[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference vicki::boats

Title:Powerboats
Notice:Introductions 2 /Classifieds 3 / '97 Ski Season 1267
Moderator:KWLITY::SUTER
Created:Thu May 12 1988
Last Modified:Wed Jun 04 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1275
Total number of notes:18109

308.0. "Boat Documentation and Citizenship" by CURIE::THACKERAY (Ray Thackeray MR03 DTN 297-5622) Fri Mar 17 1989 16:39

    I'm dumbfounded and speechless, but I just had a conversation
    with 1st Commercial to apply for a boat loan on a 37' motor yacht.
    And was told that, because I'm not a US Citizen (I'm British, living
    here), then I cannot get a loan without an American co-signatory.
    
    That is blatent discrimination, the first I have come across after
    five years in North America......
    
    After all, if I can get a mortgage to buy a house, then why not
    a boat? Damn and bloody blast it, I pay my taxes like everybody
    else here.
    
    The reason given was that it is a "Coastguard regulation", because
    one has to be a US Citizen to document a boat.
    
    Is this true?? I'm going to have to enquire about this, but find
    myself in an extremely awkward position. I can't believe it......
    
    Totally bemused,
    
    Ray
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
308.1Never thought of that?PACKER::GIBSONFri Mar 17 1989 17:208
    Yup. You found a snag. If you want to Document a vessel in the USA
    you must be a US citizen. Only way for you to do it is Cash and
    Carry or find a partner to by the boat with. Its not a "Discrimination"
    type case. It is to protect the country military wise, Just think
    if ol'Col Kadaffy had a fleet of "Yacht's" in our country.
    
                                      Sorry.
    
308.3ARCHER::SUTERI see a little open water!!!!Tue Mar 21 1989 08:5517
Moved By moderator
                  <<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
                      -<           Powerboats           >-
================================================================================
Note 230.9                  Boat Financing Rates 1989                    9 of 13
CURIE::FSMITH                                         8 lines  17-MAR-1989 17:07
                        -< Try Another Finance Company >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Ray, I would check with other financers regarding this issue. I
    am in the process of getting a boat loan through the Maine Savings
    Bank in Portland, Maine. I would be happy to give you the name and
    number if you send me mail. It may or not be true regarding the
    citizenship issue. Follow through and please keep us posted.
    
    Fred Smith
    
308.4if you're Kuaiti, then it's OKARCHER::SUTERI see a little open water!!!!Tue Mar 21 1989 08:5614
Moved by Moderaotr
                  <<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
                      -<           Powerboats           >-
================================================================================
Note 230.10                 Boat Financing Rates 1989                   10 of 13
HPSCAD::WHITMAN "Acid rain burns my BASS"             5 lines  20-MAR-1989 08:17
                      -< if you're Kuaiti, then it's OK >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  Gee,  as I recall last summer there were 14 Kuaiti tankers flying US
colors (i.e. with US documentation)?  Were the owners really US citizens in
disguise?????

Al
308.5a bit more on documentationARCHER::SUTERI see a little open water!!!!Tue Mar 21 1989 08:5721
Moved by moderator
                  <<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
                      -<           Powerboats           >-
================================================================================
Note 230.11                 Boat Financing Rates 1989                   11 of 13
MSCSSE::BERENS "Alan Berens"                         12 lines  20-MAR-1989 08:57
                        -< a bit more on documentation >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As I understand it, yes, you must be an American citizen to document a 
boat. Since many states do not have boat title laws, Coast Guard 
documentation is about the only way a lender has of being reasonably 
sure that the boat you're using as loan collateral is legally yours and 
that there are no liens against the boat.

Documentation also involves something called a preferred ship's
mortgage, the existence of which is recorded on the documentation
papers. This makes it difficult for you to sell the boat without paying
off the mortgage first. The preferred ship's mortgage also makes it
easier for the lender to repossess the boat if you default on the loan. 

308.6Give em a callARCHER::SUTERI see a little open water!!!!Tue Mar 21 1989 08:5719
Moved by moderator
                  <<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
                      -<           Powerboats           >-
================================================================================
Note 230.12                 Boat Financing Rates 1989                   12 of 13
LEVERS::SWEET "Capt. Codfish...GW Fishing Team"      10 lines  20-MAR-1989 09:30
                            -< Give them a call... >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Ray,
    
       My boat is being documented by New England Marine Documentation
    Service ( I got my loan through 1st commercial). Their phone number
    is  617-889-4903. The brochure says two basic qualifications: US
    citizen and a vessel of 5 net tons.
    
