[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference taveng::bagels

Title:BAGELS and other things of Jewish interest
Notice:1.0 policy, 280.0 directory, 32.0 registration
Moderator:SMURF::FENSTER
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1524
Total number of notes:18709

916.0. "An Adult Bar Mitzvah" by DOCSRV::STARIN (US Navy Reserve 75 years 1915-1990) Tue Apr 03 1990 16:23

I am considering studying to become a Bar Mitzvah after I complete my 
present course of study at Temple Adath Yeshurun in Manchester, NH.

I realize it's going to be a challenge but I'm inspired to try knowing that 
Henny Youngman became a Bar Mitzvah at 75 or so.

I'd be interested in hearing from any fellow BAGELER's who were made 
a Bar Mitzvah after age 13.

Thanks.

Mark
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
916.1Becoming is automaticCASP::SEIDMANAaron SeidmanThu Apr 05 1990 01:5727
    >I'd be interested in hearing from any fellow BAGELER's who were made 
    >a Bar Mitzvah after age 13.

    Nit:  This has been said before, but no one was "made a Bar Mitzvah"
    after age 13--becoming Bar/Bat Mitzvah is strictly a function of age.
    
    Once one has reached the age of Bar/Bat Mitzvah, one may participate in
    certain community activities, such as being called to the public
    reading of the Torah.  The first time one has an opportunity to perform
    such a mitzvah can be an occasion for celebration.  That is what the
    fuss is all about.
    
    There are other situations where one celebrates as well.  For instance,
    many of us are first-born and therefore are obliged to fast the day
    before Pesah begins (in memory of the fact that the Hebrew first-born
    were spared when the tenth plague was visited on Pharoah and his
    people).  However, I (and many others) often attend a Siyyum--a study
    session--at which someone completes study of a tractate of the Talmud.
    Now, as it happens, completing a tractate is an occasion for
    celebration, and everyone who is present is obligated to rejoice with
    the person who did it.  Since this obligation supersedes the obligation
    to fast, that is the end of the fast for the day.
    
    [I didn't have to add that second paragraph to make the point, but with
    Pesah just around the corner...:^) ]
    
    						Aaron
916.2If it is what you want, DO IT!LDYBUG::PINCKThu Apr 05 1990 17:4912
    
    My fiance went for his first aliah (sp) twice :-).  Once
    at the synogogue that we goto and once at my parents. Both
    Rabbis make a nice speech/fuss about welcoming him into
    the Jewish community.  At my parents the sisterhood and
    mens club welcomed him during their Bar Mitzvah present
    speech.
    
    The point is that it was a very nice,friendly way to be included
    in the community and to meet people at a newish synogogue.
    
    Amy
916.3VAXWRK::ZAITCHIKVAXworkers of the World Unite!Sun Apr 08 1990 08:3920
Mark-
To follow up on .1 the point would be that when you become
Jewish you will automatically BE "bar mitzva", i.e. a full
member of the Jewish community. And I am sure that all will
rejoice with you!
But as far as emotionally what it means to feel that sense of
"new belonging" as an adult rather than as a child of 13,
yes... there are many people who had their "celebration"
at a later age. And so they experienced their belonging
only at that later age, despite the correct point of law
in .1. I wasn't aware that Henny Youngman did this late
in life, but in Israel I have seen a good number of
Russian Jews celebrate a "bar mitzva" when they arrived
in Israel, quite a few years beyond 13. I suppose that
an adult can really understand quite a bit more about the
significance of the event than a 13 year old can.
Anyway, hope you are doing well, and hope you enjoy
Passover.
-ZAITCH 

916.4ThanksDOCSRV::STARINElectronic ArchaeologistMon Apr 09 1990 21:458
    Re all:
    
    Thanks for your comments both here and off-line. I also appreciate
    your patience as I continue in my studies.
    
    Happy Pesach to all!
    
    Mark