[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::womannotes-v3

Title:Topics of Interest to Women
Notice:V3 is closed. TURRIS::WOMANNOTES-V5 is open.
Moderator:REGENT::BROOMHEAD
Created:Thu Jan 30 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 30 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1078
Total number of notes:52352

781.0. "FGD - help wanted in believing that "NO" works" by LEZAH::BOBBITT (dance, the storm is over) Mon Apr 22 1991 10:11

    I am posting this for a member of the community who wishes to remain
    anonymous.  This topic is titled FGD - for general discussion.
    
    The previous topic is "for sensitive responses only" (SRO)
    
    -Jody
    
    --------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    
    I always feel awkward when I talk about the times when I was taken
    advantage of sexually. Of the four times that it happened only once was
    intercourse involved. That instance I call date rape but there are
    probably many people who would simply call it "a situation out of
    control". The first time was with a Phd student who was a mentor to me.
    I thought he was the most important person I would ever meet in my
    life. I hung onto his every word. And I tried to do anything and
    everything he ever told me to do because I was sure he knew what was
    best for me and I wanted to be just like him. He abused me twice. In
    both cases I could have said no but I never thought to question
    anything he told me to do. Then I had to deal with being wrong. 

    The second time was with my best friend's ex. I knew I didn't feel any
    attraction for him. He stopped by one evening when I was feeling very
    depressed and it was nice to have company until I realized what his
    agenda was. My own fear kept me from screaming. And I will go to my
    grave living with my mistake. Supposedly, its not rape because I didn't
    scream, or say no, or hit him or try to stop him. 

    My third time was with a soldier who I was stupid enough to flirt with.
    He took me far away and told me I wasn't going to get home unless I did
    what he wanted. And the last time was with a mentor on my job. Again,
    someone who I trusted so completly that I felt he would never do
    anything or tell me to do anything unless it would help me be a better
    person.  And again I was wrong. 

    All this happened when I was 16-19 years old. Above the age of consent
    but far too immature to be able to handle what was happening. And it
    has crippled me  terribly. 

    Its taken me a while to figure out the damage. It certainly hasn't made
    me afraid of sex. Instead it has made me unwilling to trust a guy who
    won't spell out his agenda. I don't like to walk into things where
    there isn't a game plan. Not with guys. I like to know what's going to
    happen and if the guy doesn't have a plan, I'll make one. Too bad for
    him if he doesn't like it. Nor should he ever try to surprise me. I'm
    guaranteed to hate it. 

    This has become a problem. I guess I'm writing because I'd like some
    gentle  advice from people who can relate, people who suffered abuse
    from those they  trusted. I've begun to realize that I never learned
    that its okay to say no and that guys will take no for an answer. I'm
    scared half to death that they won't take no for an answer! So I walk
    in with all of my "no"'s up front. And I expand myself into a big
    monster determined to have my way so that I won't have to negotiate
    anything. I think I'm afraid that as a girl if I try to negotiate with
    a guy I'll automatically lose. 

    I'm wondering if anyone else out there has scars about trusting guys
    and I'd  like to know how they learned to overcome them.

    I get the feeling that a lot of people will have a difficult time
    relating to  where I'm coming from and how I don't feel that my "no"
    will be respected. I'd  appreciated it if those people try to refrain
    from calling me stupid or  pitiful. Or tell me that I have no right to
    claim any kind of survivor status  from things that happened when I was
    old enough to stop them, but didn't. I feel bad enough about this as it
    is and I'd rather not have to feel worse.

    Ann
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
781.1clarificationLEZAH::BOBBITTdance, the storm is overMon Apr 22 1991 10:244
    Again, as with note 780.0, "Ann" is not the basenoters real name.
    
    -Jody
    
781.2Of course you aren't stupid!R2ME2::BENNISONVictor L. Bennison DTN 381-2156 ZK2-3/R56Mon Apr 22 1991 11:0835
    Ann,
    
    I'm not an expert on this, but it sounds to me like you need to do some
    work on your feelings of self-worth.  You need to find out why you
    can't say "no" without feeling guilty or ineffectual.  There are books
    out on that very topic; women who feel guilty when they say "no".  But
    you probably won't be able to fix yourself without some professional
    help.  And I think you want to get help, because your heuristic fix of
    requiring a detailed game plan up front would drive most normal guys
    away, sooner or later.  Healthy relationships need to be based on
    trust, freedom, understanding, mutual respect and caring.  
    
    There are many men like the one's who have taken advantage of you.
    Most of those who took advantage of you probably knew that's what they
    were doing.  They saw that you were vulnerable and took advantage of
    it.  But with your inability to say "no", it's possible that
    some just thought it was what you wanted.  You probably could have
    stopped most of them with the verbal and physical powers at your
    disposal, if you had truly had access to those powers.  You need to
    gain access to those powers.  To do this may take a lot of work with
    a therapist, but it is achievable.  You can do it.
    
