T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
218.1 | Need to compensate for the bow down effect. | NAC::SWEET | Capt. Codfish...GW Fishing Team | Wed Dec 14 1988 08:42 | 11 |
| While I do not know the exact rules about adding tanks I would say
that besides safty you must think about the trim of the boat and
how it will ride when that new tank is filled. If you have tabs
you can probably compensate for it but if not you may be running
bow down. I suppose you would only fill this tank when you really
will need it, since 80 gallons should handle most day trips. If
you really only need in once in long while, then carry a couple
of jugs...many a boat has run to the canyons with 4 or more of these
to top off the tanks on the way home...
Bruce
|
218.2 | It's been done... | ARCHER::SUTER | Water is meant to ski on! | Wed Dec 14 1988 08:49 | 7 |
|
I know some manufacturers actually put tanks in the bow. A
former member of this notesfile, Dan Sullivan, had a 19' Larson
with the onboard tank mounted up front. It also helped the boat
to plane when pulling skiers.
Rick
|
218.3 | Greater risk than I'd like! | CIMNET::CREASER | Auxiliary Coxswain | Wed Dec 14 1988 11:13 | 21 |
| Best check with the Coast Guard for specifics of a bow mounted tank.
A couple of considerations are:
Any addition or modification of your fuel system deserves careful
planning for a secure mount (don't want it bashing about....the
bow generally has far greater motion and shock loading than a position
close to the boat center of gravity), full ventilation (remember
the gasoline fumes are heaver than air and will settle in a vee
berth area....likely means having only spark proof electricals such
as switches and motors/blowers), static protection grounds and
if you are considering permanent fuel lines, the routing and protection
of the line pose additional thought.
It's rather far fetched, but I would wonder about added risk during
a bow-on collison especially without added structural support around
the tank.
Just be careful!
Jerry
|
218.4 | "FUEL" for thought! | NRADM::WILSON | Rick Wilson DTN 234-5218 | Wed Dec 14 1988 11:29 | 32 |
| RE:
>> I have no room under the deck but need more fuel and thought
>> I would put a tank under the V-bunk is this ok by coast guard rules?
I don't know whether the Coasties would approve of this or not, but
common sense dictates that it should be a no-no. You are looking to
store gasoline in the passenger compartment of a 27' boat, which I
ass-u-me will at times be ocupied by people. People who may light
up a butt, switch on a light, turn on a stove, etc.
I believe that the previous replies which mention boats that have tanks
under the bow are talking about open boats, with below decks areas that
are used strictly for storage of life jackets etc.. This is a totally
different situation from a 27' cruiser. In an enclosed boat, gasoline
fumes can accumulate from a leaky or improperly vented tank, worn or
cracked fuel lines, spilled fuel from overfilling or sloshing. This
can cause an explosion and fire that you will not be likely to forget,
if you manage to survive.
A few years ago some guy made an ocean crossing an 18' or 20' outboard
powered boat, with the boat being almost a floating fuel tank. One of
his biggest fears during the entire voyage was the threat of fire.
In your case the convenience of extra fuel may not be worth the risk
if the only place to store it is in the cabin. Have you checked with
Silverton to see what their recomendations are? Maybe they know of
a safer place for your extra fuel.
Just my $.02 worth.
Rick W.
|
218.5 | Thanks for the help | MAMIE::CASEY | | Wed Dec 14 1988 16:33 | 5 |
| Thanks for the help, maybe the best bet is to LIVE with what I have
and not take any chances.
Thanks
Tom
|
218.6 | Bow tank & reconfigure seats | KAHALA::SUTER | We dun't need no stinkin' skis, (sometimes) | Wed May 15 1991 16:38 | 45 |
| Moved by moderator
------------------
<<< VICKI::SIE$DATA0:[NOTES$LIBRARY]BOATS.NOTE;1 >>>
-< Hit it! >-
================================================================================
Note 840.0 Need help with re-configuration No replies
SITBUL::FYFE 36 lines 15-MAY-1991 15:11
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have a 1973 Glastron 16.5 run-about with a closed bow. It has a
70hp outboard on the back.
