T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
253.1 | Here is the chart | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Wed Aug 07 1991 11:31 | 46 |
| Account Requirement Monthly Additional Optional
Service Features Services
Fee
BASIC *Direct deposit FREE | |
Checking or $100 payroll |Dividends on balances |
deposited, AND |> $1000 |PayMate Bill
balances >= | |Paying Service:
$1000 | |$.25 transaction
|Unlimited Checkwriting|$1.00/monthly
*Direct deposit or | |minimum
$100 payroll $2.00 | |
deposited, AND | |Personal
balances < $1000 | |ADVANTAGE
|Limited Overdraft |Credit Line
*No direct deposit |Protection |
or $100 payroll $2.00 | |Personalized
deposited, AND | |Checks
balances >= | |
$1000 | |
| |
*No direct deposit | |24-Hour ATM
or $100 payroll $4.00 | |Access:
deposited, AND | |DCU ATMs -- FREE
balances < $1000 |Network ATMs --
|$1.00 per
-------------------------------------------------------------|transaction
|
DCU PLUS CD balances >= FREE |Dividends on balances |24-Hour EasyTouch
Checking $2500 |> $1000 |Access FREE
| |
CD balances < $5.00 |Unlimited Checkwriting|All-Occasion Gift
$2500 | |Checks -- $2.50
|Limited Overdraft |
|Protection |
| |
|$500 ADVANTAGE |
|Credit Line |
| |
|Purchase Protection |
|Program |
* Your direct deposit or at least $100 of your payroll automatically deposited
weekly to your BASIC Checking Account.
|
253.2 | DCU Brochure Verbage | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Wed Aug 07 1991 11:48 | 75 |
|
LIFESTYLE CHECKING
MORE CHOICES!
MORE OPTIONS!
"You can choose any color you want, as long as it is black"
Henry Ford -- 1908
That was Henry Ford's approach to the automobile industry at the turn
of the century. If you wanted automobile transportation, you had to buy a
black Model T. How things have changed!
"Choice" is the watchword of the American consumer today, as well it
should be.
At DCU, we have taken a positive approach to offering our members
diversified, high quality, competitively priced products and services. We
have restructured and expanded our checking accounts so you can select the one
that best matches your lifestyle.
We are very pleased to announce the introduction on September 1, 1991
of two new checking accounts -- our BASIC Checking Account and the DCU PLUS
Checking Account -- designed to give you flexibility and unlimited access to
your funds. These two accounts will replace our existing Share Draft Account.
Both new accounts offer you unlimited checkwriting, overdraft
protection, the option to access your funds with an ATM card or by any
touch-tone phone and earn dividends everyday your account balance is $1,000
or more. Please refer to the reference chart and enclosed General Disclosure
Statement and Truth-in-Savings Disclosure for complete details on our new
accounts.
--- BASIC Checking Account ---
Since most of our members have their pay deposited directly into their
checking account, we built our BASIC Checking Account around direct deposit
and payroll deduction. This account is free of monthly service fees if you
maintain the necessary balance requirement, AND have either your direct
deposit or at least $100 of your payroll automatically deposited weekly to
your Basic Checking Account.
And, to protect you against the embarrassment and costs of overdrawing your
account, we have a free, limited overdraft protection feature. Each month,
DCU will automatically transfer funds (maximum of 3 transfers per month) from
your Primary Share Account to your BASIC Checking Account to cover drafts
drawn on insufficient funds. All optional services are available with this
account.
--- DCU PLUS Checking Account ---
Have you ever asked yourself, "Why do banks make me keep a minimum balance in
my checking account when I have money deposited in Certificates of Deposit
(CDs)?" Well, we have! And that's why we developed the DCU PLUS Checking
Account. There is no minimum balance requirement in this account, and it's
free of monthly service fees when you have $2,500 or more in CDs at DCU, in
your own account.
Every DCU PLUS Checking Account comes with free, limited overdraft protection,
a $500 Personal ADVANTAGE Credit Line for credit qualified applicants and a
unique Purchase Protection program, so purchases made with DCU PLUS Checking
Account drafts are protected against theft or damage and have double warranty
period. All optional services are also available with this account.
--- Tell us which account you want! ---
So you may choose the type of checking account you want, we have attached an
Account Selection Card to this folder. Please take a moment to complete the
Account Selection Card and return it to us. Whichever account you select, you
may continue to use your existing drafts. If you do not return the card by
September 1, 1991, your current Share Draft Checking Account will
automatically change over to a BASIC Checking Account on September 1st.
|
253.4 | | CVG::EDRY | This note's for you | Wed Aug 07 1991 13:33 | 7 |
|
In my opinion this is the STUPIDIST thing DCU has ever decided to
due. I've been a member since they opened, but not for long!
I will call HQ and give them a piece of my mind too!
|
253.5 | | CVG::EDRY | This note's for you | Wed Aug 07 1991 13:46 | 10 |
|
RE: .3
Can you provide a pointer (telephone number) to NFCU?
Anyone else know of other institutions that offer free unlimited
checking with no minumum balance??
- Bob
|
253.7 | Free - r = fee | KOALA::FAMULARO | Joe MS:ZKO3-2/X07 DTN381-2565 | Wed Aug 07 1991 13:58 | 23 |
| Just called HQ.
Reasons for fees...
1) Loans down
2) Delinquencies up
3) Deposits down
4) Services up
It takes money to run a business and they've got to get it from
somewhere.
What upsets me is that if my balance drops from $1000 to $999 for ONE
day I'm going to get hit with that $2 fee. The fee should be applied
based on the average daily balance for the month.
I told the customer service representative that DCU should of sent out
a letter to all members explaining why they took this course of action
and the cost justifications for doing so. She told be she'd forward
the suggestion up the chain.
I'll be looking for the letter!
|
253.8 | Let's not all withdraw at the same time!!! | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Wed Aug 07 1991 14:03 | 22 |
|
I surrender. DCU, you have killed me with kindness and concern. You
have smothered me with options and choices when all I ever wanted was
value; a reasonable rate of return and access to reasonable loans.
This completes the transition of DCU from a credit union owned by it's
members for its members, to a bank in it for the money. The members of
this institution should FLOOD the phone lines of DCU (8-223-6735) with
calls of protest concerning this. I assume nothing like this could happen
without approval of the BoD. Who are the people we should send our
thank you notes to???
If any out there had any doubts what-so-ever about what DCU is and
where it is going, this should crystalize the picture for you. Makes
me wonder if all this additional revenue is required to replace the
anticipated loan losses.
Well, the timing couldn't have been better! I was about to order
checks. I guess I'll still have to, except from the bank down the
street.
Chow DCU! It's been real. And pretty unreal at times.
|
253.9 | I guess DCU doesn't want the business... | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Wed Aug 07 1991 14:15 | 60 |
| I have spoken with several DCU members in this facility (DCO, Landover
MD) this morning. Almost all indicated that they would close their DCU
checking account. None of them were happy about the information.
Now that DCU wants to deprive us of the one benefit (i.e., "real" free
checking) which caused many (if not most) of us to join DCU in the first
place, DCU will be evaluated on its remaining merits.
Cost: The cost of BASIC checking is low ($2-4), but the cost of ATM
usage is high ($1 per trans). Other local (to DC/MD/VA)
banks offer flat-rate checking for a slightly higher price,
but many offer unlimited access to their own ATMs for free.
There are no free ATMs for DCU in the Mid-Atlantic area.
Convenience:
There is a single office in all the Mid-Atlantic. It is
highly available to those who work in the building, but
many people are located elsewhere or work on-site during the
day. DCU has no evening hours. Other banks offer multiple
branches with evening hours. This will be even more
critical now that several local offices are being combined
into one new large office several miles from here.
ATMs: DCU has no local free ATMs. To find a usable ATM, one must
locate a CIRRUS machine, which may mandate a considerable
drive. Other banks have copious free ATMs. And just about
every bank in the area subscribes to the MOST network,
making practically ANY ATM usable for a fee (FYI: last time
I saw an ATM which wasn't MOST was about 2 years ago; that
back has since joined in).
Rates: DCU's interest rates seem consistently low, compared to most
area banks. They are "competitive" with some, but I can't
name a bank with lower interest rates.
Communication:
This is the first bank I've worked with that announced
major fee changes with LESS than a month's notice. I STILL
wouldn't know about it if I hadn't happened to see a
brochure while I was filling out a withdrawl form! And the
tone of the brochure! I can't imagine any bank having the
NERVE to call a fee increase an increase in our "choices"!
Other: EasyTouch is a plus, but highly available MOST machines and
free local ATMs can easily cancel this out. Overdraft
protection is also a plus, but it is hardly unique.
Bottom Line:
Perhaps this is an inventive way of handling complaints
from DCU members out of the Northeast. Now that they've
dropped their major competitive edge, they seem to be
encouraging people to bank elsewhere. I hope that the
revenues from the fees will cover the losses from the
inevitable account closings.
As for me, I am beginning my search for a new bank TODAY!
Sadly,
-- Russ
|
253.11 | Time to start looking at other options.... | HDLITE::HORTON | Ken Horton, KA1GFN | Wed Aug 07 1991 14:52 | 20 |
| I just just talking to one of the tellers here in Marlboro as I had some
questions on the new accounts.
On the BASIC checking, the $1000 minimum must be in the checking account.
Balances in other accounts do not count toward this minimum. That means having
to keep $1000 in an account that pays a lower interest than a savings account.
I usually have enough in savings, not in checking, to meet this minimum.
In our case my wife and I each have an account. This means having to keep
$1000 in each checking account or pay the service charge for each account.
As far as the PLUS account, I cannot see having to keep $2,500 in a CD
to get free checking and paying $5 if the CD balance drops below this and
other account balances are not considered.
I have always kept DCU mainly for the convenience and may continue to do
so. At the same time I will probably consider moving my saving deposits to
another credit union which pays higher interest rates. I have been considering
this for awhile but the time has now come. I would have to pay the $2 fee but
will make it up on the other end.
|
253.12 | | PEACHS::MITCHAM | Andy in Alpharetta (near Atlanta) | Wed Aug 07 1991 14:54 | 8 |
| > "You can choose any color you want, as long as it is black"
> Henry Ford -- 1908
How ironic that they chose this quote to boldly place on the literature
going to DCU members. The irony is, no matter what choice I have, it
will still cost me. That is, unless I withdraw my funds from DCU...<sigh>.
-Andy
|
253.13 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Wed Aug 07 1991 15:01 | 18 |
|
>Reasons for fees...
> 1) Loans down (rates stink)
> 2) Delinquencies up (they said they are still lower than the norm)
> 3) Deposits down (down even further now)
> 4) Services up (why? we obviously don't have money for
them)
Wait a minute!! Isn't this the same line of B.S. they fed us when the
credit card minimums and rates were jacked up? We are all being taken
for fools. Let's see how much more money they get when people start
closing accounts. Don't they know this kind of logic hasn't worked for
the government and won't work for them???
I'm totally convinced there are idiots running this credit union. At
least right now. In the future? That is up to us...
|
253.14 | I actually won a point.. | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Wed Aug 07 1991 15:10 | 38 |
| I just got off the phone with DCU, and actually got them to
change a ruling in my favor.
I have a line-of-credit account, and NON-USED Checking, and
a savings..
I DON'T use, never HAVE used, never WILL use the checking
account. I don't even have checks for the account. However,
it seems that the account was set up when I applied for the
Line-of-credit. To be used as a clearing account for any
draft checks I write against the L.o.C.
After reading the responses here, I called.. Sure enough
they said I was going to be charged $2. a month any month
that I wrote a LOC draft... Because it would clear thru
the checking account, it would set the flag for a charge..
I argued, successfully, that I don't have a checking account,
that they (DCU) set it up for a clearing area. After about ten
minutes of going back and forth, I was put on hold. When the
clerk returned, she said if I simply closed the checking account
then they would use the draft account as a clearing account,
and I wouldn't be charged a monthly fee.
News Flash...
While I was writing this, I thought I'd call my local DCU
office to find out about closing my Checking account.. Sure
enought, all I have to do is visit them and sign a form to
close the account. Seems the DCU has changed policy lately
that you don't need a checking account to have a LOC account.
Anyways.. I'll keep the LOC account (The rate is still pretty
good... around 11 1/8), and my emergency savings account.
Boy.. Am I glad my wife works for a bank, so we get free ATM
and checking.. Along with interest. :-)
|
253.15 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Wed Aug 07 1991 15:52 | 8 |
|
RE: .14
> Anyways.. I'll keep the LOC account (The rate is still pretty
> good... around 11 1/8), and my emergency savings account.
The current rate for the unsecured line of credit (what they call the
Advantage LOC) is 17.25%. You must be referring to the Equity LOC.
|
253.16 | I am outta here! | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Wed Aug 07 1991 16:11 | 5 |
| I just got off the phone with DCU Headquarters. The rep I talked to
seemed to be writing down my comments. She tried some of the same lines
used in the brochure, but I didn't bite. I've been a member since day
one. But not any more.
Denny
|
253.17 | | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Wed Aug 07 1991 16:16 | 28 |
| re .15
You're right... This is really a second mortgage LOC...
A co-worker just noticed something else..
-- You only get interest on your balance
-- if the balance is over $1000
What this means is.. Not only won't we pay interest
on your $999.99, but we'll charge you a fee besides..
The few people I've talked to here will be closing
their checking account, and looking elsewhere..
Not only because of the new fees, but also because of
lack of notice... What ever happened to a 60-90 day notice..
The trouble is.. Even if some people do close accounts,
DCU will make money in the long run.. Those that stay
will be either those that don't mind paying the service
charge (ie.. "I'll end up paying it to someone..), or
those who can afford to leave $1000 balance at all times.
DCU makes money from the small guys with a fee monthly,
or by loaning out the larger balances...
I know it stinks... but I'm not surprised
|
253.18 | | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Wed Aug 07 1991 16:32 | 5 |
| ...But they do lose my paycheck going onto their balance sheet every
month. I've talked to about a half dozen people with checking. All but
1 are pulling out. I'll probably pull my savings too, because if they
go under I don't want to have to wait for the Government to pay me off.
Denny
|
253.19 | Another essential service offered | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Wed Aug 07 1991 16:40 | 20 |
|
RE: .2 (DCU brochure)
>Every DCU PLUS Checking Account comes with free, limited overdraft protection,
>a $500 Personal ADVANTAGE Credit Line for credit qualified applicants and a
>unique Purchase Protection program, so purchases made with DCU PLUS Checking
>Account drafts are protected against theft or damage and have double warranty
>period. All optional services are also available with this account.
And is this another "additional service" we have been screaming
for? Are the additional fees going to replace somebodys blender that
broke out of warranty? Is the what a credit union is for? Come on
DCU. This is ridiculous.
>--- Tell us which account you want! ---
We want what we have now!
Stop trying to help us before you bankrupt us...
|
253.20 | me and mine | AKOCOA::OSTIGUY | Digital Internal Use Only | Wed Aug 07 1991 16:58 | 13 |
| Not only do I have to close out my checking account but each of my
kids have one too......
What a waste. CDs, Savings, CRTs, RSVP....all will be going away
assuming there are more reasonable banks out there.
Maybe I'll go to that guy on T.V. selling CDs in Govt. funds who give
a FREE checking acct. Just ticks me off that I ordered (small batch) of
new checks two weeks ago.
Adios DCU !
Lloyd
|
253.21 | if enough leave, maybe they'll change their minds | HAVASU::HEISER | mountains robed in glory | Wed Aug 07 1991 19:23 | 7 |
| After they closed the PNO branch, I stayed with them because of the free
checking and Visa.
I just found out (for you westerners) that First Interstate has free
checking with automatic deposit. I no longer see a reason to stay.
Mike
|
253.22 | Are idiots running the DCU? | SMAUG::GARROD | An Englishman's mind works best when it is almost too late | Thu Aug 08 1991 01:18 | 32 |
| Does anybody know if there is a way to get free checking by keeping
money in any other account other than checking? If the answer is NO
then it's BYE BYE DCU for me.
My checking account bounces up and down as I write check. I'm not going
to fund it to the level to make sure it doesn't drop below $1000 at
all. It annoys me enough trying to make sure it doesn't drop below 0
anbd exercise the credit line but at least that is only a few cents
charge until I notice and refill it.
With my Baybanks account they don't care about the checking account as
long as I keep a certain amount of money in the Money Market Account.
Also how come they're springing this on us with less than 1 months
notice. This is the first I've read about it (ie here in this
non-official channel). I presume official notice comes 2 weeks before
1st Sept in our monthly statements.
Finally I have a few things to say to DCU administration:
1, Changing the rules with next to no notice stinks.
2, Getting the members to pay for screwups the DCU board and
management made in giving loans to bankrupt institutions
is not the way to run a business.
3, Your policies are driving the institution into the ground
4, You've lost me as a customer if you can't come up with a way
for me to maintain free checking without having to watch my
checking account balance on a daily basis. I'd even accept
an average minimum over a month rather than an absolute minimum.
5, We have far more choices than Henry Ford's customers and DCU
won't be on a lot of peoples lists if you continue with these
ascenine policies.
|
253.23 | Free == $5/month? | TOOK::ROSENBAUM | Rich Rosenbaum | Thu Aug 08 1991 02:04 | 13 |
| .1 implies (states, actually) that there will be no interest earned on the
first $1000 in your checking account. I presume one could get at least
6% interest by placing that $1000 in an account _somewhere_. So one
loses the opportunity to earn $60/year (say).
In other words you end up paying $5/month. (More if you could earn
>6%, of course.)
Seems it would be better to keep a minimum balance (near $0) and pay
the $2/month...
Rich
|
253.24 | | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Thu Aug 08 1991 09:02 | 4 |
| Merchants NAtional Bank in Leominster has no fee/ check charge
checking accounts. You only pay for buying your checks. I'm stopping on
the way home.
Denny
|
253.25 | Cooper Bank- | MACROW::MCEVOY | Make Schembechler what Gibson is - GONE! | Thu Aug 08 1991 10:27 | 11 |
|
Cooperative Bank in Littleton/Groton -
FREE checking (plus graduated interest) if either:
- keep 500$ balance
OR
- Get paycheck direct deposit to them
508-635-5000
|
253.26 | DCU R.I.P. | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Thu Aug 08 1991 11:02 | 93 |
|
I'd like to ask very specific questions concerning the reasons they
gave for instituting fees on checking. I realize it will be a cold day
in hell before I get any answers but I'll ask anyways.
1. Loans down
A. What loans are down?
B. Did it ever occur to the management of DCU that the loan
policies may be the reason?
C. Did it ever occur to the management of DCU that the loan
rates may be the reason?
D. Have you considered lowering rates to stimulate business?
E. If the money can't be loaned to members it is "parked"
in a liquid investment to collect interest. So DCU shouldn't be
losing money. Is this not the case?
2. Delinquencies up
A. Delinquencies on what are up? Mortgages? credit cards? LOC?
B. Have you considered increasing the cost of THOSE services
instead of levying a fee on checking accounts and people who are
NOT delinquent?
C. Have you considered tightening your policies on these delinquent
proan services or adding additional criteria to reduce them?
D. Exactly what are the delinquency rates and are they higher than
the industry norm?
E. Are you not already accounting for delinquency when offering a
service?
3. Deposits down.
A. How will this new fee on checking increase deposits?
B. What else has DCU done or considered to stimulate deposits?
C. Why are falling deposits reason to institute a checking fee?
4. Services up.
A. Why are you adding adding services which eliminate a basic
service which members depend on?
B. Why are you adding services which are not self-supporting?
C. Who decides what services will be offered?
D. Is a service offered by DCU forever (free checking wasn't) or
will it be terminated if deemed unprofitable?
E. Where is the money coming from to provide the new service of
insuring items purchased with DCU checks?
F. Why is DCU offering a service (insurance of purchases) normally
associated with credit card companies?
Commentary:
In my opinion, this change and the change to the Visa card minimum
purchase have the same objective. DCU has the ability to calculate
with a reasonably high degree of accuracy the amount of money they
will be gaining from the changes and know exactly who they will be
affecting.
In the case of the credit cards, I believe DCU is trying to get rid of
members who use their credit card wisely and to their (members) advantage
by paying the balance every month and those who use their cards
infrequently. A free Visa card isn't free if you have to purchase $2000
more than you otherwise would. Maybe DCU miscalculated and Digital
employees pay off the balance more than the norm. But doesn't DCU make
money on any charges made with the card? Are you still losing money
DCU?
In the case of this recent change, DCU is targeting members who maintain
their money in higher interest accounts and move it to checking when
needed. And members that don't have thousands to park in their
checking are just too much overhead for them. This will encourage them
to go elsewhere. It appears DCU doesn't need or want the small saver
anymore. I guess they've gotten too big to give a damn about them.
DCU now is instituting changes which are designed to cull out the
membership.
The Digital Credit Union does not exist anymore. The Bank of Digital
now stands in it's place. The reasons why DCU got so big and has been
so successful don't exist anymore, or they are fading fast. What is
left is an institution and management who don't give a damn about the
very reasons the credit union exists in the first place.
