[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::fddi

Title:FDDI - The Next Generation
Moderator:NETCAD::STEFANI
Created:Thu Apr 27 1989
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2259
Total number of notes:8590

311.0. "Synernetics competition" by EISJKC::CYR () Thu Jul 25 1991 18:19

The Northeast Government Accounts Group (NGAG) is currently having a bit of
difficulty competing with Synernetics' LANplex 5004 modular hub in an FDDI/
Ethernet extended LAN configuration.  Digital's hardware totaled $360K, at 21%
discount for the configuration.  Synernetics' hardware solution was quoted at 
$185K.  This is almost 1/2 of Digital's quote!

I am checking further into the proposed configuration to see if we are comparing
equivalent solutions.  I also have a technical question that I would like to
have some assistance with.  I believe that the following is a representation
of part of the network configuration.  Doesn't this break the "2 repeater"
Ethernet rule?


	+-------------------+
	|  LANplex 5004     |
     A  |-------------------|  B
    ----|  FDDI Enterprise  |----      punch-
    ----|  Access Module    |----      down 
	|-------------------|          +----+      
	|  Ethernet Express |----------|    |------REPEATER------ ThinWire drops
	|  Module (10BASE-T |----------|    |------REPEATER------ ThinWire drops
	|  Repeater)        |----------|    |------REPEATER------ ThinWire drops
	|-------------------|          +----+
	|  Spare slot       |
	|-------------------|
	|  Spare slot       |
	+-------------------+

Aren't there 3 repeaters between the ThinWire stations on different 10BASE-T
ports?  This configuration is also shown in Synernetics' marketing literarure.

Joe Cyr
Network Consultant, NGAG
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
311.1KONING::KONINGEesti vabaks!Wed Jul 31 1991 14:007
The Ethernet conference is a better place for the repeater question.

On the cost comparison: could you show what the configuration looks like?
I assume the piece you drew was just a small part, since that clearly
doesn't come anywhere near $100k.

	paul