I currently carry between 2 and 3 6-gallon fuel tanks in the aft
compartment (depending on the days activities).
What I need is a sanity check.
I would like to put a fuel tank in the bow, perhaps 15 gals.,under the
deck. There is ample room to do this. I have seen other boats of
similar construction and configuration with the fuel tanks in the
front so I know it can be done. The question is should I do it?
Reasons:
There is a lot of weight in the back of the boat with the battery and
fuel and no storage available for anything else in the back. What I
want to do is remove the weight and gain some useful storage.
What I would like to do is mount a back bench seat which would fold
up for access to the aft compartment and storage. The two front folding
seats might even get replaced with swivel seats.
All of this would make use of the unused space under the deck, move a
significant amount of weight forward, gain more usable and easier
accessed storage space, make more room inside the boat for
people(read: comfort), and give me a summer project to keep me out
of trouble :-)
Expenses will be minimal (under $300) or the job will not be done
(I'm cheap).
Comments, suggestions, ideas?
Doug.
|
218.7 | Don't do it! | SONATA::DUBIE | My name isn't DUBIE! | Thu May 16 1991 09:31 | 13 |
| I tried this with my 16 foot Lyman (with closed bow) which I use on the
coast of Maine. Actually I was installing a propane tank for the stove
but the concept is similar. After a considerable amount of time and
work, I tried out the configuration. It took about three minutes to
realize that it was a TERRIBLE idea! The bow was much too heavy and the
boat would not handle in, what I consider to be, a safe manner. Since
it's a rather small boat and it's used in sometimes quite choppy
waters, the lightness of the bow is very important to stay above the
waves. So I put the tank in the stern along with the battery and four
6-gallon tanks which is a lot of weight but the boat handles MUCH
better. BTW it has a 50 Yamaha with newly-added but untried Doel fins.
Ben Day
|
218.8 | Not that much weight! | MR4DEC::DCADMUS | | Thu May 16 1991 10:48 | 25 |
|
I'M not sure I agree with the previos response. Gasoline weighs about
6#/gal, so that makes abut 100# added weight (I assume you will use an
aluminum tank), equivalent to about 15 Gal of water that would have to
be dispalced by the hull sinking lower. I used to carry
anchosr,jackets, tools, spare parts, plus a spare full gas can under
the bow of my old 17' Thompson and really never saw much difference in
handling or abilty to handle some heavy seas.
It really depends on the design of the Hull. IF you have a narrow bow
and not much flare, the bow will drop much more than a boat like my old
thompson which was pretty beamy up frward and hasd a pretty good flare
at the bow.
Another option you may want to consider is to add gunwale tanks that
mount on either side of the hull.
A good selection of tanks at reasonable prices is available from
Defender Industries in New Rochelle, N.Y- their adress and phone number
are elsewhere in this conference.If you do put in a bow tank, you can
get a triangular tank tat will minimise wasted space. IF you put a tank
in the bow,make sure it is fastened down securely! The motion in the
bow is much more than at the stern, and you don't need a 15-16 gal
tankful of gasoline bouncing around when the weather turns foul.
|
218.9 | Now I've got to find a tank ... | SITBUL::FYFE | | Thu May 16 1991 12:34 | 17 |
|
The aft end sits so low in the water I think it might actually benefit
from having some weight up front. I can't really increase the usable
space without moving the fuel forward so that will be my first
priority.
The bow flares out quite a bit and will 'slap' the water in rough seas
as opposed to plowing down and thru so I don't think that will be a
problem. I haven't climbed into the bow yet but I am wondering if
I will have to reinforce the hull before adding the new fuel tank.
After thinking on it a while I figured I can build the back folding
bench seat to fold out flat to become a 'sun deck' :-)
This could really be a fun project ...