People out there had better realize that the next election for the
Board of Directors and the next annual meeting may be their last chance
to save what is left of DCU and correct this very disturbing change of
course. If the current group of people are left at the helm any longer,
the DCU we knew will be just another stinking bank. There are plenty
of those around. What we want and need is a credit union.
Phil
|
253.27 | Another Bank in the C/S Area | CSC32::B_HARRISON | Bruce Harrison | Thu Aug 08 1991 11:24 | 5 |
|
Since (as .-1 put so well!) DCU is now the Bank of Digital, does anyone
know of another Bank in the Colorado Springs area that offers free
checking?
|
253.28 | | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Thu Aug 08 1991 11:53 | 29 |
| re: .23 (no interest on the first $1000)
I may have this wrong, but I don't believe that is the case. The chart
states that there would be interest on "balances > $1000", as I recall.
That should mean (I hope) that a $1001 balance will earn interest on
the entire amount. But a $999 balance would earn no interest.
re: short notice
I am still floored by this! It was an _ACCIDENT_ that I happened to
come across the information in the first place! I'd love to know when
the first reader gets an "official" notice from DCU in the mail. I
also find it interesting that they chose to do the nonsense during a
big vacation month, where few people are around to complain!
re: the brochure
This is a serious error on DCU's part. They honestly believe they can
disguise a simple rate hike by saying it adds to our "choices". I
cannot trust a financial institution which has gone to such lengths to
bury the truth! If I can't trust what they say, how can they expect me
to trust them with my hard-earned dollars?
Do other branches have these brochures out as well? This information
must get out to people NOW! Please feel free to forward my postings in
.1 and .2 to anyone who is interested. Give others the option to
withdraw their funds before they get blind-sided with the fees!
-- Russ
|
253.29 | Please forward to DCU and BOD | UGETIT::ATKINSON | | Thu Aug 08 1991 12:05 | 10 |
|
Would the Moderator please officially forward this conversation,
appropriately cleaned up, to the spokesperson to address the many
issues brought up here. The DCU management should answer these
comments. Also, the entire listing should be forwarded to all
Board members, as they should have mail accounts, awareness of
this discussion, and access to this NOTES file to respond if
they dare.
Dave
|
253.30 | They will be arriving in the statements for last month. | HDLITE::HORTON | Ken Horton, KA1GFN | Thu Aug 08 1991 12:07 | 3 |
| I was told by one of the tellers that the brochure is being mailed along with
everyones statement this month. Statements should be arriving any day now. I
picked up mine already at the MRO4 branch where I work.
|
253.31 | ACT AS A GROUP OF OWNERS!! | TYFYS::MEEHAN | A lot of professionals are crackpots -���- | Thu Aug 08 1991 12:16 | 28 |
| I also feel that the DCU has made a MAJOR mistake in trying to
hide a rate hike by saying they are adding to our "choices".
The only problem with people closing their accounts, is I don't
believe the DCU will see the error they made. The only way I
can think of to get this point across it to have people close
their accounts in mass. There is nothing like a mass of angry
customer to get a business' attention. Because the DCU is trying
to act like a "business" instead of a credit union, I think we the
member should act as we would with any business where we are the
majority share holders. ACT AS A GROUP! This will get the attention
I think we need. Seeing we can't affect the management or the BOD
(notice BOD can stand for Board of Directors or Bank of Digital -���-)
we need to do something that will make these two groups take notice
that the owners (that what we are) are not happy with their management
or the services we what and feel we need. The DCU is there to serve
us, that what we want and that what we require. Until the DCU learns
this and start acting like a credit union, they've lost me.
I for one am going to close my checking account and I am trying to
organize at least my fellow employees to all go over on the same
day to do the same. I do plan on leaving a token draft account of
$10. So I can vote my dissatisfaction with the BOD when the time
comes. When the VISA comes up for renewal I'll cancel that.
One_who_is_feedup,
Jim
|
253.32 | More data from DCU | PLOUGH::KINZELMAN | Paul Kinzelman | Thu Aug 08 1991 12:58 | 13 |
| I just spoke to DCU and told them that I thought their advertising
campaign smacked of sleezy marketing as opposed to honesty. I can get
the sleezy approach elsewhere. Even if news is bad, and I had to start
paying for my account, I'd prefer the up-front, honest approach of
saying, I'm sorry, but because of x, y, and z, we now have to start
charging and here are your options. I said that I thought they were
insulting our intelligence with their sleezy advertising approach of
trying to convince us that it was really to our advantage.
I also asked about interest if you keep $1001 in the account, and it
drops to $999 for one day out of the month. For all the days of the
month, you get interest on $1001, except for 1 day when you get no
interest.
|
253.33 | And how about some accountability??? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Thu Aug 08 1991 12:59 | 25 |
|
Without a doubt, it is time to stand up and be counted on our part.
And in the same vein, I want to know who, by name, instituted or voted
for this abomination. To try and make it seem like they are doing us a
big favor, almost like we wanted this, is pure deceit. As an owner
(for now) I want to know what individual or groups of individuals are
so out of touch with its membership. I also want to know who did NOT
want to institute this. No babies with the bath water here. But it's
time for accountability on DCU's part. Enough is enough. The BoD,
Officers, Loan Committee, etc. are comprised of PEOPLE. Who are the
people responsible? Who voted for insuring broken blenders instead of
providing a basic service to it's members?
Somehow, I know what the reply will be....
During these difficult times of declining deposits, increasing
delinquency, and declining loans it would be detrimental to DCU to resign
or step-down,..... or come forward.
Meanwhile, the poor tellers, branch managers and people who answer the
phones take the heat.
|
253.34 | there *were* the best of times -- this is the worst of times! | CVG::EDRY | This note's for you | Thu Aug 08 1991 13:21 | 16 |
|
we the owners of DCU aren't allowed accountability from the BoD!
they are in their own world, one that is out of touch with the world
the members/owners live in. after seeing DCU flourish at times during
the past 12 years, i now feel the institution has come full circle and
is embarked on a course that is out of step with what was, and has
always been, a members basic service credit union. instead of fair
rates for loan/deposits, we pay more and receive less, instead of free
checking and low minumums, we have high balance requirements and
frivolous services.
the BoD, each and every one of them, should be voted out of office and
fresh blood infused into the institution. maybe then we can see DCU
return to what it was during the good times...
|
253.35 | I thought I saw some there | HAVASU::HEISER | sleep with 1 eye open | Thu Aug 08 1991 13:40 | 6 |
| Re: Colorado Springs area
Don't you have a First Interstate there? Free checking with auto.
deposit if you do. They're all over the west.
Mike
|
253.36 | Deja vu! | NEST::JOYCE | Ms. Chievious | Thu Aug 08 1991 13:56 | 19 |
| This reminds me of the time several years ago when the Bank of
New England took over Guaranty Bank. The first thing they did
was raise all the fees, which essentially drove all the small
customers away. *Everyone* I know who had an account there
closed it and went elsewhere. My brother told me of the day he
was in line closing his account. It seemed evryone else in line
was doing the same thing.
This is the same Bank of New England that was recently taken over
by the feds.
And, somehow I'm not surprised that they tried to pass this off
as "more choices". After all, this is the same organization that
has advertised a 1 hour middle-of-the-day closing as a way to
serve us better!
Guess I'll be shopping for a new bank.
Maryellen
|
253.37 | RE: taking the feedback to DCU. | BEIRUT::SUNNAA | | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:03 | 10 |
|
Carl Leeber has been the person who takes care of forwarding the
notesfile entries to DCU and have been relaying back DCU responses to
the questions and issues.
I will discuss with Carl this specific topic and how we go about
cleaning it up and relaying the responses to DCU.
Nisreen Sunnaa
Moderator
|
253.38 | | BEIRUT::SUNNAA | | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:06 | 8 |
|
I am wondering how much this sudden fee increase have to do with DCU's
Ex-President's scandal. Does this warrant a question on how much $$
was really involved, and are we paying the price for it now..?
I think it is time to look for another bank.
Nisreen
|
253.39 | Naaaaahhhhhhh. Just another service... | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:14 | 6 |
|
RE: .38
I had wondered the same thing but did not want to mix disasters and be
so cynical. But one definitely has to wonder. Too many coincidences
usually is no coincidence.
|
253.40 | Petition? | MACROW::MCEVOY | Make Schembechler what Gibson is - GONE! | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:27 | 3 |
|
Would a petition of some sort help? Could we use a note in
this notes file for petition/signatures?
|
253.41 | | BEIRUT::SUNNAA | | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:31 | 6 |
|
re: -1
See note 255.0
|
253.42 | | BEATLE::REILLY | So I rewired it... | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:36 | 19 |
|
I am so glad that I took my checking account and auto deposit
elsewhere back when DCU first started pulling these kinds of moves.
I'd hate to have to feel "rushed" to find a new bank before September
1st.
Problem is, I still have a savings account there and I have a small
amount automatically deducted into that account every week. I think I'm
gonna pull that out now, too. DCU is just starting to annoy me.
At first I thought they were just inept. They may be; they are
certainly stupid enough to believe that we would be fooled by a ruse
such as this "choice" promotion. But I have a feeling the noter
who said DCU knows exactly what they are doing may be right - they
have decided who they want to do business with and are giving the
rest of us incentives to leave. In either case, I fear for the
solvency of an institution that offers NO reasons to keep money there.
- Sean
|
253.43 | Combine drives? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | It's on my list | Thu Aug 08 1991 14:37 | 8 |
|
RE: .40
Any petition or signature drive should include a petion to get members
on the BoD election ballot. Or is this only restricted to 2 months
before the election? My guess is there would be PLENTY of people to
choose from besides the incumbants.
|
253.44 | NFS in new Hampshire has some free accts | STAR::PARKE | I'm a surgeon, NOT Jack the Ripper | Thu Aug 08 1991 15:09 | 10 |
| In New Hampster, NFS Savings Bank has a "Passport" checking account
which has no fees, and the first checks are free.
An added Benefit, they return your checks with the statements, which
DCU never has.
On to DCUageddon
Bill
|
253.45 | A piece of my mind | CNTROL::STECKO | | Thu Aug 08 1991 16:43 | 30 |
|
A teller at the DCU in the facility where I work, when asked why
this sudden change to checking account fees said that there are
80,000 DCU checking accounts and 8,000 of them maintain near $0
balances, and that these measures were taken to eliminate these
non profitable accounts.
Now I don't know how accurate that is but, I hardly believe
that this would be the only reason, especially when they are
requiring a $1000 balance to dodge the monthly service fee. I
think this tellers response shows that the DCU management hasn't
even adequately informed its employee's of the changes and their
reasons.
I agree with an earlier reply that the only way to make the BoD
understand how we feel about this sudden change and the seeminly
underhanded way that it is being introduced, is to act in mass.
I plan on looking around for a local bank with free checking,
while keeping the minimun $5 in my savings account to vote
for someone who represents my needs and wants in the DCU. I also
plan on calling the DCU main office and giving a piece of my mind
on the way that they handled this: under 1 month notice, no
reasons explained, and the underhanded way it was introduced (ie.
the "More Choices, More Options!" brochure, which is written to
sound as if the DCU is introducing something that will benefit
DCU members.
My $.02 worth....free of charge,
Ted
|
253.46 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Thu Aug 08 1991 18:29 | 5 |
| I think it would be a marketing coup for banks in areas with
high densities of DCU members to advertize specials for DCU
members who switch to their institutions.
Joe Oppelt
|
253.47 | | BUNYIP::QUODLING | I'll have some of what Marketing is Smoking... | Thu Aug 08 1991 18:41 | 56 |
| A couple of observations...
The brochure from DCU says "You can choose any color you want, as long
as it is black" How prophetic. This will be a black day, for the DCU
and its shareholders.
8000 un-used accounts. Have they tried something mundane like asking
the people if they really need them any more... THey probably can't
even contact most of them now.
IN this time of economic trouble when most of us have semi willingly
accepted no or minimal pay rises over the last few years, they expect
as to have sufficient funds to just leave $1K as a "place holder"
Also, looking at the brochure
* Unlimited checkwriting. (Boy wouldn't it be nice to get them
back...) Does this mean that checks will be free? It certainly infers
it. Hmm, I wonder if the Cafeteria will accept checks as payment for
lunch...
* Limited Overdraft protection. So that they can move money between
your accounts without notifying you... I have this feature with my bank
back in Australia, it doesn't cost any extra, but at least there I
trust the good sense of my Bank Branch Manager (as he is a personal
friend, and has to sign off on any transfers).
* $500 Credit Line - Give me a break, I receive 3-4 offers a month
for credits cards offering 3-10 times that credit. There is no mention
of the "cost" of that credit line...
* Personalized checks. You mean like the ones I have now, with my name
on them, that I pay DCU far more for than I would at "Current","
Check's in the mail" or any of the other check printers, who
incidentally offer several styles of check, and dozens of
colors/patterns.
* All occasion gift checks. $2.50 to send someone a check (Now there is
a real personal gift...) that says "Happy Generic Day" on it...
* Choice is the watchword of the American Consumer today, as they say
in their literature. And everyone else that I have ever seen that
introduces a new level of service will retain the existing service as
one of the choices. What is being offered is not a choice. It is two
options, both of which will now cost us more money than we have spent
in the past.
I'll give the DCU the grace of a week or so, to recant this ridiculous
decision, and then I'll be off to one of the many banks that offers
better interest rates, better services, less hassles and better
management. (And as has been shown, there are more than enough of those
around in this competitive economic climate.)
Peter Q.
|
253.48 | How stupid do they think we are? | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Thu Aug 08 1991 19:08 | 12 |
| Sigh. For the first time in over 10 years, I'm looking for alternate
banking services. The gaul! I've got $X (5 figures) in an IRA
account, and they're going to charge me for checking! As a "charter
member", my loyalty is about to come to an end.
The DCU is a joke. Can we call for a recall of the entire board?
I for one will not vote for any of the incumbents on the next election
of BOD.
I haven't read this whole thread (I will extract and read it later)
so sorry if this has been said before.
|
253.49 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Thu Aug 08 1991 19:29 | 6 |
| If I choose the $2500 CD option (as if I had the money to
simply do that) would it count for all 3 of my checking accounts
at DCU? (Mine and 2 family accounts.) At least that would
beat having to keep $3000 total in the 3 accounts...
Joe Oppelt
|
253.50 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Thu Aug 08 1991 19:30 | 3 |
|
Oh, I get it! This is an April Fool's joke a half year
early!
|
253.51 | | ILUVNH::BADGER | One Happy camper ;-) | Thu Aug 08 1991 22:36 | 3 |
| Since Digital promoted direct deposite, and since petty cash is set up
for EFT, I wonder Digital's involvement. Does anyone have a list
of other banks Digital will make paycheck deposits into?
|
253.52 | direct deposit | TOOK::ROSENBAUM | Rich Rosenbaum | Fri Aug 09 1991 00:36 | 13 |
| re .-1: Does anyone have a list
of other banks Digital will make paycheck deposits into?
To the best of my understanding...
Any bank that ties into the Automated Clearinghouse (ACH) system.
In other words, any bank.
Get the form from personnel. You'll probably have to supply a voided
check (from the destination account) with the form back to Digital.
Rich
|
253.53 | Read the fine print.. It stinks | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Fri Aug 09 1991 09:09 | 54 |
| I received my statement yesterday. With all the comments
about this fiasco, I decided to read the pamphlets.
Enclosed were three items..
o Lifestyle Checking.. (Explains the new Checking features)
o Schedule of Fees..
o Member Agreement..
Enough has been said about the Lifestyle Checking brochure, that
I won't get into it..
However.. There are a few points from the other books that I
found disturbing.
I don't have a checking account with DCU, and am I glad I don't.
At most (if not all) banks, you get your checks returned with
your statement.. Now I keep my checks for X years (I currently
have 5 years worth), just in case I'm audited or a mix payment
at a business..
If I read the 'Schedule of Fee' brochure correctly, (and please
correct me if I'm wrong), if I needed a copy of my check, they
would charge me $1.00 for item ($10.00 if before 6/87).
I suppose they think their doing me a service by holding the
checks for me..
Here is from the 'Member Agreement'
General Disclosure Statement:
4. All accounts are subject to DCU's Fee Schedule
which may be changed from time to time without
notice.
5. We (DCU) reserve the right to change any provision
of this Disclosure and to establish, from time to
time, rules and regulations concerning any account,
which will be available for inspection upon request.
One other thing. The so called 'Purchase Security / Extended
Protection' for your purchases made by check...
THIS SERVICE IS ONLY IN EFFECT BETWEEN
01-SEP-91 AND 31-OCT-91
Are they serious... The d*mn service is only for two months...
Like I said earlier.. Thanks but no thanks..
|
253.54 | More free checking | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Fri Aug 09 1991 09:20 | 6 |
| 1st Safety Fund Bank had an ad in the local paper last night for
Free Checking*. They have branches in Leominster, Fitchburg, Gardner,
Worcester, and either Northborough or Westborough.
Denny
*No Fine Print
|
253.56 | Not unique to DCU... | SCAACT::AINSLEY | Less than 150 kts. is TOO slow | Fri Aug 09 1991 10:08 | 7 |
| re: .55
Actually Al, if I remember correctly, all Federally (sp?) insured banks/savings
and loans/etc. can hold your money for some long time after you ask for it.
It's in all their fine print.
Bob
|
253.57 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 10:15 | 3 |
| Re: .55: So, transfer your SHARE account (savings) balance to your
SHAREDRAFT account (checking) and write a final "to close account"
check.
|
253.58 | Nashua Trust | KOALA::FAMULARO | Joe MS:ZKO3-2/X07 DTN381-2565 | Fri Aug 09 1991 10:20 | 2 |
| Nashua Trust - $500 minimum balance, 4.75%, no fee as long as balance
does not drop below $500
|
253.59 | One unhappy customer | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 11:12 | 36 |
| I just spoke with Mary Madden (DCUHQ, DTN 223-6735 x207). I encourage
you to call her directly instead of speaking with one of the human
answering machines who are just taking notes.
Bottom line, is they're complaining about the expense of servicing the
checking accounts and say that their fees are less than other financial
institutions of their size (80000 members). This may be true, but
their interest rates are also less, and their checking service is
cheaper to deliver (no returned checks). Somehow, it doesn't
feel like any real "benchmarking" was done. They somehow think their
competition is Citibank when in reality their competition is the local
banks in Gardner, Fitchburg, Shrewsbury, etc.
I pointed out that we, the members, ought to have some say in how
our services are created and delivered. I was quite happy with DCU
before they put in VISA. If their expenses are so high, how about
dropping the VISA accounts?
She metioned the ATM card. I countered with a $1.00 fee to use it on
any machine noother than the DCU installed machines, and mentioned that I
wouldn't even need a ATM card with my local bank because their branch
is close by.
I pointed out that my $x (substantially greater than the $2500 CD
requirement) in IRA accounts is a longer-term deposit than a 90-day CD.
They didn't quite understand that. (The answer was one filled with
rhetoric, inferring that she was off-guard on the topic.)
I told her that since I can find better rates on savings accounts,
loans, and fee-less (or lower caps, like $500 instead of $1000) by
shopping around, that my ONLY reason for staying with DCU is one of
convenience. It used to be that the DCU offered real savings. Now
they look like any other bank.
I may keep my account (since I have a second mortgage with them) but
I'm likely to move most of my business elsewhere.
|
253.60 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 11:19 | 10 |
| That was the specifics. Now for the general:
How can we return the control of the DCU to us? It appears that the
board of directors is marching to a drummer other than than us - their
owner and customer.
Does the charter allow for a recall movement? I am beginning to feel
that the DCU board should be removed. The incumbents are getting
complacent. I thought they were doing a good job. Now I can see they
weren't. It's time for a change.
|
253.61 | | USOPS::GALLANT | Chiquita Cherry | Fri Aug 09 1991 11:32 | 35 |
|
Well I read through about half of the replies listed here
and while I don't normally participate in this conference,
I felt the need to voice my opinion on this situation as
well.
Like most, I, too, had absolutely NO knowldedge of this
happening. I was in a DCU branch yesterday and noticed
the flyer - but thought it was an OPTION, not a REQUIREMENT.
What CHOICE are you giving me, DCU?!? (FWIW.. I got the
actually "official" word last night in my statement)
The economy isn't in the best of shape and we're in a
recession - GASP! - maybe there are a few of us out there
who don't HAVE $1000 to put into your facility and even
if we DID - wouldn't put it into a CHECKING account.
(I know mine would go RIGHT into a savings account)
This absolutely INFURIATES me. The main reason I chose
to come to the DCU was because my former bank was charging
me up the ying-yang to have my money there. Are you here
for us or are we here for you????
I've currently got three, yes THREE checking accounts
with the DCU. Now I'm not only not going to get interest
(which I don't get anyway because I'm not "rich" enough)
but I'm going to get slapped with $6/month because I
know full well that I won't be able to keep a balance
of +1000.
If and when I can find a bank/credit union with free
checking, etc... it's see ya later DCU.
