[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::cellular

Title:Cellular Telephones
Moderator:COVERT::COVERT
Created:Wed Dec 21 1988
Last Modified:Thu May 22 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:514
Total number of notes:4434

451.0. "GSM,PCS, DCS,... ?" by ULYSSE::SEZNEC (Carpe Diem) Tue Aug 08 1995 11:46

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
451.1RANGER::WASSERJohn A. WasserWed Aug 09 1995 17:1915
451.2BRUMMY::MARTIN::BELLMartin Bell, M&U PSC, @BBPFri Aug 11 1995 06:3420
451.3RANGER::WASSERJohn A. WasserFri Aug 11 1995 13:3322
451.4ATLANT::SCHMIDTSee http://atlant2.zko.dec.com/Fri Aug 11 1995 16:297
451.5BUSY::BUSY::SLABOUNTYHoly rusted metal, Batman!Fri Aug 11 1995 17:273
451.6skylab.zko.dec.com::FISHERHow may I be honest with you today?-TuvokFri Aug 11 1995 17:283
451.7LJSRV2::phones.ljo.dec.com::kotokAlan Kotok, IBG, [email protected], DTN 226-2936Fri Aug 11 1995 17:533
451.8skylab.zko.dec.com::FISHERHow may I be honest with you today?-TuvokMon Aug 14 1995 11:307
451.9BRUMMY::MARTIN::BELLMartin Bell, M&U PSC, @BBPWed Aug 16 1995 13:2711
451.10Rough Guide.SNOFS1::HAGARTYDMein Leben als HundSun Oct 08 1995 21:3723
451.11COVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertSat Apr 05 1997 14:1816
	W A R N I N G :

	A friend of mine recently asked me, "Have you gotten a PCS
	phone yet?" to which I replied, "I don't think it's ready
	for prime time yet here in Boston."

	He insisted that his new Cellular One (Southwestern Bell)
	Digital PCS service was great, and was dual mode with the
	analog system, and so on and so on.

	Well, it's not PCS.  Southwestern Bell is using "PCS" for their
	850 MHz TDMA digital service (operates on the same frequencies
	as AMPS).

	This is about as close to false and deceptive advertising as
	anything I've seen so far.
451.12COVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertMon Apr 07 1997 23:3365
Quick summary:  PCS (in North America) is a new frequency allocation in
the 1850-1990 MHz bands.  There can be six carriers: A/B/C carriers each
get a 30 MHz allocation; C/D/E carriers get 10 MHz.

Extracted from the Omnipoint FAQ:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    � PCS operates in different frequencies from cellular. In the
    United States, cellular systems operate in the 824-849 megahertz
    (MHz) frequency bands; PCS operates in the1850-1990 MHz bands. All
    other things being equal, this difference in frequency use does not
    translate into any real advantage for PCS operators because the
    higher frequencies do not allow signals to travel as far as
    cellular signals. Consequently�again, all other things being
    equal--it generally takes a greater number of cell sites to cover a
    specific area using PCS frequencies than cellular frequencies. The
    advantage for PCS here is that more cell sites will mean better
    coverage and fewer dropped calls.

    � PCS licenses have different bandwidth sizes than cellular
    licenses. Cellular licenses give the operators (there are two
    licenses in each market) 25 MHz with which to work, whereas PCS
    operators can have two different sizes of licenses: 30 MHz (A-, B-
    and C-blocks) and 10 MHz (D-, E-, and F-blocks). There are six PCS
    licenses in each market. In addition, PCS operators can aggregate
    up to 40 MHz of spectrum in each market by buying one of each kind
    of license, generally allowing them to serve more customers in a
    market than cellular. Cellular carriers and other commercial mobile
    radio service (CMRS) operators can buy PCS licenses in markets that
    they cover as long as they do not exceed 45 MHz of combined
    frequencies for any particular market. The real advantage for PCS
    is that the 30 MHz and 10 MHz licenses are contiguous, which cuts
    down on the cost of infrastructure and subscriber equipment. So,
    the advantages are: 1) more capacity, and; 2) lower infrastructure
    and subscriber costs.

    � PCS covers different geographic regions than cellular. A/B-block
    PCS licenses are based on Major Trading Areas (MTAs)--geographic
    regions developed by Rand McNally that are approximately the size
    of one or more states�and Basic Trading Areas (BTAs), smaller
    regions that fit within the MTAs. There are 51 MTAs and 493 BTAs in
    the United States. The A/B-block auction sold MTA licenses, while
    the C-, D-, E-, and F-block auctions are based on BTA licenses.
    Cellular licenses are based on Metropolitan statistical areas
    (MSAs) and rural service areas (RSAs), both of which approximate
    BTAs in size.

