[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::fddi

Title:FDDI - The Next Generation
Moderator:NETCAD::STEFANI
Created:Thu Apr 27 1989
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2259
Total number of notes:8590

160.0. "Fiber, a "Fad"?" by SUBWAY::HABER () Tue Oct 23 1990 16:21

    Hi All,
    
    Iave a customer who feels FDDI is just a "fad" that will be replaced by
    something else in a couple of years.  This guy is an IBM bigot and is
    probably talking from his IBM sales rep.
    
    Has anyone heard or read anything that might fall in line with what my
    customer thinks?
    
    Thanks
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
160.1Just a few thoughts...STKHLM::WEBJORNGullik Webj�rn TSSC Network SupportFri Oct 26 1990 08:3628
    I have heard the same type of comments, especially from people with
    interests in syncronous signalling techniques, ( T1, T3 and the like ).
    
    My comments are usually:
    
    1.	Fiber is here to stay, why else is all the PTT's replacing fiber
    with copper?? Fiber has already happened!!!!
    
    2. FDDI is unique in that the whole computer industry has adopted the
    technology, and products have actually WAITED until all the standards
    work was done. This assures a success that will by far surpass
    ethernet. There will be no 802.3 vs. ethernet type debate.
    
    3. Because of the total industry support, competing technologies will
    probably have a hard time carving out market share, FDDI will have a
    cost advantage over any competing concept to come up. ( There is really
    no compettition today, is there ?? ) Maybe other things will come, like
    sonet, dqdb, and whatnot, as long as there is no SIGNIFICANT advantage
    in speed, throughput, distance the economy of FDDI will be most
    important.
    
    4.	Sure 1 Gbit or higher speed or technology will come eventually, but
    FDDI will still have it's place for a long time. Higher speeds will
    most certainly be fiber though.....
    
    
    	My_5_cents_worth	/Gullik
    
160.2IBM is moving to fiberJANUS::BARKERJeremy Barker - T&N/CBN Diag. Eng. - Reading, UKFri Oct 26 1990 14:566
Re: .0

Interestingly IBM have recently announced fiber-optic channels for the
System/390 (ESCOM is a term that fits in somewhere).

jb
160.3Let the outsider sell it FOR you.GLDOA::TREMBATHPeter. Call when you get work...Sun Nov 04 1990 19:2116
    Your rebuttals will probably be seen as DEC propaganda no matter what
    you say. Get this guy to open up any trade magazine, outside
    consultant's editorial, DATApro's articles on the future etc... and let
    them win him over for you.
    
    For example:
    
     " If you work for a Fortune 1000 company, there is FDDI in
       your future " - George F. Colony, President of Forrester Research
     		       November, 1988
    
    If the individual is a key player, you might want to pick up his tab
    and send him to an industry trade conference on FDDI or Networking. 
    Get in touch with NAC Marketing or Engineering for a suggestion on a good
    conference.