/Kim
|
253.62 | I have enough trouble keeping 1 checking account balanced... | SCAACT::AINSLEY | Less than 150 kts. is TOO slow | Fri Aug 09 1991 11:46 | 6 |
| A minor rat-hole here...
re: .61 and others, why do you have more than one checking account? Business
on the side?
Bob_the_curious
|
253.63 | These charges are going to cost Digital. | HSOMAI::KISER | Engage mind THEN activate fingers. | Fri Aug 09 1991 11:58 | 25 |
| I just sent the attached memo to the Traveletter Department because I
refuse to pay the DCU charges. So much for DCU's actions being totally
separate from Digital. I don't follow DELTA_IDEAS notes. Has the
impact of this come up there?
Subject: Reimbursment for My Future Travel Expenses
Xxxxx,
I understand that you are the one to contact regarding the automatic
deposit of expense reimbursement in to a DCU account. Since I am
currently having this done, I need to arrange for you to discontinue
it.
Recent changes in DCU policy are forcing me to close my checking
account with DCU before September 1, 1991, therefore I no longer desire
to have my expenses deposited there. I realize that, depositing
expenses this way, has aided Digital's cost reductions and I regret
having to make this change, but I have little choice under the
circumstances.
Thank you.
Jim Kiser
|
253.64 | Any others you noticed that increased? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:03 | 21 |
|
Other interesting things from their "Schedule of Fees":
ATM services with savings account $1.00 per month
Point of Sale transactions (what are these?) $0.25 per transaction
RSVP (over 3 withdrawals per month) $10.00 per withdrawal
Certified Check (used to be $0.50??) $3.00
Stop Payment (used to be $5!!) $15.00
OK, DCU. There are also MAJOR increases hidden in some of these new
fees! Which ones are new? And which ones have increased and what was
the old charge?
We are being taken in more ways than one people!
|
253.65 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:06 | 15 |
| A few other items:
"Purchase Security" and "extended protection": When did these
"services" show up? And, who asked for them, and how much is it
costing the DCU and us? If it is costing the DCU as much as a penny,
it is costing us interest and increased fees for a service that I, for
one, didn't ask for. Besides, if you read the Ts & Cs, you'll see that
it's a gimmick. They only pay for the excess loss over and above what
your normal insurance doesn't cover. Please, DCU, take this away.
Second: "Inactive accounts": My children have what would be
considered inactive accounts. They have small savings accounts set up
to teach them the value of savings. Now the $2.50/quarter fee will
make these accounts cost more than they return. So much for teaching
kids good savings habits.
|
253.66 | | NEST::JOYCE | Ms. Chievious | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:06 | 35 |
| I also called Mary Madden (yesterday) to express my displeasure
with this new policy.
My major concerns were with the lack of notice and the
uncompetitive pricing. I was told that the announcement was
within regulations, and encouraged (several times) to shop
around. I responded that I thought a credit union which is
allegedly owned by the members owed its members more notice than
we got. And, I don't understand how an institution run for the
benefit of its members needs to charge more for its services than
businesses who need to make a profit. I got what must be the
party line about this being a business decision. I also heard
that business is down, the 88,000 members are spread across the
country increasing costs, and loan defaults are up (but are below
the industry average). And, again, i was encouraged to shop
around.
I believe the DCU has severely underestimated the response it
will receive from its members about this new change. I will shop
around. My preliminary research indicates most financial
institutions in the area are cheaper than doing business with the
DCU.
I encourage everyone displeased with this decision to call and
express your opinion. Ok, so even if you like it, call. It will
be interesting to see what happens.
One more thing, the person who answered the phone refered to
"they" who made the decision. I was told it was both the Board
of Directors and high management that decided on this fee
increase.
Maryellen
|
253.67 | | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:09 | 23 |
|
BTW...
If you try to cash a check at the DCU
and you are not a member, the check
cashing fee is $2.00 per item..
Now, what about the poor guy who doesn't
have an account, but gets his petty
cash check (because we no longer get
cash from petty cash (oxymoron maybe))
, anyways to stay on subject.. He
needs the cash for business, the only
way is to cash at DCU.. Wham.. $2.00
charge..
They seem to make it manditory to at
least keep a savings account...
THAT's IT...
Lets all of us keep a $5.00 saving
account...but no checking accounts.
|
253.68 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:21 | 18 |
| Re: $5.00 savings account.
I was just wondering. They penalize you $2.50 a quarter for an
account with less than $100 balance.
What if you only have $5.00 (just so you can cash checks, say)?
Where are they going to take the $10.00 a year from? And, what is
the cost of servicing all those $5.00 a year accounts?
I will find it difficult to totally abandon DCU - at least in the very
short term future - because I have a car loan and a 2nd mortgate.
However, it would be fairly easy to change from a source of revenue
(with IRA, savings accounts, weekly deposits - I earn interest, but
they do too) to a source of expense only (only the loans, and the loan
holding accounts). Then, talk about expenses. What happens if we all
take our deposits away, and leave them servicing only debt? Without
deposits they can't make loans at all. Then see how much longer they
last.
|
253.69 | | CVG::EDRY | This note's for you | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:33 | 25 |
|
Shop around they say:
Well I did... I called 10 different banks in southern NH area and this
is what I found:
NOT ONE had a minumal checking account (a reasonable number of free
checks no interest type) that wouldn't wave the monthly service fee
(most were $5 per month) if I kept $500 in the account.
MANY would wave the service fee for $300, the lowest was $250.
A LOT didn't calculate the minumum on a daily basis, but rather
considered that *average* monthly balance. Where DCU yanks your for
$2.00 if you fall a penny bellow $1,000.00 for a day, alot of
commercial institution are more liberal by allowing average monthly
minimums.
In short, DCUs $1,000.00 average daily balance minumum was *way out of
wack* with the commercial institutions in the area.
So, DCU, what's this shop around crap suppose to prove, just how bad of
deal (err.. choice) you giving us???
|
253.70 | | DEMON3::CLEVELAND | Notes -- Fun or Satanic Cult??? | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:34 | 17 |
| Boy--millions get looted in a real estate scam, but it took a lousy
$2/month to get my blood boiling...and boy, is it boiling!
I don't doubt that the loan losses had something to do with this. They
have gone from having one of the best checking account deals around, to
the worst. I don't think it's some sort of miscalculation...they
appear to be in bad enough shape to require these moves. Instead of
this, they might have closed some of the branch offices, but as I've
just been NEXT-UNSEENing through here, I've seen "we want Bay area
office", "we want Seattle office", etc. I think that it's this
obsession of the members and board to open human-staffed branch
offices that has driven the DCU to the brink of disaster, possibly to
pushed over by a real-estate scam and a member exodus.
See you, DCU...and I just ordered 600 checks...
Tim
|
253.71 | Ever hear of belt tightening??? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 12:53 | 27 |
|
RE: "go shop around"
This attitude is absolutely appalling. I interpret this as take a hike
if you don't like it. Business decision my arse. There is more going
on here than we know, and that they are telling us.
As a member, I want to know DCU expenses. I want to see how many
people work for DCU and if they have cutback anywhere. All these "new
services" require people to administer them. I find it no coincidence
that one of the first menu choices you hear when calling DCU is "enter
3 for DCU employment". Digital and everybody else is slimming down,
cutting back. What has DCU done to follow suit? Have salaries been
increasing? Have freezes been employed? Or have they just gone full
speed ahead with all these new services at the expense of the very
basic services a credit union is supposed to provide?
I fear we have created a monster which has now turned on it's creators
for it's last meal. With a potential membership base shrinking (DEC)
can DCU afford the loss of thousands of it's members and survive as a
financial institution? I have a substantial deposit from the sale of
stock that I was planning on making. Right now that money is going to
the new institution that my "shopping around" has so EASILY found. If
I put it into DCU, heaven knows what tricks they will pull to keep it
there (30 day notice to withdraw?). This disaster could create a run
on DCU that it had better be prepared to handle.
|
253.72 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:01 | 23 |
| >So, DCU, what's this shop around crap suppose to prove, just how bad of
>deal (err.. choice) you giving us???
It certainly shows that, but it also shows something else:
We (DEC) are having Six Sigma implanted in our brains. One of the
important points of Total Quality Deployment is making sure that you
deliver goods and services that customers want. One way to find out
what they want (in goods and services) is by asking them. I don't
think we were asked. [Nee, I know so - there was no survey.] Another
important mechanism is "benchmarking" - comparing your goods and
services to others offering similar goods and services. It would
appear that the DCU management echelon benchmarked the *existence* of
fees, but failed to benchmark the magnitude and scope of those fees.
I got the clear message that they understand fees are common, but I
have no idea how the fees were established, and if they did any
comparison in the marketplace, then they must know that their fee
structure is way out of line. Two possible conclusions come to mind
here. (1) They're blind/naive and/or don't care -or- (2) they really
want to go out of business and this is the first stage of the fire
sale.
|
253.73 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:06 | 12 |
| Oh, here's another chuckle from this morning's phone conversation.
After citing DEC's desire to become "leaner and meaner", I asked what
DCU has done to trim their fat. I was told they'd closed the Phoenix
branch.
Of course they did! The whole plant was closed.
So, painful as it may be, why not consider closing one of the two
Marlboro branches? SHR has a branch and a ATM. Yet, MRO has two fully
functional branches about the same distance apart as the two buildings
in the SHR cluster.
|
253.75 | ex | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:23 | 12 |
| > <<< Note 253.67 by MPO::WHITTALL "All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-)...." >>>
> Now, what about the poor guy who doesn't
> have an account, but gets his petty
> cash check (because we no longer get
> cash from petty cash (oxymoron maybe))
> , anyways to stay on subject.. He
> needs the cash for business, the only
> way is to cash at DCU.. Wham.. $2.00
Why do you say 'the only way is to cash at DCU'? Why can't he take it
to any bank where he has an account? After all, his name's on it.
Denny
|
253.76 | | CARTUN::KFERRIS | | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:28 | 13 |
| I'm not sure if the DCU realizes this or not, but
not many people (I'm mainly speaking for myself)
can keep a balance of $1000 in their account. The
way the economy is today, it's almost impossible.
The way we were notified about this is very irritating,
and disappointing. I read my satment and all the
litterature they sent last night, and I honestly don't
recall seeing this. I have always had a good experience
with DCU, up until now. Their way of notification was
poor, and by being a DCU member I feel I've been cheated.
This is just one more headache that I don't need.
|
253.77 | | NOTIME::SACKS | Gerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085 | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:48 | 5 |
| DCU's ATMs have recently been hooked up to the network so you can use them
to make withdrawals from other banks. It seems to me that if your site has
a DCU ATM, you can still have the convenience of an on-site source of cash
without having a DCU account of any kind. They've definitely shot themselves
in the foot with this one.
|
253.78 | Sliding down a slippery slope | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:57 | 53 |
| re: .72 (DCU ignorance of fees)
My guess is that DCU has studied the "industry standards" for fees.
Unfortunately for DCU, New England has more aggressive competition in
the banking industry than in many other parts of the country, so
"industry standard" fees are out of line in N.E. -- right where most of
the DCU depositers are located!
Now, in the Mid-Atlantic region (where I am) their fee schedule doesn't
look too bad. But the problem here is that the HIDDEN costs make the
fee schedule uncompetitive! The major hidden cost: the single weekday-
only daytime-only branch is not sufficient to handle the needs for many
people. We have to resort to ATMs at a $1 per shot. This was
reasonable, though, as careful planning for withdrawls could still keep
the costs down. Now that many people will be paying $2-$5 on top of
current ATM fees, this picture changes drastically. Add to this the
fact that many (and I mean MANY; perhaps even MOST) of the people currently
employed in the DCO office park are scheduled to be moved to a new
facility a few miles away in another few months, and you have an
incovenient bank with only marginally competitive fees and rates!
DCU is quite foolish if it thinks that its single weekday-daytime
branch with $2-5 checking and $1 ATMs is attractive compared to
institutions with $(single-digit) checking having branches all over,
night-time/weekend hours, and free local ATMs.
Other points (some people may have alluded to these):
This whole mess will undoubtedly cost DCU the direct deposits of many
DCU members who will take their banking elsewhere. I wonder what the
balance point is? That is, I can't help but wonder at what point the
reduced total of deposited pay checks will cost DCU more than the fees
collected on the remaining accounts. The less the amount on deposit,
the less DCU can loan. The less DCU can loan, the less it can earn.
So I wonder how many lost paychecks it would take before DCU actually
started to see REDUCED earnings due to fees?
Another issue is growth. DCU already has the problem that it must fish
from a stagnant pool. That is, new DCU members must come from the
ranks of Digital employees. Since Digital hasn't been hiring in any
significant numbers and isn't expected to for probably 2 years or more,
how is DCU going to attract new members? They are working hard to push
current members away. What happens when the pool of members begins to
shrink and there is no new influx of members to add to deposits? Will
they raise fees yet again, and start this dreadful cycle over again?
It seems that DCU only wants to cater to people who can afford to have
thousands of dollars hanging around in low-interest checking accounts.
But given Digital's current financial tightness and the resulting
raises, it would seem that the number of people who can afford to do
this should shrink continually for many months to come.
-- Russ
|
253.79 | Sure there are more examples... | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 13:57 | 24 |
|
RE: .73
Not only does the MRO complex have *2* fully staffed branches (MR1 &
MR4) but there is an ATM in MRO3 and a brand new drive thru teller in
front of MR1. I don't know if they have shut down the MR3 ATM when
this was installed. Seems a tad excessive.
I would just love to see the rate of growth of employees working for
DCU over the last 5 years and relate it to all these additional
services that seem to now cost us a necessary service. I also want to
know officer salaries and perks and see if they correspond to banking
industry norms. We already know the loan criteria are different for
officers than for us.
This could be a first. A self-inflicted run on a banking institution.
Maybe being listed as one of the largest credit unions went to their
heads I guess. Probably thought they did it on their own. All the
very loyal DCU members had nothing to do with it. In one fell swoop
that loyalty has been destroyed. Let's see how DCU makes it without
the edge WE have given it.
Why do I feel like a passenger on the Titanic?
|
253.80 | Pull all but minimums | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 14:08 | 18 |
|
Strategy for making our point:
All members who wish to register their protest over this should go to
the nearest DCU branch and withdraw all funds down to the current
minimums. At the same time, request a pink form to close your
checking accounts (and others?). Make sure the teller and/or branch
manager know why you are doing this. Tell them you will grant DCU a 1
week grace period to rescind the current increases. If at the end of
the 1 week they are not rescinded, you will return with the completed
cards to completely close your accounts.
I would do this right now, but I have to wait for the branch to re-open
from their mid-day closing! Just another service I didn't ask for, and
suffer from.
Will report back on what the response is.
|
253.81 | More NFS information | STAR::PARKE | I'm a surgeon, NOT Jack the Ripper | Fri Aug 09 1991 14:13 | 15 |
| I looked at my information on the NFS Passport-I account (I opened it
so that I could recieve interest on secondary checking acct, DCU only
pays on the sharedraft acct, not the secondary -51 acct). What I found
was:
Min balance of $100 or pay a fee of $8.
Unlimited checks (but you have to pay to have them printed }8-)} )
There was also some other "free" goodies including
Credit card registration
A Keychain that will return if lost (drop in MBX)
I may be moving more accounts there or somewhere else where I get
service for the funds on deposit.
|
253.82 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Fri Aug 09 1991 14:20 | 6 |
| I found out from "the voice" at the other end at the DCU that
these fees are waived for your kids' accounts. Kids under
18 do not need to maintain minimum balances or levels of
activity to avoid fees.
Joe Oppelt
|
253.83 | | CVG::EDRY | This note's for you | Fri Aug 09 1991 14:45 | 5 |
|
get it in writing!
|
253.84 | | PEACHS::MITCHAM | Andy in Alpharetta (near Atlanta) | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:10 | 25 |
| I currently have a portion of my weekly pay deposited directly to both DCU
share draft account and a savings account; the remainder goes to a checking
account at a local federal savings bank -- Georgia Federal. Georgia Federal
allows free checking with direct deposit but does not pay interest on checking.
I only use my DCU checking account for paying the mortgage, automobile loan
and an occasional bit of cash here or there so I was thinking about closing
my checking account there and have all of my current DCU portion deposited
into DCU savings. I am told I can still do unlimited withdrawals from savings
so I could withdrawl what I need from savings and deposit it into my local
checking account when needed.
But then, I got to thinking: Why keep my savings? Why not have -all- my
money deposited into my local bank? I've called Georgia Federal and they
said it would be no problem having my savings automatically deposited as well.
And their interest rate currently is 5.5% (higher than DCU's, isn't it?).
I suppose I'll be stopping by one of their offices soon
FWIW: It may be a pain in the rear to do it, and more costly to Digital, but
I will gladly submit my travel advance request 2-3 weeks in advance and wait
than have it automatically deposited to my DCU account if I will incur a
charge to do so.
-Andy
|
253.85 | Call and be heard | WNDPAS::ALINSKAS | | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:22 | 2 |
| DCU Customer Service is registering complaints by badge number as of a
few minutes ago, so call and register your complaint.
|
253.86 | What's the number? | PEACHS::MITCHAM | Andy in Alpharetta (near Atlanta) | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:30 | 0 |
253.87 | Sounds okay to me | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:31 | 10 |
| re: .84
>And their interest rate currently is 5.5% (higher than DCU's, isn't it?).
Last time I looked (a couple of days ago), DCUs LARGEST interest rate
was 6.0% (actual, not effective yield). And that was on JUMBO CD's (over
$50K, I think) and IRAs. I don't recall standard savings exactly, but
I think it was about 5.0%. Checking was under 5%.
-- Russ
|
253.88 | | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:52 | 32 |
| >< Note 253.75 by HPSRAD::RIEU "Read his Lips...Know new taxes!" >
> -< ex >-
>
>> <<< Note 253.67 by MPO::WHITTALL "All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-)...." >>>
>> Now, what about the poor guy who doesn't
>> have an account, but gets his petty
>> cash check (because we no longer get
>> cash from petty cash (oxymoron maybe))
>> , anyways to stay on subject.. He
>> needs the cash for business, the only
>> way is to cash at DCU.. Wham.. $2.00
>
> Why do you say 'the only way is to cash at DCU'? Why can't he take it
> to any bank where he has an account? After all, his name's on it.
> Denny
>
What I was referring to was those who get there petty cash checks
and want the cash.. Without having to then deposit/cash them at
their local bank.. Or those who (finally) get a travel advance
signed 1 1/2 hours before leaving.. an the only local place is
a DCU branch.. Of this I speak from experience :-(
As a side note..
One of the people in the office wonder if these new fees
are being started to help pay the legal fees for the
lawsuit against the old Prez...
Sounds crazy... Maybe, then again.. Maybe not.. :-)
Csw
|
253.89 | A sad visit | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 15:58 | 68 |
|
Well, just got back from the ZKO branch. I must admit, I feel terrible
for the people who work the windows. They were, and always have been,
very nice and helpful. This catastrophic miscalculation by upper
management and the BoD may cost some very good people their jobs.
Sound familiar?
When I told them that I would like a pink card to close my checking
account, her response was a saddened "reeeally?" She asked why and I
told her the recent rate increase/service elimination had to be the
worse marketing stunt of all times. DCU was insulting the intelligence
of it members to sell it as a new choice.
I then requested all the balances in my accounts, savings, checking,
RSVP & CDSs. She said, "You can't change things around to get the free
checking?" I just looked at her. I didn't even have to answer, and
she said "It's the principle." I nodded.
I then told her I wanted to close my RSVP account, filled out the card
and received a check. The card statement I would loose all interest to
date (for the quarter). One months worth in this case. It's worth it.
I then showed her the deposit that was planned and will now go
elsewhere.
She then asked me to take and fill out one of the "Let us Know"
customersatisfaction cards. She said she really wanted me to fill it
out and send it in. We then stepped through the new "Schedule of
Fees". She then explained which ones were new and which ones went up.
I asked here specifically about the Stop Payment which I knew increased
from $5 to $15. She stated that it was raised to stop certain members
from abusing it. It was made the same as NSF to discourage the writing
of checks and placing a stop payment instead of letting them bounce.
I absolutely agreed with their reasons and logic. I, however, would
have suggested an escalating stop payment fee, ($5, $10, $15, $20,
during a calendar year. Now this is the type of simple explanation
that goes a LONG way. The teller should be made a DCU officer!
I then told her I would be back in a week to close out checking if
DCU went through with the new "choices". Meanwhile, the line was
forming. Sorry people in line.
I also requested and received a DCU Annual Report. She gave me a 1990
Annual Report that was a 9" x 17" foldup. May enter it later if time
permits. Everybody should ask for one and read it. From the section
by Chairman of the Board, Mark Steinkrauss:
"Despite the challenges of a troubled regional and national economy in
1990, DCU continued to be successful. In the midst of a tumultuous
year for the financial services industry, we experienced solid growth
consistent with sound business practices. DCU's achievement of 13%
growth in 1990, with assets of $371 million, is directly attributable
to the loyalty of our members, the dedication of the staff and its
efforts to provide the best service possibleto our members, and the
support of Digital Equipment Corporation. All this is evidenced in the
fact that DCU is the largest credit union in New England and #50
nationally."
