    to use the ECSO channels. There is still one ALL-IN-1 engineer left in
    the former LC who will handle these issues. By the time he finds a new 
    job I hope that Israel has committed to continue V3 support.
    
    As far as your sorting problem is concerned, I can remember that we
    discussed this very intensively during the localization process. Elin
    Christensen brought it up. 
    If my memory serves me well, we could not implement language or country
    specific sorting tables in the standard product, because:
    
    1) we had to introduce new NCS collating sequences and conversion
    functions and we were sure that not all customers would like the idea
    that a layered product changes the NCS mechanism of there VAX
    
    2) we expected problems in multilingual installations because of the
    different DOCDB.FDL needed. 
    
    
    	Maybe you should ask Elin for the outcome of our discussion
    	Sorry, don't have more details, as my old pointers are slowly
    	fading away,
    		regards,
    		Stefan
    
1788.17ECSO works, support from Frankfurt is great!COPCLU::COPLE4::GLARGAARDAllan Glargaard, DS @DMOWed Nov 24 1993 13:3113
Re. 1788.15, Stefan,

  I reported my problem through ECSO like in the old days and got
  excellent support from Frankfurt like nothing had happened! That's
  what I call keeping up the good spirit!

  One thing though: the sorting I'm talking about is not the default
  sorting of DOCDB.DAT, its the sorting done with BIND/SORT_KEY when a
  user (or application) asks for a sort by this table explicitly.

  Best regards,
  Allan

1788.23It's always in the STARS!AIMTEC::WICKS_AAtlanta&#039;s Most (In)famous WelshmanThu Jan 13 1994 16:3512
    Charly,
    
    there's a STARS article entitled 
    *INTERNAL* Responsible Parties for LLV Translation of ALL-IN-1          
    which givesyou the names you need.
    
    I suspect though that the parties involved may already be on there
    way to sunny Reading.
    
    Regards,
    
    Andrew.D.wicks
1788.25Support from Tel-Aviv on its wayTAVENG::WEISSBREMIttamar - Israel EngieeringThu Jan 27 1994 10:4114
    Hi,
    
    
    Yes, I18N and L10N job of ALL-IN-1 has "relocated" to Tel-Aviv (i.e.
    ISE Israel) with translation support of Valbonne. Building of a team
    takes time...
    So although funding for support is still some place on the way, we are
    getting structured and hope to be responsive soon. Proper announcement 
    will be made.
    
    
    Regards,
    
    Ittamar