Doug.
|
218.10 | | WONDER::COYLE | | Thu May 16 1991 14:00 | 6 |
| If the weight and balence, center of gravity is the main concern,
maybe you should put an equicaalnt weight up there and take the
boat out with relatively empty tanks. Sort of a preproject
test ride.
-Joe
|
218.11 | Another thing to look out for... | TOOK::SWIST | Jim Swist LKG2-2/T2 DTN 226-7102 | Thu May 16 1991 14:46 | 6 |
| I know you said your boat rides down at the stern but you still might
want to check whether the bilge drainage system is depending on the
current angle - I know in my boat that I have a marginal situation with
regard to bilge water not necessarily collecting at the rear of the
boat. If I added 100# at the bow, I'd exacerbate the problem.
|
218.12 | FRONT TANK FOR SKIING WITH 15'+OUTBOARD | TMCUK2::SURPLICE | Ken Surplice - Euro MicroVAX, PDP prd mgr | Thu May 16 1991 17:16 | 10 |
| My 15' speed/ski boat + 100 Outboard came with a 5 gallon tank and
battery in the stern compartment.
The battery is still at the rear but I've moved the fuel to the front
where there are now two tanks holding 5+10=15 gallons in total.
Much better for skiing. In fact, at the end of the day when fuel is
running low, the boat handling is noticably worse.
Cheers- Ken
|
218.13 | Ventilation of the compartment... | BINKLY::SMITH | | Fri May 17 1991 10:38 | 9 |
|
One other thing to consider in placing the gas tanks in the
bow is ventilation. Granted you do not have an engine
creating a spark up there but I would think it would be
just unwise on principle to place gas tanks in an unventilated
compartment. All you would need is a spark or a smoker to get
near the bow and BOOM... your weekend is ruined.
Mike
|
218.14 | Looks good so far ... | SITBUL::FYFE | | Mon May 20 1991 13:04 | 28 |
|
I looked under the bow thisweekend and found the perfect spot for the
tank. It looks like this
/\ -
/ \ |
/ \ |
/ \ |
/ \ |
/ \
/ \ 26"
| | -
| | | |
| | | |
| | 13" |
| | | |
| | | |
-------------- _ -
|---- 14" ---|
with about 18" in height. It is all reinforced by the boat flooring.
Where would I go to have a custom tank built? Out of what material?
The hardest part will be getting the tank under the deck.
Doug.
|
218.15 | The old standby... BOAT/US | GOLF::WILSON | Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure | Tue May 21 1991 10:27 | 12 |
|
Doug,
I dont' think it's necessary to have a tank custom built. Check
the BOAT/US catalog, they've got all different sizes and shapes
of gas tanks, one of which should fit your boat. This should
save you a lot of time and money over having one custom made.
If you don't have a catalog, give me your mail stop and I'll send
copies of the appropriate pages. Or stop by my house some night
since you live right in Milford.
Rick
|
218.16 | vent it... | HYEND::J_BORZUMATO | | Tue May 21 1991 12:54 | 11 |
| Besides BOAT U.S there are various other places to buy tanks.
Boat U.S. is a good choice.
One othere thing, do't forget to vent the new tank, with an overboard
vent.
IF you don't you cannot draw fuel from a vacuum, and gas fumes in
a confined area, can be a nasty suprise..
JIm.
|
218.17 | Made like it belongs there ... | SITBUL::FYFE | | Tue May 21 1991 15:54 | 8 |
|
You can be sure that once this is done it will look and perform
like factory.
I do wonder if the fuel pump on the 2-stroke will have any difficulties
with the extra fuel line distance though ...
Doug.
|
218.18 | | DNEAST::OKERHOLM_PAU | | Fri May 24 1991 16:38 | 3 |
| Re .17>
I think it may actually pump better since the tank may be higher.
The pump should be more effected by height than distance.
|