"Our principle objective is stated in our mission statement: To provide
the Digital community with diversified, high quality, competitively
priced, easily understood financial services offered conveniently
efficiently and helpfully. This translates into seeking to provide the
best service possible, competitive lending rates, and attractive rates
on savings. We will continue our prudent lending and investment
practices so that our members' investments remain safe and sound."
Can there be any doubt the BoD must go? And go NOW!
|
253.90 | I'm outta here | SETC::PRENTICE | Ed TAY1-2H4 227-4379 SETC | Fri Aug 09 1991 16:30 | 18 |
| I'm as upset as anyone about the way this was handled. However, I really
doubt that this note and its replies will do much to change the situation. For
anyone that needs to vent steam, this is a perfect place, but there are other
"choices".
I'd be real interested in seeing a brand new BoD elected by the membership
from the membership. If and only if that happens, I'll back back, but for now
I simply emptied out my three largest accounts (my kid's college funds). I'll
continue to keep my loans, but not the deposits. Vote with your feet and walk
away from DCU if you disagree with the current management. You could always
come back if they solve not only the checking fee problem, but the larger
problem as well. The larger problem for me is that I no longer trust the
management of DCU to act in a responsible business manner. I wouldn't be at
all surprised to see a run on the bank as a result of this fiasco. I don't
want my money tied up when FDIC has to step in to decide who gets money first.
I'm already out for the majority of the deposits.
/egp
|
253.91 | telephone number | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Fri Aug 09 1991 16:39 | 4 |
|
The number to call is DTN 223-6735, ex. 207. This is Mary Madden's
extension in the Communications Dept. You're likely to get a
recording.
|
253.92 | Special extraction through note 253.89. | MOOV01::LEEBER | Carl MOO-1(ACO/E37) 297-3957(232-2535), U WANT MODELS? | Fri Aug 09 1991 16:48 | 10 |
| Just to let you all know;
A special extraction containing the stripped topic replies since the
last regular extraction and note 253.89 (inclusive) was forwarded to
DCU. (See note 2.0 for normal extraction information).
Carl Leeber
Batched Notes Extractor
P.S. I'm going back on vacation for two weeks so I will be unable to
forward to DCU until I return 26-AUG-1991.
|
253.93 | Trying to vote loudly | MLTVAX::SCONCE | Bill Sconce | Fri Aug 09 1991 16:48 | 24 |
| I called Mary Madden, and left my message with voicemail. That's a good way
to do it.
The message was a verbal version of this:
================================================================================
Note 255.9 RESERVED: Open Letters to DCU RE: Checking FEES 9 of 9
MLTVAX::SCONCE "Bill Sconce" 15 lines 9-AUG-1991 15:33
-< I vote "no" >-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To: DCU
Re: New checking-account fee structure "choices"
Dear DCU,
I have today withdrawn all but $10 from each of my DCU checking and savings
accounts.
In the happy event that DCU reconsiders and elects to continue offering savings
and checking as it has since the days when I joined (what was then called) WCU,
I shall be pleased to re-deposit my money and offer you my thanks.
-Bill Sconce
|
253.94 | | NOTIME::SACKS | Gerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085 | Fri Aug 09 1991 17:56 | 2 |
| Not to defend the imposition of fees for normal services, but $15 for a stop
payment is typical in New England banks.
|
253.95 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Fri Aug 09 1991 18:31 | 9 |
| Many banks will charge the stop payment fee ONLY if the bearer
of the check attempts to cash it. This practice is helpful
if you (or the bearer) have lost a check and you replace it
with another. You can then rest assured that if the first
check is found, it cannot be cashed because the stop-payment
will catch it. But if it remains lost forever you do not have
to waste the $15.00.
Joe Oppelt
|
253.96 | now costs $5 to replace ATM card | HUMOR::EPPES | I'm not making this up, you know | Fri Aug 09 1991 19:55 | 11 |
| One other new fee that bugs me (I have the same complaints as everyone else):
They will now charge $5 for a replacement ATM card! (It's listed on that chart
of the new "services.") So when my card stops working through NO FAULT OF MY
OWN (which has happened to me a few times - I don't mistreat my card or keep it
near other magnetic stuff or anything), I will now have to pay $5 to get a new
one?! Phooey!!!
This is all very discouraging.
-- Nina
|
253.97 | Disgusting, simply disgusting . . . | 16BITS::DELBALSO | I (spade) my (dog face) | Fri Aug 09 1991 22:16 | 68 |
| Some observations and comments, having just read the previous 96 replies -
First of all, I agree in principle with everything everyone's said. I'm
as ripped as anyone about this new "choice" DCU is giving me.
- Pulling out our accounts and watching them squirm -
The idea's a good one, but I sorely fear it won't happen that way.
80000 members don't read this conference. Some may not even regularly
look at their statements to learn about this new "feature". Some may
be in positions that prevent them from taking such an action. Some
may feel "uncomfortable" reacting that way for one reason or another.
There may be many reasons why some people won't pull their accounts,
but I'll bet that the majority of members will just go on like nothing
happened. That's human nature.
- Replace the BoD -
I've certainly been a proponent and cheerleader for this action since
the Mangone screwup, but for the same or similar reasons as above, the
majority of the membership will still vote for the incumbents (or not
vote at all which I believe is the equivalent) and the clowns will remain
right where they are. I wish I could be proven wrong on these predictions,
but I'm willing to take odds that it won't happen.
- The "Four reasons" for instituting a checking account fee -
I contend that there's a fifth which overshadows all the others. A reason
that really required the charge, and that the other four are a polite
cover up to pull the wool over our eyes.
I contend that the DCU's losses from the Mangone fiasco are very real
and significant and that this is a source of revenue to help cover that
loss. (Unless they can prove there were no losses, my contention is
arithmetically correct, if nothing more.)
I further contend that the BoD recommended and approved this "feature"
to enable the DCU to bring in revenues to recover from the Mangone loss
before things had an opportubity to get nasty with respect to federal
investigations, etc. I.E., it was a means for the incompetent clowns
on the BoD to cover their own butts.
If this is not the case, of course I'll welcome their response here, but,
as always, I will not hold my breath in anticipation of such response.
- I predict that regardless of the furor raised here, or the number of
calls they receive, or the number of dollars removed from closed accounts,
that the new charges will take place on 9/1 as scheduled. Let's face it -
DCU is big and has no need to be responsive.
- For those expressing to DCU _INTENT_ to close accounts, I'd be very wary
about that ability of theirs to hold your dough for 60 days. This would
be a good time for them to exercise their muscle and enforce that
prerogative of theirs. Just to show us, ya know. If I were intending to
close out my accounts I'd give 'em no warning at all - Just do it.
- Finally, if I am wrong, and if a significant number of member/owners
_DO_ start pulling their accounts to the extent that it starts to
"hurt" DCU, I feel sorry for those left with debt to the DCU who
need to remain there, because I see DCU's reaction as being a quick
clampdown on violations to T's&C's on loans. "Yes - we know you've
only missed your payment by two days, but that _does_ give us the option
to begin foreclosure proceedings on your house, reposess your car,
and put some nasty smudges on your credit rating."
I've said it a buhzillion times, but I'll say it again folks. It's not
the DCU that's at fault here. It's the idiot BoD who oversee their
activities. DCU can't do spit without their approval. Steinkrauss & Co.
should be out on their ears.
-Jack
PS. By all means, if you're planning on closing your accounts, don't let
anything I've said disuade you.
|
253.98 | I'd like to know the whole story | ILUVNH::BADGER | One Happy camper ;-) | Fri Aug 09 1991 22:46 | 9 |
| One small correction, the fees don't start until 10/1.
I also talked to Mary and a couple others. The i don't give a dam what
you think or do attitude is appaulling.
I wonder, does the uproar over this incident mask another? If everyone
is
focusing their attention in one direction....
|
253.99 | Couldn't run a piss up in a brewery | SMAUG::GARROD | An Englishman's mind works best when it is almost too late | Sat Aug 10 1991 00:17 | 18 |
| I don't know who at the DCU dreamed up the:
"You can choose any color you want, as long as it is black"
Henry Ford - 1908
intro to their "More choices More Options!" pamplet but my first
reaction was.
Yep DCU that's exactly what you are proposing to me: "Pay more or Pay
more".
Yes DCU my account will be closing pretty soon and I have $15,000
sitting in my RSVP account.
Up yours basically,
Dave
|
253.100 | A brief bank survey from Maryland | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Sat Aug 10 1991 18:27 | 55 |
| The following is posted for the sake of information and discussion and
is not an advertisement for any financial institution.
I lived in New England until 1985 and still have relatives in Mass and
NY. I know for a fact that the banks in NE have much better programs
than here (Maryland). I picked up brochures for 3 local banks today.
This is what I found:
INSTITUTION CONDITIONS FOR SPECIAL
NAME FREE CHECKING NOTES
-------------- ---------------------- --------------------------------------
MD National Direct Deposit, OR BankLine (equivalent to EasyTouch,
Bank $500 Minimum Daily except that it includes histories
Balance, OR of last 6 checks processed, last 6
$1500 Minimum Daily ATMs, last 3 deposits, ATM locations,
Savings Balance and much more)
Free ATM service at over 250 ATMs
Access to MOST and CIRRUS ATMs at
$1.50 per transaction
Many, many branches with evening and
Saturday hours
Carroll County Direct Deposit, OR Free ATM service at bank ATMs
Bank & Trust Senior Citizen, OR Access to MOST and PLUS ATMs at
$600 Minimum Balance, $1.00 per transaction
OR Branches with evening and Saturday
$600 Minimum Savings hours
Balance
First National $450 Minimum Balance EasyBank Debit VISA Card
Bank of MD PhoneFirst (EasyTouch-like) system
with ability to check deposits,
balances, etc. First two calls
per month free, $.50 thereafter.
Calls to check deposits and rates
always free.
Free ATM service at bank ATMs
Access to MOST, PLUS, VISA ATMs at
$.75 to $2.00 per transaction
(depending on machine & transaction)
Many branches with evening and
Saturday hours
All of the above also have interest checking with $1000 minimums and interest
rates ranging from 5.0% to current money market rates.
It appeared that I erred in a previous note when I said that DCU was
marginally competitive. It appears that DCU isn't competitive at all!
So far, it looks like I'll be banking with MD National.
-- Russ
|
253.101 | We shouldn't need to compare... | TALK::JARVIS | Next Unseen, The Infinite Voyage | Sat Aug 10 1991 22:05 | 8 |
| It's interesting that DCU tries to compare itself to local banks.
That's why I originally went to DCU, because it didn't compare to any
local banks. It's rates were better, it's service was comparable, it's
fees were lower and it was more convenient. Now, it's rates are
comparable, it's service worse, and looks like, from my survey
yesterday, it's fees are higher.
-Garth
|
253.102 | valid means to reduce expenses? | SLOAN::HOM | | Mon Aug 12 1991 10:16 | 7 |
| If the number of members with very low balances are accurate, then
you can view this as a means to reduce cost. Why should the DCU
be burdened with the admin costs of maintaining accounts with low
balances?
Hopefully, the reduced expenses, will result in higher interest rates.
|
253.103 | | DEMON3::CLEVELAND | Notes -- Fun or Satanic Cult??? | Mon Aug 12 1991 11:11 | 34 |
| > <<< Note 253.97 by 16BITS::DELBALSO "I (spade) my (dog face)" >>>
> -< Disgusting, simply disgusting . . . >-
>
>I've said it a buhzillion times, but I'll say it again folks. It's not
>the DCU that's at fault here. It's the idiot BoD who oversee their
>activities. DCU can't do spit without their approval. Steinkrauss & Co.
>should be out on their ears.
You must be joking. It was the president that got the DCU involved in the
real estate scam! I blame the board for failure of their oversight duties,
but I can understand how a group of volunteers would be somewhat at the
mercy of "professional bankers". Don't look at this fee increase by itself
-- look at the whole picture. I'm sure the board has made mistakes, and
should be replaced, but I can't excuse the DCU for their part in this
fiasco.
> <<< Note 253.102 by SLOAN::HOM >>>
> -< valid means to reduce expenses? >-
>
>If the number of members with very low balances are accurate, then
>you can view this as a means to reduce cost. Why should the DCU
>be burdened with the admin costs of maintaining accounts with low
>balances?
>
>Hopefully, the reduced expenses, will result in higher interest rates.
Unfortunately, first we get to pay the fees, then we wait to find out if
interest rates are increased. If this really was the problem (which I
doubt) they should have made the move before letting rates fall so low.
Why should I leave $1000 in a DCU checking account getting less than 5%?
Especially if I can get free checking elsewhere.
Tim
|
253.104 | | BEATLE::REILLY | So I rewired it... | Mon Aug 12 1991 11:11 | 11 |
|
If you ask me, checking account balances are supposed to be low. Keep
enough in there to handle your bills and put the rest in savings.
I have a question. Can you have just a savings account (shares) and
not a checking (share drafts) AND get no charge? Maybe what a lot of
these low-balance checking account people want is just a savings
account, but just signed up for the shares/share drafts 'cause it was
all free anyway way back when they signed on.
- Sean
|
253.105 | Did you get your info from another source. | MPO::WHITTALL | All I can do is 8-) 8-) 8-).... | Mon Aug 12 1991 11:13 | 14 |
| >< Note 253.98 by ILUVNH::BADGER "One Happy camper ;-)" >
> -< I'd like to know the whole story >-
>
> One small correction, the fees don't start until 10/1.
>
What makes you think this... The pamphlets I get in the mail
all state that the fees/charges are effective 9/1/91..
You may not see the actual charges until your October bill,
but you start losing interest, and are accountable for
minimum deposits as of 9/1..
Csw
|
253.106 | New fees = 100X overhead of inactive accounts | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'm from DCU and I'm here to help you | Mon Aug 12 1991 11:21 | 22 |
|
RE: .102
I agree that DCU should target inactive accounts that add to it's
overhead. However, it was DCU policy in the past to REQUIRE checking
accounts in certain circumstances. Now that their policies have lead
to a large number of inactive accounts, they want to slap US with a
fee. But DCU has targetted almost everybody with this latest fiasco.
I can't imagine the overhead costing anywhere near what will be
generated in fees and interest not being paid. This is a MASSIVE fee
generating change by DCU to bring money in for a reason. And I think
we all know what that reason is. We just know of the real estate
"impropriety" that transpired. Makes you wonder if there may have been
other "activities" going on. All this just really makes you wonder.
My advice, get out while you still can. A lot of banks and S & L's
were proclaimed to be solid the day before they locked the doors.
Trust is something not easily gained. DCU seems to have lost quite a
bit of it in a very short time period. If you can't trust your own
credit union, it's time to find an institution you can trust.
|
253.107 | Update | MLTVAX::SCONCE | Bill Sconce | Mon Aug 12 1991 12:22 | 7 |
| FWIW, Mary Madden returned the call I left on her voicemail on Friday.
She made it clear that she was calling to talk, not listen, that DCU
"has a responsibility to oversee operations in such a way as to...",
and that there is no chance whatsoever that initiation of the new
fee structure on 1 September would be reconsidered. She then encouraged
me to "shop around"...
|
253.108 | Encouraging customers to leave your business??? | LAVC::CAHILL | Jim Cahill | Mon Aug 12 1991 12:58 | 23 |
| > She then encouraged me to "shop around"...
I already have. Several months ago, I switched my direct deposit to Polaroid
Credit Union (since renamed Direct Credit Union). They have services which
match *my* lifestyle, like direct access to funds (free ATM access at all
Xpress 24, NYCE, CIRRUS, Yankee 24, etc., and even those ATMs in supermarkets
that BayBanks charges you a fee to use), free checking with either direct
deposit or a $500(?) balance, better rates than DCU, an EasyTouch type phone
service, an 800 number for customer service, and more.
I've kept my DCU accounts active due to an outstanding loan I have from them,
but with the new fees making it even less attractive to do business with DCU,
I guess it's time to complete the switch and take my money to another bank.
The convenience of a DCU branch where I work just isn't enough to justify
paying/losing more money. Considering the number of times a year I need to
go to the credit union branch office, I'll survive. In this day and age of
free ATM access, I find myself going into an actual branch office less often
anyway.
Bye, DCU.
Jim
|
253.109 | I also 'shopped around' | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Mon Aug 12 1991 13:16 | 5 |
| I started savings and checking accouts at Merchants National Bank in
Leominster on Sat. I'll close my checking as soon as my Direct Deposit
change form is processed. I have to keep $5 in Savings until I
refinance my stock loan.
Denny
|
253.111 | Blatant Propaganda... | DECSIM::GILLETT | And you may ask yourself, 'How do I work this?' | Mon Aug 12 1991 18:09 | 31 |
| I'm really rippin' about this fee-stuff! It makes me mad as hell
to see my credit union doing this stuff to me and my fellow CU
members. And I hate this "Official Spokesperson Says 'Go Shop
Around' " stuff that others have reported.
My first temptation is to pull the whole shootin' works out of
DCU, and hoof it to some other bank or CU who won't pull this
kind of stuff, or at least isn't afraid to call a rate hike a
rate hike (and not "More choices and options").
On the other hand, for those of you/us who enjoy fighting and
getting Bad Things fixed, there's always the choice to turn and
get after 'em. Which is what I think needs to happen here.
It's OUR credit union, spending/loaning/losing OUR money. If
you're scared, diversify with other savings institutions. But if
you turn and run, then you're giving up something which belongs
to US (indeed is held up as a fringe benefit and a positive thing
about being employed by Digital -- I remember my personnel
interview well on this subject). Let's not raise the white flag
yet. Let's raise our own Skull and Crossbones and fight. We're
not exactly a bunch of lemmings here without our own set of
"Choices and Options" (and lawyers, petitions, letter-writing
campaigns, pickets, appeals to DEC's BoD and other general
uproariousness).
Remember, you are a SHAREHOLDER in DCU, not just a customer.
Illegitimi non Carborundum! (And no, I won't translate that here)
/Chris
|
253.112 | Looking into the wind. | DESERT::STARKEY | | Mon Aug 12 1991 18:48 | 6 |
| Maybe I'm all wet, but I still think the DCU is a good deal..All the
banks that I talked with still want a min of $500 which I can't afford.
I think $2 a month is a great deal compared to local banks. Although
one of the reasons I joined DCU was for the freebees..But life and
circumstances to change..
Mike, happy to have a checking account and a job for now...
|
253.113 | DCU is a good deal? Wanna invest in Coffler Banking? :-) | JAC::COFFLER | Cancer cures Smoking ... | Mon Aug 12 1991 20:46 | 17 |
| re: .112
In my shopping, the DCU was the WORST of EVERY FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
that I checked.
How you can think that the DCU is still a good deal is beyond me. The
DCU requires $1000+ to not have a monthly fee. *NO OTHER NH BANK* has
that requirement. The DCU requires $1000+ to pay interest. *NO OTHER
NH BANK* has that requirement. Also, the DCU interest rates are lower
than nearly *ANY* other bank around.
I'm after zero fee, and decent interest. I can do that for a $100
minimum in NH banks. I can do that at the DCU for $1000. Which is the
better deal? Yes, the monthly rate is higher at local banks *IF* you
are charged the monthly rate. I don't expect to be. But even if I am,
the interest earned on $100-$1000 each month will easily make up the
occasional difference.
|
253.114 | this ship just hit an iceberg... | WMOIS::BELANGER_F | | Mon Aug 12 1991 21:12 | 17 |
|
I just "shopped around" with 1st Safety Fund Bank in Gardner (across
from Grossman's), and here's what their checking account is like:
Free checks (printing, that is...)
Free checking, NO FEES at all!
No interest paid, but I figured out that with the checks at DCU costing
$11 a bunch, and the fees, and the lousey interest rate on my checking
account $$'s anyway, it's worth the switch. And I get the check copies
back, and don't have to pay $1.00 a copy for lousey quality copies from
microfilm anyway. And I can just keep enough in the checking account to
cover the checks, and not much more. So I can put the rest in a decent
savings account that pays better than DCU's paltry rates. I'm bailing
out before this ship sinks, and it will, judging by the attitude of the
DCU management we've been hearing about.
Fred (soon to be ex-passenger of the DCU Titanic)
|
253.115 | | ISLNDS::STRATTON | Can you see the real me? | Mon Aug 12 1991 23:23 | 9 |
| Jim left Digital at the end of June and is now working for another
company. He is getting paid every other week, but still has automatic
deposit to the DCU. So, even if we kept $1,000 in the checking
account, we'd still get charged the fee since the new rule states
WEEKLY automatic deposit.
3 more members (Jim, myself & our son) soon to be leaving...
Roberta
|
253.116 | Third Choice | NEWVAX::TURRO | Watch the skies | Tue Aug 13 1991 01:42 | 15 |
| I was outraged to have found out on such short notice. After reading
the first 20 replies or so I have to agree with all .
