[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference vmszoo::rc

Title:Welcome To The Radio Control Conference
Notice:dir's in 11, who's who in 4, sales in 6, auctions 19
Moderator:VMSSG::FRIEDRICHS
Created:Tue Jan 13 1987
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1706
Total number of notes:27193

466.0. "Kit reviews in tabular form" by --UnknownUser-- () Mon Feb 08 1988 15:39

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
466.2Slightly modified formatMURPHY::ANKERAnker Berg-SonneTue Feb 09 1988 12:5160
		This  note is reserved for airplane  kit  reviews.    The
	actual review table is in reply number  one  to the note.  Please
	do NOT reply to this note.  To have a review included send a mail
	message with you  review  to me at MURPHY::ANKER.  Reviews should
	be submitted as a  table  entry  plus a maximum of two lines free
	form comment.  You can  review  any  kit,  including  ARC and ARF
	kits.  The format of the table is as follows:

Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
		Wood:	A - First class
			B - Good
			C - So so
			D - Awful - Firewood
	
		Plans:	A - Perfect
			B - Good
			C - Could be better
			D - What plans
	
		Skill (needed):
			M - Master builder
			A - Advanced
			E - Experienced
			N - Novice
	
		Rating (overall):
			A - Couldn't be better
			B - Very good
			C - Good
			D - Not my favorite
			E - I wouldn't recommend it
			F - I'll give it to my worst enemy
	
		Flying capability:
			F - Floater
			B - Brick
			A - Aerobatic
			H - Hot
			M - Mild
			S - Scale
			T - Tender
		
		Skill (needed):
			M - Master flyer
			A - Advanced
			E - Experienced
			N - Novice
	
		Rating (overall):
			A - Couldn't be better
			B - Very good
			C - Good
			D - Not my favorite
			E - I wouldn't recommend it
			F - I'll give it to my worst enemy
466.3Kit review tableMURPHY::ANKERAnker Berg-SonneTue Feb 09 1988 12:52122
Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
ACE 4-40      MURPHY::	C	B	N/E	C	A/F	N/E	B
bipe           ANKER
		An ideal first bipe. Building requires careful alignment and
		soldering of carbanes. Flies like a dream. Ground handling easy.

Coverite 	K::	B	B	E	C	A	E	C
Black Baron Spl	Fisher
		40 size - very stable - Top if fuselage is plastic (a nuisance)
		recommend alternate Coverite Sorta Scale Foker (no plastic)

Coverite 	K::	B	B	E	C	H	A	C
Jeep		Fisher
		40 size - scale - the scale color (tan) is not easy to see

Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Duraplane     MURPHY::	B	B	N	B	B	N	E
               ANKER
	       	Not as crash resistant as they claim. Flies terribly.
		
Flite Line    MURPHY::	B	C	E	C	A/H	E	B
Scooter II     ANKER
		A great little beginner's pattern plane. Building instructions
		are very cryptic.

Goldberg	K::	B	A	N	A	M	NE	A
Falcon 56 Mk II Fisher
		40 size
		Built mine with optional Ailerons - takes ruff landings

Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Great Planes  MURPHY::	B/C	B	E	B	A	E	B
Super Aero-    ANKER
master		Probably the most popular bipe in existence, with good reason.
		Slight strengthening mods recommended.
		
Great Planes  MURPHY::	A	B	E	B	H/A	E	B
Super Sportster ANKER
60		An extremely well flying symmetrical low wing plane. Kit was
		of extremely good quality
		
Great Planes  MURPHY::	B	A	N	B	F	N	B
PT-20 and 40   ANKER
		An ideal first plane. Top-notch instruction book, excellent
		flyer.
		
Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Great Planes  MURPHY::	B	B	N	C	A	N/E	C/D
Trainer 40     ANKER
		Not nearly as easy to build/fly as PT series. Not fun enough
		for more experienced flyers.
		
Kyosho		K::	B	B	N	E	B	E	E
Wingmaster	Fisher
		.10 to .20 size Ultralight - plastic and aluminum
		needs lots of smooth runway - easy to cause expensive damage

Mark's Models MURPHY::	C	C	E	D	T	E	D
Fokker D7      ANKER
		Very inexpensive and  quickly built WW I bipe.  Squirrely
		on the ground and easy to break.  Fun anyway.
		
Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Marks Models	K::	C	D	E	E	M	E	E
Mustang 	Fisher
		Fun Scale - 40 size - Forward fuselage had inadequate strength

Midwest	 	K::	B	B	N	B	AF	NE	B
Das Bipe Stick	Fisher
		40 size - good first Bipe - lands slow - good Aerobatics
		really takes a beating - I cartwheeled on landing 3 time one day

NorthEast       Dan	B	B	N	B	 A	N/E	B	
Train-Air 20	Snow
		A stable  quick  building  4  channel trainer.  Excellent
		plans and instruction book.

Kit name	Revi	<-------Kit quality----->	<-Flying quality->
		ewer	Wo	Pl	Sk	Ra	Cap	Sk	Ra
			od	an	il	ti	abi	il	ti
				s	l	ng	lity	l	ng
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Piece O' Cake   Dan	D	C	E	E	  F      N       A	
		Snow
		Unfortunately this  powered  glider  is  such a miserable
		kit.  The  finished  plane is a fantastic flyer, provided
		you can muddle through to the finish.

Sure Flight 	K::	B	B	N	C	F	N	C
Cessna 182	Fisher
		20 size - all foam - easy to repair in field built mine
		with optional Ailerons

World Engines   Dan     C	C	E	E	  	
Robinhood 80    Snow
		A so-so kit, very little in either instructions or flying
		tips.  Does appear to fly very well.
              MURPHY::  				S/F 	N/E 	B
               ANKER
	       	Extremely scale like. If you dare start with such a big plane
		it's probably the best you can buy. Final product has exteme-
		ly good value. Don't mind not having to build it.