[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::bridge

Title:The Game of Bridge
Moderator:COLLIS::JACKSON
Created:Thu Oct 30 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1969
Total number of notes:14668

1932.0. "A harder play problem (from Alan Frantz)" by MOIRA::FAIMAN (Wandrer, du M�der, du bist zu Haus) Fri Feb 14 1997 08:56

If you thought the 6NT double squeeze posted earlier in the week was tricky,
then be warned that this one is even more contorted.  This came up in another
club game, last night in Framingham, with Kotok as my partner.

First, let me explain the rules about playing with Kotok (I know this well as
we have played together regularly for nearly thirty years).  He is an
unabashed "results player".  This adds amusement to our postmortems.  No
matter how theoretically sound a call or a play may have been, if it didn't
work out at the table, you lose the postmortem.  But the converse permits me
to gain occasional very satisfying retribution, namely, no matter how unwise
my call or play may have been, if it did or should have succeeded then I get
full credit.  The other rule in these good-natured blame-assignment sessions
is that he who committed the first sin owns the entire blame for subsequent
follies on either side, but that caveat does not apply in this case.  Last
night I put Alan in this terrible 20% or so slam, but since there was a line
to make it, he owns all the blame.  See if you can find the winning line. . .

Board 9, unfavorable vul, matchpoints against weak opponents:

West (dummy)     S- Q65    H- 9       D- QJ3        C- AQT962
East (Kotok)        S- AK      H-KQT4    D- AT872   C- 54

The contract is 6DX.  The opening lead is the HA (thank you), followed by a
switch to the SJ.  Plan the play.  (As you might guess +1540 will get all the
matchpoints, even beating some 800s and 1100s, while -200 will be absolute
zero.)

Oh, if you insist, I'll confess to the auction that got us into this stunning
contract:

North    East     South         West      Notes:
  P        1C*       1S         Dbl**     * Precision, 16+ HCP, most any shape
  P        2D        P          3C        ** Positive, 9+ HCP, gf, unbalanced
  P        3NT       P          4D***     *** Why stay with the field in 3NT?
  P        4S        P          5C        cue bids
  P        5D        P          6D****    **** I bought this bid at 4D, 5D
						gets no MP
 Dbl      All pass                        he wanted to pound his shoe on
						the table!

Well, I suppose most of you geniuses in the readership of this notesfile have
figured out that we are going to need both minor suit finesses, and some
other help, so let's take the play forward a couple tricks:

AH, RHO following small (probably cannot make without this helpful opening
lead); SJ, RHO following small and you win your SA; next comes the club
finesse (what else) and LHO comes right up with the KC (over next hurdle);
QD, RHO ducks (over another hurdle); JD,KD,AD, LHO pitches heart (oops, a
water jump looms ahead); now plan the play beginning at trick 6.  Enjoy.

   -- Alan
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1932.1AC, club ruffCADSYS::GROSSThe bug stops hereFri Feb 14 1997 11:2615
At trick 6 these cards remain:
	S:Q6 H:-   D:3   C:AT962
	S:K  H:KQT D:T87 C:5
RHO started with K9xx of diamonds. How about cashing KS, club to the A, QS.
If RHO follows to all these tricks, sluff the 10H, take the marked diamond
finesse, claim. It can't be so simple. If RHO ruffs the QS you can overruff,
ruff the 10H, ruff a club back to hand, draw the last trump and claim.
Even this seems too simple. What if RHO started with a stiff club? Can't do it
because we need two dummy entries to pull off a trump coup and the AC has to
be one of them. What if RHO started with a stiff spade? Now you need two dummy
entries (AC and heart ruff will do) and a discard for the KS. So the play has
to be: AC, club ruff, heart ruff, run club winners until RHO ruffs, overruff,
draw the last trump and claim.

Dave
1932.2Trump coup use DG's line in .-1 if 3-2 clubsDAVIDB::DMILLERThis bug fix broke what???????Mon Feb 17 1997 10:524
	Looks like LHO has JTxxxxx-Axxx-x-K, leaving RHO with x-Jxxx-K9xx-Jxxx

	CA (Assume LHO shows out), CT pitching SK if not covered, c-ruff,
	H-ruff, run clubs until ruff/overruff.
1932.3(from Craig Zastera)MOIRA::FAIMANWandrer, du M�der, du bist zu HausTue Feb 18 1997 10:5822
>dummy:	S- Q65  H- 9        D- QJ3     C- AQT962
>Kotok:	S- AK    H-KQT4  D- AT872  C- 54
after: 1. HA,9,x,4  2. SJ,5,x,A  3. C5,K,A,x
         4. DQ,x,2,x  5. DJ,K,A,Hx   6. ???
  