Reasons for this increase (IMHO)
Make up $10,000,000.00 in losses to the former DCU president !
I too will check out another bank with free checking and that will
be my third choice.
In reference to the Ford quote. How much "RED INK" will flow from
this DCU blunder.
Mike Turro
|
253.117 | Just remember who's money is doing all this | ALLVAX::DUNTON | Frankly my dear..... | Tue Aug 13 1991 11:09 | 31 |
|
having only read the last few (I've just started reading this file
because of this "new options" business).. I think that if folks
similar to .111 want to hang on to that 'leaking washing machine'
and keep pouring money into it hoping the leaks will slow or stop..
fine - let'm. I also think, that if others of us wish to seek
for other washing machines that perhaps don't leak at all or as
much - we should (and perhaps post our findings here for others to
see and benifit from).
Personally, it's been nice having all the conviences of DCU (such as
closing for lunch and at 4pm so you have to go during working hours
to get there - and heaven forbid your building doesn't have an office
or a teller machine.. so now your late for work or have to leave
early), but I'm not paying for the conviences of MY money. I have
another checking accout all lined up that pays interest on $25 min bal
with no monthly fees.. Plus.. they're open during lunch all week and
till 6pm on thurs and fri.
Just my $0.02 worth I guess...
K-
- just an addendum.... if you think about it... next time your near
any banking establishment, check out the size and quality of their
buildings. Who do you suppose is paying for that..? and now they
want more to continue to deal with YOUR money.. wake up America...
Cash worked for how many years..? A little inconvienient your
saying..? Well how inconvienient is it to pay that bill while your
right there at the grocery store..? Guess I should shut up before I
really boil over...
|
253.118 | Sticking with DCU | STOKES::NEVIN | | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:10 | 20 |
| There are several advantages to doing banking at DCU:
1) For those who have a DCU in their building, it is MUCH more
convenient than doing business elsewhere. I figure that the $2.00
fee would be quickly used up by driving to another bank even a few
times a month.
2) The NCUA, which insures credit unions is in a much more secure
position than any of the other Federal agencies which insure banks,
and most other credit unions are difficult to get into.
3) The fees are not all that high.
4) From what I have seen, the DCU staff is significantly more
competent than most of the banks which I've seen in this area. (Near
Andover).
If you shop around, you can probably find a better deal at other
banks (I found some similar deals from other banks), but I don't
think its worth the inconvenience.
|
253.119 | Beware of lost interest... | COOKIE::WITHERS | Bob Withers - In search of a quiet moment | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:10 | 7 |
| Beware...if you close your account -right now- you'll lose your interest
for the quarter.
My plan is to wait until very early October, absorb the$2 or $4 fee, which ever
it ends up being, and then close my accounts.
BobW
|
253.120 | | SSBN1::YANKES | | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:15 | 8 |
|
Re: .119
Or, alternatively, just leave enough money in the account to keep it
active and accruing interest and then withdraw that "placeholder" after the
start of the next quarter on Oct 1.
-craig
|
253.121 | | CALS::THACKERAY | | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:40 | 18 |
| Hang on a minute. I've heard about the ex-president of DCU losing us
varying sums of money, viz:
$75million (source, Boston Globe)
$10million (source, this notesfile)
$nothing (source, Mary Madden, DCU. I don't believe it).
Now, if all those 80,000 DCU members had to pay their $2/month, the
extra revenue to DCU would be $1.9million per year. If you take the
$10million loss figure above, that means it will take more than 5 years
to get the loot back.
I sense there must be some kind of connection.
Question: How much profit has DCU made over the last 5 years? Is there
a trend?
Ray
|
253.122 | please call 223-8444 | ICS::THOMPSONP | | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:47 | 5 |
| RE:253.110 That is NOT the DCU number but mine and I DON'T work for
DCU. The correct no. is DTN 223-8444.
Patti Thompson
U.S. Personnel Systems
|
253.123 | DTN 223-8444 is customer service | VIA::63008::jmartin | Joseph A. Martin, ULTRIX VM | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:50 | 6 |
| I put the wrong number in the now-deleted 253.110
I apologize to the person whose number I entered. I realize that the
consequences must have been pretty obnoxious. I am sorry.
\Joe
|
253.124 | | ULTRA::KINDEL | Bill Kindel @ LTN1 | Tue Aug 13 1991 13:56 | 53 |
| Re .many:
Having been on vacation when the announcement hit my mailbox, this all
came as a surprise to me. I've held my tongue for a day, trying to put
it all in perspective. Time's up, so here are a few random comments.
1. I have direct deposit of more than $100 per paycheck to my DCU share
draft account, but rarely keep its balance above $1000. That means
I'm looking at $2/month to keep it open.
2. Moving $1000 from other savings to the share draft account would
waive the monthly fee (and cause the account to bear interest).
3. The monthly interest on $1000 is $4.17 at 5% APR.
4. My BayBank account requires a $2000 balance (in checking or
companion savings) to waive MUCH HIGHER service charges. A number
(more than one) of other options are offered that allow for
free checking, even on interest-bearing NOW accounts.
5. I have a 5-figure IRA account at DCU. I believe it SHOULD be
applicable toward fee waivers.
6. The two-week prior notice we received is UNACCEPTABLY short.
7. DCU has stupid operating rules that lead to excessive holds on
deposits and non-acceptance of endorsements that meet the
requirements of the Uniform Commercial Code and Massachusetts law.
8. DCU has NO ATMs near my home. Having one near my office doesn't
help much. BayBank has X-Press 24 machines throughout the area
and doesn't charge me anything to use them. I'm NOT willing to
pay $1 to get access to my account when I'm near my home.
9. DCU obviously hopes that its members will increase their savings
rate. Never mind the 8000 accounts that keep low balances and
don't generate enough income to cover their costs. What DCU needs
is to increase its deposits (and to pay as little as possible upon
same) so it can dilute the losses from its lousy loan portfolio.
10. DCU continuously underestimates its members. While there's a LOT
of inertia in one's banking relationship, it makes NO SENSE to take
actions that serve to anger one's customers. How can DCU expect to
receive our continued TRUST if they aren't willing to talk candidly
about the financial condition of the institution? The announcement
of Mr. Mangone's sudden departure looked like a good beginning in
this regard, but the sugar-coated fee increase was two steps back.
*** PLEASE DCU, TALK TO US AS BUSINESS PARTNERS!!! ***
I'm still evaluating my own actions. For the short term, moving $1000
to my primary DCU share draft account (and keeping it there) will
negate any monthly charges and cost less than $2 in lost interest.
I can't say that the answer will be the same for my other accounts.
|
253.125 | IRA regulations aren't DCU's fault | SSAG::GARDNER | | Tue Aug 13 1991 16:35 | 21 |
| re IRA accounts counting towards fee waivers
To give credit where credit is due, while I'd agree with most other
comments regarding DCU's stupidity, IRAs not counting towards a fee
waiver isn't their fault. That's a blessing granted by our "friends"
in Washington (Hi, I'm your congressman, I'm here to do you a favor).
IRAs are wrapped in regulations to make sure you can't receive any
benefit from them without formally withdrawing money and paying taxes
on it. For example, IRAs cannot be considered in approving or
disapproving loan applications (this I know for certainty). While I
haven't read a description of the actual regulation, I'm certain that
they cannot be used to justify waiver of fees. If they were, the IRS
would consider the waived fee as a "withdrawal" from the IRA.
Sure, $2/month is a bit picayune. But I can imagine fees that would
amount to several hundred dollars a year (e.g., brokerage commisions
for an active stock trader). And I can imagine opening an IRA that
provided below market returns in return for waiving said fees. That is
tantamount to withdrawing the fees from a normal IRA. It ain't
allowed. And DCU isn't allowed to consider IRAs in waiving fees.
|
253.126 | what about the choice we've had all along!? | XANADU::FLEISCHER | without vision the people perish (381-0899 ZKO3-2/T63) | Tue Aug 13 1991 17:06 | 8 |
| re Note 253.2:
> "Choice" is the watchword of the American consumer today, as well it
> should be.
What utter contempt for the members!
Bob
|
253.127 | auto loans | DESERT::STARKEY | | Tue Aug 13 1991 17:50 | 7 |
| Loans are down...I wonder why??? Have you ever checked with the
members and evaluated how many loans were with "other" institutions
especially for auto loans...How many of us working POOR can afford the
20-30 % down payment plus TAX & Li. I would rather have my loan thru
DCU if it was still cheaper than an outside source. Maybe we need to
rethink the policy!
|
253.128 | | 16BITS::DELBALSO | I (spade) my (dog face) | Wed Aug 14 1991 09:44 | 11 |
| I just saw an interesting piece of mail which is apparently circulating on
the Net regarding this subject. I neither have, nor wish to obtain, permission
to repost it here, but the tail end of the message says something to the effect
that "If we all complain formally, they [DCU] will have to do away with the
charge".
Unless I'm mistaken, nothing could be further from the truth. "They" don't
have to do a damn thing unless they want to, regardless of how many
complaints they get.
-Jack
|
253.129 | Compromise? | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Wed Aug 14 1991 10:25 | 20 |
| On the issue of checking charges: How about a compromise:
I'd be willing to live with the fee structure if they changed an "and"
to an "or".
Currently, you get free checking:
If (you have CDs in excess of $2500) or ( (you have direct deposit
of $100+ weekly) and (your balance does not drop below
$1000) )
A subtle change would fix this for me:
If (you have CDs in excess of $2500) or ( (you have direct deposit
of $100+ weekly) *or* (your balance does not drop below
$1000) ) ^^
This would encourage more people to use direct deposit *and* save DEC
payroll money too (but, then again, maybe everyone already does).
|
253.130 | GMAC financing beat DCU | CSC32::B_HARRISON | Bruce Harrison | Wed Aug 14 1991 11:34 | 10 |
|
re: .127
FWIW
I just bought a car with $500.00 down (actually I applied my rebate, so NO
cash out of my pocket) and got a 11.50% interest loan from GMAC. If I
remember correctly DCU wanted around 13.00% for a 100% financed auto
loan.
|
253.131 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Wed Aug 14 1991 13:47 | 9 |
| re: .125:
Ed, what you said is logical, and in fact, I was all ready to accept
that as the explanation, until:
WCIS (Worcester Counter Institution for Savings, a central Mass bank
with lots of branches) has free checking with an IRA over $2500.
However, they have a $15.00/year service fee, and their IRA interest
rate isn't real great
|
253.132 | WCIS has free checking if-WCIS has free checking if--wcis | SLSTRN::SCHULMAN | SANFORD | Wed Aug 14 1991 15:53 | 3 |
| If I read the WCIS brochure correctly (yesterday) they offered free
checking with interest if you had a direct deposit. I'll double check
that.
|
253.133 | | YNGSTR::BROWN | | Wed Aug 14 1991 16:44 | 10 |
| I still like the idea of the before/after service charge comparison.
Except instead of the b.s about more delinquencies, etc., they should
just be honest about it:
rate before discovering rate after discovering
Mangone embezzled $70m Mangone embezzled $70m
Sharedraft: ... ...
_kb
|
253.134 | | TOOK::MORRISON | Bob M. LKG2-2/BB9 226-7570 | Wed Aug 14 1991 17:43 | 9 |
| I knew that we depositors would have to somehow make up the losses that the
former DCU president incurred, so I wasn't surprised when DCU changed its fee
structure. But of course I was distressed.
Re branch office hours: As of June 30 I had worked in DEC for 10 years
without an on-site branch (14 years total). On the rare occasions when I went
to a branch in Marlboro, it was always open at lunch time. On starting at LKG,
I checked the branch office hours. What a joke! LKG is a big plant and some
people have to walk a considerable distance to get from their work area to the
branch.
|
253.135 | letters at the DCU branch | NAC::SCHLENER | | Wed Aug 14 1991 18:28 | 5 |
| According to a friend, the DCU branches now have some type of letter
you can sign inorder to protest this change. We need to get the word
out to everyone in order to get as many of these letters to the BoD.
Cindy
|
253.136 | DCU will soon be out of business | AIDEV::POLIKOFF | LMO2-1/C9 Marlboro MA 296-5391 | Wed Aug 14 1991 19:15 | 12 |
| They apparently think that since Dukaka sp? :*) raised fees and
fines in Massachusetts and got away with it, DCU can do the same thing.
If a Governor and presidential candidate does something it must be OK.
Right?
They forgot that Mass is in the toilet because of what Dukaka did
and DCU will shortly be in the toilet with MA.
On the other hand, the $1000.00 is only a weeks pay for most
of us.
Arnie
|
253.137 | We work for the same company, right? | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Wed Aug 14 1991 19:59 | 16 |
| re: .136
> On the other hand, the $1000.00 is only a weeks pay for most
> of us.
I didn't see a smiley face attached to that statement.
I can assure you that there is a sizable number of DECcies who don't
even come CLOSE to a net paycheck of $1000 per week. Nor, at current
raise levels, are many of these people likely to break that level
within the next decade.
$1000.00 is far from a trivial sum, I assure you.
-- Russ
Digital Services/EIS
|
253.138 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Wed Aug 14 1991 20:33 | 10 |
| Re: .136 and application of the Mass Miracle strategy to the DCU:
I had a humorous thought. I think this whole thing is a conspiracy
between Mikey and the Public Relations outfit that dreamed up the
glossy brocuhre that was supposed to trick us into thinking that this
was good for us.
On the other hand, if they'd been successful, Mikey would have a PR
firm that could get him elected president or maybe even appointed King
of England.
|
253.139 | Charge for ATM usage for savings-only accounts | VMSDEV::WIBECAN | This is the way we hole the hole | Thu Aug 15 1991 10:38 | 7 |
| I don't know if anyone noticed, but with everyone talking about closing
checking accounts:
There is a monthly fee (it's only a dollar, but it's still a fee) for ATM usage
if you have a savings-only account.
Brian
|
253.140 | My views of DCU's Choices.... | EXPRES::NEFF | If it's out there...it's not in here. | Thu Aug 15 1991 12:50 | 50 |
|
Written :: 13-Aug-1991
As you all know by now the DCU has informed us that our checking accounts
will be taking on a new twist, LifeStyle checking. A checking account that
is designed to give us flexibility and unlimited access to our funds.
The DCU boasts that the "LifeStyle" checking has "More Choices" and will
present "More Options". They go ahead and quote Henry Ford, "You can choose
any color you want, as long as it is black." Then you open the pamphlet and
you are astonished. You think to yourself, is there more than this or do
they take me for a total idiot. That was my impression of this "New"
checking not offered but rather thrown upon us by the DCU.
What the people at DCU are trying to tell us in their quaint little way is,
they will be charging us a fee for our once "FREE" checking. I find it
quite comical the way they went about this. Making it sound like we are
getting outstanding benefits with this "New" checking account. When all
that we are getting is raked over the coals.
Remember back a few months when the DCU sent out the real reasons why the
President of their establishment was fired. Well to refresh your memory,
he single-handedly stole 70,000,000.00 or so dollars right out from under
our noses. Now it's time to recover the money by passing the collection
tray to the members.
I don't agree with the increase although I don't feel the DCU will change
that.......but, I am appalled at the way it is being handled. Again the
"poor" are taxed and the "rich" are getting the full benefit of the
thievery rained upon us.
Speaking for myself, a balance of 1,000 dollars at "all" times is not an
easy task. Especially considering the economy and the hard times Digital
is facing within.
It is sad to say that politics are so rampant throughout our society that
even our financial institution isn't autonomous from its graft. It's also
not enough to have to put up with this type of rhetoric in the press but
now the DCU puts out a pamphlet that is totally ludicrous. It is an utter
insult to our intelligence and financial well being.
If the DCU really gave us a choice, I would choose black.....
Steve
_sbn
|
253.141 | A great way to spend your vacation... | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Thu Aug 15 1991 13:17 | 84 |
|
I stopped by DCU headquarters this morning and had a very pleasant and
informative 2 hour conversation with Mary Madden. Nice use of vacation
time huh?
We covered many topics and she was extremely helpful. She provided me
with this years monthly statements of condition, a sample petition for
running for the BoD, almost all DCU Annual Reports dating back to when
DCU opened and the DCU Election Guidelines (not part of the bylaws). I
will be combing through this new material tonight. I'm still awaiting
word whether I can have access to the full report from the auditors.
She said DCU will be issuing a statement today. I can't say exactly
what it will contain or address (Mangone, checking fees???), just have
to wait and see. See flatly stated that DCU WILL be imposing the new
checking 'choices' as it is necessary due to the reasons already given.
Also, sound business practice. However, deposits being down is
inaccurate. They are increasing. Not sure if they are anymore.
I also communicated directly to her mine, and many others, displeasure
with the 'choices' brochure. I said many, including myself, considered
it insulting. She didn't quite agree but hey, she's got a right to her
opinion. After all she does work for DCU. I also mentioned that the
overriding message coming out of DCU seems to be "shop around". Here,
she and DCU may be taking a bum rap. Usually this is one statement in
a long conversation being offered as friendly advice I guess. I
mentioned that those words really do tend to stick in people's minds no
matter what else was discussed and they may consider dropping it. I
also pointed out that people ARE shopping around and almost without
exception have found better deals. So DCU may be offering good advice
and really burning themselves in several ways. She said there were
some people who were satisfied with or understood the changes and were
not leaving. I must say that's hard to believe but who knows?
I asked what the basis of the "DCU hasn't lost anything" statement was
and it was as I suspected. They anticipate recovering money from a $10
million dollar civil suit against Mr. Mangone, $6 million (max.) from the
bonding agency and the sale of the property involved. Nothing has been
collected on the first two yet. She said many lawyers are working on
it (great:-(). I don't know if they have been able to dispose of any
of the real estate involved. I guess we can at least look forward to a
seperate line item on next year's statements labeled "Legal Expenses".
Total value of the participation loans was $18 million. There were
several of these (less than 20) made. She defended them as
"investments" by DCU and that they had been cleared by the auditors and
NCUA. This is where we disagreed. I told her that I considered them
loans to non-DCU members and that as such, they were contrary to the
DCU bylaws. The names on the loans were trust companies, not
individuals. The loans were originated at Barnstable Credit Union and
DCU bought into them in varying degrees (50-90%). All were qualified
by Barnstable CU and reviewed by DCU for completeness (proper
documentation). I asked whether DCU performed any of their own
verification and the answer was no. I then asked if I walked into DCU
with all the proper forms filled out and documentation, if I could get
a loan with no independent verification. Of course I could not. This
I feel is where the DCU BoD (who approved all of these) has failed
miserably. It would seem to me that loans of these amounts and sound
business practice would require DCU verification. Not just rubber
stamping documentation received from another source. Anyways, we
disagreed on these very major points. Everybody will see it
differently I'm sure.
I asked for pre-change versions of Article 3, Section 5a dealing with
the 60 day notice of withdrawal and also Article 6 (Elections),
Section 3 which was deleted entirely. These were very recent changes.
I asked why nominations have never been taken for the Credit Committee
and Supervisory Committee as stipulated in Article 7, Section 5a.
Didn't get much of an answer here. Awaiting a more detailed response.
I also told her I thought the bylaws needed to be added to in the
areas of public disclosure of the interests of DCU BoD and it's senior
management. That all usch interests should be fully disclosed in the
annual report, along with compensation paid to them, as Digital does.
All in all a very good conversation and she will be getting back to me
on many items that are unresolved. She is a very nice person and doing
a tough job in a very difficult time. Try to seperate the message from
the messenger when speaking with her. She does listen well. I just
hope the senior management and BoD listen as well as she does.
Will be back when I have more...
|
253.142 | Correct figures | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Thu Aug 15 1991 13:22 | 11 |
|
RE: .140
The amount DCU is dealing with concerning the participation loans is
$18,000,000. Not $70 million. The NCUA has a seperate suit brought
against people involved with the Barnstable CU (including Mangone) for
$47,000,000. DCU is NOT part of that action.
$18 million is bad enough, $70 million would have closed the doors long
ago.
|
253.143 | Effective date for new service fees = 9/29 | SICML::LEVIN | My kind of town, Chicago is | Thu Aug 15 1991 13:50 | 17 |
| Re: previous notes regarding 9/1 vs 10/1 as date new rates go into effect.
It's my understanding (based on phone conversation with DCU yesterday) that
although the new schedule is effective September 1, the service fees are
applied at the end of the statement period.
So, just as people here have noted that if you withdraw, you don't get interest,
it also applies that if you close your checking account before the end of the
period, you won't be assessed the charges.
Specifically, I was told that the actual date the first fees would be applied
would be Sept. 29th -- close to, but not identical to "10/1".
(I probably will close my checking account, but don't have any other plans to
close down all DCU business.)
/Marvin
|
253.144 | | CNTROL::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Thu Aug 15 1991 16:51 | 13 |
| I know I'm dating myself on this and showing that I don't read my
inserts very often, but when did the money market checking go away.
There was a time where funds in the checking account below a certain
amount earned a small amount of interest. Above this amount, they
earned money market fund interest.
While choices were being offered, why wasn't this one reinstituted?
