[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference vmsnet::hunting$note:hunting

Title:The Hunting Notesfile
Notice:Registry #7, For Sale #15, Success #270
Moderator:SALEM::PAPPALARDO
Created:Wed Sep 02 1987
Last Modified:Tue Jun 03 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1561
Total number of notes:17784

1004.0. "Just a couple of questions" by SALEM::MACGREGOR () Tue Aug 06 1991 16:42

    I have a couple of questions to ask that maybe some of you fine and
    knowledgable hunters out there can help me and my friend with. First of
    all what is the general opinion of Nosler's Solid Base Ballistic Tip
    Boattails? Second My friend has a Browning Semi-Auto in 30/06 and would
    like to know if anyone has a particular reload that has worked well for
    them in this particular rifle. It's getting close to all kinds of
    seasons and we are just trying to save some time. I will be loading the
    Noslers BTBT's in my 300 Win Mag, 180 gr. From most of the people that
    I have read from and a couple of people that I have talked to I have
    gotten a more favorable opinion about the Ballistic Tips but have heard
    a couple of negatives. What do you people think?
    							Bret
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1004.1forgot to add some info.SALEM::MACGREGORTue Aug 06 1991 16:493
    I also forgot to add that my friend has settled on 165 gr. boattails
    for his reloads.
    							Bret
1004.2balistic tipsKNGBUD::LAFOSSETue Aug 06 1991 18:3520
    Bret,
    
    while you may be able to cut down your "time to market" by getting
    other peoples load data, thats not to say it'll shoot the same in an
    identical rifle. It'll merely give you a starting point, and save a
    little time and money by choosing the better powder for your
    cartrige/bullet combo.
    
    My neighbor is getting excellent results with 4064 in his Weatherby
    30-06... i'll see what i can come up with tonight...
    
    havn't heard of anything about balistic tip results yet... as far as
    accuracy... i'm not getting any outa my .270 using em...
    
    thats not to say you won't... receiving end results on big game???
    havn't heard anything good or bad.  Too soon to tell?  Someone in this
    file must be hunting with em, hopefully you'll get some info
    
    FWIW,  Fra
    
1004.3LUDWIG::BINGCriminal control NOT gun controlWed Aug 07 1991 07:148
    
    I shot some 140 gr ballistic tips out of my 7mmREM MAG. To say the
    least the results were amazing. I shot at a gallon jug of water and
    said "Holy Crap" (you know what I mean) 3 times before the last piece
    of plastic hit the ground. I think they would cause lots of meat
    damage. Just my opinion.
    
                            WB
1004.4Good resultsSKIVT::WENERWed Aug 07 1991 08:369
    
    	I shot a box of 165 gr. Ballistic tips from my .308 Weatherby
    bolt that a friend loaded.  I was cutting bullets at 100 yds with 
    them from a bench!   But, I've also been doing pretty much the same
    with plain old factory 165 spbt Federal Premiums...  Maybe it's the
    gun..?  In any event, they performed well on the accuracy end, can't
    vouch for the results in game tho - 
    
    Rob
1004.5a thoughtOASS::SOBCZYNSKI_LWed Aug 07 1991 08:5115
     
    
    Ref .3 your right, the balistic tips may be an over kill, not that
    their not effective, quite the opposite, their an over kill for deer
    huning.  down at the local fantasy shop we got into a discussion about
    Nosler Balistic Tips, and the previous comment about sums it up.  
    