    Fortunately, there are also lots and lots of men who would not
    knowingly take advantage of you.  I, for one, am a guy who has always 
    taken "no", any "no", seriously.  I would tell you an almost ridiculous 
    story of one such "no", except it is a much too personal one concerning 
    myself and my wife.  
    
    My advice would be for you to talk to EAP and get recommendations for
    therapists.  Since you have had problems with male authority figures
    you might want to work with a female therapist.  I wish you the best
    of luck in dealing with this problem.  Remember that you are an 
    important person.  You will find lots of support in this notesfile.
    
    					- Vick
781.3It depends the way you look at itMR4DEC::MAHONEYWed Apr 24 1991 16:2415
    I know of a person who was asaulted from the back, with intent of
    raping her... and you know what? she fought so hard, that not only the
    man did not succeed, but she struggled long enough with him to get all
    details of his appearance to give them to police, she scratched him and
    gave exact details to police... the result?
    the guy was aprehended 2 hrs later and put behind bars... there was a
    trial, and a stiff fine along couple months in jail.
    
    If a woman fight, it is very hard for a man to succeed...
    If there is no oposition, no fight, no "NOs" involved... then we cannot
    use the word "taken advantage of..." I call it to consent and then feel
    sorry about it (which is altogether a very different thing) Of course
    that is my own opinion, (and I think I read right)
    
    Believe me, NO is a wonderful and POWERFUL word... learn to use it.
781.4BTOVT::THIGPEN_SBe The FalconWed Apr 24 1991 16:324
.3,

I'm just gonna assume I can't parse that second paragraph and get the meaning
it intended.
781.5gaspRUTLND::JOHNSTONGazpacho...my drug of choiceWed Apr 24 1991 16:488
    re.4 in reponse to .3
    
    You are a good deal more charitable than I.
    
    I was wondering wondering what .3's comment vis-a-vis consent would be
    when faced with some of my old pictures [complete with choke-hold
    bruises, scratches, blood and gobbets of loose hair] from the fight I
    put up and lost.
781.6CFSCTC::KHERI'm not Mrs. KherWed Apr 24 1991 17:019
    .3
    
    Can you explain what you mean? I'm having a hard time following you.
    Considering that the average woman is smaller that the average man, I
    think it's fairly easy for a man to succeed even if the woman fights.
    And if the woman feels her life is in danger, she may not fight to the
    end. Does that mean she wasn't "taken advantage of..."?
    
    m
781.7"and I used to believe in fairies too" (DFR)RYKO::NANCYBPreparation; not paranoiaWed Apr 24 1991 22:3325
	re: .3       

>    If a woman fight, it is very hard for a man to succeed...

	Wow, the only thing I will say to that is: 
	(knee-jerk reactions deleted...)
	
	I think your statement above is extremely easy for the
	average person to believe unless it's proven otherwise 
	to you.  Then you just may be shocked at how useless your
	defensive maneuvers are against someone who is 60% or more
	stronger and who knows what maneuvers you're likely to use.

	And then is all it takes is a dulling blow to your head and
	you're f*cked.


	OK, 1 more thing:

>    If a woman fight, it is very hard for a man to succeed...

	"harder" yes.  "very hard" no.   (IMO, of course)		


						nancy b.
781.8pow!ASDS::BARLOWi THINK i can, i THINK i can...Thu Apr 25 1991 14:2020
    
    reply to .3
    
    I would suggest that you read 780.2 and then rethink and RESTATE
    what you said.  Women are raped every day and many of them
    fight it.  Some don't.  Some have guns pointed at their heads which
    stops them from fighting it.  I would suggest that the majority
    of men wouldn't have sex with a woman who didn't seem like she
    wanted to.  I wouldn't think it would really be much fun, in the
    traditional, sexual sense.  Of course, if the real intent was
    to humiliate the woman, then perhaps it would be fun, in a sick
    sense.
    
    You know, men can be raped to.  Do you also think that only men
    who don't fight or say no are raped?
    
    I think you need to seriously re-evaluate your opinions on this.
    
    
    Rachael Barlow
781.9JUST MY OPINIONRHODES::DOHERTYSun Apr 28 1991 14:4013
    response to .3
    
    I think it is great that your friend fought hard and was not hurt
    and the guy was caught.  But get a grip.  Men are generally bigger
    and stronger than women and if they have a weapon it probably would
    not matter how hard you fought back.  I Also strongly disagree with
    you about the consent thing.  There are many women who for whatever
    reason have a hard time saying no to men.  And alot of men will
    use that weakness even though they know it is not what the woman
    wants.
    
    Kathy