The biggest problem I have with all of this is that I don't see any
choices. I see that I will be charged for something that always used
to be free. If I want a buyer protection plan I'll use my American
Express card. The same thing goes if I need a cash advance. I don't
need this "choice" from DCU.
|
253.145 | | BEIRUT::SUNNAA | | Thu Aug 15 1991 16:55 | 7 |
|
Just to keep everyone updated, I was contacted by DCU (Mary Madden)
with a request to post a statement in the conference.
I am expecting it anytime, and as soon as I receive it I will post it.
Nisreen (moderator)
|
253.146 | | LEDS::PRIBORSKY | I'd rather be rafting | Thu Aug 15 1991 17:13 | 5 |
| Re: .145: When you do post it (if it is not a reply to this note)
please tell us here (as a reply to this note) where the statement can
be found.
Thanks.
|
253.147 | Take DCU's Advise... SHOP AROUND!!!! | BCVAXA::PILOTTE | | Thu Aug 15 1991 17:15 | 21 |
| I have seen a couple of replies in here on MERCHANTS NATIONAL BANK
which have offices in (Fitchburg, Leominster and Townsend)
Here are some more details.
o Free Checking with direct deposit
o Balances from 1000 to 4999 earn 4% anything over $5000 earns 5%
on checking accounts.
o No Charge for use of ATM cards regardless of where you use them.
(This is great for me seeing XPRESS-24 is just about everywhere)
o All cancelled checks are mailed back to you with your monthly
Statements.
Needless to say I switched to Merchants several months ago and am
glad I did.
|
253.148 | SAFCU here I come... | DENVER::DAVISGB | Can't come outta the booth | Thu Aug 15 1991 19:15 | 12 |
| I did some shopping around and found a good example of an institution
that appears to work for it's members.
Sandia Area Federal Credit Union - Albuquerque, New Mexico
No minimum balance in sharedraft acct.
No monthly fee (you purchase checks, just like DCU)
Interest on sharedrafts: 4.5% over $300, figured DAILY!
Hours: 9-4:30, 9-5 driveup, Saturdays 9-1
ATM card that works over Plus, Link, and a few others
bye bye DCU.....
|
253.149 | Disclosure doesn't say daily min. balance of $1000 | RHETT::WILLIAMS | | Thu Aug 15 1991 19:16 | 12 |
| I actually took the time to read the disclosure statement. No where in that
statement does it state that checking requires a daily min of $1000.00 or
does it state that checking requires a monthly min. of $1000.00, I asked the
teller in our branch where that information is available, she put me in touch
with the manager for that branch...who informed me that it was left out of the
information sent to members, but was sent to the branches.
The way the disclosure statement reads is that if you have a $1000.00 min
balance then you won't be charged the fee.
Something is suppose to come to the membership soon.
Loretta
|
253.150 | | CSC32::GULDEN | | Fri Aug 16 1991 04:03 | 6 |
| It appears to me that DCU is downsizing just like Digital. Since they
have 8000 inactive accounts I really think they want members to leave.
This isn't the same DCU I started with. I will probably leave my
account open long enough to use all my checks then close it out.
Wes
|
253.151 | A trembling RI'er | SPOCK::IRONS | Shiny, happy people holding hands! | Fri Aug 16 1991 17:06 | 11 |
| Well, being from Rhode Island, where the word Credit Union makes one
tremble in their shoes and check their pockets/purses for their
wallets, this big money rip-off scandel and increased fees in the DCU
scares me. Although, I didn't lose a thing from the RI scandels, I
think everyone should think of theses scandels and beware. DCU might
be desparately trying not to go under, as incredible as it might seem.
The main reason I joined DCU is because of convienience. I'll wait and
see what unfolds here, but probably I'll join a RI bank.
dave
|
253.152 | Contact your Traveletter department to add weight to the issue! | POBOX::KAPLOW | Set the WAYBACK machine for 1982 | Fri Aug 16 1991 18:33 | 12 |
| re: .63
Anyone who is planning on closing their DCU checking account, and
now has expenses directly deposited there:
PLEASE!!! Contact your local FMC (their DTN is in the Digital
Telephone Directory under Traveletter) and tell them to stop
sending your expense checks to DCU. I just spoke with the Midwest
FMC in Colorado (they handle Chicago), and they are expecting a
deluge of these requests. The FMC manager has spoken with the
local DCU manager to no avail. They are elevating the issue within
Digital to put pressure on the DCU. It can't hurt.
|
253.153 | | VERGA::WELLCOME | Steve Wellcome (Maynard) | Mon Aug 19 1991 10:11 | 13 |
| When DCU first opened, I didn't join; I had a checking account with
another bank that was giving very good service. After a couple of
years, DCU's rates and convenience were obviously better, so I joined.
Would I join DCU now? I doubt it. Will I leave DCU? Quite possibly.
I've got two CD's, a RSVP account, and a savings account, all with
"significant" cash in them; why the hell do I need $1000 in my
*checking* account???
And can anybody tell me why low-activity accounts are so burdensomely
expensive? They're just another record in a computer file. The
only expense is monthly mailings and a little computer time.
Twelve 29-cent stamps is $3.48/year.
|
253.154 | CD=Free Checking | CNTROL::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Tue Aug 20 1991 12:29 | 7 |
| � I've got two CD's, a RSVP account, and a savings account, all with
� "significant" cash in them; why the hell do I need $1000 in my
� *checking* account???
Since you have CDs, you *don't* need to keep $1000 in checking to avoid
the fees. You also get the "added benefits" of a credit line and
purchase protection.
|
253.155 | With features like this, who needs requirements? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Tue Aug 20 1991 13:34 | 11 |
|
RE: .154
Your CD's must be >= $2500 for "DCU PLUS Checking". If they fall below
$2500, there is a $5 charge. Hmmmm, the "additional features" (gotta
love this brochure!) column also states "dividends on balances > $1000.
So if you have $2500 in CDs and a balance of $999 you get no interest
on your checking balance? What a feature. This should be listed as a
requirement for interest instead of a feature.
|
253.156 | | CNTROL::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Tue Aug 20 1991 13:53 | 5 |
| �Hmmmm, the "additional features" (gotta
� love this brochure!) column also states "dividends on balances > $1000.
They don't pay dividends on checking balances <$1000 under the current
schedule.
|
253.157 | I'm not using my CD's for service free checking, in fact I moved it to another bank. | HDLITE::HORTON | Ken Horton, KA1GFN | Tue Aug 20 1991 14:04 | 12 |
| re : 154, 155
From the way that I read the brochure, you would have to keep $2500 in your
CD in order to avoid service fees on checking. This means that at some point
in the future, if you needed the money which was in CD's, you would be forced to
pay the service fee. Even having > $1000 in checking would not be an option to
avoid the fee. This limitation put me totally against the PLUS checking.
As it had happened, I had closed my CD's about a month ago upon maturity.
The timing was right as I opened up CD's in another bank last week. The amount
was many times higher than the $1000 I would have needed in checking to avoid
the service fee but I did not consider this a reasonable option.
|
253.158 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Tue Aug 20 1991 14:15 | 32 |
|
RE: .156
Yes, but I was hoping the PLUS in DCU PLUS checking meant something
besides PLUS additional frivilous benefits. OK, overdraft protection
may be useful but if you don't bounce checks, then it's not needed.
Purchase protection, a PLUS? Next joke.
So, bottom line is even the "free" DCU plus account requires a high
minimum balance of $1000 to get interest. I would think that having
$2500 in CDs DCU could lower that $1000 a bit. From all my
investigations into choices 3,4,5,etc., $1000 is VERY high. Small
credit unions are much lower. Large banks are much lower. How on
earth does DCU arrive at the conclusion this is competitive? Maybe we
should be asking DCU to post the names of institions which it used to
determine it's 'choices' were competitive? I've given up trying to
find these (un)competitive places.
I have cut out a great add in one section of the Worcester Telegram. A
very timely add IMO. The top reads "If this is your bank's idea of
"free" checking, perhaps you should check with us." Under these words
are cutouts of adds for 3 institutions that say: "Free Checking!
(minimum balance $2500) Monster Bank of Massachusetts", "Free
Checking! Minimum balance $800 Rich Bank of Central Mass.", Free
Checking! (Minimum Balance $1000) Big, Big City Bank"
Then at the bottom it says: "We're the Leominster Credit Union, and if
you're sick and tired of high fees and exaggerated claims, you owe it
to yourself to check us out."
I almost busted a gut laughing.
|
253.159 | missing from the ad | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Tue Aug 20 1991 15:31 | 3 |
| Thing is, I did check them (LCU) out last week. They too have
minimums. They might not be as high but they're there.
Denny
|
253.160 | | VERGA::WELLCOME | Steve Wellcome (Maynard) | Tue Aug 20 1991 15:55 | 12 |
| The way I read the brochure, if I don't choose "CHECKING PLUS!!!"
and instead opt for a plain old vanilla-flavored checking account,
the fact that I have two CDs doesn't matter.
And what happens when the CDs reach maturity? If I sign up for
"CHECKING PLUS!!!" it means I *have* to buy another DCU CD, and
that sure doesn't sound as though DCU is extending my "list of
available options." It's restricting my list of options...to DCU.
Anybody else remember pre-DCU and Worker's Credit Union in Fitchburg?
I found their service excellent...maybe time to reestablish contact....
|
253.161 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 21 1991 10:01 | 14 |
|
RE: .159
Yes, LCU has minimums too. Almost all do. But they are $100 & $400
depending on the account. LCU is a fairly small CU in comparison to
DCU so how can they keep their minimums so low in these hard times?
I also checked out Peoples Savings Bank which is a fairly large bank in
Central Mass. Their minimums were no where near DCU. They also
offered about 6 different variations ('choices' in DCU lingo) of
checking.
Has anybody found any place that is WORSE than DCU???
|
253.162 | Yes... | SLOAN::HOM | | Wed Aug 21 1991 10:47 | 7 |
| I have an account with BayBank. Their minimum balance is $1,500. But
they offer more ATM's.
Unfortunately, most of the banks near Maynard and east of Maynard
have high minimum balance requirements.
Gim
|
253.163 | | BEATLE::REILLY | So I rewired it... | Wed Aug 21 1991 13:06 | 28 |
|
No question that Big Banks have high minimums. But then you do get
more Big Services. For DCU, I don't want or expect Big Services, and
as a trade-off I expect no minimums.
For instance, at BayBanks I need $2000 in savings to get absolutely no
fee whatsoever (there are many other checking plans). Why do I
consdider that still better than DCU?
- The $2000 can be in savings (making better interest)
- Convenience - there are always more BayBanks near me than DCU's.
- Free ATM - DCU ATM is not free in my opinion, because when you
need money, you are generally only near a Cirrus, not a DCU machine,
hence $1 charge. Baybanks ATM's are EVERYWHERE. I live by the ATM.
- My ATM can be used anywhere a MasterCard can as a withdrawl from
my checking account for NO fee (Express Check).
The above two basically give me the ability to get money anywhere
and write checks anytime without having to carry a checking book
around.
DCU keeps comparing itself to other banks, but the only thing they
have in common are the FEES not the SERVICES. Fine if you want
require minimums, but you better give me high services. If you have l
low services give me no minimums. DCU was the few places to do the
latter.
- Sean
|
253.164 | re: .160 WCU was pretty good . . . | MVDS00::LOCKRIDGE | Artificial Insanity | Wed Aug 21 1991 13:28 | 19 |
| re: .160
> Anybody else remember pre-DCU and Worker's Credit Union in Fitchburg?
> I found their service excellent...maybe time to reestablish contact....
I joined WCU when I joined Digital. I seem to remember their service
being fairly good. I started out in Mass, transferred to NJ and then
to NH and had no problems with them that I recall. Dealing with them
through the mail was effortless. I changed over to DCU when it was
started (I still have my "Charter Member" certificate filed away - too
bad THAT'S not worth $2500 :-) ) because of convenience and at the
time, DCU paid better interest and had better rates.
For the most part I was well pleased with WCU. If I still lived in
Mass (heaven forbid! :-) ), I'd probably look into them again. I'm
sure giving serious consideration to moving all my funds out of DCU
with this latest fiasco.
-Bob
|
253.165 | requiring direct deposit to waive fees | BROKE::LERNER | Cyndi Bliss NUO1-1/B09 264-0583 | Wed Aug 21 1991 15:24 | 7 |
| The other thing that every bank I looked at (including the megalith
baybank where I've had an account for years specifically because of
the free ATMs all over MA) had was that they did not require direct
deposit to waive fees. At least the way I read the stuff from the DCU,
just having >1000 in the checking account would only waive part of the
fees. To waive all the fees, you'd have to have at least $100 of your
paycheck direct deposited to the checking account at DCU.
|
253.166 | solutions are required - not too many options | SLOAN::HOM | | Wed Aug 21 1991 15:48 | 18 |
| As everyone knows, there's a huge loss due to actions of the past
DCU president. Some amount of the money will be recovered by ligitation
and bonds. There will be a portion nonetheless that will NOT be covered.
Since the DCU deals with money, the only way to make up for the
non-performing loans is to either increase revenue, i.e. the new
fees and higher loan interest or reduce expenses (lower interest rates paid
on deposits, fewer tellers, etc.)
I don't believe that increasing the number of shareholders is a viable
option at this time.
Seems to me that the DCU has taken this course of action by necessity.
I, however, in no way support the manner that it was done. The ad
"more options..." is an insult to anyone's intelligence.
Gim
|
253.167 | Direct Deposits Delayed? | CGVAX2::LEVY_J | | Wed Aug 21 1991 16:01 | 17 |
| Anyone know why the direct deposits have not been done yet today?
I understand this is usually accomplished Tuesday night. I was
just told by DCU in MKO that O/T is a problem and "some" other
direct deposits also.
The system came up after the hurricane and now apparently is down
again.
I'm probably just getting paranoid, what with things like they are
these days, but would really like some reassurance I'll be paid
this week.
Think I'll go back to a hard check - I think the feel of it in my
hand would be nice.
Janet
|
253.168 | Direct Deposit...last one I hope! | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his Lips...Know new taxes! | Wed Aug 21 1991 16:51 | 2 |
| Mine's in there.
Denny
|
253.169 | FREE CHECKING IN WESTFORD | REGENT::CIAMPA | | Wed Aug 21 1991 17:46 | 11 |
| WOW! TOO MANY TO READ! BUT IF NO ONE ALREADY MENTIONED IT:
CENTRAL SAVINGS BANK IN WESTFORD ON 110 OFFERS FREE CHECKING WITH
DIRECT DEPOSIT INTO THE ACCOUNT.
THE HAVE ABOUT 5 OTHER BRANCHES ALONG 495 AND NORTH
DON'T KNOW THE NUMBER OFF HAND BUT IF ANYONE IS INTERESTED I'LL LOOK IT
UP.
JOE
|
253.170 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Wed Aug 21 1991 19:06 | 16 |
| People have been asking about what it costs to maintain small,
inactive accounts. They mentioned monthly mailings. You
only get a monthly mailing if there is a checking account
attached to the account.
My family has 7 accounts under my badge. (My own, and 6
family sub-accounts.) My primary account and 2 of the family
accounts have checking accounts. We get monthly statements for
them regardless of the past month's activity (or lack thereof.)
The other 4 accounts (relatively inactive) do not have checking
accounts, and we only get quarterly statements for them.
So the cost to maintain inactive samll accounts may even be
less than estimated.
Joe Oppelt
|
253.171 | checking vs. savings | SICML::LEVIN | My kind of town, Chicago is | Fri Aug 23 1991 19:26 | 16 |
| re: .170
<< So the cost to maintain inactive samll accounts may even be
<< less than estimated.
Yes, I guess thats why it's only the checking accounts - which are legally
required to send monthly statements - that are getting the service charge,
not the savings only for which DCU is only obligated to send quarterlies.
I've suggested to DCU that they follow the lead of some other financial groups
and let people request that all family accounts be consolidated onto a single
statement. I was told that that's the only possible way they could even attempt
to control mailing costs on the statements this way - since otherwise they have
to send each account separately. (Seems in some families people don't want their
spouse to see each other's statements.)
/Marvin
|
253.172 | Today $2.00 tomorrow ..... | MSBCS::KING | VSS BXB/LTN System Management Group DTN:293-5677 | Mon Aug 26 1991 11:00 | 20 |
| I'd guess that in the future the fees will increase. Perhaps as early as next
year. Financial institutions have a habit of doing this. Sliding increases in
unobtusively while we get used to the current fees. I think the climbing
interest rate on the VISA card is a perfect evidence of that. I think it was
10.46% when I got one 4� years ago. Now its 15.50% and I'm cancelling it when
it comes up for renewal.
I sent a letter to DCU care of the Board of Directors detailing my
dissatisfaction with their current practices. I have not heard back from them
so I guess they just don't care. I guess they don't need my business anymore.
I could have maintained a balance to waive the fees easily but do not wish to tie
up that much money so that it can earn a paltry 4.45% interest. It can do much
better in a mutual fund.
I am very unhappy with DCU and do not think they deserve my patronage any longer.
Bryan
|
253.173 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Tue Aug 27 1991 15:24 | 21 |
|
And to add insult to injury....
Back page of latest DTW:
"Digital Credit Union expands checking account services
Effective September 1, 1991 Digital Credit Union (DCU) will introduce
'Lifestyle Checking', an expanded program offering two accounts with
unlimited check writing privileges, overdraft protection, ATM
availability, and touch tone phone access. Plus, members have the
opportunity to earn interest every day their account balance is $1,000
or more."
.
.
.
blah, blah... blah, blah... blah, blah...
Is this a DCU submission? WILL THEY NEVER LEARN?
|
253.174 | Think about publishing deadlines... | SSBN1::YANKES | | Tue Aug 27 1991 18:07 | 14 |
|
Re: .173
Something to ponder before flaming about the DTW: This fee issue has
only been brewing for a few weeks now, and publications do have deadlines
that are typically far in advance of when it goes to print. (I know, I
know, the "T" in "DTW" is supposed to mean "This" week, but most of the
items reported on are typically several weeks old.) It is quite possible
that the deadline for getting this article into DTW was before this
notesfile started exploding in anger. While the BoD _might_ be trying
to ignore the complaints in this notesfile, I wouldn't take the DTW
article as proof of it.
-craig
|
253.175 | We got lip service | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his lips...Know new taxes! | Wed Aug 28 1991 09:03 | 4 |
| re:-1 (DTW lead time)
That may be true, but how do you explain the 'MORE OPTIONS', " MORE
CHOICES' posters still being up in the branches?
Denny
|
253.176 | But what about the expanded fees??? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 09:33 | 9 |
|
RE: .174
I'm fully aware of the lead times involved in publishing DTW. My
primary objection to the article was AGAIN the insulting 'choices' BS
as well as the use of the term 'expanded'. The only thing that has
'expanded' have been the charges and fees. Yet not one single word of
the new fees in the article. Pure, unadulterated propaganda. But what
has become typical of DCU communication; tell half the story.
|
253.177 | Keep "then" versus "now" information separate. | SSBN1::YANKES | | Wed Aug 28 1991 11:26 | 22 |
|
Re: .175
Excuse me, but I didn't say that _every_ piece of communication
that we're seeing is reasonable to expect and thus I was not, and am
not, defending every aspect of this PR catastrophy. I was pushing back
on the DTW complaint, however, since even if the BoD changed their minds
*immediately* after the very first outcry in this notesfile, that DTW
article would probably still hit the streets due to publishing deadlines.
Therefore, its existance is indicative of nothing other than what the
BoD's PR compaign was _back then_ and says nothing about their views
today. (And yes, the PR campain back then was, and still is, to hide
the fees. Is it really news to anyone, then, that the DTW article
didn't say "hey you folks are going to pay through the nose now!"?)
The posters are, of course, a totally different issue since they
could be removed within an hour of the BoD calling whomever and saying
"we blew it, take 'em down." Therefore, they are indicative of what
the Board feels _today_ -- which is the important thing if we're all
trying to read between the lines for some hint of a fee pullback.
-craig
|
253.178 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 12:59 | 19 |
|
RE: .177
>the Board feels _today_ -- which is the important thing if we're all
>trying to read between the lines for some hint of a fee pullback.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
While I was optimistic that this would occur also, after the first BoD
meeting I was convinced this is not a possibility.
If fact, a comment was made (not sure by who) that the BoD wasn't sure
that the people in this conference necessarily represented the views of the
DCU membership. A reference was made to "people whining" in here. So
while the BoD reads this conference, they discount what is said in here
to a certain degree. They will have to tell you how much. Maybe the
BoD should publish their phone numbers in the next brochure so that all
members can call them personally and then they can see first hand if we
are "representative"?
|
253.179 | | SSBN1::YANKES | | Wed Aug 28 1991 13:34 | 18 |
|
Re: .178
Well, frankly, *I* don't know just how representative this
notesfile is of the overall DCU membership either since there is no
factual basis (ie. survey of all the members' views compared to the
views of the DCU Notesfile participants) for making such a claim.
