[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::fddi

Title:FDDI - The Next Generation
Moderator:NETCAD::STEFANI
Created:Thu Apr 27 1989
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2259
Total number of notes:8590

1294.0. "gigaswitch configuration valid?" by CGOOA::CRICK () Sun Mar 27 1994 23:31

We are planning on using Gigaswiches in the following configuration:



		 _____A|Router|B___A|Router|B___________________________
		|							|
		|	Dual Ring					|
		|							|
		|____A|GigaSwitch1|B_________________A|Gigaswitch2|B____|
			||...|				   ||...|
			|	Dual Rings		   |
			|				   |
			|_A|Bridge|B_A|Bridge|B_A|Bridge|B_|
				|	|	   |
				|	|	   |
			    -------- --------  ---------  Ethernet Lans

In this configuration the routers, Gigaswitches and Ethernet/FDDI bridges are
all DAS connections.  Gigiaswitch1 will be set up as the root bridge.  Several
Bridges rings will be connected to the Gigaswitches as shown above.

Is the following true?:

1. The customer feels that the Ethernet/FDDI bridges DO NOT require 
spanning tree for this configuration to work.

2. I assume that in this configuration Gigaswitch2 will detect a loop and 
disable the port that connects the Bridge ring.  The Bridge ring will then wrap
at the last bridges B port.

3. If Gigaswitch1 then fails, spanning tree will be recalculated and Gigaswitch2
will enable the port that connects the Bridge ring and the ring will then wrap
at the A port of the bridge connected to Gigaswitch1. 
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1294.1Flip the A-B ports...CGOOA::CRICKSun Mar 27 1994 23:352
    The A-B ports on the Routers should be reversed in my diagram.
    
1294.2KONING::KONINGPaul Koning, B-16504Mon Mar 28 1994 15:078
1. If you have a loop, you need spanning tree.

2. In this case, one of the ports ends up in backup state, but that does NOT
   wrap the ring.  All that happens is that the port is not used for bridging.

Why the prejudice against spanning tree?

	paul