Omnipoint initially obtained the licenses to operate PCS-1900 GSM based
service:

    � the New York MTA "A-band" license (27 million pops)
    � "C-band" BTAs: Amarillo, Texas; Springfield-Holyoke, Mass.;
    Lebanon-Claremont, N.H.; Pittsfield, Mass; Philadelphia,
    Pa.-Wilmington, Del.; Harrisburg, Pa.; York-Hanover, Pa.; Reading,
    Pa.; Atlantic City, N.J.; Dover, Del.; Sunbury-Shamokin, Pa.;
    Williamsport, Pa.; Pottsville, Pa.; State College, Pa.;
    Buffalo-Niagara, N.Y.; Rochester, N.Y.; Pine Bluff, Ark.; Wichita,
    Kans. (13.3 million pops)

More recently, Omnipoint obtained D, E, or F band licenses for Boston,
Providence, Washington DC, Baltimore, Norfolk, Miami, Detroit, St. Louis,
Indianapolis, Nashville, and San Antonio.

/john
451.13bhajee.rto.dec.com::JAERVINENOra, the Old Rural AmateurMon Apr 28 1997 05:212
    Any dual PCS 1900/GSM phones sighted yet?
    
451.14COVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertMon Apr 28 1997 10:1453
No dual mode 1900/anything sighted yet.

I mistakenly thought the Motorola 8800 was 900/1900, but it is, instead,
900/1800, designed to allow Orange/One-to-One/Eplus customers the ability
to roam on 900 MHz GSM systems outside their home countries as roaming
agreements are established.

The GSM MoU Organization says that it is going to encourage the development
of tri-mode 900/1800/1900 phones.

Another nasty kick in the head for the U.S.:  Not all those 1900 MHz
systems are going to be GSM based.

Specifically, while Omnipoint (to serve the Northeast), Sprint Spectrum
(Washington, DC), Bell South (Carolinas), VoiceStream (plains and Hawaii),
Pacific Bell (California), and Microcell (Montreal, Ottawa, Quebec City)
are now operational as GSM 1900 carriers, other 1900 carriers such as
SprintPCS (Denver) are not GSM compatible.  If there are any areas where
no company planning to offer GSM service got one of the licenses for one
of the 1900 MHz bands, (I hope this is not the case) there will be possibly
permanent holes in coverage.

Confusion abounds.  The Sprint Spectrum site is at www.sprintspectrum-apc.com.
If you forget the "-apc" you'll end up at the SprintPCS site instead.

I wanted to find out more details about what technology SprintPCS was using
and spoke to someone at their customer service center whose name had been
given to me as an "expert".  He said all of the following things, most of
which are incorrect:

	- Our PCS technology is better than GSM.  Which is basically an
	  analog technology.  (He was completely silent when I told him
	  that GSM was fully digital and always had been.)

	- Compatibility will be provided between the Sprint Spectrum
	  APC (GSM) system by "upgrading" it to PCS.  All he could say
	  when I told him that it was my understanding that GSM was
	  the leading technology worldwide was that this was not true.

Omnipoint seems to be the clear leader in setting up roaming; if I
had a 1900 MHz phone, my Omnipoint card would let me roam in DC, in
the Carolinas with BellSouth Mobility, in Honolulu, Oklahoma City,
Albuquerque, Santa Fe, Las Vegas and Portland with VoiceStream, in
SFO/LAX/SanDiego with Pacific Bell, and in Montreal, Ottawa, and
Quebec City with Microcell.  These are all fully active roaming
agreements.  See www.omnipoint.com.

As far as I know, Omnipoint is the only real GSM carrier so far to have
any overseas agreements; last Friday they added Sweden to their list
which previously included the UK, the Republic of Ireland, the
Netherlands, Germany, and Switzerland.

/john
451.15bhajee.rto.dec.com::JAERVINENOra, the Old Rural AmateurMon Apr 28 1997 12:019
�As far as I know, Omnipoint is the only real GSM carrier so far to have
�any overseas agreements; last Friday they added Sweden to their list
�which previously included the UK, the Republic of Ireland, the
�Netherlands, Germany, and Switzerland.
    
    Telecom Finland says they've signed roaming contracts with Omnipoint,
    Western Wireless and APC. (They also have their 1800 MHz network up and
    running for tests now - they just call it GSM 1800).
    
451.16APC still has no roaming with _anyone_ but OmnipointCOVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertMon Apr 28 1997 14:187
Signed does not mean operational.

PacBell claims on their web site "more than 700 bilateral roaming
agreements" but doesn't have a single operational one.  I wonder
how they count to 700.

/john
451.17bhajee.rto.dec.com::JAERVINENOra, the Old Rural AmateurMon Apr 28 1997 16:555
    >Signed does not mean operational.
    
    I know. But better signed than not signed... and they (Telecom Finland)
    have about 60 operational contracts.