We can think we're representative (and who knows, we just might be!),
but we really can't chide the board for not believing something that we
can't prove ourselves. I'm not trying to sound like I'm defending the
board, but lets put their statements into perspective before we lambast
them every time they exhale!
As to a fee pullback, I don't expect it either.
-craig
p.s. What is the status of the petition to hold a special meeting?
|
253.180 | Does DCU read their own surveys? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 14:52 | 49 |
|
RE: .178
The fact that we have access to a means of expressing our opinions
(this conference) and many of the thousands of DCU membership cannot
or do not participate in this forum does not invalidate many of the
issues brought up in here.
DCU always cites their research and market studies as a basis for their
decisions. Well, I would also like to quote from one of their surveys.
Boy am I glad I don't throw anything out! ;-)
This is from the InputOutput flyer dated October, 1989. The first
segment entitled "The results are in...". Second paragraph, first
sentence:
"According to the analysis submitted by Wallace and Washburn, Inc.,
most of our members joined and continue to do business with the Credit
Union because of automatic payroll deduction, convenient locations, and
FREE checking."
(the capitalization of FREE is theirs, not mine)
Now my question is "Doesn't DCU or it's BoD read their own market
surveys?" If FREE checking is listed in the top 3 reasons people join
and do business with DCU, wouldn't the elimination of that program
severely impact DCU? Especially when almost all of it's competitors
are offering free checking of one sort or another?
Now, one of the following must be true. Anybody have any other
explanations?
1. They didn't know all of the above and decided to institute fees
to generate income. In which case they didn't do their homework
and just decided to institute the fees because they needed the
income.
2. They knew all of the above but decided to take a chance with new
fees because they believed members perceived benefit from other
DCU services and wouldn't leave. And they need the income.
3. They knew of the importance of FREE checking to DCU members but
needed the sizable income that the new fees would generate. In
which case, they are not in the good condition they profess (IMO).
4. DCU members are hooked on the convenience and are too lazy to
go elsewhere. (unless their pocket is being picked of course)
|
253.181 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 14:56 | 9 |
|
> p.s. What is the status of the petition to hold a special meeting?
Planning and organization is underway. First meeting to be held
before the end of this week. Look for visible signs of action at
locations near you next week. Volunteers still welcome. The more
participation the better. Stay tuned...
|
253.182 | | CHIEFF::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Wed Aug 28 1991 16:01 | 1 |
| DCU still offers free checking. There are just more strings attached.
|
253.183 | | CHIEFF::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Wed Aug 28 1991 16:01 | 2 |
| How many notesfiles, editorial pages, etc. are there out there where
people contribute just to say "well done"?
|
253.184 | Strings?? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 16:37 | 10 |
|
.182> DCU still offers free checking. There are just more strings attached.
Right. They also offer free loans. But with strings attached.
.183> How many notesfiles, editorial pages, etc. are there out there where
.183> people contribute just to say "well done"?
^^^^^^^^^
Hmmm, the COOKING notesfile maybe? ;-)
|
253.185 | | SSBN1::YANKES | | Wed Aug 28 1991 18:45 | 19 |
|
Re: .180
You missed the point of what I'm saying. I _didn't_ say that the
points being raised here are invalid since not everyone in DCU
participates. I _did_ say that we shouldn't expect for the BoD
to automatically treat this notesfile as a cross-the-board survey of
the membership. A subtle, but important, difference since notesfiles
tend to attract the people who are the most opinionated about a topic.
For example, if 99% of the people participating in the FELINE
conference think that cats are great pets, it doesn't mean that 99% of
the whole world thinks that cats are great pets. (And no, I don't
participate in that conference so don't hold me to those numbers! :-)
Our views are important and I certainly hope the BoD is listening
(and, preferably, acting upon what they read here), but we have to be
careful about considering this notesfile as having _the_ representative
view of the membership.
-craig
|
253.186 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Aug 28 1991 19:59 | 21 |
|
RE: .185
I didn't miss your point. I know exactly what you're saying. I'm
merely stating what was said at the meeting. I have never said and
will not say we represent the DCU membership as a whole. At the same
time, I don't expect the BoD to dismiss or discount the people, comments,
suggestions, complaints, etc. just because they happen to appear here
instead in one of their surveys.
I would love to see a DCU survey issued at this time to guage whether
the BoD represents the DCU membership. How about it BoD? Can you
spare a survey? You can even put it in next month's statements. That
way everybody should get one and you'll get a real good idea of just
what the membership thinks. But please spare the Mom and apple pie
questions. Find out if members have recently shopped around for loans
and gone with DCU or somebody else. Find out if members think it's more
important to offer paying bills by phone and purchase protection or
free checking with a reasonable minimum. Find out if members expect a
credit union to be more than competitive when it comes to rates.
|
253.187 | Surveys -- not with monthly statements, either | MLTVAX::SCONCE | Bill Sconce | Thu Aug 29 1991 10:49 | 15 |
| The "point" about selective sampling could (and should) be taken one step
further.
The community whose opinions are important to DCU's future are not just those
who participate in this conference, as previously observed. However, neither
is the community whose opinions are important to DCU's future just those who
are current DCU members.
The community whose opinions are important to DCU's future are:
o all current DCU members, plus
o all DEC employees who have not seen fit to join DCU, plus
o all DEC employees who used to be DCU members and have seen fit to leave.
A really meaningful survey should not just be mailed with statements. It
would have to include all DEC employees.
|
253.188 | I'm a whiner, too! | LAVC::CAHILL | Jim Cahill | Thu Aug 29 1991 11:33 | 14 |
| I believe that for every "whiner" in this conference, there are probably 10-100
others who are just too feed up to fight it, and are closing their accounts and
taking their business elsewhere.
If I was a businessman and someone came into my store to complain about
something, I'd wonder how many other shoppers just said "Oh, well, I'll just
spend my money somewhere else!"
A survey is a good idea, but unfortunately, a lot of "whiners" have already
shopped around and gone elsewhere. The few that are actively fighting to get
our credit union turned around and back on track are now being labeled as
"whiners"..... how sad.
Jim
|
253.189 | Should we change this to DCU_WHINERS? | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Thu Aug 29 1991 11:42 | 15 |
|
RE: .187 & .188
Excellent points on both!
I'm sure the Communist Party aparatchiks in the U.S.S.R. considered
the people in the streets whiners too. All movements start out as a
single person "whining" in the street.
Whiners are people who complain and offer no solutions or alternatives.
Activists speak out and offer real solutions to real problems. Too bad
our credit union and it's management and BoD haven't learned to tell
the difference. Guess their "surveys" have been telling them what they
want to hear.
|
253.190 | | AURORA::MACDONALD | | Thu Aug 29 1991 12:42 | 8 |
|
Re: whiners
A conversation with a teller here at the ZKO branch revealed that
a number of people just came in and said "give me my money."
Steve
|
253.191 | Teller here was unusually sour this am! | BTOVT::EDSON_D | | Thu Aug 29 1991 13:58 | 5 |
| re .190
You know, I got a sour look from the teller here this morning!
She's always cheerful. I wonder if they're running into the
same bailout?
|
253.192 | | VERGA::WELLCOME | Steve Wellcome (Maynard) | Thu Aug 29 1991 14:23 | 23 |
| The readers of this file are certainly not typical of the DCU
membership at large; thanks to the diligent efforts of several
noters, chiefly Phil Gransewicz, we are much better informed
about the facts than most members. Would the DCU membership
at large tend to share the opinions expressed in this notesfile
if they were aware of all the facts, instead of just the material
presented in the glossy propaganda blurbs? I expect so. If the
BoD chooses to continue its present policy, which seems to be to
keep the members as ignorant as possible about what is going
on,...I am disturbed.
My guess is:
1) the credit union is hurting;
2) the BoD thinks (rightly or wrongly) that if the members knew
how bad things are, they'd bail out;
3) therfore, the BoD is doing its best to convince us everything
is "just fine" while they attempt to bail out the sinking boat.
This is not necessarily a bad thing to do, and I suppose one might
argue that it's the way to best prevent a wholesale panic that COULD
cause the collapse of the credit union. At this point, I think DCU,
while not particularly robust, is in not immediate danger of
collapsing. But I remain annoyed by the BoD's attitude in general.
|
253.193 | | HPSRAD::RIEU | Read his lips...Know new taxes! | Thu Aug 29 1991 14:29 | 5 |
| I think the reason the tellers may be getting glum is that a lot of
the 'Direct deposit authorization Forms' have cleared payroll since the
new rates hit the fan. I'm sure that once people see that their pay is
now going to their new bank, they'll be closing their DCU accounts.
Denny
|
253.194 | DCU exists to serve its members not the other way around! | HPSRAD::KOPACKO | Ray Kopacko | Thu Aug 29 1991 16:20 | 23 |
| RE: .188
> I believe that for every "whiner" in this conference, there are probably
> 10-100 others who are just too feed up to fight it, and are closing their
> accounts and taking their business elsewhere.
Count me in as one of the silent ones you refer to. I hope that the board does
not make the mistake of only seeing scores of "whiners" in the notes file
or at these special meetings and think that they can blow them off. For
everyone that speaks up about this nonsense, there will be plenty who won't
bother. I personally feel that this is the proverbial straw that broke the
camel's back and have zero confidence in the DCU as a financial institution.
The convenience of the DCU is not worth being treated as an idiot who is
expected to be glad to be treated as one.
The DCU board and management have gone amuck with both their attitudes and
their practices. Many in this file have done a fine job of pointing this out
and I am thankful for your efforts. I regret that I can not find the time
nor energy (nor dollars!) to spend to correct the situation. I will remain
a member with a minimal savings account to secure voting rights and would be
happy to return in the future if the DCU can mend its ways.
Ray Kopacko
|
253.195 | | AURORA::MACDONALD | | Thu Aug 29 1991 16:49 | 12 |
|
Re: .194
> The convenience of the DCU is not worth being treated as an
> idiot who is expected to be glad to be treated as one.
You've said a mouthful. If they think that the $2 a month and
the convenience make it worth taking their crap they'd better
wake up fast while they still have a DCU to wake up to.
Steve
|
253.196 | | COOKIE::FREIWALD | Teach Peace! | Thu Aug 29 1991 21:03 | 8 |
|
A point on the ratio of 'whiners' to the silent masses.
A standard rule in politics is one letter is worth about a thousand votes.
If this extends to one 'whiner' being worth a thousand other dissatisfieds
the DCU is going to be in for some rough times.
:-Chuck
|
253.197 | DCU Incompetence NEVER Ends! | EMIRFI::SEGAL | Len Segal, MLO6-1/U30, 223-7687 | Fri Aug 30 1991 11:39 | 48 |
| DCU STRIKES AGAIN!!
I (tried) to close my RSVP and Sharedraft Accts at DCU on Monday of
this week. All I wanted to do was to TRANSFER the $100 that was
left in each of these accounts to my Share 1 Acct!! Simple, right?
NO, not at DCU. They transferred the Sharedraft balance to Share 1,
but "CAN'T TRANSFER THE RSVP", they "have to" Mail a check to my
home, as the RSVP $100 balance is "UNAVAILABLE". I never heard such
rubbish... [Dianne L. Ardogna (sp?) at the Mill was the teller and
attached a note to my receipt.]
I would have raised holy hell, but unfortunately I wasn't there (I'm
out on STD for the next few weeks due to a separated shoulder). My
Wife (also a DECcie, she also has her own account, and she is
co-signer on my accounts) took care of the transaction.
<set mode sarcastic>
Well, it is 4 days later and no sign of a check...it'll probably
take a few months, after all they'll probably have to get $100 worth
of gold transferred from Fort Knox and sell it on the open market to
pay me off!
<set mode back to mild flame>
Whenever they get around to sending me the check, I'll just deposit
it at a real financial institution, NOT DCU. I find it hard to
believe that they are that stupid that they would rather "lose" the
funds than transfer them to another DCU sub-account. [Yes, I know
that I can't re-open the RSVP for at least a year...have no fear, by
then DCU will probably be charging us interest to hold our money!
:-(]
I sent a pointed, but polite letter to every member of the DCU BOD,
never got a response, but hardly expect one. I am a Charter Member
of DCU, with my name up on the plaque, have had CD's and a loan
(~1982, but the handling of that was a joke...it took a full week to
get approval on a SHARE SECURED LOAN, where the entire amount of the
loan principal was being held by DCU in the DCU...I did the same
thing at another CU and it took 4 hours to "approve" and receive the
check), I used to keep >$20K in DCU when they paid competitive
interest rates, etc., my ATM cards expired in May 91 and I never
received replacements (nor do I want them at this point), and gave
them back my gold VISA last year, etc.
DCU...A great "institution" to do business with (provided that you
are ready for an institution!!).
|
253.198 | RSVP experiance | MSBCS::KING | VSS BXB/LTN System Management Group DTN:293-5677 | Fri Aug 30 1991 12:05 | 17 |
| Len,
I transferred my money out of RSVP into one of the other
sharedrafts a few months ago because I needed the money. The last
$100 were moved into the share 1 account immediately. The only
problem I had was I cannot open up another RSVP account for 1 year.
Why? I don't know. I suppose its just another benign rule set up
by the credit union to protect their cash reserves.
I went to the Taylor Street branch. I like the people down there
and will miss them when I close my account out tomorrow. I'm
moving to Baybank where the checking account is free of all
services charges if you have direct deposit and work at DEC.
Bryan
|
253.199 | | DECSIM::GILLETT | And you may ask yourself, 'How do I work this?' | Fri Aug 30 1991 12:10 | 46 |
| > I (tried) to close my RSVP and Sharedraft Accts at DCU on Monday of
> this week. All I wanted to do was to TRANSFER the $100 that was
> left in each of these accounts to my Share 1 Acct!! Simple, right?
> NO, not at DCU. They transferred the Sharedraft balance to Share 1,
> but "CAN'T TRANSFER THE RSVP", they "have to" Mail a check to my
> home, as the RSVP $100 balance is "UNAVAILABLE".
That's incredibly strange! I've never had trouble moving money
around different accounts, nor have I had trouble taking *large*
sums (well, large for me...5 figures) of money out of savings or
RSVP. Of course, I've never tried to *close* my RSVP account, at
least not yet :-).
Part of me wants to believe that this is some sort of Engineered
Annoyance, but I find that hard to believe. Why the heck would
they do that?
> I would have raised holy hell, but unfortunately I wasn't there (I'm
Well, when you get back there, you should *still* raise holy hell.
> (~1982, but the handling of that was a joke...it took a full week to
> get approval on a SHARE SECURED LOAN, where the entire amount of the
> loan principal was being held by DCU in the DCU...I did the same
> thing at another CU and it took 4 hours to "approve" and receive the
> check), I used to keep >$20K in DCU when they paid competitive
Secured loans at DCU are still a real hassle. You have to go
through the full loan qualification process, and then pay (I
believe) something on the order of 10% for your money. The
process takes at least a week to process, and is an enormous
hassle. All this, so you can borrow against your *OWN MONEY*
(!).
I wanted to do a secured loan deal in April when I bought a new
car. After seeing what DCU was up to, I went down to Hudson
(Mass) Savings Bank, deposited $15K, took out a secured loan for
$13K (at 2% interest above the interest on the CD securing the
loan), and was in and out of the bank with a cashier's check in
less than 30 minutes. That what I call real service. And the
terms of the loan are such that if you work the numbers, I'm
making money on the whole deal.
Well, that's $15K less for DCU to conservatively invest :-).
/Chris
|
253.200 | I'm out of here too ! | AKOCOA::OSTIGUY | Digital Internal Use Only | Fri Aug 30 1991 12:34 | 11 |
| I hope the info. about BAYBANK being free if a DECee uses Direct
deposit since I t will be closing out my many RSVP (few kids) accounts
and transferring them to a FREE checking environment. I can not
see keeping 1k in a checking acct. even though my balance has often
been at that level. And taking $ out of an RSVP to buy a CD is
stupid ... it should make no difference the DCU were my 1,5k
plus is stored as long as its in DCU.
Next week my transfer will begin.....just got to get to a BayBank !
Also an original DCU member who has all sorts of accounts ! Lloyd
|
253.201 | Direct Deposit != FREE at Baybank | BEATLE::REILLY | So I rewired it... | Fri Aug 30 1991 12:58 | 15 |
|
� I hope the info. about BAYBANK being free if a DECee uses Direct
� deposit since I t will be closing out my many RSVP (few kids) accounts
� and transferring them to a FREE checking environment.
It's not free if you use direct deposit. There are many different
types of checking accounts there, all with different ways of
calculating your "fees," and there are a few ways to get a FREE
checking account.
However... there is no such account there that gives you FREE checking
merely by having direct deposit. You need to meet some some other
qualifications.
- Sean
|
253.202 | No problem here | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Fri Aug 30 1991 13:00 | 12 |
|
RE: rsvp
Hmmmm, I closed mine out completely and was handed a check for the
entire amount on the spot. Why would any money be required to be left?
And what's this about not being able to open another RSVP for a year.
When I closed mine that was never stated. Does it appear in PUBLISHED
DCU literature? This BS (worse than red tape) must go. It appears to
be punitive and that should NOT be the policy of a CREDIT UNION under
any circumstances.
|
253.203 | | CHIEFF::MACNEAL | ruck `n' roll | Fri Aug 30 1991 13:07 | 2 |
| Maybe it was becasue you had your wife close your RSVP account instead
of you doing it in person?
|
253.204 | Baybank account is free | MSBCS::KING | VSS BXB/LTN System Management Group DTN:293-5677 | Fri Aug 30 1991 13:51 | 10 |
| Sean,
The Baybank account that is free of monthly fees is the Fee
Saver account. I called Baybank in Everett the other day and they
told me DEC employees can get this account if they have direct
deposit.
Bryan
|
253.205 | | RGB::SEILER | Larry Seiler | Fri Aug 30 1991 14:01 | 7 |
| The stuff about not re-opening an RSVP account for a year is in the
literature, or at least it was a couple of years ago when I opened mine.
Plus I got a warning from the teller when I was going to close it.
I should have closed it anyway.
Enjoy,
Larry
|
253.206 | | BEATLE::REILLY | So I rewired it... | Fri Aug 30 1991 14:19 | 17 |
|
� The Baybank account that is free of monthly fees is the Fee
� Saver account. I called Baybank in Everett the other day and they
� told me DEC employees can get this account if they have direct
� deposit.
You are definitely getting different information than me. I just
called now to make sure, but they confirmed the brochure they sent
out to me when the fees went up - in order to obtain NO monthly charges
(this includes any constant fees per month as well as fees per
transaction since either mean "not free" to me) just having direct
deposit is not enough. EXCEPT - the operator did tell me that the
Westfield and Springfield DEC faciltities were exempt and could get
free checking for just having direct deposit. That struck me as very
strange. Why those 2 plants?
- Sean
|
253.207 | | AKOCOA::SALLOWAY | You'll See Perpetual Change | Fri Aug 30 1991 14:28 | 10 |
| I just converted my BayBank account to a no-fee account as a Digital
Direct Deposit customer. This has been costing me $8/month, but I
thought it was worth it for unlimited BayBank ATM usage, and Debit
Card access to my checking account at MAsterCard merchants. But they
never told me about the special deal as a Digital emplyee, even
though I have been using direct deposit there for years.
So, for me at least, something good came out of this discussion.
-Brian
|
253.208 | | BEIRUT::SUNNAA | | Fri Aug 30 1991 16:26 | 13 |
|
RE: Baybank
There is a baybank BASIC checking where you only pay 1.50 a month with
automatic deposit and you're limited to 8 checks a month and I think 3
ATM withdrawls. But you can withdraw $$ at the teller at no fee.
Additional checks over the 8 checks and 3 (maybe 4) ATM withdrawls, you
pay $.75.
It's is true that Westfield and Springfield facilities are offered free
checking account with Baybank.
|
253.209 | historic reasons | TOOK::ROSENBAUM | Rich Rosenbaum | Sat Aug 31 1991 00:18 | 8 |
| re. .206
- the operator did tell me that the
Westfield and Springfield DEC faciltities were exempt and could get
free checking for just having direct deposit. That struck me as very
strange. Why those 2 plants?
Those plants have been "grandfathered" under an agreement
with BayBank that dates back some time ago.
|
253.210 | Resolution of .197 DCU Saga | EMIRFI::SEGAL | Len Segal, MLO6-1/U30, 223-7687 | Tue Sep 03 1991 10:50 | 23 |
| RE: .197
Well I spoke with Mary Madden this AM and she didn't understand why
the teller couldn't process the transaction (cancel RSVP and xfer
the balance directly to Share 1) while my Wife was at the teller's
window. BTW: The transaction should have been done on 8/26 (when
my Wife tried to close out the RSVP and the teller told her that a
"check must be mailed to me at home" to close it out), however DCU
actually transferred the balance to Share 1 on 8/30 (they took 5
days to do this)!!
Mary told me that she would talk to the Mill Branch and correct the
"misinformation". I told her that I was used to misinformation at
DCU, it's been a continuing saga since its inception (refer to .197
for some examples), and that was one of the reasons that I have
moved almost all my $$ out of DCU. If the DCU were "honest and
upfront" with us, and stopped making the rules up "as they go", we
would be tolerant of the problems that DCU has and the steps it must
take to recover from them.