    Good luck.
    
    Capt. Codfish  
308.7NOT PERSONAL DISCRIMINATIONARCHER::SUTERI see a little open water!!!!Tue Mar 21 1989 08:5816
Moved by moderator
                  <<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
                      -<           Powerboats           >-
================================================================================
Note 230.13                 Boat Financing Rates 1989                   13 of 13
TYCOBB::J_BORZUMATO                                   7 lines  20-MAR-1989 09:48
                        -< NOT PERSONAL DISCRIMINATION >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    MINE IS DOCUMENTED AS WELL, ONE MANDATORY REQUIREMENT WAS U.S.
    CITIZENSHIP. WHEN IN ROME DO AS THE ROMANS DO. IT ONE OF THE LAWS
    OF THE LAND. I DOUBT THAT THIS HAS ANYTHING TO DO WITH PERSONAL
    DISCRIMINATION. BUT IT INTENTIONALLY DOES DISCRIMINATE FROM
    A LEGAL POINT OF VIEW, AND I BELIEVE IT IS MEANT TOO.
    
    JIM
308.8International, or just U.S.?LUDWIG::BOURGAULTI have a story to tell.....Wed Mar 22 1989 02:5912
    
    Has anybody asked if this is a U.S.-only situation, or is it
    an international custom?  Are there age-old agreements that
    say you must be a citizen of a country to "register" a boat
    there?  Is this a recent (treaty) development?  
    
    I work midnight to 0800, so I can't call up the Coast Guard
    (District headquarters is in Boston, MA.....) and ask about
    it.  Maybe I will be awake enough when I get home to do so...
    if I produce any relevant information, I'll post it....
    
                                      - Ed -
308.9Don't even buy it !!!!USRCV1::FRASCHFri Mar 31 1989 15:209
    I don't know about this being an international requirement but,
    it IS illegal to even sell a documented boat to a non US citizen!!
    Ray, the guy selling you the boat could get his buns in the frying
    pan for doing it! I think I can find the Public Law No. if you really
    want to dig into it but I know it is the law!!
    Before you get into trouble, I would back out of the deal and find
    a non documented vessel!!
    
    Don
308.10CURIE::THACKERAYRay Thackeray MR03 DTN 297-5622Mon Apr 03 1989 11:5019
    Hi Don,
    
    Well, in all fairness, the person selling me the boat was pursued
    by me, not the other way round and we hardly discussed documentation,
    but the next boat I want will be of documentable weight, for sure.
    Of course, I had to back out of the deal when I found out that I
    couldn't get the money!
    
    Anyway, since then, a friend has expressed interest in a partnership
    and we've been looking into the documentation issue, to my satisfaction
    (he, as an American citizen, has to own over half of the boat).
    Now we have to work on the legal issues.....
    
    Tally-ho,
    
    Ray.
    
    PS. Is this law anacronistic or is there a real reason besides the
        issue of international theft?
308.11Documented VS "Documentable"SMART5::JGUNNERSONJLGFri Jun 09 1989 14:129
    (Ok, so I am catching up after being away for a long time). There is a
    difference between a boat that is documented and one that is
    "documentable". A non-US citizen can by a boat that isn't documented,
    but is eligible to be documented, there it is "documentable". If this
    person wishes to use it than they would register it as any other boat
    might be. A large boat can be registered only, it doesn't have to
    documented. Of course financing is better if you can document it. 
    
    john 
308.12CURIE::THACKERAYRay Thackeray MR03 DTN 297-5622Fri Jun 09 1989 15:343
    But doesn't any boat over a certain displacement HAVE to be documented?
    
    Ray
308.13BMT::SAPIENZAKnowledge applied is wisdom gained.Fri Jun 09 1989 18:5111
    
    .12> But doesn't any boat over a certain displacement HAVE to be documented?
    
       Nope, not mandatory as far as the government is concerned. However,
    most lending institutions require documentation for their own peace of
    mind. (Tracking a documented boat is easier than tracking a registered
    boat, in the event of theft or misplacement that is.)
    
    
    Frank