  Isn't this (now) nearly cold?
  Club to dummy's CA.
      1. if LHO shows out (e.g. he is 7-4-1-1 or some such)
            continue high clubs from dummy, ruffing the CJ whenever it
            appears  (pitch any major card if RHO plays low)
            Your diamond length now matches RHO's.  So ruff a heart back
to dummy and run clubs, pitching all your (good) major cards until RHO
ruffs.  If he refuses to, you're in dummy at trick 12 with you and RHO
down to only diamonds, so coup him.
     2. If both follow, ruff 3rd round of clubs, return to dummy with a
heart ruff and continue clubs as in (1).

I think this line can only fail if RHO started with a stiff club
(meaning LHO flew king from C:KJxx).  This seems too remote to worry
about as a practical matter (and I don't see how to make it in this case
anyway).
>     CraigZa
1932.4(from Alan Kotok)MOIRA::FAIMANWandrer, du M�der, du bist zu HausTue Feb 18 1997 11:0344
Neil,

Here's my independent solution to the problem Frantz just posted.  You can
post this just ahead of the "expert" solution...

Standing in the shower last night I thought of a winning line of play.
After the disastrous (to the defense) lead of HA, Sx, I win in hand.  The
following seems evident at the time:

1. S are probably 6-2, since with 7 LHO would have jumped, and with 5 to
the J, she wouldn't have bid at all.

2. Both the C and D finesses are on, or this hand has no prayer.

3. From the double, K9xx of D are on my right.  If RHO has all 5 trumps,
there's also no play.

4. The only question is the D and H distribution.

5. Given all that, the only question is what to do with the H ten.
Although I handn't thought this thru all that clearly at the table this
early, I eventually decided that I would play for the HJ to drop, which is
not the best line.

Consider the following:

Cash the other spade honor in hand, which must work.

Take the C finesse, and when the CK appears, it's evident that RHO held 2
spades, 3 hearts, 4 diamonds and 4 clubs.  So the chances of the H jack
dropping are not all that good.

Now lead the SQ.  If RHO discards (say a H), then I discard the losing HT.
I am now prepared to take the 3 necessary D finesses.  If, instead, RHO
ruffs, I overruff, but now need only 2 D finesses.

In that case, I now ruff the HT with the DQ and lead the DJ.  If that is
ducked, I can lead the Dx to my AT8 in hand.  If covered, I win the A, and
lead a C back to dummy in order to finesse against the 9.

If I was not constantly being hounded by the director to speed up, I might
actually have figured this out at the table.  Who knows?

Alan
1932.5answer to the 6DX problem (from Alan Frantz)MOIRA::FAIMANWandrer, du M�der, du bist zu HausTue Feb 18 1997 11:0431
 To restate the problem:

Board 9, unfavorable vul, matchpoints against weak opponents:

West (dummy)     S- Q65    H- 9       D- QJ3        C- AQT962
East (Kotok)        S- AK      H-KQT4    D- AT872   C- 54

The contract is 6DX.  The opening lead is the HA (thank you), followed by a
switch to the SJ.  Plan the play.  (As you might guess +1540 will get all the
matchpoints, even beating some 800s and 1100s, while -200 will be absolute
zero.)

This turns out to be a trump coup with very delicate timing.  We had taken
the play up to trick 6 as follows:  AH;  JS to AS; Cx,CK,CA; QD,ducked;
JD,KD,AD,Hx;

It is not hard to read LHO for 6511 at this point, giving RHO 2344 including
the K9xx of trump.  The winning line is:  C to CQ; C ruff (required to1
shorten trump); SK; HK; H ruff to get to dummy for this three card ending:

      Dummy:  S- Q    H- D-   C- xx
LHO: irrelevant             RHO:  S-  H-  D- 9x   C-x
      Declarer:  S-  H- Q  D- T8  C-

The SQ from dummy now pickles RHO.  Whether he ruffs now or at the next
trick, he has been neatly trump couped.

Alas, Kotok didn't find it at the table, and -200 got a zero.  Maybe I need
to find better partners. . .     ;-)

							-- Alan