[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::video

Title:Consumer video topics
Notice:For Sale/Wanted ads in note 10
Moderator:QUARK::LIONEL
Created:Mon May 07 1990
Last Modified:Tue Jun 03 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1216
Total number of notes:10064

562.0. "Digital vs Non-Digital TV?" by ODIXIE::WATSONPH () Mon Dec 23 1991 09:51

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
562.1QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centMon Dec 23 1991 10:1110
562.2HYDRA::SCHAFERMark Schafer, SPE MROThu Apr 03 1997 10:557
    Today's paper says that Digital TVs will be in the stores in time for
    Christmas 1998.  Lots of other info, too, about prices and broadcast
    channels for digital and analog.
    
    Is this really it, or is there more to the story?
    
    Mark
562.3QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centThu Apr 03 1997 12:0914
What is being discussed is a digital broadcast format.  "Digital TVs", which
receive analog signals but process them digitally, have existed for years.
I have one which I bought in 1986.

Yes, it does seem likely that digital broadcast signals will be available 
in the next couple of years along with TVs that will receive them - at price
premiums of $1500 or so over a comparable "analog" TV, at least at first.
The stated goal is that sometime in the future (7-15 years, depending on whom
you ask), broadcasters will stop transmitting analog signals and "return" that
spectrum to the government.  You would then need an adapter to view the digital
signals on your analog sets (such will certainly be avaiable soon after
digital signals start being transmitted.)

					Steve
562.4JAMIN::WASSERJohn A. WasserThu Apr 03 1997 13:429
> The stated goal is that sometime in the future (7-15 years, depending on whom
> you ask), broadcasters will stop transmitting analog signals

	A news piece I just heard said that the proposed regulations 
	say "9 years".  They also said that "some" digital broadcasting
	would be required within 10 years.  I guess that means that
	a broadcaster that chooses not to go to digital can continue
	sending analog for 9 years, then nothing for 1 year, then they
	loose their license.
562.5Better reception?ASDG::SBILLTue Apr 08 1997 14:198
Will this provide better reception of over the air broadcasts? With analog
signals, you basically have to get perfect reception in order to get a watchable
picture. Will changing over to digital allow people in fringe areas to get a
perfect picture even with poor reception of the signal?

Steve B. 

562.6SOLVIT::SNORAT::OLOUGHLINThe fun begins at 80!Tue Apr 08 1997 14:5310
    
    
     Another question please.
    
     How does Digital TV broadcast into a DTV stack up against 
     DVD and LDs? 
    
     Rick.
    
     
562.7QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centTue Apr 08 1997 16:0413
Re: .5

It might do better, but the DTV signals are in the UHF band, which typically
has more problems with reception than the VHF band.

Re: .6

The HDTV signal is potentially better than both DVD and LD.  DVD and LD are
neck-and-neck in overall picture quality, but a lot depends on the program
material and how it is mastered onto the disc.  DVD has less chroma noise than
LD, but LD's resolution is consistently good whereas DVD can be variable.

				Steve
562.8NPSS::NEWTONThomas NewtonWed Apr 09 1997 00:2216
    The last I heard, the broadcasters and the computer industry "agreed to
    disagree" on HDTV signal formats.

      -  The broadcasters want to use some fixed number of interlaced (TV
         style) resolutions.  Their interest is in grabbing onto the free
         spectrum being given away by the Government before someone wakes
         up and starts charging for it.

      -  The computer industry wants to use a non-interlaced picture, and
         to let the resolutions be programmable.  (This alternative would
         make it easier to use a HDTV set as a computer monitor and would
         also provide higher picture quality.)

    It is up to buyers to determine which format lives ... and to determine
    whether their new HDTV set is compatible with their programming sources.