The discussion was cordial, but it only points to the need for a
"Mary Madden clone" in each branch to prevent the people there from
making up the rules "on the fly."
|
253.211 | Baybank | RUTLND::MCMAHON | Code so clean you can eat off it! | Tue Sep 03 1991 14:32 | 28 |
| re: Baybank. I'm ready to close my account out with those bozos. I've
been a customer for over ten years and right now I'm in the middle of
selling my house and buying another one. I took a treasurer's check
from Boston Federal Savings Bank (main office is in Burlington, MA) and
was going to be depositing it in my Baybank account. I was going to
need it within a couple of days for a down payment when I signed the
Purchase and Sale on my new house. I was told I wouldn't have access to
the funds for FIVE days while it cleared. I explained that it was a
treasurer's check from a bank in the same county and I was told it
didn't matter - it had to clear like any other check. I took the check
to the DCU and was told the funds were available immediately.
A few weeks later, I called Baybank about having funds wired into our
account, the proceeds from the impending sale of our house, and when
would the funds be available to me. We were trying to pass papers on
both houses the same day. I was told it would be at least 24 hours
AFTER THE WIRE TRANSFER WAS POSTED TO MY ACCOUNT. I was also given this
whole song and dance about how I would have to notify the branch
manager ahead of time because banks are very conservative and don't
like surprises, etc. You'd think they'd never handled a wire transfer
before. I checked with DCU and they told me how to have the money
routed to my account and that as soon as it was posted, it was
available to me.
I also have to pay $8.50 a month in service fees so my DEC direct-deposit
account won't cost me for every single transaction I make.
|
253.212 | Encountered same problem at MRO4 with closing RSVP account. | HDLITE::HORTON | Ken Horton, KA1GFN | Tue Sep 03 1991 16:20 | 8 |
| I recently closed my wifes RSVP account and was also told that they had
to mail the $100 remaining balance directly to our house. The teller told
me that if I needed the money immediately than she could probably get it
OK'ed by making a telephone call. It did not really matter to me so I figured
I would just wait for the check. This was at the MRO4
/Ken
|
253.213 | | CSC32::J_OPPELT | Royal Pane and Glass Co. | Tue Sep 03 1991 20:12 | 26 |
| The following is a part of what I recently mailed to a fellow
conference participant. I liked the way some of it sounded
so I thought I'd just paste it in here too:
In the past I have been one for reason
and understanding with DCU complaints. Mortgage hassles -- it
happens at every bank. Odd hours. It happens at many credit unions.
Lack of branches/ATMs -- most other credit unions I have dealt
with have had ONE branch, period. No frills. But they all have
the better rates for savings and loans.
Sometimes I wonder if ATT or IBM have credit unions, and if so,
how they operate.
I have been able to overlook all the other inconveniences and erosion
of benefits from DCU. But the "choices" we have today regarding
checking accounts are not acceptable to me -- even if it *IS* only
$2/month more than I was paying before. Mary Madden keeps saying to
compare DCU rates against other banks. The proper logic should
be to compare DCU rates against other CREDIT UNIONS. I'd like to
bet that most credit unions do not charge for checking.
There will be change in the month of September. I guarantee it.
The change will be where I do my banking.
Joe Oppelt
|
253.214 | Time to close accounts... DCU needs my interest money. | STAR::BUDA | Lighting fuses as I go | Tue Sep 03 1991 20:55 | 9 |
| I just closed my RSVP, and am in the process of closing the other
accounts. The teller had to call to 'headquarters' to get this done.
She could not give me a receipt at the time, but did tell me what the
ending balance would be (even I could have figured that out...).
No hassles closing an account, so I guess Mary is correct. Shop around
and find a better deal. I know I am.
- mark
|
253.215 | DCU holds treasure checks as well | ATPS::MOSKAL | | Wed Sep 04 1991 09:22 | 29 |
| re: .211
> re: Baybank. I'm ready to close my account out with those bozos. I've
> been a customer for over ten years and right now I'm in the middle of
> selling my house and buying another one. I took a treasurer's check
> from Boston Federal Savings Bank (main office is in Burlington, MA) and
> was going to be depositing it in my Baybank account. I was going to
> need it within a couple of days for a down payment when I signed the
> Purchase and Sale on my new house. I was told I wouldn't have access to
> the funds for FIVE days while it cleared. I explained that it was a
> treasurer's check from a bank in the same county and I was told it
> didn't matter - it had to clear like any other check. I took the check
> to the DCU and was told the funds were available immediately.
When we purchased our home, I used my DCU account to consolidate funds
for the closing. A few days before the closing, I deposited a CERTIFIED
bank draft/treasure's check into said account. The day before the closing,
I went to the DCU to get a bank draft only to find out that they had
placed a hold on the CERTIFIED deposit I had made a few days earlier.
Even though the draft/check had been cleared (originating bank had received
confirmation of the tranfer) by that time, DCU's hold wasn't scheduled
to expire for 2 more days. I ended up having to go down to DCU
headquarters to free up the funds..
With CERTIFIED funds, there should never be a hold!
Moreso, once a draft/check has cleared the originating bank, any holds
should expire immediately!
|
253.216 | DCU has good mortgage rates | NOTIME::SACKS | Gerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085 | Wed Sep 04 1991 11:20 | 7 |
| re DCU's loan rates as compared to other credit unions:
I've been shopping for mortgages. According to The Boston Globe's guide
to interest rates (published every Saturday), DCU's mortgage rates have
been consistently lower than other New England area credit unions for at
least the last several weeks. They're still a little higher than mortgage
companies, so I'm going with a mortgage company.
|
253.217 | Check around in NH | STAR::BUDA | Lighting fuses as I go | Wed Sep 04 1991 11:44 | 4 |
| Check out the ones in NH. The last I checked, they were not lower, but
higher, in more than one way (pts etc.).
- mark
|
253.218 | Hate the hassle, but... | TLE::EKLUND | Always smiling on the inside! | Wed Sep 04 1991 13:07 | 33 |
| Normally, I'm "read-only", but have follwed this conference for a
very long time. I'm also a charter member of DCU, have a variety of
checking accounts, regular accounts (would you believe 6?!), RSVPs (4)
and IRAs (2). Once had a car loan, now paid off. Also do VISA. Lots
of money flows through, and a lot just sits there.
I am more than a little disturbed over the change to checking. I'm
looking, but slowly. I figure that a whole LOT of people are in the
same mode. It takes time, and it's a hassle to change. And most
places may have free checking, but you still pay for the checks, so I
may stay long enough to use up the current supply. And I surely
will not pull out in the middle of a quarter, giving up substantial
interest...
And I'm pretty sure that there is an army of people in the same
boat. The shoe may not fall today or tomorrow or next month, but fall
it will... Two dollars a month is still two dollars a month.
Take note: just as many of us are "slow" to leave, we will be even
slower to return. And at that point the same conditions will be
necessary - DCU will need to offer us a BETTER deal than other
institutions, not just a comparable deal... So rolling back the
checking fees will probably NOT be sufficient to get us back.
If I were responsible for running the DCU, I would be very nervous
about the next few months, especially around the end of the quarter or
beginning of the new quarter. I would expect dramatic withdrawals.
Just my two cents.
Cheers!
Dave Eklund
|
253.219 | re. .218 | AKOCOA::OSTIGUY | Digital Internal Use Only | Wed Sep 04 1991 14:05 | 11 |
| Well said Dave. Although I did immediately close out one of my kids checking
account I have many more to go but will not do so in haste. I am looking and
looking for a place where the amount of cash I keep in the Institution is
sufficient to off-set any checking account maintenance costs. Any one of
the 3 RSVP accounts I have are many times greater that the lousy certificate
amount they want me to purchase etc. etc. etc.
Haste makes waste but once my actions have taken place they will never be
undoable with this DCU.
Still peeved ! Lloyd
|
253.220 | Subtle changes | VSSCAD::RITCHIE | Elaine Kokernak Ritchie | Wed Sep 04 1991 14:24 | 8 |
| I was at DCU yesterday to make a deposit to RSVP. Since I was not
awake, I told the teller to deposit to checking. The receipt now says
"Basic Checking" instead of Sharedraft for the account name.
I guess we aren't a credit union any more if we don't have sharedrafts.
Elaine
|
253.221 | | DECSIM::GILLETT | And you may ask yourself, 'How do I work this?' | Wed Sep 04 1991 14:29 | 22 |
| re: last two
I don't believe DCU is going to feel anything significant for
awhile. I suspect that the first wave of closings are from
either smaller depositors (not intended to belittle anybody here,
I consider myself to be a small depositor, although I'm hanging
on here for now) or people closing nonessential accounts. When
people with larger sums of money start making their decisions,
they could see some serious pounding here.
Think about it, if 100 "mere" $10,000 depositors up and leave,
they're down a cool million bucks. That's gotta hurt. And while
us small-timers can quickly jump to the nearest free checking
deal in the area, people with 6-figure deposits need to more
carefully consider their alternatives. When that starts
happening, maybe somebody over there will wake up.
Unfortunately, the way things are now I doubt that anybody in DCU
is going to listen until the "big players" start moving their
money elsewhere.
/c
|
253.222 | | BROKE::LERNER | Cyndi Bliss NUO1-1/B09 264-0583 | Wed Sep 04 1991 14:40 | 5 |
| re -.1
some of us "bigger" depositers have moved. I just moved >10k out of
the DCU (something akin to life savings). I'd imagine I'm not the only
one. The fees were just the last straw.
|
253.223 | | COOKIE::WITHERS | Bob Withers - In search of a quiet moment | Wed Sep 04 1991 14:45 | 12 |
| >================================================================================
>Note 253.213 STANDARD "FREE" CHECKING GOES AWAY SEPT 1!!! 213 of 213
>CSC32::J_OPPELT "Royal Pane and Glass Co." 26 lines 3-SEP-1991 19:12
>--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> The proper logic should
> be to compare DCU rates against other CREDIT UNIONS. I'd like to
> bet that most credit unions do not charge for checking.
If you look at the comparison I posted of Colorado institutions, SSFCU charges
$2/month if your combined savings and checking balance goes below $100.
> Joe Oppelt
BobW
|
253.224 | I am out of here too.... | MAVRIC::POST | When in doubt punt..... | Wed Sep 04 1991 15:03 | 38 |
| Howdy,
I am also one of those "silent" ones (in fact this is my first note in this
conference) who has had enough and is pulling out...
To reply to note .218 I have done alot of busness with the IBM Poughkeepsie
Employees Federal Credit Union, and would like to add my two cents. My father
worked for IBM in NY, and my family has done business with the IBM Employees
CU for 20+ years or so...When I started with DEC in '87 one of the first
things I did was join the DCU *assuming* I would get service comparible to the
IBM CU.
One of the 1st things out of college I needed was a new car. My college car was
on its last legs. Having only been working for 3 or so months I wanted to
finance 100% of the auto. The DCU policy was you must have 1 years insurance
paid in full up front. It did not matter that it was being deducted from my
check via Metpay. 1 years insurace was about 1000.00 which was 10% down on the
vehicle, and if I put 10% down I did not need the 1 years insurance!!! So I
checked with the IBM CU. 100% was fine, no insurance pre-payment, no hassel,
and the rate was 1� points lower and fixed!
I have another new vehicle loan with the IBM CU. I was able to apply by mail,
and again hassel free with a rate of 9.75% fixed, No matter how much down,
1 to 5 years and was willing to finance upto 100% of the bottom line INCLUDING
SALESTAX AND OTHER MISC STUFF, (I however opted for 90% of the purchase
price, 10% + tax and reg out of my pocket)
As for checking, the rates are comparible to DCU, interest earned no matter the
balance and ALWAYS FREE (other than the printing of the checks of course)...
ATM Usage - their internal and NYCE and as far as I know, free of charge!
Well the wife and I are going to share one checking account it looks like, and
I as soon as I refinance my current DCU auto loan with the IBM CU, I am
closing my accounts....
-Don Post
|
253.225 | New role for DCU... | SSBN1::YANKES | | Wed Sep 04 1991 15:18 | 26 |
|
Re: .221
Add one more to the list of >$10K people who have moved out of DCU.
(Well, come Oct 1 we'll move the IRAs and actually close most of the
accounts -- but they are down to the minimums already.)
Oh, I do stand corrected. I am going to keep a small bit of money
in my savings account. No, not for political impact, but rather for
lunch money when my wallet is low since I happen to work in a facility
that has a DCU branch in it. That's right, DCU has gone from being our
main repository of cash to being a backup lunch money provider. Congrats,
DCU, on your new role. May you do it better than you did your previous
role.
Concerning coming back (re: a few back there), I agree. Changing
banks (especially checking accounts) is a royal pain that I do not
relish doing. Unless DCU changes to offering something signficantly
better (_not_ just matching) what I now have at the local bank, I have
no incentive to undergo the hassle of moving banks again.
But, I am going to occasionally follow this notesfile in a
read-only mode. The next few months look like it could be an
interesting period in DCU's history.
-craig
|
253.226 | Been so long since it was a credit union, we all forget | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Sep 04 1991 15:19 | 19 |
|
RE: .221
I have pulled over 10K out already. I just don't trust the current
management with my money. I don't know what 'choice' they will offer
me next. I don't know what 'investment' I'll have to reimburse them
for next.
I certainly don't consider myself a big fish but credit unions shouldn't
be about big fish or little fish. They should be about members. The
Bank of Digital doesn't have members, it has customers. I don't think
many DCU members out there realize this very important difference and
what it SHOULD mean to them. The credit union, it's management and BoD
are accountable to its owners, that's you and I. Banks are accountable
to its owners, the stockholders. Exercise your rights of ownership if
you don't like what YOUR credit union has become.
DCU will be as good as we make it or let it will become more of a
bank if we all let it happen.
|
253.227 | Loosing in more than one way... | STAR::BUDA | Lighting fuses as I go | Wed Sep 04 1991 18:00 | 7 |
| I am oving over $5k of loans out of DCU. They were making money on
this money. This is actually worse, as they loose the interest.
They actually may be happy to see a bunch of money leave, as they had
too much and did not know what to do with it, last I heard...
- mark
|
253.228 | | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Wed Sep 04 1991 19:20 | 19 |
| RE: .227
>I am oving over $5k of loans out of DCU. They were making money on
>this money. This is actually worse, as they loose the interest.
>
>They actually may be happy to see a bunch of money leave, as they had
>too much and did not know what to do with it, last I heard...
Yes, you're right on both points.
Their excess deposits hurt the almighty ratios that DCU seems to care
more about than its members. More money on deposit should mean more
income for DCU since what they pay us should be less than what they are
making on it (HOPEFULLY!). Maybe there is NOBODY that wants to borrow
all our deposited money??? You know, I hear loan demand is down... ;-)
Very bizarre.
Hmmm, maybe we need people in charge that know how to MAKE a buck instead
of trying to TAKE a buck out of our pockets? Now there's a thought...
|
253.229 | | WLDBIL::KILGORE | Digital had it Then! | Thu Sep 05 1991 09:00 | 14 |
|
I've been wondering about this deposit/loan ratio for a while now...
I'll swear a few days ago I heard a comment on a news broadcast that
any recession recovery would be made sluggish by the fact that people
are saving less, so there is less capital to jump-start the economy.
All other things being equal, this should swing the deposit/loan ratio
in favor of loans, as a general rule. But DCU is claiming just the
opposite -- fewer loans, which swings the deposit/loan ratio in favor
of deposits.
Could it be that DCU members are much smarter than other banking
customers? Could it be that DCU does not know how to make loans?
|
253.230 | No excuse! | SSDEVO::RMCLEAN | | Fri Sep 06 1991 12:23 | 5 |
| The whole thing sounds Hokey! If the DCU could bring in more money from the
current set of customers then they Gotta be able to make money. It is clear
with the low interest rates there is NO reason they can't make money. Things
like Tnotes and Tbills are liquid and easy to manipulate. The difference in
rates between the rate they pay us and these is considerable.
|
253.231 | | NOTIME::SACKS | Gerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085 | Fri Sep 06 1991 17:10 | 4 |
| re .-1:
Have you looked at T-bill and T-note rates lately? They're in 5.5% to 5.75%
range.
|
253.232 | 1% profit is better than a loss!!! | SSDEVO::RMCLEAN | | Fri Sep 06 1991 18:35 | 4 |
| For short range ones that is true but that is STILL better than what they
pay us to give them the money!!! If ya can't find a better place to put
it then this would be good. They also could buy/sell 30year notes and make
money if they really have that much....
|
253.233 | 30 YEAR T BONDS ARE VERY SPECULATIVE | SMAUG::GARROD | An Englishman's mind works best when it is almost too late | Fri Sep 06 1991 20:27 | 10 |
| Re .-1
I sincerely hope they DON'T buy/sell 30 year notes. Not unless they
have the proverbial crystal ball that says for CERTAIN that interest
rates will only ever go down and not up. I don't want my credit union
speculating on 30 year notes. I'd much prefer they buy a 30 year
mortage to a member than a 30 year T bond. Here's one thing they are
doing right.
Dave
|
253.234 | Believe it when I READ it, in the financials. | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | I'M DCU and you're not. | Mon Sep 09 1991 08:50 | 6 |
|
RE: .233
I wouldn't speak so soon. Have we actually had an accurate statement
from DCU on what they do and don't "invest" in? Might be a good
question for tomorrow night's session.
|
253.235 | Something interesting | STAR::PARKE | I'm a surgeon, NOT Jack the Ripper | Mon Sep 09 1991 10:10 | 7 |
| I got my August statement Friday and to my suprise, the dividends were posted
to my sharedraft accounts as of the end of the month. I thought they weren't
supposed to be posted til the end of September ?
Also, there was another wonderful offer include. Hows about using their "auto
service" to buy, etc cars. How much comission does DCU get for this kind of
stuff ??
|
253.236 | | TOMK::KRUPINSKI | Repeal the 16th Amendment! | Mon Sep 09 1991 12:52 | 8 |
| It may very well be that DCU wants to get the owners of
very small/inactive accounts to take their money elsewhere..
I wonder how many of these accounts will be replaced by those
who used to use DCU as their primary financial institution, but
will now use it simply for "lunch money"?
Tom_K
|
253.237 | Lunch for me too... | SSDEVO::RMCLEAN | | Mon Sep 09 1991 14:20 | 6 |
| Count me in on the Lunch money from now on. I just got a new checking account
outside.
Also... Re .-3 I would much rather they invest in Tbills then let the money
sit around!!! Yes it would be nice to lend it to members but if you can't
find enough it is better to have a guaranteed return than 0%
|
253.238 | What a difference a year makes!! | SCHOOL::RIEU | Read his lips...Know new taxes | Fri Aug 07 1992 08:52 | 45 |
| Thanks Russ, you got the ball rolling!!!
Denny
<<< SMAUG::USER$944:[NOTES$LIBRARY]DCU.NOTE;5 >>>
-< DCU >-
================================================================================
Note 253.0 STANDARD "FREE" CHECKING GOES AWAY SEPT 1!!! 237 replies
NEWVAX::PAVLICEK "Zot, the Ethical Hacker" 35 lines 7-AUG-1991 09:59
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh rapture... Oh joy...
DCU is now offering us a "choice". It seems that we were unfairly
burdened by that old single-choice free checking account. But now,
DCU has "taken a positive approach to offering our members diversified,
high quality, competitively priced products and services"! They "have
restructured and expanded our checking accounts so you can select the
one that best matches your lifestyle"!
Now, you have a CHOICE! Now you can CHOOSE TO PAY FOR YOUR CHECKING
ACCOUNT!!!
Oh the wonder of it all!
Think how deprived we once were, suffering along with free checking!
Now we can have the honor of paying for it!
When, you ask? When will you get this marvelous choice?
Why, September 1, 1991! You hardly have anytime to wait at all until
this "choice" is all yours!!!
Isn't that FANTASTIC!?!?!?
-----------------
I joined DCU solely because of the free checking. Looks like I won't
be keeping my money here much longer.
The quotes are from a DCU flier in the DCO branch. I'll try to type in
the flier and the rates schedule when I get a chance.
Depressed,
-- Russ
|
253.239 | Hard to believe a year has passed | GUFFAW::GRANSEWICZ | | Fri Aug 07 1992 14:09 | 5 |
|
August 7th, 1991 - The date the shot heard 'round the DCU membership
was fired. Also, the beginning of the return of ownership to the
members.
|
253.240 | What a year! WHAT A YEAR!!! | NEWVAX::PAVLICEK | Zot, the Ethical Hacker | Mon Aug 10 1992 12:06 | 14 |
| re: .238
> Thanks Russ, you got the ball rolling!!!
I'd normally respond with "Anytime, dude!", but I sure as heck hope
this is the last time we'll need to travel down this road!
So, with that in mind, I'll just say:
Never again, dude! (Hopefully! 8^)
-- Russ
PS/ I think the new board is doing a great job!
|