    Apparently all the bullets manufactured regardless of any features, BT,
    PT etc., do not really have any effect or become critical until after
    'X' number of yards.  'X' would be dependant on the caliber and load of
    the firearm being used.   Up to 100 yards for a 30-06 any ole bullet
    (full load) is accurate, this is my understanding.
    
    ls	
    
1004.6a starting point is what we are looking forSALEM::MACGREGORWed Aug 07 1991 09:3411
    re .2 Yes Fra thats what I was looking for, a starting point. I more or
    less know what I want, it's my friend thats needs HIS starting point. I
    had a 30/06 but in need of money it forced a sale (with the intention
    that I could buy it back) so now all I have is my 300. I am going to
    slow the velocity down a bit, for both bear and deer. One person that
    my friend talked to said they didn't expand too well, would go right
    through what one was shooting at. I suppose it depends on shot
    placement and that would be for just about any bullet. It's all a
    matter ones own opinion I guess. I am going to give the Ballistic Tips
    a shot (no pun intended) and see what happens. 
    							Bret 
1004.7BT = Rapid ExpansionFELICE::keithKeith DilsworthWed Aug 07 1991 11:0110
I read somplace in this file that the Nosler Balistic Tips expand rapidly at
lower velocities.  This winter I bought a TC Contender and read a lot of
articles on the verious calibers and loads.  One of them said that the BTs
performed very well at the Contender velocities due to their expansion
characteristics.  They might tend to be a little to radid expanding for a
300 WinMag.

I am using the 150gr BTs in my 309JDJ Contender.

keith
1004.8Yuck. Too much $ for no returnDECWET::HELSELLegitimate sporting purposeWed Aug 07 1991 12:5318
    I have never had any luck with Nosler anythings out of my .300
    weatherby or my other sweet shooter, an H&K .308  Not only aren't
    they accurate (for me) but they tear the heck out of the meat.  I
    always get them all over the paper at the range.  
    
    I don't know what everybody else shoots, but I'm kind of a velocity
    fan.
    
    For accuracy and a nice hitting bullet, I prefer Sierra Game King BTs.
    I've had great luck with them.  Nice sharp accuracy, minimal damage and
    quick death.
    
    Last year I found that Speer BTs work in a pinch.
    
    fwiw
    
    /brett
    
1004.9WAHOO::LEVESQUEGoing nonlinearThu Aug 08 1991 09:099
 I've got a .270 that I will be using when I hunt this year (in rifle country)
in NH. Since the shots are rarely beyond 100 yards, I am assuming that the
bullet will retain significant velocity when it impacts the deer. Given
the fact that I want to minimize meat damage, does anybody have any opinions
on which factory ammo would be best to accomplish this? Right now I have 130
grain ammo from both Remington and Federal. Should I go to 150 grain to get
the lower velocity? Any particular brand?

 The Doctah
1004.10Federal Hi-Power 150'sSALEM::MACGREGORThu Aug 08 1991 09:257
    In my opinion Federal makes the best factory ammo on the market today.
    I had used Federal Hi-Power and Premiums and was very happy with both.
    I ended up using more of the Hi-Power because it was cheaper and seemed
    to be just as accurate to me as the Premium. I myself have never owned
    a .270 but have fired them on occasion. I would opt for the 150's but
    then again this is just my opinion.
    							Bret
1004.11still looking for a load for 30/06SALEM::MACGREGORThu Aug 08 1991 09:335
    Does anyone have a reload for a BAR? I haven't read a thing here yet on
    my second question. Is there any load for a 30/06 in 165 gr. Boattails 
    that we should consider for a starting point. I will decrease powder
    and work up to a good load. Thanks in advance.
    							bret
1004.12RE: .11BTOVT::MCGINNISMon Aug 12 1991 10:1912
    As I believe it was stated earlier you can buy Federal Premium
    boattails in 165 gr.  I used to shoot 165 gr. in reloads for my 30-06
    long before factory loads were available.  I did this because I could
    never decide between 150 or 180 gr. so the 165 gr. seemed like a good
    compromise.  I've now switched to a Remington model 7 in 308 because
    I've gotten lazy in my middle years and decided a lighter gun was best
    for me.  I still shoot 165 gr. as they are also available in factory
    loads for the 308.  By the way, I find that the new factory loads are
    just as accurate as the reloads I used to shoot.  One more thing that
    I've found is that you don't lose much hitting power when you go from
    30-06 to 308.  The only thing you lose is alot of excess weight to
    carry around.