[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::cooks

Title:How to Make them Goodies
Notice:Please Don't Start New Notes for Old Topics! Check 5.*
Moderator:FUTURE::DDESMAISONSec.com::winalski
Created:Tue Feb 18 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:4127
Total number of notes:31160

3728.0. "Nutritional value, canned vs frozen vegetables?" by CALS::HEALEY (DTN 297-2426) Thu Jan 07 1993 09:23

	I have a question regarding the nutritional value of canned
	versus frozen vegetables.  I have always believed that you
	might as well be eating cardboard for all the nutritional
	value that is in canned vegetables.  For that reason, if I
	cannot make fresh, I opt for frozen vegetables which I cook
	in the microwave.

	My husband bears with this but there are certain vegetables
	that he prefers canned, primarily green beans and corn.  Am
	I right in believing that frozen has more nutritional value
	than canned?  Does canned have any nutrional value?  I would
	only give in on green beans and corn.  For the rest, I'll 
	still cook frozen or fresh so the most that I would serve
	would be canned veggie twice a week.

	FWIW, I am aware of the sodium difference but this is not
	what concerns me here.  I could also buy sodium free canned
	vegetables but I think it might be the saltiness that my
	husband prefers, that and the fact that the canned veggies
	are overcooked and taste like a tin can (except corn).
	
	Karen
	
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
3728.1Read this in Vegetarian Times, I believe.JULIET::CANTONI_MIDon't you cryyyieeyyy tonite...Thu Jan 07 1993 11:4417
    That's funny - Me and my sister actually prefer canned green beans over
    fresh (unless they're cooked to death).  And, I prefer canned corn,
    too (not over fresh, though).
    
    Anyway, I've heard that frozen veggies contain more vitamins and
    minerals than canned, unless you use the liquid from the can as well. 
    Anytime veggies are allowed to soak and/or cook in liquid, the vitamins
    and minerals leech out into the liquid.
    
    I've also heard that frozen veggies are more nutritious than *fresh* if
    the fresh veggies have had to travel a long distance to get to your
    store.  This is because frozen veggies are frozen ripe and fresh almost
    immediately after picking.  Most fresh veggies are picked before they
    are ripe, and are allowed to "ripen" during transport.
    
    Helpfully,
    Michelle
3728.2barely edibleCADSYS::HECTOR::RICHARDSONThu Jan 07 1993 13:0310
    My ex-husband like canned peas.  I don't know if there is any
    nutritional value in the things because I never could stomach them
    myself - the mushier and more overcooked they were the more he liked
    them.  Ycch.  They sure didn't nourish me, because I never thought they
    were worth eating!  I don't use many canned veggies.  Sometimes I use
    vacuum-packed corn, and we do eat canned beans (especially garbanzos).
    Most canned vegetables are awfully overcooked to my taste, and are
    often also oversalted unless you buy the unsalted ones.
    
    /Charlotte
3728.3Canned Peas, pleaseMCIS2::KOSKINENThu Jan 07 1993 16:578
    I confess to liking canned peas (Leseur brand only), which do not taste
    a thing like fresh peas from the garden (the best!). That is probably
    because I grew up eating them. It's those fat, bright green frozen
    peas I can't get down. I think it has to do with Sunday dinners as a
    child. I have met numerous others who feel the same way about Leseur
    brand peas.
    
    Anne
3728.4Canned Peas; NOT!GJOVAX::MORRISONSun Jan 10 1993 23:214
    The ONLY vegetable in fresh / frozen / canned form that I CANNOT stand
    are canned peas - BARF!!! Although I do seem to recall eating the
    Leseur brand a long while back and thinking they were on the edge of
    eatable.
3728.5FRUST::HAMILTONMon Jan 11 1993 09:0410
I remember reading in Consumers Reports, albeit 10-12 years ago, that they
could find no measurable difference in vitamin content when comparing 
frozen and canned vegetables.  They attributed this to the then modern
pressure cooking techniques. Interesting huh?

Does anyone have a newer source of information on this subject?



Scott
3728.6CALS::HEALEYDTN 297-2426Mon Jan 11 1993 09:2616

	Well, I've decided to give in on certain vegetables.  I've agreed
	to serve canned corn and canned green beans.  Actually, I really
	don't like frozen green beans and canned are allright so that is
	fine with me.  Peas and spinach will continue to be the frozen
	variety.

	Re: those big mushy peas.  I can't stand them either but I really
	like tiny peas.  The best is Bird's eye "tender tiny peas".  They
	are kind of sweet and not at all mushy.  Sometimes you can do
	allright with the more generic brands of peas (Food Club) but 
	I prefer to spend the extra $.10 since I know Bird's eye is always
	good.

	Karen
3728.7can't convince myself to eat them anyhowCADSYS::HECTOR::RICHARDSONMon Jan 11 1993 12:1811
    Well, even if the vitamins are still in them, they don't end up in my
    diet because I never could manage to choke down enough of the sodden,
    mushy canned peas to constitute a 'serving" of them.  Ycch.  I'd rather
    eat stuff that is in-season, like winter squash now, than those things. 
    The frozen peas are pretty good, though, if you avoid the ones that are
    frozen in some kind of sauce.  It was only my ex- who had to have the
    canned peas.  Not sure why.  His mother used to can quite a few
    vegetables (especially stewed tomatoes) at home, but I don't remember
    her canning peas, and her canned veggies tasted good, anyhow.
    
    /Charlotte