| There's a Muslim community in Boston, and while there's no notesfile
(that I know of) specifically devoted to Islamic topics, you might try
posting your request in OPHION::BLACKNOTES, where some readers may be
able to help. Of course, some of those readers may also read COOKS ...
|
| Thanks for the follow-up.
For those curious about whether Halal and Kosher are interchangeable,
I checked with some friends of both religions in question, and from
the strictest point of view, they're not. The Jewish folks are
strongly observant, and, given the generally widespread availability
of Kosher meat in the Northeastern US, they said that if they couldn't
get Kosher meat, then it probably wouldn't make much difference to
them whether it was Halal or not. I asked how they would feel if
traveling in, say, some part of the world where Halal and "ordinary"
meat were widely available, but not Kosher meat, and they said they'd
possibly go vegetarian for a short time, or maybe eat Halal meat. They
probably wouldn't eat "ordinary" meat at all unless it was a situation
of extreme hardship, and, in such situations, Jewish law specifically
allows the Kosher laws to be broken.
My Muslim friends are not quite as strongly observant (it's fairly
difficult to be so in the US, as other Muslim noters will confirm),
and they said that they use Kosher meat when appropriate (i.e., when
observant relatives are visiting), but would prefer Halal meat if it
were more available.
According to both of them, the main difference between the two is the
actual words which are pronounced at the time the animal is
slaughtered. But they also said that Halal meat, being available in
much smaller quantity in the US, is more likely to be slaughtered
"more personally".
One last thing: I know many people who prefer Kosher meat to
"ordinary" meat for its presumably higher quality, and not for any
religious reason. My own experience is that Kosher meat is not of
higher quality than what I normally buy in the stores which sell meat
of the quality I prefer, but it is better than the average quality of
meat available in New England (but that wouldn't be too difficult).
|