[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::space

Title:Space Exploration
Notice:Shuttle launch schedules, see Note 6
Moderator:PRAGMA::GRIFFIN
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:974
Total number of notes:18843

241.0. "CHALLENGER: A MAJOR MALFUNCTION" by CHEV02::MARSH (Jeffrey Marsh, DTN 474-5739) Wed Jan 07 1987 22:14

I saw a book in the store last weekend, "Challenger: A Major
Malfunction" by Malcolm McConnell.  The teasers on the dust cover
read like a synopsis of an episode of "Dynasty" and the only
quoted reviewer whose name I recognized was Barry Goldwater(!) who
wrote, "I couldn't put it down."  (Perhaps the senator plans to
review books now that he's retired.  :-)  )

Here's the $18 question:  Is this book just lurid sensationalism
or is it serious journalism?  I don't have a chance of getting it
through my local so-called library and I'd like to know if it's
worth buying.

Has anyone read this book or seen a review of it?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
241.1An unfriendly reviewSKYLAB::FISHERBurns Fisher 381-1466, ZKO1-1/D42Thu Jan 08 1987 12:5356
    From Space World, Jan 87:
    
    Challenger: A Major Malfuncition
    Review by John Rhea
    
    "investigative reporters are like hunding dogs,@ Pres. Carter's
    press secretary Jody Powell once observed. "If you keep them in
    the kennel too long, when they get out all they want to do is snap
    at buterflies and [urinate] on the pickup truck."
    
    Instead of a pickup truck, Malcolm McConnell, the resident space
    expert at READER'S DIGEST <that tells you something about it...bf>
    has directed his attentions at the Space Shuttle and NASA.  The
    results are comparable.
    
    No one even remotely assoicated with the Challenger tragedy of a
    year ago escapes McC's crossfire.  NASA Admin James Fletcher is
    accuesd of rigging the award of the solid rocket booster contract
    to Morton-Thiokol in his role as "leading member" of the :mormon
    Mafia".  Public Affairs Director Shirley Green is supposed to have
    funneled White HOuse pressure on the launch team to get Challenger
    off on time so Pres. Reagan could reap political dividends from
    teacher-in-space Christa McAuliffe during his State of the Union
    speech.  Congressman Bill Nelson's "junket" on the previous Shuttle
    flight is said to have prevented needed spare parts from being
    available in time for NASA to meet the original Challenger deadline.
    The who-said-what-to-whom litany of discussions between the booster
    managers from Thiokol and Marashal Space Flights Center on the eve
    of the launch is trotted again.
    
    Although McConnell cliams to have sources somehow not available
    to other reporters, there is a universal lack of revelations in
    this book.  A skillful rewrite of the Rogers Commission report,
    yes, and there is a particular poignancy in his firsthand description
    of the scene at the VIP viewing site as Challenger exploded, but
    this is not the expos� that the imflammatory dust jacket ("A True
    Story of Politics, Greed, and the Wrong Stuff") would lead you to
    believe.
    
    <Another third of a page or uncomplementary description deleted due to
    tired fingers>
    
    In the publicity barrage accompanying the book's release this month,
    Doubleday concedes it took a few liberties with its own launch schedule
    in order to get it out in time for the anniversary of the disaster
    (although denying it was a "quickie" book)--and incidentally, beat
    a competing book due out in March from Crown Publishers.
    
    It would be conforting to think this next book, Prescription For
    Disaster by Joseph Trento, might be an intidote to McConnells hysteria.
     But don't bet on it; Crown describes Trento as an "investigative
    reporter" for Cable News Network.  Back to your kennels until you
    can tell butterflies from pickup trucks!

    
    Burns
241.2STRATA::RPETERSONWed Mar 30 1994 00:085
    can you tell me where I can find current info on the latest findings or
    newly released info about the CHALLENGER disaster.
    
    thanx
    Bob.